Fragments to Turbantius — Book 5

Ad Turbantium

Julian of Eclanum (c. 386–c. 455 AD) · written c. 418–430 AD · Quoted by Augustine

Jump to contents

Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “What need is there, then, for me to say anything against the…§5.1.1–5.3.8

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.1.1Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “What need is there, then, for me to say anything against the usual, empty things you set at the beginning of this book, ‘about the ill will that you boast you bear for the truth, and about the small number of the would-be wise whom you are glad to please’?”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.1.2Knowledge of the holy writings is difficult and suited to few learned people.

The aim is to establish that God, the creator of humanity and of the universe, is just, truthful, and good, and that he continually adds to his gifts to human beings.

There is one best reason for good studies: that God should be honored.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.1.3Your position is so disgraceful and empty: it tries to attribute injustice to God, the creation of human beings to the devil, substance to sin, and consciousness without knowledge to infants.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.1.4Simple people, who are occupied with other business and have acquired no learning, have nevertheless taken care to enter Christ’s Church through faith alone. They should not be easily frightened by obscure questions. Believing God to be the true creator of human beings, they should also hold without doubt that he is good, truthful, and just. Maintaining this understanding of the Trinity, they should embrace and praise whatever they hear agreeing with this judgment. No force of argument should tear this from them; they should reject every authority and association trying to persuade them of the contrary.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.2.5Why, then, did shame about those members follow sin, unless an indecent movement arose there?

‘They made garments for themselves’ (Genesis 3:7).

‘Garments’ can be understood as clothing for the whole body, which belongs to the duty of modesty.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.2.6Painters and poets have always had equal freedom to dare anything. [Horace, Art of Poetry 9–10.]

They felt nothing indecent or new there.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.2.7If preference is given to the translation using perizomata—that is, coverings tied around the waist—I will say their sides were covered rather than their thighs.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.3.8Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “You insert other words from my book, where I said that ‘the disobedience of the flesh was most deservedly paid back to the disobedient human being, because it was unjust that he who had not obeyed his Lord should be obeyed by his servant, that is, by his body.’ And you try to show ‘that this disobedience of the flesh is rather to be praised, if it is the punishment of sin.’ And as though it were some person who knowingly afflicts the sinner, you adorn it in the high style of tragedy, as if it were some great good, ‘as an avenger of wickedness, and in this a servant of God.’”

Latin · §5.1.1–5.3.8

The Latin is on each section page: §5.1.1 §5.1.2 §5.1.3 §5.1.4 §5.2.5 §5.2.6 §5.2.7 §5.3.8

Latin source witness: §5.1.1 · §5.1.2 · §5.1.3 · §5.1.4 · §5.2.5 · §5.2.6 · §5.2.7 · §5.3.8

If lust is punishment for sin, chastity must be cast aside, lest chastity, rebelling against God, be said…§5.3.9–5.4.18

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.3.9If lust is punishment for sin, chastity must be cast aside, lest chastity, rebelling against God, be said to weaken the sentence he imposed.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.3.10‘God handed them over to a depraved mind, to do what is unfitting’ (Romans 1:28).

When he attacked the crimes of the ungodly, he heightened them by using the language of punishments. Showing how deeply his heart, the dwelling of every virtue, recoiled from their shamefulness, he said that such people seemed to him not so much guilty as condemned.

How should we understand God’s handing people over? He hands them over by abandoning them.

‘They exchanged the glory of the incorruptible God for the likeness of an image of corruptible humanity, birds, four-footed animals, and reptiles. Therefore God handed them over in the desire of their heart to uncleanness’ (Romans 1:23–24).

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.3.11They were already burning with desires for shameful deeds.

How, then, should we think they fell into such acts through the power of God handing them over?

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.3.13When they are said to have been handed over to their own desires, we should understand that they were left alone through God’s patience, not forced into sins through his power.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.4.14The apostle says: ‘God’s kindness leads you to repentance’ (Romans 2:4).

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.4.15God hands people over so that evils occur only by showing patient goodness while they occur.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.4.16Lust is just and should be publicly praised if, by refusing to obey him, it punished the person who did not obey God.

Nothing can be considered more praiseworthy if it avenged the injustice of the offense, vindicated the wrong done to God, and had so little partnership in sin that it assumed the office of avenger.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.4.18‘Their foolish heart was filled with darkness’ (Romans 1:21).

We should note that he calls foolishness the cause of all evils.

Latin · §5.3.9–5.4.18

The Latin is on each section page: §5.3.9 §5.3.10 §5.3.11 §5.3.13 §5.4.14 §5.4.15 §5.4.16 §5.4.18

Latin source witness: §5.3.9 · §5.3.10 · §5.3.11 · §5.3.13 · §5.4.14 · §5.4.15 · §5.4.16 · §5.4.18

Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Then you put in other words of mine. And you charge me falsely…§5.5.19–5.7.26

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.5.19Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Then you put in other words of mine. And you charge me falsely with having contradicted myself, since, ‘when I had said that the disobedience of his own body was paid back to the disobedient human being as a punishment, I at once named other members of the body expressly, saying that they serve our will at its nod.’”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.5.20When it comes to sowing children, the members created for this work serve precisely at the will’s direction. Unless impediments arise from weakness or excess, they obey the mind’s command.

This kind of movement belongs among the many things in our body that, through their own order and hidden arrangement, require the will’s consent, not its command.

Like hunger, thirst, and digestion, they require the will’s consent, not its command.

You feel ashamed — as you say — and are prevented by horror from speaking about such things, but compelled by necessity.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.5.21The members do not follow in the direction we want if we will something their physical structure does not permit.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.5.22Even the genitals obey the mind’s command.

They are not moved at the mind’s command, but instead await consent.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.5.23Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “What of the fact that this most beautiful handmaid of yours, whom I am ashamed to name so often even to blame her, but whom you are not ashamed to praise, ‘you think becomes more commendable because the other parts of the body also serve her so that she is roused more ardently, whether the eyes, seeing in order to desire, or other members in kisses and embraces’? You also found how to make a man’s ears subject to her, and you raised up her title, very ancient indeed but plainly most glorious, recalling what Tullius set down in the account of his Counsels.”

When drunken young men, excited also by flute music as often happens, were breaking down a chaste woman’s door, Pythagoras is said to have told the flute player to play a solemn spondaic rhythm. When she did, the slowness of the measures and gravity of the song quieted their raging insolence. [Cicero, On His Own Counsels, a lost work.]

It receives consent rather than commands.

It is excited by other stimuli, or broken and quieted by music.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.6.24How fittingly Jeremiah, with the chorus of prophets and all the saints, would cry out: ‘Who will give water to my head and a fountain of tears to my eyes?’ (Jeremiah 9:1).

Glorious struggles.

The wickedness of a declining age.

The ruin of morals.

The destruction of modesty.

They say with the Manichaeans that a necessity of evil exists in their flesh.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.7.25Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Now, because I said that this ‘movement’ of desire was ‘indecent because disobedient,’ you want it thought that I said ‘that it is subject neither to the body nor to the mind, but is always untamed, with a wild strength.’ … Where are those ‘glorious struggles’ of the saints that you admitted are waged against it?”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.7.26The Paternian heretics, also called Venustians, are like the Manichaeans. They say the devil made the human body from the loins to the feet, while God placed the upper parts upon it as though upon a base. They add that human effort requires only keeping the soul clean, which they say lives in the stomach and head. If the pubic region is smeared with the filth of every shameful act, they say this is no concern of theirs. Thus, to serve lust disgracefully themselves, they always assign it a title of independent power.

Latin · §5.5.19–5.7.26

Latin source witness: §5.5.19 · §5.5.20 · §5.5.21 · §5.5.22 · §5.5.23 · §5.6.24 · §5.7.25 · §5.7.26

If I concede — as you say — that desire’s evil cannot be conquered, I will profess myself an advocate of…§5.7.27–5.9.35

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.7.27If I concede — as you say — that desire’s evil cannot be conquered, I will profess myself an advocate of shamefulness. But if I said that I called this evil natural, yet one that could be conquered — that is, avoided —

People can avoid every sin when they can conquer the evil of desire. If lust is a natural evil and is conquered by love of virtue, all the more can the vices arising solely from the will be overcome.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.7.29The opinion that the genitals could have served at the will’s direction in paradise is feeble and soft.

Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “In this way that opinion of yours could indeed very easily be true as well, by which you say that a human being is without sin if he wills.”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.7.30Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “So do not do what you do not want to suffer, and do not say ‘that we invite to sweet thefts the people to whom we read out the Apostle saying: I know that good does not dwell in me, that is, in my flesh’ (Romans 7:18).”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.8.31For what they afterward did by propagation is the good of marriage; but what they first covered in shame is the evil of desire.

It is impossible for a good thing not to share its praise with that without which it cannot exist.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.8.32Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “I certainly never said that ‘the pleasure of the flesh’ is ‘unconquerable,’ as you falsely charge that ‘I usually do.’”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.8.33Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “You remark that ‘it was in vain that you showed anything, with the Apostle as witness, about the shame of those people and the covering of their shameful parts.’ For you call ‘more modest’ the parts that he calls unpresentable. … So again you take refuge, in vain, in Balbus and the writings of the philosophers.”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.8.34Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “What I said ‘about limping and arriving,’ you did not understand, if you are not acting in bad faith. For I did not mean ‘the arriving to be taken as the human being who is born from marital intercourse,’ which you suppose, or pretend, that I meant.”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.9.35Not conjugal — that is, licit and honorable — intercourse was prohibited, but the command was that the cause of this act be the will for offspring, not the pleasure of the flesh; and what cannot happen without desire should nevertheless happen not for the sake of desire.

O the depth of the riches of God’s wisdom and knowledge (Romans 11:33)! Besides the future repayment of deeds, he willed free choice in large part to fulfill the form of judgment. Most justly, the good person and the evil person are each entrusted to themselves, so that the good person may enjoy himself and the evil person suffer himself.

Latin · §5.7.27–5.9.35

Latin source witness: §5.7.27 · §5.7.29 · §5.7.30 · §5.8.31 · §5.8.32 · §5.8.33 · §5.8.34 · §5.9.35

There can be absolutely nothing that is both sin and punishment for sin. Augustine reports, speaking to…§5.9.36–5.11.45

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.9.36There can be absolutely nothing that is both sin and punishment for sin.

Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “And on top of this you boast that my statements contradict each other: because I said, not indeed, as you falsely charge, ‘that bodily intercourse was invented by the devil’ … but I said ‘that the disobedience of the flesh, which shows itself in the flesh that desires against the spirit, came about through the devil’s wound’; and again, because I said: ‘This law of sin, which fights against the law of the mind, was brought on by God as retribution, and is therefore a punishment of sin.’ These, you assert, contradict each other.”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.9.39The Lord honored the glory of continence with freedom of choice, saying: ‘Let the one who can receive it receive it’ (Matthew 19:12).

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.9.40Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “You thought that the Apostle's warning, that no one should possess his vessel in the sickness of desire (1 Thessalonians 4:4-5), is to be taken not of marriage but of fornication.”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.10.41Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “But you insert other words of mine, where I commended the will of spouses who are truly devout because they are Christians, who beget children in this age for this purpose, that they may be reborn in Christ for the sake of the other age. Then you mention that you already demolished this view of mine in your second book.”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.10.42Nothing of that kind can be thought about during intercourse.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.10.43Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “You boast and pour out an empty, frothy eloquence, ‘comparing parents to parricides, asserting that the cause of children being born with condemnation lies in them.’”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.11.44It would have been better for that man not to be born (Matthew 26:24).

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.11.45The ancient holy fathers did not devote themselves to producing offspring with the intention of generating guilty children to be cleansed by baptism, because the baptism through which we are now adopted had not yet been instituted.

Latin · §5.9.36–5.11.45

Latin source witness: §5.9.36 · §5.9.39 · §5.9.40 · §5.10.41 · §5.10.42 · §5.10.43 · §5.11.44 · §5.11.45

Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Now, as for Joseph, whose ‘wife’ I called Mary on the testimony of…§5.12.46–5.15.54

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.12.46Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Now, as for Joseph, whose ‘wife’ I called Mary on the testimony of the Gospel, you argue long and at length against my view, and you try to show ‘that, because intercourse was absent, it was in no way a marriage.’”

“So I ought not to be thought, just because I said that the whole good of marriage, that is, this threefold good, was fulfilled in those parents of Christ, to have said it, as you falsely charge, ‘so that whatever was otherwise would seem to be evil.’”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.12.47Joseph was regarded by everyone as though he were her husband.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.12.48She received the name ‘wife’ from the pledge of betrothal.

The first spouses were established so that they would be spouses without the union of the two sexes.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.13.49Human beings are created by God.

‘You joined me together with bones and sinews; you granted me life and mercy’ (Job 10:11–12).

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.14.51A thing existing in a subject cannot exist without the thing in which it inheres. Therefore the evil in a parent, existing in that subject, cannot transmit guilt to another thing—the offspring—to which it has not passed.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.15.52Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “Why do you labor with great arguments to reach the brink of impiety, so that ‘the flesh of Christ, because he was born of Mary, whose virgin flesh had been propagated from Adam like that of everyone else, differs in no way from sinful flesh, and the Apostle is believed to have said without any distinction that he was sent in the likeness of sinful flesh’ (Romans 8:3)? Or rather you press the point ‘that no flesh is sinful flesh, so that Christ’s may not be so either.’”

“But you said ‘that I had not understood this saying of the Apostle.’”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.15.53Even if newborns could draw some evil from their parents, it would be cleansed by God’s hands, because he himself forms them in their mothers’ wombs.

God’s works are hidden (compare Sirach 3:22–23).

This pronouncement exposes the emptiness of those who think nature’s depths can be comprehended by some investigation.

‘I do not know how you appeared in my womb’ (2 Maccabees 7:22).

Why are children not cleansed by the very act of their making, so that the maker’s majesty purifies them from the alleged pollutions of their parents?

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.15.54Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “From another book of mine, which I wrote to Marcellinus of holy memory, you chose to set down, as though lodging an objection against me, what was said of Adam, ‘that he corrupted in himself all who were to come from his stock.’ … But the words in that same sentence of mine that matter most for the point, I will say, since you did not want to say them; and why you did not want to will at once be clear: ‘By the hidden decay of his fleshly desire,’ I said, ‘he corrupted in himself all who were to come from his stock.’”

Latin · §5.12.46–5.15.54

Latin source witness: §5.12.46 · §5.12.47 · §5.12.48 · §5.13.49 · §5.14.51 · §5.15.52 · §5.15.53 · §5.15.54

The error of Apollinaris, who denied that Christ possessed bodily sensation.§5.15.55–5.16.62

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.15.55The error of Apollinaris, who denied that Christ possessed bodily sensation.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.15.56Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “But far be it from us, as you falsely charge, ‘to bring the reborn back under the necessity of crimes, while God bestows the gifts of virtues.’”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.15.57A dissimilar nature could not provide an example.

‘He committed no sin’ (1 Peter 2:22).

Notice that the apostle judged it sufficient to show there was no sin in Christ by saying he committed no sin, teaching that someone who did not commit it could not possess it.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.15.58Remove the reason of his example, and you will also remove the reason for his becoming a ransom for us.

We hurry to faith’s defenses in the hope of being free from evil. Yet we do not become free from what is inborn: male sexual capacity itself remains after baptism.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.16.59Sins are not born from something free from sin.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.16.60When it serves married people for producing offspring, lust is then honored.

Using lust always entails guilt.

Adulterers sin less than married people, because lust serves married people so that they sin, while it commands adulterers.

If lust is evil, it binds married people whom it serves with greater guilt than adulterers whom it rules.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.16.61We know that its excess can be held within permitted limits by the mind’s power.

We testify that virgins and those practicing continence possess complete disdain for it.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.16.62Marriage is nothing other than the union of bodies.

Propagation is impossible without mutual desire and the natural act.

Latin · §5.15.55–5.16.62

Latin source witness: §5.15.55 · §5.15.56 · §5.15.57 · §5.15.58 · §5.16.59 · §5.16.60 · §5.16.61 · §5.16.62

Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “But again you say that I contradict myself, setting out, of…§5.16.63–5.16.66

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.16.63Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “But again you say that I contradict myself, setting out, of course, other words of mine, where, distinguishing the duty of propagation from the seeking of fleshly delight, I said: ‘It is one thing to lie together only with the will to beget, which has no fault; another, in lying together, to seek the pleasure of the flesh, but not outside one’s spouse, which has a pardonable fault.’”

“For you falsely charge ‘that we offer an excuse to shameful and wicked people, so that when they have committed unspeakable and unclean acts, they may say that they did it against their will, and therefore have no sin.’”

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.16.64Guilt cannot be born from an act that has no guilt.

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.16.65You praised continence in the Christian age not to kindle people toward virginity, but to condemn the good of marriage established by God.

If you sincerely invite people to pursue continence, then you acknowledge that those who will it can maintain chastity’s virtue, so that whoever wishes may be holy in body and spirit (compare 1 Corinthians 7:34).

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5.16.66Augustine reports, speaking to Julian: “You assert ‘that the apostolic sentence by which he marks out heretics who forbid marriage (1 Timothy 4:3) touches me too,’ as though I were saying: ‘After Christ’s coming, marriages are shameful.’”

“What you say, Christian teaching does not say; that is, to set down your own words, ‘that a human being is sufficient to give laws to the impulses inborn in him.’”

Latin · §5.16.63–5.16.66

The Latin is on each section page: §5.16.63 §5.16.64 §5.16.65 §5.16.66

Latin source witness: §5.16.63 · §5.16.64 · §5.16.65 · §5.16.66

Contents