Fragments on 1 Corinthians

Fragmenta in epistulam i ad Corinthios

Severianus of Gabala (fl. c. 400 AD) · PG 65

Severianus of Gabala (fl. c. 400) was bishop of Gabala in Syria. He preached in Constantinople and became an enemy of John Chrysostom. Contemporaries knew him as the author of biblical commentaries and sermons.

Jump to contents

The Source of Grace and Calling§1

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

1On 1 Corinthians 1:1–2: He did not put this at the head of the letter idly. He wanted to show that it is God's will for everyone to bear the name of Christ, and for there to be apostles. At once he sets beside himself a man the Corinthians knew, and he deflates the conceit of those who were proud of their eloquence. He binds up the division that had wrongly arisen by calling them one church, and God's church. And he puts "in Christ Jesus" first, not "in this man" or "in that one." Notice how often, in a few lines, he names Christ Jesus. From the very opening he teaches that we should take our name from no one but our Lord Jesus Christ, and by naming Jesus Christ again and again he heals the wound left by the split into rival names.

"To those sanctified in Christ Jesus." No man sanctified you, he says, but God in Christ. If you call on a man, he says, take your name from him; but if you call on Jesus Christ, take your name from the one you call on. "With all who call on" is well put. You are not the only ones; all believers everywhere call on Christ and are named after him, not after men. So do not be the only ones to stand out by bringing in an impious novelty. Notice too that he did not say "with all who call the name," but "who call on," and so shows that the Son of God is God, for it is God that one calls on. "In every place, theirs and ours": if every place calls on Jesus Christ, follow the many, and do not be the only ones to do something odd, apart from everyone else. "Theirs and ours" goes with "Lord." It means: we who write and you who enjoy the letter have one Christ Jesus.

On 1 Corinthians 1:3–6: Take your name from the one from whom you have grace and peace. Setting these words down even before the proof and the exercise of debate bears on the question at issue. And this does as much as anything to set the present faults right: if grace comes from our Lord Jesus Christ and not from men, he says, it is fitting to be named after him. He presses the same point. If wealth comes from him and knowledge comes from him, why do you give yourselves the name of one man as your teacher, of another as the one who baptized you, of another as your leader, and of yet another as your benefactor? That is why he says further on, "What do you have that you did not receive? And if you did receive it, why do you boast as though you had not received it?" (1 Corinthians 4:7).

"In every word." There is a word of wisdom and a word of knowledge (1 Corinthians 12:8), and there are many words of gifts, so he says, "in every word and all knowledge." And since knowledge also comes in many kinds, he adds "and all knowledge." The letter was written to Greeks, who had not received the Old and the New together, and who were gaining knowledge from both: "even as the testimony of Christ was confirmed in you."

On 1 Corinthians 1:8–9: Whoever needs to be confirmed is not yet complete. So he showed that they need correcting, giving thanks for what they had received and correcting them for what they had left undone. "God is faithful, through whom you were called." Having said that God will confirm them, he went on, "God is faithful" (for God, who can give these things, is true), "through whom you were called into the fellowship of his Son": not into fellowship with a man, but into the fellowship of his Son. Why then do you give up being named after the Son, into whose fellowship you were called, and take your names from men? Notice again that "through whom" is said of the Father, not only of the Son. It does not lower the Father that we are called through him into the fellowship of his Son. Romans says, "through him and from him and to him are all things" (Romans 11:36), yet that does not make God greater than himself because of "from whom" and less than himself because of "through whom." Said of one and the same person, these words do not make him both less and greater than himself; in the same way "through whom," said of the Son, does not make the Son less.

When he came to the contest itself, to persuade them not to take their names from…

Greek · §1

The Greek is on each section page: §1

The Power of the Cross§2

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

2…men, he recalls the name of Jesus Christ, after whom everyone ought to be called, from the very start of the contest. What he says now is not about doctrines, and he does not blame them for that, but for what we mentioned before, as the words that follow show.

On 1 Corinthians 1:13 and 1:17a: Does Christ have co-heirs, he asks, with whom he has shared you out, you who believe? He did not say, "Was Christ divided?" but, "Did Christ share out with you?" The words that follow show this, for he says, "Was Paul crucified for us?" Christ died for the salvation of the world; none of us did. From this he shows that some wanted to be named after the man who baptized them. This good thing, he says, which the Savior commanded and which brings salvation, would have become a burden to me if you were going to be called after me because I baptized you. How then shall we understand "Christ did not send me to baptize but to preach the gospel"? Someone who is not an apostle can baptize, while few held the rank of apostle, and no one could be baptized without first hearing the gospel. So he says, "I was sent to preach the gospel": that is the chief thing, not baptizing. The word "chiefly" is left out here: I was not sent chiefly to baptize. He speaks the same way elsewhere, when he says, "Is it for oxen that God cares?" (1 Corinthians 9:9). That is not because God does not care for them. In the law Moses really does speak about oxen, the beasts that serve farmers. David too says, "Men and beasts you will save, O Lord, as you have multiplied your mercy, O God" (Psalm 36:6–7). And Solomon says, "The righteous man pities the lives of his beasts" (Proverbs 12:10); how much more God? What then does he mean? That God does not care chiefly for oxen. Here too the sense is elliptical, just like "Christ did not send me to baptize."

On 1 Corinthians 1:17: As he moves on to another charge and comes to another correction, without wholly laying the first aside, he makes the end of the first serve as the opening of the second. "Christ did not send me to baptize" belonged to the first charge, that each of you says, "I am of Paul," and "I am of Apollos." But "not in wisdom of speech" begins a different line of treatment. So he set "to preach the gospel" as both the end of the first matter and the beginning of the second. "So that the cross of Christ may not be emptied": if the preaching is credited to human intelligence and learning, the power of the cross is not shown.

On 1 Corinthians 1:18–20: "The word of the cross." He does not mean the spoken phrase or its utterance, but its power. The deed looks weak, but when you look for its cause, it proves to be a great mystery. "But to us who are being saved it is the power of God." Some want to take "Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God" as said of God the Word; so we should note here that he calls the word of the cross the power of God. "For it is written, I will destroy the wisdom of the wise" (Isaiah 29:14). The apostle could have been trusted when teaching on his own authority, since he had Christ speaking in him (2 Corinthians 13:3). Even so he also draws on the witness of the Old Testament, and so makes his disciples' conviction stronger. Having used the text "I will destroy the wisdom of the wise," he goes on as if the point were already granted: "Where is the wise man? Where is the scribe?" The wise man is the Greek's; the scribe is the Jews'.

On 1 Corinthians 1:21: He speaks of two wisdoms. One is the harmony seen in the things God made. The other is the wisdom by which human beings, being rational, have understanding. Since, he says, we did not know God through the understanding we have, nor through the wisdom seen in the things he made, God was pleased to save those who believe through the foolishness of preaching. What he says is great, and it does not show itself to those who skim past it, for this is how he displays God's power and complete wisdom. The size and beauty of the world, he says, measureless and beyond reach as they are, did not persuade you to know God. Instead you left the Maker and worshiped the very things through which you should have come to know him. To show you the surpassing greatness of his power, God enlightened the world through the confessed weakness of the cross, enlightening people whom creation had not persuaded but only overawed.

On 1 Corinthians 1:22–25: He shows how absurd it is for people to rely on learning and to think that eloquence adorns godliness. One must not answer the Greeks who look for wisdom, he says; one must not even give signs to the Jews who ask for them. Yet signs belong to the Spirit, while wisdom of words belongs to outside learning. If it was not right to give even the wonders of the Spirit to those who asked, how much less the things of outside wisdom (for one is not…

Greek · §2

The Greek is on each section page: §2

The Boasting of the Cross vs. Human Pride§3

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

3…to give them to those who put God to the test, but to those who ask in faith), then eloquence is ruled out altogether, as a plot against the glory of the cross. "But we preach Christ crucified," and the rest. Plainly he calls Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God with respect to the word of the cross, as he did above: "For the word of the cross is folly to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God" (1 Corinthians 1:18). What follows makes this clearer still. After saying, "but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God," he added, "because the foolishness of God is wiser than men, and the weakness of God is stronger than men." Who would say that God the Word is what is meant by "the weakness of God"? "The foolishness of God" is said of Christ crucified. God the Word is powerful as the Father is, not a power that is a part filling out the Father's substance; and he is wise in the same way. What the visible creation could not achieve, nor angels or archangels coming down from heaven, nor patriarchs and prophets, nor the law given through Moses, nor the voices carried to the people from the midst of the fire, because the choice of the obstinate would not allow it, the foolishness of the cross achieved. That is why Christ crucified is the power of God and the wisdom of God: he accomplished more than the whole dispensation and carried more conviction than all creation. This too is the power of the one who planned it and brought it off: he saved human beings by what counts for nothing and led them to faith in himself.

The second catena form adds: Then he teaches how the preaching seems to be foolishness. They look for signs and wisdom; we preach Christ crucified, the power and wisdom of God, and we promise those who believe salvation from the one who was crucified.

On 1 Corinthians 1:26: He added "according to the flesh" to set it against the Spirit, and the phrase serves in common for the words that follow.

On 1 Corinthians 1:29: "So that no flesh may boast before him": that is, so that they may not credit the success of the preaching to their own advantages. He said "flesh" and not "soul" to belittle human boasting. Why "before him" and not "before men"? Because boasting in our own advantages had been set up against boasting in God: what they ought to have credited to God, they credited to men. That is why he said "before him," for boasting carried on in the sight of the one who sees all things was impious. The whole subject shows that he did not say "before him" with the Coming in view, for he has to deal with people who boast of eloquence and of having baptized, and he is speaking about such matters as these.

On 1 Corinthians 1:30: "But of him you are." Everyone alike says that this is said here of being saved, not in the sense of creation, as it says elsewhere: "who were born, not of blood nor of the will of the flesh, but of God" (John 1:13). If then we are of him, how can we boast in advantages of our own? Next, "in Christ Jesus, who became for us wisdom and sanctification and redemption." Human wisdom did not save us, for it was going astray; he himself became our wisdom, to bring us to know God. No human understanding snatched us away; Jesus crucified did. Men did not redeem us. So let the boast be drawn from the one who saved, not from those who were saved.

On 1 Corinthians 2:3–4: I was always afraid that outside learning would puff you up, so I did not use persuasive wisdom. "In weakness," he says, meaning the weakness that comes from persecution, for that is how he always speaks: "in weakness and in fear and in trembling," the weakness caused by those who persecuted me. I showed the fear and trembling I felt for you; I was lowly in everything, so that you might learn from this and not be puffed up. Since he had said "my speech," so that he would not seem to be putting forward the very thing opposed…

Greek · §3

The Greek is on each section page: §3

The distinction of the Spirit and the unity of knowledge§4

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

4…to it, eloquence, he says, "and my preaching was not in persuasive words of wisdom." For there is a wisdom that is not a matter of phrases but of divine knowledge, of the Spirit and of power. The Holy Spirit both supplies a word of wisdom and works wonders, and so he said, "in demonstration of the Spirit and of power." What is said is not yet proof; a wonder carries its proof with it.

The second catena form adds: He shows that he did not preach relying on any human power either.

On 1 Corinthians 2:5: Had he only spoken, he would have been no different from those who use wisdom and trust in their own speech. But by working mighty deeds he showed the strength of God, and the preaching drew its force from there. So he rightly went on, "but in demonstration of the Spirit and of power, so that your faith might not rest on human wisdom but on the power of God."

On 1 Corinthians 2:6: That is, not among the learned, but among those who are mature in godliness. He said "among the mature," not "to the mature." Someone who talks to whoever happens along often meets contradiction too. But someone who brings the saving word to the mature and godly does not simply talk: he lays the words up in their souls and stores them there like treasure.

On 1 Corinthians 2:7–8: If it had been hidden, then clearly finding it out was not a task for reasoning; revealing it truly belonged to God. In place of saying that they did not understand, he gives the proof of it: "for if they had known, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory." By "rulers" he means Pilate and Herod and those around them, and by "the Lord of glory" God made flesh.

On 1 Corinthians 2:9: This quotation is not found in the Old Testament in these words, but in other words with the same meaning. Isaiah says, "Lord, who has believed our report? And to whom has the arm of the Lord been revealed?" (Isaiah 53:1) and, "Who shall tell of his generation?" (Isaiah 53:8). And Moses says, "The hidden things belong to the Lord God" (Deuteronomy 29:29). What is hidden with God plainly escaped both eye and heart. We must not think, however, that God revealed the mystery to some without discernment and let others perish in ignorance. We must know, and be convinced, that by his power of foreknowledge he measured out to each what each deserved, for each one's good, and gave it. For he foresees each person's choice even before that person exists.

On 1 Corinthians 2:10: By "the depths of God" he means God's deepest dispensations, which escape our notice. By these words he shows that the Spirit searches, not as one who does not know, but as one who knows. Some say that "Spirit" here means the Father, others the Son, so we must answer both. It cannot mean the Father, for he says, "We have received not the spirit of the world, but the Spirit that is from God" (1 Corinthians 2:12), and no one is from himself; if it were said of God, from whom would God be? One might suspect it means the Son, but he cannot be the one the passage is about. Who would say that God the Word searches in order to learn the things of God? And if they were to say that the Son is taught, how did they fail to see from what follows that the Spirit of God knows as a man's spirit knows what is in him? Besides, the whole passage shows that the Holy Spirit is meant. Notice too that he says the Holy Spirit is "from God," but he did not say the unclean spirit is "from the world," only "of the world." The Paraclete is not a part of God, but the devil, since he came into being, is a part of creation. The Holy Spirit, then, is from God.

On 1 Corinthians 2:11–13: He does not mean that, as our spirit within us is better than we are, so the Spirit in God is better than God, when he says straight away, "For who among men knows the things of a man except the spirit that is in him?" Then what of "in," and of "from God"? "In him" points to a part that fills out the whole man, while "from him" points to the cause. Note too that God and the Holy Spirit are two persons, while a man and the spirit in him are not two persons but one man. So, to show that the Father and the Spirit are exactly the same in knowledge, he compared the knowledge of the spirit in us with the knowledge of the Father and the Spirit. As in us there is no discord within the one and the same spirit, that is, the soul and the mind, and we know what we know, so in the Father and the Holy Spirit there is no discord of knowledge, but sameness. "That we might know the things freely given to us by God": the Spirit gave them, and the mind took hold of them. "Which we also speak." Again he shows something more: not only, he says, not…

Greek · §4

The Greek is on each section page: §4

The distinction between the natural and spiritual mind§5

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

5…discover by reasoning what has been revealed to us; we also proclaim it. We do not dress it up in fine words but "compare spiritual things with spiritual," grasping his revelations by the power of the Spirit and proclaiming them in due order. "Comparing spiritual things with spiritual": when a second revelation interprets and clarifies the earlier one, those who received the revelations compared the later with the earlier, found them the same, and so gained a firmer assurance of the truth revealed.

The second catena form adds: Of a man he said "the spirit that is in him," but of the Holy Spirit he did not say "that is in God"; he said "that is from God." There is a great difference between "in him" and "from God." He was exact when he called the Holy Spirit "from God," as a living being with its own subsistence, and the unclean spirit "of the world," as something that fills out the world's substance; for the devil is part of its creation, in that he came into being. The word "comparing" can also be taken in the opposite sense, as "distinguishing" and "separating"; but the first sense is better.

On 1 Corinthians 2:14–15: "The natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit." By "natural" he means the man who keeps in step with his own reasonings. "For they are folly to him." So deep is the spiritual revelation that to the wise of this world it looks like folly, so far beyond their grasp is God's revelation. The grace of the Holy Spirit, as it displayed its power, refuted the man of technique, and not by technique but by the force of its wonders. Spiritual people do not overturn reasonings with reasonings. They receive the mind that comes from God and the revelation that comes from there, and they speak from that, so that whoever opposes them is not refuting reasonings but setting himself against the knowledge of God. That is why he says, "For who has known the mind of the Lord, so as to instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ" (1 Corinthians 2:16), that is, his knowledge.

The second catena form adds: Or he means the man who is sick in the reasonings of his soul and is not sound in his grasp of the truth, just as he calls "fleshly" the man who is sick with fleshly desires and a slave of pleasures. So the natural man cannot take the truth in. His soul has been so damaged that he thinks God's dispensation and grace are folly. "And he cannot know, because he is examined spiritually." The natural man looks for clever arguments about the cross and pushes the preaching away as foolish and unconvincing. Because he does not look to the wonders the Spirit works, he can no longer even see that he is setting himself against the truth while the power and wonders of the Spirit refute him. "Is examined" means that he is refuted closely and after scrutiny. But the spiritual man, who has received the Spirit, uses the signs he displays to refute everything that others wrongly bring as refutation, while he himself is refuted by no one. Then, to confirm the argument, he cites the Old Testament as well and says:

On 1 Corinthians 2:16: "Will instruct" means "will correct." "We have the mind…

Greek · §5

The Greek is on each section page: §5

Judgment of Works and the Temple of God§6

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

6…of Christ our God." If men cannot grasp the mind of God so as to know it, then they cannot know ours either, since we have the mind and wisdom of God.

On 1 Corinthians 3:1–3: Unbelievers are more ready to follow wonders. So I gave you a word, but not the perfect and hidden wisdom, the dispensation of the Passion, which only the mature among believers accept. He also uses "milk" as a figure for moral teaching and for coming to faith through signs, and "solid food" for the proclamation of divine doctrines. "Milk" can also mean the light commands: "Honor your father and your mother" (Exodus 20:12), "You shall not commit adultery" (Exodus 20:14), and the like, and "Come, follow me" (Matthew 19:21). Then, when he says, "You are fleshly and walk in a merely human way," he means: you honor what is human and do not seek the things of God.

On 1 Corinthians 3:5: That is, equal in their service.

On 1 Corinthians 3:6–10: Some of this he says in terms of farming, some in terms of building. He says that he himself planted, made the beginning, and laid the foundation of God's building. He charges those who build on the foundation after him not to treat the building as a side task. By "foundation" he means the faith and the preaching.

On 1 Corinthians 3:11–15: Christ is not called the foundation of creation, as the Arians falsely insist, but of the faith. Christ was preached, and the whole building rises on this foundation. Those who teach preach one faith and proclaim the life of the gospel; it is up to us to make ourselves precious stones, or wood, hay or straw. So when he says, "Let each one take care how he builds on it," what can that refer to if not to how we live? "For no one can lay any other foundation than the one already laid." The teacher proclaims Christ and passes on his commands; the rest is to become like gold through purity, or like hay through weakness. So when he charges, "Let each one take care," and what follows, he is addressing those who wanted to be named after the men who baptized or taught them. "If anyone's work that he has built on it remains": you see that the builder builds something good. But sometimes it does not remain, because the will has changed for the worse. "If anyone's work is burned up, he will suffer loss, but he himself will be saved, yet so as through fire." The words are out of their natural order. It should be read: "If anyone's work is burned up, it will suffer loss, yet so as through fire," meaning that it will be burned up and suffer loss as through fire, "but he himself will be saved," for the turn for the worse did not happen through him.

This is said with the words out of their natural order, so that it runs: "If anyone's work remains, he will receive a reward, and he himself will be saved. If anyone's work is burned, it will suffer loss and be burned as through fire." But how will he himself be saved if the work he built is burned up? "Yet so as through fire": he will be judged on whether he left out anything that served to correct sinners or to warn them, as in Ezekiel.

On 1 Corinthians 3:16–18: He turns again to those who trust in their own wisdom. He calls believers temples of God, and he says that those who trust in eloquence destroy the temple of God, as the next words will show: "If anyone among you thinks he is wise in this age, let him become a fool." Why, then, does someone who trusts in outside wisdom destroy the temple? If you are God's temple, you ought to have him as your teacher and revealer. But if you leave the one who dwells in you and rely on your own intelligence, you no longer keep the temple a temple; you destroy it. "If anyone among you thinks he is wise" is aimed at those who are struck and harmed by outside learning, for by saying "among you" he marked them off.

Those who have been instructed, who have received the word of knowledge into themselves and have not been shaken from the teaching, he calls temples of the Holy Spirit and unshakable houses of the Spirit who has come to dwell in them. Those who have done something worthy of the Spirit's working he calls spiritual, just as we call people orators and craftsmen when they have given a display of their oratory and their craft. So those who take in a different teaching drawn from outside wisdom have ruined their own reasoning, debasing the faith, the Spirit's temple, like counterfeit coin. That is why he threatens that God will destroy them: they left the Teacher who dwells in them and wandered off after outside wisdom, which is well able to supply deceit.

On 1 Corinthians 3:21–23: Having charged them not to accept outside wisdom, he teaches them not to boast in wise men either…

Greek · §6

The Greek is on each section page: §6

The False Judgment of Disciples§7

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

7…for such boasting is cheap when all things are yours: the apostles (they were sent for the sake of those who would benefit), the world, which came to be for your enjoyment, life, since you are being saved, and death (if death held no terrors, the things of the life to come would not have been preferred to this one). "Things present and things to come" are said on the same principle: those who despise present things as passing obtain the things to come. So all the things he has listed are yours, because you have become Christ's, and those who are made Christ's own are pleasing to God.

The second catena form adds: "All things are yours." How, and in what way? Because you have become Christ's. And to show that those who are made Christ's own are pleasing to God, he added, "and Christ is God's."

On 1 Corinthians 4:1: It is enough for us to be honored as servants of Christ; to have people named after us is offensive.

On 1 Corinthians 4:2: Look on us as servants of God, but do not you inquire which servant is faithful, for that is where your danger lies; and it is not right for teachers to be judged by their pupils. Why does he say this? He was aware that they honored some unworthy teachers and passed over worthy ones, and he foresaw that this would lead to schisms among them. That is why he rebukes them so sharply, hurrying to check the trouble.

On 1 Corinthians 4:3: So that he would not seem to say this out of disdain, as a man who had been slighted, he all but says: Do not think I am sending you this on my own account. I do not live in a way that calls for me to be examined by you. I think that beneath me, where you or any man is concerned. By "a human day" he means human beings, pointing to how passing and short-lived human life is. Then, since "I know nothing against myself" seems a large claim, he added, "but I am not justified by this." For a man can stumble through ignorance without his conscience pricking him. Besides, it is not avoiding evil that justifies; it is achieving virtue that makes a man complete. It is likely, too, that he said this out of restraint: do not think more highly than befits you, but wait for the judge.

On 1 Corinthians 4:5: All the way through he keeps to his aim, bringing to their senses those who wanted to be named after one man and not after another, for that is what people do who sit in judgment on who is worthy and who is not. So do not think more highly than befits you, but wait for the judge. A put-on character can deceive you, but nothing hidden could escape the one who brings to light the hidden things of darkness. He said this because much among them went on by deceit, and unworthy men were honored. Those who were honored were not wholly good; they held to virtue only for show, while those who were good in their nature were passed over. Otherwise he would not have said this.

On 1 Corinthians 4:6: He brings forward himself and Apollos and keeps silent about the names of those who demanded honor and wanted the disciples named after them, so that you may take from us a pattern and an example for treating teachers with moderation. Do not think of us beyond what is written, but regard us as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God (1 Corinthians 4:1), and do not dishonor some teachers while honoring others. Here he exposed their attitude more plainly: whoever was named after one man and slighted another was puffed up on the first man's behalf and turned his conceit against the second.

On 1 Corinthians 4:7: You who want to be called after this man or to drop that one, who judges you? Are you not waiting for the judge? You, whose part is to obey, are waiting for the judge, and yet you put your teacher under your own judgment?

The second catena form adds: And you, a layman, who judges you for what you think or do, that you dare to judge others, and teachers at that? Is it not the Lord? If you, the disciple, wait for the Lord as judge, how can you put your teacher under your own judgment, calling one worthy and another unworthy?

Why do you think you have an advantage that you neither have nor have received? He means the surpassing intelligence that would let a person judge and test even teachers. Even if you received your understanding from God, you must give the glory to God who gave it, not think great things of yourself and be lifted up, putting it forward as an advantage of your own.

On 1 Corinthians 4:8: Not that things really stood so with them; he shows that this was their state of mind. They held false opinions of themselves and thought they had been filled with all knowledge, to the point of judging even their teachers. Already the gifts have become a surfeit to you, and you no longer long for them. "Without us" means: before we reigned, you got there first and reigned. And by setting "would that you did reign" in between…

Greek · §7

The Greek is on each section page: §7

The Purpose of Paul's Visit and Correction§8

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

8…he shows how he himself feels. Then, by saying "so that we too might reign with you," he makes plain that he counts their successes as blessings of his own. It is reasonable, too, to read "you have reigned" and "you have become rich" as questions, so that the words carry the same tone as "Already you are filled."

On 1 Corinthians 4:9: As I see it, if you have become rich and have reigned without us, then we who have endured everything have become the last of all, men condemned to death. "To men," he says, because they see our sufferings, "and to angels," because they marvel at our steadfastness.

On 1 Corinthians 4:10: These words are of the same kind. Those who teach you live in contempt and poverty, so that the world even takes them for fools, while you who are taught want to be already in wealth and in the honors of Christ. He says this to show that in spiritual gifts "a disciple is not above his teacher" (Matthew 10:24).

On 1 Corinthians 4:11–13: We endure everything for Christ's sake, and to this day we humble ourselves. How then can you, living in the flesh, be preferred before God to those who toil, are persecuted, are reviled and are beaten? Through all this he teaches what a Christian must be like, and how he must humble himself. That is, scrapings. We have become like the sweepings and the dung carried out of a house that has been cleaned, despised by everyone, and we are the refuse of all, putting ourselves beneath everyone for Christ's sake. And "offscouring" is the word for the towel that wipes the sweat off a laborer and rubs away the grime that clings to him.

On 1 Corinthians 4:14: Having attacked them hard in the earlier words, he comforts them with these, so that by mixing the astringent with the sweet he may make up a medicine with the power to save. "Shaming" means putting to confusion.

On 1 Corinthians 4:15: By calling himself their father, and the men they were named after their tutors, he shows that his affection for them is truer than the others', and that, since a father is the one warning them, they ought not to take offense.

On 1 Corinthians 4:16: Become imitators of me by not looking down on anyone or being lifted up, and by being called after no one but Christ.

On 1 Corinthians 4:18–20: You see that what he said earlier, "We are weak, but you are strong," and all the rest, was said because some had become puffed up and proud. "But I will come to you soon, if the Lord wills, and I will find out not the talk of those who are puffed up but their power." In these words he rebukes them strongly, and by threatening to come in person he himself bears witness that they can still be set right. He announces his coming as if to see whether they will show themselves humbled, and corrects them by his word before he comes. Yet he added "if the Lord wills." Indignation drove him to say "I will come," but reverence reminded him to add that finest of additions, "if the Lord wills." Here he brings into the open what he had said earlier in veiled terms, so as not to seem to rebuke them too harshly: "for the kingdom of God is not in word," meaning polished speech, since the apostles did not teach and preach without words.

The second catena form adds: He announces his coming so that they may set themselves right before he arrives. It becomes clearer from this that his anger is aimed at those who boast in the wisdom of this world, for he does not mean to discredit ordinary speech; and this he proclaimed to them too, for all to hear.

On 1 Corinthians 4:21: Correction comes in two forms: by admonition for those who will listen, and by force and compulsion for the stiff-necked. In his kindness he left the choice between them to the Corinthians, so that they might repent and set themselves right. By "rod" he meant the compelling power of the Spirit, which Paul used against Elymas (Acts 13:8–11), and which God used against Paul himself (Acts 9:3–9).

On 1 Corinthians 5:1–5: They were puffed up, not because that man had a woman in the way described, but because he was eloquent. They did not mourn that he had his father's wife; they were proud that he was well educated. Their mourning would either have cut the fornicator off if he persisted, or driven the outrage out and brought him back. Not simply "who did" but "who has carried out": he did not fall because he was swept away; he made the evil his deliberate work. And he says that he is present in spirit, casting his vote with them and joining in the condemnation (by "spirit" he means…

Greek · §8

The Greek is on each section page: §8

The Leaven of Sin and the Law§9

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

9…the gift), "when you are gathered together, with the power of Christ." Those who were puffed up over the fornicator because of his eloquence were only part of the whole church, but he calls everyone to gather to condemn the fornication. By "the spirit," they have said, he means not the soul but the gift.

The second catena form adds: So as not to seem stirred to anger without reason, he adds its cause: not only fornication, but fornication of a kind not found even among the Gentiles, is reported among you. And you are proud of having been adorned with the wisdom of the world, when you ought to mourn over him for daring a fornication that is not customary even among others. He did not say "who did" but "who has carried out," to make plain that he did the evil with long persistence; he did not sin because he was swept away, which would have given him some excuse. The apostle could have condemned him on his own, but he wants the Corinthians to cast their votes with him, so that in this way they may be cleansed by cutting themselves off from fellowship with the lawbreaker, above all those who were puffed up over their learning. He does not do this to put the man under Satan's power, for by doing that he would have delighted Satan. Rather, we are used to blaming Satan for all the hardships of life, such as diseases, griefs, bereavements and other troubles; as the apostle himself says somewhere, "A thorn of Satan was given to me, to buffet me" (2 Corinthians 12:7). In just this way he now orders him handed over to Satan, that is, to the hardships of life. He hands him over to life's afflictions, for that is what "for the destruction of the flesh" means, not the ruin of the soul: so that, roused by what happens to his body, he may repent, and the spirit in him, which is the gift, may be saved. He does not mean the soul here, as though the flesh did not rise and the soul alone were saved.

On 1 Corinthians 5:6: You see that they boasted about him. They paid no attention to how shocking his fall was; his eloquence had puffed them up. He orders him expelled, so that the rest, by keeping company with him, do not also rush shamelessly into sin.

On 1 Corinthians 5:7: By "old leaven" he means sin, with which the old man was leavened through and through. He carries the type over to the reality. The unleavened bread of the Jews, unmixed with old leaven, foreshadowed the new people, unmixed with the sins of the old man. The lamb sacrificed among the Jews showed forth the Passion and the whole mystery of the dispensation of the cross. He says what follows because leaven is a more elaborate thing, while unleavened bread is simpler.

On 1 Corinthians 5:8: He stayed with the figure, as if to say: not in a wicked and evil life, but in a life with no admixture of that old leaven. That is what "with the unleavened bread of sincerity and truth" means.

On 1 Corinthians 5:9–10: He wrote this not in another letter but in this one. He does not forbid keeping company with outsiders, because if they had shunned everyone of that kind, the preaching would have been hindered. Nearly everyone among the Gentiles, so to speak, was like that, and these people stood to gain from the company of believers. So he makes clear that we should rebuke our own people when they sin, but appeal to those who have gone astray.

The second catena form adds: He says, after all, "But now I have written to you" (1 Corinthians 5:11).

On 1 Corinthians 5:13: "Drive out the wicked man from among yourselves" is a saying of Moses which Paul repeats (Deuteronomy 17:7). He recalls a saying found in the Old Testament to show not only that they gain by it, like people rid of a plague, but also that such a step is no innovation: the lawgiver too thought that such people should be cut off.

On 1 Corinthians 5:12: He said this with good reason, for it is of his own…

Greek · §9

The Greek is on each section page: §9

The Body and the Temporary Nature of Food§10

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

10…people that a man becomes judge, not of outsiders. But God is the judge of all, since he is the Master of all.

On 1 Corinthians 6:1: He reproaches them because, though they had saints who could judge their cases, they were going to law before unbelievers.

On 1 Corinthians 6:2: Having said above, "You judge those inside, but God will judge those outside," he now puts the whole world under the judgment of the saints. Here, they examine the lives of believers in order to correct them; there, they are entrusted with judging the world, not to correct sinful ways but to expose and condemn them. The twelve apostles will judge the twelve tribes (Matthew 19:28), Jews judging Jews, on the evidence of the very prophets the tribes believed in; yet they did not believe, and that is why they rejected Christ. The other holy ones, that is, those from the nations, will condemn those who did not turn away from idols and believe in the true God. So there is no disagreement between the evangelist and the apostle, for Christ spoke in both. It is written, "The queen of the south will rise up and condemn this generation, and the men of Nineveh will rise up and condemn you" (Matthew 12:41–42).

On 1 Corinthians 6:3: Did he not say, "and the world is judged by you"? Here, by "angels" he does not mean angels by nature, but the ministering priests, the teachers of the people, who will very likely be judged by the saints for teaching falsely about Christ. By saying, "how much more the things of this life?" he showed that he was not speaking of angels by nature, but of those who hold an angel's rank and do spiritual work. If he did mean angels in the strict sense, he plainly meant those who rebelled and fell away from God. Priests were indeed called angels, as Malachi says: "The lips of a priest shall guard knowledge, and they shall seek the law from his mouth, for he is the angel of the Lord of hosts" (Malachi 2:7). So these are the priests we judge, the ones who led the people astray, and likewise those who founded heresies and twisted Christ's teaching.

On 1 Corinthians 6:4: The least member of the church is a better choice than an unbeliever. Yet the apostle seems to have left something unsaid that is plain enough: the more serious charges must be kept for the mature.

On 1 Corinthians 6:7: You show that the devil has beaten you, not only by going to law before unbelievers, but by the very fact that you have lawsuits with one another.

On 1 Corinthians 6:11: He spoke of one working of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit in those who are justified, and so taught that their substance is one.

On 1 Corinthians 6:12–13: By "by anything" he means not a person but a thing, for this is what the passage is about: "Food is for the stomach and the stomach for food, and God will do away with both the one and the other."

The second catena form adds: He means a shameful thing and a passion. Speaking about himself, he urges the others to self-control. He knew that their greed came from the belly, for most people will dare anything for the pleasures of the belly, so he teaches that it does no good to be a slave to one's stomach.

"We know that food is for the stomach." The stomach, too, is set apart for food; yet these things are temporary, and God will bring them to an end. After the resurrection, when immortality is given, there will be no more need of food. Why then do you take such pains over temporary things, which breed fornication and shameful pleasures?

On 1 Corinthians 6:14: It is plain that food and eating are temporary. But the body is set apart not for fornication but for the Lord, and the Lord for the body. So the body cannot be temporary; it will be raised to last for ever, after the pattern of Christ.

On 1 Corinthians 6:15: By the body and members of Christ he means the body of those who have believed and been baptized.

On 1 Corinthians 6:16–19: Whatever sin a man commits to feed or clothe his body, he commits to adorn it and supply its needs, and so to honor the body. But the man who joins himself to a prostitute, making his own body one body with her, outrages and dishonors it. Clothes and finery are outside the body, so whoever sins over them sins outside the body. Or again: the slanderer, or the liar, harms and robs others, and a man commits adultery with another man's wife; but the fornicator outrages himself, and the harm of the act passes to no one else. So whatever sin a man commits, he has sinned, but not against his own body, nor has he dishonored his own flesh as the fornicator has. And yet a murderer, staining his hand with blood, also sins against his own body, and so does the slanderer, who bloodies his tongue, as it were, with his abuse. But the fornicator, he says, plunges his whole self into the…

Greek · §10

The Greek is on each section page: §10

Marriage and Self-Control§11

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

11…mire of fornication. So Paul fell in with the common opinion when he said that the other sins are outside the body. Others say the text means this: the fornicator sins against his own body, that is, against the very make-up of his own body, against the very structure of a human being, so to speak, and against the origins of our birth. It is as if he said: stop outraging, by unlawful intercourse, the workshop of nature from which your own body also sprang. Others again say that Paul was eager to show that the sin of fornication is beyond pardon. He had said above, "Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ?" and so on, and had shown from this that the fornicator offends against the members of Christ. So he goes on, "Every sin," and the rest. The slanderer, the robber or the grasping man has offended against the person he slandered or wronged, but the fornicator sins against his own body, which is the members of Christ. Once a man has become part of the body of Christ through the adoption the Spirit gives, he will be charged not with fornication only but with impiety as well, since he makes the members of Christ the members of a prostitute and outrages his own body as Christ's temple. That is why he adds, "Or do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit within you, whom you have from God," and so on. In the sin of fornication you sin against the body as against God's temple, and it drives the Holy Spirit away. Not that the other sins go unpunished, for every one of them costs a man the kingdom; but, given the case in hand, he was eager to declare fornication the worst of all. He wanted to tear the passion out by the roots, since the Corinthians were committing it with particular impiety: "It is actually reported," he says, "that there is fornication among you" (1 Corinthians 5:1), and so on.

On 1 Corinthians 6:19–20: The fornicator is guilty of impiety as well, for by outraging his own body he has defiled the temple of the Holy Spirit. He says this because some were committing fornication with contempt, thinking it a small slip, or no slip at all, since Moses did not even mention it in his Ten Commandments. The price is the saving blood of Christ, which he gave as a ransom for us. Glorify God, then, not only in the gift but in the body as well, so that nature, will and gift may all glorify God.

The second catena form adds: "Glorify God, then, in your body and in your spirit." Others have taken "spirit" to mean the soul.

On 1 Corinthians 7:1: He wrote this in reply to the clergy, for it was they who had written to the apostle. He forbade fornication as unlawful, allowed the partnership of marriage as godly and as a release from fornication, and praised continence as the more perfect way.

On 1 Corinthians 7:2–4: He teaches that those joined in marriage have authority over each other rather than over themselves. It is a fine debt for those who live together when, besides the rest of their harmony, they know to pay each other this one as something owed. The apostle stooped so far as a matter of wise management, to cut out fornication, the worst of diseases, by teaching this.

On 1 Corinthians 7:5: Since he had said that they are each other's servants, he goes on, consistently, to say that they must not deprive each other of themselves, except by a godly agreement. Otherwise they may become the cause of each other's fornication, or ruin their authority over each other by parting against each other's will.

On 1 Corinthians 7:6–7: It is in allowance for the nature of the body that I say you should come together again, since I am not saying this to shut out continence for you; I want everyone to be continent, as I am myself.

On 1 Corinthians 7:8–9: He advises widows, and unmarried men who have not taken up virginity, to be continent; but if the flesh got the better of them, to marry. He shows by this that continence is a great thing; yet he allows marriage as a good bond.

On 1 Corinthians 7:10–11: He would not have said that a wife must not separate from her husband about those who separate in order to renounce the world and give themselves to Christ. "Let her be reconciled to her husband, or remain unmarried" is plainly about those who part because of some quarrel. Above he spoke of separation for the sake of continence; here, of separation that comes from bickering. Then he said, "not I but the Lord," because there are things the apostle says on his own, and the Lord did not say everything in person. He means: I charge you with what the Lord already charged in the Gospels about married people, when he said, "What God…

Greek · §11

The Greek is on each section page: §11

Paul's Counsel on Virginity§12

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

12…has joined together, let no man separate" (Matthew 19:6). These words too, "but if she does separate, let her remain unmarried," agree with what the Lord said: "If anyone marries a woman who has been divorced, he commits adultery" (Matthew 5:32), and so does she, if she is married to another.

On 1 Corinthians 7:12: When he says, "I, not the Lord," he is not laying down a law against the Lord's. Some things the Lord said in person; others, about parting from an unbelieving spouse, are said now for the first time by the apostle. And he teaches that unbelief does not overpower faith; rather, the faith of the believing partner sanctifies even the unbeliever.

On 1 Corinthians 7:13: He is not speaking of taking an unbeliever in marriage, but of bearing with an unbeliever.

On 1 Corinthians 7:14: The children are holy: clean, and not defiled even by the unbelief, for in them the parents' faith wins out over the unbelief.

On 1 Corinthians 7:17: To one God assigned the task of saving, to another that of being saved, giving each what each deserved. By "as God has assigned to each" he does not mean having an unbelieving spouse, but bearing with one.

On 1 Corinthians 7:18–24: Circumcision is not good in itself; it was good because God commanded it. Uncircumcision is God's handiwork, not a reward the uncircumcised have earned. Then he says to the slave: do not set your heart on a freedom that will pass; even if you can gain it, make use of your slavery instead. The reward is greater when a man busy in the service of men does not neglect to please God. Let each one remain in the state in which he was called, the slave not chafing at his slavery, the free man not puffed up, for with God there is no difference.

In this respect a believing slave has nothing less than a free man. With God the slave too is seen as free, and has been set free by him. That is what "is the Lord's freedman" means: he has been freed by the Lord. And the man called to the faith as a free man will have nothing more than the slave; he is Christ's slave just as the other is.

That is: do not, for the sake of your needs, live like slaves, without a free man's spirit, courting men, and so abandon the true Master, whose blood bought you.

Grace knows no difference between slavery and mastery. So do not run from slavery as though it were unworthy of the faith; because of it you have no less than anyone else in the faith. And even if you could obtain your freedom, let your concern be rather how you can make better use of what you have, as one whose care is to be free from evil. To show that the free man has no more with Christ on that account, and that the slave is not made less, he adds, for that very reason: "For he who was called in the Lord as a slave is the Lord's freedman; likewise he who was called as a free man is Christ's slave."

On 1 Corinthians 7:25–26: Elsewhere he says, "since you seek proof of Christ speaking in me" (2 Corinthians 13:3); how then does he now say, "I have no command of the Lord"? Who would accept him if he says what the Lord has not commanded him? Plainly he does not mean that he has no command to teach about virginity. He means that he did not receive from God the right to order you to remain virgins, but rather to give his opinion and advise that virginity is good and useful. That is why, as one giving advice, he says "I think" and calls it "good," and leaves the choice of taking it up to his hearers. The thing is pleasing to God, as the Lord too said that some have made themselves eunuchs for the sake of the kingdom (Matthew 19:12), calling virginity "becoming a eunuch" because the body is left unused. So he says he has no command, and the matter was left to each one's judgment with the words, "Let him who can accept it accept it" (Matthew 19:12). Then, by calling himself trustworthy, he makes plain that what he says is trustworthy and fit to be a command. He says "I think" not because he doubts that virginity is good, but to make sure it is not taken for a command.

On 1 Corinthians 7:28: He showed that he brings in virginity, not to accuse marriage, but to spare the saints; for marriage fills the flesh with birth pains and toil.

The second catena form adds: He is concerned to set them free from the cares of this life, and after saying, "I would spare you," he recommends virginity to spare the saints.

On 1 Corinthians 7:29–31: He gives another reason for preferring virginity, and shows throughout that he does not accuse marriage when he prefers holiness. The world is near its end, and we must recognize that what we have we do not really have, since we leave it behind: "so that those who have wives may be as though they had none." If it is good for those who have to have as though they had not, how much better for the virgin not to enter marriage at all? "And those who use this world as though not using it to the full": by this he rules out unmeasured enjoyment, but need…

Greek · §12

The Greek is on each section page: §12

Knowledge and Love§13

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

13…he leaves in place. The words “the form of this world is passing away” (1 Corinthians 7:31) show that the world itself does not pass away. What changes is the form of the present life, corruption turning into incorruption: cities, walls, laws, farming, crafts. These lie over this life like a kind of outward shape, and it is that shape which undergoes change.

The second catena form adds: By this he makes plain how brief human life is, so that people may turn to repentance, as men who have already reached the end of life and so look down on passing things. That is: do not let the griefs of this life cast you down, and do not let what seems worth rejoicing over carry you away with joy, for everything here is passing and does not stand. The form and shape of the world, as it were, are its civic life, laws, farming, crafts and trade, and none of them will be needed once corruption has been changed into incorruption.

On 1 Corinthians 7:32: He has shown why he said, “But I am sparing you” (1 Corinthians 7:28): so that you do not pour out your cares on things that do not last. What follows shows this still more clearly. He has given the reason why virginity is preferred to marriage. It is not the marriage bed, or abstaining from it, but that marriage is full of cares, and that the mind should be occupied, as God wills, with devotion.

On 1 Corinthians 7:36–38: Some think he means a man behaving shamefully toward himself, as if the sense were, “if anyone thinks he is behaving shamefully toward his own virginity.” That is not so, and what follows proves it, for he says, “So then he who gives her in marriage does well, and he who does not give her in marriage does better” (1 Corinthians 7:38). Nobody gives himself in marriage; one is given by someone else.

On 1 Corinthians 7:40: In the judgment of this blessed man, the better course is to remain as she is. Marriage belongs to bodily ease; remaining belongs to a more perfect devotion. This is said by way of comparison. She is blessed if she marries and has a husband to protect her, but more blessed if, with her eyes on devotion, she does not marry and gives herself wholly to God.

On 1 Corinthians 8:1–3: The Corinthians were eating food offered to idols and saying, “For us there is no such thing as idol food; I make it holy by calling on the name of Christ, and I eat.” So he shows that they are not the only wise ones who know this, and says, “We know that we all have knowledge.” In other words: what you know, I know too, but what you suffer, I do not suffer. What you know and I know is not the point to look at. What I know, that one must not eat for the sake of the weak, you do not know, but I do. Why then are you puffed up by a knowledge that comes nowhere near mine? So he goes on: “If anyone among you thinks he knows something, he has not yet known as he ought to know.” For example, what I know, you do not yet know. “But if anyone loves God, he is known by him.” Whatever we, as human beings, may suppose we know, we do not yet know anything. And what is blessedness? To love God and to be known by him. This is not because he is unaware of those who do not love him, but because he makes those who love him his own. “Knowing” is used for making someone one's own, just as “not knowing” is used for estrangement, as in the Lord's words, “Depart; I never knew you” (Matthew 7:23).

The second catena form adds: Knowledge of this kind, then, puffs up and does harm if you know only your own point and not the other one as well, that love builds up. For out of love you must also, for the sake of the…

Greek · §13

The Greek is on each section page: §13

Apostolic Authority and Conduct§14

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

14…weak brother, not eat in an idol's temple, so that he is not wounded. The one among you who thinks he knows something knows nothing, for he did not realize that others were being harmed by what these people knew.

On 1 Corinthians 8:6: He had said first, “There is no God but one” (1 Corinthians 8:4). So that he would not seem to cast the Son out of the Godhead, he added “the Father.” And truly there is no other Father but one; so too there is no other God the Son but one. If the Son is called the one Lord and the Father is no less Lord, then clearly, when the Father is called the one God, the Son is no less God. “From whom are all things” does not point to substance, since created things do not come from God's substance; the “from whom” points to the Father's will. Then, by saying “and we to him,” he lets us supply what the phrase leaves out: “but for us there is one God, and we hope in him.” Again, something is left out of “and we through him”: “we have been called,” or “we have been saved.” He is not saying that we came into being through him, for by saying “all things” he had already included “we.” “All things” means everything that came into being; “we” means those who were brought under his saving plan and are being saved.

What you gain is nothing; what harms the weaker ones is great.

On 1 Corinthians 8:10–12: What knowledge? That God is one and an idol is nothing in the world.

The second catena form adds: The one who does not have this knowledge, that God is one and an idol is nothing in the world, thinks he is eating idol food and is wounded. Your knowledge harms the weak one. Many even of those who have believed have not yet understood that there is no such thing as idol food, and they are harmed by the believer who eats.

On 1 Corinthians 8:13–9:1: I do not just say that I will not eat idol food; I will not eat meat at all if my brother is made to stumble by it. He shows that even where he had a right, such as being fed by them, he would not bear to burden anyone. He builds this case through many points. First he mentions his own rank, to show the grounds on which he could reasonably have received support had he wished to receive it, just as the others too received from those they received from. “I too,” he says, “am an apostle. I have authority over myself, and I am under no one who compels me to receive or forbids me. The other apostles may have something more than I do, in having been with Christ, but I am not without even that.”

On 1 Corinthians 9:2: To those who question me whether I am an apostle, this is my defense: you, my seal, and my teaching. Do I not give orders as an apostle? Do I not lay down laws for the churches? Am I under other teachers? So I have the right, but I do not use it to the full, so that I may not make some of little faith stumble because of me.

On 1 Corinthians 9:3: That is, the confirmation and the proof.

On 1 Corinthians 9:4: He shows that the law has laid down that those who serve, whether at altars or in the gospel, live from them.

On 1 Corinthians 9:5: By saying “wife” and adding “sister,” he made clear that the woman who travels with an apostle is fitting, chaste and pure, whether she was a spouse or not. Clearly women did travel with Peter and the others, eager for their teaching. He does not say this to cast blame, far from it. He is showing how far his own strictness of life went, and shaming the Corinthians into not living carelessly, so that they do not become a stumbling block to others.

On 1 Corinthians 9:6: Or are we alone forbidden to do what others do? He put in Barnabas as his fellow worker so as not to seem proud, as if he alone were doing right.

On 1 Corinthians 9:8: These are not my own words that I speak. Does not the law say the same?

On 1 Corinthians 9:15: “I have not written this,” he says, “to carry off something from you. Far from it!”

On 1 Corinthians 9:19: It is no great thing if you keep away from idol food for your brother's sake. I too made myself a slave to those I am not subject to, so that I might help many.

On 1 Corinthians 9:20: By “Jews” he means those who are Israelites by birth. By “those under the law” he means those who are not of their race but who keep the law of the Jews and have become proselytes.

On 1 Corinthians 9:21: By “those outside the law” he means the Greeks, who are not under the law of Moses. He did not say, “To the Greeks I became as a Greek,” because he would not stoop even to pretend to Greek religion. So by “those outside the law” he means those who have turned from the nations.

On 1 Corinthians 9:22: I seemed to those who came from the Greeks not to be under the law, and I bore that reputation in order to rescue them from Jewish observances. So he gave way to everyone at the start, bringing himself along with them, so that, having gone along with them, he might, little by little, toward himself…

Greek · §14

The Greek is on each section page: §14

Testing God and the End of the Age§15

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

15…draw them over. People do not come to terms at all with those who agree with them in nothing, but they do with those who come part of the way to meet them.

On 1 Corinthians 9:23: Since the gospel too seems not to have made use of the law, I copied its way of managing things, handling matters as it wishes, so that in this very respect I may share in it.

On 1 Corinthians 9:24: He does not mean that one out of all of us is picked; otherwise people would have given up on themselves, seeing how hard success is. Clearly the picture is drawn with the nations he has just named in view. Everyone, he says, competes in this life as in a stadium: Jews by the law, Greeks by their error. But one alone is the word of truth, the one that wins and takes the prize. So run, so that you are not left behind with the rest.

On 1 Corinthians 9:25: What great thing is it, he says, if you abstain from meat for your brother's sake? The athlete must master himself in everything: in anger, in glory, and in all the rest. They do it to win a crown that perishes, but we a crown that does not. He did not say this idly. He was correcting those who, to fill their bellies, put on a show of philosophy and said that idol food is not idol food.

On 1 Corinthians 10:1–8: The inspired Paul brings forward the types from the old covenant and the shadows there that sketched in advance the truth to come, so as to sober the Corinthians by setting the ancients beside them. If, he says, those who were baptized into Moses, who was a type of Christ, in the cloud and the sea, who ate the manna, the spiritual food, and drank the spiritual drink from the rock, were struck down in the wilderness when they turned to drunkenness, fornication and idolatry, because they insulted the type and the shadow, what would those not suffer who sin against the truth itself?

On 1 Corinthians 10:9: Since they were saying, “For me there is no idol; I give thanks and eat,” this, he says, is putting the Lord to the test. When you do something Jesus did not command, as though you were trusting him, you are testing him rather than trusting him.

On 1 Corinthians 10:11: The coming of Christ has reached you, he says, and after it there will be no further commandment, no law, no prophets. By “the ends” he does not mean the last generation, at which the world will reach its completion, but the final way of life, the life in Christ, upon which the completion of the ages will arrive.

On 1 Corinthians 10:13: He did not pray that they should not be tested, since an untested man is unproven, but that they should be tested in a way they could bear.

The second catena form adds: From this he shows that those among them who believed had to endure some unpleasantness from their fellow citizens.

On 1 Corinthians 10:14: You see that everything he said before was being built up for this.

On 1 Corinthians 10:20: Do not look at their idols, which are nothing, but at the intent with which they sacrifice to demons and not to God. What is done there amounts to a denial of God.

On 1 Corinthians 10:22: It is written that God said to them through Moses, “They provoked me to jealousy with what is no god; they angered me with their idols” (Deuteronomy 32:21). The Corinthians were eating idol food. That is why he says, “Or are we provoking the Lord to jealousy?” meaning “Are we stirring him to anger?” “Are we stronger than he?” By this he showed that the Lord does not want us to eat idol food. So do not want, he says, what the Lord does not want, as though you were stronger and wiser than he.

On 1 Corinthians 10:25: It was likely that, in their scruples, they would no longer dare even to buy food at market for fear of hearing, “You bought idol food.” So he eases that fear. By “conscience” he means not the conscience of the one who knows that an idol is nothing, but that of the one who has seen someone buying the…

Greek · §15

The Greek is on each section page: §15

The Image of God and Order in the Assembly§16

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

16…idol food, and who thinks that idol food is something.

On 1 Corinthians 10:26: What you eat belongs to the Lord, since the earth does too, and everything that fills it.

On 1 Corinthians 10:31: Do everything with care, so that people give glory to God because of you and do not stumble.

On 1 Corinthians 10:32: Do not become a cause of stumbling to Jews and Greeks: see that they do not flee the faith with your bad conduct as their excuse. Nor to the church of God: see that those of little faith are not made to stumble.

On 1 Corinthians 11:2: He praises them now, though they have gone wrong, so that from here on they may at least be persuaded by what he says.

On 1 Corinthians 11:3: He speaks to spur them on rather than to approve them, so that he can then make his exhortation firm in them: “But I want you to know that the head of every man is Christ, the head of a woman is the man, and the head of Christ is God.” Read impiously, this is taken as speaking of the Godhead; read piously, of the saving plan. The subject here is not being made (look: the man did not make the woman), and the order Paul used does not have that in view. It looks only to subordination, not to any difference of nature. In general, what is in view here is not the Godhead of the Only-begotten but the saving plan, which stands closer by nature to the man and the woman.

The followers of Arius say, “As Christ is head of the man because he is his maker, so God is head of Christ as his maker.” They seem not to know what comes next: “the head of the woman is the man.” He is not her maker, and he is of one substance with her; and on the same reasoning we turn out to be of one substance with Christ. So they talk nonsense about everything. “Head” is used here in the sense of ruling, not of making. So whoever has Christ as ruler and head insults his own ruler when he sins. On this reasoning, by being subject to Christ we are subject to God the Father, because God is also the head of Christ.

On 1 Corinthians 11:4: By “prophesying” he means interpreting the prophets. Or else the difference between the prophets of old and the new ones lies here: the old prophets spoke in general terms about the Jews' falling away, the calling of the nations and Christ's coming in the flesh, while the new ones spoke of particular cases, as Peter did with Ananias.

On 1 Corinthians 11:7: From these words it appears that man is the image of God neither in his soul nor in his body. If he were the image in either of these, the woman too would certainly have been called the image of God, since she too has the form of a body and a soul like the man's. If the woman has the same soul and flesh as the man and is still not called the image, then clearly man is the image of God in his rule. When the discussion concerns the creatures without reason, the woman too is the image of God. But when man is weighed against women, the man alone is the image, because male and female among human beings rule over everything on the earth, in the sea and in the air, while the man rules over the woman, and no one on earth rules over the man. As nothing that exists rules over God, so nothing on earth rules over the man. By “nature” we understand the truth of the things themselves.

The second catena form adds: Just as the man who obeys his Sovereign well is the glory and praise of God, so the woman who is rightly subject to him is the glory of the man.

On 1 Corinthians 11:10: The apostle says this because he has seen how rough and unyielding women are, and he reminds them that God has also set angels over us. Some say that the priests of the church are called “angels” here, and that women cover their heads because of them, since women have not been given the freedom to rule. Perhaps he said this because women too used to prophesy by the Holy Spirit. When the Spirit is at work, the ministering angels must be present, and so the woman must cover her head.

On 1 Corinthians 11:14–15: He judged this not by ancient custom but by the custom of their own day. Even those who wore their hair long in the old days cut part of it off, though they wore it longer than they should have; but for a woman to be shorn was always disapproved.

On 1 Corinthians 11:19: By “factions” he means not factions over doctrine but factions over customs and practices.

On 1 Corinthians 11:20–21: He rebukes them because, when they came together as if for communion in the holy body, they did not wait for one another. Some were kept busy by their poverty and came late, and the well-off got in first and did not wait for the others. In their gluttony they neglected the Lord's supper, and toward the…

Greek · §16

The Greek is on each section page: §16

The Body and its Members§17

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

17…suppers of their own they hurried. These they laid on lavishly in the church, as if to show up the want of those who had nothing, since they got drunk while others went hungry. They got in ahead of the communion and enjoyed their own fine food.

On 1 Corinthians 12:1–2: By “spiritual gifts” he now means the workings of the Holy Spirit, which he distributes to each according to worth: to one to preach the gospel, to another to prophesy, to another something else. By saying “you were led away to the idols,” he shows how very different prophecy is from soothsaying. At the idols, those possessed by the unclean spirit are not sober. They are carried off by the unclean spirit and do not go by their own free choice; that is what he shows by “you were led away,” carried off as they were. So he says: you know from what you went through how the unclean spirit works, but the gifts of the Holy Spirit work purely. So the soothsayer is darkened in soul and does not know what he is saying, while the prophet's soul grows brighter; it learns what it did not know and speaks what has been revealed to it. The demon, as an enemy, darkens the soul; the Spirit, as a benefactor, comes to the soul and gives it light. He goes on to show this.

On 1 Corinthians 12:3: Everything blasphemous against Christ is worked by the evil one, who clouds the soul. He says this to guard them against those who pretend to be carried by God and yet speak against Christ. Legion and the Pythian soothsayer both named the Lord Jesus, so we do not say that whoever says this says it perfectly, since many righteous men are called “lords.” What counts is to confess Christ's lordship and mastery over all. Perhaps, too, they said it to test him, as the devil did when he took him up onto the mountain (Matthew 4:8). That is why he does not accept their witness either, since it came from the unworthy and from those testing him.

On 1 Corinthians 12:8–10: “The word of wisdom” is to understand what was spoken in God's wisdom in the prophets and evangelists, and to set it before the hearers. “The word of knowledge” is the revelation of hidden things, which someone who did not know them at first learns from grace and then speaks. “Faith” is simply believing the preaching: merely hearing it is not faith; faith is receiving faithfully what has been said. “Discernment of spirits”: soothsaying has copied prophecy, in that in soothsaying too the Holy Spirit seems to foretell, so he has given the power to tell these apart, so that we are not led astray.

On 1 Corinthians 12:12: He pictures Christ by the whole body made up of many members, meaning the church by “Christ.” Christ is called the head of the church and the church the body of Christ, and here he has named the church “Christ,” pointing to the lesser by the greater.

On 1 Corinthians 12:14: He says this so that they do not look down on the humbler members of the church. Even if someone is lesser by nature, he still contributes to the common good of the church.

On 1 Corinthians 12:27: He did not say “members from members” but “many members from one member,” for the head of the whole body is a member.

On 1 Corinthians 12:28: Since he has spoken of members and a body, he starts from the most honored of the other members after the head, the apostles. By “prophets” he means those in the church, not those under the law. Third, teachers. Do not be surprised that the teacher is placed ahead of those who work healings and mighty deeds. The signs are there so that the knowledge may be believed, and the knowledge is set before people by those who teach. “Helps”: he speaks of this elsewhere: “he who leads, with diligence” (Romans 12:8). “Administrations”: the governing of the church.

On 1 Corinthians 12:31: For this reason he shows that they took great pride in the gift of tongues, and in the other gifts too. So he shows that love is the greatest thing. Those other gifts are given even…

Greek · §17

The Greek is on each section page: §17

Tongues, Love, and Perfect Knowledge§18

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

18…to the unworthy for the building up of the church, but the achievement of love belongs to the devout. So this is what he says: “Earnestly desire the greater gifts. And I am showing you a way” (1 Corinthians 12:31) that leads you to the enjoyment of the greater gifts, and the way is love. The one who loves fulfills the law; the one who fulfills the law wins approval; the one who wins approval receives a spiritual gift.

The second catena form adds: He saw them envying those who had the gifts while their love stayed cold, so he teaches that love is the highest good of all.

On 1 Corinthians 13:1: And what tongue do angels have, when they have no chest, no larynx, no tongue, no voice? But Moses says in Deuteronomy that God set the boundaries of the nations according to the number of the angels of God (Deuteronomy 32:8). He clearly set them at the time when he divided into languages those who had tried to build the tower. They were no longer kept in concord by a common speech; they had become strangers to one another, as it were, through the changes of language. So angels were appointed, each to guard the nation entrusted to him, so that none might be squandered and lost. That is why he calls the difference of languages “tongues of angels.” We should know that, just as David speaks of “bread of angels” (Psalm 78:25) not because angels eat, so he speaks of “tongues of angels” not because angels speak. Both are said because the angels serve God's ordering of things. The “tongue of men,” then, is the trained tongue, for the artful tongue is something brought in on top of the natural one. The “tongue of angels” is the natural tongue divided into many. “I have become sounding brass or a clanging cymbal.” From this it is clear that by “of angels” he means the change and difference of languages. Someone who speaks in other tongues among people who do not know them is like a cymbal that makes only a noise and shows no meaning.

The second catena form adds: By “tongue of men” he means the language of rhetoric, grammar, philosophy, speculation, prose writing, the arts and debate.

On 1 Corinthians 13:2: By “mystery” he means anything that is unknown but revealed by the power of the Spirit. Each such thing is a mystery, as he says elsewhere, “For I do not want you to be ignorant of this mystery” (Romans 11:25), and again, “Look, I tell you a mystery” (1 Corinthians 15:51).

On 1 Corinthians 13:4: A little further on he teaches what love is, where he says, “Love is patient,” and the rest. So showing mercy is one thing and loving is another. Even giving one's property to the poor and handing oneself over to martyrdom, if it is not yet done for love's sake, slips without our noticing into vainglory and empty ambition. So if we share, we must share out of love for the one who receives or out of love for God who commanded it; and if we bear witness, we must endure it out of love for the Lord.

On 1 Corinthians 13:8: “Love never fails”: that is, it never slips into sin.

On 1 Corinthians 13:10: What is partial is done away with when complete knowledge has been given. We know little now, and more still lies hidden.

On 1 Corinthians 13:11–12: When I was a child, he says, I had a child's way of reasoning, but when I grew to full manhood I had a man's understanding. I no longer knew simply that my father is my father, but also in what sense he is a father. In the same way, whatever I know in part now, I will learn at the time of completion; and what I grasp now only dimly, as in a mirror, I will then know clearly. He did not say, “Then I will know mysteries,” which would have been the natural sequel, but “I will be known.” The one who is known by God and made his own is the one who also gains the sight of the mysteries with his own eyes.

On 1 Corinthians 13:13: Since not all knowledge has yet been revealed to us, what remains for us is to believe that all knowledge will be revealed to us.

Greek · §18

The Greek is on each section page: §18

The distinction between tongues and prophecy§19

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

19And believers believe so that they may hope, and those who hope need love, so that we do not fall away from hope. That is why he said, “Greater than this is love,” for it is through love that the law is fulfilled.

On 1 Corinthians 14:1–5: If he does not interpret, but only speaks in a tongue and does not make its meaning clear, because he lacks this gift of interpretation, he does speak mysteries (that is, clearly, the Spirit who supplies the tongues does) and he utters mysteries through the tongues. But he does not build up the church, which does not understand what he is saying. The one who speaks in a tongue builds himself up, knowing that he is uttering what he did not know; he perceived that the grace of the Holy Spirit was in him, and he was built up. So if the one who speaks in tongues also interprets, he is not less than the prophet.

“Be eager,” he says, “for prophecy more than the other gifts.” He said this because the gifts were given to match each person's way of life, and it was up to them which gift they wished to be eager for and receive. When some speak in tongues, no one who hears understands. Even so, though what is spoken is unclear to people, the one who speaks in the Spirit speaks mysteries (for the Spirit who supplies the tongues utters mysteries), while the one who prophesies helps those who hear, because he speaks to them plainly. The grace is greater if the one who speaks in tongues also receives the gift of interpreting; perhaps it was that he did not have both.

On 1 Corinthians 14:6: What good will I do you, he says, if I cannot speak to you about what was revealed to me by God, or about what I myself have come to know and grasp, or about what I have understood in the prophets, or about what I have resolved to counsel or teach you? If I speak about these things and you do not understand, what good will I do you?

On 1 Corinthians 14:7: Consider, he says, that even with lifeless things, the flute and the lyre, if the notes are not distinct, what is piped or played becomes a blur.

On 1 Corinthians 14:10: “Nothing is without voice”: that is, clearly, no race of men.

On 1 Corinthians 14:12: By “spiritual things” he means the different gifts of the Holy Spirit.

On 1 Corinthians 14:13–14: If, he says, I speak in some tongue that I do not know, without even knowing what it means, I am persuaded that my mind is unfruitful, since it does not have the meaning of what was said. Let him pray to obtain a double grace: to speak in tongues and to interpret them. Praying in a tongue is the working of the Holy Spirit, but the mind bears no fruit, because no one can understand what is said or benefit from it. That is why, he says, I must do this: make clear what the Spirit supplies to me, to build up those who hear, so that my mind is not unfruitful for want of the meaning of the words.

On 1 Corinthians 14:16: Because no one can benefit from what is said or understand it, if I give thanks in a tongue, the listener does not give you back the “Amen.” By “outsider” he means one who, so to speak, has not yet enlisted: one not yet baptized.

On 1 Corinthians 14:19: With the clarity of the mind, and in the ordinary language.

On 1 Corinthians 14:20: Be eager to become mature: to understand the Scriptures.

On 1 Corinthians 14:21–23: Note this. When the Jews are asked to show where God spoke to them in many tongues and they disobeyed, they cannot show it. But we show that when the Holy Spirit came and made the division into tongues, the Jews in their disbelief said, “They are full of new wine” (Acts 2:13). So tongues are a sign not for believers but for unbelievers, and prophecy is not for unbelievers but for believers. Tongues do build up, then, when the hearer learns that the speaker is speaking a language he does not know; yet he does not receive the building up that comes from the benefit of spiritual teaching, since it is not understood and makes no headway. Prophecy concerns things to come, and it is not just anyone who believes what is said about them, but the believer. The unbeliever needs a man who does not know the language he is using, and who so shows that the Spirit of God is in him. So the tongue was a wonder, while prophecy was a wonder by its fulfillment, not in the speaking. Divine Scripture speaks of unbelief in two ways: the true unbelief of the Greeks, and the little faith of the devout. By “unbeliever” he means the Greek, and by “outsider” the one not yet baptized, the one not yet enlisted; at that time they were not called catechumens or unbaptized.

The second catena form adds: He calls the writings of the other prophets “law” too, since they lived under the law. What was spoken through Isaiah (Isaiah 28:11) came to pass when the Spirit came down on the apostles and they spoke in tongues and the Jews mocked. Clearly tongues are of benefit when the hearer realizes that the speaker is speaking a language he does not know and did not learn from men. Yet the thing does not benefit the…

Greek · §19

The Greek is on each section page: §19

The Necessity of the Resurrection§20

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

20…hearer, because it is not understood. The sign is given to unbelievers, so that they may believe what they see; prophecy is given so that one may accept what was said and bless the Lord.

On 1 Corinthians 14:26: Let each one build up the church through whatever grace he has from God.

On 1 Corinthians 14:28: By saying “let him be silent,” he taught that one who speaks by the Holy Spirit speaks when he wishes and keeps silent when he wishes, as the prophets did. Not so those possessed by an unclean spirit: they speak even when they do not wish to, and say things they do not know.

On 1 Corinthians 14:29–32: By these words he shows that the Holy Spirit revealed the mysteries to souls, and they, once enlightened, revealed them to men. It was not as in soothsaying, where the soothsayer does not know what he is uttering. So he has now made good what he said at the start: that when you were Gentiles, you were led away to the dumb idols, carried off as you were. “Let two or three prophets speak, and let the others judge”: those who have the gift of discerning spirits. “If something is revealed to another who is sitting, let the first be silent,” since it lies with them at one time to be silent and at another to speak. “And the spirits of prophets are subject to prophets.” Do not be afraid, he says, that by falling silent you are slighting the Spirit, for the gifts know how to yield to one another.

The second catena form adds that this is so that the church may be built up and there may be no confusion from everyone speaking at once.

On 1 Corinthians 15:1–2: I am not telling you anything strange, he says, but what I preached. And it is not that I preached and you did not accept it: you received it. Nor did you receive something empty and useless, but that in which you are being saved. Since he is about to say, “I made known to you how the Lord Jesus died for us,” he says, “in what word”: this gospel, given so that the resurrection may be believed, for Jesus, who died for us, is the firstfruits of the resurrection. If death did not have to be destroyed, the Savior would not have become man. “Unless you believed in vain” stands for “except if you believed in vain.” For I say that if you do not hold it fast, it is plain that you believed in vain.

On 1 Corinthians 15:3: He said “first of all” meaning “before everything else”: I handed this on to you. I did not hand on an argument of my own, but what I received from the Scriptures. It was confirmed to him by his own eyes that Christ died and rose, and Christ called him from heaven.

On 1 Corinthians 15:4: How was he buried, if, as the heretics say, he did not have flesh?

On 1 Corinthians 15:6: “Above five hundred” means “more than five hundred.”

On 1 Corinthians 15:8: An untimely birth is what is expelled from the womb before it has been fully formed and has had its proper time there, and it cannot live. Just as babies are shaped in the womb, souls were shaped beforehand under the law toward godliness, and were born again of water and Spirit (John 3:5). Paul, though, persecuted the church without being shaped to completion under the law; he was persecuting it. That is why he called himself an untimely birth, and he adds next, “because I persecuted the church of God.”

On 1 Corinthians 15:9–10a: “The least of the apostles,” because they did not persecute but believed, while I persecuted. He was a persecutor, and yet by God's foreknowledge he obtained so great a grace; that is why he also labored more than the others.

On 1 Corinthians 15:10b: I did not receive great grace for nothing. I used it for the preaching, and labored more abundantly than all of them.

On 1 Corinthians 15:12–13: It cannot be that Christ rose and the rest do not. It is agreed that Christ died and rose for no other reason than our resurrection.

On 1 Corinthians 15:14–18: If Christ has not been raised, he says, in vain…

Greek · §20

The Greek is on each section page: §20

The Nature of Resurrection and Death§21

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

21…did you believe that your sins are forgiven, when the very one who forgives them has not been raised. But if Christ has been raised, as indeed he has, then clearly sins are forgiven, and the resurrection of the dead will take place.

On 1 Corinthians 15:19: We are pitiable on this account: we do not go after the good things of this life. If we look down on the goods of the present life, and of our own will humble ourselves in poverty, in self-control and in other ways, hoping for something else, how are we not pitiable, chasing the very opposite of what we pray for? By adding “only” he showed that godliness is good for the present life as well.

On 1 Corinthians 15:12–20: We ask what death they say the Savior underwent, or what resurrection. If both were mere appearance, the faith of Christians comes down to appearance. But if the death was real, his resurrection was real too. Let them say what death or what resurrection they mean. Is death the taking of flesh? Then the Lord had flesh. And if he had flesh, he also died; and if he died, he also rose, Christ having become the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep. So our bodies too have been raised. But what death am I to reckon it? Dying because of sins? But he himself says, “The ruler of this world is coming, and he has nothing in me” (John 14:30). And if he died as a sinner, the death that belongs to sin, because he took away the sin of the world (John 1:29), then on that reasoning he has not risen to this day, for he is always a sinner in that he takes away the sin of the world. And what resurrection of the Lord does Paul speak of? Release from the flesh? Then he had flesh. Release from sins? Then the same argument as before will be made. Besides, if Christ is the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep, whatever resurrection we grant ourselves we are bound to grant the Savior too. What resurrection, then, do we receive? Release from the flesh? Then the Lord too had flesh. Release from sins? Then the Lord too had sins from which he was released. So on every side they are pressed by the sequence and force of the apostle's words.

If the resurrection belongs to the soul, and its resurrection is understood as release either from the flesh or from sins, how did those who fell asleep in Christ perish, if indeed they were righteous? If they were in Christ, they were not sinners; and if it is release from the flesh, the soul is immortal and did not perish. You see that he is speaking of our flesh, which falls asleep in Christ when we die, the one who has departed being good.

The second catena form adds, on “only” (1 Corinthians 15:19): In this life we practice godliness, and in that life we receive the rewards.

On 1 Corinthians 15:21–22: Let those who accept these words say through what man death came, or what death it is. Through Adam? But it was the soul that sinned, and the body that was condemned. Then: “As in Adam all die,” and the rest. He speaks by the sentence passed on the case, for not everyone is said to have died: Enoch and Elijah are alive, and some will be found living at the…

Greek · §21

The Greek is on each section page: §21

The Order of Resurrection and the Kingdom§22

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

22…coming of the Savior.

The second catena form adds: “In Adam” stands for “because of Adam,” just as “in Christ” stands for “because of Christ.” So in Adam we die, clearly in the body, and in Christ they will be made alive, clearly in the body. If souls were alive before Christ, and after Christ it is again only souls that live, what did the saving plan add?

On 1 Corinthians 15:23–25: By “order” he means the order of the righteous and of the unrighteous. Here “those who are Christ's” does not mean the faithful in particular, but everyone, because all are Christ's. At his coming there will be the resurrection of all, when the end also comes: the drowning of death and of the devil, for this is the end of the world. By “the kingdom” he means not his own, but the one the evil one seized when he brought down Adam and those descended from him. In handing this kingdom over to the Father he will not be a stranger to it, for the Son reigns together with the Father. “Reign until” does not mark a time limit but emphasis, as if someone were to say, “I must live virtuously until I achieve righteousness.” He does not mean that once I have achieved it I will no longer live in righteousness, but that righteousness has to be achieved by me through virtuous effort. In the prophets too, “until” does not always mark a limit but emphasis, as in the Old Testament where he says, “I am, I am, until you grow old” (Isaiah 46:4). He does not say that the old age of those who grow old is the limit of his being, but that even when you grow old, I am: not growing old with you, but always being. So here too “until” marks the goal reached. What he means is this: his kingdom will not be broken off in the meantime, nor will believers fail, until what he purposed has been accomplished; and once he has accomplished it, he will reign without end.

On 1 Corinthians 15:29: If the bodies, he says, stay dead and do not rise, why are we baptized for these dead, as though they would rise and be judged, receiving forgiveness of sins so as not to be condemned?

On 1 Corinthians 15:32: As far as man could do it, he says, I fought with wild beasts, but God saved me.

On 1 Corinthians 15:35–38: The Greeks object that a seed once split no longer sprouts, and so neither is a man raised again if his foot has been cut off or his body maimed altogether. They do not know that the comparison is not of one nature with another, but with the power of the Maker. That is, who gave the seed its nature to sprout and its power as seed? Was it not God? Who makes the seed first die and then rise? Is it not God?

Greek · §22

The Greek is on each section page: §22

The distinction between nature and choice in resurrection§23

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

23So he who gave the grain its power as seed has also given our bodies the strength to rise. I did not bring in the body of crops and of men as though they were alike, but to set before you the Creator's power.

On 1 Corinthians 15:40–42: Not as though the other kinds of flesh rise; he is using an illustration. By “heavenly bodies” he means the sun and the moon, and what follows shows it: “So also is the resurrection of the dead.” You see that what came first was an illustration; now he has given the thing the illustration was for.

On 1 Corinthians 15:44: By the body “of the soul” he means the body put to death by the soul's sin, and by the “spiritual” body the one raised by the power of the Spirit. That body will no longer live by the weakness of the soul, which is not strong enough to hold the body's frame together, but by the power of the Spirit, which carries it over into immortality.

On 1 Corinthians 15:45: This is what Moses says: “And the man became a living soul” (Genesis 2:7). The second man became a life-giving spirit. This is what the Gospel says: “For what has been conceived in her is from the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 1:20).

On 1 Corinthians 15:47: Man is “from the earth” by nature, and “earthy” by choice. He says that Christ is “from heaven”: not by likeness; nor does eternity come from resurrection.

On 1 Corinthians 15:47–49: The followers of Valentinus and Marcion, the followers of Photinus and those of Apollinarius all run to this text, but the passage refutes them all. I ask: did the earthy man from the earth have a soul or not? They will not deny it. And the Lord from heaven had a body from the earth. Again I ask: why does he call the first man “from the earth, earthy,” but the Lord “from heaven”? And after that, “As is the earthy” (and he no longer mentions earth, but says) “so are those who are earthy”? Clearly because “from the earth” belongs to nature, while “earthy” belongs to choice. When he comes to “as is the earthy,” and is accusing those who have not lived well, he no longer mentions nature or “from the earth,” and he no longer calls the Lord “from heaven” but “heavenly.” Again, the spiritual too were from the earth. “As is the earthy, so are those who are earthy, and as is the heavenly, so are those who are heavenly.” And it follows of necessity: if some deny that the Lord from heaven took flesh, because he is from heaven, they must also refuse to grant that the heavenly ones took a body, since “as is the earthy, so are those who are earthy.” And so this stands on no ground at all if it is understood…

Greek · §23

The Greek is on each section page: §23

The Nature of Resurrection and Transformation§24

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

24…otherwise than this: he spoke of nature, which is why he says “from the earth.” From the earth come both the heavenly ones and those called earthy, but the two are no longer both earthy. So we must notice that the Lord is said to be “from heaven,” not the heavenly ones, and that the heavenly ones are from the earth, not the Lord from heaven. By “the image of the earthy” he means the earthy way of living, and by “the image of the heavenly” the heavenly way of life. That is: we copied Adam's disobedience; let us also copy the obedience of the Son of God by obeying.

On 1 Corinthians 15:50: Many of the heretics, in their great folly, drag this text against the resurrection. But he did not say that flesh and blood do not rise; he said that they “will not inherit the kingdom of God.” He shut them out of the kingdom of the Son of God, not out of the grace of the resurrection. What he means is this: flesh, while it is flesh, does not inherit, and blood, while it is blood, does not inherit. As long as flesh is flesh, it is perishable; but once it has put on incorruption and laid aside the weakness of the flesh, it becomes something else, that is, imperishable. He has proved what he said before. He calls the kingdom “incorruption,” and “corruption” the mortality of this age. Opposites do not become heirs of their opposites.

On 1 Corinthians 15:52: He made clear that there are many trumpets, for by mentioning the last he implied the first ones too. “And the dead will be raised incorruptible, and we shall be changed.” If the dead are incorruptible, clearly they too will be changed. What need, then, for “and we shall be changed”? Surely he said “incorruptible” of everyone alike, while “we shall be changed” now hints at the change for the better. That is why he said “we,” of the righteous.

The second catena form adds: By saying this and pointing to the body, he hemmed in the heretics who say there is a resurrection not of the flesh but of the soul. These people are impious even about the divine plan itself, supposing that Christ took flesh not in truth but in appearance, which is senseless. If he had no flesh, what was it that died and was buried and rose? And if these things happened in appearance, then we too die in appearance. The “we” would be superfluous, unless perhaps he means it to point to the saints, standing for “the righteous among us,” just as elsewhere, by saying “we who are alive” (1 Thessalonians 4:17), he pointed to the saints around him.

On 1 Corinthians 16:1: “Collection” is the name for a contribution made by gathering money, for the relief of the poor.

Greek · §24

The Greek is on each section page: §24

Contents