▶ Listen to the King James Version 0:00 / 4:47 1×
1 Now in those days the Philistines gathered their forces for warfare against Israel. So Achish said to David, “You must understand that you and your men are to go out to battle with me.” 2 David replied, “Then you will come to know what your servant can do.” “Very well,” said Achish. “I will make you my bodyguard for life.” Verse 2: 1 passage in the Fathers 3 Now by this time Samuel had died, and all Israel had mourned for him and buried him in Ramah, his own city. And Saul had removed the mediums and spiritists from the land. Verse 3: 1 passage in the Fathers 4 The Philistines came together and camped at Shunem, while Saul gathered all Israel and camped at Gilboa. 5 When Saul saw the Philistine army, he was afraid and trembled violently. Verse 5: 1 passage in the Fathers 6 He inquired of the LORD, but the LORD did not answer him by dreams or Urim or prophets. Verse 6: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 7 Then Saul said to his servants, “Find me a woman who is a medium, so I can go and consult her.” “There is a medium at Endor,” his servants replied. Verse 7: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 8 So Saul disguised himself by putting on different clothes, and he set out with two of his men. They came to the woman at night, and Saul said, “Consult a spirit for me. Bring up for me the one I name.” 9 But the woman replied, “Surely you know what Saul has done, how he has killed the mediums and spiritists in the land. Why have you set a trap to get me killed?” 10 Then Saul swore to her by the LORD: “As surely as the LORD lives, no punishment shall come upon you for this.” 11 “Whom shall I bring up for you?” the woman asked. “Bring up Samuel,” he replied. Verse 11: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 12 But when the woman saw Samuel, she cried out in a loud voice and said to Saul, “Why have you deceived me? You are Saul!” Verse 12: 3 passages in the Fathers, with commentary 13 “Do not be afraid,” the king replied. “What do you see?” “I see a god coming up out of the earth,” the woman answered. Verse 13: commentary from the Fathers 14 “What does he look like?” asked Saul. “An old man is coming up,” she replied. “And he is wearing a robe.” So Saul knew that it was Samuel, and he bowed facedown in reverence. Verse 14: commentary from the Fathers 15 Then Samuel said to Saul, “Why have you disturbed me by bringing me up?” “I am deeply distressed,” replied Saul. “The Philistines are fighting against me, and God has turned away from me. He no longer answers me, either by prophets or by dreams. So I have called on you to tell me what to do.” Verse 15: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 16 “Why do you consult me,” asked Samuel, “since the LORD has turned away from you and become your enemy? Verse 16: commentary from the Fathers 17 He has done exactly what He spoke through me: The LORD has torn the kingship out of your hand and given it to your neighbor David. Verse 17: 1 passage in the Fathers, with commentary 18 Because you did not obey the LORD or carry out His burning anger against Amalek, the LORD has done this to you today. Verse 18: commentary from the Fathers 19 Moreover, the LORD will deliver Israel with you into the hand of the Philistines, and tomorrow you and your sons will be with me. And the LORD will deliver the army of Israel into the hand of the Philistines.” Verse 19: commentary from the Fathers 20 Immediately Saul fell flat on the ground, terrified by the words of Samuel. And his strength was gone, because he had not eaten anything all that day and night. 21 When the woman came to Saul and saw how distraught he was, she said to him, “Look, your maidservant has obeyed your voice. I took my life in my hands and did as you told me. 22 Now please listen to your servant and let me set a morsel of bread before you so you may eat and have the strength to go on your way.” 23 Saul refused, saying, “I will not eat.” But his servants joined the woman in urging him, and he heeded their voice. He got up from the ground and sat on the bed. Verse 23: 1 passage in the Fathers 24 The woman had a fattened calf at her house, and she quickly slaughtered it. She also took flour, kneaded it, and baked unleavened bread. 25 She served it to Saul and his servants, and they ate. And that night they got up and left.
Audio: the King James Version read aloud, from Larry Sanger's Deep Dive Bible (public domain).
×
This chapter in the Fathers
1 Samuel 28 14 passages
10 of 25 verses cited
4 writers
Most cited verses 1 Samuel 28:12 3 passages 1 Samuel 28:11 3 passages 1 Samuel 28:2 1 passage 1 Samuel 28:17 1 passage 1 Samuel 28:6 1 passage 1 Samuel 28:7 1 passage 1 Samuel 28:5 1 passage 1 Samuel 28:3 1 passage Select a marked verse to see who cites it.
Verse
1 Samuel 28:2 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:3 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:5 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:6 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (1) All 1 passage
On 1 Samuel 28:6–7
Saul went to the medium because the Lord did not answer him, and one who runs to such practices is forsaken.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Which Saul experienced: 'You have not listened to me,' he says, 'nor even in sleep' (1 Samuel 28:6); and he went toward the medium. If ever, therefore, you see a rich Christian having everything well, but having haste toward astrologers or toward necromancers or toward such things, these were forsaken. And if you see a poor man having fallen from wealth, but possessing God, such as Job was (Job 1:1), this one was not forsaken.
Commentary on the Psalms, §16 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:7 1 comment from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Complete (1) All 1 passage
On 1 Samuel 28:6–7
Saul went to the medium because the Lord did not answer him, and one who runs to such practices is forsaken.
— Didymus the Blind, c. 313–c. 398 AD
Which Saul experienced: 'You have not listened to me,' he says, 'nor even in sleep' (1 Samuel 28:6); and he went toward the medium. If ever, therefore, you see a rich Christian having everything well, but having haste toward astrologers or toward necromancers or toward such things, these were forsaken. And if you see a poor man having fallen from wealth, but possessing God, such as Job was (Job 1:1), this one was not forsaken.
Commentary on the Psalms, §16 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:11 4 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (4) All 3 passages
On 1 Samuel 28:11–12
Saul, fearing the battle and getting no answer from God, turned to necromancy, and what appeared as Samuel was a shadow formed by demonic working.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Is it then still lawful for you to hesitate, that Saul has melted away condemned by his own votes? For since he was fearing the weakness unto battle of those gathered against him, he was claiming to learn the things about to be from God. And when that one was silent, and unveiling nothing, he turns toward grieving the one who has chosen to be silent. And he arrives unto necromancy, although he had wiped out, it says, the knowers—I mean those thinking to know the things about to be. Then he says: ‘Lead up Samuel for me,’ (1 Samuel 28:11) not as if the charm or the magicians’ art were able to bring the holy one’s soul, but as those divinizing always using such a voice; and I have learned that with certain unspeakable words bewitching the demons, and charming water, they look down upon idols and shadows, and as in a mirror shapes of some, the demons perhaps fashionably molding the figures of those said to be brought up. And indeed the little woman said at the beginnings: I see gods going up from the earth. Then after this: ‘And the woman,’ (1 Samuel 28:12) it says, ‘saw Samuel.’ And nothing hard, that in equal and like shape of blessed Samuel a shadow and idol was seen, formed from demonic working. If then someone should think the prophet’s soul was truly called up, and will vote the true for the little woman’s words, since she says she has also seen gods going up from the earth, then let him also gift the lie to the customs of the divination, yet let him think according to truth that there are also some gods of such a rank who have risen from the earth—although God by nature is one and alone.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 6, §16 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–12
Saul, fearing the battle and getting no answer from God, turned to necromancy, and what appeared as Samuel was a shadow formed by demonic working.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Is it then still lawful for you to hesitate, that Saul has melted away condemned by his own votes? For since he was fearing the weakness unto battle of those gathered against him, he was claiming to learn the things about to be from God. And when that one was silent, and unveiling nothing, he turns toward grieving the one who has chosen to be silent. And he arrives unto necromancy, although he had wiped out, it says, the knowers—I mean those thinking to know the things about to be. Then he says: ‘Lead up Samuel for me,’ (1 Samuel 28:11) not as if the charm or the magicians’ art were able to bring the holy one’s soul, but as those divinizing always using such a voice; and I have learned that with certain unspeakable words bewitching the demons, and charming water, they look down upon idols and shadows, and as in a mirror shapes of some, the demons perhaps fashionably molding the figures of those said to be brought up. And indeed the little woman said at the beginnings: I see gods going up from the earth. Then after this: ‘And the woman,’ (1 Samuel 28:12) it says, ‘saw Samuel.’ And nothing hard, that in equal and like shape of blessed Samuel a shadow and idol was seen, formed from demonic working. If then someone should think the prophet’s soul was truly called up, and will vote the true for the little woman’s words, since she says she has also seen gods going up from the earth, then let him also gift the lie to the customs of the divination, yet let him think according to truth that there are also some gods of such a rank who have risen from the earth—although God by nature is one and alone.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 6, §16 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–12
The words "the woman said" are the narrative voice of the writer, who is believed to be the Holy Spirit.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
For what things are written? “And the woman said, ‘Whom shall I bring up for you?’” (1 Samuel 28:11–14) Whose person is it that says, “the woman said”? Is it the person of the Holy Spirit, from whom the Scripture is believed to have been written, or of someone else? For the narrative person everywhere—as even those practiced in all sorts of discourses know—is the person of the writer; and the writer for these words is believed to be not a human being, but the Holy Spirit who moved human beings as writer. Therefore the Holy Spirit says: “And the woman said, ‘Whom shall I bring up for you?’ And he said, ‘Samuel for me.’ Who says: ‘And the woman saw Samuel, and the woman cried out with a great voice, saying…’?” (1 Samuel 28:11-12)
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–12
Some of the brothers say the medium lies and Samuel was not brought up, since so holy a prophet cannot be in Hades.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
And indeed we know some of our brothers who have looked the Scripture in the face and say: “I do not believe the medium. The medium says she has seen Samuel—she lies.” (1 Samuel 28:12)
“Samuel was not brought up; Samuel does not speak. But just as there are some false prophets saying, ‘Thus says the Lord,’ and ‘the Lord has not spoken,’ so also this demon lies, promising to bring up the one Saul commands. ‘Whom shall I bring up?’ she says; ‘Bring Samuel up for me.’ And these things are said by those who claim this story is not true: Samuel in Hades? Samuel is brought up by a medium—the exceptional one among the prophets, the one dedicated to God from birth, the one said before birth to be in the temple, the one who at weaning put on the ephod and the double cloak and became a priest of the Lord, to whom while still a child the Lord gave oracles by speaking? Samuel in Hades? Samuel among the underworld—the one who succeeded Eli when he was condemned by providence for the children’s sins and lawlessness? Samuel in Hades, whom God heard at the time of wheat harvest and gave rain to come from heaven? Samuel in Hades—the one who spoke so boldly: Did he take anyone’s desire? He did not take the calf; he did not take the ox; he judged and condemned the people while remaining poor; he never desired to take anything from so great and so large a people.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §3 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–14
It is nonsense to think that a prophet's soul, entrusted to a faithful Creator, was dragged from its place by a woman's charms.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
And most wise Peter somehow perhaps has cheated the athletes of the piety unto Christ, having written thus: ‘So that even suffering under others according to his will, let them set aside their souls to a faithful Creator.’ (1 Peter 4:19) And if Satan forces a soul set aside to God, leading and carrying wherever he should choose according to times, how would the one standing before the saints be understood faithful, having taken as it were each one’s spirit as a deposit? These things then are nonsense, and a terrible stroke, to think according to truth that a prophet’s voice was dragged down by cold charms of a most foul little woman from the places allotted to her.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 6, §15 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:12 6 comments from the Fathers, 3 passages citing this verse
Selected (2) Complete (6) All 3 passages
On 1 Samuel 28:11–12
Saul, fearing the battle and getting no answer from God, turned to necromancy, and what appeared as Samuel was a shadow formed by demonic working.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Is it then still lawful for you to hesitate, that Saul has melted away condemned by his own votes? For since he was fearing the weakness unto battle of those gathered against him, he was claiming to learn the things about to be from God. And when that one was silent, and unveiling nothing, he turns toward grieving the one who has chosen to be silent. And he arrives unto necromancy, although he had wiped out, it says, the knowers—I mean those thinking to know the things about to be. Then he says: ‘Lead up Samuel for me,’ (1 Samuel 28:11) not as if the charm or the magicians’ art were able to bring the holy one’s soul, but as those divinizing always using such a voice; and I have learned that with certain unspeakable words bewitching the demons, and charming water, they look down upon idols and shadows, and as in a mirror shapes of some, the demons perhaps fashionably molding the figures of those said to be brought up. And indeed the little woman said at the beginnings: I see gods going up from the earth. Then after this: ‘And the woman,’ (1 Samuel 28:12) it says, ‘saw Samuel.’ And nothing hard, that in equal and like shape of blessed Samuel a shadow and idol was seen, formed from demonic working. If then someone should think the prophet’s soul was truly called up, and will vote the true for the little woman’s words, since she says she has also seen gods going up from the earth, then let him also gift the lie to the customs of the divination, yet let him think according to truth that there are also some gods of such a rank who have risen from the earth—although God by nature is one and alone.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 6, §16 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:12–14
Scripture says the woman saw Samuel and that Saul knew it was Samuel, not that he supposed it, and no one knows what is not.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… I know that the one from that argument says: “No wonder; for Satan himself transforms himself into an angel of light. So it is no great thing if his servants also transform themselves as servants of righteousness.” (2 Corinthians 11:14–15) But what is it that “the woman saw”? “Samuel.” And why has it not been said: “The woman saw a demon that pretended to be Samuel”? But it is written that “Saul knew that it is Samuel.” If it were not Samuel, it ought to have been written: “Saul supposed him to be Samuel.” But now it is written: “Saul knew”—and no one knows what is not; therefore “Saul knew that it is Samuel,” “and he fell on his face on the earth and worshiped.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–12
Saul, fearing the battle and getting no answer from God, turned to necromancy, and what appeared as Samuel was a shadow formed by demonic working.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
Is it then still lawful for you to hesitate, that Saul has melted away condemned by his own votes? For since he was fearing the weakness unto battle of those gathered against him, he was claiming to learn the things about to be from God. And when that one was silent, and unveiling nothing, he turns toward grieving the one who has chosen to be silent. And he arrives unto necromancy, although he had wiped out, it says, the knowers—I mean those thinking to know the things about to be. Then he says: ‘Lead up Samuel for me,’ (1 Samuel 28:11) not as if the charm or the magicians’ art were able to bring the holy one’s soul, but as those divinizing always using such a voice; and I have learned that with certain unspeakable words bewitching the demons, and charming water, they look down upon idols and shadows, and as in a mirror shapes of some, the demons perhaps fashionably molding the figures of those said to be brought up. And indeed the little woman said at the beginnings: I see gods going up from the earth. Then after this: ‘And the woman,’ (1 Samuel 28:12) it says, ‘saw Samuel.’ And nothing hard, that in equal and like shape of blessed Samuel a shadow and idol was seen, formed from demonic working. If then someone should think the prophet’s soul was truly called up, and will vote the true for the little woman’s words, since she says she has also seen gods going up from the earth, then let him also gift the lie to the customs of the divination, yet let him think according to truth that there are also some gods of such a rank who have risen from the earth—although God by nature is one and alone.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 6, §16 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–12
The words "the woman said" are the narrative voice of the writer, who is believed to be the Holy Spirit.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
For what things are written? “And the woman said, ‘Whom shall I bring up for you?’” (1 Samuel 28:11–14) Whose person is it that says, “the woman said”? Is it the person of the Holy Spirit, from whom the Scripture is believed to have been written, or of someone else? For the narrative person everywhere—as even those practiced in all sorts of discourses know—is the person of the writer; and the writer for these words is believed to be not a human being, but the Holy Spirit who moved human beings as writer. Therefore the Holy Spirit says: “And the woman said, ‘Whom shall I bring up for you?’ And he said, ‘Samuel for me.’ Who says: ‘And the woman saw Samuel, and the woman cried out with a great voice, saying…’?” (1 Samuel 28:11-12)
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–12
Some of the brothers say the medium lies and Samuel was not brought up, since so holy a prophet cannot be in Hades.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
And indeed we know some of our brothers who have looked the Scripture in the face and say: “I do not believe the medium. The medium says she has seen Samuel—she lies.” (1 Samuel 28:12)
“Samuel was not brought up; Samuel does not speak. But just as there are some false prophets saying, ‘Thus says the Lord,’ and ‘the Lord has not spoken,’ so also this demon lies, promising to bring up the one Saul commands. ‘Whom shall I bring up?’ she says; ‘Bring Samuel up for me.’ And these things are said by those who claim this story is not true: Samuel in Hades? Samuel is brought up by a medium—the exceptional one among the prophets, the one dedicated to God from birth, the one said before birth to be in the temple, the one who at weaning put on the ephod and the double cloak and became a priest of the Lord, to whom while still a child the Lord gave oracles by speaking? Samuel in Hades? Samuel among the underworld—the one who succeeded Eli when he was condemned by providence for the children’s sins and lawlessness? Samuel in Hades, whom God heard at the time of wheat harvest and gave rain to come from heaven? Samuel in Hades—the one who spoke so boldly: Did he take anyone’s desire? He did not take the calf; he did not take the ox; he judged and condemned the people while remaining poor; he never desired to take anything from so great and so large a people.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §3 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–14
It is nonsense to think that a prophet's soul, entrusted to a faithful Creator, was dragged from its place by a woman's charms.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
And most wise Peter somehow perhaps has cheated the athletes of the piety unto Christ, having written thus: ‘So that even suffering under others according to his will, let them set aside their souls to a faithful Creator.’ (1 Peter 4:19) And if Satan forces a soul set aside to God, leading and carrying wherever he should choose according to times, how would the one standing before the saints be understood faithful, having taken as it were each one’s spirit as a deposit? These things then are nonsense, and a terrible stroke, to think according to truth that a prophet’s voice was dragged down by cold charms of a most foul little woman from the places allotted to her.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 6, §15 → read in full
Scripture says in its own person, not the demon's, that she saw Samuel, so it is Samuel who has come up.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
These things, then, show that the words are not false and that it is Samuel who has come up. What then is a medium doing here? What is a medium doing about the bringing-up of the righteous man’s soul? That first speaker fled—so as not to seem to have a contest against so many other questions in the passage—and says: “It is not Samuel; the demon lies, since the Scripture cannot lie.” (Psalm 16:10) But the Scripture’s words are not from the demon’s person but from her own [Scripture's own person] : “And she saw Samuel,” (1 Samuel 28:12) “Saul said…”—the things spoken from Samuel. …
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §6 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:12–14
Scripture says the woman saw Samuel and that Saul knew it was Samuel, not that he supposed it, and no one knows what is not.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… I know that the one from that argument says: “No wonder; for Satan himself transforms himself into an angel of light. So it is no great thing if his servants also transform themselves as servants of righteousness.” (2 Corinthians 11:14–15) But what is it that “the woman saw”? “Samuel.” And why has it not been said: “The woman saw a demon that pretended to be Samuel”? But it is written that “Saul knew that it is Samuel.” If it were not Samuel, it ought to have been written: “Saul supposed him to be Samuel.” But now it is written: “Saul knew”—and no one knows what is not; therefore “Saul knew that it is Samuel,” “and he fell on his face on the earth and worshiped.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
3 passages in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:13 2 comments from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (2)
On 1 Samuel 28:12–14
Scripture says the woman saw Samuel and that Saul knew it was Samuel, not that he supposed it, and no one knows what is not.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… I know that the one from that argument says: “No wonder; for Satan himself transforms himself into an angel of light. So it is no great thing if his servants also transform themselves as servants of righteousness.” (2 Corinthians 11:14–15) But what is it that “the woman saw”? “Samuel.” And why has it not been said: “The woman saw a demon that pretended to be Samuel”? But it is written that “Saul knew that it is Samuel.” If it were not Samuel, it ought to have been written: “Saul supposed him to be Samuel.” But now it is written: “Saul knew”—and no one knows what is not; therefore “Saul knew that it is Samuel,” “and he fell on his face on the earth and worshiped.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–14
It is nonsense to think that a prophet's soul, entrusted to a faithful Creator, was dragged from its place by a woman's charms.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
And most wise Peter somehow perhaps has cheated the athletes of the piety unto Christ, having written thus: ‘So that even suffering under others according to his will, let them set aside their souls to a faithful Creator.’ (1 Peter 4:19) And if Satan forces a soul set aside to God, leading and carrying wherever he should choose according to times, how would the one standing before the saints be understood faithful, having taken as it were each one’s spirit as a deposit? These things then are nonsense, and a terrible stroke, to think according to truth that a prophet’s voice was dragged down by cold charms of a most foul little woman from the places allotted to her.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 6, §15 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:12–14
Scripture says the woman saw Samuel and that Saul knew it was Samuel, not that he supposed it, and no one knows what is not.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… I know that the one from that argument says: “No wonder; for Satan himself transforms himself into an angel of light. So it is no great thing if his servants also transform themselves as servants of righteousness.” (2 Corinthians 11:14–15) But what is it that “the woman saw”? “Samuel.” And why has it not been said: “The woman saw a demon that pretended to be Samuel”? But it is written that “Saul knew that it is Samuel.” If it were not Samuel, it ought to have been written: “Saul supposed him to be Samuel.” But now it is written: “Saul knew”—and no one knows what is not; therefore “Saul knew that it is Samuel,” “and he fell on his face on the earth and worshiped.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:14 2 comments from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (2)
On 1 Samuel 28:12–14
Scripture says the woman saw Samuel and that Saul knew it was Samuel, not that he supposed it, and no one knows what is not.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… I know that the one from that argument says: “No wonder; for Satan himself transforms himself into an angel of light. So it is no great thing if his servants also transform themselves as servants of righteousness.” (2 Corinthians 11:14–15) But what is it that “the woman saw”? “Samuel.” And why has it not been said: “The woman saw a demon that pretended to be Samuel”? But it is written that “Saul knew that it is Samuel.” If it were not Samuel, it ought to have been written: “Saul supposed him to be Samuel.” But now it is written: “Saul knew”—and no one knows what is not; therefore “Saul knew that it is Samuel,” “and he fell on his face on the earth and worshiped.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:11–14
It is nonsense to think that a prophet's soul, entrusted to a faithful Creator, was dragged from its place by a woman's charms.
— Cyril of Alexandria, c. 376–444 AD
And most wise Peter somehow perhaps has cheated the athletes of the piety unto Christ, having written thus: ‘So that even suffering under others according to his will, let them set aside their souls to a faithful Creator.’ (1 Peter 4:19) And if Satan forces a soul set aside to God, leading and carrying wherever he should choose according to times, how would the one standing before the saints be understood faithful, having taken as it were each one’s spirit as a deposit? These things then are nonsense, and a terrible stroke, to think according to truth that a prophet’s voice was dragged down by cold charms of a most foul little woman from the places allotted to her.
On Adoration and Worship in Spirit and Truth, Book 6, §15 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:12–14
Scripture says the woman saw Samuel and that Saul knew it was Samuel, not that he supposed it, and no one knows what is not.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… I know that the one from that argument says: “No wonder; for Satan himself transforms himself into an angel of light. So it is no great thing if his servants also transform themselves as servants of righteousness.” (2 Corinthians 11:14–15) But what is it that “the woman saw”? “Samuel.” And why has it not been said: “The woman saw a demon that pretended to be Samuel”? But it is written that “Saul knew that it is Samuel.” If it were not Samuel, it ought to have been written: “Saul supposed him to be Samuel.” But now it is written: “Saul knew”—and no one knows what is not; therefore “Saul knew that it is Samuel,” “and he fell on his face on the earth and worshiped.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:15 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 1 passage
Samuel could be in Hades because Christ himself went down there to save, and the prophets went before him to announce his coming.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… I ask the one who said the earlier things (“Samuel in Hades?” and what follows) and let him answer the question: Who is greater, Samuel or Jesus the Christ? Who is greater, the prophets or Jesus the Christ? … Here no one who has once come to know the Lord as Jesus Christ, the one proclaimed beforehand by the prophets, will dare to say that the Christ is not greater than the prophets.
When therefore you confess that Jesus Christ is greater—Christ in Hades, or did he not come to be there? … It is written that the fifteenth Psalm is borne upon him: “For you will not abandon my soul to Hades, nor will you give your holy one to see corruption.” (Acts 2:27–31) Then Jesus Christ is in Hades. …
Then after this if he answers that Christ has gone down into Hades, I will say: Christ has gone down into Hades to do what—to conquer, or to be conquered by death? … Therefore the Savior has come down to save; has he come down there proclaimed beforehand by the prophets, or not? …
What then? Moses—yes—but not the prophets after him? And not Samuel? What is out of place in physicians going down to those who are badly off? And what is out of place in the chief physician also going down to those who are badly off? … Do not fear; do not be stunned: Jesus has come to be in Hades, and the prophets before him, and they proclaim beforehand Christ’s sojourn.
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §6 → read in full
Samuel could be in Hades because Christ himself went down there to save, and the prophets went before him to announce his coming.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… I ask the one who said the earlier things (“Samuel in Hades?” and what follows) and let him answer the question: Who is greater, Samuel or Jesus the Christ? Who is greater, the prophets or Jesus the Christ? … Here no one who has once come to know the Lord as Jesus Christ, the one proclaimed beforehand by the prophets, will dare to say that the Christ is not greater than the prophets.
When therefore you confess that Jesus Christ is greater—Christ in Hades, or did he not come to be there? … It is written that the fifteenth Psalm is borne upon him: “For you will not abandon my soul to Hades, nor will you give your holy one to see corruption.” (Acts 2:27–31) Then Jesus Christ is in Hades. …
Then after this if he answers that Christ has gone down into Hades, I will say: Christ has gone down into Hades to do what—to conquer, or to be conquered by death? … Therefore the Savior has come down to save; has he come down there proclaimed beforehand by the prophets, or not? …
What then? Moses—yes—but not the prophets after him? And not Samuel? What is out of place in physicians going down to those who are badly off? And what is out of place in the chief physician also going down to those who are badly off? … Do not fear; do not be stunned: Jesus has come to be in Hades, and the prophets before him, and they proclaim beforehand Christ’s sojourn.
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §6 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:15–17
Scripture, which must be believed, says that Samuel himself spoke to Saul.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… Then again the person of the Scripture: “And Samuel said to Saul, ‘Why have you provoked me to bring me up?’” “Said,” says the Scripture that must be believed—“Samuel said, ‘Why have you provoked me to bring me up?’” … Again the Scripture has not spoken otherwise, but that Samuel himself said: “And why have you inquired of me? And the Lord has stood away from you.” Does he speak truly or falsely when he says these things: “The Lord has stood away from you and has become against you and has made another for himself, as he spoke by my hand, and he will tear the kingdom from your hand”—and a demon prophesies about Israel’s kingdom? …
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:16 1 comment from the Fathers
Complete (1)
On 1 Samuel 28:15–17
Scripture, which must be believed, says that Samuel himself spoke to Saul.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… Then again the person of the Scripture: “And Samuel said to Saul, ‘Why have you provoked me to bring me up?’” “Said,” says the Scripture that must be believed—“Samuel said, ‘Why have you provoked me to bring me up?’” … Again the Scripture has not spoken otherwise, but that Samuel himself said: “And why have you inquired of me? And the Lord has stood away from you.” Does he speak truly or falsely when he says these things: “The Lord has stood away from you and has become against you and has made another for himself, as he spoke by my hand, and he will tear the kingdom from your hand”—and a demon prophesies about Israel’s kingdom? …
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:17 2 comments from the Fathers, 1 passage citing this verse
Selected (1) Complete (2) All 1 passage
On 1 Samuel 28:17–19
A demon could not know David's kingdom, Saul's sparing of Amalek, or Saul's death tomorrow, so the words are God's.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
I say that both the story and the examination concerning it are necessary, so that we may see what holds us after the departure. “He has spoken by my hand, and the Lord will tear the kingdom from your hand and will give it to your neighbor, to David.” (1 Samuel 28:17–19) But a demon cannot know David’s kingdom, the one appointed by the Lord. “Because you did not hear the Lord’s voice, you did not execute the wrath of his anger on Amalek.” Are these not God’s words? Are they not true? For truly Saul did not do the Lord’s will, but “spared the king of Amalek,” for which Samuel reproached Saul both before his falling asleep and at the departure: “And because of this word the Lord has done this to you on this day; and the Lord will also give Israel into the foreigners’ hand.” Can a demon prophesy concerning the whole people of God that the Lord is about to hand Israel over? “And also the camp of Israel the Lord will hand over into the foreigners’ hand. Make haste, Saul; tomorrow you also and your sons with me.” And can a demon know this—concerning a king appointed with a prophetic act—that tomorrow Saul was about to leave life, and his sons with him? “Tomorrow you and your sons with me.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §5 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:15–17
Scripture, which must be believed, says that Samuel himself spoke to Saul.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
… Then again the person of the Scripture: “And Samuel said to Saul, ‘Why have you provoked me to bring me up?’” “Said,” says the Scripture that must be believed—“Samuel said, ‘Why have you provoked me to bring me up?’” … Again the Scripture has not spoken otherwise, but that Samuel himself said: “And why have you inquired of me? And the Lord has stood away from you.” Does he speak truly or falsely when he says these things: “The Lord has stood away from you and has become against you and has made another for himself, as he spoke by my hand, and he will tear the kingdom from your hand”—and a demon prophesies about Israel’s kingdom? …
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §4 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:17–19
A demon could not know David's kingdom, Saul's sparing of Amalek, or Saul's death tomorrow, so the words are God's.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
I say that both the story and the examination concerning it are necessary, so that we may see what holds us after the departure. “He has spoken by my hand, and the Lord will tear the kingdom from your hand and will give it to your neighbor, to David.” (1 Samuel 28:17–19) But a demon cannot know David’s kingdom, the one appointed by the Lord. “Because you did not hear the Lord’s voice, you did not execute the wrath of his anger on Amalek.” Are these not God’s words? Are they not true? For truly Saul did not do the Lord’s will, but “spared the king of Amalek,” for which Samuel reproached Saul both before his falling asleep and at the departure: “And because of this word the Lord has done this to you on this day; and the Lord will also give Israel into the foreigners’ hand.” Can a demon prophesy concerning the whole people of God that the Lord is about to hand Israel over? “And also the camp of Israel the Lord will hand over into the foreigners’ hand. Make haste, Saul; tomorrow you also and your sons with me.” And can a demon know this—concerning a king appointed with a prophetic act—that tomorrow Saul was about to leave life, and his sons with him? “Tomorrow you and your sons with me.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §5 → read in full
1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:18 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On 1 Samuel 28:17–19
A demon could not know David's kingdom, Saul's sparing of Amalek, or Saul's death tomorrow, so the words are God's.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
I say that both the story and the examination concerning it are necessary, so that we may see what holds us after the departure. “He has spoken by my hand, and the Lord will tear the kingdom from your hand and will give it to your neighbor, to David.” (1 Samuel 28:17–19) But a demon cannot know David’s kingdom, the one appointed by the Lord. “Because you did not hear the Lord’s voice, you did not execute the wrath of his anger on Amalek.” Are these not God’s words? Are they not true? For truly Saul did not do the Lord’s will, but “spared the king of Amalek,” for which Samuel reproached Saul both before his falling asleep and at the departure: “And because of this word the Lord has done this to you on this day; and the Lord will also give Israel into the foreigners’ hand.” Can a demon prophesy concerning the whole people of God that the Lord is about to hand Israel over? “And also the camp of Israel the Lord will hand over into the foreigners’ hand. Make haste, Saul; tomorrow you also and your sons with me.” And can a demon know this—concerning a king appointed with a prophetic act—that tomorrow Saul was about to leave life, and his sons with him? “Tomorrow you and your sons with me.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §5 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:17–19
A demon could not know David's kingdom, Saul's sparing of Amalek, or Saul's death tomorrow, so the words are God's.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
I say that both the story and the examination concerning it are necessary, so that we may see what holds us after the departure. “He has spoken by my hand, and the Lord will tear the kingdom from your hand and will give it to your neighbor, to David.” (1 Samuel 28:17–19) But a demon cannot know David’s kingdom, the one appointed by the Lord. “Because you did not hear the Lord’s voice, you did not execute the wrath of his anger on Amalek.” Are these not God’s words? Are they not true? For truly Saul did not do the Lord’s will, but “spared the king of Amalek,” for which Samuel reproached Saul both before his falling asleep and at the departure: “And because of this word the Lord has done this to you on this day; and the Lord will also give Israel into the foreigners’ hand.” Can a demon prophesy concerning the whole people of God that the Lord is about to hand Israel over? “And also the camp of Israel the Lord will hand over into the foreigners’ hand. Make haste, Saul; tomorrow you also and your sons with me.” And can a demon know this—concerning a king appointed with a prophetic act—that tomorrow Saul was about to leave life, and his sons with him? “Tomorrow you and your sons with me.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §5 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:19 1 comment from the Fathers
Selected (1) Complete (1)
On 1 Samuel 28:17–19
A demon could not know David's kingdom, Saul's sparing of Amalek, or Saul's death tomorrow, so the words are God's.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
I say that both the story and the examination concerning it are necessary, so that we may see what holds us after the departure. “He has spoken by my hand, and the Lord will tear the kingdom from your hand and will give it to your neighbor, to David.” (1 Samuel 28:17–19) But a demon cannot know David’s kingdom, the one appointed by the Lord. “Because you did not hear the Lord’s voice, you did not execute the wrath of his anger on Amalek.” Are these not God’s words? Are they not true? For truly Saul did not do the Lord’s will, but “spared the king of Amalek,” for which Samuel reproached Saul both before his falling asleep and at the departure: “And because of this word the Lord has done this to you on this day; and the Lord will also give Israel into the foreigners’ hand.” Can a demon prophesy concerning the whole people of God that the Lord is about to hand Israel over? “And also the camp of Israel the Lord will hand over into the foreigners’ hand. Make haste, Saul; tomorrow you also and your sons with me.” And can a demon know this—concerning a king appointed with a prophetic act—that tomorrow Saul was about to leave life, and his sons with him? “Tomorrow you and your sons with me.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §5 → read in full
On 1 Samuel 28:17–19
A demon could not know David's kingdom, Saul's sparing of Amalek, or Saul's death tomorrow, so the words are God's.
— Origen of Alexandria, c. 185–c. 254 AD
I say that both the story and the examination concerning it are necessary, so that we may see what holds us after the departure. “He has spoken by my hand, and the Lord will tear the kingdom from your hand and will give it to your neighbor, to David.” (1 Samuel 28:17–19) But a demon cannot know David’s kingdom, the one appointed by the Lord. “Because you did not hear the Lord’s voice, you did not execute the wrath of his anger on Amalek.” Are these not God’s words? Are they not true? For truly Saul did not do the Lord’s will, but “spared the king of Amalek,” for which Samuel reproached Saul both before his falling asleep and at the departure: “And because of this word the Lord has done this to you on this day; and the Lord will also give Israel into the foreigners’ hand.” Can a demon prophesy concerning the whole people of God that the Lord is about to hand Israel over? “And also the camp of Israel the Lord will hand over into the foreigners’ hand. Make haste, Saul; tomorrow you also and your sons with me.” And can a demon know this—concerning a king appointed with a prophetic act—that tomorrow Saul was about to leave life, and his sons with him? “Tomorrow you and your sons with me.”
Homily on Saul and the Medium of Endor, §5 → read in full
Back to the chapter Verse
1 Samuel 28:23 1 passage in the Fathers, earliest first
Back to the chapter