On the Flesh of Christ · §21 · Tertullian

The Virgin's flesh must be Christ's own flesh

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

Tertullian is arguing against those who say the Word became flesh without taking flesh from the Virgin's womb, and he now presses the testimony of Isaiah and Elizabeth to show that Mary was truly Christ's mother.

So if they insist that this was fitting for the newness of the thing—that just as the Word did not become flesh from a man's seed, so neither did he become flesh from the virgin's flesh—why should the whole newness not be this: that flesh not born from seed came forth from flesh? I will come still closer to the contest. “Behold,” he says, “the virgin shall conceive in the womb” (Isaiah 7:14). What shall she conceive? The Word, certainly, not a man's seed—and certainly so that she might bear a son. For “she shall bear,” he says, “a son.” Therefore, just as it was hers to conceive, so what she bore is hers, even though what she conceived was not hers. On the other hand, if the Word became flesh from himself, then he conceived and bore himself, and the prophecy is void. For the virgin did not conceive and did not bear, if whatever she bore from the Word she conceived is not his flesh. But will only this voice of the prophet be made void? Or also the angel's announcement of the virgin's conception and birth? Or also all Scripture now, whatever proclaims the mother of Christ? For how is she his mother, unless because he was in her womb? But he received nothing from her womb that would make her a mother in whose womb he was. Flesh that is foreign does not deserve this name. No one calls it a mother's womb unless the flesh is a daughter of the womb. But it is not a daughter of the womb if it was born from itself. So Elizabeth too will be silent—she who was carrying the prophet, an infant already aware of his Lord, and who was moreover filled with the Holy Spirit. For she says without cause, “And why is this granted to me, that the mother of my Lord should come to me?” (Luke 1:43). If Mary was carrying in her womb not a son but a guest, Jesus, how does Elizabeth say, “Blessed is the fruit of your womb” (Luke 1:42)? What is this fruit of the womb, which did not sprout from the womb, which did not put down root in the womb, which does not belong to the one whose womb it is—and which is certainly the fruit of the womb, Christ? Or is it because he himself is the flower from the branch that came forth from the root of Jesse, and the root of Jesse is the family of David, the branch from the root is Mary from David, the flower from the branch is the son of Mary, who is called Jesus Christ—will he himself also be the fruit? For the flower is the fruit, because through the flower and from the flower every fruit is brought to ripeness into fruit. What then? Do they deny to the fruit its flower, and to the flower its branch, and to the branch its root, so that the root may not claim for itself through the branch the ownership of what is from the branch—the flower and the fruit? Since every step of descent is traced from the last back to the first, let them now know that the flesh of Christ clings not only to Mary, but to David through Mary, and to Jesse through David. Therefore God swears to him that this fruit from the loins of David—that is, from the posterity of his flesh—will sit on his throne (Psalm 132:11). If from the loins of David, how much more from the loins of Mary, through whom he was in the loins of David?

Latin

Si ergo contendunt hoc competisse novitati, ut quemadmodum non ex viri semine, ita nec ex virginis carne caro fieret dei verbum, quare non hoc sit tota novitas, ut caro non ex semine nata carne processerit? Accedam adhuc cominius ad congressum. Ecce, inquit, virgo concipiet in utero. Quidnam? utique dei verbum, non viri semen, certe ut pareret filium. Nam et pariet, inquit, filium. Ergo ut ipsius fuit concepisse, ita ipsius est quod peperit, licet non ipsius fuerit quod concepit. Contra si verbum ex se caro factum est, iam ipsum se concepit et peperit, et vacat prophetia. Non enim virgo concepit neque peperit, si non quiequid peperit ex verbo concepto caro ipsius est. Sola haec autem prophetae vox evacuabitur? an et angeli conceptum et partum virginis annuntiantis? an et omnis iam scriptura, quaecunque matrem pronuntiat Christi? Quomodo enim mater, nisi quia iu utero eius fuit? Sed nihil ex utero eius accepit quod matrem eam faceret in cuius utero fuit. Hoc nomen non debet caro extranea. Matris uterum non appellat nisi filia uteri caro. Filia uteri porro non est si sibi nata est. Tacebit igitur et Elisabeth prophetam portans iam domini sui conscium infantem, et insuper spiritu sancta adimpleta. Sine causa enim dicit, Et unde mihi ut mater domini mei ad me veniat? Si Maria non filium, sed hospitem in utero gestabat Iesum, quomodo dicit, Benedictus fructus uteri tui? Quis hic fructas uteri, qui non ex utero germinavit, qui non in utero radicem egit, qui non eius est cuius est uterus et qui utique fructus uteri, Christus? An quia ipse est fles de virga profecta ex radice Iesse, radix autem Iesse genus David, virga ex radice Maria ex David, flos ex virga filius Mariae, qui dicitur Iesus Christus, ipse erit et fructus? Flos enim fructus, quia per florem et ex flore omnis fructus eruditur in fructum. Quid ergo? Negant et fructui suum florem et flori suam virgam et virgae suam radicem, quominus suam radix sibi vindicet per virgam proprietatem eius quod ex virga est, floris et fructus; siquidem omnis gradus generis ab ultimo ad principalem recensetur, ut iam nunc carnem Christi, non tantum Mariae, sed et David per Mariam et Iesse per David sciant adhaerere. Ideo hunc fructum ex lumbis David, id est ex posteritate carnis eius, iurat illi deus consessurum in throno ipsius. Si ex lumbis David, quanto magis ex lumbis Mariae, ob quam in lumbis David?

Report a mistake in this passage