Tertullian, On the Flesh of Christ 5
There are plainly other foolish things too, the ones that belong to the insults and passions of God. Or let them call a crucified God wisdom. Take this away too, Marcion—or rather, take this above all. For what is more unworthy of God, what more shameful: to be born or to die? To carry flesh or a cross? To be circumcised or nailed up? To be brought up or buried? To be laid in a manger or shut in a tomb? You will be wiser if you do not believe these things either. But you will not be wise unless you become a fool in the world by believing God's foolish things. Was it for this reason that you did not cut the passions away from Christ, because as a phantom he lacked any sense of them? We said before that he could equally have undergone the empty mockeries of an imaginary birth and infancy. But answer now, killer of truth: was not God truly crucified? Did he not truly die, because he was truly crucified? Was he not truly raised again, because he truly died? Did Paul falsely set himself to know nothing among us but Jesus crucified (1 Corinthians 2:2)? Did he falsely assert that he was buried, falsely insist that he was raised again (1 Corinthians 15:4)? Then our faith is false too, and everything we hope from Christ will be a phantom. You are the wickedest of men, who excuse the killers of God. For Christ suffered nothing from them if he truly suffered nothing. Spare the one hope of the whole world, you who destroy the necessary shame of faith. Whatever is unworthy of God is for my benefit. I am saved if I am not ashamed of my Lord. Whoever is ashamed of me, he says, I will be ashamed of him too (Mark 8:38). I find no other materials for shame that prove me, through contempt of blushing, well shameless and happily foolish. The Son of God was crucified; I am not ashamed, because it is shameful. And the Son of God died; it is entirely believable, because it is absurd. And he was buried and rose again; it is certain, because it is impossible. For how will these things be true in him if he himself was not true, if he did not truly have in himself what could be fastened, what could die, what could be buried and raised again—this flesh, suffused with blood, built on bones, woven with sinews, entwined with veins, which knows how to be born and to die? Human without doubt, as born from a human. And therefore it will be mortal in Christ, because Christ is man and Son of Man. Or why is Christ man and son of man, if he has nothing of man and nothing from man? Unless either man is something other than flesh, or man's flesh comes from somewhere other than man, or Mary is something other than man, or the God of Marcion is man. Otherwise Christ would not be called man without flesh, nor son of man without some human parent, just as he would not be God without the Spirit of God, nor Son of God without God the Father. Thus the census of both substances exhibited him as man and God: born from here, unborn from there; fleshly from here, spiritual from there; weak from here, supremely strong from there; dying from here, living from there. This property of the conditions, divine and human, is marked out by the equal truth of each nature, by the same faith of both spirit and flesh. The powers of the Spirit of God proved him God; the passions proved the flesh of man. If the powers were not without the Spirit, likewise the passions were not without flesh. If the flesh with its passions was feigned, then the Spirit with its powers was false too. Why do you halve Christ with a lie? He was entirely truth. He preferred, believe me, to be born than to lie in any part—and indeed against himself—by carrying flesh hard without bones, solid without muscles, bloody without blood, clothed without a tunic, hungry without hunger, eating without teeth, speaking without a tongue, so that his speech was a phantom to the ears through the image of a voice. Then he was a phantom even after the resurrection, when he offered his hands and feet to his disciples to inspect, saying, Look, that it is I, for a spirit does not have bones as you see me having (Luke 24:39)—without doubt hands and feet and bones, which a spirit does not have, but flesh does. How do you interpret this voice, Marcion, who bring Jesus only from a God who is best and simple and good? Look, he deceives and tricks and cheats the eyes of all, the senses of all, the approaches and touches of all. Then you should have brought Christ not from heaven but from some circus troupe, not God above man but a man magician, not the high priest of salvation but the artisan of spectacle, not the raiser of the dead but the caller away of the living. Except that even if he was a magician, he was born.
Latin
Sunt plane et alia tam stulta, quae pertinent ad contumelias et passiones dei. Aut prudentiam dicant deum crucifixum. Aufer hoc quoque, Mercion, immo hoc potius. Quid enim indignius deo, quid magis erubescendum, nasci an mori? carnem gestare an crucem? eircumcidi an suffigi? educari an sepeliri? in praesepe deponi an in menimento recondi? Sapientior eris si nec ista credideris. Sed non eris sapiens, nisi stultus in saeculo fueris, dei stulta credendo. An ideo passiones a Christo non recidisti, quia ut phantasma vacabat a sensu carum? Diximus retro aeque illum et nativitatis et infantiae imaginariae vacua ludibria subire potuisse. Sed iam hic responde, interfector veritatis, noune vere crucifixus est deus? nonae vere mortuus est, ut vere crucifixus? nonne vere resuscitatus, ut vere scilicet mortuus? Falso se statuit inter nos scire Paulus tantum Iesum crucifixum, falso sepultum ingessit, falso resuscitatum inculcavit. Falsa est igitur et fides nostra, et phantasma erit totum quod speramus a Christo. Scelestissime hominum, qui interemptores excusas dei. Nihil enim ab eis passus est Christus, si nihil vere est passus. Parce unicae spei totius orbis, qui destruis necessarium dedecus fidei. Quodcunque deo indignum est, mihi expedit. Salvus sum si non confundar de domino meo. Qui mei, inquit, confusus fuerit, confundar et ego eius. Alias non invenio materias confusionis quae me per contemptum ruboris probent bene impudentem et feliciter stultum. Crucifixus est dei filius; non pudet, quia pudendum est. Et mortuus est dei filius; prorsus credibile est, quia ineptum est. Et sepultus resurresit; certum est, quia impossibile est. Nam quomodo vera in illo erunt, si ipse non fuit verus, si non vere habuit in se quod figeretur, quod moreretur, quod sepeliretur et resuscitaretur? carnem scilicet hanc sanguine suffusam, ossibus structam, nervis intextam, venia implexam, quae nasci et mori novit, humanam sine dubio, ut natam de homine. Ideoque mortalis haec erit in Christo, quia Christus homo et filius hominis. Aut cur homo Christus et hominis filius, si nihil hominis et nihil ex homine? nisi si aut aliud est homo quam caro, aut aliunde caro hominis quam ex homine, aut aliud est Maria quam homo, aut homo deus Marcionis. Aliter non diceretur homo Christus sine carne, nec hominis filius sine aliquo parente homine, sicut nec deus sine spiritu dei, nec dei filius sine deo patre. Ita utriusque substantiae census hominem et deum exhibuit, hine natum, inde non natum,hinc carneum, inde spiritalem, hine infirmum, inde praefortem, hinc morientem, inde viventem. Quae proprietas conditionum, divinae et humanae, aequa utique naturae cuiusque veritate dispuncta est, eadem fide et spiritus et carnis. Virtutes spiritus dei deum, passiones carnem hominis probaverunt. Si virtutes non sine spiritu, perinde et passiones non sine carne. Si caro cum passionibus ficta, et spiritus ergo cum virtutibus falsus. Quid dimidias mendacio Christum? Totus veritas fuit. Maluit, crede, nasci quam ex aliqua parte mentiri, et quidem in semetipsum, ut carnem gestaret sine ossibus duram, sine musculis solidam, sine sanguine cruentam, sine tunica vestitam, sine fame esurientem, sine dentibus edentem, sine lingua loquentem, ut phantasma auribus fuerit sermo eius per imaginem vocis. Fuit itaque phantasma etiam post resurrectionem, cum manus et pedes suos discipulis inspiciendos offert, Aspicite, dicens quod ego sum quia spiritus ossa non habet, sicut me habentem videtis; sine dubio manus et pedes et ossa, quae spiritus non habet, sed caro. Quomodo hanc vocem interpretaris, Marcion, qui a deo optimo et simplici et bono tantum infers Iesum? Ecce fallit et decipit et circumvenit omnium oculos, omnium sensus, omnium accessus et contactus. Ergo iam Christum non de caelo deferre debueras, sed de aliquo circulatorio coetu, nec deum praeter hominem, sed magum hominem, nec salutis pontificem, sed spectaculi artiflcem, nec mortuorum resuscitatorem, sed vivorum avocatorom Nisi quod et si magus fuit natus est.