To Florus · §3.190 · Julian of Eclanum

To Florus 3.190

Click or tap any sentence to jump there. The side buttons skip a paragraph.

But afterward you introduce the statement dear to you: ‘If no evil were within human nature, it would not need to be saved. Whoever says it is not good denies a good Creator to the nature created; whoever denies it contains evil begrudges a merciful Savior to the nature corrupted’ (Augustine, Marriage and Sexual Desire 2.36). Let the reader pay attention: you will see that he has said nothing other than what he had denied should be said. You have pronounced evil naturally present in the very thing you said was not naturally evil.

Latin source witness

Latin

Sed post haec admoves sententiam tibi caram et dicis: Si autem naturae humanae mali nihil inesset, salvanda non esset. Qui ergo dicit eam bonum non esse, bonum negat conditae Creatorem; qui vero negat ei malum inesse, misericordem vitiatae invidet Salvatorem [n247] . Sit igitur lector intentus, videbit nihil te dixisse aliud, quam quod dicendum negaras; pronuntiasti enim ei rei malum inesse naturaliter, quam dixeras malam non esse naturaliter.