▶ Listen to the King James Version 0:00 / 5:17 1×
1 Now as Jesus was passing by, He saw a man blind from birth, Verse 1: 2 passages in the Fathers 2 and His disciples asked Him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” Verse 2: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 3 Jesus answered, “Neither this man nor his parents sinned, but this happened so that the works of God would be displayed in him. Verse 3: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 4 While it is daytime, we must do the works of Him who sent Me. Night is coming, when no one can work. Verse 4: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 5 While I am in the world, I am the light of the world.” Verse 5: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 6 When Jesus had said this, He spit on the ground, made some mud, and applied it to the man’s eyes. Verse 6: 7 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 7 Then He told him, “Go, wash in the Pool of Siloam” (which means “Sent”). So the man went and washed, and came back seeing. Verse 7: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 8 At this, his neighbors and those who had formerly seen him begging began to ask, “Isn’t this the man who used to sit and beg?” Verse 8: 1 passage in the Fathers 9 Some claimed that he was, but others said, “No, he just looks like him.” But the man kept saying, “I am the one.” Verse 9: 3 passages in the Fathers 10 “How then were your eyes opened?” they asked. Verse 10: 1 passage in the Fathers 11 He answered, “The man they call Jesus made some mud and anointed my eyes, and He told me to go to Siloam and wash. So I went and washed and received my sight.” Verse 11: 1 passage in the Fathers 12 “Where is He?” they asked. “I do not know,” he answered. 13 They brought to the Pharisees the man who had been blind. Verse 13: commentary from the Fathers 14 Now the day on which Jesus had made the mud and opened his eyes was a Sabbath. Verse 14: commentary from the Fathers 15 So the Pharisees also asked him how he had received his sight. The man answered, “He put mud on my eyes, and I washed, and now I can see.” Verse 15: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 16 Because of this, some of the Pharisees said, “This man is not from God, for He does not keep the Sabbath.” But others said, “How can a sinful man perform such signs?” And there was division among them. Verse 16: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 17 So once again they asked the man who had been blind, “What do you say about Him, since it was your eyes He opened?” “He is a prophet,” the man replied. Verse 17: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 18 The Jews still did not believe that the man had been blind and had received his sight until they summoned his parents Verse 18: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 19 and asked, “Is this your son, the one you say was born blind? So how is it that he can now see?” Verse 19: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 20 His parents answered, “We know he is our son, and we know he was born blind. Verse 20: commentary from the Fathers 21 But how he can now see or who opened his eyes, we do not know. Ask him. He is old enough to speak for himself.” Verse 21: commentary from the Fathers 22 His parents said this because they were afraid of the Jews. For the Jews had already determined that anyone who confessed Jesus as the Christ would be put out of the synagogue. 23 That was why his parents said, “He is old enough. Ask him.” 24 So a second time they called for the man who had been blind and said, “Give glory to God! We know that this man is a sinner.” Verse 24: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 25 He answered, “Whether He is a sinner I do not know. There is one thing I do know: I was blind, but now I see!” Verse 25: 1 passage in the Fathers 26 “What did He do to you?” they asked. “How did He open your eyes?” Verse 26: commentary from the Fathers 27 He replied, “I already told you, and you did not listen. Why do you want to hear it again? Do you also want to become His disciples?” Verse 27: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 28 Then they heaped insults on him and said, “You are His disciple; we are disciples of Moses. Verse 28: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 29 We know that God spoke to Moses, but we do not know where this man is from.” Verse 29: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 30 “That is remarkable indeed!” the man said. “You do not know where He is from, and yet He opened my eyes. Verse 30: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 31 We know that God does not listen to sinners, but He does listen to the one who worships Him and does His will. Verse 31: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 32 Never before has anyone heard of opening the eyes of a man born blind. Verse 32: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 33 If this man were not from God, He could do no such thing.” Verse 33: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 34 They replied, “You were born in utter sin, and you are instructing us?” And they threw him out. Verse 34: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 35 When Jesus heard that they had thrown him out, He found the man and said, “Do you believe in the Son of Man ?” Verse 35: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 36 “Who is He, Sir?” he replied. “Tell me so that I may believe in Him.” Verse 36: commentary from the Fathers 37 “You have already seen Him,” Jesus answered. “He is the One speaking with you.” Verse 37: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 38 “Lord, I believe,” he said. And he worshiped Jesus. 39 Then Jesus declared, “For judgment I have come into this world, so that the blind may see and those who see may become blind.” Verse 39: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 40 Some of the Pharisees who were with Him heard this, and they asked Him, “Are we blind too?” Verse 40: commentary from the Fathers 41 “If you were blind,” Jesus replied, “you would not be guilty of sin. But since you claim you can see, your guilt remains.” Verse 41: commentary from the Fathers
Audio: the King James Version read aloud, from Larry Sanger's Deep Dive Bible (public domain).
×
This chapter in the Fathers
John 9 59 passages
29 of 41 verses cited
16 writers
Most cited verses John 9:6 7 passages John 9:39 4 passages John 9:2 4 passages John 9:16 4 passages John 9:4 3 passages John 9:9 3 passages John 9:33 2 passages John 9:34 2 passages On the chapter as a whole Select a marked verse to see who cites it.
Verse
John 9:1 2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:2 3 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 4 passages
On John 9:2–3
Since the man could not have sinned before birth, the disciples blamed his parents, but Jesus says the blindness serves to reveal God's power.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Since the blind man was blind from birth, it appears to the disciples to seek the cause; and as it was impossible for him to commit the same sin before being born, they look to that of the parents. For he knew through the grief of parents that there are sufferings concerning children. But the Lord says that blindness does not come because of some sin, but for the sake of the glory of God about to be, for the purpose of the power of God being known through the paradoxically occurring sight (John 9:7).
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
Unborn people cannot sin, nor bear others' sins.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
This question is mistaken; neither does anyone sin before being born who does not exist at all, nor is another punished for another.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
On John 9:2–3
Jesus' answer overturns the false teaching that souls sin before birth and are sent into bodies as punishment.
— Theophilus of Alexandria, c. 345–412 AD
In this, the Savior himself was overturning an unlawful doctrine. For some people supposed that sinning souls are sent from heaven into a body for the sake of punishment, and that sometimes the soul remains pre-existing by itself apart from the body, while at other times it is intertwined with bodies on account of its own sins—so that a woman can conceive only when some soul sins. Destroying this error, Christ, when he was asked, said: "Neither this man sinned nor his parents, but this happened so that the works of God might be revealed" (John 9:3).
Fragments on John, §1 → read in full
On John 9:2–3
Since the man could not have sinned before birth, the disciples blamed his parents, but Jesus says the blindness serves to reveal God's power.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Since the blind man was blind from birth, it appears to the disciples to seek the cause; and as it was impossible for him to commit the same sin before being born, they look to that of the parents. For he knew through the grief of parents that there are sufferings concerning children. But the Lord says that blindness does not come because of some sin, but for the sake of the glory of God about to be, for the purpose of the power of God being known through the paradoxically occurring sight (John 9:7).
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:3 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 2 passages
On John 9:2–3
Since the man could not have sinned before birth, the disciples blamed his parents, but Jesus says the blindness serves to reveal God's power.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Since the blind man was blind from birth, it appears to the disciples to seek the cause; and as it was impossible for him to commit the same sin before being born, they look to that of the parents. For he knew through the grief of parents that there are sufferings concerning children. But the Lord says that blindness does not come because of some sin, but for the sake of the glory of God about to be, for the purpose of the power of God being known through the paradoxically occurring sight (John 9:7).
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:2–3
Jesus' answer overturns the false teaching that souls sin before birth and are sent into bodies as punishment.
— Theophilus of Alexandria, c. 345–412 AD
In this, the Savior himself was overturning an unlawful doctrine. For some people supposed that sinning souls are sent from heaven into a body for the sake of punishment, and that sometimes the soul remains pre-existing by itself apart from the body, while at other times it is intertwined with bodies on account of its own sins—so that a woman can conceive only when some soul sins. Destroying this error, Christ, when he was asked, said: "Neither this man sinned nor his parents, but this happened so that the works of God might be revealed" (John 9:3).
Fragments on John, §1 → read in full
On John 9:2–3
Since the man could not have sinned before birth, the disciples blamed his parents, but Jesus says the blindness serves to reveal God's power.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Since the blind man was blind from birth, it appears to the disciples to seek the cause; and as it was impossible for him to commit the same sin before being born, they look to that of the parents. For he knew through the grief of parents that there are sufferings concerning children. But the Lord says that blindness does not come because of some sin, but for the sake of the glory of God about to be, for the purpose of the power of God being known through the paradoxically occurring sight (John 9:7).
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:4 1 comment from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 3 passages
The 'day' is this life, the time for good works, and the 'night' is the age to come, when nothing more can be done.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
… But the Savior, having said, 'Until it is day, work the works of light; night comes when no one is able to work' (John 9:4), urged the conduct in this life as providing us the time for works, but referred to the night as the things to come and the eternal, as when it is no longer possible to do anything, but as being in darkness in inaction, having lost the time for works.
Fragments on Romans, §12 → read in full
The 'day' is this life, the time for good works, and the 'night' is the age to come, when nothing more can be done.
— Diodorus of Tarsus, c. 330–c. 390 AD
… But the Savior, having said, 'Until it is day, work the works of light; night comes when no one is able to work' (John 9:4), urged the conduct in this life as providing us the time for works, but referred to the night as the things to come and the eternal, as when it is no longer possible to do anything, but as being in darkness in inaction, having lost the time for works.
Fragments on Romans, §12 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:5 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 9:5–7
By forming eyes from clay Jesus shows he is the one who formed Adam from clay, and the healed man stands for the nations who once were blind.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
He called himself light of the world as enlightening the faithful's souls and because he was about to open the eyes of the one "blind from birth" (John 9:1).
He spat on the ground and made clay from the spittle and anointed the clay on the blind man's eyes, wanting to show through the clay that he himself is the one who also fashioned Adam from clay; for to say "I am the one who did this" seemed offensive to the hearers. But being shown through the work, this no longer stood in the way. Therefore not simply, but in that manner, he crafted the eyes; and he not only formed and opened but also granted seeing, which is proof that he also ensouled Adam with the soul; for if that is not active, an eye, even if finished, would never see.
[John 9:7] This looks toward an image of those from the nations once blind, now enlightened and teaching Israel Christ's power.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
On John 9:5–7
By forming eyes from clay Jesus shows he is the one who formed Adam from clay, and the healed man stands for the nations who once were blind.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
He called himself light of the world as enlightening the faithful's souls and because he was about to open the eyes of the one "blind from birth" (John 9:1).
He spat on the ground and made clay from the spittle and anointed the clay on the blind man's eyes, wanting to show through the clay that he himself is the one who also fashioned Adam from clay; for to say "I am the one who did this" seemed offensive to the hearers. But being shown through the work, this no longer stood in the way. Therefore not simply, but in that manner, he crafted the eyes; and he not only formed and opened but also granted seeing, which is proof that he also ensouled Adam with the soul; for if that is not active, an eye, even if finished, would never see.
[John 9:7] This looks toward an image of those from the nations once blind, now enlightened and teaching Israel Christ's power.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:6 1 comment from the Fathers, 7 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 7 passages
On John 9:5–7
By forming eyes from clay Jesus shows he is the one who formed Adam from clay, and the healed man stands for the nations who once were blind.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
He called himself light of the world as enlightening the faithful's souls and because he was about to open the eyes of the one "blind from birth" (John 9:1).
He spat on the ground and made clay from the spittle and anointed the clay on the blind man's eyes, wanting to show through the clay that he himself is the one who also fashioned Adam from clay; for to say "I am the one who did this" seemed offensive to the hearers. But being shown through the work, this no longer stood in the way. Therefore not simply, but in that manner, he crafted the eyes; and he not only formed and opened but also granted seeing, which is proof that he also ensouled Adam with the soul; for if that is not active, an eye, even if finished, would never see.
[John 9:7] This looks toward an image of those from the nations once blind, now enlightened and teaching Israel Christ's power.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
On John 9:5–7
By forming eyes from clay Jesus shows he is the one who formed Adam from clay, and the healed man stands for the nations who once were blind.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
He called himself light of the world as enlightening the faithful's souls and because he was about to open the eyes of the one "blind from birth" (John 9:1).
He spat on the ground and made clay from the spittle and anointed the clay on the blind man's eyes, wanting to show through the clay that he himself is the one who also fashioned Adam from clay; for to say "I am the one who did this" seemed offensive to the hearers. But being shown through the work, this no longer stood in the way. Therefore not simply, but in that manner, he crafted the eyes; and he not only formed and opened but also granted seeing, which is proof that he also ensouled Adam with the soul; for if that is not active, an eye, even if finished, would never see.
[John 9:7] This looks toward an image of those from the nations once blind, now enlightened and teaching Israel Christ's power.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
7 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · On Pascha §1.56 For when from his spittle he makes clay and anoints our eyes and makes us see clearly, and when he opens the ears of our heart so that having ears we may be able to hear, and when we smell his fragrance recognizing that his name is… Apollinaris of Laodicea c. 310–c. 390 AD · Fragments on John §7 And that he made the blind man see on the Sabbath, they do not consider; but that 'he made clay' [John 9:6 ], they judge, being scoffers of the Lord, working his works many times on this day, so that from the 'slavery under the elements'… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Zechariah §23 And it is to be testified by the theory of one and two things recorded in the Gospels: a sign and a wonder was the leading of the blind man from birth to sight, his eyes having been anointed with clay, having been brought from the ground… Severianus of Gabala fl. c. 400 AD · On the Man Born Blind §5 And having spat, and having made clay, he anointed his eyes, and said to him: 'Go, wash in the pool of Siloam'; and having washed, he looked up. Severianus of Gabala fl. c. 400 AD · On the Man Born Blind §6 But he, caring less for the threat, possessed more of the truth, and says: A certain man, called Jesus, having made clay, anointed my eyes and said to me: 'Go, wash in the Siloam'. Asterius of Amasea c. 350–c. 410 AD · Homilies §2 As for those who are more pious than the wealthy ones, having reviewed the Gospel history, they handed it over to the weavers; I say the Christ our Lord meeting with the disciples, each miracle as the narrative has it: the wedding in… Ammonius of Alexandria fl. 5th century AD · Fragments on John §19 [John 9:6 ] He spat on the ground and made clay from the spittle and anointed the clay on the blind man's eyes, wanting to show through the clay that he himself is the one who also fashioned Adam from clay; for to say "I am the one who… Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:7 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (2) All 1 passage
On John 9:5–7
By forming eyes from clay Jesus shows he is the one who formed Adam from clay, and the healed man stands for the nations who once were blind.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
He called himself light of the world as enlightening the faithful's souls and because he was about to open the eyes of the one "blind from birth" (John 9:1).
He spat on the ground and made clay from the spittle and anointed the clay on the blind man's eyes, wanting to show through the clay that he himself is the one who also fashioned Adam from clay; for to say "I am the one who did this" seemed offensive to the hearers. But being shown through the work, this no longer stood in the way. Therefore not simply, but in that manner, he crafted the eyes; and he not only formed and opened but also granted seeing, which is proof that he also ensouled Adam with the soul; for if that is not active, an eye, even if finished, would never see.
[John 9:7] This looks toward an image of those from the nations once blind, now enlightened and teaching Israel Christ's power.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
John notes that Siloam means 'Sent' because the healing shows the Creator's power sent to renew his creation and cleanse it from sin.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
The participation of Siloam in the work, which is interpreted as having been sent, just as the evangelist did not mark in vain, shows the sending of the Creator's power toward the renewal of his own creation, being made purifying from sins, of which the water of the bath was a symbol, and through the cleansing of sins bringing back health and bringing the diseased and purified nature into perfection.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:5–7
By forming eyes from clay Jesus shows he is the one who formed Adam from clay, and the healed man stands for the nations who once were blind.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
He called himself light of the world as enlightening the faithful's souls and because he was about to open the eyes of the one "blind from birth" (John 9:1).
He spat on the ground and made clay from the spittle and anointed the clay on the blind man's eyes, wanting to show through the clay that he himself is the one who also fashioned Adam from clay; for to say "I am the one who did this" seemed offensive to the hearers. But being shown through the work, this no longer stood in the way. Therefore not simply, but in that manner, he crafted the eyes; and he not only formed and opened but also granted seeing, which is proof that he also ensouled Adam with the soul; for if that is not active, an eye, even if finished, would never see.
[John 9:7] This looks toward an image of those from the nations once blind, now enlightened and teaching Israel Christ's power.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
John notes that Siloam means 'Sent' because the healing shows the Creator's power sent to renew his creation and cleanse it from sin.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
The participation of Siloam in the work, which is interpreted as having been sent, just as the evangelist did not mark in vain, shows the sending of the Creator's power toward the renewal of his own creation, being made purifying from sins, of which the water of the bath was a symbol, and through the cleansing of sins bringing back health and bringing the diseased and purified nature into perfection.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:8 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:9 3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:10 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:11 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:13 1 comment from the Fathers
Complete (1)
On John 9:13–15
The Pharisees question the man not to learn the truth but to frighten him by the way they ask.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
But the Pharisees and the rulers of the Jews, seeing that the wonder has many attracting to Christ, being bitten by the zeal of impiety, and being struck by the sting of the truth, call the once-blind man in. And it was to see an evil theater, of piety being avenged, and of evil judges judging, and of a great advocate contending, and of God rewarding and overseeing. They call the once-blind and having seen again, the children of the Jews, and they set him in the midst of the council, and say to him: 'Tell how you received sight, and who opened your eyes to you, and what he did to you?' (John 9:15). These things they said, not that they might know, but that by the form of the question they might instill fear. For often the form of the question becomes to the one asked a teacher to answer, or to be silent; …
On the Man Born Blind, §5 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:14 2 comments from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (2)
On John 9:14–16
The Pharisees ignore the healing and fault only the making of clay on the Sabbath, though serving God's work is the true keeping of the Sabbath.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
And that he made the blind man see on the Sabbath, they do not consider; but that 'he made clay' , they judge, being scoffers of the Lord, working his works many times on this day, so that from the 'slavery under the elements' Galatians 4:3, as the apostle says, he might free the men having made them fit from the Sabbath-slavery into the slavery of God; for to work the work of God according to the Sabbath-rule is to serve God instead of the Sabbath.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:13–15
The Pharisees question the man not to learn the truth but to frighten him by the way they ask.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
But the Pharisees and the rulers of the Jews, seeing that the wonder has many attracting to Christ, being bitten by the zeal of impiety, and being struck by the sting of the truth, call the once-blind man in. And it was to see an evil theater, of piety being avenged, and of evil judges judging, and of a great advocate contending, and of God rewarding and overseeing. They call the once-blind and having seen again, the children of the Jews, and they set him in the midst of the council, and say to him: 'Tell how you received sight, and who opened your eyes to you, and what he did to you?' (John 9:15). These things they said, not that they might know, but that by the form of the question they might instill fear. For often the form of the question becomes to the one asked a teacher to answer, or to be silent; …
On the Man Born Blind, §5 → read in full
On John 9:14–16
The Pharisees ignore the healing and fault only the making of clay on the Sabbath, though serving God's work is the true keeping of the Sabbath.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
And that he made the blind man see on the Sabbath, they do not consider; but that 'he made clay' , they judge, being scoffers of the Lord, working his works many times on this day, so that from the 'slavery under the elements' Galatians 4:3, as the apostle says, he might free the men having made them fit from the Sabbath-slavery into the slavery of God; for to work the work of God according to the Sabbath-rule is to serve God instead of the Sabbath.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:15 3 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (3) All 2 passages
On John 9:14–16
The Pharisees ignore the healing and fault only the making of clay on the Sabbath, though serving God's work is the true keeping of the Sabbath.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
And that he made the blind man see on the Sabbath, they do not consider; but that 'he made clay' , they judge, being scoffers of the Lord, working his works many times on this day, so that from the 'slavery under the elements' Galatians 4:3, as the apostle says, he might free the men having made them fit from the Sabbath-slavery into the slavery of God; for to work the work of God according to the Sabbath-rule is to serve God instead of the Sabbath.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
Unafraid, the man tells what happened, knowing the benefit though not yet who his benefactor was.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
… How did you see? Who opened your eyes? But he, caring less for the threat, possessed more of the truth, and says: A certain man, called Jesus, having made clay, anointed my eyes and said to me: 'Go, wash in the Siloam' (John 9:6). And having gone, I washed, and I saw. He did not know the truth, but he recognized the benefit; he did not yet know the merit of the benefactor. A certain man, having made clay, anointed my eyes, and I see.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
On John 9:13–15
The Pharisees question the man not to learn the truth but to frighten him by the way they ask.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
But the Pharisees and the rulers of the Jews, seeing that the wonder has many attracting to Christ, being bitten by the zeal of impiety, and being struck by the sting of the truth, call the once-blind man in. And it was to see an evil theater, of piety being avenged, and of evil judges judging, and of a great advocate contending, and of God rewarding and overseeing. They call the once-blind and having seen again, the children of the Jews, and they set him in the midst of the council, and say to him: 'Tell how you received sight, and who opened your eyes to you, and what he did to you?' (John 9:15). These things they said, not that they might know, but that by the form of the question they might instill fear. For often the form of the question becomes to the one asked a teacher to answer, or to be silent; …
On the Man Born Blind, §5 → read in full
On John 9:14–16
The Pharisees ignore the healing and fault only the making of clay on the Sabbath, though serving God's work is the true keeping of the Sabbath.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
And that he made the blind man see on the Sabbath, they do not consider; but that 'he made clay' , they judge, being scoffers of the Lord, working his works many times on this day, so that from the 'slavery under the elements' Galatians 4:3, as the apostle says, he might free the men having made them fit from the Sabbath-slavery into the slavery of God; for to work the work of God according to the Sabbath-rule is to serve God instead of the Sabbath.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
Unafraid, the man tells what happened, knowing the benefit though not yet who his benefactor was.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
… How did you see? Who opened your eyes? But he, caring less for the threat, possessed more of the truth, and says: A certain man, called Jesus, having made clay, anointed my eyes and said to me: 'Go, wash in the Siloam' (John 9:6). And having gone, I washed, and I saw. He did not know the truth, but he recognized the benefit; he did not yet know the merit of the benefactor. A certain man, having made clay, anointed my eyes, and I see.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:16 3 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (3) All 4 passages
On John 9:14–16
The Pharisees ignore the healing and fault only the making of clay on the Sabbath, though serving God's work is the true keeping of the Sabbath.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
And that he made the blind man see on the Sabbath, they do not consider; but that 'he made clay' , they judge, being scoffers of the Lord, working his works many times on this day, so that from the 'slavery under the elements' Galatians 4:3, as the apostle says, he might free the men having made them fit from the Sabbath-slavery into the slavery of God; for to work the work of God according to the Sabbath-rule is to serve God instead of the Sabbath.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:16–17
The Pharisees hope to make the healed man disown Jesus, but he boldly calls him a prophet, as far as he yet understood.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Not as needing to learn something, these approach the question from the blind man (John 9:15), but as if shaming him with something more defamatory against the Lord because of the perceived brevity regarding the Sabbath (John 9:17); for they thought that being among many, they would drag one down, and these things were meager and cheap, but they thought it great to stop the praise for him and to be able to condemn the thing done not being testified by him who was healed. But he did not show fear, having known the Lord through trial (John 9:17), but as much as he was able to grasp, he says about him to be a prophet, and this appropriately, since he did not know the authority of the divinity, not knowing that he had made him by his own power.
So much does a pre-conceived dogma and a certain disposition toward the passing of right upon things prevail, and to darken the reasoning.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:14–16
The Pharisees ignore the healing and fault only the making of clay on the Sabbath, though serving God's work is the true keeping of the Sabbath.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
And that he made the blind man see on the Sabbath, they do not consider; but that 'he made clay' , they judge, being scoffers of the Lord, working his works many times on this day, so that from the 'slavery under the elements' Galatians 4:3, as the apostle says, he might free the men having made them fit from the Sabbath-slavery into the slavery of God; for to work the work of God according to the Sabbath-rule is to serve God instead of the Sabbath.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
They charge Christ for clay made with one finger on the Sabbath while they water and rescue animals with their whole hand.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
From extreme impiety they preferred the Sabbath to his divine power and blaspheming said that this man is not from God. For Christ, having anointed the clay with one finger on the Sabbath, is charged, while they with a whole hand loosing animals and leading them to drink and pulling up sheep fallen into a pit are not accused.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
On John 9:16–17
The Pharisees hope to make the healed man disown Jesus, but he boldly calls him a prophet, as far as he yet understood.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Not as needing to learn something, these approach the question from the blind man (John 9:15), but as if shaming him with something more defamatory against the Lord because of the perceived brevity regarding the Sabbath (John 9:17); for they thought that being among many, they would drag one down, and these things were meager and cheap, but they thought it great to stop the praise for him and to be able to condemn the thing done not being testified by him who was healed. But he did not show fear, having known the Lord through trial (John 9:17), but as much as he was able to grasp, he says about him to be a prophet, and this appropriately, since he did not know the authority of the divinity, not knowing that he had made him by his own power.
So much does a pre-conceived dogma and a certain disposition toward the passing of right upon things prevail, and to darken the reasoning.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:17 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 9:16–17
The Pharisees hope to make the healed man disown Jesus, but he boldly calls him a prophet, as far as he yet understood.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Not as needing to learn something, these approach the question from the blind man (John 9:15), but as if shaming him with something more defamatory against the Lord because of the perceived brevity regarding the Sabbath (John 9:17); for they thought that being among many, they would drag one down, and these things were meager and cheap, but they thought it great to stop the praise for him and to be able to condemn the thing done not being testified by him who was healed. But he did not show fear, having known the Lord through trial (John 9:17), but as much as he was able to grasp, he says about him to be a prophet, and this appropriately, since he did not know the authority of the divinity, not knowing that he had made him by his own power.
So much does a pre-conceived dogma and a certain disposition toward the passing of right upon things prevail, and to darken the reasoning.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:16–17
The Pharisees hope to make the healed man disown Jesus, but he boldly calls him a prophet, as far as he yet understood.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Not as needing to learn something, these approach the question from the blind man (John 9:15), but as if shaming him with something more defamatory against the Lord because of the perceived brevity regarding the Sabbath (John 9:17); for they thought that being among many, they would drag one down, and these things were meager and cheap, but they thought it great to stop the praise for him and to be able to condemn the thing done not being testified by him who was healed. But he did not show fear, having known the Lord through trial (John 9:17), but as much as he was able to grasp, he says about him to be a prophet, and this appropriately, since he did not know the authority of the divinity, not knowing that he had made him by his own power.
So much does a pre-conceived dogma and a certain disposition toward the passing of right upon things prevail, and to darken the reasoning.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:18 1 comment from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (1) All 2 passages
On John 9:18–19
Failing with the man, they try to frighten his parents, for faith cannot live in a quarrelsome soul.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Not finding the denial they wanted from the healed one, they seek this from the parents, hoping that they, having been disturbed, would be accomplices to them in denying, because this one born blind is the one now seeing . But the evangelist says that they do not even believe; for faith does not dwell in a contentious soul and in a soul arraying itself against the power of God, so that they are not without cause for their unbelief, but are even greatly to blame, having constructed hardness within themselves, through which they did not receive the good of faith. They disturb the parents, accusing them, saying that they say their son was born blind; how, they say, to see a son [John 9:28].
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:19 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 1 passage
On John 9:19–21
God let the man be of legal age, so he could speak for himself and his parents' testimony could settle that he had been blind.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Again the same form of questioning: 'This is your son, whom you say was born blind? (John 9:19) How then does he see now?' They, having perceived the way of malice, that they are bringing threats, say to them: 'We know that this is our son; and that he was born blind we know; but how he sees now, or who opened his eyes, we do not know; he has age, ask him; he himself will speak about himself. And see the wisdom of God.'
So that they might not divert his voice, the one who had seen, as if he were a child, or as if he did not know how to speak, as in common courts, God caused him first to be shown in the age of law [of legal age] . 'He has age,' they say; 'ask him'; because immature advocates are needed, but those bringing maturity, they themselves become their own advocates.
… The parents testified so that there would be no doubt that he was not blind.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
On John 9:18–19
Failing with the man, they try to frighten his parents, for faith cannot live in a quarrelsome soul.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
Not finding the denial they wanted from the healed one, they seek this from the parents, hoping that they, having been disturbed, would be accomplices to them in denying, because this one born blind is the one now seeing . But the evangelist says that they do not even believe; for faith does not dwell in a contentious soul and in a soul arraying itself against the power of God, so that they are not without cause for their unbelief, but are even greatly to blame, having constructed hardness within themselves, through which they did not receive the good of faith. They disturb the parents, accusing them, saying that they say their son was born blind; how, they say, to see a son [John 9:28].
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:19–21
God let the man be of legal age, so he could speak for himself and his parents' testimony could settle that he had been blind.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Again the same form of questioning: 'This is your son, whom you say was born blind? (John 9:19) How then does he see now?' They, having perceived the way of malice, that they are bringing threats, say to them: 'We know that this is our son; and that he was born blind we know; but how he sees now, or who opened his eyes, we do not know; he has age, ask him; he himself will speak about himself. And see the wisdom of God.'
So that they might not divert his voice, the one who had seen, as if he were a child, or as if he did not know how to speak, as in common courts, God caused him first to be shown in the age of law [of legal age] . 'He has age,' they say; 'ask him'; because immature advocates are needed, but those bringing maturity, they themselves become their own advocates.
… The parents testified so that there would be no doubt that he was not blind.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:20 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On John 9:19–21
God let the man be of legal age, so he could speak for himself and his parents' testimony could settle that he had been blind.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Again the same form of questioning: 'This is your son, whom you say was born blind? (John 9:19) How then does he see now?' They, having perceived the way of malice, that they are bringing threats, say to them: 'We know that this is our son; and that he was born blind we know; but how he sees now, or who opened his eyes, we do not know; he has age, ask him; he himself will speak about himself. And see the wisdom of God.'
So that they might not divert his voice, the one who had seen, as if he were a child, or as if he did not know how to speak, as in common courts, God caused him first to be shown in the age of law [of legal age] . 'He has age,' they say; 'ask him'; because immature advocates are needed, but those bringing maturity, they themselves become their own advocates.
… The parents testified so that there would be no doubt that he was not blind.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
On John 9:19–21
God let the man be of legal age, so he could speak for himself and his parents' testimony could settle that he had been blind.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Again the same form of questioning: 'This is your son, whom you say was born blind? (John 9:19) How then does he see now?' They, having perceived the way of malice, that they are bringing threats, say to them: 'We know that this is our son; and that he was born blind we know; but how he sees now, or who opened his eyes, we do not know; he has age, ask him; he himself will speak about himself. And see the wisdom of God.'
So that they might not divert his voice, the one who had seen, as if he were a child, or as if he did not know how to speak, as in common courts, God caused him first to be shown in the age of law [of legal age] . 'He has age,' they say; 'ask him'; because immature advocates are needed, but those bringing maturity, they themselves become their own advocates.
… The parents testified so that there would be no doubt that he was not blind.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:21 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On John 9:19–21
God let the man be of legal age, so he could speak for himself and his parents' testimony could settle that he had been blind.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Again the same form of questioning: 'This is your son, whom you say was born blind? (John 9:19) How then does he see now?' They, having perceived the way of malice, that they are bringing threats, say to them: 'We know that this is our son; and that he was born blind we know; but how he sees now, or who opened his eyes, we do not know; he has age, ask him; he himself will speak about himself. And see the wisdom of God.'
So that they might not divert his voice, the one who had seen, as if he were a child, or as if he did not know how to speak, as in common courts, God caused him first to be shown in the age of law [of legal age] . 'He has age,' they say; 'ask him'; because immature advocates are needed, but those bringing maturity, they themselves become their own advocates.
… The parents testified so that there would be no doubt that he was not blind.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
On John 9:19–21
God let the man be of legal age, so he could speak for himself and his parents' testimony could settle that he had been blind.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Again the same form of questioning: 'This is your son, whom you say was born blind? (John 9:19) How then does he see now?' They, having perceived the way of malice, that they are bringing threats, say to them: 'We know that this is our son; and that he was born blind we know; but how he sees now, or who opened his eyes, we do not know; he has age, ask him; he himself will speak about himself. And see the wisdom of God.'
So that they might not divert his voice, the one who had seen, as if he were a child, or as if he did not know how to speak, as in common courts, God caused him first to be shown in the age of law [of legal age] . 'He has age,' they say; 'ask him'; because immature advocates are needed, but those bringing maturity, they themselves become their own advocates.
… The parents testified so that there would be no doubt that he was not blind.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:24 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 1 passage
If the healing is God's work and God is owed the glory, then the one who did it, Christ, is God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Since they were not able to deny it, they endeavored instead to cover it, and they say: 'Give glory to God; we know that this man is a sinful human.' The glory of the Son is the glory of the Father, and the glory is undivided. … They say to him, 'Give glory to God.' How? By our law? And is it right to benefit another and for another to be glorified? 'Give glory to God.' Another benefactor, and to another should I give glory? They confessed that Jesus made clay and anointed his eyes; does the one who opened them confess, and should I give the glory to another? Why should I give glory to God? Because this work is the work of God. Therefore, seeing, you confess that Christ is God. 'Give glory to God.' For if the work is of God, and to Him the glory is owed, the maker of the work is God Himself.
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
If the healing is God's work and God is owed the glory, then the one who did it, Christ, is God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Since they were not able to deny it, they endeavored instead to cover it, and they say: 'Give glory to God; we know that this man is a sinful human.' The glory of the Son is the glory of the Father, and the glory is undivided. … They say to him, 'Give glory to God.' How? By our law? And is it right to benefit another and for another to be glorified? 'Give glory to God.' Another benefactor, and to another should I give glory? They confessed that Jesus made clay and anointed his eyes; does the one who opened them confess, and should I give the glory to another? Why should I give glory to God? Because this work is the work of God. Therefore, seeing, you confess that Christ is God. 'Give glory to God.' For if the work is of God, and to Him the glory is owed, the maker of the work is God Himself.
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
They praise God's work but condemn its doer.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Foolish are the Jews who bid God be glorified because of the wonder, yet condemn the one who did God's work.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:25 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:26 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On John 9:26–27
The man answers as Jesus himself had answered, and by asking 'Will you also become his disciples?' he admits that he is one.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
“You did not hear; why do you wish to hear me again? Do you not also wish to become his disciples?” (John 9:27). And he who has not yet heard Christ's teaching imitates it. For the Jews, having surrounded the Savior in Solomon's Colonnade during the festivals (John 10:23), said to him: “How long will you lift up our soul? If you are the Christ, tell us plainly.” He says to them: “I said to you, and you did not hear; why do you wish to hear again?” And see the piety of the advocate.
Because he paid attention to the malice of the Jews, for they do everything and shape threats and fear to be cast upon him so that he might not confess himself teacher, he says to them: “I said to you already, and you did not hear; why do you wish to hear again? Do you not also wish to become his disciples?” By saying, “Do you not also?”, he showed that the “I am” is being confessed.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
On John 9:26–27
The man answers as Jesus himself had answered, and by asking 'Will you also become his disciples?' he admits that he is one.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
“You did not hear; why do you wish to hear me again? Do you not also wish to become his disciples?” (John 9:27). And he who has not yet heard Christ's teaching imitates it. For the Jews, having surrounded the Savior in Solomon's Colonnade during the festivals (John 10:23), said to him: “How long will you lift up our soul? If you are the Christ, tell us plainly.” He says to them: “I said to you, and you did not hear; why do you wish to hear again?” And see the piety of the advocate.
Because he paid attention to the malice of the Jews, for they do everything and shape threats and fear to be cast upon him so that he might not confess himself teacher, he says to them: “I said to you already, and you did not hear; why do you wish to hear again? Do you not also wish to become his disciples?” By saying, “Do you not also?”, he showed that the “I am” is being confessed.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:27 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 9:26–27
The man answers as Jesus himself had answered, and by asking 'Will you also become his disciples?' he admits that he is one.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
“You did not hear; why do you wish to hear me again? Do you not also wish to become his disciples?” (John 9:27). And he who has not yet heard Christ's teaching imitates it. For the Jews, having surrounded the Savior in Solomon's Colonnade during the festivals (John 10:23), said to him: “How long will you lift up our soul? If you are the Christ, tell us plainly.” He says to them: “I said to you, and you did not hear; why do you wish to hear again?” And see the piety of the advocate.
Because he paid attention to the malice of the Jews, for they do everything and shape threats and fear to be cast upon him so that he might not confess himself teacher, he says to them: “I said to you already, and you did not hear; why do you wish to hear again? Do you not also wish to become his disciples?” By saying, “Do you not also?”, he showed that the “I am” is being confessed.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
On John 9:26–27
The man answers as Jesus himself had answered, and by asking 'Will you also become his disciples?' he admits that he is one.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
“You did not hear; why do you wish to hear me again? Do you not also wish to become his disciples?” (John 9:27). And he who has not yet heard Christ's teaching imitates it. For the Jews, having surrounded the Savior in Solomon's Colonnade during the festivals (John 10:23), said to him: “How long will you lift up our soul? If you are the Christ, tell us plainly.” He says to them: “I said to you, and you did not hear; why do you wish to hear again?” And see the piety of the advocate.
Because he paid attention to the malice of the Jews, for they do everything and shape threats and fear to be cast upon him so that he might not confess himself teacher, he says to them: “I said to you already, and you did not hear; why do you wish to hear again? Do you not also wish to become his disciples?” By saying, “Do you not also?”, he showed that the “I am” is being confessed.
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:28 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (2) All 1 passage
On John 9:28–31
The Pharisees' 'we do not know where he is from' betrays ignorance of both his births, and the healed man turns their words against them.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
You say this out of arrogance. What they say is such a thing. We know that God through Moses gave law, but this one we do not know, except as one loosening the law; for on the Sabbath he healed the blind; for it is for this purpose they say they do not know him . And that you are a disciple of him, they say as if you are disparaging him; and that he does not know, they say as if they are able to conceive nothing concerning the suspicion of his birth according to the flesh, nor anything concerning his unspeakable birth. What then is against this the healed one? From these same words he perceives them and makes them fall upon themselves. This, he says, the wonderful thing, that you do not know where he is from, surpasses human comprehension. Furthermore, since he himself has not spoken from above, but knowing, for he says, 'we know that God does not hear sinners' , that he has spoken.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:28–33
One man stands alone against the crowd of his accusers and argues that a healing never heard of before proves Jesus is from God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Then what was against him from the Jews? They mocked him and said: “You are a disciple of that man, but we are disciples of Moses. We know that God spoke to Moses; but this one we do not know from where he is.” Consider the multitude of the objectors, and the power of one standing against them. And the advocate of the truth did not be silent again, but stood firm, saying, “For in this it is wonderful,” saying, that you do not know from where he is, and he opened my eyes (John 9:30). … He stands struggling, and God is the overseer and the judge; many are terrible against one strong man, an unbelieving cloud against a single drop of faith. From the age, he says, it was not heard that someone opened the eyes of one born blind (John 9:32). If this man were not from God, he would not have been able to do anything. Because you magnify yourselves, he says, in the teaching of Moses. He does not mention Moses at all, …
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:29 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (2) All 1 passage
On John 9:28–31
The Pharisees' 'we do not know where he is from' betrays ignorance of both his births, and the healed man turns their words against them.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
You say this out of arrogance. What they say is such a thing. We know that God through Moses gave law, but this one we do not know, except as one loosening the law; for on the Sabbath he healed the blind; for it is for this purpose they say they do not know him . And that you are a disciple of him, they say as if you are disparaging him; and that he does not know, they say as if they are able to conceive nothing concerning the suspicion of his birth according to the flesh, nor anything concerning his unspeakable birth. What then is against this the healed one? From these same words he perceives them and makes them fall upon themselves. This, he says, the wonderful thing, that you do not know where he is from, surpasses human comprehension. Furthermore, since he himself has not spoken from above, but knowing, for he says, 'we know that God does not hear sinners' , that he has spoken.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:28–33
One man stands alone against the crowd of his accusers and argues that a healing never heard of before proves Jesus is from God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Then what was against him from the Jews? They mocked him and said: “You are a disciple of that man, but we are disciples of Moses. We know that God spoke to Moses; but this one we do not know from where he is.” Consider the multitude of the objectors, and the power of one standing against them. And the advocate of the truth did not be silent again, but stood firm, saying, “For in this it is wonderful,” saying, that you do not know from where he is, and he opened my eyes (John 9:30). … He stands struggling, and God is the overseer and the judge; many are terrible against one strong man, an unbelieving cloud against a single drop of faith. From the age, he says, it was not heard that someone opened the eyes of one born blind (John 9:32). If this man were not from God, he would not have been able to do anything. Because you magnify yourselves, he says, in the teaching of Moses. He does not mention Moses at all, …
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:30 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (2) All 2 passages
On John 9:28–31
The Pharisees' 'we do not know where he is from' betrays ignorance of both his births, and the healed man turns their words against them.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
You say this out of arrogance. What they say is such a thing. We know that God through Moses gave law, but this one we do not know, except as one loosening the law; for on the Sabbath he healed the blind; for it is for this purpose they say they do not know him . And that you are a disciple of him, they say as if you are disparaging him; and that he does not know, they say as if they are able to conceive nothing concerning the suspicion of his birth according to the flesh, nor anything concerning his unspeakable birth. What then is against this the healed one? From these same words he perceives them and makes them fall upon themselves. This, he says, the wonderful thing, that you do not know where he is from, surpasses human comprehension. Furthermore, since he himself has not spoken from above, but knowing, for he says, 'we know that God does not hear sinners' , that he has spoken.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:28–33
One man stands alone against the crowd of his accusers and argues that a healing never heard of before proves Jesus is from God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Then what was against him from the Jews? They mocked him and said: “You are a disciple of that man, but we are disciples of Moses. We know that God spoke to Moses; but this one we do not know from where he is.” Consider the multitude of the objectors, and the power of one standing against them. And the advocate of the truth did not be silent again, but stood firm, saying, “For in this it is wonderful,” saying, that you do not know from where he is, and he opened my eyes (John 9:30). … He stands struggling, and God is the overseer and the judge; many are terrible against one strong man, an unbelieving cloud against a single drop of faith. From the age, he says, it was not heard that someone opened the eyes of one born blind (John 9:32). If this man were not from God, he would not have been able to do anything. Because you magnify yourselves, he says, in the teaching of Moses. He does not mention Moses at all, …
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:31 3 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (3) All 2 passages
On John 9:28–31
The Pharisees' 'we do not know where he is from' betrays ignorance of both his births, and the healed man turns their words against them.
— Apollinaris of Laodicea, c. 310–c. 390 AD
You say this out of arrogance. What they say is such a thing. We know that God through Moses gave law, but this one we do not know, except as one loosening the law; for on the Sabbath he healed the blind; for it is for this purpose they say they do not know him . And that you are a disciple of him, they say as if you are disparaging him; and that he does not know, they say as if they are able to conceive nothing concerning the suspicion of his birth according to the flesh, nor anything concerning his unspeakable birth. What then is against this the healed one? From these same words he perceives them and makes them fall upon themselves. This, he says, the wonderful thing, that you do not know where he is from, surpasses human comprehension. Furthermore, since he himself has not spoken from above, but knowing, for he says, 'we know that God does not hear sinners' , that he has spoken.
Fragments on John, §7 → read in full
On John 9:28–33
One man stands alone against the crowd of his accusers and argues that a healing never heard of before proves Jesus is from God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Then what was against him from the Jews? They mocked him and said: “You are a disciple of that man, but we are disciples of Moses. We know that God spoke to Moses; but this one we do not know from where he is.” Consider the multitude of the objectors, and the power of one standing against them. And the advocate of the truth did not be silent again, but stood firm, saying, “For in this it is wonderful,” saying, that you do not know from where he is, and he opened my eyes (John 9:30). … He stands struggling, and God is the overseer and the judge; many are terrible against one strong man, an unbelieving cloud against a single drop of faith. From the age, he says, it was not heard that someone opened the eyes of one born blind (John 9:32). If this man were not from God, he would not have been able to do anything. Because you magnify yourselves, he says, in the teaching of Moses. He does not mention Moses at all, …
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
God works wonders through the righteous, not through sinners.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
Not as a respecter of persons—God forbid—but as just and lover of the just, God works wonders through the saints, not through those who sin.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:32 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (2) All 2 passages
On John 9:28–33
One man stands alone against the crowd of his accusers and argues that a healing never heard of before proves Jesus is from God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Then what was against him from the Jews? They mocked him and said: “You are a disciple of that man, but we are disciples of Moses. We know that God spoke to Moses; but this one we do not know from where he is.” Consider the multitude of the objectors, and the power of one standing against them. And the advocate of the truth did not be silent again, but stood firm, saying, “For in this it is wonderful,” saying, that you do not know from where he is, and he opened my eyes (John 9:30). … He stands struggling, and God is the overseer and the judge; many are terrible against one strong man, an unbelieving cloud against a single drop of faith. From the age, he says, it was not heard that someone opened the eyes of one born blind (John 9:32). If this man were not from God, he would not have been able to do anything. Because you magnify yourselves, he says, in the teaching of Moses. He does not mention Moses at all, …
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
On John 9:32–33
The man's point is that no prophet ever opened the eyes of one born blind.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
… For he says, 'From the beginning of the age it has not been heard that anyone opened the eyes of one born blind' (John 9:32), that is, 'Who else opened them, a prophet?' Nor did they see the superiority, nor the comparison. But as much as this man held to the truth, so much did they not cease from shamelessness.
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:33 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (2) All 2 passages
On John 9:28–33
One man stands alone against the crowd of his accusers and argues that a healing never heard of before proves Jesus is from God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Then what was against him from the Jews? They mocked him and said: “You are a disciple of that man, but we are disciples of Moses. We know that God spoke to Moses; but this one we do not know from where he is.” Consider the multitude of the objectors, and the power of one standing against them. And the advocate of the truth did not be silent again, but stood firm, saying, “For in this it is wonderful,” saying, that you do not know from where he is, and he opened my eyes (John 9:30). … He stands struggling, and God is the overseer and the judge; many are terrible against one strong man, an unbelieving cloud against a single drop of faith. From the age, he says, it was not heard that someone opened the eyes of one born blind (John 9:32). If this man were not from God, he would not have been able to do anything. Because you magnify yourselves, he says, in the teaching of Moses. He does not mention Moses at all, …
On the Man Born Blind, §6 → read in full
On John 9:32–33
The man's point is that no prophet ever opened the eyes of one born blind.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
… For he says, 'From the beginning of the age it has not been heard that anyone opened the eyes of one born blind' (John 9:32), that is, 'Who else opened them, a prophet?' Nor did they see the superiority, nor the comparison. But as much as this man held to the truth, so much did they not cease from shamelessness.
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:34 1 comment from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 2 passages
On John 9:34–35
Cast out of the synagogue for his bold witness, the man is met outside by Jesus, as a wrestler by the judge of the contest.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
… He spoke with such boldness that they ordered him to be cast out. And they cast him out, says the evangelist, out (John 9:34). Blessed is the one set apart from the synagogue of evildoers. And see what happens. Because he contended the good struggle, and sympathized with the glory of God, and confessed the Savior gloriously with much boldness; and while his theater was being filled with wrestling matches, the wrestler was cast out without receiving the crown, and the referee meets him outside.
For Jesus heard, he says, that they had cast him out; and finding him, he says to him. Oh, the speech of the one finding him! That which error destroys, truth finds. Why then did he meet him? The Savior saw a soul full of gratitude; he saw a soul not yet having been made known to speak concerning God, but considering him to be some faithful prophet; …
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
On John 9:34–35
Cast out of the synagogue for his bold witness, the man is met outside by Jesus, as a wrestler by the judge of the contest.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
… He spoke with such boldness that they ordered him to be cast out. And they cast him out, says the evangelist, out (John 9:34). Blessed is the one set apart from the synagogue of evildoers. And see what happens. Because he contended the good struggle, and sympathized with the glory of God, and confessed the Savior gloriously with much boldness; and while his theater was being filled with wrestling matches, the wrestler was cast out without receiving the crown, and the referee meets him outside.
For Jesus heard, he says, that they had cast him out; and finding him, he says to him. Oh, the speech of the one finding him! That which error destroys, truth finds. Why then did he meet him? The Savior saw a soul full of gratitude; he saw a soul not yet having been made known to speak concerning God, but considering him to be some faithful prophet; …
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:35 3 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (3) All 2 passages
On John 9:34–35
Cast out of the synagogue for his bold witness, the man is met outside by Jesus, as a wrestler by the judge of the contest.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
… He spoke with such boldness that they ordered him to be cast out. And they cast him out, says the evangelist, out (John 9:34). Blessed is the one set apart from the synagogue of evildoers. And see what happens. Because he contended the good struggle, and sympathized with the glory of God, and confessed the Savior gloriously with much boldness; and while his theater was being filled with wrestling matches, the wrestler was cast out without receiving the crown, and the referee meets him outside.
For Jesus heard, he says, that they had cast him out; and finding him, he says to him. Oh, the speech of the one finding him! That which error destroys, truth finds. Why then did he meet him? The Savior saw a soul full of gratitude; he saw a soul not yet having been made known to speak concerning God, but considering him to be some faithful prophet; …
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
On John 9:35–37
The man had never seen Jesus' face, so he asks who the Son of God is, but he knows the voice, and Jesus leads him from 'prophet' to faith in the Son of God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Suspecting a human, he struggles thus: what will he do if he learns the glory of the deity? … Therefore, moreover, the Lord corrected him toward knowledge, having received the struggle, and having sealed the faith for him.
The Savior answers him; for this one did not recognize the character. For when He sent him to the pool of Siloam to wash, He sent him blind; but when he returned seeing, he did not see the Savior because of the crowd being mixed there, but immediately, before seeing the Master, having been called into the struggle, he struggled. … When therefore He sent him out, Christ finding him, said to him: 'Do you believe in the Son of God?' (John 9:35). For it is not necessary for you to believe in a struggling man as a prophet, but as the Son of God.
That one, not having recognized the face, recognized the voice. 'Do you believe,' He says, 'in the Son of God?' He knew the voice, and with delight he cried out, 'And who is He, Lord, so that I may believe in Him?' … And the prophet replied: 'And you have seen Him, and the one speaking with you, He is that one.'
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
On John 9:34–35
Cast out of the synagogue for his bold witness, the man is met outside by Jesus, as a wrestler by the judge of the contest.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
… He spoke with such boldness that they ordered him to be cast out. And they cast him out, says the evangelist, out (John 9:34). Blessed is the one set apart from the synagogue of evildoers. And see what happens. Because he contended the good struggle, and sympathized with the glory of God, and confessed the Savior gloriously with much boldness; and while his theater was being filled with wrestling matches, the wrestler was cast out without receiving the crown, and the referee meets him outside.
For Jesus heard, he says, that they had cast him out; and finding him, he says to him. Oh, the speech of the one finding him! That which error destroys, truth finds. Why then did he meet him? The Savior saw a soul full of gratitude; he saw a soul not yet having been made known to speak concerning God, but considering him to be some faithful prophet; …
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
Jesus asks in order to teach that faith in him is faith in God made man.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
He asks not as ignorant; for he knew that he believed, since he had contended against Jews, but showing that he greatly delights in his believing, he teaches that the one who believes in Jesus does not believe as in one human among us, but as in God become man; for thus the mystery concerning Christ is full.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
On John 9:35–37
The man had never seen Jesus' face, so he asks who the Son of God is, but he knows the voice, and Jesus leads him from 'prophet' to faith in the Son of God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Suspecting a human, he struggles thus: what will he do if he learns the glory of the deity? … Therefore, moreover, the Lord corrected him toward knowledge, having received the struggle, and having sealed the faith for him.
The Savior answers him; for this one did not recognize the character. For when He sent him to the pool of Siloam to wash, He sent him blind; but when he returned seeing, he did not see the Savior because of the crowd being mixed there, but immediately, before seeing the Master, having been called into the struggle, he struggled. … When therefore He sent him out, Christ finding him, said to him: 'Do you believe in the Son of God?' (John 9:35). For it is not necessary for you to believe in a struggling man as a prophet, but as the Son of God.
That one, not having recognized the face, recognized the voice. 'Do you believe,' He says, 'in the Son of God?' He knew the voice, and with delight he cried out, 'And who is He, Lord, so that I may believe in Him?' … And the prophet replied: 'And you have seen Him, and the one speaking with you, He is that one.'
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:36 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On John 9:35–37
The man had never seen Jesus' face, so he asks who the Son of God is, but he knows the voice, and Jesus leads him from 'prophet' to faith in the Son of God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Suspecting a human, he struggles thus: what will he do if he learns the glory of the deity? … Therefore, moreover, the Lord corrected him toward knowledge, having received the struggle, and having sealed the faith for him.
The Savior answers him; for this one did not recognize the character. For when He sent him to the pool of Siloam to wash, He sent him blind; but when he returned seeing, he did not see the Savior because of the crowd being mixed there, but immediately, before seeing the Master, having been called into the struggle, he struggled. … When therefore He sent him out, Christ finding him, said to him: 'Do you believe in the Son of God?' (John 9:35). For it is not necessary for you to believe in a struggling man as a prophet, but as the Son of God.
That one, not having recognized the face, recognized the voice. 'Do you believe,' He says, 'in the Son of God?' He knew the voice, and with delight he cried out, 'And who is He, Lord, so that I may believe in Him?' … And the prophet replied: 'And you have seen Him, and the one speaking with you, He is that one.'
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
On John 9:35–37
The man had never seen Jesus' face, so he asks who the Son of God is, but he knows the voice, and Jesus leads him from 'prophet' to faith in the Son of God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Suspecting a human, he struggles thus: what will he do if he learns the glory of the deity? … Therefore, moreover, the Lord corrected him toward knowledge, having received the struggle, and having sealed the faith for him.
The Savior answers him; for this one did not recognize the character. For when He sent him to the pool of Siloam to wash, He sent him blind; but when he returned seeing, he did not see the Savior because of the crowd being mixed there, but immediately, before seeing the Master, having been called into the struggle, he struggled. … When therefore He sent him out, Christ finding him, said to him: 'Do you believe in the Son of God?' (John 9:35). For it is not necessary for you to believe in a struggling man as a prophet, but as the Son of God.
That one, not having recognized the face, recognized the voice. 'Do you believe,' He says, 'in the Son of God?' He knew the voice, and with delight he cried out, 'And who is He, Lord, so that I may believe in Him?' … And the prophet replied: 'And you have seen Him, and the one speaking with you, He is that one.'
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:37 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 1 passage
On John 9:35–37
The man had never seen Jesus' face, so he asks who the Son of God is, but he knows the voice, and Jesus leads him from 'prophet' to faith in the Son of God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Suspecting a human, he struggles thus: what will he do if he learns the glory of the deity? … Therefore, moreover, the Lord corrected him toward knowledge, having received the struggle, and having sealed the faith for him.
The Savior answers him; for this one did not recognize the character. For when He sent him to the pool of Siloam to wash, He sent him blind; but when he returned seeing, he did not see the Savior because of the crowd being mixed there, but immediately, before seeing the Master, having been called into the struggle, he struggled. … When therefore He sent him out, Christ finding him, said to him: 'Do you believe in the Son of God?' (John 9:35). For it is not necessary for you to believe in a struggling man as a prophet, but as the Son of God.
That one, not having recognized the face, recognized the voice. 'Do you believe,' He says, 'in the Son of God?' He knew the voice, and with delight he cried out, 'And who is He, Lord, so that I may believe in Him?' … And the prophet replied: 'And you have seen Him, and the one speaking with you, He is that one.'
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
On John 9:35–37
The man had never seen Jesus' face, so he asks who the Son of God is, but he knows the voice, and Jesus leads him from 'prophet' to faith in the Son of God.
— Severianus of Gabala, fl. c. 400 AD
Suspecting a human, he struggles thus: what will he do if he learns the glory of the deity? … Therefore, moreover, the Lord corrected him toward knowledge, having received the struggle, and having sealed the faith for him.
The Savior answers him; for this one did not recognize the character. For when He sent him to the pool of Siloam to wash, He sent him blind; but when he returned seeing, he did not see the Savior because of the crowd being mixed there, but immediately, before seeing the Master, having been called into the struggle, he struggled. … When therefore He sent him out, Christ finding him, said to him: 'Do you believe in the Son of God?' (John 9:35). For it is not necessary for you to believe in a struggling man as a prophet, but as the Son of God.
That one, not having recognized the face, recognized the voice. 'Do you believe,' He says, 'in the Son of God?' He knew the voice, and with delight he cried out, 'And who is He, Lord, so that I may believe in Him?' … And the prophet replied: 'And you have seen Him, and the one speaking with you, He is that one.'
On the Man Born Blind, §7 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:39 4 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (4) All 4 passages
Jesus never blinded anyone's bodily eyes, so the blinding he speaks of is of those who see wrongly.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
… Jesus says he works [this blindness] in the Gospel, saying: 'I came that those who do not see might see, and those who see might become blind' (John 9:39). But Jesus, according to history, has made no one blind, but has granted sight to the blind. It is therefore evident that he makes those who see badly blind, and makes those who are useful to see again with the useful eyes, …
On Genesis, §31 → read in full
Jesus never blinded anyone's bodily eyes, so the blinding he speaks of is of those who see wrongly.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
… Jesus says he works [this blindness] in the Gospel, saying: 'I came that those who do not see might see, and those who see might become blind' (John 9:39). But Jesus, according to history, has made no one blind, but has granted sight to the blind. It is therefore evident that he makes those who see badly blind, and makes those who are useful to see again with the useful eyes, …
On Genesis, §31 → read in full
We have two kinds of eyes, and the Word opens the soul's eyes while closing the eyes of sense so the soul can see without distraction.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
That is why our Saviour too, knowing that we have this twofold kind of eyes, says: “For judgement I came into this world, that those who do not see may see, and that those who see may become blind” (John 9:39). By “those who do not see” he hints at the eyes of the soul, which the Word makes see; by “those who see,” at the eyes of the senses; and these the Word blinded, so that the soul might see without distraction what it ought.
Against Celsus, Book VII, §39 → read in full
On John 9:39–41
His condemners are themselves condemned as sinners.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
That is: unto greater punishment; for those who condemned him as a sinner are themselves condemned as sinners.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
On John 9:39–41
Those blind from ignorance seem to have no sin, yet ignorance of good and evil is itself a sin of neglect.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
The "eyes of the heart" have been enlightened (Ephesians 1:18), shining by the light of the true one. The one opposite, being blinded by that which causes ignorance, seems not to have sin because he does not act willingly or sluggishly sinning. But this ignorance in another way is sin; for it was logical to have the knowledge of good and evil. Therefore, he is accused for the neglect of this, in favor of that ignorance. For this, the "slave who did not know the will of the master will be given little" (Luke 12:48).
Fragments on John, §3 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Origen of Alexandria c. 185–c. 254 AD · Against Celsus, Book VII §39 That is why our Saviour too, knowing that we have this twofold kind of eyes, says: “For judgement I came into this world, that those who do not see may see, and that those who see may become blind”. Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · Commentary on Zechariah §146 Similarly, according to the theory applied, one should attempt to take what was said in the Gospel by our Savior, as previously brought forward: 'I came into the world for judgment, so that those not seeing might see and those seeing… Didymus the Blind c. 313–c. 398 AD · On Genesis §31 But the serpent, wanting them to be wise unto evil, wished to open those eyes running toward this, who, while virtue is at work, are not opened but happen to be closed, remaining blind, which Jesus says he works in the Gospel, saying: 'I… Ammonius of Alexandria fl. 5th century AD · Fragments on John §19 [John 9:39 ] That is: unto greater punishment; for those who condemned him as a sinner are themselves condemned as sinners. Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:40 2 comments from the Fathers
Complete (2)
On John 9:39–41
His condemners are themselves condemned as sinners.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
That is: unto greater punishment; for those who condemned him as a sinner are themselves condemned as sinners.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
On John 9:39–41
Those blind from ignorance seem to have no sin, yet ignorance of good and evil is itself a sin of neglect.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
The "eyes of the heart" have been enlightened (Ephesians 1:18), shining by the light of the true one. The one opposite, being blinded by that which causes ignorance, seems not to have sin because he does not act willingly or sluggishly sinning. But this ignorance in another way is sin; for it was logical to have the knowledge of good and evil. Therefore, he is accused for the neglect of this, in favor of that ignorance. For this, the "slave who did not know the will of the master will be given little" (Luke 12:48).
Fragments on John, §3 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
John 9:41 2 comments from the Fathers
Complete (2)
On John 9:39–41
His condemners are themselves condemned as sinners.
— Ammonius of Alexandria, fl. 5th century AD
That is: unto greater punishment; for those who condemned him as a sinner are themselves condemned as sinners.
Fragments on John, §19 → read in full
On John 9:39–41
Those blind from ignorance seem to have no sin, yet ignorance of good and evil is itself a sin of neglect.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
The "eyes of the heart" have been enlightened (Ephesians 1:18), shining by the light of the true one. The one opposite, being blinded by that which causes ignorance, seems not to have sin because he does not act willingly or sluggishly sinning. But this ignorance in another way is sin; for it was logical to have the knowledge of good and evil. Therefore, he is accused for the neglect of this, in favor of that ignorance. For this, the "slave who did not know the will of the master will be given little" (Luke 12:48).
Fragments on John, §3 → read in full
Back to the chapter