On the Flesh of Christ · §14 · Tertullian

Christ did not bear an angel

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

Tertullian is refuting the view that Christ bore an angel, after having argued that Christ bore true human flesh and soul.

But they say Christ bore an angel. On what ground? On the same ground on which he bore a man. Then the reason for Christ bearing a man is the same. The salvation of man was the reason—to restore what had perished. Man had perished; man had to be restored. For Christ to bear an angel, there is no such reason. For even if destruction is reckoned to the angels, into the fire prepared for the devil and his angels, restoration has never been promised to them. Christ received no command from the Father about the salvation of angels. What the Father neither promised nor commanded, Christ could not carry out. So for what purpose did he bear an angel too, except as a strong attendant, with whom he might work out the salvation of man? For the Son of God was not sufficient, alone, to free man, who had been cast down by a single, solitary serpent. Then there is no longer one God, nor one savior, if there are two artificers of salvation, and each one needing the other. Or was it so that he might free man through an angel? Why then did he descend to do what he was going to accomplish through an angel? If through an angel, why did he himself come? If through himself, why the angel?

He was indeed called the angel of great counsel, that is, a messenger—a title of office, not of nature. For he was going to announce to the world the great plan of the Father, namely the restoration of man. But he is not therefore to be understood as an angel like some Gabriel or Michael. For the son is also sent to the vine-dressers by the lord of the vineyard, just as the servants were, to seek the fruits. But the son will not for that reason be counted as one of the servants, because he took up the servants' office. So I would more readily say, if anything, that the Son himself is an angel—that is, a messenger of the Father—than that an angel was in the Son.

But since it was declared about the Son himself: "You have diminished him a little below the angels" (Psalm 8:5), how will he be seen to have put on an angel, when he is diminished below the angels in this way—as he becomes man, as flesh and soul and Son of Man? But as the Spirit of God and the power of the Most High, can he be held below the angels—he who is God and the Son of God? Therefore, as much as he was made lower than the angels while bearing a man, so much was he not made lower while bearing an angel.

This opinion could suit Ebion, who made Jesus a bare man, solely from the seed of David—that is, not also the Son of God—though clearly somewhat more glorious than the prophets, so that he might declare that an angel was in him, just as in Zechariah. Except that Christ never said: "And the angel who was speaking in me said to me." Nor did he use that daily formula of all the prophets: "Thus says the Lord." For he himself was the Lord, speaking openly from his own authority: "But I say to you" (Matthew 5:22). What more is there to say? Hear Isaiah crying out: "Not an angel, nor a legate, but the Lord himself saved them" (Isaiah 63:9).

Latin

Sed angelum, aiunt, gestavit Christus. Qua ratione? Qua et hominem. Eadem ergo est et causa ut hominem gestaret Christus. Salus hominis fuit causa, scilicet ad restituendum quod perierat. Homo perierat, hominem restitui oportuerat. Ut angelum gestaret Christus, nihil tale de causa est. Nam et si angelis perditio reputatur in ignem praeparatum diabolo et angelis eius, nunquam tamen illis restitutio repromissa est. Nullum mandatum de salute angelorum suscepit Christus a patre. Quod pater neque repromisit neque mandavit, Christus administrare non potuit. Cui igitur rei angelum quoque gestavit, nisi ut satellitem fortem, cum quo salutem hominis operaretur? Idoneus enim non erat dei filius qui solus hominem liberaret, a solo et singulari serpente deiectum. Ergo iam non unus deus, nec unus salutificator, si duo salutis artifices, et utique alter altero indigens. An vero ut per angelum liberaret hominem? Cur ergo descendit ad id quod per angelum erat expediturus? Si per angelum, quid et ipse? si per se, quid et angelus? Dictus est quidem magni consilii angelus, id est numtius, officii, non naturae vocabulo. Magnum enim cogitatum patris, super hominis scilicet restitutione, adnuntiaturus saeculo erat. Non ideo tamen sic angelus intellegendus ut aliqui Gabriel aut Michaël. Nam et filius domino vineae mittitur ad cultores, sicut et famuli, de fructibus petitum. Sed non propterea unus ex famulis deputabitur filius quia famulorum successit officio. Facilius ergo dicam, si forte, ipsum filium angelum, id est nuntium patris, quam angelum in filio. Sed cum de filio ipso sit pronuntiatum: Minuisti eum modicum quid citra angelos, quomodo videbitur angelum induisse, sic infra angelos deminutus, dum homo fit, qua caro et anima et filius hominis? qua autem spiritus dei et virtus altissimi, num potest infra angelos haberi, deus scilicet et dei filius? Quanto ergo, dum hominem gestat, minor angelis factus est, tanto non, dum angelum gestat. Poterit haec opinio Hebioni convenire, qui nudum hominem et tantum ex semine David, id est non et dei filium, constituit Iesum; plane prophetis aliquo gloriosiorem, ut ita in illo angelum fuisse edicat quemadmodum in Zacharia. Nisi quod a Christo nunquam est dictum: Et ait mihi angelus, qui in me loquebatur. Sed nec quotidianum illud omnium prophetarum: Haec dicit dominus. Ipse enim erat dominus coram ex sua auctoritate pronuntians: Ego autem dico vobis. Quid ultra ad haec? Esaiam exclamantem audi: Non angelus neque legatus, sed ipse dominus salvos eos fecit.

Report a mistake in this passage