On the Flesh of Christ · §3 · Tertullian

God's will and power to be born without change

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

Tertullian is answering Marcion's objection that birth was impossible or unworthy for God, arguing that God could be born and remain God.

It follows necessarily, since you think you had the right to decide this, that you judged birth either impossible for God or unworthy of him. But nothing is impossible for God except what he does not will. Let us consider, then, whether he willed the birth—because if he willed it, he both could do it and was born. I take the short way. If God had not willed the birth, for whatever reason, he would not have presented himself as a man to be seen. For who, seeing him as a man, would deny that he had been born? So what he had not willed to be, he would not have willed to be seen at all. The mere opinion of anything displeasing is rejected, because it makes no difference whether a thing exists or not, if when it does not exist it is presumed to exist. Of course it matters that what truly does not exist should not suffer a false report. But, you say, his own conscience was enough for him. Let people think he was born if they wanted, since they saw a man. How much more worthy, then, and how much more consistent it would have been for him to have endured human opinion as one truly born, rather than to undergo that same opinion without the birth, to the injury of his own conscience—which you count as confidence—so that, not born, he would endure being thought born against his own conscience? Tell me what was worth so much that Christ, knowing what he was, should present himself as what he was not. You cannot say, "If he had been born and put on man, he would have ceased to be God, losing what he was while becoming what he was not." For there is no danger to God's own state. But, you say, I deny that God was truly turned into man, so as to undergo birth and be embodied in flesh, because one who is without end must also be unchangeable. For to be turned into another thing is the end of the former thing. Conversion therefore does not suit one whom end does not suit. Clearly, the nature of changeable things has this law: they do not remain in what they are turned into, and so by not remaining they perish, losing what they were by being converted. But nothing is equal to God; his nature stands apart from the condition of all things. If, then, the things that stand apart from God—from which God stands apart—lose what they were when they are converted, where will the difference of divinity from other things be, unless it holds the opposite, that is, that God can be turned into all things and still persevere as he is? Otherwise he will be equal to those things which, when converted, lose what they were—and since he is not equal to them in all things, neither is he in the outcome of conversion. You have read at some time that the Creator's angels were turned into human appearance, and you believed it, and that they carried such truth of body that Abraham washed their feet (Genesis 18:4), and Lot was rescued from the Sodomites by their hands (Genesis 19:16), and an angel also wrestled with a man and desired to be released with the whole weight of his body, so firmly was he held (Genesis 32:24-26). What was permitted to the lower angels of God—to be converted into human bodily form and yet remain angels—will you take away from the more powerful God, as if Christ, truly clothed in man, could not have persevered as God? Or did those angels also appear as phantoms of flesh? But you will not dare to say this. For if in your view the Creator's angels are as Christ is, then Christ will belong to that God whose angels are such as Christ is. If you had not deliberately rejected some Scriptures that resist your opinion and corrupted others, the Gospel of John would have confounded you on this point, preaching that the Spirit in bodily form of a dove descended and settled upon the Lord (John 1:32). That Spirit, since it was this, was as truly a dove as it was the Spirit, and it had not destroyed its own substance by taking on an external substance. But you ask where the body of the dove is, once the Spirit was taken back into heaven—and likewise the bodies of the angels. It was withdrawn by the same means by which it had been produced. If you had seen it when it was brought forth from nothing, you would know also when it was withdrawn into nothing. If its beginning was not visible, neither was its end. Yet the body had solidity, at whatever moment the body was seen. What is written cannot not have been.

Latin

Necesse est, quatenus hoc putas arbitrio tuo licuisse, ut aut impossibilem aut inconvenientem deo existimaveris nativitatem. Sed deo nihil impossibile nisi quod non vult. An ergo voluerit nasci (quia si voluit, et potuit et natus est) consideremus. Ad compendium decurro. Si enim nasci se deus noluisset, quacunque de causa. nec hominem se videri praestitisset. Nam quis hominem videns eum negaret natum? Ita quod noluisset esse, nec videri omnino voluisset. Omnis rei displicentis etiam opinio reprobatur, quia nihil interest utrum sit quid an non sit, si cum non sit esse praesumitur. Plane interest ut falsum non patiatur quod vere non est. Sed satis erat illi, inquis, conscientia sua. Viderint homines si natum putabant, quia hominem videbant. Quanto ergo dignius quantoque constantius humanam sustinuisset existimationem vere natus, eandem existimationem etiam non natus subiturus cum iniuria conscientiae suae quam tu ad fiduciam reputas, ut non natus adversus conscientiam suam natum se existimari sustineret? Quid tanti fuit edoce, quod sciens Christus quid esset id se quod non erat exhiberet? Non potes dicere, Ne si natus fuisset et hominem induisset, deus esse desisset, amittens quod erat, dum fit quod non erat. Periculum enim status sui deo nullum est. Sed ideo, inquis, nego deum in hominem vere conversum, ita ut et nasceretur et carne corporaretur, quia qui sine fine est etiam inconvertibilis sit necesse est. Converti enim in aliud finis est pristini. Non competit ergo conversio cui non competit finis. Plane natura convertibilium ea lege est, ne permaneant in eo quod convertitur in eis, et ita non permanendo pereant, dum perdunt convertendo quod fuerunt. Sed nihil deo par est; natura eius ab omnium rerum condicione distat Si ergo quae a deo distant, a quibus deus distat, cum convertuntur amittunt quod fuerunt, ubi erit diversitas divinitatis a ceteris rebus, nisi ut contrarium obtineat, id est ut deus et in omnia converti possit et qualis est perseverare? Aliequin par erit eorum quae conversa amittunt quod fuerunt, quorum utique in omnibus par non est, sic nec in exitu conversionis. Angelos creatoris conversos in effigiem humanam aliquando legisti, et credidisti, et tantam corporis gestasse veritatem, ut et pedes eis laverit Abraham, et manibus ipsorum ereptus sit Sodomitis Loth, conluctatus quoque homini angelus toto corporis pondere dimitti desideraverit, adeo detinebatur. Quod enim angelis inferioribus dei licuit conversis in corpulentiam humanam, ut angeli nihilominus permanerent, hoc tu potentiori deo auferes, qussi non valuerit Christus vere hominem indutus deus perseverare? Aut numquid et angeli illi phantasmata carnis apparuerunt? Sed non audebis hoc dicere. Nam si sic apud te angeli creatoris sicut et Christus, eius dei erit Christus cuius angeli tales qualis et Christus. Si scripturas opinioni tuae resistentes non de industria alias reiecisses, alias corrupisses, confudisset te in hac specie evangelium Ioannis, praedicans spiritum columbae corpore lapsum desedisse super dominum. Qui spiritus cum hoc esset, tam vere erat et columba quam et spiritus, nec interfecerat substantiam propriam assumpta substantia extranea. Sed quaeris corpus columbae ubi sit resumpto spiritu in caelum, aeque et angelorum. Eadem ratione interceptum est qua et editum fuerat. Si vidisses cum de nihilo proferebatur, scisses et cum in nihilum subducebatur. Si non fuit initium visihile, nec finis. Tamen corporis soliditas erat, quoquo momento corpus videbatur. Non potest non fuisse quod scriptum est.

Report a mistake in this passage