▶ Listen to the King James Version 0:00 / 3:17 1×
1 Guard your steps when you go to the house of God. Draw near to listen rather than to offer the sacrifice of fools, who do not know that they do wrong. Verse 1: 2 passages in the Fathers 2 Do not be quick to speak, and do not be hasty in your heart to utter a word before God. After all, God is in heaven and you are on earth. So let your words be few. Verse 2: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 3 As a dream comes through many cares, so the speech of a fool comes with many words. Verse 3: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 4 When you make a vow to God, do not delay in fulfilling it, because He takes no pleasure in fools. Fulfill your vow. Verse 4: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 5 It is better not to vow than to make a vow and not fulfill it. Verse 5: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 6 Do not let your mouth cause your flesh to sin, and do not tell the messenger that your vow was a mistake. Why should God be angry with your words and destroy the work of your hands? Verse 6: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 7 For as many dreams bring futility, so do many words. Therefore, fear God. Verse 7: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 8 If you see the oppression of the poor and the denial of justice and righteousness in the province, do not be astonished at the matter; for one official is watched by a superior, and others higher still are over them. Verse 8: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 9 The produce of the earth is taken by all; the king himself profits from the fields. Verse 9: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 10 He who loves money is never satisfied by money, and he who loves wealth is never satisfied by income. This too is futile. Verse 10: 5 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 11 When good things increase, so do those who consume them; what then is the profit to the owner, except to behold them with his eyes? Verse 11: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 12 The sleep of the worker is sweet, whether he eats little or much, but the abundance of the rich man permits him no sleep. Verse 12: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 13 There is a grievous evil I have seen under the sun: wealth hoarded to the harm of its owner, Verse 13: 4 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 14 or wealth lost in a failed venture, so when that man has a son there is nothing to pass on. Verse 14: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 15 As a man came from his mother’s womb, so he will depart again, naked as he arrived. He takes nothing for his labor to carry in his hands. Verse 15: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 16 This too is a grievous evil: Exactly as a man is born, so he will depart. What does he gain as he toils for the wind? Verse 16: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 17 Moreover, all his days he eats in darkness, with much sorrow, sickness, and anger. Verse 17: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 18 Here is what I have seen to be good and fitting: to eat and drink, and to find satisfaction in all the labor one does under the sun during the few days of life that God has given him—for this is his lot. Verse 18: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 19 Furthermore, God has given riches and wealth to every man, and He has enabled him to enjoy them, to accept his lot, and to rejoice in his labor. This is a gift from God. Verse 19: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 20 For a man seldom considers the days of his life, because God keeps him occupied with the joy of his heart. Verse 20: 2 passages in the Fathers, with commentary
Audio: the King James Version read aloud, from Larry Sanger's Deep Dive Bible (public domain).
×
This chapter in the Fathers
Ecclesiastes 5 44 passages
20 of 20 verses cited
7 writers
Most cited verses Ecclesiastes 5:10 5 passages Ecclesiastes 5:13 4 passages Ecclesiastes 5:5 3 passages Ecclesiastes 5:4 3 passages Ecclesiastes 5:3 2 passages Ecclesiastes 5:7 2 passages Ecclesiastes 5:8 2 passages Ecclesiastes 5:9 2 passages Select a marked verse to see who cites it.
Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:1 2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:2 1 comment from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:2–3
It is good to spare the tongue, for we speak within God's hearing and must not let slip whatever comes to mind, since dream images follow the soul's cares and idle chatter goes with folly.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
It is good to spare the tongue, and to keep a steady heart in your eagerness to speak (Ecclesiastes 5:2). For we must not be careless about our words and let slip through the voice whatever comes into the mind, even when it is out of place. Rather, we must bear in mind that, though we stand far from heaven, we speak within God's hearing (Ecclesiastes 5:2), and that it pays to speak without stumbling. Just as all manner of dream images attend the varied cares of the soul, so idle chatter is yoked to folly (Ecclesiastes 5:3).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.1 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:2–3
It is good to spare the tongue, for we speak within God's hearing and must not let slip whatever comes to mind, since dream images follow the soul's cares and idle chatter goes with folly.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
It is good to spare the tongue, and to keep a steady heart in your eagerness to speak (Ecclesiastes 5:2). For we must not be careless about our words and let slip through the voice whatever comes into the mind, even when it is out of place. Rather, we must bear in mind that, though we stand far from heaven, we speak within God's hearing (Ecclesiastes 5:2), and that it pays to speak without stumbling. Just as all manner of dream images attend the varied cares of the soul, so idle chatter is yoked to folly (Ecclesiastes 5:3).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.1 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:3 1 comment from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (1) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:2–3
It is good to spare the tongue, for we speak within God's hearing and must not let slip whatever comes to mind, since dream images follow the soul's cares and idle chatter goes with folly.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
It is good to spare the tongue, and to keep a steady heart in your eagerness to speak (Ecclesiastes 5:2). For we must not be careless about our words and let slip through the voice whatever comes into the mind, even when it is out of place. Rather, we must bear in mind that, though we stand far from heaven, we speak within God's hearing (Ecclesiastes 5:2), and that it pays to speak without stumbling. Just as all manner of dream images attend the varied cares of the soul, so idle chatter is yoked to folly (Ecclesiastes 5:3).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.1 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:2–3
It is good to spare the tongue, for we speak within God's hearing and must not let slip whatever comes to mind, since dream images follow the soul's cares and idle chatter goes with folly.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
It is good to spare the tongue, and to keep a steady heart in your eagerness to speak (Ecclesiastes 5:2). For we must not be careless about our words and let slip through the voice whatever comes into the mind, even when it is out of place. Rather, we must bear in mind that, though we stand far from heaven, we speak within God's hearing (Ecclesiastes 5:2), and that it pays to speak without stumbling. Just as all manner of dream images attend the varied cares of the soul, so idle chatter is yoked to folly (Ecclesiastes 5:3).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.1 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:4 2 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Complete (2) All 3 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:4–5
Whatever you vow to God you must carry out at once, for delay is not without loss, and it is better not to vow than to vow and not pay.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
For I say that we must remember him who speaks plainly through the most wise Moses: ‘You shall keep what goes out through your lips’ (Deuteronomy 23:23). That is, whatever you vow, hasten to carry it out, and very promptly. For in such matters delay is not without loss. ‘For if you make a vow to the Lord,’ it says, ‘do not delay in paying it’ (Deuteronomy 23:21; Ecclesiastes 5:4). ‘It is better that you should not vow than that you should vow and not pay’ (Ecclesiastes 5:5).
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 16, §16 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:4–7
To promise God something and then delay keeping it is a fault, and the servant who knew his duty and left it undone will be punished more than the one who did not know.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
Let us therefore see what it means to promise and to delay; for it is not always the large interval of time that the delay signifies, but the complete denial of the promise. For Jacob appears to have given to God the tenth parts after many years, while walking toward Mesopotamia, and Hannah bringing Samuel to God after a long time.
Regarding the gifts around the body, it is thus; but regarding the gifts of the soul and the body, how should one interpret delay? I think that he who promises correct faith and says it is a creation, delays one thing from the Holy Trinity; and he who promises to confess all things through God and introduces automatism again, delays; and regarding the other dogmas, likewise. Regarding virtues, it is thus: he who promises righteousness and is unrighteous, delays in fulfilling it; and he who promises temperance and is again committing fornication, delays. Regarding the things of the body: he who promises self-control and again takes on various bonds, delays; and he who promises virginity or monogamy and having married or having married a second time, delays in fulfilling it.
As for how 'it is good not to vow or to vow and not to fulfill,' we will solve this by bringing in the Gospel, that the servant who did not know and did not do will be punished little, but he who knew and did not do will be punished much. 'Do not give your mouth to sin your flesh, and do not say before the face of God that it is ignorance, so that God may not be angry at your voice and destroy the works of your hands' (Eccl 5:5-6). For in a multitude of dreams and vanities and many words—'In a multitude, he says, of dreams' (Eccl 5:7)—evil 'and of vanities and words' (Eccl 5:7) false, a man becomes, his works being destroyed from the abandonment of God, which happened to him because of his own lawlessness.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:5 2 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Complete (2) All 3 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:4–5
Whatever you vow to God you must carry out at once, for delay is not without loss, and it is better not to vow than to vow and not pay.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
For I say that we must remember him who speaks plainly through the most wise Moses: ‘You shall keep what goes out through your lips’ (Deuteronomy 23:23). That is, whatever you vow, hasten to carry it out, and very promptly. For in such matters delay is not without loss. ‘For if you make a vow to the Lord,’ it says, ‘do not delay in paying it’ (Deuteronomy 23:21; Ecclesiastes 5:4). ‘It is better that you should not vow than that you should vow and not pay’ (Ecclesiastes 5:5).
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 16, §16 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:4–7
To promise God something and then delay keeping it is a fault, and the servant who knew his duty and left it undone will be punished more than the one who did not know.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
Let us therefore see what it means to promise and to delay; for it is not always the large interval of time that the delay signifies, but the complete denial of the promise. For Jacob appears to have given to God the tenth parts after many years, while walking toward Mesopotamia, and Hannah bringing Samuel to God after a long time.
Regarding the gifts around the body, it is thus; but regarding the gifts of the soul and the body, how should one interpret delay? I think that he who promises correct faith and says it is a creation, delays one thing from the Holy Trinity; and he who promises to confess all things through God and introduces automatism again, delays; and regarding the other dogmas, likewise. Regarding virtues, it is thus: he who promises righteousness and is unrighteous, delays in fulfilling it; and he who promises temperance and is again committing fornication, delays. Regarding the things of the body: he who promises self-control and again takes on various bonds, delays; and he who promises virginity or monogamy and having married or having married a second time, delays in fulfilling it.
As for how 'it is good not to vow or to vow and not to fulfill,' we will solve this by bringing in the Gospel, that the servant who did not know and did not do will be punished little, but he who knew and did not do will be punished much. 'Do not give your mouth to sin your flesh, and do not say before the face of God that it is ignorance, so that God may not be angry at your voice and destroy the works of your hands' (Eccl 5:5-6). For in a multitude of dreams and vanities and many words—'In a multitude, he says, of dreams' (Eccl 5:7)—evil 'and of vanities and words' (Eccl 5:7) false, a man becomes, his works being destroyed from the abandonment of God, which happened to him because of his own lawlessness.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:6 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (2) All 1 passage
On Ecclesiastes 5:4–7
To promise God something and then delay keeping it is a fault, and the servant who knew his duty and left it undone will be punished more than the one who did not know.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
Let us therefore see what it means to promise and to delay; for it is not always the large interval of time that the delay signifies, but the complete denial of the promise. For Jacob appears to have given to God the tenth parts after many years, while walking toward Mesopotamia, and Hannah bringing Samuel to God after a long time.
Regarding the gifts around the body, it is thus; but regarding the gifts of the soul and the body, how should one interpret delay? I think that he who promises correct faith and says it is a creation, delays one thing from the Holy Trinity; and he who promises to confess all things through God and introduces automatism again, delays; and regarding the other dogmas, likewise. Regarding virtues, it is thus: he who promises righteousness and is unrighteous, delays in fulfilling it; and he who promises temperance and is again committing fornication, delays. Regarding the things of the body: he who promises self-control and again takes on various bonds, delays; and he who promises virginity or monogamy and having married or having married a second time, delays in fulfilling it.
As for how 'it is good not to vow or to vow and not to fulfill,' we will solve this by bringing in the Gospel, that the servant who did not know and did not do will be punished little, but he who knew and did not do will be punished much. 'Do not give your mouth to sin your flesh, and do not say before the face of God that it is ignorance, so that God may not be angry at your voice and destroy the works of your hands' (Eccl 5:5-6). For in a multitude of dreams and vanities and many words—'In a multitude, he says, of dreams' (Eccl 5:7)—evil 'and of vanities and words' (Eccl 5:7) false, a man becomes, his works being destroyed from the abandonment of God, which happened to him because of his own lawlessness.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:6–7
Flee a flood of fine-sounding words, for God hears them and the one who trusts them sees his works destroyed.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
You must flee by every means the flood of such fine-sounding words, knowing that God will hear them (Ecclesiastes 5:6). For the one who sets his mind on such things gains nothing but to watch his own works being destroyed by God (Ecclesiastes 5:6). For as many dreams are empty, so too are many words (Ecclesiastes 5:7).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.1 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:7 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (2) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:4–7
To promise God something and then delay keeping it is a fault, and the servant who knew his duty and left it undone will be punished more than the one who did not know.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
Let us therefore see what it means to promise and to delay; for it is not always the large interval of time that the delay signifies, but the complete denial of the promise. For Jacob appears to have given to God the tenth parts after many years, while walking toward Mesopotamia, and Hannah bringing Samuel to God after a long time.
Regarding the gifts around the body, it is thus; but regarding the gifts of the soul and the body, how should one interpret delay? I think that he who promises correct faith and says it is a creation, delays one thing from the Holy Trinity; and he who promises to confess all things through God and introduces automatism again, delays; and regarding the other dogmas, likewise. Regarding virtues, it is thus: he who promises righteousness and is unrighteous, delays in fulfilling it; and he who promises temperance and is again committing fornication, delays. Regarding the things of the body: he who promises self-control and again takes on various bonds, delays; and he who promises virginity or monogamy and having married or having married a second time, delays in fulfilling it.
As for how 'it is good not to vow or to vow and not to fulfill,' we will solve this by bringing in the Gospel, that the servant who did not know and did not do will be punished little, but he who knew and did not do will be punished much. 'Do not give your mouth to sin your flesh, and do not say before the face of God that it is ignorance, so that God may not be angry at your voice and destroy the works of your hands' (Eccl 5:5-6). For in a multitude of dreams and vanities and many words—'In a multitude, he says, of dreams' (Eccl 5:7)—evil 'and of vanities and words' (Eccl 5:7) false, a man becomes, his works being destroyed from the abandonment of God, which happened to him because of his own lawlessness.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:6–7
Flee a flood of fine-sounding words, for God hears them and the one who trusts them sees his works destroyed.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
You must flee by every means the flood of such fine-sounding words, knowing that God will hear them (Ecclesiastes 5:6). For the one who sets his mind on such things gains nothing but to watch his own works being destroyed by God (Ecclesiastes 5:6). For as many dreams are empty, so too are many words (Ecclesiastes 5:7).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.1 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:8 3 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:8–9
Do not be amazed at injustice among men as if there were no providence, for God preserves all things through Christ and provides for all through the holy angels.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
If you see oppression of the poor and the seizing of judgment and justice in a land, do not marvel at the matter; for high sits above high and the high ones are upon them (Eccl 5:8). And abundance of the land is upon everything, the work of the field of the king (Eccl 5:9). …
If you see, he says, among men some being slandered, others being treated unjustly in judgment, and others practicing righteousness, do not marvel at these things happening as if there were no providence. For know that God through Christ preserves all things, and this one again provides for all through the holy angels abounding in the knowledge of those on earth.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
Do not wonder at oppression of the poor, but avoid seeming greater than the powerful, for wickedness will not rescue you.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
So there is no need to wonder when you look at the poor being oppressed and at judges who reason dishonestly (Ecclesiastes 5:8). But you must avoid seeming to be greater than those who are more powerful (Ecclesiastes 5:8). For even if you should manage this, still wickedness, of itself, will not rescue you from the terrors that are to come upon you.
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.1 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:8–9
Do not be amazed at injustice among men as if there were no providence, for God preserves all things through Christ and provides for all through the holy angels.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
If you see oppression of the poor and the seizing of judgment and justice in a land, do not marvel at the matter; for high sits above high and the high ones are upon them (Eccl 5:8). And abundance of the land is upon everything, the work of the field of the king (Eccl 5:9). …
If you see, he says, among men some being slandered, others being treated unjustly in judgment, and others practicing righteousness, do not marvel at these things happening as if there were no providence. For know that God through Christ preserves all things, and this one again provides for all through the holy angels abounding in the knowledge of those on earth.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:8–12
God, the King of the world, will bring tribulation on those who prefer greed and give the knowledge of God and sweet rest to those who lived well, and the Lord has entrusted this world to angels.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
For God is the King of the world brought into being through him, who will give tribulation to those who prefer greed and the vanity of this life over the knowledge of Christ, but to those who have lived in goodness and have served in courage and righteousness, he will give the knowledge of God and sweet rest, even if they have known only a few things here or many words, knowing in part and prophesying in part; and the one will receive such an end, but the one filled with wickedness he will not allow the worm born of it to rest.
Since the Lord entrusted this world to angels, Moses shows by saying: 'When the Most High divided the nations, as he scattered the sons of Adam, he set the boundaries of nations according to the number of the angels of God.' And the Lord our own in the Gospels named the world a field, saying: 'The world is a field.' And regarding the abundance of the earth, he says of those on earth, if indeed, 'Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth'; what other inheritance is there for rational nature besides the knowledge of God? And he called the angels high, because they partake of the high Lord: 'For high above all nations is the Lord,' he says.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:9 5 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (5) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:8–9
Do not be amazed at injustice among men as if there were no providence, for God preserves all things through Christ and provides for all through the holy angels.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
If you see oppression of the poor and the seizing of judgment and justice in a land, do not marvel at the matter; for high sits above high and the high ones are upon them (Eccl 5:8). And abundance of the land is upon everything, the work of the field of the king (Eccl 5:9). …
If you see, he says, among men some being slandered, others being treated unjustly in judgment, and others practicing righteousness, do not marvel at these things happening as if there were no providence. For know that God through Christ preserves all things, and this one again provides for all through the holy angels abounding in the knowledge of those on earth.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
A cultivated field shows that it has a king, as a driven chariot shows a charioteer and a rowed ship a pilot, even when he is not seen.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
'Abundance of the earth is in everything, a king of the cultivated field is there' (Ecclesiastes 5:9). In the literal sense: no one is lord, master, or ruler of a field while it is being blamed for bearing 'thorns and thistles' (Gen 3:18); but of a cultivated field, there is a king. He calls the king the owner. In the literal sense: if you see a cultivated field, know that it has a master and a king; just as if you see a chariot being driven in the manner of a charioteer, you realize you are receiving the impression of a charioteer; and if you see a ship being rowed and it must be steered in a certain way, you receive the impression of a pilot, even if you do not see him.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §1 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:8–9
Do not be amazed at injustice among men as if there were no providence, for God preserves all things through Christ and provides for all through the holy angels.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
If you see oppression of the poor and the seizing of judgment and justice in a land, do not marvel at the matter; for high sits above high and the high ones are upon them (Eccl 5:8). And abundance of the land is upon everything, the work of the field of the king (Eccl 5:9). …
If you see, he says, among men some being slandered, others being treated unjustly in judgment, and others practicing righteousness, do not marvel at these things happening as if there were no providence. For know that God through Christ preserves all things, and this one again provides for all through the holy angels abounding in the knowledge of those on earth.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:8–12
God, the King of the world, will bring tribulation on those who prefer greed and give the knowledge of God and sweet rest to those who lived well, and the Lord has entrusted this world to angels.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
For God is the King of the world brought into being through him, who will give tribulation to those who prefer greed and the vanity of this life over the knowledge of Christ, but to those who have lived in goodness and have served in courage and righteousness, he will give the knowledge of God and sweet rest, even if they have known only a few things here or many words, knowing in part and prophesying in part; and the one will receive such an end, but the one filled with wickedness he will not allow the worm born of it to rest.
Since the Lord entrusted this world to angels, Moses shows by saying: 'When the Most High divided the nations, as he scattered the sons of Adam, he set the boundaries of nations according to the number of the angels of God.' And the Lord our own in the Gospels named the world a field, saying: 'The world is a field.' And regarding the abundance of the earth, he says of those on earth, if indeed, 'Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth'; what other inheritance is there for rational nature besides the knowledge of God? And he called the angels high, because they partake of the high Lord: 'For high above all nations is the Lord,' he says.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
A cultivated field shows that it has a king, as a driven chariot shows a charioteer and a rowed ship a pilot, even when he is not seen.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
'Abundance of the earth is in everything, a king of the cultivated field is there' (Ecclesiastes 5:9). In the literal sense: no one is lord, master, or ruler of a field while it is being blamed for bearing 'thorns and thistles' (Gen 3:18); but of a cultivated field, there is a king. He calls the king the owner. In the literal sense: if you see a cultivated field, know that it has a master and a king; just as if you see a chariot being driven in the manner of a charioteer, you realize you are receiving the impression of a charioteer; and if you see a ship being rowed and it must be steered in a certain way, you receive the impression of a pilot, even if you do not see him.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §1 → read in full
A field in order points to its ruler, as a fabric points to a weaver, and a soul well farmed and sown in tears likewise has a king.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
And those who occasionally introduce the idea that God's providence rules all things, say, if they are constructing something, that it is providence; just as a fabric clearly shows that there is a weaver, even if the weaver does not appear, so one, seeing a cultivated field, receives the impression that it has a leader and a ruler. … But it is also more powerful and more public to say so, if one sees a soul like a cultivated field, having been tilled, in bloom, with produce and trees and a multitude of produce. For 'one bore a hundred, another sixty, another thirty' (Matthew 13:8). When you see, therefore, a soul thus being farmed and having 'sown in tears' (Ps 126:5) and having itself ready for 'reaping in joy' (Ps 126:6), of this cultivated thing there is a king, a word meaning a leader, a word meaning one ruling and reigning.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §1 → read in full
The Church, with its right teaching and good works, is a field whose king is the practical life, but where there are false teachers the field has a tyrant or a robber.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
But one should also take another analogy: the Church of God, according to the pious doctrines and the ethical works, and those who practice them, are called a field. … The practical life is a king for this field, because it has worked. But when you see false teachers and "churches committing adultery", know that this field has not worked truly; it does not have a king who praises it, but rather a tyrant or a robber. For robbers and tyrants especially pursue the wilderness.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §1 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:10 4 comments from the Fathers, 5 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (4) All 5 passages
Greed is never satisfied: what is added to wealth only kindles the appetite for more, and the greedy person, as Hades never does, never says 'Enough'.
— Basil of Caesarea, c. 330–379 AD
You are eager to add ten more talents to your ten; when they become twenty, you seek another twenty, and what is added never stops your impulse but kindles your appetite. … Whatever the eye sees, the greedy person desires. The eye is not satisfied with seeing, nor the money-lover with taking (Ecclesiastes 5:10 [4:8 LXX] ). Hades never said, “Enough,” and the greedy person never said, “Enough.” … When will you use what you have? When will you enjoy it, always gripped by the labors of acquisition?
Homily to the Rich, §5 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:8–12
God, the King of the world, will bring tribulation on those who prefer greed and give the knowledge of God and sweet rest to those who lived well, and the Lord has entrusted this world to angels.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
For God is the King of the world brought into being through him, who will give tribulation to those who prefer greed and the vanity of this life over the knowledge of Christ, but to those who have lived in goodness and have served in courage and righteousness, he will give the knowledge of God and sweet rest, even if they have known only a few things here or many words, knowing in part and prophesying in part; and the one will receive such an end, but the one filled with wickedness he will not allow the worm born of it to rest.
Since the Lord entrusted this world to angels, Moses shows by saying: 'When the Most High divided the nations, as he scattered the sons of Adam, he set the boundaries of nations according to the number of the angels of God.' And the Lord our own in the Gospels named the world a field, saying: 'The world is a field.' And regarding the abundance of the earth, he says of those on earth, if indeed, 'Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth'; what other inheritance is there for rational nature besides the knowledge of God? And he called the angels high, because they partake of the high Lord: 'For high above all nations is the Lord,' he says.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
The one who loves material things is never filled, but the one who loves the words of the Lord will be filled with refined silver, so the verse speaks of fake silver.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
"He who loves silver will not be filled with silver" (Eccl 5:10). As for the literal sense: the one desiring material things is never filled, … It can be said concerning silver here: "it is not praised". For the one loving "the words of the Lord" will also be filled with "refined silver". For he does not always know "in part", nor, having transitioned from "out of the fullness", does he remain in the "from the fullness", but he will encounter eventually to approach "face to face" (1 Cor 13:12) the truth and to acquire the very "fullness" of the mind of Christ. … Therefore, the discourse is concerning fake silver.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §1 → read in full
Greed is never satisfied: what is added to wealth only kindles the appetite for more, and the greedy person, as Hades never does, never says 'Enough'.
— Basil of Caesarea, c. 330–379 AD
You are eager to add ten more talents to your ten; when they become twenty, you seek another twenty, and what is added never stops your impulse but kindles your appetite. … Whatever the eye sees, the greedy person desires. The eye is not satisfied with seeing, nor the money-lover with taking (Ecclesiastes 5:10 [4:8 LXX] ). Hades never said, “Enough,” and the greedy person never said, “Enough.” … When will you use what you have? When will you enjoy it, always gripped by the labors of acquisition?
Homily to the Rich, §5 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:10–15
The man who craves money never has his fill, hoarding wealth brings sleepless nights, and the wealth must perish while he himself departs as he came.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Just as a possession seized by robbery is most harmful and most unholy, so the man who craves money never has his fill, nor does he win the goodwill of his neighbors, even if such men gain ever so vast a sum of silver (Ecclesiastes 5:10). For this is vain. But goodness gladdens beyond measure those who keep company with it and makes them strong, granting them the power to see each thing clearly (Ecclesiastes 5:11). It is a great thing, too, not to cling to such cares. The poor man, even if he is a slave and has not stuffed his belly full, enjoys the gentle rest that sleep brings; but the desire for wealth lives with sleepless nights and weariness of soul (Ecclesiastes 5:12). What could be more absurd than to hoard up wealth with great effort and care and keep it safe, guarding for oneself the source of countless evils (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? That wealth must one day perish and be destroyed, whether its owner has children or not (Ecclesiastes 5:14). And he himself, even if he does not wish it, must fall to the earth and depart just as he was when he first came into being (Ecclesiastes 5:15).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
5 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:11 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (2) All 1 passage
On Ecclesiastes 5:8–12
God, the King of the world, will bring tribulation on those who prefer greed and give the knowledge of God and sweet rest to those who lived well, and the Lord has entrusted this world to angels.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
For God is the King of the world brought into being through him, who will give tribulation to those who prefer greed and the vanity of this life over the knowledge of Christ, but to those who have lived in goodness and have served in courage and righteousness, he will give the knowledge of God and sweet rest, even if they have known only a few things here or many words, knowing in part and prophesying in part; and the one will receive such an end, but the one filled with wickedness he will not allow the worm born of it to rest.
Since the Lord entrusted this world to angels, Moses shows by saying: 'When the Most High divided the nations, as he scattered the sons of Adam, he set the boundaries of nations according to the number of the angels of God.' And the Lord our own in the Gospels named the world a field, saying: 'The world is a field.' And regarding the abundance of the earth, he says of those on earth, if indeed, 'Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth'; what other inheritance is there for rational nature besides the knowledge of God? And he called the angels high, because they partake of the high Lord: 'For high above all nations is the Lord,' he says.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:10–15
The man who craves money never has his fill, hoarding wealth brings sleepless nights, and the wealth must perish while he himself departs as he came.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Just as a possession seized by robbery is most harmful and most unholy, so the man who craves money never has his fill, nor does he win the goodwill of his neighbors, even if such men gain ever so vast a sum of silver (Ecclesiastes 5:10). For this is vain. But goodness gladdens beyond measure those who keep company with it and makes them strong, granting them the power to see each thing clearly (Ecclesiastes 5:11). It is a great thing, too, not to cling to such cares. The poor man, even if he is a slave and has not stuffed his belly full, enjoys the gentle rest that sleep brings; but the desire for wealth lives with sleepless nights and weariness of soul (Ecclesiastes 5:12). What could be more absurd than to hoard up wealth with great effort and care and keep it safe, guarding for oneself the source of countless evils (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? That wealth must one day perish and be destroyed, whether its owner has children or not (Ecclesiastes 5:14). And he himself, even if he does not wish it, must fall to the earth and depart just as he was when he first came into being (Ecclesiastes 5:15).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:12 4 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (4) All 1 passage
On Ecclesiastes 5:8–12
God, the King of the world, will bring tribulation on those who prefer greed and give the knowledge of God and sweet rest to those who lived well, and the Lord has entrusted this world to angels.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
For God is the King of the world brought into being through him, who will give tribulation to those who prefer greed and the vanity of this life over the knowledge of Christ, but to those who have lived in goodness and have served in courage and righteousness, he will give the knowledge of God and sweet rest, even if they have known only a few things here or many words, knowing in part and prophesying in part; and the one will receive such an end, but the one filled with wickedness he will not allow the worm born of it to rest.
Since the Lord entrusted this world to angels, Moses shows by saying: 'When the Most High divided the nations, as he scattered the sons of Adam, he set the boundaries of nations according to the number of the angels of God.' And the Lord our own in the Gospels named the world a field, saying: 'The world is a field.' And regarding the abundance of the earth, he says of those on earth, if indeed, 'Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth'; what other inheritance is there for rational nature besides the knowledge of God? And he called the angels high, because they partake of the high Lord: 'For high above all nations is the Lord,' he says.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:10–15
The man who craves money never has his fill, hoarding wealth brings sleepless nights, and the wealth must perish while he himself departs as he came.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Just as a possession seized by robbery is most harmful and most unholy, so the man who craves money never has his fill, nor does he win the goodwill of his neighbors, even if such men gain ever so vast a sum of silver (Ecclesiastes 5:10). For this is vain. But goodness gladdens beyond measure those who keep company with it and makes them strong, granting them the power to see each thing clearly (Ecclesiastes 5:11). It is a great thing, too, not to cling to such cares. The poor man, even if he is a slave and has not stuffed his belly full, enjoys the gentle rest that sleep brings; but the desire for wealth lives with sleepless nights and weariness of soul (Ecclesiastes 5:12). What could be more absurd than to hoard up wealth with great effort and care and keep it safe, guarding for oneself the source of countless evils (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? That wealth must one day perish and be destroyed, whether its owner has children or not (Ecclesiastes 5:14). And he himself, even if he does not wish it, must fall to the earth and depart just as he was when he first came into being (Ecclesiastes 5:15).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
The slave who obeys from fear of judgment and abstains from evil sleeps sweetly, but he has the spirit of slavery and is not yet a son.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
He says that in time, in a certain way, he is a slave, obedient and private in his knowledge—and he is rich, having gathered many observations—and the sleep of one who thinks himself a slave and a slave-servant is sweet, whether he perceives little or much. And if he has the practice, so that this slave may have the 'spirit' of 'slavery,' he is not yet a 'son.' He is subject to the fear of judgment and 'abstains' from evil—if it must be said that he abstains—from the 'fear of punishment.' This, then, is a slave moved by the fear of the law.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:12–13
Wealth can hold its owner instead of the owner holding it, so that the lover of silver becomes a slave to mammon and endures all pains for his gain.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Another, thinking to be in many things, but having erred, has the care that does not permit him to sleep, a vain care. There is a sickness, which I saw under the sun (Ecclesiastes 5:13), a wealth guarded by one for his own wickedness, and that wealth will be lost in evil distraction. He says such things: For what is the purpose of someone's wealth? It is evident that even there the master of wealth is the wealth itself. This, then, is the one who has a sweetness from someone, and he himself is the master of the wealth; just as he is able to use the wealth well, holding it and not serving it, that is, the mammon (Matt 6:24), in this way wealth can hold the possessor; and woe to him, when he becomes a lover of silver, when he becomes a slave to mammon. He says, therefore, that such is 'wealth guarded by it.' He did not say simply the wealth itself, but 'guarded by it.' This is the wealth of the possessor. Thus also: how all painful things are endured for the sake of his acquisition.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:13 5 comments from the Fathers, 4 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (5) All 4 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:13–14
Providing for children is only a fine-looking excuse for greed, and wealth gathered with labor may prepare material of sins for others, so the soul should be given its inheritance first.
— Basil of Caesarea, c. 330–379 AD
“But wealth is necessary because of the children.” This is a fine-looking excuse for greed. For you put forward the children, but you fill up your own heart. Do not blame the blameless one. The child has his own master, his own steward. From another he received his life, from him he awaits the resources of life. Were the Gospels not written for those who have married? “If you wish to be perfect, sell your possessions, and give to the poor” (Matthew 19:21). When you asked the Lord for children, when you thought it right to become a father of children, did you add this: “Give me children, so that I may disobey your commandments? Give me children, so that I may not reach the kingdom of heaven?” And who will be the guarantor of the child’s choice, that he will use what is given to him as he ought? For to many people wealth has become a servant of licentiousness. Or do you not hear Ecclesiastes saying: “I saw a grievous sickness, wealth kept by its owner to his own harm” (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? And again: “I am leaving it to the man who comes after me” (Ecclesiastes 2:18). “And who knows whether he will be wise or a fool?” (Ecclesiastes 2:19). See to it, then, that after gathering wealth with countless labors, you do not prepare material of sins for others, and then be found punished doubly: for the wrongs you yourself committed, and for the wrongs you supplied to another.
Homily to the Rich, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:10–15
The man who craves money never has his fill, hoarding wealth brings sleepless nights, and the wealth must perish while he himself departs as he came.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Just as a possession seized by robbery is most harmful and most unholy, so the man who craves money never has his fill, nor does he win the goodwill of his neighbors, even if such men gain ever so vast a sum of silver (Ecclesiastes 5:10). For this is vain. But goodness gladdens beyond measure those who keep company with it and makes them strong, granting them the power to see each thing clearly (Ecclesiastes 5:11). It is a great thing, too, not to cling to such cares. The poor man, even if he is a slave and has not stuffed his belly full, enjoys the gentle rest that sleep brings; but the desire for wealth lives with sleepless nights and weariness of soul (Ecclesiastes 5:12). What could be more absurd than to hoard up wealth with great effort and care and keep it safe, guarding for oneself the source of countless evils (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? That wealth must one day perish and be destroyed, whether its owner has children or not (Ecclesiastes 5:14). And he himself, even if he does not wish it, must fall to the earth and depart just as he was when he first came into being (Ecclesiastes 5:15).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:12–13
Wealth can hold its owner instead of the owner holding it, so that the lover of silver becomes a slave to mammon and endures all pains for his gain.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Another, thinking to be in many things, but having erred, has the care that does not permit him to sleep, a vain care. There is a sickness, which I saw under the sun (Ecclesiastes 5:13), a wealth guarded by one for his own wickedness, and that wealth will be lost in evil distraction. He says such things: For what is the purpose of someone's wealth? It is evident that even there the master of wealth is the wealth itself. This, then, is the one who has a sweetness from someone, and he himself is the master of the wealth; just as he is able to use the wealth well, holding it and not serving it, that is, the mammon (Matt 6:24), in this way wealth can hold the possessor; and woe to him, when he becomes a lover of silver, when he becomes a slave to mammon. He says, therefore, that such is 'wealth guarded by it.' He did not say simply the wealth itself, but 'guarded by it.' This is the wealth of the possessor. Thus also: how all painful things are endured for the sake of his acquisition.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
The sickness is wealth guarded for itself, which shows great wickedness and leaves its keeper without the wisdom of God.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
There is a sickness which I saw under the sun, wealth being guarded by it for its own wickedness. The abundance of wickedness is now shown by wealth; and this wickedness is signified by sickness. … Therefore, everyone guarding this wealth for himself will not know the wisdom of God, nor will he cast his heart into understanding
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §6 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:13–14
Providing for children is only a fine-looking excuse for greed, and wealth gathered with labor may prepare material of sins for others, so the soul should be given its inheritance first.
— Basil of Caesarea, c. 330–379 AD
“But wealth is necessary because of the children.” This is a fine-looking excuse for greed. For you put forward the children, but you fill up your own heart. Do not blame the blameless one. The child has his own master, his own steward. From another he received his life, from him he awaits the resources of life. Were the Gospels not written for those who have married? “If you wish to be perfect, sell your possessions, and give to the poor” (Matthew 19:21). When you asked the Lord for children, when you thought it right to become a father of children, did you add this: “Give me children, so that I may disobey your commandments? Give me children, so that I may not reach the kingdom of heaven?” And who will be the guarantor of the child’s choice, that he will use what is given to him as he ought? For to many people wealth has become a servant of licentiousness. Or do you not hear Ecclesiastes saying: “I saw a grievous sickness, wealth kept by its owner to his own harm” (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? And again: “I am leaving it to the man who comes after me” (Ecclesiastes 2:18). “And who knows whether he will be wise or a fool?” (Ecclesiastes 2:19). See to it, then, that after gathering wealth with countless labors, you do not prepare material of sins for others, and then be found punished doubly: for the wrongs you yourself committed, and for the wrongs you supplied to another.
Homily to the Rich, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:13–15
The sickness is that neither the owner nor his heirs enjoy the wealth, for it is lost in distraction, as with the man who buys slaves who die, builds ships that are wrecked, and sows and loses even the seed.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
And the terror of the sickness is this: neither he himself enjoys it, nor does any of his successors. Furthermore, is it not 'that wealth will be lost in evil distraction'? There is wealth being lost by suddenness or by being snatched away by wars or robbers having become strong and finding and taking it. … This is not being taken in distraction. But when someone becomes a sailor or does other things for the sake of mobile wealth to gain much, often he is lost in the distraction. …
There was a time when we had in our hands: “God has given the sons of men an evil distraction” (Eccl 1:13). Often he buys slaves and they die; he builds ships and they are wrecked; he sows and loses even the seed. So in distraction it is lost — not in profligacy, not in idleness of hands. “And he begot a son, and there is nothing in his hand” (Ecclesiastes 5:14). “Just as he came out naked from his mother’s womb, he will return to go as he came” (Eccl 5:14). Men make children their excuse when they gather wealth; indeed they sometimes do wrong and plunder and do other things, saying, “I do this for the children’s sake.”
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
4 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:14 6 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (6) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:13–14
Providing for children is only a fine-looking excuse for greed, and wealth gathered with labor may prepare material of sins for others, so the soul should be given its inheritance first.
— Basil of Caesarea, c. 330–379 AD
“But wealth is necessary because of the children.” This is a fine-looking excuse for greed. For you put forward the children, but you fill up your own heart. Do not blame the blameless one. The child has his own master, his own steward. From another he received his life, from him he awaits the resources of life. Were the Gospels not written for those who have married? “If you wish to be perfect, sell your possessions, and give to the poor” (Matthew 19:21). When you asked the Lord for children, when you thought it right to become a father of children, did you add this: “Give me children, so that I may disobey your commandments? Give me children, so that I may not reach the kingdom of heaven?” And who will be the guarantor of the child’s choice, that he will use what is given to him as he ought? For to many people wealth has become a servant of licentiousness. Or do you not hear Ecclesiastes saying: “I saw a grievous sickness, wealth kept by its owner to his own harm” (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? And again: “I am leaving it to the man who comes after me” (Ecclesiastes 2:18). “And who knows whether he will be wise or a fool?” (Ecclesiastes 2:19). See to it, then, that after gathering wealth with countless labors, you do not prepare material of sins for others, and then be found punished doubly: for the wrongs you yourself committed, and for the wrongs you supplied to another.
Homily to the Rich, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:14–15
The evil is ignorance, and as the man came into the world with it, with it he will leave, whereas Job, a righteous man, goes naked free from malice and wickedness.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
An evil distraction is ignorance which, through punishment, separates the unclean from spiritual contemplation. Just as he went out from his mother's womb naked (Ecclesiastes 5:15), he will return to go his way as he has come, and he will take nothing from his labor, so that he may go with nothing in his hand (Eccl 5:15). And this too is an evil sickness; for just as it came to be, so it will depart.
And Job says: 'Naked I came out from the womb of my mother, and naked I will depart there' (Job 1:21); but the one here says 'just as he went out from his mother's womb naked, he will return to go his way as he has come' (Ecclesiastes 5:15). But Job, as a righteous man, goes naked, free from malice and wickedness; but this one, with that ignorance by which he came into this world, with this also he will depart there.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:10–15
The man who craves money never has his fill, hoarding wealth brings sleepless nights, and the wealth must perish while he himself departs as he came.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Just as a possession seized by robbery is most harmful and most unholy, so the man who craves money never has his fill, nor does he win the goodwill of his neighbors, even if such men gain ever so vast a sum of silver (Ecclesiastes 5:10). For this is vain. But goodness gladdens beyond measure those who keep company with it and makes them strong, granting them the power to see each thing clearly (Ecclesiastes 5:11). It is a great thing, too, not to cling to such cares. The poor man, even if he is a slave and has not stuffed his belly full, enjoys the gentle rest that sleep brings; but the desire for wealth lives with sleepless nights and weariness of soul (Ecclesiastes 5:12). What could be more absurd than to hoard up wealth with great effort and care and keep it safe, guarding for oneself the source of countless evils (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? That wealth must one day perish and be destroyed, whether its owner has children or not (Ecclesiastes 5:14). And he himself, even if he does not wish it, must fall to the earth and depart just as he was when he first came into being (Ecclesiastes 5:15).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:13–14
Providing for children is only a fine-looking excuse for greed, and wealth gathered with labor may prepare material of sins for others, so the soul should be given its inheritance first.
— Basil of Caesarea, c. 330–379 AD
“But wealth is necessary because of the children.” This is a fine-looking excuse for greed. For you put forward the children, but you fill up your own heart. Do not blame the blameless one. The child has his own master, his own steward. From another he received his life, from him he awaits the resources of life. Were the Gospels not written for those who have married? “If you wish to be perfect, sell your possessions, and give to the poor” (Matthew 19:21). When you asked the Lord for children, when you thought it right to become a father of children, did you add this: “Give me children, so that I may disobey your commandments? Give me children, so that I may not reach the kingdom of heaven?” And who will be the guarantor of the child’s choice, that he will use what is given to him as he ought? For to many people wealth has become a servant of licentiousness. Or do you not hear Ecclesiastes saying: “I saw a grievous sickness, wealth kept by its owner to his own harm” (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? And again: “I am leaving it to the man who comes after me” (Ecclesiastes 2:18). “And who knows whether he will be wise or a fool?” (Ecclesiastes 2:19). See to it, then, that after gathering wealth with countless labors, you do not prepare material of sins for others, and then be found punished doubly: for the wrongs you yourself committed, and for the wrongs you supplied to another.
Homily to the Rich, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:13–15
The sickness is that neither the owner nor his heirs enjoy the wealth, for it is lost in distraction, as with the man who buys slaves who die, builds ships that are wrecked, and sows and loses even the seed.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
And the terror of the sickness is this: neither he himself enjoys it, nor does any of his successors. Furthermore, is it not 'that wealth will be lost in evil distraction'? There is wealth being lost by suddenness or by being snatched away by wars or robbers having become strong and finding and taking it. … This is not being taken in distraction. But when someone becomes a sailor or does other things for the sake of mobile wealth to gain much, often he is lost in the distraction. …
There was a time when we had in our hands: “God has given the sons of men an evil distraction” (Eccl 1:13). Often he buys slaves and they die; he builds ships and they are wrecked; he sows and loses even the seed. So in distraction it is lost — not in profligacy, not in idleness of hands. “And he begot a son, and there is nothing in his hand” (Ecclesiastes 5:14). “Just as he came out naked from his mother’s womb, he will return to go as he came” (Eccl 5:14). Men make children their excuse when they gather wealth; indeed they sometimes do wrong and plunder and do other things, saying, “I do this for the children’s sake.”
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
A son may leave as he came, without what his father valued, since many who loved the learning of this world had sons who did not.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Many who possessed the things of “falsely-named knowledge” (1 Tim 6:20) or of Greek philosophy did not have sons who were lovers of these things; rather their sons depart together with them, having acquired nothing in the same way. Many unlearned men, at any rate, have become sons of wise men. This son, then, departs as he came: he came without such instruction and departs without it. But this too is possible: that one begets him who is reputed wise in this way — begets someone in wickedness, in licentiousness, the other kinds of evil — and he comes out naked of what the father was zealous for. The father was zealous, though, not at all about the kinds of evil, but about glory and “falsely-named knowledge.”
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §5 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:14–15
The man zealous for wealth gains nothing from it, neither enjoying it nor ruling his son, and at death returns as poor as he was born, able to take only the soul's goods.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
I saw, then, one zealous for wealth, and the wealth profited him nothing: for he neither enjoyed it, nor became master of the son he had, but is altogether poor, just as he was when born — born without money, without clothing. Again, “in the hand of the son” means “in the son’s power there is nothing.” We are accustomed to say, “he has the wealth under his hand.” When, then, the day of death comes, he returns again without dignity, without authority, taking nothing from this life; only the soul’s goods can one take up.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:14–15
The evil is ignorance, and as the man came into the world with it, with it he will leave, whereas Job, a righteous man, goes naked free from malice and wickedness.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
An evil distraction is ignorance which, through punishment, separates the unclean from spiritual contemplation. Just as he went out from his mother's womb naked (Ecclesiastes 5:15), he will return to go his way as he has come, and he will take nothing from his labor, so that he may go with nothing in his hand (Eccl 5:15). And this too is an evil sickness; for just as it came to be, so it will depart.
And Job says: 'Naked I came out from the womb of my mother, and naked I will depart there' (Job 1:21); but the one here says 'just as he went out from his mother's womb naked, he will return to go his way as he has come' (Ecclesiastes 5:15). But Job, as a righteous man, goes naked, free from malice and wickedness; but this one, with that ignorance by which he came into this world, with this also he will depart there.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:15 7 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (7) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:14–15
The evil is ignorance, and as the man came into the world with it, with it he will leave, whereas Job, a righteous man, goes naked free from malice and wickedness.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
An evil distraction is ignorance which, through punishment, separates the unclean from spiritual contemplation. Just as he went out from his mother's womb naked (Ecclesiastes 5:15), he will return to go his way as he has come, and he will take nothing from his labor, so that he may go with nothing in his hand (Eccl 5:15). And this too is an evil sickness; for just as it came to be, so it will depart.
And Job says: 'Naked I came out from the womb of my mother, and naked I will depart there' (Job 1:21); but the one here says 'just as he went out from his mother's womb naked, he will return to go his way as he has come' (Ecclesiastes 5:15). But Job, as a righteous man, goes naked, free from malice and wickedness; but this one, with that ignorance by which he came into this world, with this also he will depart there.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:10–15
The man who craves money never has his fill, hoarding wealth brings sleepless nights, and the wealth must perish while he himself departs as he came.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Just as a possession seized by robbery is most harmful and most unholy, so the man who craves money never has his fill, nor does he win the goodwill of his neighbors, even if such men gain ever so vast a sum of silver (Ecclesiastes 5:10). For this is vain. But goodness gladdens beyond measure those who keep company with it and makes them strong, granting them the power to see each thing clearly (Ecclesiastes 5:11). It is a great thing, too, not to cling to such cares. The poor man, even if he is a slave and has not stuffed his belly full, enjoys the gentle rest that sleep brings; but the desire for wealth lives with sleepless nights and weariness of soul (Ecclesiastes 5:12). What could be more absurd than to hoard up wealth with great effort and care and keep it safe, guarding for oneself the source of countless evils (Ecclesiastes 5:13)? That wealth must one day perish and be destroyed, whether its owner has children or not (Ecclesiastes 5:14). And he himself, even if he does not wish it, must fall to the earth and depart just as he was when he first came into being (Ecclesiastes 5:15).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:13–15
The sickness is that neither the owner nor his heirs enjoy the wealth, for it is lost in distraction, as with the man who buys slaves who die, builds ships that are wrecked, and sows and loses even the seed.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
And the terror of the sickness is this: neither he himself enjoys it, nor does any of his successors. Furthermore, is it not 'that wealth will be lost in evil distraction'? There is wealth being lost by suddenness or by being snatched away by wars or robbers having become strong and finding and taking it. … This is not being taken in distraction. But when someone becomes a sailor or does other things for the sake of mobile wealth to gain much, often he is lost in the distraction. …
There was a time when we had in our hands: “God has given the sons of men an evil distraction” (Eccl 1:13). Often he buys slaves and they die; he builds ships and they are wrecked; he sows and loses even the seed. So in distraction it is lost — not in profligacy, not in idleness of hands. “And he begot a son, and there is nothing in his hand” (Ecclesiastes 5:14). “Just as he came out naked from his mother’s womb, he will return to go as he came” (Eccl 5:14). Men make children their excuse when they gather wealth; indeed they sometimes do wrong and plunder and do other things, saying, “I do this for the children’s sake.”
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:14–15
The man zealous for wealth gains nothing from it, neither enjoying it nor ruling his son, and at death returns as poor as he was born, able to take only the soul's goods.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
I saw, then, one zealous for wealth, and the wealth profited him nothing: for he neither enjoyed it, nor became master of the son he had, but is altogether poor, just as he was when born — born without money, without clothing. Again, “in the hand of the son” means “in the son’s power there is nothing.” We are accustomed to say, “he has the wealth under his hand.” When, then, the day of death comes, he returns again without dignity, without authority, taking nothing from this life; only the soul’s goods can one take up.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:14–15
The evil is ignorance, and as the man came into the world with it, with it he will leave, whereas Job, a righteous man, goes naked free from malice and wickedness.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
An evil distraction is ignorance which, through punishment, separates the unclean from spiritual contemplation. Just as he went out from his mother's womb naked (Ecclesiastes 5:15), he will return to go his way as he has come, and he will take nothing from his labor, so that he may go with nothing in his hand (Eccl 5:15). And this too is an evil sickness; for just as it came to be, so it will depart.
And Job says: 'Naked I came out from the womb of my mother, and naked I will depart there' (Job 1:21); but the one here says 'just as he went out from his mother's womb naked, he will return to go his way as he has come' (Ecclesiastes 5:15). But Job, as a righteous man, goes naked, free from malice and wickedness; but this one, with that ignorance by which he came into this world, with this also he will depart there.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
Wisdom and habits are called mothers, as people are called sons of perdition or of light, and this man's mother, wickedness, brought him forth, so he enters having acquired nothing.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
I say that wisdom is the mother of the wise man: “for wisdom was justified by her children” (Matt 11:19); and the children of wisdom are the wise. “And your mother will guide you” — wisdom. And again, habits — the worse and the better — are called mothers of the things done according to them. So too one is called “son of perdition” (John 17:12), “son of vipers” (Matt 3:7), “of death,” “son of light” (Luke 16:8), and another “son of peace” (Luke 10:6). Here we take the blameworthy mother, since the person under discussion is not an excellent one. According to the anagogy he has a blameworthy mother: just as his mother — wickedness — brought him forth, so he enters here having acquired nothing, in opposition to what his father — who gathered toilsome wealth — provided, and his mother, the habit that bore him.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §5 → read in full
He will leave taking nothing of his toil, and he stores up not knowing for whom he gathers.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
He will turn back to go as he has come, and he will take nothing of his toil. The fact of the history is clear: he takes nothing of what he labored for. He lets them go and did not know at the time, even if they come upon his enemies. 'He stores up,' he says, 'and does not know for whom he gathers them' (Psalm 39:6).
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §5 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:15–16
The verse can mean that he takes nothing, though if taken as a partial denial he takes with him the good he does with his money and office, and what he gathers for the wind does not remain.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
But concerning sensible and human things it is said: “Do not fear when a man grows rich and the glory of his house is multiplied, for when he dies he will not take all things” (Psalm 49:16-17). Here the pretext that says “he will not take all things” is not a partial denial but a universal one — instead of “nothing.” And if you wish to take it literally as a partial privative denial, it says this: that there are things one does take — if, having money, he does good; if, having glory and office, he reaches out to the helpless and tries to help — from his zealous labors he takes these with him: … If, then, “in his abundance he toils for the wind” (Ecclesiastes 5:16), what he gathers does not remain.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:16 3 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (3) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:15–16
The verse can mean that he takes nothing, though if taken as a partial denial he takes with him the good he does with his money and office, and what he gathers for the wind does not remain.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
But concerning sensible and human things it is said: “Do not fear when a man grows rich and the glory of his house is multiplied, for when he dies he will not take all things” (Psalm 49:16-17). Here the pretext that says “he will not take all things” is not a partial denial but a universal one — instead of “nothing.” And if you wish to take it literally as a partial privative denial, it says this: that there are things one does take — if, having money, he does good; if, having glory and office, he reaches out to the helpless and tries to help — from his zealous labors he takes these with him: … If, then, “in his abundance he toils for the wind” (Ecclesiastes 5:16), what he gathers does not remain.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §4 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:16–17
The man's toil becomes wind because his wealth is not his own, and his days are darkness, meaning ignorance, and mourning, so that he has died while living.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
And what is his abundance, for which he toils toward the wind? His toil becomes wind, that is, his wealth is being overturned by nature; it is not becoming his own, not being held, so as even to be sent to a son. And indeed all his days are in darkness and in mourning. Darkness here means ignorance and the lack of clarity of things. And he mourns, missing those things which he hoped for, from which he thinks he has a pleasant life. And something stands before him. For mourning is raised up over death. In a certain way, therefore, he has died while living, 'and all his days are in darkness and he mourns' (Ecclesiastes 5:17). 'And the one who squanders,' he says, 'has died while living' (1 Tim 5:6).
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §5 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:16–17
One about to depart with empty hands toils for nothing, serving the wind, after a life of unholy desires and griefs, so that his days are darkness and his life mourning.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
As he is about to depart with empty hands, he adds to his own wickedness, as if he did not consider that an end of life like his birth lies before him, and that he toils for nothing, serving some gust of wind rather than his own purpose (Ecclesiastes 5:16), after spending his whole life in most unholy desires and senseless impulses, and in griefs and sicknesses besides (Ecclesiastes 5:17). In short, for such a man the days are darkness and life is mourning.
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:17 2 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Complete (2) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:16–17
The man's toil becomes wind because his wealth is not his own, and his days are darkness, meaning ignorance, and mourning, so that he has died while living.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
And what is his abundance, for which he toils toward the wind? His toil becomes wind, that is, his wealth is being overturned by nature; it is not becoming his own, not being held, so as even to be sent to a son. And indeed all his days are in darkness and in mourning. Darkness here means ignorance and the lack of clarity of things. And he mourns, missing those things which he hoped for, from which he thinks he has a pleasant life. And something stands before him. For mourning is raised up over death. In a certain way, therefore, he has died while living, 'and all his days are in darkness and he mourns' (Ecclesiastes 5:17). 'And the one who squanders,' he says, 'has died while living' (1 Tim 5:6).
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §5 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:16–17
One about to depart with empty hands toils for nothing, serving the wind, after a life of unholy desires and griefs, so that his days are darkness and his life mourning.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
As he is about to depart with empty hands, he adds to his own wickedness, as if he did not consider that an end of life like his birth lies before him, and that he toils for nothing, serving some gust of wind rather than his own purpose (Ecclesiastes 5:16), after spending his whole life in most unholy desires and senseless impulses, and in griefs and sicknesses besides (Ecclesiastes 5:17). In short, for such a man the days are darkness and life is mourning.
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:18 3 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (3) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
Enjoying one's labors with gladness, over possessions given by God and not seized by robbery, is a gift of God.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Yet this is good and not to be cast aside, for it is a gift of God: that a person can enjoy his own labors with gladness, having received possessions given by God and not seized by robbery (Ecclesiastes 5:18-19). For such a man is not sick with griefs, nor is he much enslaved to evil thoughts; he measures out his life in good deeds toward all, glad of heart and rejoicing in the gift of God (Ecclesiastes 5:20).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
Eating and drinking and enjoying one's labor are God's gift, and the knowledge of God is named by the intellect food, drink, goodness, portion, wealth, joy and gift.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
Behold, what I saw was good, which is beautiful: to eat and to drink and to see goodness in all his labor (Ecclesiastes 5:18), by which he labors under the sun, a number of the days of his life which God gave to him (Eccl 5:18); for it is a portion of Him. And indeed every man to whom God gave wealth and possessions, and empowered him to eat from it and to take his portion and to be joyful in his labor (Eccl 5:18), this is a gift of God (Eccl 5:19). For he will not remember many of the days of his life; for God distracts him with the joy of his heart.
The knowledge of God is called by the intellect food and drink and goodness and portion and wealth and possessions and joy and distraction of God and light and life and gift; and the Holy Spirit sets many other names upon knowledge, which it is not possible now to recount, unless the rule of the scholia permits.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
A saying such as 'Let us eat and drink' must be read according to the speaker, for the same writer speaks there in the person of those who say there is no life after this one.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
One must take the words toward those speaking. If the speaker is wise, one must listen to them wisely. If, being wise, he personifies another face and brings it appropriately to that man, one must again listen to the conversation in that person. Since the apostle himself says: 'whether we eat or whether we drink, we neither lack nor exceed' (1 Corinthians 8:8), whether we are Christians or wise.
Or 'slaves of Christ', we have neither addition nor subtraction from the eating of anything still. But when he says, 'Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die' (1 Corinthians 15:32), it is the same scribe, the same one speaking, but not from his own person, not as an apostle speaks, but he took the persona of those saying that beyond this present life, there is no life after these things.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §8 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
Enjoying one's labors with gladness, over possessions given by God and not seized by robbery, is a gift of God.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Yet this is good and not to be cast aside, for it is a gift of God: that a person can enjoy his own labors with gladness, having received possessions given by God and not seized by robbery (Ecclesiastes 5:18-19). For such a man is not sick with griefs, nor is he much enslaved to evil thoughts; he measures out his life in good deeds toward all, glad of heart and rejoicing in the gift of God (Ecclesiastes 5:20).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:19 10 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (3) Complete (10) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
Enjoying one's labors with gladness, over possessions given by God and not seized by robbery, is a gift of God.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Yet this is good and not to be cast aside, for it is a gift of God: that a person can enjoy his own labors with gladness, having received possessions given by God and not seized by robbery (Ecclesiastes 5:18-19). For such a man is not sick with griefs, nor is he much enslaved to evil thoughts; he measures out his life in good deeds toward all, glad of heart and rejoicing in the gift of God (Ecclesiastes 5:20).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
The power to eat, take a share and be glad in one's labor is itself a gift of God, though some fail to use it through stinginess or sickness.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
The power to eat from it, to take a part of it, and to be glad in its labor—this is a gift of God. Wealth was given to a man so that he might eat and be glad from it, and therefore this gift was from God. … Often one uses the gift and enjoys what is in it, but sometimes one fails to do so, either because he himself, through much stinginess, consumes nothing toward being glad, or because he is hindered by sickness or some other circumstance.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
A man with much money can eat and drink only what suffices, and that is God's gift, while one who goes beyond what is necessary has gifts of pleasure instead.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
If he has much money, if he has myriads of grain and much wine, he is not able to eat or drink everything, but he has a gift; which he is able to receive, the sufficient food, even until being satisfied, and that similarly, 'this is a gift of God.' If, therefore, anyone eats or drinks beyond what is necessary, he does not have these things as a gift of God, but as gifts of pleasure.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
Eating and drinking and enjoying one's labor are God's gift, and the knowledge of God is named by the intellect food, drink, goodness, portion, wealth, joy and gift.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
Behold, what I saw was good, which is beautiful: to eat and to drink and to see goodness in all his labor (Ecclesiastes 5:18), by which he labors under the sun, a number of the days of his life which God gave to him (Eccl 5:18); for it is a portion of Him. And indeed every man to whom God gave wealth and possessions, and empowered him to eat from it and to take his portion and to be joyful in his labor (Eccl 5:18), this is a gift of God (Eccl 5:19). For he will not remember many of the days of his life; for God distracts him with the joy of his heart.
The knowledge of God is called by the intellect food and drink and goodness and portion and wealth and possessions and joy and distraction of God and light and life and gift; and the Holy Spirit sets many other names upon knowledge, which it is not possible now to recount, unless the rule of the scholia permits.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
A saying such as 'Let us eat and drink' must be read according to the speaker, for the same writer speaks there in the person of those who say there is no life after this one.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
One must take the words toward those speaking. If the speaker is wise, one must listen to them wisely. If, being wise, he personifies another face and brings it appropriately to that man, one must again listen to the conversation in that person. Since the apostle himself says: 'whether we eat or whether we drink, we neither lack nor exceed' (1 Corinthians 8:8), whether we are Christians or wise.
Or 'slaves of Christ', we have neither addition nor subtraction from the eating of anything still. But when he says, 'Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die' (1 Corinthians 15:32), it is the same scribe, the same one speaking, but not from his own person, not as an apostle speaks, but he took the persona of those saying that beyond this present life, there is no life after these things.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §8 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
Enjoying one's labors with gladness, over possessions given by God and not seized by robbery, is a gift of God.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Yet this is good and not to be cast aside, for it is a gift of God: that a person can enjoy his own labors with gladness, having received possessions given by God and not seized by robbery (Ecclesiastes 5:18-19). For such a man is not sick with griefs, nor is he much enslaved to evil thoughts; he measures out his life in good deeds toward all, glad of heart and rejoicing in the gift of God (Ecclesiastes 5:20).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
Judas received spiritual wealth but was not empowered by it, having given away the truth for gain.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
To contrast those who indeed received wealth of wisdom and knowledge, but did not indeed preserve it, it is said, 'and empowered him' (Ecclesiastes 5:19). For even the traitor Judas received intellectual wealth and spiritual possessions, but he was not empowered by them, having given away wisdom and the truth of God for the sake of gain.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
The power to eat, take a share and be glad in one's labor is itself a gift of God, though some fail to use it through stinginess or sickness.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
The power to eat from it, to take a part of it, and to be glad in its labor—this is a gift of God. Wealth was given to a man so that he might eat and be glad from it, and therefore this gift was from God. … Often one uses the gift and enjoys what is in it, but sometimes one fails to do so, either because he himself, through much stinginess, consumes nothing toward being glad, or because he is hindered by sickness or some other circumstance.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
Not everything God gives is a spiritual gift: wealth, health, life and the authority of rulers are gifts of God but sensible and human, unlike a word of wisdom or knowledge.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
I was saying what even the apostle says: 'that I often intended to come to you' (Romans 1:13). For what reason then? 'That I might impart to you a spiritual gift' (Romans 1:11). And I was saying that not all things given by God are spiritual gifts. Whenever anyone receives a 'word of wisdom,' a 'word of knowledge,' and some other virtue, he has received a spiritual grace; but not if someone receives wealth or health or something of that kind; he has received a gift of God and a grace, but not a spiritual one.
The Lord 'causes death and makes alive' (1 Sam 2:6). If He 'makes alive,' meaning grain, wine, this very life, He has provided, but not a spiritual gift. The Lord 'appoints kings and removes them' (Dan 2:21). The authorities given to the rulers are certainly not 'spiritual gifts.' And the grace here, which is the gift, is not spiritual, being sensible and human.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
A man with much money can eat and drink only what suffices, and that is God's gift, while one who goes beyond what is necessary has gifts of pleasure instead.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
If he has much money, if he has myriads of grain and much wine, he is not able to eat or drink everything, but he has a gift; which he is able to receive, the sufficient food, even until being satisfied, and that similarly, 'this is a gift of God.' If, therefore, anyone eats or drinks beyond what is necessary, he does not have these things as a gift of God, but as gifts of pleasure.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
God gives wisdom as wealth, that a man may eat the bread of wisdom.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
And toward the ascent, thus: God gives wisdom and the 'wealth' in wisdom. And the 'existing things,' the contemplations of wisdom, so that the man might eat and drink from which he received, the bread of wisdom.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
A portion of the gift is given to each according to his power, as a trainer gives athletes different amounts of food and the master in the parable of the talents gave each according to his ability.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
If, for example, a trainer provides food to athletes and to those around the contest—for he also has others like bodyguards—he gives to each according to a proportion: to one athlete seven pounds of meat—and this is his portion—to another four; and to the one not competing, he gives two. Thus, a portion is given to each according to his power and his capacity. In this way also the parable of the talents in the Gospel occurred. He gave to each of his slaves his own silver, 'to each according to his own ability, to the one five, to the other two, and to the other one' (Matthew 25:15).
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
Spiritual nourishment, like the water Jesus gives, remains with a man and is not a brief refreshment, and the one who opens the inner eyes will be filled with bread.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Since a more human expression is sometimes used, you know that there are things called sensible comforts for prayers, not only for eating, but also for removing sorrows; and these, therefore, are the spiritual nourishments. And someone receives in order to be glad, and receives a 'portion' so that it may remain with him. He is not only gladdened and fed and drinks from a brief encounter, but also continuously. For he continues drinking from the spring and the water which Jesus gives, and it remains with him. For he has within himself a spring having become a source for eternal life.
And again: 'Open your eyes and be filled with bread' (Proverbs 20:13). The one who opens the eyes of the 'inner man' 'shall be filled with bread'. And the loaves, therefore, thus remain like 'the spring which changes into eternal life'. And this has become useful by way of history, when the widow in Sarepta of Sidon, having only a few drachmae, fed Elijah and she herself had nothing, until prosperity came from the rain (1 Kings 17:14).
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
Ecclesiastes 5:20 7 comments from the Fathers, 2 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (7) All 2 passages
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
Enjoying one's labors with gladness, over possessions given by God and not seized by robbery, is a gift of God.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Yet this is good and not to be cast aside, for it is a gift of God: that a person can enjoy his own labors with gladness, having received possessions given by God and not seized by robbery (Ecclesiastes 5:18-19). For such a man is not sick with griefs, nor is he much enslaved to evil thoughts; he measures out his life in good deeds toward all, glad of heart and rejoicing in the gift of God (Ecclesiastes 5:20).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
Eating and drinking and enjoying one's labor are God's gift, and the knowledge of God is named by the intellect food, drink, goodness, portion, wealth, joy and gift.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
Behold, what I saw was good, which is beautiful: to eat and to drink and to see goodness in all his labor (Ecclesiastes 5:18), by which he labors under the sun, a number of the days of his life which God gave to him (Eccl 5:18); for it is a portion of Him. And indeed every man to whom God gave wealth and possessions, and empowered him to eat from it and to take his portion and to be joyful in his labor (Eccl 5:18), this is a gift of God (Eccl 5:19). For he will not remember many of the days of his life; for God distracts him with the joy of his heart.
The knowledge of God is called by the intellect food and drink and goodness and portion and wealth and possessions and joy and distraction of God and light and life and gift; and the Holy Spirit sets many other names upon knowledge, which it is not possible now to recount, unless the rule of the scholia permits.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
A saying such as 'Let us eat and drink' must be read according to the speaker, for the same writer speaks there in the person of those who say there is no life after this one.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
One must take the words toward those speaking. If the speaker is wise, one must listen to them wisely. If, being wise, he personifies another face and brings it appropriately to that man, one must again listen to the conversation in that person. Since the apostle himself says: 'whether we eat or whether we drink, we neither lack nor exceed' (1 Corinthians 8:8), whether we are Christians or wise.
Or 'slaves of Christ', we have neither addition nor subtraction from the eating of anything still. But when he says, 'Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die' (1 Corinthians 15:32), it is the same scribe, the same one speaking, but not from his own person, not as an apostle speaks, but he took the persona of those saying that beyond this present life, there is no life after these things.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §8 → read in full
On Ecclesiastes 5:18–20
Enjoying one's labors with gladness, over possessions given by God and not seized by robbery, is a gift of God.
— Gregory Thaumaturgus, c. 213–c. 270 AD
Yet this is good and not to be cast aside, for it is a gift of God: that a person can enjoy his own labors with gladness, having received possessions given by God and not seized by robbery (Ecclesiastes 5:18-19). For such a man is not sick with griefs, nor is he much enslaved to evil thoughts; he measures out his life in good deeds toward all, glad of heart and rejoicing in the gift of God (Ecclesiastes 5:20).
Paraphrase of Ecclesiastes, §5.2 → read in full
True knowledge is a distraction from God, separating the purified soul from sensible things.
— Evagrius Ponticus, c. 345–399 AD
Regarding spiritual knowledge, few remember this kind of life and the sensory life, since his heart is always occupied with contemplation. A true knowledge, which separates the purified soul from sensible things, is a distraction from God.
Notes on Ecclesiastes, §7 → read in full
The man who does not remember many things has hope only for the present, and God distracts him in these things so that the soul does not become motionless.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Something greater happens. He does not remember many things, but has hope only for the present, saying, 'Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die' (Isa 22:13). Therefore, is this what it means that 'God distracts him' (Ecclesiastes 5:20)? He distracts him in these things, since he does not want to acquire the preceding things, nor does he labor for the taking up of them. So that the soul does not become motionless, other things are given to it. And I said this at the beginning of the book, when I had it: 'God gave a wicked distraction.'
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §8 → read in full
To live by philosophy and virtue is the true life, but men attend to pleasant distractions and so do not remember the divine life of reason and contemplation, as distinct from the common life shared with animals.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Therefore, the ascent: 'that he does not remember many of the days of his life, because God distracts him in the joy of his heart' (Ecclesiastes 5:20). To live according to philosophy and virtue is the chief and true life. And men do not remember many things, nor do they do much regarding that; they attend only to those who distract them and bring pleasant things, and they strive only about those things which they collect. But it was necessary to remember many things of those which will be useful to his life truly.
And here, then, is the common life, according to which we feel, according to which we have the soul yoked to the body, and according to which irrational animals move and perceive. The divine life, according to reason and contemplation, is the particular life of this man. Therefore, does he not remember this? He does not remember those things contributing to this life, if he has something futile.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §8 → read in full
The heart in this verse is the mind that sees God, though in the literal sense the man rejoices in a heart he wanted to feed on pleasure.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Again, here 'heart' for us is the true mind, which sees God. For instance, the saint says 'with boldness' to God: 'my heart was not stuck to me through scandal' … Again, others have 'fleshly hearts, in which the Spirit of the living God writes.' And he says 'fleshly' meaning those receptive to the writing of the Spirit. It is also possible, according to the literal sense, that he rejoices in his own heart. For he desired to have a heart feeding on pleasure.
Commentary on Ecclesiastes, §8 → read in full
2 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter