Fragments to Turbantius — Book 6
Ad Turbantium
Foolishness is the mother of all vices. ‘God loves no one except the person who lives with wisdom’ (Wisdom…§6.1.1–6.6.16
6.1.1Foolishness is the mother of all vices.
‘God loves no one except the person who lives with wisdom’ (Wisdom 7:28).
The good of an unviolated and blameless nature.
6.1.2Those who either neglected to learn what ought to be known, or are unafraid to condemn what they do not know.
In the noonday of discovered truth, without the shadow of ignorance, you rave through envy of me.
Envy immediately torments the very author from whom it arises.
One and the same vice cannot be both sin and punishment for sin.
6.2.3Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “After finishing your preface, in which you labored, as you usually do, to prove what I myself preach, ‘that God is the maker of human beings,’ you then set out my words, where I said: ‘A human being who is born of the desire of the flesh is born to the world, not to God; but he is born to God when he is reborn of water and the Spirit.’”
“You lie in wait for these words of mine so as to assert that it must be understood from them that I said that whatever belongs to the world belongs to the devil, because, of course, I had said elsewhere ‘that those who are born from the union of bodies belong to the devil’s jurisdiction,’ asserting, that is, that they ‘are rescued from the power of darkness when they are reborn in Christ.’”
6.3.6The grace of Christ’s mysteries is rich in many gifts.
Rather, he shows them to be his own by raising what he made in them through additional benefits, before their own obedient exercise of will.
6.4.8Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Let us consider the point at issue in this chapter, where he says: ‘God commends his love toward us, in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us’ (Romans 5:8). You want this to be thought said with infants excepted.”
“But you, already in your first book, crying out against us, said: ‘Christ died for infants too.’”
6.5.11Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “What I said in my book, which you oppose, is entirely true: ‘For that what was forgiven in the parent is passed on in the offspring happens in wonderful ways, but still it happens; and because the way itself is not traced out by easy reasoning, nor explained in speech, unbelievers do not believe it.’ You lay a false trap for these words of mine, as though I had said that it can ‘neither be grasped by reason nor explained in speech,’ taking away from it what I said, ‘not easy,’ whether of ‘reasoning’ or of ‘speech.’ ‘No’ reasoning, which is what you say, is one thing; ‘not easy’ reasoning, which is what I said, is another.”
6.6.15Examples give no support to something that cannot be defended in itself.
6.6.16Albinus affirms that among all animals the crocodile alone moves its upper jaws; and fire, though destructive to everything else, is a plaything for the salamander.
Natural characteristics are not changed by an accidental occurrence.
A parent cannot transmit to offspring what the parent does not possess.
Curiosity usually wonders less at what it has understood. Against this, divine provision arranged that…§6.7.17–6.9.26
6.7.17Curiosity usually wonders less at what it has understood. Against this, divine provision arranged that many things should arise from the earth, distinguished by countless properties.
6.7.18By the nature of things, parents cannot be shown to hand on what they are believed to have lost. If they hand it on, they have not lost it.
6.7.20Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “See, the circumcised man hands on to the one born of him what he lacked in himself. What, then, is it that you say: ‘By the nature of things it cannot happen that people should be shown to hand on what they are believed to have lacked’? The foreskin is good, not evil, because God made it, just as you argued at great length about the wild olive.”
“So the circumcision of the flesh not only overturns, beyond doubt, that maxim of yours, general as it were, in which you say: ‘By the nature of things it cannot happen that a parent should hand on to his offspring what he himself lacked’ …”
6.8.22You tried to stir up the crowd against me.
Forgetting our single combat, you took refuge in the crowd.
With a treaty offered, it was agreed to settle the war, so that our contest would decide everyone’s battles.
6.8.23Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Do not mock the members of Christ with the name ‘sedentary craftsmen.’ … What is this: ‘When you begin to show them this, they will become more bitter toward me’? Do not lie to them, and they will not.”
“For I do not, as you falsely charge, ‘assert that they are the devil’s property,’ since I know they were redeemed by Christ’s blood; I do not ‘assign any marriages to the devil,’ insofar as they are marriages; I do not ‘make him out to be the craftsman of the genitals’; nor do I assert that he is ‘the arouser of men,’ except to unlawful acts, nor ‘the one who makes women fertile,’ nor ‘the maker of infants.’”
6.9.24Explain how sin can justly be charged to a person who neither wished nor was able to sin.
How can an act of choice be mixed into the condition of reproductive seed?
In what way did it happen?
6.9.25Always busily working for his enemy’s profit.
6.9.26The devil and God have made this agreement between them: God is to claim whatever is washed, and the devil whatever is born. But on this condition: God, by a power subject to another, is to make fruitful the very sexual union that the devil established.
Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “And yet we give thanks that you do not think this that being…§6.9.27–6.11.34
6.9.27Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “And yet we give thanks that you do not think this that being washed is superfluous. For you do not admit to the kingdom of God those who are born, unless they are washed; and so you show that being washed is far better than being born.”
6.10.28No human sin can exist without an act of free choice.
One person is not held liable for another person’s sins.
6.10.29We must all appear before Christ’s judgment seat, so that each may receive what belongs to his own body, according to what he has done, whether good or evil. (2 Corinthians 5:10)
6.10.30Sexual desire is not wholly rebellious against the mind.
Let God be called the creator of infants who are such as befit God’s hands—that is, innocent infants.
6.10.31Explain how the devil dares to claim as his own infants created in Christ—that is, in his power.
6.10.32When God grants the glory of regeneration to infants who have deserved neither good nor evil by anything of their own, he teaches by that very act that they belong to his care, his right, and his dominion: he anticipates their will with the lavish gift of an inexpressible benefit.
6.10.33Where the apostle says ‘by nature children of wrath,’ it can be understood as ‘truly children of wrath.’ (Ephesians 2:3)
6.11.34Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “You run through the parts that make up the people (the multitude of Christians, which with good reason is most hostile to you), describing and mocking them one by one; among them you touch on ‘the students who attend lectures,’ and you say that they will shout against me: ‘O the times, O the morals!’ (Cicero, Against Catiline 1) And yet you dread the verdict of the crowd, where you could find supporters so loud for you that they would frighten me with Tullius’s words, because ‘I think that the genital part of the body comes from somewhere other than where the whole comes from.’”
Even in a worn-out body, lust cannot be restrained.§6.11.35–6.14.43
6.11.35Even in a worn-out body, lust cannot be restrained.
6.11.36Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “But which of us says: ‘This evil that infants draw from their origin can either exist, or has ever existed, without a substance in which it is’? As though we said it, you go looking for judges trained in logic, and you mock the common people.”
6.12.37Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “And what sort of thing is it that, so as to persist in your perversity, you accuse Zosimus of blessed memory, bishop of the Apostolic See, of betraying his trust?”
6.12.38Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Remember, indeed, how you insultingly throw up the dissension of the Roman people over the appointment of a bishop. I ask you whether those people did it by their own will. If you deny it, how do you defend free choice? But if you admit it, how do you call it ‘God’s vengeance’?”
6.12.39You yourself have also changed your views: at the beginning of your conversion you held the same view that I do.
6.13.40The baptized are only partly cleansed. This is more clearly apparent from your own words.
Grace does not make a person completely new.
6.14.41The flesh is said to desire because the soul desires in a fleshly way.
The baptized person has nothing left to put to death.
6.14.43Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “You want it to seem so incredible ‘that in the womb of a baptized woman, whose body is the temple of God, a human being is formed who will be under the devil unless he is reborn to God from God.’”
Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Where, then, did you hear or read me saying ‘that people are not…§6.14.44–6.18.53
6.14.44Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Where, then, did you hear or read me saying ‘that people are not renewed through baptism, but as if renewed; not freed, but as if freed; not saved, but as if saved’?”
“It is not I, then, who make God’s grace empty; but you, its enemy, seem to have gone after empty display, so as to bring into your argument Epicurus, who denied that the gods have a body, but something like a body, nor blood, but something like blood …”
“But which of us says ‘that whatever is done in the present age is to be blamed’?”
6.15.45That resurrection does not forgive anyone’s sins, but sifts each person’s deserts. For it renders to each person according to his works.
6.15.46None of the righteous there will any longer bruise his body and bring it into subjection. No one will humble his soul with a hard bed and bodily filth.
No one will expose his blessed disregard for shame to insults, his cheeks to slaps, or his back to lashes. Nor will he strive to forge strength out of weakness. Frugality will not struggle with poverty, nor greatness of soul with grief, nor patience with pain.
6.15.47Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Again you say ‘that no one hates his own flesh’ (Ephesians 5:29). Who denies it? Yet you assert that it must be broken down by the rigor of discipline.”
“So, when all sins are forgiven in baptism, that is, all the offspring of desire, if desire itself was also used up there, how do the saints fight against it, so that it may not conceive, ‘with bruising of the body, squalor of the limbs, breaking down of the flesh’? These are your words.”
6.16.49Do not be mistaken: neither the sexually immoral nor those who serve idols will possess God’s kingdom. (1 Corinthians 6:9–10)
And that is what you were; but you were washed, but you were sanctified. (1 Corinthians 6:11)
If sexual desire were an evil, the person who is baptized would be free of it.
6.16.50Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “But if, as you indicated in one place, ‘the school of Dinomachus, which joins moral goodness and pleasure, pleases you’ … it is enough for us that you admit that one pleasure is unlawful and another lawful.”
6.17.51Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Now let us look at that most excellent sharpness of yours, by which you saw how to refute what I said: ‘that the desire of the flesh is forgiven in baptism, not so that it does not exist, but so that it is not counted as sin; and although its guilt has already been loosed, it still remains.’ Against these words of mine you argue, most acute man, as though I had said that desire itself is freed from guilt through baptism, because I said ‘its guilt having already been loosed’: as though by ‘its’ I meant the guilt by which desire itself is guilty, so that, with that loosed, it remains acquitted.”
“But it suits you rather, since you proclaim it good, to say ‘that to its natural good,’ as you say of infants, ‘the good of sanctification is added,’ and let the desire of the flesh be a holy daughter of God.”
6.18.53You have changed your position: forgetting your entire book, you have declared that lust is a substance.
The third kind of quality is a passing state and an enduring quality of feeling. A passing state is placed…§6.18.54–6.20.63
6.18.54The third kind of quality is a passing state and an enduring quality of feeling. A passing state is placed among qualities because it is a starting point of qualities. To it are also assigned the experiences of mind or body that come and go in a moment. An enduring quality of feeling, however, arises from more powerful causes and clings to everyone in whom it occurs so firmly that it can be removed only with great efforts—or cannot be removed at all.
6.18.56Closing Aristotle’s wrestling school, let us return from it to the sacred Scriptures.
Sexual desire, then, is a sensation, and it is not an evil quality. Therefore, when sexual desire is diminished, sensation is diminished.
6.18.57Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “So if you do not want to be contentious, I think you now see how rightly it is understood (though you try to explain it otherwise) that when the prophet had said, ‘Who is gracious to all your iniquities,’ which happens, of course, through the forgiveness of all sins, he at once added, ‘Who heals all your diseases’ (Psalm 103:3). By this he meant those evils with which the inner wars of the saints do not rest until they are healed, or, as far as they can be in this life, are lessened more and more.”
6.19.58Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “So ‘this wound, inflicted on the human race by the devil, compels whatever is born through it to be under the devil, as though he were rightfully picking fruit from his own shrub.’ You set out these words from my book to refute them, and you lie in wait for them as though I had said ‘that the devil is the author of human nature, and the maker of the very substance of which a human being consists.’”
6.19.60You cannot imagine in what dialectical treatise I found that all opposites can be reversed.
In no dialectical treatise can it be found that all opposites can be reversed.
6.19.61Everything belonging to this class can be demonstrated by this one example. If someone has sacrificed to idols once, he can be burdened by the impiety of what he has done until he obtains forgiveness: the act has ended, but its guilt remains. But it is absolutely impossible for the act to remain and the guilt to depart—that is, for him to go on sacrificing to demons and yet be regarded as free from profanation.
6.19.62When the act has passed away, its guilt remains in the conscience of the person who sinned until it is forgiven.
6.20.63The same pattern observed in the devil ought also to have been observed in an evil human being: no one should be condemned except for the faults of his own will. Therefore there is no original sin. Otherwise the work of him who created even the devil good cannot be approved.
‘Greater’ and ‘lesser’ belong to the defined category of quantity. But quantity is not only incapable of…§6.20.64–6.23.71
6.20.64‘Greater’ and ‘lesser’ belong to the defined category of quantity. But quantity is not only incapable of receiving contraries—which it has in common with quality and other categories—it also has no contrary, which it has in common with the definition of substance. Good and evil, however, are contraries.
6.20.65If something properly ordered belongs to God, and something belonging to God is good, then being subject to the devil is good, since the order established by God is preserved in this way. It follows that rebelling against the devil is evil, since resistance disturbs the order established by God.
6.21.66The devil’s work is not allowed to pass through God’s work.
The root of evil cannot be placed in God’s gift.
The order of things does not allow evil to be produced from good, or anything unjust from what is just.
Sins are not born from something free from sin.
Guilt cannot be born from this work, which has no guilt.
6.21.67That man was cast into these miseries not by nature as a mother, but as by a stepmother.
No fuller’s cleansing herb cleanses me of the Manichean stain — as you say.
6.22.68Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “What I said in another book of mine, writing to Marcellinus, was ‘that the children of the woman who believed the serpent so as to be corrupted by lust are not set free except through the Son of the Virgin, who believed the angel so as to conceive without lust.’ You set it out in such a way, and wanted it taken in such a way, as though I had said ‘that the serpent had joined with Eve in bodily intercourse.’”
6.22.69Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “So you have not, by your whole argument, crushed, as you boast, my assertion about the evil of fleshly desire and of original sin.”
“About the testimonies of the catholic writers Saint Basil of Caesarea and Saint John of Constantinople, whose meaning you said agrees with your views, I answered you in the first book of this work of mine with truth entirely sufficient and certain.”
“In the second book too we did enough to make it plain that it is not, as you abusively call it, ‘a conspiracy of lost men’ …”
“Hence also ‘the murmur of the people, which alone,’ you say, ‘is set against you by us,’ is not alone, since it rests on the authority of such great teachers …”
6.23.70Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “As for the Apostle’s words where he says, ‘I know that good does not dwell in me, that is, in my flesh,’ and the rest up to where he says, ‘Wretched man that I am, who will free me from the body of this death?’ (Romans 7:18–24): you affirm ‘that I understand them otherwise than that whole passage ought to be understood.’ Without knowing it, you credit me with a great deal.”
“Against these movements, which must first be fought down so that they do not rule, and afterward healed so that they are wholly put out, you yourself also admitted that the saints wage glorious struggles.”
6.23.71It is contradictory for the person who says, ‘It is no longer I who live, but Christ lives in me,’ also to say, ‘I know that good does not dwell in me, that is, in my flesh.’ (Galatians 2:20; Romans 7:18)
You make the apostle say these things as though he meant that, despite his resistance, some hand of deadly pleasure dragged him off to prostitutes.
Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Why do you try in vain ‘to transfer these words to the pride of…§6.23.72–6.24.75
6.23.72Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Why do you try in vain ‘to transfer these words to the pride of the Jews, as though the Apostle had represented in himself those who despised the gifts of Christ as not necessary for them’? For that is your conjecture. … But you say that they were despised by the Jews for this reason, ‘that he gave pardon for sins which they themselves had avoided through the admonition of the law.’”
6.23.73The apostle emphasizes the power of habit.
Through the good law and the holy commandment, the minds of the wicked had become more savage, because no instruction could instill virtue without their own willing participation.
The law is holy, and the commandment holy and just and good. Has what is good, then, become death for me? Certainly not! But sin, so that it might appear as sin, worked death in me through what is good, so that sin might become sinful beyond measure through the commandment. (Romans 7:12–13)
6.24.75The expression ‘in whom all sinned’ is used as though it said ‘because of which all sinned,’ just as it says, ‘By what does a young man correct his way?’ (Romans 5:12; Psalm 119:9, LXX/Vulgate Psalm 118:9)
In this way, of course, all people are not to be understood as having sinned originally in one man, all together as though in the unity of one lump, but because that first man sinned; that is, when they imitate him, not when they are born from him.
How a young man corrects his way (Psalm 119:9)§6.24.76
6.24.76By what does a young man correct his way? By guarding your words. (Psalm 119:9; LXX/Vulgate Psalm 118:9)
Moses fled at this word. (Acts 7:29)
Latin · §6.24.76
The Latin is on each section page: §6.24.76
But if he was speaking about the transmission of sin by descent, nowhere would it have been more…§6.24.77–6.26.83
6.24.77But if he was speaking about the transmission of sin by descent, nowhere would it have been more appropriate for him to say, ‘Sin passed to all for this reason: because all were begotten through married people’s pleasure.’ He would have added, ‘It passes in this way: they flowed from the decaying flesh of the first man.’
6.24.80Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “You do not want ‘many,’ which he said later, to be understood as ‘all,’ which he had said earlier, for you think that ‘many’ was said so that ‘all’ would not be understood.” (Romans 5:12,18–19)
6.25.82The proverb will no longer be used which says that parents ate sour grapes and their children’s teeth were set on edge. A son will not die for his father’s sin, nor a father for his son’s sin; the soul that sins will itself die. (Ezekiel 18:2–4,20)
6.26.83Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “That I have answered you on everything, Julian, and refuted everything by which, in four volumes, you thought and argued that original sin is not to be believed, and that the desire of the flesh cannot be blamed without condemning marriage, I think you see, if you are not obstinate.”
“… You dare, besides, to say that you have taken up war against the ungodly … You dare to join yourself to the company of the holy patriarchs, prophets, apostles, martyrs and priests … You dare to say that you are being overcome by a fellowship of Manichaeans.”