▶ Listen to the King James Version 0:00 / 6:05 1×
1 Some time later there was a feast of the Jews, and Jesus went up to Jerusalem. Verse 1: 1 passage in the Fathers 2 Now there is in Jerusalem near the Sheep Gate a pool with five covered colonnades, which in Hebrew is called Bethesda. Verse 2: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 3 On these walkways lay a great number of the sick, the blind, the lame, and the paralyzed. Verse 3: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 5 One man there had been an invalid for thirty-eight years. Verse 5: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 6 When Jesus saw him lying there and realized that he had spent a long time in this condition, He asked him, “Do you want to get well?” Verse 6: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 7 “Sir,” the invalid replied, “I have no one to help me into the pool when the water is stirred. While I am on my way, someone else goes in before me.” Verse 7: commentary from the Fathers 8 Then Jesus told him, “Get up, pick up your mat, and walk.” Verse 8: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 9 Immediately the man was made well, and he picked up his mat and began to walk. Now this happened on the Sabbath day, Verse 9: commentary from the Fathers 10 so the Jews said to the man who had been healed, “This is the Sabbath! It is unlawful for you to carry your mat.” Verse 10: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 11 But he answered, “The man who made me well told me, ‘Pick up your mat and walk.’” Verse 11: 1 passage in the Fathers 12 “Who is this man who told you to pick it up and walk?” they asked. 13 But the man who was healed did not know who it was, for Jesus had slipped away while the crowd was there. 14 Afterward, Jesus found the man at the temple and said to him, “See, you have been made well. Stop sinning, or something worse may happen to you.” Verse 14: 2 passages in the Fathers 15 And the man went away and told the Jews that it was Jesus who had made him well. 16 Now because Jesus was doing these things on the Sabbath, the Jews began to persecute Him. Verse 16: 2 passages in the Fathers 17 But Jesus answered them, “To this very day My Father is at His work, and I too am working.” Verse 17: 10 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 18 Because of this, the Jews tried all the harder to kill Him. Not only was He breaking the Sabbath, but He was even calling God His own Father, making Himself equal with God. Verse 18: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 19 So Jesus replied, “Truly, truly, I tell you, the Son can do nothing by Himself, unless He sees the Father doing it. For whatever the Father does, the Son also does. Verse 19: 11 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 20 The Father loves the Son and shows Him all He does. And to your amazement, He will show Him even greater works than these. Verse 20: 2 passages in the Fathers 21 For just as the Father raises the dead and gives them life, so also the Son gives life to whom He wishes. Verse 21: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 22 Furthermore, the Father judges no one, but has assigned all judgment to the Son, Verse 22: 7 passages in the Fathers 23 so that all may honor the Son just as they honor the Father. Whoever does not honor the Son does not honor the Father who sent Him. Verse 23: 9 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 24 Truly, truly, I tell you, whoever hears My word and believes Him who sent Me has eternal life and will not come under judgment. Indeed, he has crossed over from death to life. Verse 24: 8 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 25 Truly, truly, I tell you, the hour is coming and has now come when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear will live. Verse 25: commentary from the Fathers 26 For as the Father has life in Himself, so also He has granted the Son to have life in Himself. Verse 26: 6 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 27 And He has given Him authority to execute judgment, because He is the Son of Man. Verse 27: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 28 Do not be amazed at this, for the hour is coming when all who are in their graves will hear His voice Verse 28: 9 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 29 and come out—those who have done good to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil to the resurrection of judgment. Verse 29: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 30 I can do nothing by Myself; I judge only as I hear. And My judgment is just, because I do not seek My own will, but the will of Him who sent Me. Verse 30: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 31 If I testify about Myself, My testimony is not valid. Verse 31: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 32 There is another who testifies about Me, and I know that His testimony about Me is valid. Verse 32: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 33 You have sent to John, and he has testified to the truth. Verse 33: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 34 Even though I do not accept human testimony, I say these things so that you may be saved. Verse 34: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 35 John was a lamp that burned and gave light, and you were willing for a season to bask in his light. Verse 35: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 36 But I have testimony more substantial than that of John. For the works that the Father has given Me to accomplish—the very works I am doing—testify about Me that the Father has sent Me. Verse 36: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 37 And the Father who sent Me has Himself testified about Me. You have never heard His voice nor seen His form, Verse 37: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 38 nor does His word abide in you, because you do not believe the One He sent. Verse 38: commentary from the Fathers 39 You pore over the Scriptures because you presume that by them you possess eternal life. These are the very words that testify about Me, Verse 39: 16 passages in the Fathers 40 yet you refuse to come to Me to have life. Verse 40: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 41 I do not accept glory from men, Verse 41: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 42 but I know you, that you do not have the love of God within you. Verse 42: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 43 I have come in My Father’s name, and you have not received Me; but if someone else comes in his own name, you will receive him. Verse 43: 6 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 44 How can you believe if you accept glory from one another, yet do not seek the glory that comes from the only God? Verse 44: 7 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 45 Do not think that I will accuse you before the Father. Your accuser is Moses, in whom you have put your hope. Verse 45: 5 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 46 If you had believed Moses, you would believe Me, because he wrote about Me. Verse 46: 10 passages in the Fathers 47 But since you do not believe what he wrote, how will you believe what I say?”
Audio: the King James Version read aloud, from Larry Sanger's Deep Dive Bible (public domain).
×
This chapter in the Fathers
John 5 164 passages
39 of 46 verses cited
25 writers
Most cited verses John 5:39 16 passages John 5:19 11 passages John 5:46 10 passages John 5:17 10 passages John 5:23 9 passages John 5:28 9 passages John 5:24 8 passages John 5:44 7 passages On the chapter as a whole Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.21.4 A person in God is a hypostasis or individual subsistence, incommunicable, living, rational, willing, powerful, and active John 5 ; 14. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.23.1 He is called Person in the same signification as the Father, because He is a subsistence, individual, incommunicable — John 1 — of living nature — John 5 — understanding — John 1:18 — willing — Matthew 11:27; John 5:21 — powerful —… Louis Le Blanc de Beaulieu 1614–1675 AD · Theological Theses §107 Yet Scripture's testimony was greater than the Baptist's — as Christ our Lord teaches plainly, where he sets Scripture's witness to himself above John's. Louis Le Blanc de Beaulieu 1614–1675 AD · Theological Theses §496 Scripture stress: fountain of life (Ps 36); John 5 life-in-Himself. Select a marked verse to see who cites it.
Also cited: verse 4 (numbered differently in this translation).
Verse
John 5:1 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:2 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 5:2–4
The Sheep Gate was where sacrificial sheep gathered, and the pool's angel-stirred healing prefigured baptism.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
It was called "Sheep Gate" because there the sheep to be slaughtered for the feast were gathered and their entrails were washed there.
[John 5:4] Here the mystery of baptism was prefigured, in which every kind of sin was healed. An angel coming down into the water and stirring it put healing power into them. It is unclear on what day and hour the angel came down.…
Fragments on John, §10 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:3 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 5:2–4
The Sheep Gate was where sacrificial sheep gathered, and the pool's angel-stirred healing prefigured baptism.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
It was called "Sheep Gate" because there the sheep to be slaughtered for the feast were gathered and their entrails were washed there.
[John 5:4] Here the mystery of baptism was prefigured, in which every kind of sin was healed. An angel coming down into the water and stirring it put healing power into them. It is unclear on what day and hour the angel came down.…
Fragments on John, §10 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:4 3 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Complete (3) All 3 passages
On John 5:2–4
The Sheep Gate was where sacrificial sheep gathered, and the pool's angel-stirred healing prefigured baptism.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
It was called "Sheep Gate" because there the sheep to be slaughtered for the feast were gathered and their entrails were washed there.
[John 5:4] Here the mystery of baptism was prefigured, in which every kind of sin was healed. An angel coming down into the water and stirring it put healing power into them. It is unclear on what day and hour the angel came down.…
Fragments on John, §10 → read in full
The pool healed only when the angel stirred it, showing that baptismal water helps only when Christ comes to it.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
…so that they would not attribute everything to the waters, the waters did not heal before an angel stood over them and stirred them, so that they might learn that the waters of baptism do not benefit the soul by themselves before the angel of great counsel [Christ] , putting on a human body, comes to baptism.…
On “It Is Not Possible”, §1 → read in full
On John 5:4–6
The angel's rare healings picture the law's limited grace, and Jesus asks only to stir the man's desire.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
…This was a type of the legal worship given through angels to one nation only and at one time only—at the feast's end—that is, healing advancing at the last times and not continuing into what follows.
[John 5:6] He asks not as one ignorant, but rousing him to desire to be healed.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:5 2 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Complete (2) All 3 passages
On John 5:4–6
The angel's rare healings picture the law's limited grace, and Jesus asks only to stir the man's desire.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
…This was a type of the legal worship given through angels to one nation only and at one time only—at the feast's end—that is, healing advancing at the last times and not continuing into what follows.
[John 5:6] He asks not as one ignorant, but rousing him to desire to be healed.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
Healing in the thirty-eighth year, short of the forty years of punishment, shows the Lord sparing the full penalty by grace.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
The thirty-eighth year of the lying paralytic signifies a time of punishment already being fulfilled, that just as the people for forty years tested the judgments in the wilderness, and forty days the destruction fell, and the law punished the sinners for forty years, so the Lord, sparing the fullness of the punishment, heals the sick man in the thirty-eighth year, just as he also spared the legal punishments through grace, the cosmic time having been fulfilled.
Fragments on John, §3 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:6 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 1 passage
On John 5:6–8
Jesus humbly asked whether the man wanted healing in order to expose the cruelty of those who never helped him, then healed him without the water.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
See his lack of arrogance. He did not say, “Do you want me to heal you?” For he did not wish to speak boastfully or to proclaim himself before the miracles. The man says, “I do want it, but I have no man.” For where there is no friend, there is no man anywhere.
“This is also why I ask,” Jesus says, “not so that I may learn—for what sick person does not want to be made well?—but so that you may expose the cruelty of your good citizens, because they did not even give you a hand to throw you toward the spring, something even an enemy would have done if asked. Since until now you have had no man to put you into the pool, look: I, who for your sake became man, heal your suffering even without waters. Rise, take up your mat and go” (John 5:8).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
On John 5:4–6
The angel's rare healings picture the law's limited grace, and Jesus asks only to stir the man's desire.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
…This was a type of the legal worship given through angels to one nation only and at one time only—at the feast's end—that is, healing advancing at the last times and not continuing into what follows.
[John 5:6] He asks not as one ignorant, but rousing him to desire to be healed.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
On John 5:6–8
Jesus humbly asked whether the man wanted healing in order to expose the cruelty of those who never helped him, then healed him without the water.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
See his lack of arrogance. He did not say, “Do you want me to heal you?” For he did not wish to speak boastfully or to proclaim himself before the miracles. The man says, “I do want it, but I have no man.” For where there is no friend, there is no man anywhere.
“This is also why I ask,” Jesus says, “not so that I may learn—for what sick person does not want to be made well?—but so that you may expose the cruelty of your good citizens, because they did not even give you a hand to throw you toward the spring, something even an enemy would have done if asked. Since until now you have had no man to put you into the pool, look: I, who for your sake became man, heal your suffering even without waters. Rise, take up your mat and go” (John 5:8).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:7 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On John 5:6–8
Jesus humbly asked whether the man wanted healing in order to expose the cruelty of those who never helped him, then healed him without the water.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
See his lack of arrogance. He did not say, “Do you want me to heal you?” For he did not wish to speak boastfully or to proclaim himself before the miracles. The man says, “I do want it, but I have no man.” For where there is no friend, there is no man anywhere.
“This is also why I ask,” Jesus says, “not so that I may learn—for what sick person does not want to be made well?—but so that you may expose the cruelty of your good citizens, because they did not even give you a hand to throw you toward the spring, something even an enemy would have done if asked. Since until now you have had no man to put you into the pool, look: I, who for your sake became man, heal your suffering even without waters. Rise, take up your mat and go” (John 5:8).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
On John 5:6–8
Jesus humbly asked whether the man wanted healing in order to expose the cruelty of those who never helped him, then healed him without the water.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
See his lack of arrogance. He did not say, “Do you want me to heal you?” For he did not wish to speak boastfully or to proclaim himself before the miracles. The man says, “I do want it, but I have no man.” For where there is no friend, there is no man anywhere.
“This is also why I ask,” Jesus says, “not so that I may learn—for what sick person does not want to be made well?—but so that you may expose the cruelty of your good citizens, because they did not even give you a hand to throw you toward the spring, something even an enemy would have done if asked. Since until now you have had no man to put you into the pool, look: I, who for your sake became man, heal your suffering even without waters. Rise, take up your mat and go” (John 5:8).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:8 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (2) All 2 passages
On John 5:6–8
Jesus humbly asked whether the man wanted healing in order to expose the cruelty of those who never helped him, then healed him without the water.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
See his lack of arrogance. He did not say, “Do you want me to heal you?” For he did not wish to speak boastfully or to proclaim himself before the miracles. The man says, “I do want it, but I have no man.” For where there is no friend, there is no man anywhere.
“This is also why I ask,” Jesus says, “not so that I may learn—for what sick person does not want to be made well?—but so that you may expose the cruelty of your good citizens, because they did not even give you a hand to throw you toward the spring, something even an enemy would have done if asked. Since until now you have had no man to put you into the pool, look: I, who for your sake became man, heal your suffering even without waters. Rise, take up your mat and go” (John 5:8).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
On John 5:8–10
Jesus had the man carry his mat, as he had the leftover bread gathered, to make the miracle plain and beyond suspicion.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
He does not simply command him to carry the mat. What he did with the loaves, he does here as well. Just as there he commands the leftover pieces of bread to be carried, so here too, to make the miracle clear and to free the healing from Jewish suspicion, and to show that he is not some deceiver but a savior and the common physician of nature, he commands him to carry the mat. So the Jews said, “It is the Sabbath; it is not lawful for you to carry your mat” (John 5:10).…
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
On John 5:6–8
Jesus humbly asked whether the man wanted healing in order to expose the cruelty of those who never helped him, then healed him without the water.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
See his lack of arrogance. He did not say, “Do you want me to heal you?” For he did not wish to speak boastfully or to proclaim himself before the miracles. The man says, “I do want it, but I have no man.” For where there is no friend, there is no man anywhere.
“This is also why I ask,” Jesus says, “not so that I may learn—for what sick person does not want to be made well?—but so that you may expose the cruelty of your good citizens, because they did not even give you a hand to throw you toward the spring, something even an enemy would have done if asked. Since until now you have had no man to put you into the pool, look: I, who for your sake became man, heal your suffering even without waters. Rise, take up your mat and go” (John 5:8).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
On John 5:8–10
Jesus had the man carry his mat, as he had the leftover bread gathered, to make the miracle plain and beyond suspicion.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
He does not simply command him to carry the mat. What he did with the loaves, he does here as well. Just as there he commands the leftover pieces of bread to be carried, so here too, to make the miracle clear and to free the healing from Jewish suspicion, and to show that he is not some deceiver but a savior and the common physician of nature, he commands him to carry the mat. So the Jews said, “It is the Sabbath; it is not lawful for you to carry your mat” (John 5:10).…
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:9 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On John 5:8–10
Jesus had the man carry his mat, as he had the leftover bread gathered, to make the miracle plain and beyond suspicion.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
He does not simply command him to carry the mat. What he did with the loaves, he does here as well. Just as there he commands the leftover pieces of bread to be carried, so here too, to make the miracle clear and to free the healing from Jewish suspicion, and to show that he is not some deceiver but a savior and the common physician of nature, he commands him to carry the mat. So the Jews said, “It is the Sabbath; it is not lawful for you to carry your mat” (John 5:10).…
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
On John 5:8–10
Jesus had the man carry his mat, as he had the leftover bread gathered, to make the miracle plain and beyond suspicion.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
He does not simply command him to carry the mat. What he did with the loaves, he does here as well. Just as there he commands the leftover pieces of bread to be carried, so here too, to make the miracle clear and to free the healing from Jewish suspicion, and to show that he is not some deceiver but a savior and the common physician of nature, he commands him to carry the mat. So the Jews said, “It is the Sabbath; it is not lawful for you to carry your mat” (John 5:10).…
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:10 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 5:8–10
Jesus had the man carry his mat, as he had the leftover bread gathered, to make the miracle plain and beyond suspicion.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
He does not simply command him to carry the mat. What he did with the loaves, he does here as well. Just as there he commands the leftover pieces of bread to be carried, so here too, to make the miracle clear and to free the healing from Jewish suspicion, and to show that he is not some deceiver but a savior and the common physician of nature, he commands him to carry the mat. So the Jews said, “It is the Sabbath; it is not lawful for you to carry your mat” (John 5:10).…
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
On John 5:8–10
Jesus had the man carry his mat, as he had the leftover bread gathered, to make the miracle plain and beyond suspicion.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
He does not simply command him to carry the mat. What he did with the loaves, he does here as well. Just as there he commands the leftover pieces of bread to be carried, so here too, to make the miracle clear and to free the healing from Jewish suspicion, and to show that he is not some deceiver but a savior and the common physician of nature, he commands him to carry the mat. So the Jews said, “It is the Sabbath; it is not lawful for you to carry your mat” (John 5:10).…
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:11 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:14 2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:16 2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:17 3 comments from the Fathers, 10 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 10 passages
On John 5:17–18
Like his Father, who is bound by no law, Jesus works by his own authority, which the Jews took as a claim to equality with God.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
What then does Christ do? He brings forward the Father, saying, “My Father is working until now, and I am working” (John 5:17). For just as, he says, my Father is not subject to boundaries, does not serve laws, and does not wait for commands, but by his own judgment does whatever he wills, so I also work all things with authoritative authority, equally with the Father. But for this reason they sought all the more to kill him, because he not only broke the Sabbath but also called God his own Father, making himself equal to God (John 5:18).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
Since God rested from creating, the Father's "working until now" means his providence, not new creation.
— Nemesius of Emesa, fl. c. 390 AD
…Moses says God rested from all his works which he had begun to make (Genesis 2:2). Keep creating souls today and that rest is emptied.… When it is said 'My Father is working still' (John 5:17), the sense is providence, not minting new soul-essences.
On the Nature of Man, §3.1 → read in full
On John 5:17–18
Jesus calls God his own Father and works as he does, and "Son" means the Father's equal, against those who deny it.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
"My Father," he says, "is mine alone and no one else's"; so by what with which he holds creation together—the sun and heavens, and causes bodies to grow, he works.
[John 5:18] The one equal to the Father is especially called Son as consubstantial [of one nature] . Therefore the lawless Arians are laughable who deny that the Son is equal to the Father.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
On John 5:17–18
Like his Father, who is bound by no law, Jesus works by his own authority, which the Jews took as a claim to equality with God.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
What then does Christ do? He brings forward the Father, saying, “My Father is working until now, and I am working” (John 5:17). For just as, he says, my Father is not subject to boundaries, does not serve laws, and does not wait for commands, but by his own judgment does whatever he wills, so I also work all things with authoritative authority, equally with the Father. But for this reason they sought all the more to kill him, because he not only broke the Sabbath but also called God his own Father, making himself equal to God (John 5:18).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
10 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Methodius of Olympus d. c. 311 AD · Banquet of the Ten Virgins Discourse 2 This is obvious to everyone: God is still at work on the world, just as the Lord taught when he said, 'My Father is still working'. Marcellus of Ancyra c. 280–c. 374 AD · Fragments §2 Concerning which the Savior says, 'my Father is working until now, and I am working', and again he says, 'the work,' 'I have finished what you gave me to do' (John 17:4). Apollinaris of Laodicea c. 310–c. 390 AD · Fragments on the Psalms §22 It is clear that "stretching out" and "roofing" and "making" stand for "having stretched out" and "having roofed" and "having made." So also "forming the spirit of a human being within him": since the formation by God happened once for… Nemesius of Emesa fl. c. 390 AD · On the Nature of Man §3.1 When it is said 'My Father is working still', the sense is providence, not minting new soul-essences. Amphilochius of Iconium c. 340–c. 395 AD · On “It Is Not Possible” §2 He brings forward the Father, saying, “My Father is working until now, and I am working”. Amphilochius of Iconium c. 340–c. 395 AD · On “It Is Not Possible” §3 Since they accuse me about the breaking of the Sabbath, I said, ‘My Father is working until now, and I am working’, wanting to show equal honor from both sides. Ammonius of Alexandria fl. 5th century AD · Fragments on John §11 [John 5:17 ] "My Father," he says, "is mine alone and no one else's"; so by what with which he holds creation together—the sun and heavens, and causes bodies to grow, he works. Procopius of Gaza c. 465/475–c. 528 AD · Refutation of Proclus §4 In its particular aspect, however, it is still being worked, as was said by the Savior: "My Father is working until now, and I am working". Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.23.1 He is called Person in the same signification as the Father, because He is a subsistence, individual, incommunicable — John 1 — of living nature — John 5 — understanding — John 1:18 — willing — Matthew 11:27; John 5:21 — powerful —… Louis Le Blanc de Beaulieu 1614–1675 AD · Theological Theses §1898 They also cite Christ's words in John 5:17 : 'My Father is working until now, and I am working.' The unceasing work ascribed to God there, they argue, is best explained as the continual influence by which God concurs in every action of… Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:18 2 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 4 passages
On John 5:17–18
Like his Father, who is bound by no law, Jesus works by his own authority, which the Jews took as a claim to equality with God.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
What then does Christ do? He brings forward the Father, saying, “My Father is working until now, and I am working” (John 5:17). For just as, he says, my Father is not subject to boundaries, does not serve laws, and does not wait for commands, but by his own judgment does whatever he wills, so I also work all things with authoritative authority, equally with the Father. But for this reason they sought all the more to kill him, because he not only broke the Sabbath but also called God his own Father, making himself equal to God (John 5:18).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
On John 5:17–18
Jesus calls God his own Father and works as he does, and "Son" means the Father's equal, against those who deny it.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
"My Father," he says, "is mine alone and no one else's"; so by what with which he holds creation together—the sun and heavens, and causes bodies to grow, he works.
[John 5:18] The one equal to the Father is especially called Son as consubstantial [of one nature] . Therefore the lawless Arians are laughable who deny that the Son is equal to the Father.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
On John 5:17–18
Like his Father, who is bound by no law, Jesus works by his own authority, which the Jews took as a claim to equality with God.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
What then does Christ do? He brings forward the Father, saying, “My Father is working until now, and I am working” (John 5:17). For just as, he says, my Father is not subject to boundaries, does not serve laws, and does not wait for commands, but by his own judgment does whatever he wills, so I also work all things with authoritative authority, equally with the Father. But for this reason they sought all the more to kill him, because he not only broke the Sabbath but also called God his own Father, making himself equal to God (John 5:18).
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:19 3 comments from the Fathers, 11 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 11 passages
"Cannot do anything of himself" means not weakness but unity: the Son has one nature and will with the Father and never acts apart from him.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
Jesus answers: “To weaken the madness of the Jews who think I am legislating against the Father. Since they accuse me about the breaking of the Sabbath, I said, ‘My Father is working until now, and I am working’ (John 5:17), wanting to show equal honor from both sides. But those utterly foolish people thought I was building works against works and introducing one opinion against another, and they were stirred to envy. So to correct their opinion I said, ‘The Son cannot do anything of himself unless he sees the Father doing it’ (John 5:19).
What I meant was this: ‘Why are you so angry with me, you ill-timed examiners of the Sabbath, because I break the Sabbath? I am not opposing the Father. It is not that he wants to establish the Sabbath and I to dissolve it. I am not fighting against him; I am not rebelling against his will. He does not will one thing while I wish something different. What he wills, I will; what he wishes, I wish; what he does, I do.’ For in this way I do nothing and will nothing outside of him.…
I do not have an opinion separated and cut off from the Father. Since the nature is one and the will is one, the result must also be one. So the Son cannot do anything of himself, because he cannot do anything without the Father, having the Father whole within himself: ‘I am in the Father and the Father is in me’ (John 14:10). If the works of soul and body are indistinguishable because of their union—even though their nature is divided, the body being one thing, mortal, and the soul another, immortal—how can my works and the Father’s be distinguished? Where counsel and word and knowledge and wisdom and nature and divinity are one, the Son cannot do anything of himself because he is not separated from the Father, unless he sees the Father doing it—that is, unless he sees the Father willing it.…
On “It Is Not Possible”, §3 → read in full
"Cannot do anything of himself" means not weakness but unity: the Son has one nature and will with the Father and never acts apart from him.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
Jesus answers: “To weaken the madness of the Jews who think I am legislating against the Father. Since they accuse me about the breaking of the Sabbath, I said, ‘My Father is working until now, and I am working’ (John 5:17), wanting to show equal honor from both sides. But those utterly foolish people thought I was building works against works and introducing one opinion against another, and they were stirred to envy. So to correct their opinion I said, ‘The Son cannot do anything of himself unless he sees the Father doing it’ (John 5:19).
What I meant was this: ‘Why are you so angry with me, you ill-timed examiners of the Sabbath, because I break the Sabbath? I am not opposing the Father. It is not that he wants to establish the Sabbath and I to dissolve it. I am not fighting against him; I am not rebelling against his will. He does not will one thing while I wish something different. What he wills, I will; what he wishes, I wish; what he does, I do.’ For in this way I do nothing and will nothing outside of him.…
I do not have an opinion separated and cut off from the Father. Since the nature is one and the will is one, the result must also be one. So the Son cannot do anything of himself, because he cannot do anything without the Father, having the Father whole within himself: ‘I am in the Father and the Father is in me’ (John 14:10). If the works of soul and body are indistinguishable because of their union—even though their nature is divided, the body being one thing, mortal, and the soul another, immortal—how can my works and the Father’s be distinguished? Where counsel and word and knowledge and wisdom and nature and divinity are one, the Son cannot do anything of himself because he is not separated from the Father, unless he sees the Father doing it—that is, unless he sees the Father willing it.…
On “It Is Not Possible”, §3 → read in full
"Likewise" does not mean the Son copies the Father's works, or there would be two worlds; they do the very same works.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
…“Amen, I say to you, the Son cannot do anything of himself unless he sees the Father doing it. For whatever that one does, these things the Son also does in the same way” (John 5:19). Not because he creates some things and I, by imitation, produce other things. For if that were so, there would have to be two heavens, two suns, two seas, two races of human beings, and a double world—one belonging to the Father, the other to me. For it would be necessary that, just as with painters the lines are prescribed and with teachers the letters of the alphabet, so the Father’s creation was prescribed, and I produced mine by imitation.
On “It Is Not Possible”, §2 → read in full
Father and Son share one activity, so whatever the Father does the Son does at the same moment, not as a copy.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Regarding what is said by Jesus: whatever he does (and it is clear that it is the Father) , the Son likewise does, which refers to what has paradoxically happened through him in the Gospels, overseeing how the Father did these things. To what must be said: since the Son, being consubstantial [of one nature] with the Father, has an inseparable energy of the Father's energy, being an unquenchable mirror, whatever the Father does, the Son also acts inseparably at once, and whatever the Son works, the Father immediately leads to existence, so as not to make the Son without the Father or the Father without the Son do anything.
This view must also be applied to the created things; for it is not that the Son is of a different essence when the Father creates other things. For this would follow that there are two suns and each of the existing things is double, but the creatures do not appear to be so. Therefore, the first thing is seen as the same in the energy of the Father and the Son in the things being created.
Fragments on John, §1 → read in full
11 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Novatian fl. c. 250 AD · On the Trinity 28 The Son is the image of God the Father (John 14:9; Colossians 1:15), so that, just as the Father works, so also the Son works, and the Son imitates all the Father's works. Athanasius of Alexandria c. 293/298–373 AD · Synodal Letter to the Bishops of Africa §6 So let those who put forward Ariminum answer this: can a created substance say, 'Whatever I see the Father doing, these things I also do'? Amphilochius of Iconium c. 340–c. 395 AD · On “It Is Not Possible” §1 “The Son can do nothing of himself” —how do you understand this? Amphilochius of Iconium c. 340–c. 395 AD · On “It Is Not Possible” §2 For whatever that one does, these things the Son also does in the same way”. Amphilochius of Iconium c. 340–c. 395 AD · On “It Is Not Possible” §3 So to correct their opinion I said, ‘The Son cannot do anything of himself unless he sees the Father doing it’. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §5 If it is true, as indeed it is true, that “whatever the Father does, the Son also does likewise”, then the Son too will make another son, so that he may do all things just as the Father does. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §14 For it is written: “Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God” (1 Corinthians 1:24), and “Whatever the Father does, the Son also does likewise”. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §38 For none of the things just mentioned belongs to any created power, but to the uncreated alone: to create substance, both irrational and rational, out of what is not; to give life; to forgive sins (Mark 2:10); to call creation his own; to… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §50 And as the Only-begotten is shown to be equal in power with the Father, like him, and sovereign, according to the words, “Whatever the Father does, these things the Son also does likewise”, so too is the Spirit of God, according to the… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Fragments on John §1 Regarding what is said by Jesus: whatever he does (and it is clear that it is the Father) [John 5:19 ], the Son likewise does, which refers to what has paradoxically happened through him in the Gospels, overseeing how the Father did… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On Genesis §8 Therefore, if we hear God say and it happened thus, understanding the Son as the one hearing and fulfilling the will, we do not grasp it visually, but rather so that we may have a union with the Father and the Son through these words,… Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:20 2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:21 1 comment from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Complete (1) All 3 passages
For the dead, being raised and being made alive are one thing.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
If it is said of a dead person that they are raised and made alive, the words differ alone; for making a dead person alive and raising them is the same…
Fragments on John, §1 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:22 7 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §34 Because of it, too, it is written: “For the Father judges no one, but has given all judgment to the Son”. Evagrius Ponticus c. 345–399 AD · Notes on Proverbs §20 How then does the Savior say in the Gospels: 'The Father judges no one, but has given all judgment to the Son'? Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 13 §20 Christ himself has cried out to us plainly, saying: ‘For the Father judges no one, but has given all judgment to the Son, so that all may honor the Son just as they honor the Father.’ Again, this saying, spoken through the voice of a… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 1 §21 'For the Father judges no one,' according to the Savior's own voice, 'but he has given all the judgment to the Son'; the Holy Spirit, clearly, being with him and existing in him by nature also. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on the Song of Songs §12 The companions listen, and they do not judge; rather, the Son does all the judging. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §2.13.3 To him is given all judgment, all power (Matt. John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · The Great Assize §10 John 5:22, 27 .Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:23 2 comments from the Fathers, 9 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 9 passages
The Father delights when the Son is honored as God and accepts no honor that dishonors the Son.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
And he does all things for this reason: so that all may honor the Son just as they honor the Father (John 5:23). For the Father most of all delights in honor when he sees the Son who comes from him honored in a way worthy of God. The one who does not honor the Son does not honor the Father who sent him, for the Father does not accept honor at the cost of the Son’s dishonor.
On “It Is Not Possible”, §4 → read in full
The Father delights when the Son is honored as God and accepts no honor that dishonors the Son.
— Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 340–c. 395 AD
And he does all things for this reason: so that all may honor the Son just as they honor the Father (John 5:23). For the Father most of all delights in honor when he sees the Son who comes from him honored in a way worthy of God. The one who does not honor the Son does not honor the Father who sent him, for the Father does not accept honor at the cost of the Son’s dishonor.
On “It Is Not Possible”, §4 → read in full
We honor the Son, and so the Father, by living by his word.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Just as the one transgressing the law dishonors God through transgressing, but the one keeping it honors the giver, so the one honoring the Son by doing according to the law and the right word will honor the Father likewise (John 5:23).
Fragments on John, §2 → read in full
9 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Homilies on Jeremiah §5.8 If we want to put away the veil that comes from dishonor, let us arrive at works of honor and understand what the Savior said: 'That all may honor the Son as they honor the Father,' and what the apostle said: 'Through the transgression of… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book VIII §9 But if he turns a similar objection back on us concerning Jesus, we will show that it was from God that the right to be honoured was granted to Him: “that all may honour the Son, just as they honour the Father”. Amphilochius of Iconium c. 340–c. 395 AD · On “It Is Not Possible” §4 And he does all things for this reason: so that all may honor the Son just as they honor the Father. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §14 And it is the Father’s will, according to John, “that all should honour the Son just as they honour the Father”. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §23 … “And I will not give my glory to another” (Isaiah 42:8); while John says, “that all may honour the Son just as they honour the Father”. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §28 For he was not ignorant, as these men are, of “All that the Father has is mine” (John 16:15), and “that all may honor the Son just as they honor the Father”, and “This is the true God and eternal life” (1 John 5:20), and “This is our God;… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On the Trinity §39 And they do injury both to the will of the Father, who says, “My glory I will not give to another” (Isaiah 42:8), meaning to one of another nature, and who wills that the Son be honoured as he is, and to the tradition handed down by the… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Fragments on John §2 It signifies the taking of life, but the living one does not take it; for he possesses it, unless it is signified by something else, for the name of life has multiple meanings. Hesychius of Jerusalem fl. c. 412–450 AD · On Saint Luke §2 It is written, 'Do not grieve the Holy Spirit' (Ephesians 4:30), and also, 'He who does not honor the Son does not honor the Father', which are principles that guided Luke's ministry. Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:24 2 comments from the Fathers, 8 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 8 passages
On John 5:24–25
The "dead" who hear are unbelievers raised by faith, and some escape judgment altogether, going straight either to life or to punishment.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
The dead are those once unbelieving and through faith in Christ called into life. Even if other rational animals received life, they cannot also give life.
[John 5:24] Those who do not come into judgment are either sent into Gehenna's fire as godless and impious, or into enjoyment of unspeakable goods—that is, true life; for this is to pass from death to life, freed from Gehenna and counted worthy of divine honors. Those who lived in the middle stand "on the right" and "on the left" (Matthew 25:33).
Before the passion and resurrection, and apart from being baptized, those who received Christ's word and believed that he was the Father's Son were saved.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
Justification in Christ washes away every stain, so the believer escapes judgment because no charge is left against him.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…justification in Christ is by no means partial; it is rather a complete washing away of whatever tends to stain us. Therefore he also said: ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes in me has eternal life, and does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life’ (John 5:24). If, then, the one who through Christ has justification by faith conferred on him has escaped being judged, we are bound to say that he has escaped the charges; and no kind of accusation, I say, could prevail against such a person. For ‘it is God who justifies; who is he that condemns?’ (Romans 8:33–34).
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 15, §15 → read in full
On John 5:24–25
The "dead" who hear are unbelievers raised by faith, and some escape judgment altogether, going straight either to life or to punishment.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
The dead are those once unbelieving and through faith in Christ called into life. Even if other rational animals received life, they cannot also give life.
[John 5:24] Those who do not come into judgment are either sent into Gehenna's fire as godless and impious, or into enjoyment of unspeakable goods—that is, true life; for this is to pass from death to life, freed from Gehenna and counted worthy of divine honors. Those who lived in the middle stand "on the right" and "on the left" (Matthew 25:33).
Before the passion and resurrection, and apart from being baptized, those who received Christ's word and believed that he was the Father's Son were saved.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
8 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Clement of Alexandria c. 150–c. 215 AD · The Instructor 6 As the Scripture says, 'What has come into being in him is life'. Clement of Alexandria c. 150–c. 215 AD · The Instructor 1.6 John 5:24 Thus believing alone, and regeneration, is perfection in life; for God is never weak.Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Fragments on the Psalms §256 For the Savior says, 'The one hearing my words and believing in the one who sent me has eternal life'. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 15 §15 Therefore he also said: ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes in me has eternal life, and does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life’. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 17 §8 For you have heard him say: ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life (John 6:54), and does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life; but whoever does not believe will not see… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On the True Faith, to the Princesses Arcadia and Marina §98 “Amen, amen, I say to you that the one who hears my word and believes the one who sent me has eternal life.” God and Father has sent us his own Son from the heavens, “that everyone who believes into him may not perish but may have eternal… Ammonius of Alexandria fl. 5th century AD · Fragments on John §11 [John 5:24 ] Those who do not come into judgment are either sent into Gehenna's fire as godless and impious, or into enjoyment of unspeakable goods—that is, true life; for this is to pass from death to life, freed from Gehenna and… Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.1.14 This life, one and the same as to essence, remains from its beginning unto eternity (John 3:36; 1 John 3:15). Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:25 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On John 5:24–25
The "dead" who hear are unbelievers raised by faith, and some escape judgment altogether, going straight either to life or to punishment.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
The dead are those once unbelieving and through faith in Christ called into life. Even if other rational animals received life, they cannot also give life.
[John 5:24] Those who do not come into judgment are either sent into Gehenna's fire as godless and impious, or into enjoyment of unspeakable goods—that is, true life; for this is to pass from death to life, freed from Gehenna and counted worthy of divine honors. Those who lived in the middle stand "on the right" and "on the left" (Matthew 25:33).
Before the passion and resurrection, and apart from being baptized, those who received Christ's word and believed that he was the Father's Son were saved.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
On John 5:24–25
The "dead" who hear are unbelievers raised by faith, and some escape judgment altogether, going straight either to life or to punishment.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
The dead are those once unbelieving and through faith in Christ called into life. Even if other rational animals received life, they cannot also give life.
[John 5:24] Those who do not come into judgment are either sent into Gehenna's fire as godless and impious, or into enjoyment of unspeakable goods—that is, true life; for this is to pass from death to life, freed from Gehenna and counted worthy of divine honors. Those who lived in the middle stand "on the right" and "on the left" (Matthew 25:33).
Before the passion and resurrection, and apart from being baptized, those who received Christ's word and believed that he was the Father's Son were saved.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:26 1 comment from the Fathers, 6 passages citing this verse
Complete (1) All 6 passages
On John 5:26–27
The Son "receives" life and judgment as man: his body, united to the living Word, became life-giving.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
And together with judging he also receives the life, although he is judge as God. And what the manner of the receiving would be, he himself will teach, saying: “Because he is Son of Man.” (John 5:26–27) For it is not proper to a human to be able to have the life from himself; but since the body united to him has become own to the living Word, for this reason also, very reasonably, as having its life-giving energy, he is said to receive the life; and he himself again appropriates the matter, whose own the receiving body has also become.
On the True Faith, to the Empresses Pulcheria and Eudocia, §46 → read in full
6 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Marcellus of Ancyra c. 280–c. 374 AD · On the Incarnation and against the Arians §1 They bring forward, saying: How can he be like the Father, or from the Father's being, when it is written, "Just as the Father has life in himself, so he has granted the Son also to have life in himself"? Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 11 §10 But as one who is given life in respect of his humanity, he says, ‘For just as the Father has life in himself, so he has granted the Son also to have life in himself’. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On the True Faith, to the Empresses Pulcheria and Eudocia §46 And what the manner of the receiving would be, he himself will teach, saying: “Because he is Son of Man.” For it is not proper to a human to be able to have the life from himself; but since the body united to him has become own to the… Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.5.6 For this reason God in the Scriptures is everywhere called being and living (Revelation 1:8 and 4:8; Deuteronomy; Psalm 18:46; 84:3; Jeremiah 10:10; Ezekiel 33:11; Daniel 4:34; Matthew 16:16; John 5:26 and 6:57; Acts 14:15; Romans 9:26). Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.14.3 Therefore God lives — John 5:26 . Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.21.6 In the order of persons we set the begetter before the begotten in thought — Matthew 28:19; John 5:26-27 . Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:27 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 1 passage
On John 5:27–29
Jesus judges because he is Son of God, yet also as the man who shares our weakness, and all the dead, wherever their bodies lie, will rise.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Punctuate it thus, and not as some think who, after adding "and he gave him authority to execute judgment," then add "because he is Son of Man" (John 5:27). That is not right; for he is not judge because he is Son of Man, but because he is Son of God—and for that reason he is also judge.
He says "Do not marvel" (John 5:28) because to those who saw him he seemed a mere man, yet what was said was greater than a man and for God alone to do. He did not say that he is Son of God, but that he is Son of Man—this he had said above—so that they might understand him as both man and God. What he means is this: not only as God does he judge, but also as one who became man and was tried in all our diseases apart from sin, and as one who sympathizes with our weaknesses and forgives the rest.
Or he says this: if I raise Lazarus, do not marvel at my power from that; for I am going to raise all the dead; "all who are in the tombs" (John 5:28) means all who have died. Since bodies consumed by beasts or fire or otherwise are not laid in tombs, yet they rise; for there will be a resurrection of all humans, and these too will be numbered among those in the memorials; for those who do good and evil are not the bodies in the tombs. So nothing prevents receiving also bodies consumed by fire or otherwise.…
[John 5:29] Through both fear and honor, then, he urges the human being toward salvation. So faith alone is not enough to save unless one also has good works.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
On John 5:26–27
The Son "receives" life and judgment as man: his body, united to the living Word, became life-giving.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
And together with judging he also receives the life, although he is judge as God. And what the manner of the receiving would be, he himself will teach, saying: “Because he is Son of Man.” (John 5:26–27) For it is not proper to a human to be able to have the life from himself; but since the body united to him has become own to the living Word, for this reason also, very reasonably, as having its life-giving energy, he is said to receive the life; and he himself again appropriates the matter, whose own the receiving body has also become.
On the True Faith, to the Empresses Pulcheria and Eudocia, §46 → read in full
On John 5:27–29
Jesus judges because he is Son of God, yet also as the man who shares our weakness, and all the dead, wherever their bodies lie, will rise.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Punctuate it thus, and not as some think who, after adding "and he gave him authority to execute judgment," then add "because he is Son of Man" (John 5:27). That is not right; for he is not judge because he is Son of Man, but because he is Son of God—and for that reason he is also judge.
He says "Do not marvel" (John 5:28) because to those who saw him he seemed a mere man, yet what was said was greater than a man and for God alone to do. He did not say that he is Son of God, but that he is Son of Man—this he had said above—so that they might understand him as both man and God. What he means is this: not only as God does he judge, but also as one who became man and was tried in all our diseases apart from sin, and as one who sympathizes with our weaknesses and forgives the rest.
Or he says this: if I raise Lazarus, do not marvel at my power from that; for I am going to raise all the dead; "all who are in the tombs" (John 5:28) means all who have died. Since bodies consumed by beasts or fire or otherwise are not laid in tombs, yet they rise; for there will be a resurrection of all humans, and these too will be numbered among those in the memorials; for those who do good and evil are not the bodies in the tombs. So nothing prevents receiving also bodies consumed by fire or otherwise.…
[John 5:29] Through both fear and honor, then, he urges the human being toward salvation. So faith alone is not enough to save unless one also has good works.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:28 2 comments from the Fathers, 9 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 9 passages
On John 5:27–29
Jesus judges because he is Son of God, yet also as the man who shares our weakness, and all the dead, wherever their bodies lie, will rise.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Punctuate it thus, and not as some think who, after adding "and he gave him authority to execute judgment," then add "because he is Son of Man" (John 5:27). That is not right; for he is not judge because he is Son of Man, but because he is Son of God—and for that reason he is also judge.
He says "Do not marvel" (John 5:28) because to those who saw him he seemed a mere man, yet what was said was greater than a man and for God alone to do. He did not say that he is Son of God, but that he is Son of Man—this he had said above—so that they might understand him as both man and God. What he means is this: not only as God does he judge, but also as one who became man and was tried in all our diseases apart from sin, and as one who sympathizes with our weaknesses and forgives the rest.
Or he says this: if I raise Lazarus, do not marvel at my power from that; for I am going to raise all the dead; "all who are in the tombs" (John 5:28) means all who have died. Since bodies consumed by beasts or fire or otherwise are not laid in tombs, yet they rise; for there will be a resurrection of all humans, and these too will be numbered among those in the memorials; for those who do good and evil are not the bodies in the tombs. So nothing prevents receiving also bodies consumed by fire or otherwise.…
[John 5:29] Through both fear and honor, then, he urges the human being toward salvation. So faith alone is not enough to save unless one also has good works.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
On John 5:27–29
Jesus judges because he is Son of God, yet also as the man who shares our weakness, and all the dead, wherever their bodies lie, will rise.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Punctuate it thus, and not as some think who, after adding "and he gave him authority to execute judgment," then add "because he is Son of Man" (John 5:27). That is not right; for he is not judge because he is Son of Man, but because he is Son of God—and for that reason he is also judge.
He says "Do not marvel" (John 5:28) because to those who saw him he seemed a mere man, yet what was said was greater than a man and for God alone to do. He did not say that he is Son of God, but that he is Son of Man—this he had said above—so that they might understand him as both man and God. What he means is this: not only as God does he judge, but also as one who became man and was tried in all our diseases apart from sin, and as one who sympathizes with our weaknesses and forgives the rest.
Or he says this: if I raise Lazarus, do not marvel at my power from that; for I am going to raise all the dead; "all who are in the tombs" (John 5:28) means all who have died. Since bodies consumed by beasts or fire or otherwise are not laid in tombs, yet they rise; for there will be a resurrection of all humans, and these too will be numbered among those in the memorials; for those who do good and evil are not the bodies in the tombs. So nothing prevents receiving also bodies consumed by fire or otherwise.…
[John 5:29] Through both fear and honor, then, he urges the human being toward salvation. So faith alone is not enough to save unless one also has good works.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
On John 5:28–29
"All in the graves" means all the dead, even the unburied, and only believers who sinned face the "resurrection of judgment".
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
'All those in the tombs' (John 5:28) signifies 'all those having died'; for if he did not say this—those whose bodies have been consumed by beasts or fire and are not placed in tombs, they do not rise. But since there will be a resurrection of all men, these also shall be numbered among those in the tombs. If the disputants were to contend, they must be stopped by noting that those doing good and bad things are being judged, not the bodies placed in the tombs. Therefore the word will not prevent them from receiving the truth even if the bodies were consumed by fire or otherwise.
Of men divided according to the opinion into the ungodly, that is, the unbelieving, or the godly, that is, the believing (John 5:28–29), of all the same rising men, the unbelieving and ungodly indeed rise, but not unto judgment, since he who does not believe has already been judged. But those who have believed in the Savior and have also done good works, those who rise for a resurrection of life, shall not be judged among those being raised unto judgment who sinned after believing. As for the state of infants, since they also rise, God alone knows, perhaps even those to whom the revelation of this truth has come.
Fragments on John, §2 → read in full
9 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Apollinaris of Laodicea c. 310–c. 390 AD · Fragments on John §10 This is consistent with what he said himself, that 'the dead shall come forth at the voice' having heard 'the Son of God'. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Fragments on John §2 'All those in the tombs' signifies 'all those having died'; for if he did not say this—those whose bodies have been consumed by beasts or fire and are not placed in tombs, they do not rise. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Fragments on the Psalms §117 This is like that in the Gospel, 'All those in the tombs shall hear his voice', (meaning clearly the Son), and the ones having done good things shall go forth into a resurrection of life, but the ones having doing evil things into a… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 17 §30 What the force of the feast should be taken to be, he hinted by saying, ‘It shall be for you a day of signaling.’ For it signals to us the last trumpet, sounded by the angel’s voice, at which all the dead will rise (1 Corinthians 15:52),… Ammonius of Alexandria fl. 5th century AD · Fragments on John §11 He says "Do not marvel" because to those who saw him he seemed a mere man, yet what was said was greater than a man and for God alone to do. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §1.50 But everything we have named he will do for justice alone (compare Hebrews 12:26–27) (Hebrews 12:26–27; John 5:28–29). Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · Collective Letter to Thessalonica §4.2.2 What makes death good or bad is not the dissolution of bodies, which will be raised in every class of human beings (possible echo: John 5:28–29 ), but the difference in people’s deserts, which arises from human freedom. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §2.11.2 It is plainly brought forward at John 5:28 ; 6:39–40; 11:24; Luke 14:14; Acts 17:18 and 23:6 and 24:15; Phil. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §2.12.2 4:14); the Son (ch. Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:29 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 2 passages
On John 5:27–29
Jesus judges because he is Son of God, yet also as the man who shares our weakness, and all the dead, wherever their bodies lie, will rise.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Punctuate it thus, and not as some think who, after adding "and he gave him authority to execute judgment," then add "because he is Son of Man" (John 5:27). That is not right; for he is not judge because he is Son of Man, but because he is Son of God—and for that reason he is also judge.
He says "Do not marvel" (John 5:28) because to those who saw him he seemed a mere man, yet what was said was greater than a man and for God alone to do. He did not say that he is Son of God, but that he is Son of Man—this he had said above—so that they might understand him as both man and God. What he means is this: not only as God does he judge, but also as one who became man and was tried in all our diseases apart from sin, and as one who sympathizes with our weaknesses and forgives the rest.
Or he says this: if I raise Lazarus, do not marvel at my power from that; for I am going to raise all the dead; "all who are in the tombs" (John 5:28) means all who have died. Since bodies consumed by beasts or fire or otherwise are not laid in tombs, yet they rise; for there will be a resurrection of all humans, and these too will be numbered among those in the memorials; for those who do good and evil are not the bodies in the tombs. So nothing prevents receiving also bodies consumed by fire or otherwise.…
[John 5:29] Through both fear and honor, then, he urges the human being toward salvation. So faith alone is not enough to save unless one also has good works.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
On John 5:27–29
Jesus judges because he is Son of God, yet also as the man who shares our weakness, and all the dead, wherever their bodies lie, will rise.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Punctuate it thus, and not as some think who, after adding "and he gave him authority to execute judgment," then add "because he is Son of Man" (John 5:27). That is not right; for he is not judge because he is Son of Man, but because he is Son of God—and for that reason he is also judge.
He says "Do not marvel" (John 5:28) because to those who saw him he seemed a mere man, yet what was said was greater than a man and for God alone to do. He did not say that he is Son of God, but that he is Son of Man—this he had said above—so that they might understand him as both man and God. What he means is this: not only as God does he judge, but also as one who became man and was tried in all our diseases apart from sin, and as one who sympathizes with our weaknesses and forgives the rest.
Or he says this: if I raise Lazarus, do not marvel at my power from that; for I am going to raise all the dead; "all who are in the tombs" (John 5:28) means all who have died. Since bodies consumed by beasts or fire or otherwise are not laid in tombs, yet they rise; for there will be a resurrection of all humans, and these too will be numbered among those in the memorials; for those who do good and evil are not the bodies in the tombs. So nothing prevents receiving also bodies consumed by fire or otherwise.…
[John 5:29] Through both fear and honor, then, he urges the human being toward salvation. So faith alone is not enough to save unless one also has good works.
Fragments on John, §11 → read in full
On John 5:28–29
"All in the graves" means all the dead, even the unburied, and only believers who sinned face the "resurrection of judgment".
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
'All those in the tombs' (John 5:28) signifies 'all those having died'; for if he did not say this—those whose bodies have been consumed by beasts or fire and are not placed in tombs, they do not rise. But since there will be a resurrection of all men, these also shall be numbered among those in the tombs. If the disputants were to contend, they must be stopped by noting that those doing good and bad things are being judged, not the bodies placed in the tombs. Therefore the word will not prevent them from receiving the truth even if the bodies were consumed by fire or otherwise.
Of men divided according to the opinion into the ungodly, that is, the unbelieving, or the godly, that is, the believing (John 5:28–29), of all the same rising men, the unbelieving and ungodly indeed rise, but not unto judgment, since he who does not believe has already been judged. But those who have believed in the Savior and have also done good works, those who rise for a resurrection of life, shall not be judged among those being raised unto judgment who sinned after believing. As for the state of infants, since they also rise, God alone knows, perhaps even those to whom the revelation of this truth has come.
Fragments on John, §2 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:30 1 comment from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 3 passages
Father and Son share one will; Jesus speaks this way only as man.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
…in the Trinity there is not another will and another, but one; the Word puts on weakness. Yet it is not so in truth, since he is equal to the Father, even if as man "under the law" (Galatians 4:4) he speaks.
"I do not seek my own will" (John 5:30), as you Jews, teaching and doing everything lawlessly by your own will.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
Father and Son share one will; Jesus speaks this way only as man.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
…in the Trinity there is not another will and another, but one; the Word puts on weakness. Yet it is not so in truth, since he is equal to the Father, even if as man "under the law" (Galatians 4:4) he speaks.
"I do not seek my own will" (John 5:30), as you Jews, teaching and doing everything lawlessly by your own will.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:31 1 comment from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 4 passages
Jesus avoided speaking about himself and preferred to show by deeds that he was the Christ.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
…One may see this also in the character of Jesus, who everywhere avoided speaking about himself and for that reason said, “Even if I speak about myself, my testimony is not true” (John 5:31). And since he avoided speaking about himself, and wished to show that he was the Christ by his deeds rather than by his words, for this reason the Jews say to him, “If you are the Christ, tell us plainly” (John 10:24).
Against Celsus, Book I, §48 → read in full
Jesus avoided speaking about himself and preferred to show by deeds that he was the Christ.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
…One may see this also in the character of Jesus, who everywhere avoided speaking about himself and for that reason said, “Even if I speak about myself, my testimony is not true” (John 5:31). And since he avoided speaking about himself, and wished to show that he was the Christ by his deeds rather than by his words, for this reason the Jews say to him, “If you are the Christ, tell us plainly” (John 10:24).
Against Celsus, Book I, §48 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus One can also see from Jesus' character, which everywhere avoids self-assertion, and because of this he says, 'Even if I do bear witness about myself, my testimony is not true'. Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus 1.48 It is also evident from Jesus’ character, which everywhere avoids self-praise, and therefore he says, ‘Even if I testify about myself, my testimony is not true’. Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus 48 It is evident from Jesus' character everywhere that he avoided self-praise; for this reason he said, 'Even if I do bear witness about myself, my testimony is not true'. Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book I §48 One may see this also in the character of Jesus, who everywhere avoided speaking about himself and for that reason said, “Even if I speak about myself, my testimony is not true”. Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:32 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 5:32–34
Jesus cites John's witness yet refuses human witness, because John spoke what he learned from God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Having said that another is the one who bears witness about me, and I know that his witness is true, to show that he means John he added: "You have sent to John, and he has borne witness to the truth" (John 5:32–33). Then, silencing them from the surplus and still speaking to their suspicion—they were about to say, If you do not receive witness from a human, why bring John's witness forward?—he showed that John's witness was not a human's witness but God's; for learning from him he said what he said. Therefore he added: "I do not receive the witness from a human" (John 5:34).
John's witness is above suspicion; for he did not run to the witness self-called. He bore witness to the truth—that is, to me the Christ, who is truth.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:32–34
Jesus cites John's witness yet refuses human witness, because John spoke what he learned from God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Having said that another is the one who bears witness about me, and I know that his witness is true, to show that he means John he added: "You have sent to John, and he has borne witness to the truth" (John 5:32–33). Then, silencing them from the surplus and still speaking to their suspicion—they were about to say, If you do not receive witness from a human, why bring John's witness forward?—he showed that John's witness was not a human's witness but God's; for learning from him he said what he said. Therefore he added: "I do not receive the witness from a human" (John 5:34).
John's witness is above suspicion; for he did not run to the witness self-called. He bore witness to the truth—that is, to me the Christ, who is truth.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:33 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 5:32–34
Jesus cites John's witness yet refuses human witness, because John spoke what he learned from God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Having said that another is the one who bears witness about me, and I know that his witness is true, to show that he means John he added: "You have sent to John, and he has borne witness to the truth" (John 5:32–33). Then, silencing them from the surplus and still speaking to their suspicion—they were about to say, If you do not receive witness from a human, why bring John's witness forward?—he showed that John's witness was not a human's witness but God's; for learning from him he said what he said. Therefore he added: "I do not receive the witness from a human" (John 5:34).
John's witness is above suspicion; for he did not run to the witness self-called. He bore witness to the truth—that is, to me the Christ, who is truth.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:32–34
Jesus cites John's witness yet refuses human witness, because John spoke what he learned from God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Having said that another is the one who bears witness about me, and I know that his witness is true, to show that he means John he added: "You have sent to John, and he has borne witness to the truth" (John 5:32–33). Then, silencing them from the surplus and still speaking to their suspicion—they were about to say, If you do not receive witness from a human, why bring John's witness forward?—he showed that John's witness was not a human's witness but God's; for learning from him he said what he said. Therefore he added: "I do not receive the witness from a human" (John 5:34).
John's witness is above suspicion; for he did not run to the witness self-called. He bore witness to the truth—that is, to me the Christ, who is truth.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:34 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 5:32–34
Jesus cites John's witness yet refuses human witness, because John spoke what he learned from God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Having said that another is the one who bears witness about me, and I know that his witness is true, to show that he means John he added: "You have sent to John, and he has borne witness to the truth" (John 5:32–33). Then, silencing them from the surplus and still speaking to their suspicion—they were about to say, If you do not receive witness from a human, why bring John's witness forward?—he showed that John's witness was not a human's witness but God's; for learning from him he said what he said. Therefore he added: "I do not receive the witness from a human" (John 5:34).
John's witness is above suspicion; for he did not run to the witness self-called. He bore witness to the truth—that is, to me the Christ, who is truth.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:32–34
Jesus cites John's witness yet refuses human witness, because John spoke what he learned from God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Having said that another is the one who bears witness about me, and I know that his witness is true, to show that he means John he added: "You have sent to John, and he has borne witness to the truth" (John 5:32–33). Then, silencing them from the surplus and still speaking to their suspicion—they were about to say, If you do not receive witness from a human, why bring John's witness forward?—he showed that John's witness was not a human's witness but God's; for learning from him he said what he said. Therefore he added: "I do not receive the witness from a human" (John 5:34).
John's witness is above suspicion; for he did not run to the witness self-called. He bore witness to the truth—that is, to me the Christ, who is truth.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:35 2 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 4 passages
On John 5:35–36
John is a lamp, shining with borrowed light and no longer needed once the sun, Christ, has risen.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
John is a lamp beside Christ's way of life, who is a sun: John shines, yet is covered by the excess of the solar light's glory; so also sun and moon in the regeneration shine, yet are so mastered by the glory of the saints' light as to seem not to shine at all. He called John a lamp as not having light from himself but from the Spirit's grace, and because when the sun has risen the lamp's need is superfluous.
[John 5:36] By "gift" he means the Father's good pleasure and understanding, or he says this because of the form of humanity.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
John was the lamp foretold for Christ, and the Jews rejoiced in him only briefly before letting him be killed.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Or do you not know that for those under the law in Judea the inspired Baptist was a kind of lamp going before Christ, and that God the Father spoke of him beforehand: ‘I have prepared a lamp for my Christ’ (Psalm 132:17)? The Savior himself also bore witness to this, saying of him to the teachers of the Jews: ‘He was the lamp that burns and shines, and you were willing to rejoice for a while in his light’ (John 5:35).…
Yet the Jews took delight in John for a very short time, in that they ran to the baptism he gave and marveled greatly at him; then they put the ever-shining lamp to sleep in death, all but quenching it. For even if the crime may perhaps be called Herod’s (Matthew 14:10), still he was of Israel’s blood.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 10, §16 → read in full
On John 5:35–36
John is a lamp, shining with borrowed light and no longer needed once the sun, Christ, has risen.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
John is a lamp beside Christ's way of life, who is a sun: John shines, yet is covered by the excess of the solar light's glory; so also sun and moon in the regeneration shine, yet are so mastered by the glory of the saints' light as to seem not to shine at all. He called John a lamp as not having light from himself but from the Spirit's grace, and because when the sun has risen the lamp's need is superfluous.
[John 5:36] By "gift" he means the Father's good pleasure and understanding, or he says this because of the form of humanity.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:36 1 comment from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 3 passages
On John 5:35–36
John is a lamp, shining with borrowed light and no longer needed once the sun, Christ, has risen.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
John is a lamp beside Christ's way of life, who is a sun: John shines, yet is covered by the excess of the solar light's glory; so also sun and moon in the regeneration shine, yet are so mastered by the glory of the saints' light as to seem not to shine at all. He called John a lamp as not having light from himself but from the Spirit's grace, and because when the sun has risen the lamp's need is superfluous.
[John 5:36] By "gift" he means the Father's good pleasure and understanding, or he says this because of the form of humanity.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:35–36
John is a lamp, shining with borrowed light and no longer needed once the sun, Christ, has risen.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
John is a lamp beside Christ's way of life, who is a sun: John shines, yet is covered by the excess of the solar light's glory; so also sun and moon in the regeneration shine, yet are so mastered by the glory of the saints' light as to seem not to shine at all. He called John a lamp as not having light from himself but from the Spirit's grace, and because when the sun has risen the lamp's need is superfluous.
[John 5:36] By "gift" he means the Father's good pleasure and understanding, or he says this because of the form of humanity.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:37 2 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 4 passages
On John 5:37–38
The sights at Sinai were only shadows; the true sight of the Father is Christ, so those who reject him have never seen God.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…those visions [at Sinai] were shadows of the true sight of God, and that the true revelation is Christ, in whom we have seen the Father himself (John 14:9). Indeed, when the Jews supposed that on Mount Sinai they had truly seen the God of all things, he showed them how utterly foolish their thinking was, saying: ‘You have not heard his voice, nor seen his form, and you do not have his word abiding in you, because you do not believe the one whom he sent’ (John 5:37–38).
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 9, §5 → read in full
On John 5:37–38
Those who reject Christ, the Father's Word and true form, have neither heard the Father's voice nor seen his form.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
You believed neither the prophets nor the voice brought from above nor the wonder-working of the deeds; for it belongs to simpler knowledge to say that some have seen God. These are those who have neither seen the Father's form nor heard his voice—those who did not believe in Christ, who is the Father's Word and his true form.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:37–38
The sights at Sinai were only shadows; the true sight of the Father is Christ, so those who reject him have never seen God.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…those visions [at Sinai] were shadows of the true sight of God, and that the true revelation is Christ, in whom we have seen the Father himself (John 14:9). Indeed, when the Jews supposed that on Mount Sinai they had truly seen the God of all things, he showed them how utterly foolish their thinking was, saying: ‘You have not heard his voice, nor seen his form, and you do not have his word abiding in you, because you do not believe the one whom he sent’ (John 5:37–38).
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 9, §5 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Job §81 And again, to others not paying attention, He says: 'Neither His voice have you heard, nor His appearance have you seen', and interpreting how it proceeds: 'Nor do you have His word remaining in you,' which happened if they were listening… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Fragments on the Psalms §150 For even if he despises the voice, it is good to make clear through the one approaching me with my authority, that the timely evangelical word is not understood by the heterodox, who are interrupting these things, as seen in the Savior… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 2 §14 And to Jews thinking they have seen the Father, it was said wisely by Christ: ‘Neither have you seen his form, nor have you heard his voice.’ And to Philip inquiring very eagerly, and asking more thickly than was needful, yet from love of… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 9 §5 Indeed, when the Jews supposed that on Mount Sinai they had truly seen the God of all things, he showed them how utterly foolish their thinking was, saying: ‘You have not heard his voice, nor seen his form, and you do not have his word… Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:38 2 comments from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (2)
On John 5:37–38
The sights at Sinai were only shadows; the true sight of the Father is Christ, so those who reject him have never seen God.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…those visions [at Sinai] were shadows of the true sight of God, and that the true revelation is Christ, in whom we have seen the Father himself (John 14:9). Indeed, when the Jews supposed that on Mount Sinai they had truly seen the God of all things, he showed them how utterly foolish their thinking was, saying: ‘You have not heard his voice, nor seen his form, and you do not have his word abiding in you, because you do not believe the one whom he sent’ (John 5:37–38).
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 9, §5 → read in full
On John 5:37–38
Those who reject Christ, the Father's Word and true form, have neither heard the Father's voice nor seen his form.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
You believed neither the prophets nor the voice brought from above nor the wonder-working of the deeds; for it belongs to simpler knowledge to say that some have seen God. These are those who have neither seen the Father's form nor heard his voice—those who did not believe in Christ, who is the Father's Word and his true form.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:37–38
The sights at Sinai were only shadows; the true sight of the Father is Christ, so those who reject him have never seen God.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…those visions [at Sinai] were shadows of the true sight of God, and that the true revelation is Christ, in whom we have seen the Father himself (John 14:9). Indeed, when the Jews supposed that on Mount Sinai they had truly seen the God of all things, he showed them how utterly foolish their thinking was, saying: ‘You have not heard his voice, nor seen his form, and you do not have his word abiding in you, because you do not believe the one whom he sent’ (John 5:37–38).
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 9, §5 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:39 16 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · On Pascha §2.3 We have found the sacred and lawful scriptures not silent, but compelling us to the fulfillment of the commandments that were given, commandments now being completed in us, according to what was said: "Search the scriptures, in which you… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book III §33 They do this following the counsel of Jesus, who said, “Search the Scriptures”, and the wish of Paul, who taught that we must “know how to answer each one” as is fitting (Colossians 4:6), and of him also who said, “Always be ready to make… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book V §16 They are not able to set out clearly the sense of the passages, nor have they been willing to give their time to searching the Scripture, although Jesus says, “Search the Scriptures”; and so they have formed such notions about the fire… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book VI §7 But if some are careless, and do not train themselves to attend to the divine readings, to “search the Scriptures”, and, as Jesus commanded, to seek the meaning of the Scriptures, to ask God about them, and to knock at what is shut in… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book VI §37 Very few have trained themselves to understand them: those who, following the command of Jesus, have devoted their whole life to searching “the Scriptures”, and who have toiled over examining the meaning of the sacred writings more than… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Zechariah §143 Once one Lord being shown and His name being one around all the earth and even to the desert, the thought 'from Abel' took its beginning, which is taken as a testimony, concerning which the Savior taught in the Gospel, saying: 'Search the… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 2 §11 And you are not willing to come to me, that you may have eternal life.’ And after other things again, toward the leaders of the Jews, and toward all the people: ‘Do not think that I will accuse you toward the Father; the one accusing you… Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.2.17 See also Bellarmine, On the unwritten word of God, book 4, chapter 3; and Sadeel, Whitaker, and Nigrinus on the papistic contempt of sacred Scripture — indeed Christ himself (John 17) and Paul (2 Timothy 3:15-2 Timothy 3:16). Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.4.15 Testimony: sacred letters (John 5:46; Luke 24:46; Acts 10:43); John the Baptist (John 1:7); God's voice from heaven (Matthew 3:17; Matthew 17:5; 2 Peter 1:16); miracles (John 5:36; John 10:25); resurrection (Romans 1:4); ascension (Luke… Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.5.14 Fifth, from the judgment of Christ, who for this cause exhorts the Jews to search the Scriptures — or at least approves that they set their study in searching them — because in them He presents Himself wholly to be known, and brands… Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.6.4 From Christ's precept: why would he bid us search the Scriptures if they could not be understood? Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.6.5 That he did not is absurd, and it cries out against sacred Scripture's sayings and aim (Romans 15:4; 2 Timothy 3:15; 2 Peter 1:19). Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.6.9 This is shown from John 5:39 and Psalm 19:12. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.7.4 8:20; 34:16; Luke 16:29–31; John 5:39 ); (2) its unique orthodoxy and truth, Jesus Christ, God already incarnate (Heb. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.9.5 For both the name "canon" by which Scripture is marked (Psalm 19:5; Galatians 6:16) and the thing itself teach this (Psalm 19:8; 2 Timothy 3:15-2 Timothy 3:16; James 1:21; John 20:31; 1 Corinthians 4:6; Galatians 1:8). John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · The Means of Grace §24 John 5:39 .Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:40 1 comment from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 3 passages
On John 5:40–42
Christ does not force belief, needs no human glory, and shows that their zeal against him did not come from love of God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even if Christ wants the Jews persuaded by his teaching, he does not force free will.
As one who needs nothing, I have from myself the fullest glory and do not want human glory, but I have known you, that you do not have the love of God in yourselves (John 5:41–42). He said "I have known you…" showing that they did not persecute him from love of God, even if they pretended so.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:40–42
Christ does not force belief, needs no human glory, and shows that their zeal against him did not come from love of God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even if Christ wants the Jews persuaded by his teaching, he does not force free will.
As one who needs nothing, I have from myself the fullest glory and do not want human glory, but I have known you, that you do not have the love of God in yourselves (John 5:41–42). He said "I have known you…" showing that they did not persecute him from love of God, even if they pretended so.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:41 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 5:40–42
Christ does not force belief, needs no human glory, and shows that their zeal against him did not come from love of God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even if Christ wants the Jews persuaded by his teaching, he does not force free will.
As one who needs nothing, I have from myself the fullest glory and do not want human glory, but I have known you, that you do not have the love of God in yourselves (John 5:41–42). He said "I have known you…" showing that they did not persecute him from love of God, even if they pretended so.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:40–42
Christ does not force belief, needs no human glory, and shows that their zeal against him did not come from love of God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even if Christ wants the Jews persuaded by his teaching, he does not force free will.
As one who needs nothing, I have from myself the fullest glory and do not want human glory, but I have known you, that you do not have the love of God in yourselves (John 5:41–42). He said "I have known you…" showing that they did not persecute him from love of God, even if they pretended so.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:42 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 5:40–42
Christ does not force belief, needs no human glory, and shows that their zeal against him did not come from love of God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even if Christ wants the Jews persuaded by his teaching, he does not force free will.
As one who needs nothing, I have from myself the fullest glory and do not want human glory, but I have known you, that you do not have the love of God in yourselves (John 5:41–42). He said "I have known you…" showing that they did not persecute him from love of God, even if they pretended so.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:40–42
Christ does not force belief, needs no human glory, and shows that their zeal against him did not come from love of God.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even if Christ wants the Jews persuaded by his teaching, he does not force free will.
As one who needs nothing, I have from myself the fullest glory and do not want human glory, but I have known you, that you do not have the love of God in yourselves (John 5:41–42). He said "I have known you…" showing that they did not persecute him from love of God, even if they pretended so.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:43 2 comments from the Fathers, 6 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 6 passages
On John 5:43–45
The one who will come in his own name is the antichrist, and Moses accuses them through his own writings.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even though he knows they are not persuaded and do not receive him, as God he does his own part, convicting and admonishing them. The antichrist promises the glory of this life, and for that reason you believe him.
[John 5:45] A written accusation against you lies in the Mosaic books; Moses, disbelieved by you, will accuse you.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
Christ came for the Father's glory, the coming son of lawlessness will take the divine name for himself, and those who let go the law's promise of a Christ from Israel will receive that stranger.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
…‘I have come in the name of my Father, and you do not receive me. If another should come in his own name, that one you will receive.’ (John 5:43) For Christ has visited unto glory of God the Father. And the son of lawlessness will come according to times, not unto glory of God the Father—for this I think is the, In the name of the Father—but setting around his own head, the wretched one, the name of the divinity. ‘For he will sit into the house of God showing himself, that he is God.’ (2 Thessalonians 2:4)
But Jews would not worship him, nor would they ever receive him as Christ while keeping the law; for that Christ would spring up from blood of Israel, it has clearly pre-announced. But they, having also let this go as stale, will receive an alien and other-born human.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 8, §23 → read in full
On John 5:43–45
The one who will come in his own name is the antichrist, and Moses accuses them through his own writings.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even though he knows they are not persuaded and do not receive him, as God he does his own part, convicting and admonishing them. The antichrist promises the glory of this life, and for that reason you believe him.
[John 5:45] A written accusation against you lies in the Mosaic books; Moses, disbelieved by you, will accuse you.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
6 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 8 §23 If another should come in his own name, that one you will receive.’ For Christ has visited unto glory of God the Father. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 9 §31 For we will accept no other at all besides him, as the wretched Jews indeed will: they will accept the son of lawlessness (2 Thessalonians 2:3). Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §39 For He Himself said this: ‘I have come in My Father’s name, and you do not receive Me; if another comes in his own name, him you will receive’. Ammonius of Alexandria fl. 5th century AD · Fragments on John §12 [John 5:43 ] Even though he knows they are not persuaded and do not receive him, as God he does his own part, convicting and admonishing them. Julian of Eclanum c. 386–c. 455 AD · To Florus §1.93 If another comes in his own name, you will receive him”. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.6.3 Fourth, the will and commandment of God (Deuteronomy 18:19; 1 Samuel 17:45; Luke 24:47). Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:44 3 comments from the Fathers, 7 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (3) All 7 passages
On John 5:43–45
The one who will come in his own name is the antichrist, and Moses accuses them through his own writings.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even though he knows they are not persuaded and do not receive him, as God he does his own part, convicting and admonishing them. The antichrist promises the glory of this life, and for that reason you believe him.
[John 5:45] A written accusation against you lies in the Mosaic books; Moses, disbelieved by you, will accuse you.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
Rulers and people trade honor with each other, and that mutual flattery keeps them from faith.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
He says this, reproving the minds and stating the cause of unbelief: for the rulers pursue the approval from the people, but the people love the honor from the rulers, and so you stand away from the faith toward me; the rulers do this so that the glory in you might not be diminished, and you do this so that you might not lose the honor from them.
Fragments on John, §4 → read in full
On John 5:43–45
The one who will come in his own name is the antichrist, and Moses accuses them through his own writings.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even though he knows they are not persuaded and do not receive him, as God he does his own part, convicting and admonishing them. The antichrist promises the glory of this life, and for that reason you believe him.
[John 5:45] A written accusation against you lies in the Mosaic books; Moses, disbelieved by you, will accuse you.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
Love of human praise destroys faith, so we must despise it and seek only the glory that comes from God.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
In many places, then, our Savior is seen pressing against ambition as a passion that destroys… But we must remember the 'How can you believe, who receive glory from men, and seek not the glory that comes from the only God?' (John 5:44) — and despise all glory from men, even if it is thought to come of the good — and seek the sovereign and true glory, the glory from the only God, who becomingly glorifies, beyond the worth of the glorified, the one worthy of glory.
On Prayer, §19 → read in full
Rulers and people trade honor with each other, and that mutual flattery keeps them from faith.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
He says this, reproving the minds and stating the cause of unbelief: for the rulers pursue the approval from the people, but the people love the honor from the rulers, and so you stand away from the faith toward me; the rulers do this so that the glory in you might not be diminished, and you do this so that you might not lose the honor from them.
Fragments on John, §4 → read in full
7 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · On Prayer §19 But we must remember the 'How can you believe, who receive glory from men, and seek not the glory that comes from the only God?' — and despise all glory from men, even if it is thought to come of the good — and seek the sovereign and true… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · On Prayer §29 And how is the 'How can you believe, receiving glory from one another, and seeking not the glory that comes from the only God?' not rebuking? Apollinaris of Laodicea c. 310–c. 390 AD · Fragments on John §3 22 John 5:44 [John 5:44] Then, because he says, 'You seek the glory from one another and do not seek the glory from God, you are not able to come to me.' Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Commentary on Isaiah §71 But, as the Savior says, they received glory from man and did not seek the glory that comes from the only God. Samuel Strimesius 1648–1730 AD · A Candid Inquiry into the Controversies among Evangelicals §257 It is most hostile to truth and peace (7:18) and most fertile of quarrels (2 Tim. John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · The Circumcision of the Heart §20 No man, I say, has a title to the praise of God until he feels his need of God; nor indeed until he seeks that honor which comes from God only, and neither desires nor pursues that which comes from man, unless so far only as it tends to… John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · Original Sin §28 A third symptom of this fatal disease, the love of the world, which is so deeply rooted in our nature, is the pride of life (1 John 2:16), the desire of praise, of the honor that comes from men. Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:45 1 comment from the Fathers, 5 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 5 passages
On John 5:43–45
The one who will come in his own name is the antichrist, and Moses accuses them through his own writings.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even though he knows they are not persuaded and do not receive him, as God he does his own part, convicting and admonishing them. The antichrist promises the glory of this life, and for that reason you believe him.
[John 5:45] A written accusation against you lies in the Mosaic books; Moses, disbelieved by you, will accuse you.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
On John 5:43–45
The one who will come in his own name is the antichrist, and Moses accuses them through his own writings.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Even though he knows they are not persuaded and do not receive him, as God he does his own part, convicting and admonishing them. The antichrist promises the glory of this life, and for that reason you believe him.
[John 5:45] A written accusation against you lies in the Mosaic books; Moses, disbelieved by you, will accuse you.
Fragments on John, §12 → read in full
5 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Ecclesiastes §55 For if you believed Moses, you would believe me; but if you do not believe his writings, how will you believe my words?”. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 1 §4 But if you do not believe his writings, how will you believe my words?' If then he should say he has come not at all to destroy the Law, but rather to bring it to its end (Matthew 5:17), do not think he has worked a total overturning of… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 2 §25 For if you believed Moses, you would believe me; for concerning me that one wrote.’ Zipporah therefore having been received by us into the person of the Church from the nations, the child from her will altogether be somewhere unto a type… Ammonius of Alexandria fl. 5th century AD · Fragments on John §12 [John 5:45 ] A written accusation against you lies in the Mosaic books; Moses, disbelieved by you, will accuse you. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.10.10 This is gathered from Acts 15:28; John 16:8, John 16:13; John 5:45 ; 2 Kings 17:20; Galatians 6:16; Matthew 10:20. Back to the chapter Verse
John 5:46 10 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Clement of Alexandria c. 150–c. 215 AD · Miscellanies 22 The Scriptures themselves, trustworthy witnesses, proclaim his lineage, deeds, and life; yet we too must speak, as concisely as possible. Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor §6 But if you do not believe his writings, how will you believe my words?” And Christ has sojourned in this life, and Christ is proclaimed beforehand as sojourning in this life. Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book II §4 But if you do not believe his writings, how will you believe my words?”. Athanasius of Alexandria c. 293/298–373 AD · Notes on Job §4 Those to whom he said, “If you believed Moses, you would believe me, for he wrote about me”. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Notes on the Catholic Epistles §11 It has been said regarding him before this, that this only Master and Lord Jesus Christ is true God, the one who brought the people out of Egypt through Moses; it follows that there is no other god than Moses; for indeed there is no other… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 10 §3 Indeed Christ said to the Jews: ‘If you believed Moses, you would believe me also; for he wrote about me’. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 2 §5 For he wrote about me.' We are justified, then, not from works of Law, but rather by the faith in Christ. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Commentary on Isaiah §50 Yet the outline of the truth is present in the Law (Romans 2:20), and the mystery of Christ lies hidden in its shadows; for Moses wrote about Him. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Commentary on Isaiah §71 “For if they had believed Moses, they would have believed Him, for he wrote about Him”. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.4.15 Testimony: sacred letters (John 5:39; Luke 24:46; Acts 10:43); John the Baptist (John 1:7); God's voice from heaven (Matthew 3:17; Matthew 17:5; 2 Peter 1:16); miracles (John 5:36; John 10:25); resurrection (Romans 1:4); ascension (Luke… Back to the chapter