▶ Listen to the King James Version 0:00 / 3:54 1×
1 After six days Jesus took with Him Peter, James, and John the brother of James, and led them up a high mountain by themselves. Verse 1: 8 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 2 There He was transfigured before them. His face shone like the sun, and His clothes became as white as the light. Verse 2: 6 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 3 Suddenly Moses and Elijah appeared before them, talking with Jesus. Verse 3: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 4 Peter said to Jesus, “Lord, it is good for us to be here. If You wish, I will put up three shelters —one for You, one for Moses, and one for Elijah.” Verse 4: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 5 While Peter was still speaking, a bright cloud enveloped them, and a voice from the cloud said, “This is My beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased. Listen to Him!” Verse 5: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 6 When the disciples heard this, they fell facedown in terror. Verse 6: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 7 Then Jesus came over and touched them. “Get up,” He said. “Do not be afraid.” Verse 7: commentary from the Fathers 8 And when they looked up, they saw no one except Jesus. 9 As they were coming down the mountain, Jesus commanded them, “Do not tell anyone about this vision until the Son of Man has been raised from the dead.” Verse 9: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 10 The disciples asked Him, “Why then do the scribes say that Elijah must come first?” 11 Jesus replied, “Elijah does indeed come, and he will restore all things. Verse 11: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 12 But I tell you that Elijah has already come, and they did not recognize him, but have done to him whatever they wished. In the same way, the Son of Man will suffer at their hands.” Verse 12: commentary from the Fathers 13 Then the disciples understood that He was speaking to them about John the Baptist. 14 When they came to the crowd, a man came up to Jesus and knelt before Him. Verse 14: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 15 “Lord, have mercy on my son,” he said. “He has seizures and is suffering terribly. He often falls into the fire or into the water. Verse 15: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 16 I brought him to Your disciples, but they could not heal him.” Verse 16: commentary from the Fathers 17 “O unbelieving and perverse generation!” Jesus replied. “How long must I remain with you? How long must I put up with you? Bring the boy here to Me.” Verse 17: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 18 Then Jesus rebuked the demon, and it came out of the boy, and he was healed from that moment. Verse 18: commentary from the Fathers 19 Afterward the disciples came to Jesus privately and asked, “Why couldn’t we drive it out?” Verse 19: 1 passage in the Fathers 20 “Because you have so little faith,” He answered. “For truly I tell you, if you have faith the size of a mustard seed, you can say to this mountain, ‘Move from here to there,’ and it will move. Nothing will be impossible for you.” Verse 20: 7 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 22 When they gathered together in Galilee, Jesus told them, “The Son of Man is about to be delivered into the hands of men. Verse 22: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 23 They will kill Him, and on the third day He will be raised to life.” And the disciples were deeply grieved. Verse 23: commentary from the Fathers 24 After they had arrived in Capernaum, the collectors of the two-drachma tax came to Peter and asked, “Does your Teacher pay the two drachmas?” Verse 24: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 25 “Yes,” he answered. When Peter entered the house, Jesus preempted him. “What do you think, Simon?” He asked. “From whom do the kings of the earth collect customs and taxes: from their own sons, or from others?” Verse 25: 3 passages in the Fathers 26 “From others,” Peter answered. “Then the sons are exempt,” Jesus declared. 27 “But so that we may not offend them, go to the sea, cast a hook, and take the first fish you catch. When you open its mouth, you will find a four-drachma coin. Take it and give it to them for My tax and yours.” Verse 27: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary
Audio: the King James Version read aloud, from Larry Sanger's Deep Dive Bible (public domain).
×
This chapter in the Fathers
Matthew 17 55 passages
18 of 26 verses cited
11 writers
Most cited verses Matthew 17:1 8 passages Matthew 17:20 7 passages Matthew 17:2 6 passages Matthew 17:9 4 passages Matthew 17:5 4 passages Matthew 17:17 4 passages Matthew 17:22 3 passages Matthew 17:24 3 passages Select a marked verse to see who cites it.
Also cited: verse 21 (numbered differently in this translation).
Verse
Matthew 17:1 4 comments from the Fathers, 8 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (4) All 8 passages
Christ climbs the mountain because contemplation needs a mind raised above life's cares.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
He goes up onto the mountain to show that a lowly mind would not become fit for contemplation, but the one who has become his own, outside life’s cares, in quiet (Matthew 17:1).
Fragments on Matthew, §172 → read in full
On Matthew 17:1–3
Christ appeared to each person according to what he could receive, so only Peter, James and John saw his glory on the mountain.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
Jesus, though one, was many in aspect; and he was not seen alike by all who saw him. … That even when seen he did not appear the same to all who saw him, but according to what each beholder could receive, will be clear to those who consider why, when he was about to be transfigured on the high mountain, he did not take even all the apostles, but only Peter and James and John (Matthew 17:1–2). For they alone could take in the sight of his glory at that time, and were able also to perceive Moses and Elijah, who appeared in glory (Luke 9:30–31), and to hear them talking together, and the voice from heaven out of the cloud (Matthew 17:5).
Against Celsus, Book II, §64 → read in full
Christ climbs the mountain because contemplation needs a mind raised above life's cares.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
He goes up onto the mountain to show that a lowly mind would not become fit for contemplation, but the one who has become his own, outside life’s cares, in quiet (Matthew 17:1).
Fragments on Matthew, §172 → read in full
On Matthew 17:1–2
Christ was transfigured into a better form that only those who could follow him to the height were able to see.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
For there are, as it were, different forms of the Word, as the Word appears to each of those who are being led into knowledge, in proportion to the state of each: the one who is just beginning, or who has made a little progress or more, or is already drawing near to virtue, or has even come to live in virtue.
Hence, not in the way Celsus [a critic of the Christians, whom Origen is answering] and those like him would have it, our God “was transfigured” and, going up “onto the high mountain” (Matthew 17:1-2; Mark 9:2), showed another form of himself, far better than the one seen by those who stayed below and could not follow him to the height. For those below did not have eyes able to see the transfiguration of the Word into what is glorious and more divine. They could barely receive him as he was, so that those who could not see his better form might say of him: “We saw him, and he had no form or beauty; but his form was without honour, falling short of the sons of men” (Isaiah 53:2-3).
Against Celsus, Book IV, §16 → read in full
On Matthew 17:1–2
On the mountain Christ showed his glorious form together with the spiritual law (Moses) and prophecy (Elijah).
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
He [Christ] led us up onto the “high mountain” (Matthew 17:1) of the Word and showed us his glorious form and the brightness of his garments (Matthew 17:2), and not his own only, but also that of the spiritual law, which is “Moses,” seen “in glory” with Jesus (Luke 9:30–31). He showed us also the whole of prophecy, which did not die even after he became man, but was taken up into heaven; Elijah was its symbol (2 Kings 2:11).
Against Celsus, Book VI, §68 → read in full
On Matthew 17:1–3
Christ appeared to each person according to what he could receive, so only Peter, James and John saw his glory on the mountain.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
Jesus, though one, was many in aspect; and he was not seen alike by all who saw him. … That even when seen he did not appear the same to all who saw him, but according to what each beholder could receive, will be clear to those who consider why, when he was about to be transfigured on the high mountain, he did not take even all the apostles, but only Peter and James and John (Matthew 17:1–2). For they alone could take in the sight of his glory at that time, and were able also to perceive Moses and Elijah, who appeared in glory (Luke 9:30–31), and to hear them talking together, and the voice from heaven out of the cloud (Matthew 17:5).
Against Celsus, Book II, §64 → read in full
8 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book II §64 That even when seen he did not appear the same to all who saw him, but according to what each beholder could receive, will be clear to those who consider why, when he was about to be transfigured on the high mountain, he did not take even… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book II §65 Paul knew well in what sense he said, “To me, less than the least of all the saints, this grace was given” (Ephesians 3:8); and perhaps “less than the least” means the same as “untimely born.” Just as, then, no one could readily find… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book II §72 Moreover, the voice from the cloud on the very high mountain was heard only by those who had gone up with him (compare Mark 9:2–7; Luke 9:28–35). Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book III §21 And he will marvel when he understands why some are called “outside” and others “in the house.” And again, who among those able to see would not be struck with wonder at Jesus’ movements: going up a mountain for certain words (Matthew… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book IV §16 Hence, not in the way Celsus and those like him would have it, our God “was transfigured” and, going up “onto the high mountain” (Mark 9:2), showed another form of himself, far better than the one seen by those who stayed below and could… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book VI §68 He led us up onto the “high mountain” of the Word and showed us his glorious form and the brightness of his garments (Matthew 17:2), and not his own only, but also that of the spiritual law, which is “Moses,” seen “in glory” with Jesus… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book VI §76 What will he say about the Gospel too, in which Jesus went up “onto a high mountain” and “was transfigured before” the disciples and was seen in glory, when also “Moses and Elijah,” “appearing in glory, spoke of his departure, which he… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Matthew §172 He goes up onto the mountain to show that a lowly mind would not become fit for contemplation, but the one who has become his own, outside life’s cares, in quiet. Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:2 6 comments from the Fathers, 6 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (6) All 6 passages
On Matthew 17:1–3
Christ appeared to each person according to what he could receive, so only Peter, James and John saw his glory on the mountain.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
Jesus, though one, was many in aspect; and he was not seen alike by all who saw him. … That even when seen he did not appear the same to all who saw him, but according to what each beholder could receive, will be clear to those who consider why, when he was about to be transfigured on the high mountain, he did not take even all the apostles, but only Peter and James and John (Matthew 17:1–2). For they alone could take in the sight of his glory at that time, and were able also to perceive Moses and Elijah, who appeared in glory (Luke 9:30–31), and to hear them talking together, and the voice from heaven out of the cloud (Matthew 17:5).
Against Celsus, Book II, §64 → read in full
The transfiguration was a light-like glory around the body, not a change of its form.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
We say the transfiguration took place not by the body’s human form being changed, but by a light-like glory wrapping it around. The body remained in its form, while the features were colored more gloriously by a light-like hue (Matthew 17:2).
Fragments on Matthew, §173 → read in full
On Matthew 17:1–2
Christ was transfigured into a better form that only those who could follow him to the height were able to see.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
For there are, as it were, different forms of the Word, as the Word appears to each of those who are being led into knowledge, in proportion to the state of each: the one who is just beginning, or who has made a little progress or more, or is already drawing near to virtue, or has even come to live in virtue.
Hence, not in the way Celsus [a critic of the Christians, whom Origen is answering] and those like him would have it, our God “was transfigured” and, going up “onto the high mountain” (Matthew 17:1-2; Mark 9:2), showed another form of himself, far better than the one seen by those who stayed below and could not follow him to the height. For those below did not have eyes able to see the transfiguration of the Word into what is glorious and more divine. They could barely receive him as he was, so that those who could not see his better form might say of him: “We saw him, and he had no form or beauty; but his form was without honour, falling short of the sons of men” (Isaiah 53:2-3).
Against Celsus, Book IV, §16 → read in full
On Matthew 17:1–2
On the mountain Christ showed his glorious form together with the spiritual law (Moses) and prophecy (Elijah).
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
He [Christ] led us up onto the “high mountain” (Matthew 17:1) of the Word and showed us his glorious form and the brightness of his garments (Matthew 17:2), and not his own only, but also that of the spiritual law, which is “Moses,” seen “in glory” with Jesus (Luke 9:30–31). He showed us also the whole of prophecy, which did not die even after he became man, but was taken up into heaven; Elijah was its symbol (2 Kings 2:11).
Against Celsus, Book VI, §68 → read in full
On Matthew 17:1–3
Christ appeared to each person according to what he could receive, so only Peter, James and John saw his glory on the mountain.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
Jesus, though one, was many in aspect; and he was not seen alike by all who saw him. … That even when seen he did not appear the same to all who saw him, but according to what each beholder could receive, will be clear to those who consider why, when he was about to be transfigured on the high mountain, he did not take even all the apostles, but only Peter and James and John (Matthew 17:1–2). For they alone could take in the sight of his glory at that time, and were able also to perceive Moses and Elijah, who appeared in glory (Luke 9:30–31), and to hear them talking together, and the voice from heaven out of the cloud (Matthew 17:5).
Against Celsus, Book II, §64 → read in full
The transfiguration was a light-like glory around the body, not a change of its form.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
We say the transfiguration took place not by the body’s human form being changed, but by a light-like glory wrapping it around. The body remained in its form, while the features were colored more gloriously by a light-like hue (Matthew 17:2).
Fragments on Matthew, §173 → read in full
The Word's garments are the words of Scripture, which look dull below and bright to those who go up the mountain.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
And “his garments” are different below: they are not “white,” they are not “as the light” (Matthew 17:2). If you go up “onto the high mountain,” you will see his light and “his garments.” The “garments” of the Word are the wording of Scripture; these words are the clothing of the divine thoughts. So as he himself appears different below, and when he has gone up is transfigured and “his face” becomes “like the sun” (Matthew 17:2), so too his clothing, so too “his garments.” When you are below, they are not bright, they are not “white”; but if you go up, you will see the beauty and “the light” of the garments, and you will marvel at “the face” of Jesus transfigured.
Against Celsus, Book VI, §77 → read in full
On Matthew 17:2–6
The body changes as the Creator wills, unlovely at one time and so glorious at another that the apostles fell down.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
And it is not surprising that matter, which by nature is mutable and alterable, can be changed into whatever the Creator wills, and can receive every quality the Craftsman wills, should at one time have the quality of which it is said, “He had no form nor beauty” (Isaiah 53:2), and at another time one so glorious and awe-inspiring and wonderful that those who beheld such great beauty, the three apostles who had gone up with Jesus, fell “on their faces” (Matthew 17:6).
Against Celsus, Book VI, §77 → read in full
6 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book VI §68 He led us up onto the “high mountain” (Matthew 17:1) of the Word and showed us his glorious form and the brightness of his garments, and not his own only, but also that of the spiritual law, which is “Moses,” seen “in glory” with Jesus… Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book VI §77 And “his garments” are different below: they are not “white,” they are not “as the light”. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Zechariah §31 1.342 Understand, if you are able, to take two sons of fatness having been presented to the Lord, those seen in glory with Jesus on the mountain, Moses and Elijah, making manifest the Law and the Prophets. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Romans §24 He speaks of the glory of the saints because in due time the righteous will shine like the sun (Matthew 13:43), having come into honor, glory and incorruption when their bodies are changed, just as Christ was transfigured on the mountain. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Matthew §173 The body remained in its form, while the features were colored more gloriously by a light-like hue. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §3.19.5 And that either through unusual flashing and shining of light and splendor, or through opposed and split darkness, or through production of works which agree with His perfection and excellence — Matthew 17:2,5 ; Luke 2:9; Exodus; Psalm… Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:3 3 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 1 passage
On Matthew 17:1–3
Christ appeared to each person according to what he could receive, so only Peter, James and John saw his glory on the mountain.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
Jesus, though one, was many in aspect; and he was not seen alike by all who saw him. … That even when seen he did not appear the same to all who saw him, but according to what each beholder could receive, will be clear to those who consider why, when he was about to be transfigured on the high mountain, he did not take even all the apostles, but only Peter and James and John (Matthew 17:1–2). For they alone could take in the sight of his glory at that time, and were able also to perceive Moses and Elijah, who appeared in glory (Luke 9:30–31), and to hear them talking together, and the voice from heaven out of the cloud (Matthew 17:5).
Against Celsus, Book II, §64 → read in full
On Matthew 17:1–3
Christ appeared to each person according to what he could receive, so only Peter, James and John saw his glory on the mountain.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
Jesus, though one, was many in aspect; and he was not seen alike by all who saw him. … That even when seen he did not appear the same to all who saw him, but according to what each beholder could receive, will be clear to those who consider why, when he was about to be transfigured on the high mountain, he did not take even all the apostles, but only Peter and James and John (Matthew 17:1–2). For they alone could take in the sight of his glory at that time, and were able also to perceive Moses and Elijah, who appeared in glory (Luke 9:30–31), and to hear them talking together, and the voice from heaven out of the cloud (Matthew 17:5).
Against Celsus, Book II, §64 → read in full
On Matthew 17:2–6
The body changes as the Creator wills, unlovely at one time and so glorious at another that the apostles fell down.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
And it is not surprising that matter, which by nature is mutable and alterable, can be changed into whatever the Creator wills, and can receive every quality the Craftsman wills, should at one time have the quality of which it is said, “He had no form nor beauty” (Isaiah 53:2), and at another time one so glorious and awe-inspiring and wonderful that those who beheld such great beauty, the three apostles who had gone up with Jesus, fell “on their faces” (Matthew 17:6).
Against Celsus, Book VI, §77 → read in full
On Matthew 17:3–7
Moses and the prophets speak what Christ speaks, and the disciples' fall shows that we need his mediation to bear God's voice.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
What they speak together shows that the prophets of old uttered the same things as Christ, even if in riddles. The disciples fall from extreme fear, and the Savior raises them, showing that unless he had become flesh, mediated between God and humans, and strengthened our nature, it could not have borne to hear God’s voice (Matthew 17:3–7).
Fragments on Matthew, §174 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:4 3 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 1 passage
Peter spoke without knowing, since heavenly dwelling had to wait until after Christ's resurrection and ascension.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
He did not know what he was saying. Before the Savior’s passion and resurrection, and before the dissolution of death and the corruption of our bodies, it was impossible for Peter to dwell with Christ and to long for the tents in heaven. Those things must come after the Savior’s resurrection and ascent into heaven (Matthew 17:4).
Fragments on Matthew, §175 → read in full
On Matthew 17:2–6
The body changes as the Creator wills, unlovely at one time and so glorious at another that the apostles fell down.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
And it is not surprising that matter, which by nature is mutable and alterable, can be changed into whatever the Creator wills, and can receive every quality the Craftsman wills, should at one time have the quality of which it is said, “He had no form nor beauty” (Isaiah 53:2), and at another time one so glorious and awe-inspiring and wonderful that those who beheld such great beauty, the three apostles who had gone up with Jesus, fell “on their faces” (Matthew 17:6).
Against Celsus, Book VI, §77 → read in full
On Matthew 17:3–7
Moses and the prophets speak what Christ speaks, and the disciples' fall shows that we need his mediation to bear God's voice.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
What they speak together shows that the prophets of old uttered the same things as Christ, even if in riddles. The disciples fall from extreme fear, and the Savior raises them, showing that unless he had become flesh, mediated between God and humans, and strengthened our nature, it could not have borne to hear God’s voice (Matthew 17:3–7).
Fragments on Matthew, §174 → read in full
Peter spoke without knowing, since heavenly dwelling had to wait until after Christ's resurrection and ascension.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
He did not know what he was saying. Before the Savior’s passion and resurrection, and before the dissolution of death and the corruption of our bodies, it was impossible for Peter to dwell with Christ and to long for the tents in heaven. Those things must come after the Savior’s resurrection and ascent into heaven (Matthew 17:4).
Fragments on Matthew, §175 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:5 4 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (4) All 4 passages
The Father commands us to hear Christ, not to give up Moses and the prophets, who stand beside him as servants speaking with him.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
He has commanded that we hear him, because God the Father no longer wills us to obey legal writings, nor even the shadow-sketches in type, but rather to follow what has been enjoined on us through the Savior — without thrusting out Moses and the prophets. For they were standing beside him and speaking with him, so that their presence might signify servant-like service to us, while their conversing might signify intimacy with Christ and, as it were, speaking the same things (Matthew 17:5).
Fragments on Matthew, §176 → read in full
On Matthew 17:2–6
The body changes as the Creator wills, unlovely at one time and so glorious at another that the apostles fell down.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
And it is not surprising that matter, which by nature is mutable and alterable, can be changed into whatever the Creator wills, and can receive every quality the Craftsman wills, should at one time have the quality of which it is said, “He had no form nor beauty” (Isaiah 53:2), and at another time one so glorious and awe-inspiring and wonderful that those who beheld such great beauty, the three apostles who had gone up with Jesus, fell “on their faces” (Matthew 17:6).
Against Celsus, Book VI, §77 → read in full
On Matthew 17:3–7
Moses and the prophets speak what Christ speaks, and the disciples' fall shows that we need his mediation to bear God's voice.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
What they speak together shows that the prophets of old uttered the same things as Christ, even if in riddles. The disciples fall from extreme fear, and the Savior raises them, showing that unless he had become flesh, mediated between God and humans, and strengthened our nature, it could not have borne to hear God’s voice (Matthew 17:3–7).
Fragments on Matthew, §174 → read in full
The Father commands us to hear Christ, not to give up Moses and the prophets, who stand beside him as servants speaking with him.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
He has commanded that we hear him, because God the Father no longer wills us to obey legal writings, nor even the shadow-sketches in type, but rather to follow what has been enjoined on us through the Savior — without thrusting out Moses and the prophets. For they were standing beside him and speaking with him, so that their presence might signify servant-like service to us, while their conversing might signify intimacy with Christ and, as it were, speaking the same things (Matthew 17:5).
Fragments on Matthew, §176 → read in full
God's voice is not heard by the ear, just as no one has ever seen God.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
…the Father announcing the Son appears from the voice heard there, as if proclaiming and itself the testimony coming from above through all; for a voice of God is not to be considered heard by the ear, nor is the sensible from the incorporeal.
And just as 'no one has seen God ever' (John 1:18), neither has anyone heard God.
Fragments on Matthew, §8 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book II §64 For they alone could take in the sight of his glory at that time, and were able also to perceive Moses and Elijah, who appeared in glory (Luke 9:30–31), and to hear them talking together, and the voice from heaven out of the cloud. Apollinaris of Laodicea c. 310–c. 390 AD · Fragments on Matthew §8 Regarding Matthew 17:5 , the Father announcing the Son appears from the voice heard there, as if proclaiming and itself the testimony coming from above through all; for a voice of God is not to be considered heard by the ear, nor is the… Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Matthew §176 For they were standing beside him and speaking with him, so that their presence might signify servant-like service to us, while their conversing might signify intimacy with Christ and, as it were, speaking the same things. Ludwig Crocius 1586–1655 AD · System of Sacred Theology §1.4.15 Testimony: sacred letters (John 5:39, John 5:46; Luke 24:46; Acts 10:43); John the Baptist (John 1:7); God's voice from heaven (Matthew 3:17; 2 Peter 1:16); miracles (John 5:36; John 10:25); resurrection (Romans 1:4); ascension (Luke… Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:6 3 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 2 passages
The disciples fall in fear to show how necessary Christ's mediation is, since no one could bear God approaching in glory.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The voice of God the Father is good and worthy of wonder; yet the disciples fall (Matthew 17:6), already held by unmixed fear, so that through this too we may learn how necessary the Savior’s mediation has appeared for those on earth — understood according to the manner of the incarnation. For if he had not become as we are, who of us could have borne God approaching from above and displaying his ineffable glory, scarcely bearable for any generated being? For the blessed Paul also said that he “dwells in unapproachable light.” (1 Timothy 6:16) And before this such a voice was borne at the Jordan, and a crowd was present.
Fragments on Matthew, §177 → read in full
On Matthew 17:2–6
The body changes as the Creator wills, unlovely at one time and so glorious at another that the apostles fell down.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
And it is not surprising that matter, which by nature is mutable and alterable, can be changed into whatever the Creator wills, and can receive every quality the Craftsman wills, should at one time have the quality of which it is said, “He had no form nor beauty” (Isaiah 53:2), and at another time one so glorious and awe-inspiring and wonderful that those who beheld such great beauty, the three apostles who had gone up with Jesus, fell “on their faces” (Matthew 17:6).
Against Celsus, Book VI, §77 → read in full
On Matthew 17:3–7
Moses and the prophets speak what Christ speaks, and the disciples' fall shows that we need his mediation to bear God's voice.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
What they speak together shows that the prophets of old uttered the same things as Christ, even if in riddles. The disciples fall from extreme fear, and the Savior raises them, showing that unless he had become flesh, mediated between God and humans, and strengthened our nature, it could not have borne to hear God’s voice (Matthew 17:3–7).
Fragments on Matthew, §174 → read in full
The disciples fall in fear to show how necessary Christ's mediation is, since no one could bear God approaching in glory.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The voice of God the Father is good and worthy of wonder; yet the disciples fall (Matthew 17:6), already held by unmixed fear, so that through this too we may learn how necessary the Savior’s mediation has appeared for those on earth — understood according to the manner of the incarnation. For if he had not become as we are, who of us could have borne God approaching from above and displaying his ineffable glory, scarcely bearable for any generated being? For the blessed Paul also said that he “dwells in unapproachable light.” (1 Timothy 6:16) And before this such a voice was borne at the Jordan, and a crowd was present.
Fragments on Matthew, §177 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:7 1 comment from the Fathers
Complete (1)
On Matthew 17:3–7
Moses and the prophets speak what Christ speaks, and the disciples' fall shows that we need his mediation to bear God's voice.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
What they speak together shows that the prophets of old uttered the same things as Christ, even if in riddles. The disciples fall from extreme fear, and the Savior raises them, showing that unless he had become flesh, mediated between God and humans, and strengthened our nature, it could not have borne to hear God’s voice (Matthew 17:3–7).
Fragments on Matthew, §174 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:9 1 comment from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Complete (1) All 4 passages
Jesus' command to tell no one the vision fits his character, for he avoided speaking about himself and showed he was the Christ by deeds.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
Further, I will add to my argument the very point Celsus [a critic of the Christians] assumes: that Jesus himself told of the opening of the heavens and of the Holy Spirit that came down upon him in the form of a dove at the Jordan, although Scripture does not present him as saying that he saw this. This most noble man did not see that it does not fit the one who said to his disciples about the vision on the mountain, “Tell the vision to no one until the Son of Man has risen from the dead” (Matthew 17:9), to have told his disciples what John saw and heard at the Jordan. One may see this also in the character of Jesus, who everywhere avoided speaking about himself and for that reason said, “Even if I speak about myself, my testimony is not true” (John 5:31). And since he avoided speaking about himself, and wished to show that he was the Christ by his deeds rather than by his words, for this reason the Jews say to him, “If you are the Christ, tell us plainly” (John 10:24).
Against Celsus, Book I, §48 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:11 1 comment from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 2 passages
On Matthew 17:11–12
Not knowing John as Elijah, the Jews also failed to know and killed the Lord.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Christ shows that the Jews are greatly ignorant of the scriptures, from which they did not recognize John — that is, the first Elijah, “who prepared the way of the Lord.” (Matthew 17:11–12) Not knowing him and killing the forerunner of Christ, they also failed to recognize the Lord himself and killed him.
Fragments on Matthew, §178 → read in full
On Matthew 17:11–12
Not knowing John as Elijah, the Jews also failed to know and killed the Lord.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Christ shows that the Jews are greatly ignorant of the scriptures, from which they did not recognize John — that is, the first Elijah, “who prepared the way of the Lord.” (Matthew 17:11–12) Not knowing him and killing the forerunner of Christ, they also failed to recognize the Lord himself and killed him.
Fragments on Matthew, §178 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:12 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On Matthew 17:11–12
Not knowing John as Elijah, the Jews also failed to know and killed the Lord.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Christ shows that the Jews are greatly ignorant of the scriptures, from which they did not recognize John — that is, the first Elijah, “who prepared the way of the Lord.” (Matthew 17:11–12) Not knowing him and killing the forerunner of Christ, they also failed to recognize the Lord himself and killed him.
Fragments on Matthew, §178 → read in full
On Matthew 17:11–12
Not knowing John as Elijah, the Jews also failed to know and killed the Lord.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Christ shows that the Jews are greatly ignorant of the scriptures, from which they did not recognize John — that is, the first Elijah, “who prepared the way of the Lord.” (Matthew 17:11–12) Not knowing him and killing the forerunner of Christ, they also failed to recognize the Lord himself and killed him.
Fragments on Matthew, §178 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:14 1 comment from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (1) All 2 passages
On Matthew 17:14–18
The father's unbelief deserved a refusal, yet Christ rebuked the spirit to show his own power and freed the child.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Even if the father of the demon-possessed boy, grieving, ought to have gone away without obtaining the favor — because he did not make a blameless approach, but cried out against the apostolic band and said they could not rebuke the demon, rather accusing the Lord of the powers himself (for the one who says those who received authority from Christ to cast out unclean spirits were weak for the work rather accuses the grace, not those who received it) — therefore that unbelieving and so distorted father ought to have been sent away empty.
Yet so that no one might think Christ himself powerless to accomplish the marvel, “he rebuked the unclean spirit,” (Matthew 17:14–18) and at once the child was freed from illness, “and he gave him to his father.” For before he was healed he was not the father’s, but the spirit’s that held him.
Fragments on Matthew, §179 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:15 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 2 passages
The moon cannot cause the demon's attack, since demons falsely blame elements that are good by nature.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
If the moon could produce a passion in someone by its natural law, why does it not send this on all humans, just as it pours its light on all? Again it is clear that the moon was made for shining, not for begetting demons. And if this came from the moon’s natural working, then when the demon was crushed the moon too — the cause of the passion — ought to have been harmed. But that is not so. Demons, wanting to deceive humans, put the names of the elements around themselves so that the elements might be accused as wicked — which they are not. By nature the elements are good, serving only the laws given them and having no authority from choice (Matthew 17:15).
Fragments on Matthew, §180 → read in full
On Matthew 17:14–18
The father's unbelief deserved a refusal, yet Christ rebuked the spirit to show his own power and freed the child.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Even if the father of the demon-possessed boy, grieving, ought to have gone away without obtaining the favor — because he did not make a blameless approach, but cried out against the apostolic band and said they could not rebuke the demon, rather accusing the Lord of the powers himself (for the one who says those who received authority from Christ to cast out unclean spirits were weak for the work rather accuses the grace, not those who received it) — therefore that unbelieving and so distorted father ought to have been sent away empty.
Yet so that no one might think Christ himself powerless to accomplish the marvel, “he rebuked the unclean spirit,” (Matthew 17:14–18) and at once the child was freed from illness, “and he gave him to his father.” For before he was healed he was not the father’s, but the spirit’s that held him.
Fragments on Matthew, §179 → read in full
The moon cannot cause the demon's attack, since demons falsely blame elements that are good by nature.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
If the moon could produce a passion in someone by its natural law, why does it not send this on all humans, just as it pours its light on all? Again it is clear that the moon was made for shining, not for begetting demons. And if this came from the moon’s natural working, then when the demon was crushed the moon too — the cause of the passion — ought to have been harmed. But that is not so. Demons, wanting to deceive humans, put the names of the elements around themselves so that the elements might be accused as wicked — which they are not. By nature the elements are good, serving only the laws given them and having no authority from choice (Matthew 17:15).
Fragments on Matthew, §180 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:16 1 comment from the Fathers
Complete (1)
On Matthew 17:14–18
The father's unbelief deserved a refusal, yet Christ rebuked the spirit to show his own power and freed the child.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Even if the father of the demon-possessed boy, grieving, ought to have gone away without obtaining the favor — because he did not make a blameless approach, but cried out against the apostolic band and said they could not rebuke the demon, rather accusing the Lord of the powers himself (for the one who says those who received authority from Christ to cast out unclean spirits were weak for the work rather accuses the grace, not those who received it) — therefore that unbelieving and so distorted father ought to have been sent away empty.
Yet so that no one might think Christ himself powerless to accomplish the marvel, “he rebuked the unclean spirit,” (Matthew 17:14–18) and at once the child was freed from illness, “and he gave him to his father.” For before he was healed he was not the father’s, but the spirit’s that held him.
Fragments on Matthew, §179 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:17 3 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 4 passages
Christ stayed among the not-good in gentleness during his time in the flesh, in order to correct them.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
When he says, “How long shall I dwell with you who insult and are unbelieving?” (Matthew 17:17) he shows that the time of the incarnate presence required him to dwell with the not-good in God-befitting gentleness, so that through what he does he might correct them. “How long,” he says, “shall I dwell with you so insolent and unbelieving?” — showing that his presence with flesh compelled him to associate with the not-good in order to correct them.
Fragments on Matthew, §182 → read in full
On Matthew 17:14–18
The father's unbelief deserved a refusal, yet Christ rebuked the spirit to show his own power and freed the child.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Even if the father of the demon-possessed boy, grieving, ought to have gone away without obtaining the favor — because he did not make a blameless approach, but cried out against the apostolic band and said they could not rebuke the demon, rather accusing the Lord of the powers himself (for the one who says those who received authority from Christ to cast out unclean spirits were weak for the work rather accuses the grace, not those who received it) — therefore that unbelieving and so distorted father ought to have been sent away empty.
Yet so that no one might think Christ himself powerless to accomplish the marvel, “he rebuked the unclean spirit,” (Matthew 17:14–18) and at once the child was freed from illness, “and he gave him to his father.” For before he was healed he was not the father’s, but the spirit’s that held him.
Fragments on Matthew, §179 → read in full
Christ's weariness is aimed at unbelief, not at the man himself.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
The unbeliever will somehow also be distorted and know no way to walk straight. Christ does not deem such people worthy of his company; if one may say something human, he grows weary and is distressed. Yet this is not aimed at this person’s face — and one must not think what is unfitting about them (Matthew 17:17).
Fragments on Matthew, §181 → read in full
Christ stayed among the not-good in gentleness during his time in the flesh, in order to correct them.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
When he says, “How long shall I dwell with you who insult and are unbelieving?” (Matthew 17:17) he shows that the time of the incarnate presence required him to dwell with the not-good in God-befitting gentleness, so that through what he does he might correct them. “How long,” he says, “shall I dwell with you so insolent and unbelieving?” — showing that his presence with flesh compelled him to associate with the not-good in order to correct them.
Fragments on Matthew, §182 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:18 1 comment from the Fathers
Complete (1)
On Matthew 17:14–18
The father's unbelief deserved a refusal, yet Christ rebuked the spirit to show his own power and freed the child.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Even if the father of the demon-possessed boy, grieving, ought to have gone away without obtaining the favor — because he did not make a blameless approach, but cried out against the apostolic band and said they could not rebuke the demon, rather accusing the Lord of the powers himself (for the one who says those who received authority from Christ to cast out unclean spirits were weak for the work rather accuses the grace, not those who received it) — therefore that unbelieving and so distorted father ought to have been sent away empty.
Yet so that no one might think Christ himself powerless to accomplish the marvel, “he rebuked the unclean spirit,” (Matthew 17:14–18) and at once the child was freed from illness, “and he gave him to his father.” For before he was healed he was not the father’s, but the spirit’s that held him.
Fragments on Matthew, §179 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:19 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:20 1 comment from the Fathers, 7 passages citing this verse
Complete (1) All 7 passages
Mustard-seed faith means either hot, boiling faith or a faith small in word.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
“If you have faith as a mustard seed” (Matthew 17:20) — that is, hot and boiling, or faith likened to the tiny grain because of smallness in word. For “we have the treasure” (2 Corinthians 4:7) of faith “in earthen vessels.”
Fragments on Matthew, §183 → read in full
7 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Clement of Alexandria c. 150–c. 215 AD · Miscellanies 1 Common faith lies like a foundation (for the Lord said to those who longed to be healed, 'Your faith has saved you' — Luke 7:50; 8:48), while exceptional faith, built upon that foundation, is perfected in the faithful and joined to the… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Fragments on the Psalms §29 Among these was also the spirit of moon-sickness about which the Savior says: 'If you have faith like a grain of mustard seed, you say to this mountain, Move from here to there'. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 AD · Fragments on Matthew §183 “If you have faith as a mustard seed” — that is, hot and boiling, or faith likened to the tiny grain because of smallness in word. Gennadius of Constantinople d. 471 AD · Fragments on the First and Second Epistles to the Corinthians §4 About this the Lord also says in the Gospels: “If you have faith like a grain of mustard seed, you will say to this mountain, ‘Be lifted up and thrown into the sea,’ and it will happen”. Louis Le Blanc de Beaulieu 1614–1675 AD · Theological Theses §15 He also reproaches the disciples for the defect of this faith in Matthew 17:20 , when he refers the cause why they could not cast out the demon to their unbelief. Louis Le Blanc de Beaulieu 1614–1675 AD · Theological Theses §16 Then if the faith of miracles were an excellent grade of justifying faith, Christ, when reproaching the disciples for the defect of that faith, would not say to them, If you had faith like a grain of mustard seed, you would say to this… John Wesley 1703–1791 AD · Upon Our Lord’s Sermon on the Mount Discourse XIII §26 else, give me faith, though but as a grain of mustard-seed! Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:21 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:22 3 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 3 passages
On Matthew 17:22–23
Christ foretold the passion after showing his glory so the disciples would not think they were deceived when he was seized.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So he brought the chief disciples up the mountain and showed them the glory with which he will shine upon the world in due times; then, coming down from the mountain, he freed someone from a wicked and harsh spirit. Yet he had wholly to endure the saving passion for us and bear the Jews’ perversity. When that happened it would not be strange for the disciples to be in tumult and perhaps to think and say among themselves: He who raised so many dead by God-befitting authority, who rebukes seas and spirits, who crushes Satan by a word — how has he now been caught and fallen into murderers’ snares? Were we deceived in thinking him God? So that they may know what will wholly and altogether come, he foretells to them the mystery of the passion (Matthew 17:22–23).
Fragments on Matthew, §184 → read in full
On Matthew 17:22–23
Christ foretold the passion after showing his glory so the disciples would not think they were deceived when he was seized.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So he brought the chief disciples up the mountain and showed them the glory with which he will shine upon the world in due times; then, coming down from the mountain, he freed someone from a wicked and harsh spirit. Yet he had wholly to endure the saving passion for us and bear the Jews’ perversity. When that happened it would not be strange for the disciples to be in tumult and perhaps to think and say among themselves: He who raised so many dead by God-befitting authority, who rebukes seas and spirits, who crushes Satan by a word — how has he now been caught and fallen into murderers’ snares? Were we deceived in thinking him God? So that they may know what will wholly and altogether come, he foretells to them the mystery of the passion (Matthew 17:22–23).
Fragments on Matthew, §184 → read in full
On Matthew 17:22–23
Christ joins the resurrection to the passion, and the disciples grieve out of love though it is announced to come soon.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Mixing in the word about the resurrection, he weaves power together with weakness, glory with ingloriousness, the height of divinity with the cheapness of humanity. For he died as man and lived again as God. The disciples are grieved from love toward Christ, even though the resurrection was announced to come soon — because humans grieve more hotly when they hear grievous things and feel those more than the sweetest (Matthew 17:22–23).
Fragments on Matthew, §185 → read in full
On Matthew 17:22–23
Christ says the passion is not yet near, to show his foreknowledge and that he suffers voluntarily, for the disciples' benefit.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
…he therefore says that what is going to happen in Jerusalem is not yet approaching, nor the time according to which it was necessary to suffer, so that he might reveal the divine foreknowledge being such, and that he was about to suffer voluntarily, not departing from where he was to be persuaded through ignorance.
And it happened for the disciples' benefit so that they would not be troubled as if men had prevailed against him.
Fragments on Matthew, §8 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:23 3 comments from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (3)
On Matthew 17:22–23
Christ foretold the passion after showing his glory so the disciples would not think they were deceived when he was seized.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So he brought the chief disciples up the mountain and showed them the glory with which he will shine upon the world in due times; then, coming down from the mountain, he freed someone from a wicked and harsh spirit. Yet he had wholly to endure the saving passion for us and bear the Jews’ perversity. When that happened it would not be strange for the disciples to be in tumult and perhaps to think and say among themselves: He who raised so many dead by God-befitting authority, who rebukes seas and spirits, who crushes Satan by a word — how has he now been caught and fallen into murderers’ snares? Were we deceived in thinking him God? So that they may know what will wholly and altogether come, he foretells to them the mystery of the passion (Matthew 17:22–23).
Fragments on Matthew, §184 → read in full
On Matthew 17:22–23
Christ foretold the passion after showing his glory so the disciples would not think they were deceived when he was seized.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
So he brought the chief disciples up the mountain and showed them the glory with which he will shine upon the world in due times; then, coming down from the mountain, he freed someone from a wicked and harsh spirit. Yet he had wholly to endure the saving passion for us and bear the Jews’ perversity. When that happened it would not be strange for the disciples to be in tumult and perhaps to think and say among themselves: He who raised so many dead by God-befitting authority, who rebukes seas and spirits, who crushes Satan by a word — how has he now been caught and fallen into murderers’ snares? Were we deceived in thinking him God? So that they may know what will wholly and altogether come, he foretells to them the mystery of the passion (Matthew 17:22–23).
Fragments on Matthew, §184 → read in full
On Matthew 17:22–23
Christ joins the resurrection to the passion, and the disciples grieve out of love though it is announced to come soon.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Mixing in the word about the resurrection, he weaves power together with weakness, glory with ingloriousness, the height of divinity with the cheapness of humanity. For he died as man and lived again as God. The disciples are grieved from love toward Christ, even though the resurrection was announced to come soon — because humans grieve more hotly when they hear grievous things and feel those more than the sweetest (Matthew 17:22–23).
Fragments on Matthew, §185 → read in full
On Matthew 17:22–23
Christ says the passion is not yet near, to show his foreknowledge and that he suffers voluntarily, for the disciples' benefit.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
…he therefore says that what is going to happen in Jerusalem is not yet approaching, nor the time according to which it was necessary to suffer, so that he might reveal the divine foreknowledge being such, and that he was about to suffer voluntarily, not departing from where he was to be persuaded through ignorance.
And it happened for the disciples' benefit so that they would not be troubled as if men had prevailed against him.
Fragments on Matthew, §8 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:24 2 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (2) All 3 passages
The drachma was a legal ransom set by Moses, given equally by rich and poor.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
…this was a legal matter concerning the drachmas, having been determined by Moses saying: 'each will give a ransom for his own soul, the half of a drachma' (Exodus 30:13).
These things indeed the Jews were collecting from everyone, and the drachma was being given as a ransom for two souls according to the law; neither was it being added to the rich one, as the law has said, nor was it being diminished for the poor one 'from the half of a drachma'.
Fragments on Matthew, §8 → read in full
They ask Peter craftily, expecting that Christ opposes Moses' law by not paying.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
And they ask Peter craftily. Since, they say, he is accustomed to oppose Moses’ laws, he does not even pay the didrachma (Matthew 17:24) — knowing that Christ had also said, “I came not to destroy the law but to fulfill,” (Matthew 5:17) and that the manner of the economy [God's plan of salvation] requires this. …
Fragments on Matthew, §186 → read in full
The drachma was a legal ransom set by Moses, given equally by rich and poor.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
…this was a legal matter concerning the drachmas, having been determined by Moses saying: 'each will give a ransom for his own soul, the half of a drachma' (Exodus 30:13).
These things indeed the Jews were collecting from everyone, and the drachma was being given as a ransom for two souls according to the law; neither was it being added to the rich one, as the law has said, nor was it being diminished for the poor one 'from the half of a drachma'.
Fragments on Matthew, §8 → read in full
They ask Peter craftily, expecting that Christ opposes Moses' law by not paying.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
And they ask Peter craftily. Since, they say, he is accustomed to oppose Moses’ laws, he does not even pay the didrachma (Matthew 17:24) — knowing that Christ had also said, “I came not to destroy the law but to fulfill,” (Matthew 5:17) and that the manner of the economy [God's plan of salvation] requires this. …
Fragments on Matthew, §186 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:25 3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Matthew 17:27 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 1 passage
The sign from the sea teaches that we are fish drawn from life's turmoil with Christ the royal stater in our mouths, as ransom for two.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Though able to bring forth the stater from the earth, he did not do that, but made the sign from the sea, to teach us a mystery full of contemplation. For we were fishes drawn up from life’s bitter turmoils as from a sea through the apostolic hooks, having in our mouths Christ the royal stater, given as ransom for two — for our soul and body, or for two peoples, Jews and gentiles — likewise ransoming poor and rich, since the old law also unreservedly demanded the drachma’s tax equally from rich and poor.
Fragments on Matthew, §187 → read in full
The sign from the sea teaches that we are fish drawn from life's turmoil with Christ the royal stater in our mouths, as ransom for two.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Though able to bring forth the stater from the earth, he did not do that, but made the sign from the sea, to teach us a mystery full of contemplation. For we were fishes drawn up from life’s bitter turmoils as from a sea through the apostolic hooks, having in our mouths Christ the royal stater, given as ransom for two — for our soul and body, or for two peoples, Jews and gentiles — likewise ransoming poor and rich, since the old law also unreservedly demanded the drachma’s tax equally from rich and poor.
Fragments on Matthew, §187 → read in full
Christ shows himself lord of the sea, and the fish is a type of the church hauled up by the apostles' hook.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
He presents himself as creator and lord of the sea and those in it and every element, as the proper Son of God and Father.
For this fish held a type of the church, which of old was seized by the salt and dread of unbelief and was deeply submerged in the depth, and was baptized and tossed by the storm and surge of worldly pleasures; but it was hauled up by the hook of the apostles, through teaching and fishing and the word that hunts, toward the knowledge of God, … 'who called us out of darkness into his marvelous light' (1 Pet 2:9).
Fragments on Matthew, §8 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter