Tertullian, On the Flesh of Christ 1
Those who want to unsettle the faith in the resurrection—which before these near relatives of the Sadducees remained without controversy—by denying that this hope extends to the flesh, quite logically tear apart the flesh of Christ with their questions. They claim it was either nothing at all or somehow other than human, because if it is established that it was human, the case is already decided against them: whatever rose in Christ must rise in every way. So the very point from which they destroy the claims of the flesh is where the defenses must be built up for us. Let us examine the bodily substance of the Lord; about the spiritual substance there is no dispute. The flesh is what is in question. Its truth and its quality are being reconsidered: whether it existed, and from where, and of what kind it was. The report of it will give the law for our resurrection. Marcion, in order to deny the flesh of Christ, denied also his birth—or in order to deny his birth, denied his flesh. Naturally, he did not want birth and flesh to testify for each other, since there is no birth without flesh and no flesh without birth. As if he himself could not, with the same heretical license, have either admitted the flesh and denied the birth, as Apelles did—his disciple and later his deserter—or confessed both the flesh and the birth and interpreted them differently, as Valentinus did, his fellow disciple and fellow deserter. But even the man who introduced a supposed flesh of Christ could equally have fabricated the birth as a phantom, so that the conception, the pregnancy, the delivery of the virgin, and the whole course of the infant's life from then on would be held by seeming. They would have deceived the same eyes and the same senses that the supposition of flesh deceived.
Latin
Qui fidem resurrectionis ante istos Sadducaeorum propinquos sine controversia moratam ita student inquietare, ut eam spem negent etiam ad carnem pertinere, merito Christi quoque carnem quaestionibus distrahunt, tamquam aut nullam omnino aut quoquo modo aliam praeter humanam, ne, si humanam constiterit fuisse, praeiudicatum sit adversus illos eam resurgere omni modo, quae in Christo resurrexerit. Igitur unde illi destruunt carnis vota, inde nobis erunt praestruenda. Examinemus corporalem substantiam domini; de spiritali enim certum est. Caro quaeritur. Veritas et qualitas eius retractatur: an fuerit, et unde, et cuiusmodi fuerit. Renuntiatio eius dabit legem nostrae resurrectioni. Marcion, ut carnem Christi negaret, negavit etiam nativitatem, aut ut nativitatem negaret, negavit et carnem, scilicet ne invicem sibi testimonium responderent nativitas et caro, quia nec nativitas sine carne nec caro sine nativitate; quasi non eadem licentia haeretica et ipse potuisset aut admissa carne nativitatem negare, ut Apelles discipulus et postea desertor ipsius, aut et carnem et nativitatem confessus aliter illas interpretari, ut condiscipulus et condesertor eius Valentinus. Sed et qui carnem Christi putativam introduxit, aeque potuit nativitatem quoque phantasma confingere, ut et conceptus et praegnatus et partus virginis et ipsius exinde infantis ordo τῷ δοκεῖν haberentur. Eosdem oculos eosdemque sensus fefellissent quos carnis opinio elusit.