▶ Listen to the King James Version 0:00 / 4:29 1×
1 I speak the truth in Christ; I am not lying, as confirmed by my conscience in the Holy Spirit. Verse 1: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 2 I have deep sorrow and unceasing anguish in my heart. Verse 2: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 3 For I could wish that I myself were cursed and cut off from Christ for the sake of my brothers, my own flesh and blood, Verse 3: 6 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 4 the people of Israel. Theirs is the adoption as sons; theirs the divine glory and the covenants; theirs the giving of the law, the temple worship, and the promises. Verse 4: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 5 Theirs are the patriarchs, and from them proceeds the human descent of Christ, who is God over all, forever worthy of praise! Amen. Verse 5: 19 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 6 It is not as though God’s word has failed. For not all who are descended from Israel are Israel. Verse 6: 6 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 7 Nor because they are Abraham’s descendants are they all his children. On the contrary, “Through Isaac your offspring will be reckoned.” Verse 7: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 8 So it is not the children of the flesh who are God’s children, but it is the children of the promise who are regarded as offspring. Verse 8: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 9 For this is what the promise stated: “At the appointed time I will return, and Sarah will have a son.” Verse 9: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 10 Not only that, but Rebecca’s children were conceived by one man, our father Isaac. Verse 10: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 11 Yet before the twins were born or had done anything good or bad, in order that God’s plan of election might stand, Verse 11: 8 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 12 not by works but by Him who calls, she was told, “The older will serve the younger.” Verse 12: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 13 So it is written: “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated.” Verse 13: 6 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 14 What then shall we say? Is God unjust? Certainly not! Verse 14: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 15 For He says to Moses: “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.” Verse 15: 7 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 16 So then, it does not depend on man’s desire or effort, but on God’s mercy. Verse 16: 14 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 17 For the Scripture says to Pharaoh: “I raised you up for this very purpose, that I might display My power in you, and that My name might be proclaimed in all the earth.” Verse 17: 8 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 18 Therefore God has mercy on whom He wants to have mercy, and He hardens whom He wants to harden. Verse 18: 12 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 19 One of you will say to me, “Then why does God still find fault? For who can resist His will?” Verse 19: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 20 But who are you, O man, to talk back to God? Shall what is formed say to Him who formed it, “Why did You make me like this?” Verse 20: 8 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 21 Does not the potter have the right to make from the same lump of clay one vessel for special occasions and another for common use? Verse 21: 8 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 22 What if God, intending to show His wrath and make His power known, bore with great patience the vessels of His wrath, prepared for destruction? Verse 22: 12 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 23 What if He did this to make the riches of His glory known to the vessels of His mercy, whom He prepared in advance for glory— Verse 23: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 24 including us, whom He has called not only from the Jews, but also from the Gentiles? Verse 24: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 25 As He says in Hosea: “I will call them ‘My People’ who are not My people, and I will call her ‘My Beloved’ who is not My beloved,” Verse 25: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 26 and, “It will happen that in the very place where it was said to them, ‘You are not My people,’ they will be called ‘sons of the living God.’” Verse 26: 2 passages in the Fathers 27 Isaiah cries out concerning Israel: “Though the number of the Israelites is like the sand of the sea, only the remnant will be saved. Verse 27: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 28 For the Lord will carry out His sentence on the earth thoroughly and decisively.” Verse 28: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 29 It is just as Isaiah foretold: “Unless the Lord of Hosts had left us descendants, we would have become like Sodom, we would have resembled Gomorrah.” Verse 29: 1 passage in the Fathers 30 What then will we say? That the Gentiles, who did not pursue righteousness, have obtained it, a righteousness that is by faith; Verse 30: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 31 but Israel, who pursued a law of righteousness, has not attained it. Verse 31: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 32 Why not? Because their pursuit was not by faith, but as if it were by works. They stumbled over the stumbling stone, Verse 32: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 33 as it is written: “See, I lay in Zion a stone of stumbling and a rock of offense; and the one who believes in Him will never be put to shame.” Verse 33: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary
Audio: the King James Version read aloud, from Larry Sanger's Deep Dive Bible (public domain).
×
This chapter in the Fathers
Romans 9 172 passages
33 of 33 verses cited
16 writers
Most cited verses Romans 9:5 19 passages Romans 9:16 14 passages Romans 9:18 12 passages Romans 9:22 12 passages Romans 9:11 8 passages Romans 9:20 8 passages Romans 9:17 8 passages Romans 9:21 8 passages On the chapter as a whole John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §80 It refers the gift of saving grace not to the person who works better, but to God loving and pitying one more than another. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §92 And "I choose to give to this one, and not to you," where on the human side everything is equal, is a voice just as worthy of God, and likewise serves to display his supreme liberty, as Paul proves. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §296 On Romans 9 : election does not look to a good already in the person but makes it. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §445 Plainly then predestination itself, the cause of such grace prepared and gifted, is not bound to any antecedent acts of human choice, but is constituted in God's free good pleasure — as stated in Rom. 9 :15Rom. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §479 Paul shows it in Rom. 9 : after stating Jacob's gratuitous election and Esau's being passed by, he at once thrusts off the objection human reason prompts — that if by such good pleasure one unborn brother is loved and the other hated… John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §520 Second, they try to prove foresighted demerits are the cause of reprobation — oddly enough — from Paul's own debate in Romans 9 , where we take him to establish the opposite. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §530 To the first witness from Romans 9 : Paul is not giving the reason why the Jews were reprobated, but why they failed to attain true righteousness before God — however keen they seemed as pursuers of righteousness. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §545 Here refuge is Rom. 9 : He has mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardens. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §562 With Aquinas we gladly grant: foresight of merits cannot be any reason of predestination, because foresighted merits themselves fall under predestination; yet foresight of sins can be some reason of reprobation on the side of the… John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · Justification by Faith §14 This is the very point on which Saint Paul so strongly insists in Romans 9 , namely, that the terms of pardon and acceptance must depend, not on us, but on him who calls us. Select a marked verse to see who cites it.
Verse
Romans 9:1 3 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 3 passages
Paul, who had been sent to the nations and kept saying that Israel had fallen away, swears to his sincerity so that no one will think he gloats over his own kin.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Now the blessed Paul had been appointed a minister of the divine gospel and was proclaiming Jesus to the nations. Again and again he said that those of Israel’s blood had fallen away, and he insisted that those who were once in darkness and served demons had become called according to the purpose and foreknowledge of God. So that none of the less instructed might think he was all but leaping on his own kin as they lay fallen, and smiling over their fall, he makes a necessary defense and says, “I am speaking the truth in Christ, I am not lying,” and what follows (Romans 9:1).
Fragments on Romans, §28 → read in full
Israel was God's chosen firstborn but, by its pride and its killing of the Lord, was cast out and put behind the nations.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“I am speaking the truth in Christ, I am not lying; my conscience bears witness with me” (Romans 9:1). In the beginning God made Israel his chosen one and even called him firstborn (Exodus 4:22). But they became boastful and insolent, and, what goes beyond even this, slayers of the Lord. That is why they have perished; for they have been sent away and cast out, and, having slipped wholly from their closeness to God, they have been placed behind the nations; and they have shown themselves strangers to the hope of the fathers.
Fragments on Romans, §28 → read in full
Paul, who had been sent to the nations and kept saying that Israel had fallen away, swears to his sincerity so that no one will think he gloats over his own kin.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Now the blessed Paul had been appointed a minister of the divine gospel and was proclaiming Jesus to the nations. Again and again he said that those of Israel’s blood had fallen away, and he insisted that those who were once in darkness and served demons had become called according to the purpose and foreknowledge of God. So that none of the less instructed might think he was all but leaping on his own kin as they lay fallen, and smiling over their fall, he makes a necessary defense and says, “I am speaking the truth in Christ, I am not lying,” and what follows (Romans 9:1).
Fragments on Romans, §28 → read in full
On Romans 9:1–2
Paul calls on God as witness that his sorrow for his kinsmen, who missed the promised good things, is real and constant.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
From the hoped-for good things, both extremes have proceeded (Rom 9:1-5): the contention regarding love and the lamentation regarding those who have fallen away. For those being benefited love, but those failing in the benefits lament appropriately. He says, intensifying with divine testimony, that he does not speak only in word but also in disposition and truth, that he has the greatest sorrow continually present for his kinsmen.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:2 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (1) All 1 passage
On Romans 9:1–2
Paul calls on God as witness that his sorrow for his kinsmen, who missed the promised good things, is real and constant.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
From the hoped-for good things, both extremes have proceeded (Rom 9:1-5): the contention regarding love and the lamentation regarding those who have fallen away. For those being benefited love, but those failing in the benefits lament appropriately. He says, intensifying with divine testimony, that he does not speak only in word but also in disposition and truth, that he has the greatest sorrow continually present for his kinsmen.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:3 3 comments from the Fathers, 6 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (3) All 6 passages
To grieve over the fallen is love, but to wish oneself accursed for them is hyperbole, a proof of the most perfect love.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Over those who have gone so far in perversity as to slip from their love for God, and then to suffer harsh penalties for it, one might well grieve; and to shed a tear for them out of fellow feeling would not be beyond reason; or rather, it is the fullness of love. But to wish even to be accursed from Christ on their behalf (Romans 9:3) goes beyond the measures of love. For no one, if he is in his right mind, would choose to offend God for the sake of the salvation of others, counting his own life as nothing while choosing that others should have it. What, then, does he mean in putting forward his own salvation as the price of the salvation of the Jews? The statement is a hyperbole, and it gives proof of the most perfect love. “For I could wish,” he says, “that I myself were accursed from Christ for the sake of my brothers” (Romans 9:3). It is as if he were saying, “If Israel were saved by my offending Christ, I myself would have chosen it.”
Fragments on Romans, §28 → read in full
On Romans 9:3–5
Paul justifies his willingness to be accursed by listing what Israel had, so that its fall is the more dreadful.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So, he says, I for my part would very gladly choose to be accursed from Christ, if only I could save those of my own blood (Romans 9:3). Then he adds, as if to show that the cause of his grief over them is quite able to work such a disposition in him, so that he might not seem to have said something harsh and jarring in offering his own life in exchange for the life of others: For first, he says, they are Israelites; theirs are the adoption and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the law and the worship and the promises; and from them, according to the flesh, comes Christ himself (Romans 9:4–5).
Now if they had been among those who had not known from ancient times the One who is God by nature and in truth, if the law given through Moses had not become for them the steward of their closeness to him, if they had not sprung from the root of the holy fathers and been made heirs of their good name, if they had not been the first to practice the ways of worshiping God and had not grown rich in the hopes of the promise, then one would have grieved over them more moderately. But since “theirs are the fathers,” and the rest (Romans 9:5), and since, when their affairs were all but running before a fair wind, they have fallen into an end no one expected and have missed their hope, how is what has befallen these wretched people not truly dreadful?
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
To grieve over the fallen is love, but to wish oneself accursed for them is hyperbole, a proof of the most perfect love.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Over those who have gone so far in perversity as to slip from their love for God, and then to suffer harsh penalties for it, one might well grieve; and to shed a tear for them out of fellow feeling would not be beyond reason; or rather, it is the fullness of love. But to wish even to be accursed from Christ on their behalf (Romans 9:3) goes beyond the measures of love. For no one, if he is in his right mind, would choose to offend God for the sake of the salvation of others, counting his own life as nothing while choosing that others should have it. What, then, does he mean in putting forward his own salvation as the price of the salvation of the Jews? The statement is a hyperbole, and it gives proof of the most perfect love. “For I could wish,” he says, “that I myself were accursed from Christ for the sake of my brothers” (Romans 9:3). It is as if he were saying, “If Israel were saved by my offending Christ, I myself would have chosen it.”
Fragments on Romans, §28 → read in full
Paul's sorrow and his wish to suffer for his enemies should not be doubted.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Let no one disbelieve, he says, if I lament concerning the adversaries and persecutors, nor let it be considered paradoxical if I desired to suffer the greatest things on their behalf, being handed over unto death by Christ.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
On Romans 9:3–5
Paul justifies his willingness to be accursed by listing what Israel had, so that its fall is the more dreadful.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So, he says, I for my part would very gladly choose to be accursed from Christ, if only I could save those of my own blood (Romans 9:3). Then he adds, as if to show that the cause of his grief over them is quite able to work such a disposition in him, so that he might not seem to have said something harsh and jarring in offering his own life in exchange for the life of others: For first, he says, they are Israelites; theirs are the adoption and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the law and the worship and the promises; and from them, according to the flesh, comes Christ himself (Romans 9:4–5).
Now if they had been among those who had not known from ancient times the One who is God by nature and in truth, if the law given through Moses had not become for them the steward of their closeness to him, if they had not sprung from the root of the holy fathers and been made heirs of their good name, if they had not been the first to practice the ways of worshiping God and had not grown rich in the hopes of the promise, then one would have grieved over them more moderately. But since “theirs are the fathers,” and the rest (Romans 9:5), and since, when their affairs were all but running before a fair wind, they have fallen into an end no one expected and have missed their hope, how is what has befallen these wretched people not truly dreadful?
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
6 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:4 2 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 4 passages
On Romans 9:3–5
Paul justifies his willingness to be accursed by listing what Israel had, so that its fall is the more dreadful.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So, he says, I for my part would very gladly choose to be accursed from Christ, if only I could save those of my own blood (Romans 9:3). Then he adds, as if to show that the cause of his grief over them is quite able to work such a disposition in him, so that he might not seem to have said something harsh and jarring in offering his own life in exchange for the life of others: For first, he says, they are Israelites; theirs are the adoption and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the law and the worship and the promises; and from them, according to the flesh, comes Christ himself (Romans 9:4–5).
Now if they had been among those who had not known from ancient times the One who is God by nature and in truth, if the law given through Moses had not become for them the steward of their closeness to him, if they had not sprung from the root of the holy fathers and been made heirs of their good name, if they had not been the first to practice the ways of worshiping God and had not grown rich in the hopes of the promise, then one would have grieved over them more moderately. But since “theirs are the fathers,” and the rest (Romans 9:5), and since, when their affairs were all but running before a fair wind, they have fallen into an end no one expected and have missed their hope, how is what has befallen these wretched people not truly dreadful?
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:3–5
Paul justifies his willingness to be accursed by listing what Israel had, so that its fall is the more dreadful.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So, he says, I for my part would very gladly choose to be accursed from Christ, if only I could save those of my own blood (Romans 9:3). Then he adds, as if to show that the cause of his grief over them is quite able to work such a disposition in him, so that he might not seem to have said something harsh and jarring in offering his own life in exchange for the life of others: For first, he says, they are Israelites; theirs are the adoption and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the law and the worship and the promises; and from them, according to the flesh, comes Christ himself (Romans 9:4–5).
Now if they had been among those who had not known from ancient times the One who is God by nature and in truth, if the law given through Moses had not become for them the steward of their closeness to him, if they had not sprung from the root of the holy fathers and been made heirs of their good name, if they had not been the first to practice the ways of worshiping God and had not grown rich in the hopes of the promise, then one would have grieved over them more moderately. But since “theirs are the fathers,” and the rest (Romans 9:5), and since, when their affairs were all but running before a fair wind, they have fallen into an end no one expected and have missed their hope, how is what has befallen these wretched people not truly dreadful?
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:4–5
Israel's condition is pitiable because it was glorified and chosen and kin to the Lord, yet is now cast off and brought low, though God who judged this is still to be blessed.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
For how is not their condition pitiable, especially in the eyes of their own people and kin—men called sons of God from the beginning, glorified with glory from God in the world, who received the first covenant concerning bodily ordinances, and now hold in their hands the second one that has come concerning spiritual things, and those chosen for the worship of God and the promises of future good things, the fathers of the saints and God-loving ones, those homogeneous with the flesh of the Lord, these being cast off and despised and having fallen now into the greatest shame and lowliness. But therefore, even if what happened concerning them is worthy of lamentation, it is worthy to bless the God who thus judged, the Master over all, to whom all blessing is justly returned from all and upon all.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:5 2 comments from the Fathers, 19 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 19 passages
On Romans 9:3–5
Paul justifies his willingness to be accursed by listing what Israel had, so that its fall is the more dreadful.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So, he says, I for my part would very gladly choose to be accursed from Christ, if only I could save those of my own blood (Romans 9:3). Then he adds, as if to show that the cause of his grief over them is quite able to work such a disposition in him, so that he might not seem to have said something harsh and jarring in offering his own life in exchange for the life of others: For first, he says, they are Israelites; theirs are the adoption and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the law and the worship and the promises; and from them, according to the flesh, comes Christ himself (Romans 9:4–5).
Now if they had been among those who had not known from ancient times the One who is God by nature and in truth, if the law given through Moses had not become for them the steward of their closeness to him, if they had not sprung from the root of the holy fathers and been made heirs of their good name, if they had not been the first to practice the ways of worshiping God and had not grown rich in the hopes of the promise, then one would have grieved over them more moderately. But since “theirs are the fathers,” and the rest (Romans 9:5), and since, when their affairs were all but running before a fair wind, they have fallen into an end no one expected and have missed their hope, how is what has befallen these wretched people not truly dreadful?
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:3–5
Paul justifies his willingness to be accursed by listing what Israel had, so that its fall is the more dreadful.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So, he says, I for my part would very gladly choose to be accursed from Christ, if only I could save those of my own blood (Romans 9:3). Then he adds, as if to show that the cause of his grief over them is quite able to work such a disposition in him, so that he might not seem to have said something harsh and jarring in offering his own life in exchange for the life of others: For first, he says, they are Israelites; theirs are the adoption and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the law and the worship and the promises; and from them, according to the flesh, comes Christ himself (Romans 9:4–5).
Now if they had been among those who had not known from ancient times the One who is God by nature and in truth, if the law given through Moses had not become for them the steward of their closeness to him, if they had not sprung from the root of the holy fathers and been made heirs of their good name, if they had not been the first to practice the ways of worshiping God and had not grown rich in the hopes of the promise, then one would have grieved over them more moderately. But since “theirs are the fathers,” and the rest (Romans 9:5), and since, when their affairs were all but running before a fair wind, they have fallen into an end no one expected and have missed their hope, how is what has befallen these wretched people not truly dreadful?
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:4–5
Israel's condition is pitiable because it was glorified and chosen and kin to the Lord, yet is now cast off and brought low, though God who judged this is still to be blessed.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
For how is not their condition pitiable, especially in the eyes of their own people and kin—men called sons of God from the beginning, glorified with glory from God in the world, who received the first covenant concerning bodily ordinances, and now hold in their hands the second one that has come concerning spiritual things, and those chosen for the worship of God and the promises of future good things, the fathers of the saints and God-loving ones, those homogeneous with the flesh of the Lord, these being cast off and despised and having fallen now into the greatest shame and lowliness. But therefore, even if what happened concerning them is worthy of lamentation, it is worthy to bless the God who thus judged, the Master over all, to whom all blessing is justly returned from all and upon all.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
19 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Novatian fl. c. 250 AD · On the Trinity 13 If Christ discerns the secrets of the heart, which belongs to God alone; if He forgives sins, which belongs to God alone; if He comes from heaven, which no mere man can do; if He says, "I and the Father are one" (John 10:30), which no… Novatian fl. c. 250 AD · On the Trinity 30 And again: 'From whom are the patriarchs, and from whom, according to the flesh, comes the Christ, who is God over all, blessed forever'. Eustathius of Antioch fl. c. 320–337 AD · Christological Homily on Lazarus §6 He is not one of the Jewish Christs, nor one of the Jewish and written-of Christs, but you are, according to Paul, “the one Lord, blessed above all unto the ages of ages, Amen”. Eustathius of Antioch fl. c. 320–337 AD · Oration on “The Lord Created Me” §3 But if it were fitting to attach some form of weakness to him, one might say it is consistent to attach these things to the man, not indeed to the fullness of the Godhead, nor to the dignity of the highest Wisdom, nor to the God who is… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §8 For it shows that he holds the kingdom undivided with God the Father and his Holy Spirit, and that he is “God over all”. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §11 Amen”. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §14 Nor is it in respect of equality, because it is written that the Son is great and “God over all”, “making himself equal to the Father” (John 5:18), and “swearing by himself, since he has no one greater” (Hebrews 6:13). Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §29 What they declare of the Father as God, they declare of the Son as well: that “in him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead” (Colossians 2:9); that he is “great God” (Titus 2:13) and “over all”, the one “with whom no other shall be… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §30 “Creator,” and “Sovereign,” and “of his peace there is no bound” (Isaiah 9:7), and “Saviour,” and “Christ is all in all” (Colossians 3:11), and “blessed for ever”; and that “great is the mystery of godliness” (1 Timothy 3:16), plainly the… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §38 It declares him Almighty (Revelation 1:8), Maker of the ages (Hebrews 1:2), Creator of all things (John 1:3), true God (1 John 5:20), one who has no God before him (Isaiah 43:10), above all (John 3:31), the great God, God over all (Titus… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on 2 Corinthians §1 Amen”. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §29 But since “theirs are the fathers,” and the rest, and since, when their affairs were all but running before a fair wind, they have fallen into an end no one expected and have missed their hope, how is what has befallen these wretched… Ammonius of Alexandria fl. 5th century AD · Fragments on John §2 [John 1:11] He is said to have come to his own inasmuch as, having been incarnate, he was made known to those who saw him with their eyes, or that he came to his own, who seemed to be his according to “from whom is the Christ according to… Hesychius of Jerusalem fl. c. 412–450 AD · On Saint Stephen §3 …for Christ came from them, the vine of our life (John 15:1); but it is we who gather his grapes, we who mix the wine, we who drink the new wine. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.23.2 For (1) He is called God not only attributively — John 1:1; Romans 9:5 — but also subjectively — 1 Timothy 3:16; Hebrews 1:8-9; Titus 2:13. John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · The Lord Our Righteousness §10 He who exists, over all, God, blessed forever, the supreme, the eternal. John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · Upon Our Lord’s Sermon on the Mount Discourse I §10 Yes, the one who is, the being of beings, Jehovah, the self-existent, the supreme, the God who is over all, blessed for ever. John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · Upon Our Lord’s Sermon on the Mount Discourse VI §29 Who is in heaven, high and lifted up (Isaiah 6:1), God over all, blessed forever. John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · Catholic Spirit §23 Do you believe in the Lord Jesus Christ, God over all, blessed forever? Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:6 2 comments from the Fathers, 6 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 6 passages
God's word has not failed, for it promised Abraham many nations and not only Israel, since all who walk in his faith are his children.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“But it is not as though the word of God has failed” (Romans 9:6). The statement is exact. For he says that the word of God has by no means proved false, that is, that it cannot fall away from the truth. For the God of all, as everyone agrees, promised Abraham at the beginning that he would be the father of many (Genesis 17:4–5), and again, “I will surely multiply your offspring like the stars of heaven in number” (Genesis 22:17).
Abraham, then, had to be shown to be the father not of those from Israel alone. For the nation that came from him was one, but the nations throughout the whole earth are past counting, and they too have been reckoned as Abraham’s children, if indeed they are of the promise and “walk in the footsteps of the faith” he had “in uncircumcision” (Romans 4:12), as it is written. For as blessed Paul himself says somewhere, “The promise to Abraham that he would be heir of the world did not come through the law, but through the righteousness of faith. For if those who are of the law are heirs,” he says, “faith has been emptied and the promise made void” (Romans 4:13–14).
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
God's word has not failed, for it promised Abraham many nations and not only Israel, since all who walk in his faith are his children.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“But it is not as though the word of God has failed” (Romans 9:6). The statement is exact. For he says that the word of God has by no means proved false, that is, that it cannot fall away from the truth. For the God of all, as everyone agrees, promised Abraham at the beginning that he would be the father of many (Genesis 17:4–5), and again, “I will surely multiply your offspring like the stars of heaven in number” (Genesis 22:17).
Abraham, then, had to be shown to be the father not of those from Israel alone. For the nation that came from him was one, but the nations throughout the whole earth are past counting, and they too have been reckoned as Abraham’s children, if indeed they are of the promise and “walk in the footsteps of the faith” he had “in uncircumcision” (Romans 4:12), as it is written. For as blessed Paul himself says somewhere, “The promise to Abraham that he would be heir of the world did not come through the law, but through the righteousness of faith. For if those who are of the law are heirs,” he says, “faith has been emptied and the promise made void” (Romans 4:13–14).
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:6–7
Paul's "not all are children" and "not all those of Israel are Israel" mean that true Israel is the man without deceit, not Israel according to the flesh.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
But as for that which is sometimes declared as not both seed and child, Paul writes: 'not all are children' (Rom 9:7); for not all those of Israel are Israel (Rom 9:6), but rather that one about whom the Savior said: 'Behold a man Israelite in whom there is no deceit' (John 1:47); but not these about whom it has been said: 'See Israel according to the flesh' (1 Corinthians 10:18). These things are regarding the difference between seed and child; let us return to what was explicitly set forth.
On Genesis, §85 → read in full
6 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:7 3 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 2 passages
On Romans 9:7–9
Because Abraham's offspring is reckoned in Isaac, that is by promise, the children of the flesh are not simply children of God; those who come through faith are.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Since, then, the offspring of Abraham has been reckoned as being in Isaac, that is, according to promise (Romans 9:7–8), for this is the word of promise, “About this time I will come, and Sarah shall have a son” (Romans 9:9), it would surely be plain that the children of the flesh would not, simply and in every case, be counted as children of God (Romans 9:8). Rather, it is the children of the promise, that is, those who come through faith, who would have that honor for themselves.
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:6–7
Paul's "not all are children" and "not all those of Israel are Israel" mean that true Israel is the man without deceit, not Israel according to the flesh.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
But as for that which is sometimes declared as not both seed and child, Paul writes: 'not all are children' (Rom 9:7); for not all those of Israel are Israel (Rom 9:6), but rather that one about whom the Savior said: 'Behold a man Israelite in whom there is no deceit' (John 1:47); but not these about whom it has been said: 'See Israel according to the flesh' (1 Corinthians 10:18). These things are regarding the difference between seed and child; let us return to what was explicitly set forth.
On Genesis, §85 → read in full
On Romans 9:7–9
Because Abraham's offspring is reckoned in Isaac, that is by promise, the children of the flesh are not simply children of God; those who come through faith are.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Since, then, the offspring of Abraham has been reckoned as being in Isaac, that is, according to promise (Romans 9:7–8), for this is the word of promise, “About this time I will come, and Sarah shall have a son” (Romans 9:9), it would surely be plain that the children of the flesh would not, simply and in every case, be counted as children of God (Romans 9:8). Rather, it is the children of the promise, that is, those who come through faith, who would have that honor for themselves.
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:7–9
God's truthfulness stands, because Scripture meant by Israelites those who show themselves worthy by piety, and God's promise follows foreknowledge in the Gentiles' case as in Isaac's.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
Since the things promised to the Israelites were transferred as if to the Gentiles (Rom 9:6-9), which was an accusation against God as if he were falsifying the promises, he shows the truthfulness of God, demonstrating that the Scripture did not signify the Israelites according to the flesh, but those showing through piety that they are worthy to be called Israelites and children of Abraham; for in Isaac, he says, you shall be called seed, and the things following. In Isaac, not through Isaac, which, explaining, he says: that is, not these children of the flesh are these children of God, but the children of the promise are reckoned as seed. But he wishes to say that not those from the flesh of Abraham, these are children of God, but children those from the promise, such as the pious and the righteous, whom God promised as sons to Abraham according to foreknowledge, since Isaac, having come to be from the promise, was shown to be righteous; for he foreknew and promised him righteous; for God would not be permitted to grant an impious son. Thus also he promised Abraham to be a father of nations, foreknowing the piety of the nations that were to come. Therefore he said: in Isaac you shall be called seed, that is, through the promise according to the pattern of Isaac, who was righteous and a pattern of the righteous. And the entire structure of the text is that the promise of God is according to foreknowledge, and the promise is according to the judgment of righteousness, and just as regarding Isaac, so also regarding the Gentiles.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On Genesis §85 But as for that which is sometimes declared as not both seed and child, Paul writes: 'not all are children'; for not all those of Israel are Israel (Rom 9:6), but rather that one about whom the Savior said: 'Behold a man Israelite in whom… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §29 Since, then, the offspring of Abraham has been reckoned as being in Isaac, that is, according to promise, for this is the word of promise, “About this time I will come, and Sarah shall have a son” (Romans 9:9), it would surely be plain… Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:8 2 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 3 passages
On Romans 9:7–9
Because Abraham's offspring is reckoned in Isaac, that is by promise, the children of the flesh are not simply children of God; those who come through faith are.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Since, then, the offspring of Abraham has been reckoned as being in Isaac, that is, according to promise (Romans 9:7–8), for this is the word of promise, “About this time I will come, and Sarah shall have a son” (Romans 9:9), it would surely be plain that the children of the flesh would not, simply and in every case, be counted as children of God (Romans 9:8). Rather, it is the children of the promise, that is, those who come through faith, who would have that honor for themselves.
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:7–9
Because Abraham's offspring is reckoned in Isaac, that is by promise, the children of the flesh are not simply children of God; those who come through faith are.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Since, then, the offspring of Abraham has been reckoned as being in Isaac, that is, according to promise (Romans 9:7–8), for this is the word of promise, “About this time I will come, and Sarah shall have a son” (Romans 9:9), it would surely be plain that the children of the flesh would not, simply and in every case, be counted as children of God (Romans 9:8). Rather, it is the children of the promise, that is, those who come through faith, who would have that honor for themselves.
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:7–9
God's truthfulness stands, because Scripture meant by Israelites those who show themselves worthy by piety, and God's promise follows foreknowledge in the Gentiles' case as in Isaac's.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
Since the things promised to the Israelites were transferred as if to the Gentiles (Rom 9:6-9), which was an accusation against God as if he were falsifying the promises, he shows the truthfulness of God, demonstrating that the Scripture did not signify the Israelites according to the flesh, but those showing through piety that they are worthy to be called Israelites and children of Abraham; for in Isaac, he says, you shall be called seed, and the things following. In Isaac, not through Isaac, which, explaining, he says: that is, not these children of the flesh are these children of God, but the children of the promise are reckoned as seed. But he wishes to say that not those from the flesh of Abraham, these are children of God, but children those from the promise, such as the pious and the righteous, whom God promised as sons to Abraham according to foreknowledge, since Isaac, having come to be from the promise, was shown to be righteous; for he foreknew and promised him righteous; for God would not be permitted to grant an impious son. Thus also he promised Abraham to be a father of nations, foreknowing the piety of the nations that were to come. Therefore he said: in Isaac you shall be called seed, that is, through the promise according to the pattern of Isaac, who was righteous and a pattern of the righteous. And the entire structure of the text is that the promise of God is according to foreknowledge, and the promise is according to the judgment of righteousness, and just as regarding Isaac, so also regarding the Gentiles.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Exhortation to Martyrdom §38 Only know that “it is not the children of the flesh who are children of God”; and that, just as it is said to those of the seed of Abraham, “I know that you are the seed of Abraham” (John 8:37), and “If you were children of Abraham, you… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On Genesis §92 For 'the children of the flesh are not these children of God, but the children of the promise are counted as seed'. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §29 Since, then, the offspring of Abraham has been reckoned as being in Isaac, that is, according to promise (Romans 9:7–8), for this is the word of promise, “About this time I will come, and Sarah shall have a son” (Romans 9:9), it would… Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:9 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 1 passage
On Romans 9:7–9
Because Abraham's offspring is reckoned in Isaac, that is by promise, the children of the flesh are not simply children of God; those who come through faith are.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Since, then, the offspring of Abraham has been reckoned as being in Isaac, that is, according to promise (Romans 9:7–8), for this is the word of promise, “About this time I will come, and Sarah shall have a son” (Romans 9:9), it would surely be plain that the children of the flesh would not, simply and in every case, be counted as children of God (Romans 9:8). Rather, it is the children of the promise, that is, those who come through faith, who would have that honor for themselves.
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:7–9
Because Abraham's offspring is reckoned in Isaac, that is by promise, the children of the flesh are not simply children of God; those who come through faith are.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Since, then, the offspring of Abraham has been reckoned as being in Isaac, that is, according to promise (Romans 9:7–8), for this is the word of promise, “About this time I will come, and Sarah shall have a son” (Romans 9:9), it would surely be plain that the children of the flesh would not, simply and in every case, be counted as children of God (Romans 9:8). Rather, it is the children of the promise, that is, those who come through faith, who would have that honor for themselves.
Fragments on Romans, §29 → read in full
On Romans 9:7–9
God's truthfulness stands, because Scripture meant by Israelites those who show themselves worthy by piety, and God's promise follows foreknowledge in the Gentiles' case as in Isaac's.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
Since the things promised to the Israelites were transferred as if to the Gentiles (Rom 9:6-9), which was an accusation against God as if he were falsifying the promises, he shows the truthfulness of God, demonstrating that the Scripture did not signify the Israelites according to the flesh, but those showing through piety that they are worthy to be called Israelites and children of Abraham; for in Isaac, he says, you shall be called seed, and the things following. In Isaac, not through Isaac, which, explaining, he says: that is, not these children of the flesh are these children of God, but the children of the promise are reckoned as seed. But he wishes to say that not those from the flesh of Abraham, these are children of God, but children those from the promise, such as the pious and the righteous, whom God promised as sons to Abraham according to foreknowledge, since Isaac, having come to be from the promise, was shown to be righteous; for he foreknew and promised him righteous; for God would not be permitted to grant an impious son. Thus also he promised Abraham to be a father of nations, foreknowing the piety of the nations that were to come. Therefore he said: in Isaac you shall be called seed, that is, through the promise according to the pattern of Isaac, who was righteous and a pattern of the righteous. And the entire structure of the text is that the promise of God is according to foreknowledge, and the promise is according to the judgment of righteousness, and just as regarding Isaac, so also regarding the Gentiles.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:10 2 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Complete (2) All 3 passages
Paul's sentence about Rebecca is left unfinished and needs words added to make it complete, namely that she too serves as a pattern of the calling that comes by election.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
One should note that the aim of this sentence is by no means brought to completion; rather it is left hanging and needs a brief addition, that is, words to be understood, so that it may not appear to limp. What I mean is this. He had already shown, from the fact that Isaac was given to Abraham by promise, that the children of the flesh would not necessarily be counted to him as offspring, and that it would rather befit him to bear the name of father of those who are of faith and promise. Then he takes up Rebecca and what happened in her case, and says, “And not only so,” that is, my argument will not stop at the birth of Isaac alone, “but also Rebecca, having conceived by one, our father Isaac” (Romans 9:10). And he needed to add something like this: “will also be brought in as proof and assurance,” that is, “will serve as a pattern and image of the calling and grace that come by election and foreknowledge.” For had something of that kind been added, his sentence would then have seemed complete.
But I do not know how he came to pass this over and go straight on to what was said and done at the birth of Isaac’s sons.
Fragments on Romans, §30 → read in full
On Romans 9:10–13
Paul teaches that God judges by conduct and not by descent, as Jacob and Esau, born together, had different outcomes according to what they deserved.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
Thus he rightly condemns those descended from Abraham when they live wickedly and drives them from his inheritance, just as he does Gentiles found acting similarly. Conversely, he rewards the good wills, true faith, and upright deeds of either people with eternal joys. The Teacher of the Nations therefore restrains Jewish pride and shows that the difference lies not in human seed but in conduct. They must recognize that unless they take care to be faithful, no privilege of circumcised ancestry will defend them. Jacob and Esau, after all, were conceived through one reception of seed and delivered through one act of giving birth, yet experienced very different outcomes because of the difference in what they deserved
To Florus, §1.131 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:11 4 comments from the Fathers, 8 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (4) All 8 passages
On Romans 9:11–12
God used the birth of Isaac's sons to sketch beforehand the mystery of grace by election, assuring Isaac that he would be father of countless nations of faith.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
But since the mystery of grace by election and of the gift given in foreknowledge had to be sketched out beforehand, for that very reason God, our supreme craftsman in such things, put the moment to good use and all but seized it. At the birth of the children he assured Isaac that, though he was the one and only son from Abraham, he would be the father of countless nations, those who are of the promise and who would be called in faith.
Fragments on Romans, §30 → read in full
On Romans 9:10–13
Paul teaches that God judges by conduct and not by descent, as Jacob and Esau, born together, had different outcomes according to what they deserved.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
Thus he rightly condemns those descended from Abraham when they live wickedly and drives them from his inheritance, just as he does Gentiles found acting similarly. Conversely, he rewards the good wills, true faith, and upright deeds of either people with eternal joys. The Teacher of the Nations therefore restrains Jewish pride and shows that the difference lies not in human seed but in conduct. They must recognize that unless they take care to be faithful, no privilege of circumcised ancestry will defend them. Jacob and Esau, after all, were conceived through one reception of seed and delivered through one act of giving birth, yet experienced very different outcomes because of the difference in what they deserved
To Florus, §1.131 → read in full
On Romans 9:11–12
God used the birth of Isaac's sons to sketch beforehand the mystery of grace by election, assuring Isaac that he would be father of countless nations of faith.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
But since the mystery of grace by election and of the gift given in foreknowledge had to be sketched out beforehand, for that very reason God, our supreme craftsman in such things, put the moment to good use and all but seized it. At the birth of the children he assured Isaac that, though he was the one and only son from Abraham, he would be the father of countless nations, those who are of the promise and who would be called in faith.
Fragments on Romans, §30 → read in full
On Romans 9:11–13
Paul speaks of election according to purpose, not purpose according to election, for God loved the one for his virtue and hated the other for the badness of his disposition.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
the apostle, for the demonstration of the same matter being before him, having remembered both Esau and Jacob (Rom 9:11), says thus: lest indeed, before they were born or had done anything good or evil, so that the intention of God according to election might remain … the one He loved because of his own virtue, and the other He hated because of the badness of his disposition, from which it is clear that the apostle speaks of an election according to purpose and not a purpose according to election.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:11–14
Paul answers in advance the charge that God chose by whim, since foreknowledge of Jacob's goodness and Esau's perversity makes the choice just.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
It was likely that some fault-finders would suppose that Jacob and Esau had met with an untested swing of will, and that the one was loved because God nodded assent out of personal favour, while the other was hated (Romans 9:13). So the apostle of necessity does away in advance with this view of the matter as ruinous … For if, he says, even before the infants had done anything, before any testing of them and before any deeds, the one was thought worthy of love and the other was hated, and was even appointed to serve the younger (Romans 9:11–12), then perhaps, he says, God is even unjust.
And then how is this not senseless?
For if Jacob had not become a good man, if Esau had not been wicked, one might reasonably say that the foreknowledge had perhaps gone astray, and that what was determined for both of them was the work of a random impulse and an unsteady will. But since Esau was very perverse and Jacob wise, God’s foreknowledge would do no wrong at all in granting, even ahead of time, to the one who was good in his ways that he should be loved, and to the one who was not such that he should be condemned. For it would have been no hard thing for God to bear with them patiently and wait for the time of their deeds, so that each might be shown plainly by his own actions.
Fragments on Romans, §30 → read in full
8 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · On Prayer §5 These, I think, are useful to assume beforehand toward dissolving the arguments that hold men back from praying (Matthew 6:8) (Wisdom of Solomon 11:24) (Psalm 58:3) (Galatians 1:15) (Genesis 25:23) (Romans 9:13) (Psalm 90:2) (Ephesians… Diodorus of Tarsus c. 330–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §7 And the use of these is much not only upon the old but also upon the new covenant; for the apostle, for the demonstration of the same matter being before him, having remembered both Esau and Jacob, says thus: lest indeed, before they were… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §30 For if, he says, even before the infants had done anything, before any testing of them and before any deeds, the one was thought worthy of love and the other was hated, and was even appointed to serve the younger, then perhaps, he says,… Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §3.5 For it was clear that, if he did anything unjust, his divinity would suffer exactly as much damage as his fairness did. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · Collective Letter to Thessalonica §2.7.15 Augustine attributes this explanation to the authors: “Jacob was loved because of the future works that God knew beforehand he would do” (Malachi 1:2–3). John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §229 I need not linger refuting these views: one blow from the Apostle flattens them all — the children not yet born, having done nothing good or evil, so that God's purpose according to election might stand, not from works but from the One… John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §446 So Rom. 9:11 (when they had done nothing good or evil, that God's purpose according to election might stand) and Eph. Samuel Strimesius 1648–1730 AD · A Candid Inquiry into the Controversies among Evangelicals §53 In that decree God (who by most free right could have saved everyone, passed no one by, and shown only the glory of mercy, power being enough in God and in Christ's satisfaction as ransom) decided, in His eternal counsel about all that… Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:12 4 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (4) All 1 passage
On Romans 9:11–12
God used the birth of Isaac's sons to sketch beforehand the mystery of grace by election, assuring Isaac that he would be father of countless nations of faith.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
But since the mystery of grace by election and of the gift given in foreknowledge had to be sketched out beforehand, for that very reason God, our supreme craftsman in such things, put the moment to good use and all but seized it. At the birth of the children he assured Isaac that, though he was the one and only son from Abraham, he would be the father of countless nations, those who are of the promise and who would be called in faith.
Fragments on Romans, §30 → read in full
On Romans 9:10–13
Paul teaches that God judges by conduct and not by descent, as Jacob and Esau, born together, had different outcomes according to what they deserved.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
Thus he rightly condemns those descended from Abraham when they live wickedly and drives them from his inheritance, just as he does Gentiles found acting similarly. Conversely, he rewards the good wills, true faith, and upright deeds of either people with eternal joys. The Teacher of the Nations therefore restrains Jewish pride and shows that the difference lies not in human seed but in conduct. They must recognize that unless they take care to be faithful, no privilege of circumcised ancestry will defend them. Jacob and Esau, after all, were conceived through one reception of seed and delivered through one act of giving birth, yet experienced very different outcomes because of the difference in what they deserved
To Florus, §1.131 → read in full
On Romans 9:11–12
God used the birth of Isaac's sons to sketch beforehand the mystery of grace by election, assuring Isaac that he would be father of countless nations of faith.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
But since the mystery of grace by election and of the gift given in foreknowledge had to be sketched out beforehand, for that very reason God, our supreme craftsman in such things, put the moment to good use and all but seized it. At the birth of the children he assured Isaac that, though he was the one and only son from Abraham, he would be the father of countless nations, those who are of the promise and who would be called in faith.
Fragments on Romans, §30 → read in full
On Romans 9:11–13
Paul speaks of election according to purpose, not purpose according to election, for God loved the one for his virtue and hated the other for the badness of his disposition.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
the apostle, for the demonstration of the same matter being before him, having remembered both Esau and Jacob (Rom 9:11), says thus: lest indeed, before they were born or had done anything good or evil, so that the intention of God according to election might remain … the one He loved because of his own virtue, and the other He hated because of the badness of his disposition, from which it is clear that the apostle speaks of an election according to purpose and not a purpose according to election.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:11–14
Paul answers in advance the charge that God chose by whim, since foreknowledge of Jacob's goodness and Esau's perversity makes the choice just.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
It was likely that some fault-finders would suppose that Jacob and Esau had met with an untested swing of will, and that the one was loved because God nodded assent out of personal favour, while the other was hated (Romans 9:13). So the apostle of necessity does away in advance with this view of the matter as ruinous … For if, he says, even before the infants had done anything, before any testing of them and before any deeds, the one was thought worthy of love and the other was hated, and was even appointed to serve the younger (Romans 9:11–12), then perhaps, he says, God is even unjust.
And then how is this not senseless?
For if Jacob had not become a good man, if Esau had not been wicked, one might reasonably say that the foreknowledge had perhaps gone astray, and that what was determined for both of them was the work of a random impulse and an unsteady will. But since Esau was very perverse and Jacob wise, God’s foreknowledge would do no wrong at all in granting, even ahead of time, to the one who was good in his ways that he should be loved, and to the one who was not such that he should be condemned. For it would have been no hard thing for God to bear with them patiently and wait for the time of their deeds, so that each might be shown plainly by his own actions.
Fragments on Romans, §30 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:13 4 comments from the Fathers, 6 passages citing this verse
Complete (4) All 6 passages
On Romans 9:10–13
Paul teaches that God judges by conduct and not by descent, as Jacob and Esau, born together, had different outcomes according to what they deserved.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
Thus he rightly condemns those descended from Abraham when they live wickedly and drives them from his inheritance, just as he does Gentiles found acting similarly. Conversely, he rewards the good wills, true faith, and upright deeds of either people with eternal joys. The Teacher of the Nations therefore restrains Jewish pride and shows that the difference lies not in human seed but in conduct. They must recognize that unless they take care to be faithful, no privilege of circumcised ancestry will defend them. Jacob and Esau, after all, were conceived through one reception of seed and delivered through one act of giving birth, yet experienced very different outcomes because of the difference in what they deserved
To Florus, §1.131 → read in full
On Romans 9:11–13
Paul speaks of election according to purpose, not purpose according to election, for God loved the one for his virtue and hated the other for the badness of his disposition.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
the apostle, for the demonstration of the same matter being before him, having remembered both Esau and Jacob (Rom 9:11), says thus: lest indeed, before they were born or had done anything good or evil, so that the intention of God according to election might remain … the one He loved because of his own virtue, and the other He hated because of the badness of his disposition, from which it is clear that the apostle speaks of an election according to purpose and not a purpose according to election.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:11–14
Paul answers in advance the charge that God chose by whim, since foreknowledge of Jacob's goodness and Esau's perversity makes the choice just.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
It was likely that some fault-finders would suppose that Jacob and Esau had met with an untested swing of will, and that the one was loved because God nodded assent out of personal favour, while the other was hated (Romans 9:13). So the apostle of necessity does away in advance with this view of the matter as ruinous … For if, he says, even before the infants had done anything, before any testing of them and before any deeds, the one was thought worthy of love and the other was hated, and was even appointed to serve the younger (Romans 9:11–12), then perhaps, he says, God is even unjust.
And then how is this not senseless?
For if Jacob had not become a good man, if Esau had not been wicked, one might reasonably say that the foreknowledge had perhaps gone astray, and that what was determined for both of them was the work of a random impulse and an unsteady will. But since Esau was very perverse and Jacob wise, God’s foreknowledge would do no wrong at all in granting, even ahead of time, to the one who was good in his ways that he should be loved, and to the one who was not such that he should be condemned. For it would have been no hard thing for God to bear with them patiently and wait for the time of their deeds, so that each might be shown plainly by his own actions.
Fragments on Romans, §30 → read in full
On Romans 9:13–14
Paul meets the charge of injustice in God's loving Jacob and hating Esau by denying it, which sends us to look for the answer by another route than foreknowledge.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Again, concerning Esau and Jacob, the apostle, as if speaking in a dilemma, says: 'What then shall we say to this? Is there injustice with God? May it never be!' (Romans 9:14). Because he had refuted injustice, he forced us to seek how there is not injustice with God. If it were so, as those who speak of foreknowledge say, we would rather find injustice in Him. 'I loved Jacob,' He says, 'but I hated Esau' (Romans 9:13). But one is hated or loved according to things done and according to things thought. How then does foreknowledge have room? Is injustice found with God? But he, refuting this, said: 'What then shall we say? Is there injustice with God? May it never be!' Since there is no injustice, let the matter be sought in another way, how it has come to pass.
Commentary on the Psalms, §211 → read in full
6 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · On Prayer §5 These, I think, are useful to assume beforehand toward dissolving the arguments that hold men back from praying (Matthew 6:8) (Wisdom of Solomon 11:24) (Psalm 58:3) (Galatians 1:15) (Romans 9:11–13) (Genesis 25:23) (Psalm 90:2) (Ephesians… Diodorus of Tarsus c. 330–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §7 Since before the birth of Esau and Jacob, it appears that God loved the one and hated the other —and this seemed to be an injustice to those who do not consider the justice of God according to foreknowledge (Rom 9:18)—he teaches not… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Job §16 Having come to pass—and what is established is that which is about to be made, and not everything is manifest under the sun—he who speaks and says, 'Behold, this is new, yet it has already happened in the ages before us.' But the… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on the Psalms §211 'I loved Jacob,' He says, 'but I hated Esau'. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §30 It was likely that some fault-finders would suppose that Jacob and Esau had met with an untested swing of will, and that the one was loved because God nodded assent out of personal favour, while the other was hated. Samuel Strimesius 1648–1730 AD · A Candid Inquiry into the Controversies among Evangelicals §53 In that decree God (who by most free right could have saved everyone, passed no one by, and shown only the glory of mercy, power being enough in God and in Christ's satisfaction as ransom) decided, in His eternal counsel about all that… Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:14 4 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Complete (4) All 4 passages
On Romans 9:11–14
Paul answers in advance the charge that God chose by whim, since foreknowledge of Jacob's goodness and Esau's perversity makes the choice just.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
It was likely that some fault-finders would suppose that Jacob and Esau had met with an untested swing of will, and that the one was loved because God nodded assent out of personal favour, while the other was hated (Romans 9:13). So the apostle of necessity does away in advance with this view of the matter as ruinous … For if, he says, even before the infants had done anything, before any testing of them and before any deeds, the one was thought worthy of love and the other was hated, and was even appointed to serve the younger (Romans 9:11–12), then perhaps, he says, God is even unjust.
And then how is this not senseless?
For if Jacob had not become a good man, if Esau had not been wicked, one might reasonably say that the foreknowledge had perhaps gone astray, and that what was determined for both of them was the work of a random impulse and an unsteady will. But since Esau was very perverse and Jacob wise, God’s foreknowledge would do no wrong at all in granting, even ahead of time, to the one who was good in his ways that he should be loved, and to the one who was not such that he should be condemned. For it would have been no hard thing for God to bear with them patiently and wait for the time of their deeds, so that each might be shown plainly by his own actions.
Fragments on Romans, §30 → read in full
On Romans 9:13–14
Paul meets the charge of injustice in God's loving Jacob and hating Esau by denying it, which sends us to look for the answer by another route than foreknowledge.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Again, concerning Esau and Jacob, the apostle, as if speaking in a dilemma, says: 'What then shall we say to this? Is there injustice with God? May it never be!' (Romans 9:14). Because he had refuted injustice, he forced us to seek how there is not injustice with God. If it were so, as those who speak of foreknowledge say, we would rather find injustice in Him. 'I loved Jacob,' He says, 'but I hated Esau' (Romans 9:13). But one is hated or loved according to things done and according to things thought. How then does foreknowledge have room? Is injustice found with God? But he, refuting this, said: 'What then shall we say? Is there injustice with God? May it never be!' Since there is no injustice, let the matter be sought in another way, how it has come to pass.
Commentary on the Psalms, §211 → read in full
On Romans 9:14–16
God is not unjust, for he does not fail to give each according to merit.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
What then shall we say? Is there injustice with God? (Rom 9:14) May it never be! For He says to Moses: I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion (Rom 9:15). Therefore, it is not of the one willing nor of the one running, but of the God showing mercy (Rom 9:16). … But it is not so; for God is not unrighteous so as not to give to each according to his merit (Romans 9:14).
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:14–16
God is faithful and not unjust in showing mercy to some and not to others, for mercy is not given because of our works but by God's wise authority.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
No one should suppose, he says, that those things which do not belong to the logic of justice are to have injustice in God, but rather, those things being administered according to the administration of mercy, have injustice in God; for God is faithful and there is no injustice in Him, nor is it unrighteous to show mercy to those whom He may seem to show mercy to, and others not, whom He may not wish to show mercy to. For he has said, he says, through Moses, and has made known the manner of mercy, not by the counter-measurement of human standards, but according to the wisdom of God which encompasses it, so that it is not of our works that mercy is shown, but of God who has mercy by sovereign authority. For mercy is distinguished from judging, and each man becomes the cause of himself regarding the answers he owes, reaping what he sows, according to the Apostle. But for those given out of mercy, God is the cause, knowing with wisdom and administering to whom He must and must not.
Fragments on Romans, §9 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:15 3 comments from the Fathers, 7 passages citing this verse
Complete (3) All 7 passages
On Romans 9:14–16
God is not unjust, for he does not fail to give each according to merit.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
What then shall we say? Is there injustice with God? (Rom 9:14) May it never be! For He says to Moses: I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion (Rom 9:15). Therefore, it is not of the one willing nor of the one running, but of the God showing mercy (Rom 9:16). … But it is not so; for God is not unrighteous so as not to give to each according to his merit (Romans 9:14).
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:14–16
God is faithful and not unjust in showing mercy to some and not to others, for mercy is not given because of our works but by God's wise authority.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
No one should suppose, he says, that those things which do not belong to the logic of justice are to have injustice in God, but rather, those things being administered according to the administration of mercy, have injustice in God; for God is faithful and there is no injustice in Him, nor is it unrighteous to show mercy to those whom He may seem to show mercy to, and others not, whom He may not wish to show mercy to. For he has said, he says, through Moses, and has made known the manner of mercy, not by the counter-measurement of human standards, but according to the wisdom of God which encompasses it, so that it is not of our works that mercy is shown, but of God who has mercy by sovereign authority. For mercy is distinguished from judging, and each man becomes the cause of himself regarding the answers he owes, reaping what he sows, according to the Apostle. But for those given out of mercy, God is the cause, knowing with wisdom and administering to whom He must and must not.
Fragments on Romans, §9 → read in full
God has pity on those to whom mercy is fitting, as he told Moses, so the matter is beyond all reproach.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
[If, in keeping with his foreknowledge,] he, as God, again has pity on those he may choose, or rather on those to whom it is fitting that mercy be shown, for he said somewhere to Moses, “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion” (Exodus 33:19; Romans 9:15), then how will the matter not be beyond all reproach?
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
7 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Apollinaris of Laodicea c. 310–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §9 For He says to Moses: I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion. Diodorus of Tarsus c. 330–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §7 For He says to Moses: I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §31 …knowledge, he, as God, again has pity on those he may choose, or rather on those to whom it is fitting that mercy be shown, for he said somewhere to Moses, “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I… John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §89 First among them is what the Council of Diospolis sanctioned against Pelagius: let him confess that grace is not given from merit, so that it may be true grace—that is, freely given—through the mercy of him who said, I will have mercy on… John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §366 Suffice Rom. 9:15 : I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §445 9:15Rom. 9:15 , I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy. Samuel Strimesius 1648–1730 AD · A Candid Inquiry into the Controversies among Evangelicals §53 In that decree God (who by most free right could have saved everyone, passed no one by, and shown only the glory of mercy, power being enough in God and in Christ's satisfaction as ransom) decided, in His eternal counsel about all that… Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:16 3 comments from the Fathers, 14 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 14 passages
On Romans 9:16–18
Paul sets out the objection that arises from ignorance, that if Esau, Jacob and Pharaoh are so treated, everything about us depends on God's nod.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The apostle, I think, clearly foresaw that some would perhaps suppose that it is by God’s nod that some are good and others disobedient. So of necessity he himself puts forward the objection that springs from their ignorance, and says, “So then it depends not on the one who wills, nor on the one who runs, but on God who has mercy” (Romans 9:16). For if Esau was hated even before he had done anything wicked, and Jacob was honoured even before he came into being, and if again God has mercy on whom he has mercy, is it not then right to conclude that the one who runs or wills, that is, the one eager to do something good, gains nothing, and that everything about us hangs on the nods of God? Then he heaps on top of these the words that could fix that opinion still more firmly, and says, “For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, ‘For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you’” (Romans 9:17; Exodus 9:16). To these he adds what is, as it were, the conclusion of the whole problem, and says, “So then he has mercy on whom he wills, and he hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
On Romans 9:14–16
God is not unjust, for he does not fail to give each according to merit.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
What then shall we say? Is there injustice with God? (Rom 9:14) May it never be! For He says to Moses: I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion (Rom 9:15). Therefore, it is not of the one willing nor of the one running, but of the God showing mercy (Rom 9:16). … But it is not so; for God is not unrighteous so as not to give to each according to his merit (Romans 9:14).
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:14–16
God is faithful and not unjust in showing mercy to some and not to others, for mercy is not given because of our works but by God's wise authority.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
No one should suppose, he says, that those things which do not belong to the logic of justice are to have injustice in God, but rather, those things being administered according to the administration of mercy, have injustice in God; for God is faithful and there is no injustice in Him, nor is it unrighteous to show mercy to those whom He may seem to show mercy to, and others not, whom He may not wish to show mercy to. For he has said, he says, through Moses, and has made known the manner of mercy, not by the counter-measurement of human standards, but according to the wisdom of God which encompasses it, so that it is not of our works that mercy is shown, but of God who has mercy by sovereign authority. For mercy is distinguished from judging, and each man becomes the cause of himself regarding the answers he owes, reaping what he sows, according to the Apostle. But for those given out of mercy, God is the cause, knowing with wisdom and administering to whom He must and must not.
Fragments on Romans, §9 → read in full
On Romans 9:16–18
Paul sets out the objection that arises from ignorance, that if Esau, Jacob and Pharaoh are so treated, everything about us depends on God's nod.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The apostle, I think, clearly foresaw that some would perhaps suppose that it is by God’s nod that some are good and others disobedient. So of necessity he himself puts forward the objection that springs from their ignorance, and says, “So then it depends not on the one who wills, nor on the one who runs, but on God who has mercy” (Romans 9:16). For if Esau was hated even before he had done anything wicked, and Jacob was honoured even before he came into being, and if again God has mercy on whom he has mercy, is it not then right to conclude that the one who runs or wills, that is, the one eager to do something good, gains nothing, and that everything about us hangs on the nods of God? Then he heaps on top of these the words that could fix that opinion still more firmly, and says, “For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, ‘For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you’” (Romans 9:17; Exodus 9:16). To these he adds what is, as it were, the conclusion of the whole problem, and says, “So then he has mercy on whom he wills, and he hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
14 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Apollinaris of Laodicea c. 310–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §9 Therefore, it is not of the one running or of the one willing, but of the God who shows mercy. Diodorus of Tarsus c. 330–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §7 Therefore, it is not of the one willing nor of the one running, but of the God showing mercy. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Ecclesiastes §26 This is similar to what the apostolic text says: 'not of him who runs nor of him who wills, but of God who shows mercy'. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on the Psalms §51 You provide these things mercifully and compassionately in accordance with the one: 'not of the one willing nor of the one running, but of the God who shows mercy'; for even if we have done all things from ourselves, by the mercy of God… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on the Psalms §101 Behold, those fearing God hope in his mercy; for having done all things, they expect to be shown mercy by him, as it was said a little earlier: 'not of him who wills nor of him who runs, but of the God who shows mercy'. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on the Psalms §152 And to him belongs the willing of the good, since it is 'not of him who runs nor of him who wills, but of the God who shows mercy' to successfully complete the way. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on the Psalms §153 It is also possible to take it according to the meaning already assigned to: 'not by the willer or the runner, but by the God who shows mercy'. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on the Psalms §180 The steps of the runner: for it is 'not of him who wills nor of him who runs, but of God who shows mercy'. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on the Psalms §203 Having prepared, he triumphed, but with God having fought alongside, as the scripture says: 'not of him who wills nor of him who runs, but of the God who shows mercy'. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On Genesis §64 From this it is known that he sought well from the judgment and gift of God, when, as if sealing the grace himself, he gives: 'Not of the one willing nor of the one running, but of the merciful God', and 'If the Lord builds a house, in… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §31 So of necessity he himself puts forward the objection that springs from their ignorance, and says, “So then it depends not on the one who wills, nor on the one who runs, but on God who has mercy”. Hesychius of Jerusalem fl. c. 412–450 AD · On Saint Andrew §4 …be made strong; you who are lame, run; you who run, hurry; and you who hurry, do not trust in yourselves, but in God who directs the race: 'For it depends not on the one who wills, nor on the one who runs, but on God who has mercy'. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §3.177 This is why the apostle says, “It is not of the one who wills” —understand: this act. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §96 Rather, by a more efficacious grace given from God's mere good pleasure, he receives a better will—as the Apostle says: "It is not of him who wills, nor of him who runs, but of God who shows mercy". Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:17 6 comments from the Fathers, 8 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (6) All 8 passages
On Romans 9:16–18
Paul sets out the objection that arises from ignorance, that if Esau, Jacob and Pharaoh are so treated, everything about us depends on God's nod.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The apostle, I think, clearly foresaw that some would perhaps suppose that it is by God’s nod that some are good and others disobedient. So of necessity he himself puts forward the objection that springs from their ignorance, and says, “So then it depends not on the one who wills, nor on the one who runs, but on God who has mercy” (Romans 9:16). For if Esau was hated even before he had done anything wicked, and Jacob was honoured even before he came into being, and if again God has mercy on whom he has mercy, is it not then right to conclude that the one who runs or wills, that is, the one eager to do something good, gains nothing, and that everything about us hangs on the nods of God? Then he heaps on top of these the words that could fix that opinion still more firmly, and says, “For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, ‘For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you’” (Romans 9:17; Exodus 9:16). To these he adds what is, as it were, the conclusion of the whole problem, and says, “So then he has mercy on whom he wills, and he hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
On Romans 9:16–18
Paul sets out the objection that arises from ignorance, that if Esau, Jacob and Pharaoh are so treated, everything about us depends on God's nod.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The apostle, I think, clearly foresaw that some would perhaps suppose that it is by God’s nod that some are good and others disobedient. So of necessity he himself puts forward the objection that springs from their ignorance, and says, “So then it depends not on the one who wills, nor on the one who runs, but on God who has mercy” (Romans 9:16). For if Esau was hated even before he had done anything wicked, and Jacob was honoured even before he came into being, and if again God has mercy on whom he has mercy, is it not then right to conclude that the one who runs or wills, that is, the one eager to do something good, gains nothing, and that everything about us hangs on the nods of God? Then he heaps on top of these the words that could fix that opinion still more firmly, and says, “For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, ‘For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you’” (Romans 9:17; Exodus 9:16). To these he adds what is, as it were, the conclusion of the whole problem, and says, “So then he has mercy on whom he wills, and he hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
Nothing God does is in vain, and the judgment on Pharaoh benefits the whole world, for all who see it are seized with fear and wonder.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
And this is not in vain; for nothing is in vain or irrational on the part of God, but each thing is pre-ordained by wonderful words, just as He has made known concerning Pharaoh; for the Scripture says to Pharaoh: 'I raised you up for this very purpose, so that I might show My power in you, and so that My name might be proclaimed in all the earth' (Ex 9:16). Behold, the not showing mercy to Pharaoh. It has been shown that it happens through the benefit of the whole cosmos, so that all, perceiving the judgment against the impious as much as possible, are seized with fear and wonder toward Him who has judged these things and has done them.
Fragments on Romans, §9 → read in full
God used Pharaoh to display his strength so that his name might be proclaimed, and Pharaoh deserved what he suffered for his earlier sins.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
God made use of this man to display the strength that is in himself, so that his name might be proclaimed in all the earth (Romans 9:17), and so that Pharaoh, when he suffered, might be seen to deserve his suffering; for suffering was owed to him for his first sins, even if he had not offended by his later ones.
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–18
God raised up Pharaoh only because he foresaw that Pharaoh was stubbornly diseased.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
And again the Scripture says to Pharaoh: For this very purpose I raised you up, so that I might show my power in you, and so that my name might be proclaimed in all the earth (Exod 9:16). Is not then Pharaoh not to blame, but the one raising him up for the showing of his own power? But even this is not so; for he would not have raised him, even though through him he was admonishing the others, if he had not foreseen him being stubbornly diseased.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
God could never make anything evil, for all he made was very good, and Pharaoh shared the same nature as the rest of us.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…he himself, someone says, hardened Pharaoh’s heart (Exodus 9:12); and indeed he said to him, “For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you” (Exodus 9:16; Romans 9:17). If, then, he both hardens some and raises them up, who are vessels of wrath and are said to be prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22), “why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?” (Romans 9:19). And how could the one hardened by him have become good?
What, then, could I say to this? To know the truth, it is enough to be settled in the conviction that God could never be the maker of evil things; for all that he made was very good (Genesis 1:31). If, then, they insist that the Egyptian was not a human being and did not share the same nature as we do, let them prove it, and we too will keep silent. But if he was like us, let them either openly accuse the divine voice of not seeing what is good and what is not; or, if they shudder at that, let them confess that the things he brought into existence are good.
In this way they will reject that most rash opinion.
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
"I raised you up" does not mean "I created you" but "I called you forth" to resist, so that Pharaoh, idolater and oppressor of Israel, was justly punished as a vessel of wrath.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The words spoken to Pharaoh, “For this very purpose I raised you up” (Exodus 9:16), do not mean “I created you” or “I made you”, but rather “I called you forth, to the point of choosing to set yourself against me”; and this not at the start of his life, but when Moses was being sent to redeem Israel. On what grounds, and for what reason, the all-wise Paul will make plain to us: “For God,” he says, “desiring to show his wrath,” and the rest (Romans 9:22).
In times long past the whole earth had gone astray. Some worshipped the creation (Romans 1:25); others made an object of reverence of whatever seemed good to them. At length Abraham was called to knowledge, and so the race descended from him sprang up, devoted to the worship of God. But when they too went down into Egypt and then spent a long time there, they slid into deception and worshipped the gods of the land. Yet God remembered what he had promised to the fathers (Exodus 2:24). Moses had been appointed to the mission, to release Israel from slavery; but it was necessary, both for those called to worship him and for all on earth, not only to learn that after long ages the God of the Hebrews had been made manifest, but also to be confirmed by surpassing wonders in faith in him and in the conviction that he is not, like the other gods, voiceless and powerless, but rather himself steers the universe, and that wrath strikes those who act against his will. Yet, on the other hand, God, wishing to work wonders, had to be seen to have good grounds for doing so. So Pharaoh was raised up to resist, by God’s providential ordering, and grew hard against the divine power. For this reason he was punished, and not unjustly: for he was unholy and an idolater, he maltreated Israel with clay and brickmaking (Exodus 1:14), and he made toil their wage. Therefore he was of necessity named a vessel of wrath, and was prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22)
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
8 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Diodorus of Tarsus c. 330–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §7 And the one striving is abundant. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §31 Then he heaps on top of these the words that could fix that opinion still more firmly, and says, “For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, ‘For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you’” (Exodus 9:16). Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §32 So one person has come into being for dishonour and has been allotted a nature of that kind, while another has been made, or rather raised up, hard, so that, as he himself says, his name may be proclaimed in all the earth (Exodus 9:16). Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §33 …he himself, someone says, hardened Pharaoh’s heart (Exodus 9:12); and indeed he said to him, “For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you” (Exodus 9:16). Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §34 God made use of this man to display the strength that is in himself, so that his name might be proclaimed in all the earth, and so that Pharaoh, when he suffered, might be seen to deserve his suffering; for suffering was owed to him for… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Commentary on Isaiah §4 God raised up Pharaoh, who was a vessel of anger and wrath (Romans 9:22) and was already liable to punishment for his own offences, so that, as He Himself says, He might show in him His own power and the exactness of His just judgment… Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.16.5 Permitting is that by which He wills something to happen which, though He hates it, He does not impede because of a joined good — so God willed to permit the fall of the first parents, Romans 9:17 ; Acts 4:28. Samuel Strimesius 1648–1730 AD · A Candid Inquiry into the Controversies among Evangelicals §53 All of it displays His liberty, power, wrath, and justice that avenges sins (Proverbs 16:4; Matthew 20:15, and the like). Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:18 5 comments from the Fathers, 12 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (5) All 12 passages
On Romans 9:16–18
Paul sets out the objection that arises from ignorance, that if Esau, Jacob and Pharaoh are so treated, everything about us depends on God's nod.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The apostle, I think, clearly foresaw that some would perhaps suppose that it is by God’s nod that some are good and others disobedient. So of necessity he himself puts forward the objection that springs from their ignorance, and says, “So then it depends not on the one who wills, nor on the one who runs, but on God who has mercy” (Romans 9:16). For if Esau was hated even before he had done anything wicked, and Jacob was honoured even before he came into being, and if again God has mercy on whom he has mercy, is it not then right to conclude that the one who runs or wills, that is, the one eager to do something good, gains nothing, and that everything about us hangs on the nods of God? Then he heaps on top of these the words that could fix that opinion still more firmly, and says, “For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, ‘For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you’” (Romans 9:17; Exodus 9:16). To these he adds what is, as it were, the conclusion of the whole problem, and says, “So then he has mercy on whom he wills, and he hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
On Romans 9:16–18
Paul sets out the objection that arises from ignorance, that if Esau, Jacob and Pharaoh are so treated, everything about us depends on God's nod.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The apostle, I think, clearly foresaw that some would perhaps suppose that it is by God’s nod that some are good and others disobedient. So of necessity he himself puts forward the objection that springs from their ignorance, and says, “So then it depends not on the one who wills, nor on the one who runs, but on God who has mercy” (Romans 9:16). For if Esau was hated even before he had done anything wicked, and Jacob was honoured even before he came into being, and if again God has mercy on whom he has mercy, is it not then right to conclude that the one who runs or wills, that is, the one eager to do something good, gains nothing, and that everything about us hangs on the nods of God? Then he heaps on top of these the words that could fix that opinion still more firmly, and says, “For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, ‘For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you’” (Romans 9:17; Exodus 9:16). To these he adds what is, as it were, the conclusion of the whole problem, and says, “So then he has mercy on whom he wills, and he hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–18
God raised up Pharaoh only because he foresaw that Pharaoh was stubbornly diseased.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
And again the Scripture says to Pharaoh: For this very purpose I raised you up, so that I might show my power in you, and so that my name might be proclaimed in all the earth (Exod 9:16). Is not then Pharaoh not to blame, but the one raising him up for the showing of his own power? But even this is not so; for he would not have raised him, even though through him he was admonishing the others, if he had not foreseen him being stubbornly diseased.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
God could never make anything evil, for all he made was very good, and Pharaoh shared the same nature as the rest of us.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…he himself, someone says, hardened Pharaoh’s heart (Exodus 9:12); and indeed he said to him, “For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you” (Exodus 9:16; Romans 9:17). If, then, he both hardens some and raises them up, who are vessels of wrath and are said to be prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22), “why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?” (Romans 9:19). And how could the one hardened by him have become good?
What, then, could I say to this? To know the truth, it is enough to be settled in the conviction that God could never be the maker of evil things; for all that he made was very good (Genesis 1:31). If, then, they insist that the Egyptian was not a human being and did not share the same nature as we do, let them prove it, and we too will keep silent. But if he was like us, let them either openly accuse the divine voice of not seeing what is good and what is not; or, if they shudder at that, let them confess that the things he brought into existence are good.
In this way they will reject that most rash opinion.
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
"I raised you up" does not mean "I created you" but "I called you forth" to resist, so that Pharaoh, idolater and oppressor of Israel, was justly punished as a vessel of wrath.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The words spoken to Pharaoh, “For this very purpose I raised you up” (Exodus 9:16), do not mean “I created you” or “I made you”, but rather “I called you forth, to the point of choosing to set yourself against me”; and this not at the start of his life, but when Moses was being sent to redeem Israel. On what grounds, and for what reason, the all-wise Paul will make plain to us: “For God,” he says, “desiring to show his wrath,” and the rest (Romans 9:22).
In times long past the whole earth had gone astray. Some worshipped the creation (Romans 1:25); others made an object of reverence of whatever seemed good to them. At length Abraham was called to knowledge, and so the race descended from him sprang up, devoted to the worship of God. But when they too went down into Egypt and then spent a long time there, they slid into deception and worshipped the gods of the land. Yet God remembered what he had promised to the fathers (Exodus 2:24). Moses had been appointed to the mission, to release Israel from slavery; but it was necessary, both for those called to worship him and for all on earth, not only to learn that after long ages the God of the Hebrews had been made manifest, but also to be confirmed by surpassing wonders in faith in him and in the conviction that he is not, like the other gods, voiceless and powerless, but rather himself steers the universe, and that wrath strikes those who act against his will. Yet, on the other hand, God, wishing to work wonders, had to be seen to have good grounds for doing so. So Pharaoh was raised up to resist, by God’s providential ordering, and grew hard against the divine power. For this reason he was punished, and not unjustly: for he was unholy and an idolater, he maltreated Israel with clay and brickmaking (Exodus 1:14), and he made toil their wage. Therefore he was of necessity named a vessel of wrath, and was prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22)
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:18–21
Paul answers the Jews' boast in the ceremonies by showing that God has power to reject whom he wishes and take whom he wishes among the peoples.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
They [the Jews] boasted of observing ceremonies and sacrifices, and therefore supposed that other nations, consecrated by none of the Law's rites, neither could nor should suddenly be admitted to fellowship with them. He would tell them that even if the whole of righteousness had consisted in those observances, God would still have had power to make a change among the peoples, rejecting whom he wished and taking whom he wished. In answer to this meaning, a reply is made in the person of the Jews: nothing should now be demanded from the human will, since God “has mercy on whom he wills and hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18). To this the apostle replies: “O human being, who are you to answer back to God?” (Romans 9:20). He introduces the prophet Isaiah's testimony: “Does what is molded say to the one who molded it, ‘Why did you make me like this?’” (Isaiah 45:9; Romans 9:20). He adds in his own words: “Does the potter not have power over the clay to make from the same lump one vessel for honor and another for dishonor?” (Romans 9:21).
To Florus, §1.133 → read in full
12 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Apollinaris of Laodicea c. 310–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §10 Therefore the apostle proceeds again: 'So then, whom he wishes to show mercy, whom he wishes to harden', and the following. Diodorus of Tarsus c. 330–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §7 Since before the birth of Esau and Jacob, it appears that God loved the one and hated the other (Rom 9:13)—and this seemed to be an injustice to those who do not consider the justice of God according to foreknowledge —he teaches not… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §31 To these he adds what is, as it were, the conclusion of the whole problem, and says, “So then he has mercy on whom he wills, and he hardens whom he wills”. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §1.133 In answer to this meaning, a reply is made in the person of the Jews: nothing should now be demanded from the human will, since God “has mercy on whom he wills and hardens whom he wills”. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §9 But why, in dispensing the treasury of Christ’s merits — sufficient and applicable to each and every person — he deals so unequally with equals, we ought not to ask, because we cannot know, but with the Apostle to rest in the secret will… John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §63 To stop every mouth it is enough that God himself answers (Matthew 20:15), "Is it not lawful for me to do what I will with what is mine?" and so on; and that the Apostle says Romans 9:18 , "He has mercy on whom he wills." See also… John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §82 “He has mercy on whom he wills; whom he wills he hardens”. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §193 Romans 9:18 .John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §504 As if Rom. 9:18 — I will have mercy on whom I will — meant I will have mercy on him I know just, whose ready faith I see, whom I see obey my precepts (so Faustus the Semi-Pelagian exposits, or rather corrupts, On Free Choice 1.3). John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §595 And that saying of the Apostle, often pressed against every foe of special grace: He has mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardens. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.16.1 That will is rightly attributed to God, both the perfection of God's essence and intellect, and Scripture, and the consent of men abundantly confirm — Jonah 1:14; Daniel 4:17; Romans 9:18 ; James 1:18; Psalm 115:3; Matthew 20:15;… Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.18.4 Gods mercy is taken actively or passively; here in the former way — Exodus 34:6; Romans 9:18 ; Ephesians 2:4; Titus 3:5. Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:19 6 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (6) All 4 passages
On Romans 9:19–20
Paul's answer is obscure, but it assures us that God gives each what befits him, mercy to some and, after long patience, punishment to the wicked.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“You will say to me then, ‘Why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?’” (Romans 9:19). What, then, was his way of answering? It is very obscure, and perhaps even seems to support the objections they raise; yet it is enough to assure us that nothing could come from God that lies outside what is fitting. For he gives to each what befits him: he pities and has mercy on those for whom mercy is fitting, and he subjects the wicked to punishment. Yet his wrath does not follow the offences at once and on their heels; rather, a long patience goes before it, so that some even suppose that God has stopped caring about those on earth. So Paul brings out his reply and stands up to those who say such things, directing the force of his words at the persons who had been brought forward, I mean Esau and also Pharaoh. He spoke, then, as though to each of those he had named: “But who indeed are you, O man, to answer back to God? Will what is moulded say to the one who moulded it, ‘Why have you made me like this?’” (Romans 9:20).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
God could never make anything evil, for all he made was very good, and Pharaoh shared the same nature as the rest of us.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…he himself, someone says, hardened Pharaoh’s heart (Exodus 9:12); and indeed he said to him, “For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you” (Exodus 9:16; Romans 9:17). If, then, he both hardens some and raises them up, who are vessels of wrath and are said to be prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22), “why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?” (Romans 9:19). And how could the one hardened by him have become good?
What, then, could I say to this? To know the truth, it is enough to be settled in the conviction that God could never be the maker of evil things; for all that he made was very good (Genesis 1:31). If, then, they insist that the Egyptian was not a human being and did not share the same nature as we do, let them prove it, and we too will keep silent. But if he was like us, let them either openly accuse the divine voice of not seeing what is good and what is not; or, if they shudder at that, let them confess that the things he brought into existence are good.
In this way they will reject that most rash opinion.
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
"I raised you up" does not mean "I created you" but "I called you forth" to resist, so that Pharaoh, idolater and oppressor of Israel, was justly punished as a vessel of wrath.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The words spoken to Pharaoh, “For this very purpose I raised you up” (Exodus 9:16), do not mean “I created you” or “I made you”, but rather “I called you forth, to the point of choosing to set yourself against me”; and this not at the start of his life, but when Moses was being sent to redeem Israel. On what grounds, and for what reason, the all-wise Paul will make plain to us: “For God,” he says, “desiring to show his wrath,” and the rest (Romans 9:22).
In times long past the whole earth had gone astray. Some worshipped the creation (Romans 1:25); others made an object of reverence of whatever seemed good to them. At length Abraham was called to knowledge, and so the race descended from him sprang up, devoted to the worship of God. But when they too went down into Egypt and then spent a long time there, they slid into deception and worshipped the gods of the land. Yet God remembered what he had promised to the fathers (Exodus 2:24). Moses had been appointed to the mission, to release Israel from slavery; but it was necessary, both for those called to worship him and for all on earth, not only to learn that after long ages the God of the Hebrews had been made manifest, but also to be confirmed by surpassing wonders in faith in him and in the conviction that he is not, like the other gods, voiceless and powerless, but rather himself steers the universe, and that wrath strikes those who act against his will. Yet, on the other hand, God, wishing to work wonders, had to be seen to have good grounds for doing so. So Pharaoh was raised up to resist, by God’s providential ordering, and grew hard against the divine power. For this reason he was punished, and not unjustly: for he was unholy and an idolater, he maltreated Israel with clay and brickmaking (Exodus 1:14), and he made toil their wage. Therefore he was of necessity named a vessel of wrath, and was prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22)
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:18–21
Paul answers the Jews' boast in the ceremonies by showing that God has power to reject whom he wishes and take whom he wishes among the peoples.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
They [the Jews] boasted of observing ceremonies and sacrifices, and therefore supposed that other nations, consecrated by none of the Law's rites, neither could nor should suddenly be admitted to fellowship with them. He would tell them that even if the whole of righteousness had consisted in those observances, God would still have had power to make a change among the peoples, rejecting whom he wished and taking whom he wished. In answer to this meaning, a reply is made in the person of the Jews: nothing should now be demanded from the human will, since God “has mercy on whom he wills and hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18). To this the apostle replies: “O human being, who are you to answer back to God?” (Romans 9:20). He introduces the prophet Isaiah's testimony: “Does what is molded say to the one who molded it, ‘Why did you make me like this?’” (Isaiah 45:9; Romans 9:20). He adds in his own words: “Does the potter not have power over the clay to make from the same lump one vessel for honor and another for dishonor?” (Romans 9:21).
To Florus, §1.133 → read in full
On Romans 9:19–20
Paul's answer is obscure, but it assures us that God gives each what befits him, mercy to some and, after long patience, punishment to the wicked.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“You will say to me then, ‘Why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?’” (Romans 9:19). What, then, was his way of answering? It is very obscure, and perhaps even seems to support the objections they raise; yet it is enough to assure us that nothing could come from God that lies outside what is fitting. For he gives to each what befits him: he pities and has mercy on those for whom mercy is fitting, and he subjects the wicked to punishment. Yet his wrath does not follow the offences at once and on their heels; rather, a long patience goes before it, so that some even suppose that God has stopped caring about those on earth. So Paul brings out his reply and stands up to those who say such things, directing the force of his words at the persons who had been brought forward, I mean Esau and also Pharaoh. He spoke, then, as though to each of those he had named: “But who indeed are you, O man, to answer back to God? Will what is moulded say to the one who moulded it, ‘Why have you made me like this?’” (Romans 9:20).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
On Romans 9:19–20
Paul rebukes the one who boldly searches out God's will and shows human nature's insignificance by the image of the potter's clay.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
For who has opposed his will? For if he himself performs all things through us, we are nothing in authority over what we do. But indeed, O man, who are you, the one answering back to God? Does not the thing formed say to the one who formed it: Why did you make me thus? (Rom 9:19-20). Correcting all the preceding, he reproves indeed as if you were boldly searching out the will of God, but he also shows the insignificance of human nature, taking the clay of the potter as a fitting image.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:19–21
The potter image does not strip us of free will, for those who can complain to God must be masters of themselves.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
Therefore, if God manages something according to foreknowledge, whether he raised up Pharaoh or hated Esau and loved Jacob, let no one suppose because of these things that nothing is upon us, but rather that our autonomy is being cut away. Some have spoken this, not as a reproach, but to say: 'Nevertheless, O man, who are you to answer back to God?' For they say it is absurd to have sought such great questions, unsettling the listener's mind without resolving any of them, but only rebuking those who seek to simply flee from the things sought, while also appearing to strip us of autonomy by the image of the potter, as if the potter fashions the vessels as he wills, while the rest remains as it has become from the beginning. They say these things unworthy of the apostolic grace and teaching. The word is not spoken as a reproach, but the mind holds it thus: if from which, he says, he raised up Pharaoh and hated Esau and loved Jacob, and before their birth gave all things in the will of God, and nothing is upon us, then in short: who are you, O man, and how do you answer back to God? And how do you have the authority to speak and to accuse him as if he reproaches us unjustly, saying, 'Why is he still reproaching?' … How then do you charge God, if nothing lies in our power as you say? For if nothing is up to us, neither is it in your power to complain or to answer back to God. 'Not the things of the potter,' he says, 'the vessels, since they lack sensation; they complain against the maker even if they become dishonorable, or even if they become honorable according to the maker's power' (Rom 9:21). But you complain, so you have sensation and power, as having a will that is free. And he who has the power to complain, it is evident that he is also master of himself in all other things, to say and to do what he wills. For he is not a master of himself only in complaining to God, but in other things he is deprived of mastery.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:20 8 comments from the Fathers, 8 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (8) All 8 passages
On Romans 9:19–20
Paul's answer is obscure, but it assures us that God gives each what befits him, mercy to some and, after long patience, punishment to the wicked.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“You will say to me then, ‘Why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?’” (Romans 9:19). What, then, was his way of answering? It is very obscure, and perhaps even seems to support the objections they raise; yet it is enough to assure us that nothing could come from God that lies outside what is fitting. For he gives to each what befits him: he pities and has mercy on those for whom mercy is fitting, and he subjects the wicked to punishment. Yet his wrath does not follow the offences at once and on their heels; rather, a long patience goes before it, so that some even suppose that God has stopped caring about those on earth. So Paul brings out his reply and stands up to those who say such things, directing the force of his words at the persons who had been brought forward, I mean Esau and also Pharaoh. He spoke, then, as though to each of those he had named: “But who indeed are you, O man, to answer back to God? Will what is moulded say to the one who moulded it, ‘Why have you made me like this?’” (Romans 9:20).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
God could never make anything evil, for all he made was very good, and Pharaoh shared the same nature as the rest of us.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…he himself, someone says, hardened Pharaoh’s heart (Exodus 9:12); and indeed he said to him, “For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you” (Exodus 9:16; Romans 9:17). If, then, he both hardens some and raises them up, who are vessels of wrath and are said to be prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22), “why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?” (Romans 9:19). And how could the one hardened by him have become good?
What, then, could I say to this? To know the truth, it is enough to be settled in the conviction that God could never be the maker of evil things; for all that he made was very good (Genesis 1:31). If, then, they insist that the Egyptian was not a human being and did not share the same nature as we do, let them prove it, and we too will keep silent. But if he was like us, let them either openly accuse the divine voice of not seeing what is good and what is not; or, if they shudder at that, let them confess that the things he brought into existence are good.
In this way they will reject that most rash opinion.
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
"I raised you up" does not mean "I created you" but "I called you forth" to resist, so that Pharaoh, idolater and oppressor of Israel, was justly punished as a vessel of wrath.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The words spoken to Pharaoh, “For this very purpose I raised you up” (Exodus 9:16), do not mean “I created you” or “I made you”, but rather “I called you forth, to the point of choosing to set yourself against me”; and this not at the start of his life, but when Moses was being sent to redeem Israel. On what grounds, and for what reason, the all-wise Paul will make plain to us: “For God,” he says, “desiring to show his wrath,” and the rest (Romans 9:22).
In times long past the whole earth had gone astray. Some worshipped the creation (Romans 1:25); others made an object of reverence of whatever seemed good to them. At length Abraham was called to knowledge, and so the race descended from him sprang up, devoted to the worship of God. But when they too went down into Egypt and then spent a long time there, they slid into deception and worshipped the gods of the land. Yet God remembered what he had promised to the fathers (Exodus 2:24). Moses had been appointed to the mission, to release Israel from slavery; but it was necessary, both for those called to worship him and for all on earth, not only to learn that after long ages the God of the Hebrews had been made manifest, but also to be confirmed by surpassing wonders in faith in him and in the conviction that he is not, like the other gods, voiceless and powerless, but rather himself steers the universe, and that wrath strikes those who act against his will. Yet, on the other hand, God, wishing to work wonders, had to be seen to have good grounds for doing so. So Pharaoh was raised up to resist, by God’s providential ordering, and grew hard against the divine power. For this reason he was punished, and not unjustly: for he was unholy and an idolater, he maltreated Israel with clay and brickmaking (Exodus 1:14), and he made toil their wage. Therefore he was of necessity named a vessel of wrath, and was prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22)
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:18–21
Paul answers the Jews' boast in the ceremonies by showing that God has power to reject whom he wishes and take whom he wishes among the peoples.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
They [the Jews] boasted of observing ceremonies and sacrifices, and therefore supposed that other nations, consecrated by none of the Law's rites, neither could nor should suddenly be admitted to fellowship with them. He would tell them that even if the whole of righteousness had consisted in those observances, God would still have had power to make a change among the peoples, rejecting whom he wished and taking whom he wished. In answer to this meaning, a reply is made in the person of the Jews: nothing should now be demanded from the human will, since God “has mercy on whom he wills and hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18). To this the apostle replies: “O human being, who are you to answer back to God?” (Romans 9:20). He introduces the prophet Isaiah's testimony: “Does what is molded say to the one who molded it, ‘Why did you make me like this?’” (Isaiah 45:9; Romans 9:20). He adds in his own words: “Does the potter not have power over the clay to make from the same lump one vessel for honor and another for dishonor?” (Romans 9:21).
To Florus, §1.133 → read in full
On Romans 9:19–20
Paul's answer is obscure, but it assures us that God gives each what befits him, mercy to some and, after long patience, punishment to the wicked.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“You will say to me then, ‘Why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?’” (Romans 9:19). What, then, was his way of answering? It is very obscure, and perhaps even seems to support the objections they raise; yet it is enough to assure us that nothing could come from God that lies outside what is fitting. For he gives to each what befits him: he pities and has mercy on those for whom mercy is fitting, and he subjects the wicked to punishment. Yet his wrath does not follow the offences at once and on their heels; rather, a long patience goes before it, so that some even suppose that God has stopped caring about those on earth. So Paul brings out his reply and stands up to those who say such things, directing the force of his words at the persons who had been brought forward, I mean Esau and also Pharaoh. He spoke, then, as though to each of those he had named: “But who indeed are you, O man, to answer back to God? Will what is moulded say to the one who moulded it, ‘Why have you made me like this?’” (Romans 9:20).
Fragments on Romans, §31 → read in full
On Romans 9:19–20
Paul rebukes the one who boldly searches out God's will and shows human nature's insignificance by the image of the potter's clay.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
For who has opposed his will? For if he himself performs all things through us, we are nothing in authority over what we do. But indeed, O man, who are you, the one answering back to God? Does not the thing formed say to the one who formed it: Why did you make me thus? (Rom 9:19-20). Correcting all the preceding, he reproves indeed as if you were boldly searching out the will of God, but he also shows the insignificance of human nature, taking the clay of the potter as a fitting image.
Fragments on Romans, §7 → read in full
On Romans 9:19–21
The potter image does not strip us of free will, for those who can complain to God must be masters of themselves.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
Therefore, if God manages something according to foreknowledge, whether he raised up Pharaoh or hated Esau and loved Jacob, let no one suppose because of these things that nothing is upon us, but rather that our autonomy is being cut away. Some have spoken this, not as a reproach, but to say: 'Nevertheless, O man, who are you to answer back to God?' For they say it is absurd to have sought such great questions, unsettling the listener's mind without resolving any of them, but only rebuking those who seek to simply flee from the things sought, while also appearing to strip us of autonomy by the image of the potter, as if the potter fashions the vessels as he wills, while the rest remains as it has become from the beginning. They say these things unworthy of the apostolic grace and teaching. The word is not spoken as a reproach, but the mind holds it thus: if from which, he says, he raised up Pharaoh and hated Esau and loved Jacob, and before their birth gave all things in the will of God, and nothing is upon us, then in short: who are you, O man, and how do you answer back to God? And how do you have the authority to speak and to accuse him as if he reproaches us unjustly, saying, 'Why is he still reproaching?' … How then do you charge God, if nothing lies in our power as you say? For if nothing is up to us, neither is it in your power to complain or to answer back to God. 'Not the things of the potter,' he says, 'the vessels, since they lack sensation; they complain against the maker even if they become dishonorable, or even if they become honorable according to the maker's power' (Rom 9:21). But you complain, so you have sensation and power, as having a will that is free. And he who has the power to complain, it is evident that he is also master of himself in all other things, to say and to do what he wills. For he is not a master of himself only in complaining to God, but in other things he is deprived of mastery.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
Paul cuts down rash curiosity about God's purposes, since a creature can no more know its Creator's mind than clay can, and the Creator may shape each as he sees fit.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
And regarding these things, the apostle moves the word forward to two points: first, to show that it is not fitting for men to search out the depths of God; and second, to preserve the most correct word of salvation, since some are not receiving mercy and some are receiving mercy. For he says, 'the creature does not say to the creator' (Romans 9:20), and the following. This first cuts down the rash curiosity of many, who, seeking to examine the purposes of God subtly, attempt to unearth things unsearchable for men down to the finest detail.
For who are you, he says, that you would judge God? And about what things are you searching so intently? It is impossible for you to know the mind of the Creator, just as it is for a creature to know the mind of its maker; for you differ in nothing from a soulless thing in being able to grasp the purpose of God. Moreover, it also absurdly attempts to cut into the authority of God, as if he were not obligated to have authority to arrange each of those being made in whatever way he would wish and deem beneficial, even if the nature of all is one and all are recipients of mercy. For just as the potter has the authority, with the same single material of clay being present, to make one vessel for honor and another for dishonor, so also the Creator of all things, foreknowing the future through the present, brings forth one to be shown mercy and another to be shown wrath.
Fragments on Romans, §11 → read in full
On Romans 9:20–21
God, like a potter, has authority to honour whom he wants and to punish whom he wills.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Did God not have authority as He wished? But a potter indeed fashions some for honor and others for dishonor, yet God does not have the authority that the potter has, so as to honor whom He wants and to punish whom He wills? Having said this out of surplus, he subsequently makes the solution.
Fragments on Romans, §4 → read in full
8 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Apollinaris of Laodicea c. 310–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §11 For he says, 'the creature does not say to the creator', and the following. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Job §53 If to bring about painful things or to cease these, no one of those things happening from him can promise a hindrance, nor can anyone of strength say to him: 'What have you done?'; according to the apostolic word: 'Shall not the creature… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Job §55 But it is not of a king to rule lawlessly, nor does he, proposing one thing, do another through weakness; for the Lord is “just, strong, and long-suffering” (Psalm 7:11), wherefore no one “shall oppose his judgment,” no one being able to… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Job §73 Not only concerning building, but also concerning the aforementioned, there is no one who will be able to say according to the apostle: "Why did you make me thus?"; but also those who dare something apart from the will of God, since they… Severianus of Gabala fl. c. 400 AD · Fragments on Romans §4 Romans 9:20-21 ).Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §31 Will what is moulded say to the one who moulded it, ‘Why have you made me like this?’”. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §1.133 To this the apostle replies: “O human being, who are you to answer back to God?”. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §548 Nothing else need be said but Augustine (On the Good of Perseverance 8): Let him who is freed love grace; let him who is not freed acknowledge the debt — and Paul: O man, who are you to answer God? Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:21 7 comments from the Fathers, 8 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (7) All 8 passages
The potter image does not mean that some are made evil by nature, for Jeremiah shows that God moulds each for honour or dishonour according to what they do.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
To such arguments one might reply, first of all, that they could not claim that the force of these thoughts hints to us at differences of nature. For he did not say that some were made harsh and hardened, or made into vessels of honour and of dishonour, nor did he assign them such a nature at all. Rather, he leads us to think this: that some are moulded like vessels of clay, some for honour and some for dishonour; and we have been taught the meaning of the illustration from the words of the prophets. In what way, then, some are moulded as if by a potter, some for honour and others for dishonour, and for what causes, anyone may learn by reading the words of Jeremiah. It is written thus: “Arise and go down to the potter’s house, and there you will hear my words. And I went down to the potter’s house, and there he was, making a piece of work on the stones. And the vessel that he was making fell in his hands; and again he made it into another vessel, as it seemed good in his sight to make it. And the word of the Lord came,” he says, “to me, saying: Shall I not be able to make you as this potter does, house of Israel? Look, like the potter’s clay, you are in my hands. At last I will speak against a nation or against a kingdom, to root them out; and that nation will turn from all its evils, and I will relent concerning the evils that I planned to do to them. And at last I will speak concerning a nation and concerning a kingdom, to build it up and to plant it; and they will do evil before me, so as not to hear my voice, and I will relent concerning the good things that I said I would do for them” (Jeremiah 18:2–10). Do you see how some are moulded for honour and for dishonour, not because they were allotted a nature made that way, but because they receive an equal and fitting return for what they do? So if the Maker of all punishes the one who passes from good ways to more shameful ones, and crowns with honours the one who moves from the more shameful to the better, how is it not true to say that some have by no means become evil by nature, or been moulded so by him, but have rather become vessels of dishonour because, though it was open to them to choose to win approval with God, they fell sick with a willing inclination toward evil?
Fragments on Romans, §32 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
God could never make anything evil, for all he made was very good, and Pharaoh shared the same nature as the rest of us.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…he himself, someone says, hardened Pharaoh’s heart (Exodus 9:12); and indeed he said to him, “For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you” (Exodus 9:16; Romans 9:17). If, then, he both hardens some and raises them up, who are vessels of wrath and are said to be prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22), “why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?” (Romans 9:19). And how could the one hardened by him have become good?
What, then, could I say to this? To know the truth, it is enough to be settled in the conviction that God could never be the maker of evil things; for all that he made was very good (Genesis 1:31). If, then, they insist that the Egyptian was not a human being and did not share the same nature as we do, let them prove it, and we too will keep silent. But if he was like us, let them either openly accuse the divine voice of not seeing what is good and what is not; or, if they shudder at that, let them confess that the things he brought into existence are good.
In this way they will reject that most rash opinion.
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
"I raised you up" does not mean "I created you" but "I called you forth" to resist, so that Pharaoh, idolater and oppressor of Israel, was justly punished as a vessel of wrath.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The words spoken to Pharaoh, “For this very purpose I raised you up” (Exodus 9:16), do not mean “I created you” or “I made you”, but rather “I called you forth, to the point of choosing to set yourself against me”; and this not at the start of his life, but when Moses was being sent to redeem Israel. On what grounds, and for what reason, the all-wise Paul will make plain to us: “For God,” he says, “desiring to show his wrath,” and the rest (Romans 9:22).
In times long past the whole earth had gone astray. Some worshipped the creation (Romans 1:25); others made an object of reverence of whatever seemed good to them. At length Abraham was called to knowledge, and so the race descended from him sprang up, devoted to the worship of God. But when they too went down into Egypt and then spent a long time there, they slid into deception and worshipped the gods of the land. Yet God remembered what he had promised to the fathers (Exodus 2:24). Moses had been appointed to the mission, to release Israel from slavery; but it was necessary, both for those called to worship him and for all on earth, not only to learn that after long ages the God of the Hebrews had been made manifest, but also to be confirmed by surpassing wonders in faith in him and in the conviction that he is not, like the other gods, voiceless and powerless, but rather himself steers the universe, and that wrath strikes those who act against his will. Yet, on the other hand, God, wishing to work wonders, had to be seen to have good grounds for doing so. So Pharaoh was raised up to resist, by God’s providential ordering, and grew hard against the divine power. For this reason he was punished, and not unjustly: for he was unholy and an idolater, he maltreated Israel with clay and brickmaking (Exodus 1:14), and he made toil their wage. Therefore he was of necessity named a vessel of wrath, and was prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22)
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:18–21
Paul answers the Jews' boast in the ceremonies by showing that God has power to reject whom he wishes and take whom he wishes among the peoples.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
They [the Jews] boasted of observing ceremonies and sacrifices, and therefore supposed that other nations, consecrated by none of the Law's rites, neither could nor should suddenly be admitted to fellowship with them. He would tell them that even if the whole of righteousness had consisted in those observances, God would still have had power to make a change among the peoples, rejecting whom he wished and taking whom he wished. In answer to this meaning, a reply is made in the person of the Jews: nothing should now be demanded from the human will, since God “has mercy on whom he wills and hardens whom he wills” (Romans 9:18). To this the apostle replies: “O human being, who are you to answer back to God?” (Romans 9:20). He introduces the prophet Isaiah's testimony: “Does what is molded say to the one who molded it, ‘Why did you make me like this?’” (Isaiah 45:9; Romans 9:20). He adds in his own words: “Does the potter not have power over the clay to make from the same lump one vessel for honor and another for dishonor?” (Romans 9:21).
To Florus, §1.133 → read in full
On Romans 9:19–21
The potter image does not strip us of free will, for those who can complain to God must be masters of themselves.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
Therefore, if God manages something according to foreknowledge, whether he raised up Pharaoh or hated Esau and loved Jacob, let no one suppose because of these things that nothing is upon us, but rather that our autonomy is being cut away. Some have spoken this, not as a reproach, but to say: 'Nevertheless, O man, who are you to answer back to God?' For they say it is absurd to have sought such great questions, unsettling the listener's mind without resolving any of them, but only rebuking those who seek to simply flee from the things sought, while also appearing to strip us of autonomy by the image of the potter, as if the potter fashions the vessels as he wills, while the rest remains as it has become from the beginning. They say these things unworthy of the apostolic grace and teaching. The word is not spoken as a reproach, but the mind holds it thus: if from which, he says, he raised up Pharaoh and hated Esau and loved Jacob, and before their birth gave all things in the will of God, and nothing is upon us, then in short: who are you, O man, and how do you answer back to God? And how do you have the authority to speak and to accuse him as if he reproaches us unjustly, saying, 'Why is he still reproaching?' … How then do you charge God, if nothing lies in our power as you say? For if nothing is up to us, neither is it in your power to complain or to answer back to God. 'Not the things of the potter,' he says, 'the vessels, since they lack sensation; they complain against the maker even if they become dishonorable, or even if they become honorable according to the maker's power' (Rom 9:21). But you complain, so you have sensation and power, as having a will that is free. And he who has the power to complain, it is evident that he is also master of himself in all other things, to say and to do what he wills. For he is not a master of himself only in complaining to God, but in other things he is deprived of mastery.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
On Romans 9:20–21
God, like a potter, has authority to honour whom he wants and to punish whom he wills.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Did God not have authority as He wished? But a potter indeed fashions some for honor and others for dishonor, yet God does not have the authority that the potter has, so as to honor whom He wants and to punish whom He wills? Having said this out of surplus, he subsequently makes the solution.
Fragments on Romans, §4 → read in full
The clay must not judge the potter's art, and no one should think God shows mercy or hardens at random, for he bestows according to foreknowledge of worth.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
For what does he say, why does he question the Creator? The potter knows how to use the clay and what kind of vessels are to be made for dishonor and what kind for honor. But the clay, being clay, must not judge the art of the Creator; for even if you seem to have rational perception, O man, you are left so far removed from the economy and art of God as to be an unfeeling clay to the potter's will. Therefore, do not dare to accuse God, nor suppose that he happens to show mercy to one and harden the other, but rather that according to the power of foreknowledge he bestows upon each according to his worth. Thus, it is not the one foreknowing who is the cause, but those who are foreknown, upon which it is for them to be evil or not. For he teaches that this is in us, through others; for speaking of vessels of gold, silver, and earthenware, he says: if anyone cleanses himself, he will be a vessel for honor, sanctified. So we provide the cause, but God bestows according to worth.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
The potter image does not mean that some are made evil by nature, for Jeremiah shows that God moulds each for honour or dishonour according to what they do.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
To such arguments one might reply, first of all, that they could not claim that the force of these thoughts hints to us at differences of nature. For he did not say that some were made harsh and hardened, or made into vessels of honour and of dishonour, nor did he assign them such a nature at all. Rather, he leads us to think this: that some are moulded like vessels of clay, some for honour and some for dishonour; and we have been taught the meaning of the illustration from the words of the prophets. In what way, then, some are moulded as if by a potter, some for honour and others for dishonour, and for what causes, anyone may learn by reading the words of Jeremiah. It is written thus: “Arise and go down to the potter’s house, and there you will hear my words. And I went down to the potter’s house, and there he was, making a piece of work on the stones. And the vessel that he was making fell in his hands; and again he made it into another vessel, as it seemed good in his sight to make it. And the word of the Lord came,” he says, “to me, saying: Shall I not be able to make you as this potter does, house of Israel? Look, like the potter’s clay, you are in my hands. At last I will speak against a nation or against a kingdom, to root them out; and that nation will turn from all its evils, and I will relent concerning the evils that I planned to do to them. And at last I will speak concerning a nation and concerning a kingdom, to build it up and to plant it; and they will do evil before me, so as not to hear my voice, and I will relent concerning the good things that I said I would do for them” (Jeremiah 18:2–10). Do you see how some are moulded for honour and for dishonour, not because they were allotted a nature made that way, but because they receive an equal and fitting return for what they do? So if the Maker of all punishes the one who passes from good ways to more shameful ones, and crowns with honours the one who moves from the more shameful to the better, how is it not true to say that some have by no means become evil by nature, or been moulded so by him, but have rather become vessels of dishonour because, though it was open to them to choose to win approval with God, they fell sick with a willing inclination toward evil?
Fragments on Romans, §32 → read in full
8 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Diodorus of Tarsus c. 330–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §8 'Not the things of the potter,' he says, 'the vessels, since they lack sensation; they complain against the maker even if they become dishonorable, or even if they become honorable according to the maker's power'. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §32 “…like a potter, God moulds in whatever way he wishes, so as to make one vessel for honour and another for dishonour, how will reason not persuade anyone at all to think that whatever has come to be is in every way and wholly just as it… Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §1.113 For he is called ‘the potter making from the same lump one vessel for honor according to mercy, another for dishonor according to judgment’, to whom the Church sings, ‘Mercy and judgment’” (Psalm 101:1; LXX Psalm 100:1; Augustine, On… Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §1.126 You should never have mentioned that God is called “the potter making from the same lump one vessel for honor and another for dishonor”. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §1.128 Nothing is more contradictory than saying “all” and “not all”. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §1.133 He adds in his own words: “Does the potter not have power over the clay to make from the same lump one vessel for honor and another for dishonor?”. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §2.19 We also freed the apostle Paul’s testimony from the slanderer’s snares and, with the prophet as witness, showed that our God, the potter of good vessels, is the creator of everyone (Isaiah 45:8–13) (Romans 9:21) (Isaiah 45:8–13). Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §3.97 And that God is the potter fashioning vessels of wrath and destruction (Romans 9:22). Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:22 5 comments from the Fathers, 12 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (5) All 12 passages
On Romans 9:22–24
God bore with the vessels of wrath so as to benefit the vessels of mercy, who are those called through faith from both Jews and Gentiles.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So let every reproach and every idle charge against God be dismissed. For “desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, he endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction” (Romans 9:22), in order to benefit vessels of mercy (Romans 9:23), that is, those who have received mercy through faith; for we have been called not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles (Romans 9:24).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
God could never make anything evil, for all he made was very good, and Pharaoh shared the same nature as the rest of us.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…he himself, someone says, hardened Pharaoh’s heart (Exodus 9:12); and indeed he said to him, “For this very purpose I raised you up, that I might show my power in you” (Exodus 9:16; Romans 9:17). If, then, he both hardens some and raises them up, who are vessels of wrath and are said to be prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22), “why does he still find fault? For who has resisted his will?” (Romans 9:19). And how could the one hardened by him have become good?
What, then, could I say to this? To know the truth, it is enough to be settled in the conviction that God could never be the maker of evil things; for all that he made was very good (Genesis 1:31). If, then, they insist that the Egyptian was not a human being and did not share the same nature as we do, let them prove it, and we too will keep silent. But if he was like us, let them either openly accuse the divine voice of not seeing what is good and what is not; or, if they shudder at that, let them confess that the things he brought into existence are good.
In this way they will reject that most rash opinion.
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
On Romans 9:17–22
"I raised you up" does not mean "I created you" but "I called you forth" to resist, so that Pharaoh, idolater and oppressor of Israel, was justly punished as a vessel of wrath.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The words spoken to Pharaoh, “For this very purpose I raised you up” (Exodus 9:16), do not mean “I created you” or “I made you”, but rather “I called you forth, to the point of choosing to set yourself against me”; and this not at the start of his life, but when Moses was being sent to redeem Israel. On what grounds, and for what reason, the all-wise Paul will make plain to us: “For God,” he says, “desiring to show his wrath,” and the rest (Romans 9:22).
In times long past the whole earth had gone astray. Some worshipped the creation (Romans 1:25); others made an object of reverence of whatever seemed good to them. At length Abraham was called to knowledge, and so the race descended from him sprang up, devoted to the worship of God. But when they too went down into Egypt and then spent a long time there, they slid into deception and worshipped the gods of the land. Yet God remembered what he had promised to the fathers (Exodus 2:24). Moses had been appointed to the mission, to release Israel from slavery; but it was necessary, both for those called to worship him and for all on earth, not only to learn that after long ages the God of the Hebrews had been made manifest, but also to be confirmed by surpassing wonders in faith in him and in the conviction that he is not, like the other gods, voiceless and powerless, but rather himself steers the universe, and that wrath strikes those who act against his will. Yet, on the other hand, God, wishing to work wonders, had to be seen to have good grounds for doing so. So Pharaoh was raised up to resist, by God’s providential ordering, and grew hard against the divine power. For this reason he was punished, and not unjustly: for he was unholy and an idolater, he maltreated Israel with clay and brickmaking (Exodus 1:14), and he made toil their wage. Therefore he was of necessity named a vessel of wrath, and was prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22)
Fragments on Romans, §33 → read in full
The demonstration of wrath is forgiven through long-suffering, but vessels of wrath are under death's limit.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
He speaks of a demonstration of wrath (Rom 9:22), which He forgives to men through long-suffering, allowing them to do what they want; but he speaks of men as vessels of wrath prepared for destruction (Rom 9:22), who are under the limit of death.
Fragments on Romans, §4 → read in full
On Romans 9:22–24
God bore with the vessels of wrath so as to benefit the vessels of mercy, who are those called through faith from both Jews and Gentiles.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So let every reproach and every idle charge against God be dismissed. For “desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, he endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction” (Romans 9:22), in order to benefit vessels of mercy (Romans 9:23), that is, those who have received mercy through faith; for we have been called not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles (Romans 9:24).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:22–24
Vessels of wrath and of mercy receive their lot as the wages of their own will, for Paul says elsewhere that whoever cleanses himself becomes a vessel for honour.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
Most consistently, then, Paul adds that vessels made for dishonor and those made for honor receive this as the wages of their own will: “If God, wishing to show his wrath and make his power known with great patience in vessels of wrath completed for destruction, and to make known the riches of his glory in vessels of mercy which he prepared for glory, whom he also called, namely us, not only from Jews but also from the nations” (Romans 9:22–24). Here he certainly clears up what the previous debate had concealed: God brings wrath only upon vessels completed for destruction, while glory is given to those prepared for it. By whom such vessels are prepared to receive the things we have named, the apostle's own words disclose: “In a great house there are not only gold and silver vessels but also wooden and earthenware ones, some for honor and some for dishonor. If, then, anyone cleanses himself from these, he will be a vessel sanctified for honor, useful to the Lord, prepared for every good work” (2 Timothy 2:21).
To Florus, §1.134 → read in full
12 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Job §72 It also suggests to understand that 'even if those who made claims are acting wickedly by taking authority over me, these are not innocent, having become instruments and vessels of wrath, even if they do this while acting against a sinner'. Severianus of Gabala fl. c. 400 AD · Fragments on Romans §4 He speaks of a demonstration of wrath, which He forgives to men through long-suffering, allowing them to do what they want; but he speaks of men as vessels of wrath prepared for destruction (Rom 9:22), who are under the limit of death. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §33 If, then, he both hardens some and raises them up, who are vessels of wrath and are said to be prepared for destruction, “why does he still find fault? Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §34 For “desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, he endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction”, in order to benefit vessels of mercy (Romans 9:23), that is, those who have received mercy through… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Commentary on Isaiah §4 God raised up Pharaoh, who was a vessel of anger and wrath and was already liable to punishment for his own offences, so that, as He Himself says, He might show in him His own power and the exactness of His just judgment (Romans 9:17;… Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §1.134 Most consistently, then, Paul adds that vessels made for dishonor and those made for honor receive this as the wages of their own will: “If God, wishing to show his wrath and make his power known with great patience in vessels of wrath… Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §3.97 And that God is the potter fashioning vessels of wrath and destruction (Romans 9:21). Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §3.98 But vessels driven to destruction not by the course of their free will but by the power of their maker. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §3.142 Yet the maker of even the vessels of wrath uses this well to make known the riches of his glory in vessels of mercy. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §213 Scripture calls the reprobate vessels of wrath fitted for destruction; formerly marked out for condemnation (Jude 4). John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §384 They say Contraremonstrants admit the Major; the Minor they prove from Rom. 9:22 , where vessels of mercy and of wrath mean believers and unbelievers. John Davenant 1572–1641 AD · Two Dissertations §526 Fourth: the Apostle says that when God reprobates he wills to show wrath and vengeance. Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:23 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 2 passages
On Romans 9:22–24
God bore with the vessels of wrath so as to benefit the vessels of mercy, who are those called through faith from both Jews and Gentiles.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So let every reproach and every idle charge against God be dismissed. For “desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, he endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction” (Romans 9:22), in order to benefit vessels of mercy (Romans 9:23), that is, those who have received mercy through faith; for we have been called not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles (Romans 9:24).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:22–24
God bore with the vessels of wrath so as to benefit the vessels of mercy, who are those called through faith from both Jews and Gentiles.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So let every reproach and every idle charge against God be dismissed. For “desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, he endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction” (Romans 9:22), in order to benefit vessels of mercy (Romans 9:23), that is, those who have received mercy through faith; for we have been called not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles (Romans 9:24).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:22–24
Vessels of wrath and of mercy receive their lot as the wages of their own will, for Paul says elsewhere that whoever cleanses himself becomes a vessel for honour.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
Most consistently, then, Paul adds that vessels made for dishonor and those made for honor receive this as the wages of their own will: “If God, wishing to show his wrath and make his power known with great patience in vessels of wrath completed for destruction, and to make known the riches of his glory in vessels of mercy which he prepared for glory, whom he also called, namely us, not only from Jews but also from the nations” (Romans 9:22–24). Here he certainly clears up what the previous debate had concealed: God brings wrath only upon vessels completed for destruction, while glory is given to those prepared for it. By whom such vessels are prepared to receive the things we have named, the apostle's own words disclose: “In a great house there are not only gold and silver vessels but also wooden and earthenware ones, some for honor and some for dishonor. If, then, anyone cleanses himself from these, he will be a vessel sanctified for honor, useful to the Lord, prepared for every good work” (2 Timothy 2:21).
To Florus, §1.134 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:24 2 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 3 passages
On Romans 9:22–24
God bore with the vessels of wrath so as to benefit the vessels of mercy, who are those called through faith from both Jews and Gentiles.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So let every reproach and every idle charge against God be dismissed. For “desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, he endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction” (Romans 9:22), in order to benefit vessels of mercy (Romans 9:23), that is, those who have received mercy through faith; for we have been called not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles (Romans 9:24).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:22–24
God bore with the vessels of wrath so as to benefit the vessels of mercy, who are those called through faith from both Jews and Gentiles.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So let every reproach and every idle charge against God be dismissed. For “desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, he endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction” (Romans 9:22), in order to benefit vessels of mercy (Romans 9:23), that is, those who have received mercy through faith; for we have been called not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles (Romans 9:24).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:22–24
Vessels of wrath and of mercy receive their lot as the wages of their own will, for Paul says elsewhere that whoever cleanses himself becomes a vessel for honour.
— Julian of Eclanum, c. 386–c. 455 AD
Most consistently, then, Paul adds that vessels made for dishonor and those made for honor receive this as the wages of their own will: “If God, wishing to show his wrath and make his power known with great patience in vessels of wrath completed for destruction, and to make known the riches of his glory in vessels of mercy which he prepared for glory, whom he also called, namely us, not only from Jews but also from the nations” (Romans 9:22–24). Here he certainly clears up what the previous debate had concealed: God brings wrath only upon vessels completed for destruction, while glory is given to those prepared for it. By whom such vessels are prepared to receive the things we have named, the apostle's own words disclose: “In a great house there are not only gold and silver vessels but also wooden and earthenware ones, some for honor and some for dishonor. If, then, anyone cleanses himself from these, he will be a vessel sanctified for honor, useful to the Lord, prepared for every good work” (2 Timothy 2:21).
To Florus, §1.134 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Diodorus of Tarsus c. 330–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Romans §9 For he had previously said: 'For not all those who are of Israel are Israel, these are Israel' (Romans 9:6), and he noted that there were some being saved, even if not all (Romans 11:5); and again: 'whom he called not only from the Jews… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §30 By no means” (Romans 9:14), and so on, down to “he called us, not from the Jews only but also from the Gentiles”. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §34 For “desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, he endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction” (Romans 9:22), in order to benefit vessels of mercy (Romans 9:23), that is, those who have received… Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:25 1 comment from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (1) All 2 passages
The servants of idols who were not God's people have received mercy through faith and been called, justified and sanctified through Christ.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“As indeed he says in Hosea” (Romans 9:25). We too, the servants of idols, who did not know the one who is God by nature and in truth, were not his people (Hosea 2:23); but we have received mercy through faith, have come under him, have been called through grace, and have been justified and sanctified through Christ.
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:26 2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:27 1 comment from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 2 passages
On Romans 9:27–28
Even if Israel were as many as the sand, only the remnant justified through faith will be saved, and the gospel is a short, simple word compared with the long circuit of the law and prophets.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“Though the number of the sons of Israel be as the sand of the sea” (Romans 9:27). So even if Israel were as many as the sand, “the remnant will be saved” (Romans 9:27; Isaiah 10:22), that is, those who have been justified through faith in Christ; and this has come about because God had mercy on them. “For he is completing and cutting short the word” (Romans 9:28). He saved, he says, by “completing and cutting short the word”; that is, he declared to us the preaching of the gospel as an apt and concise and, so to speak, cut-short saying. For the law and the prophets, by a long circuit of words, scarcely set before us through the letter the meaning of what they say; but the preaching of the gospel is simple and a word cut short.
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:27–28
Even if Israel were as many as the sand, only the remnant justified through faith will be saved, and the gospel is a short, simple word compared with the long circuit of the law and prophets.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“Though the number of the sons of Israel be as the sand of the sea” (Romans 9:27). So even if Israel were as many as the sand, “the remnant will be saved” (Romans 9:27; Isaiah 10:22), that is, those who have been justified through faith in Christ; and this has come about because God had mercy on them. “For he is completing and cutting short the word” (Romans 9:28). He saved, he says, by “completing and cutting short the word”; that is, he declared to us the preaching of the gospel as an apt and concise and, so to speak, cut-short saying. For the law and the prophets, by a long circuit of words, scarcely set before us through the letter the meaning of what they say; but the preaching of the gospel is simple and a word cut short.
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:28 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On Romans 9:27–28
Even if Israel were as many as the sand, only the remnant justified through faith will be saved, and the gospel is a short, simple word compared with the long circuit of the law and prophets.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“Though the number of the sons of Israel be as the sand of the sea” (Romans 9:27). So even if Israel were as many as the sand, “the remnant will be saved” (Romans 9:27; Isaiah 10:22), that is, those who have been justified through faith in Christ; and this has come about because God had mercy on them. “For he is completing and cutting short the word” (Romans 9:28). He saved, he says, by “completing and cutting short the word”; that is, he declared to us the preaching of the gospel as an apt and concise and, so to speak, cut-short saying. For the law and the prophets, by a long circuit of words, scarcely set before us through the letter the meaning of what they say; but the preaching of the gospel is simple and a word cut short.
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:27–28
Even if Israel were as many as the sand, only the remnant justified through faith will be saved, and the gospel is a short, simple word compared with the long circuit of the law and prophets.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“Though the number of the sons of Israel be as the sand of the sea” (Romans 9:27). So even if Israel were as many as the sand, “the remnant will be saved” (Romans 9:27; Isaiah 10:22), that is, those who have been justified through faith in Christ; and this has come about because God had mercy on them. “For he is completing and cutting short the word” (Romans 9:28). He saved, he says, by “completing and cutting short the word”; that is, he declared to us the preaching of the gospel as an apt and concise and, so to speak, cut-short saying. For the law and the prophets, by a long circuit of words, scarcely set before us through the letter the meaning of what they say; but the preaching of the gospel is simple and a word cut short.
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:29 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:30 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 1 passage
On Romans 9:30–32
It is strange that those with no aim of doing good were justified while Israel, trained by the law, missed righteousness, because it would not accept salvation through faith in Christ.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“But Israel, pursuing a law of righteousness” (Romans 9:31). In giving the reasons why not all the Jews have been saved, he at once weaves wonder into his argument and says: What a strange thing! The crowd of those who had gone astray, with no aim at all of doing good, has been justified (Romans 9:30), while Israel, though trained toward righteousness by the law given through Moses, missed its hope and has had no share in the gift that leads to it (Romans 9:31). What the cause is, then, is plain: they did not accept salvation through faith and justification in Christ, but thought that the boasts they had, as in shadows, were enough for them (Romans 9:32).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:30–31
The Jews fell away because they sought to be justified by works of the law, not believing in the law that invited them to faith.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
Since it has been said in the things before, that the nation of the Jews is cast off by the part that prevails, while the nations are contending for the status of adoption, it follows by seeking the cause for which those practicing in the law have fallen away, while those who have grasped the law were justified (Rom 9:29-31). He then concludes by explaining that the Jews fell away from running toward faith just as the nations did; for they desired to be justified by works of law, not believing in the law which invited them.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
On Romans 9:30–32
It is strange that those with no aim of doing good were justified while Israel, trained by the law, missed righteousness, because it would not accept salvation through faith in Christ.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“But Israel, pursuing a law of righteousness” (Romans 9:31). In giving the reasons why not all the Jews have been saved, he at once weaves wonder into his argument and says: What a strange thing! The crowd of those who had gone astray, with no aim at all of doing good, has been justified (Romans 9:30), while Israel, though trained toward righteousness by the law given through Moses, missed its hope and has had no share in the gift that leads to it (Romans 9:31). What the cause is, then, is plain: they did not accept salvation through faith and justification in Christ, but thought that the boasts they had, as in shadows, were enough for them (Romans 9:32).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:31 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 2 passages
On Romans 9:30–32
It is strange that those with no aim of doing good were justified while Israel, trained by the law, missed righteousness, because it would not accept salvation through faith in Christ.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“But Israel, pursuing a law of righteousness” (Romans 9:31). In giving the reasons why not all the Jews have been saved, he at once weaves wonder into his argument and says: What a strange thing! The crowd of those who had gone astray, with no aim at all of doing good, has been justified (Romans 9:30), while Israel, though trained toward righteousness by the law given through Moses, missed its hope and has had no share in the gift that leads to it (Romans 9:31). What the cause is, then, is plain: they did not accept salvation through faith and justification in Christ, but thought that the boasts they had, as in shadows, were enough for them (Romans 9:32).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:30–31
The Jews fell away because they sought to be justified by works of the law, not believing in the law that invited them to faith.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
Since it has been said in the things before, that the nation of the Jews is cast off by the part that prevails, while the nations are contending for the status of adoption, it follows by seeking the cause for which those practicing in the law have fallen away, while those who have grasped the law were justified (Rom 9:29-31). He then concludes by explaining that the Jews fell away from running toward faith just as the nations did; for they desired to be justified by works of law, not believing in the law which invited them.
Fragments on Romans, §8 → read in full
On Romans 9:30–32
It is strange that those with no aim of doing good were justified while Israel, trained by the law, missed righteousness, because it would not accept salvation through faith in Christ.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“But Israel, pursuing a law of righteousness” (Romans 9:31). In giving the reasons why not all the Jews have been saved, he at once weaves wonder into his argument and says: What a strange thing! The crowd of those who had gone astray, with no aim at all of doing good, has been justified (Romans 9:30), while Israel, though trained toward righteousness by the law given through Moses, missed its hope and has had no share in the gift that leads to it (Romans 9:31). What the cause is, then, is plain: they did not accept salvation through faith and justification in Christ, but thought that the boasts they had, as in shadows, were enough for them (Romans 9:32).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:32 1 comment from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 2 passages
On Romans 9:30–32
It is strange that those with no aim of doing good were justified while Israel, trained by the law, missed righteousness, because it would not accept salvation through faith in Christ.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“But Israel, pursuing a law of righteousness” (Romans 9:31). In giving the reasons why not all the Jews have been saved, he at once weaves wonder into his argument and says: What a strange thing! The crowd of those who had gone astray, with no aim at all of doing good, has been justified (Romans 9:30), while Israel, though trained toward righteousness by the law given through Moses, missed its hope and has had no share in the gift that leads to it (Romans 9:31). What the cause is, then, is plain: they did not accept salvation through faith and justification in Christ, but thought that the boasts they had, as in shadows, were enough for them (Romans 9:32).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
On Romans 9:30–32
It is strange that those with no aim of doing good were justified while Israel, trained by the law, missed righteousness, because it would not accept salvation through faith in Christ.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“But Israel, pursuing a law of righteousness” (Romans 9:31). In giving the reasons why not all the Jews have been saved, he at once weaves wonder into his argument and says: What a strange thing! The crowd of those who had gone astray, with no aim at all of doing good, has been justified (Romans 9:30), while Israel, though trained toward righteousness by the law given through Moses, missed its hope and has had no share in the gift that leads to it (Romans 9:31). What the cause is, then, is plain: they did not accept salvation through faith and justification in Christ, but thought that the boasts they had, as in shadows, were enough for them (Romans 9:32).
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §34 What the cause is, then, is plain: they did not accept salvation through faith and justification in Christ, but thought that the boasts they had, as in shadows, were enough for them. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §38 …insisting that the nations were not called for this reason, that Israel, having stumbled against Christ as against a stone, should fall away altogether from its hope in God, but rather so that, moved to jealousy by those who had been… Back to the chapter Verse
Romans 9:33 3 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 4 passages
Christ was not set in Israel to make them stumble, but God foretold the stumbling so that, knowing it, they might rise above it, and Christ is ruin to unbelievers and life to believers.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“A stone of stumbling” (Romans 9:33). Surely we do not say that Christ was set in Israel for this purpose; but since this was foreknown to God, he of necessity foretold what was to be: that a cause of slipping would lie in the foundations of Zion, and that some of the foolish would fall upon it and suffer this from their disobedience (Isaiah 8:14; Isaiah 28:16). He made the prediction for their benefit, not that they should stumble, but that, knowing it beforehand, they might rise above the evil. So Christ has been laid as a precious stone (Isaiah 28:16); but for those who stumble out of unbelief the loss was ruin, while for those who have believed the gain is life and justification.
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
Christ was not set in Israel to make them stumble, but God foretold the stumbling so that, knowing it, they might rise above it, and Christ is ruin to unbelievers and life to believers.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“A stone of stumbling” (Romans 9:33). Surely we do not say that Christ was set in Israel for this purpose; but since this was foreknown to God, he of necessity foretold what was to be: that a cause of slipping would lie in the foundations of Zion, and that some of the foolish would fall upon it and suffer this from their disobedience (Isaiah 8:14; Isaiah 28:16). He made the prediction for their benefit, not that they should stumble, but that, knowing it beforehand, they might rise above the evil. So Christ has been laid as a precious stone (Isaiah 28:16); but for those who stumble out of unbelief the loss was ruin, while for those who have believed the gain is life and justification.
Fragments on Romans, §34 → read in full
Paul's saying is gathered from two places in Isaiah, one calling the Lord a stone of stumbling and the other a precious cornerstone.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
The stated word lies scattered within the prophecies of Isaiah (Rom 9:33), not as it is now said by the apostle, being gathered together. For concerning the beginning of the book it has been written regarding the Lord according to the edition which Aquila agreed with and the apostolic one: 'He himself is your fear and he himself is your trembling, and he will be for sanctification and for a stone of stumbling, a solid stone of offense (Isa 8:14). And after much it is, that behold, I lay in the foundations of Zion a precious stone, an elect cornerstone, honorable, and he who believes will never be ashamed (Isa 28:16).
Fragments on Romans, §12 → read in full
Christ is the stone of stumbling, over which some are shattered through disobedience while those who believe in him escape shame.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
A stone of stumbling and a rock of offense (Romans 9:33); and the one who believes upon him will not be put to shame. When righteous Symeon received the divine infant into his arms, he said to God: “Now you release your servant, Master, according to your word in peace, because my eyes have seen your salvation which you prepared before the face of all the peoples,” (Luke 2:29–34) and what follows; and he added: “Behold, this one is set for the fall and rising of many in Israel, and for a sign spoken against.” (Luke 2:34) So the same one is the stone of stumbling and the rock of offense; and some, striking against him through disobedience, were shattered, while those who received the faith toward him escaped being put to shame.
On the True Faith, to the Princesses Arcadia and Marina, §89 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter