The Witness of the Spirit Discourse II

John Wesley (1703–1791 AD)

Modern English reading by Via Patrum.

About this text

John Wesley lived from 1703 to 1791. This sermon is in his 1771 Works. The printing does not give a preach date.

Wesley's second sermon on Romans 8:16, written years after the first: what the witness of the Spirit is, and answers to those who deny it.

Edition Printed in Wesley's 1771 Works, which do not say when he preached it

Wesley's own sermon in updated English wording. The 1771 panel is the text of the Works Wesley himself had printed in 1771. It is public domain. Reference Sermon 11 in the 1771 Works. Romans 8:16. The second discourse on the witness of the Spirit.

We have not yet re-checked this work against its source. We put this English text into updated wording with AI help. No scholar has yet certified it as faithful and complete. Open the 1771 text under any part to compare.

The Bible text §1

The Spirit itself bears witness with our spirit, that we are the children of God ( Romans 8:16 ). Romans 8:16 .

Why this truth matters §2

No one who believes the Scriptures to be the word of God can doubt the importance of a truth like this. It is a truth revealed there not once only, not obscurely, not in passing, but often, and in express terms. It is revealed solemnly, and on purpose, as marking one of the peculiar privileges of the children of God.

And it is the more necessary to explain and defend this truth, because there is a danger on the right hand and on the left. If we deny it, there is a danger that our religion will sink into mere formality. There is a danger that, having a form of godliness, we will neglect, if not deny, the power of it. If we allow it, but do not understand what we allow, we are liable to run into all the wildness of enthusiasm. It is therefore necessary in the highest degree to guard those who fear God from both these dangers, by a scriptural and rational illustration and confirmation of this momentous truth.

It may seem that something of this kind is the more needful, because so little has been written on the subject with any clearness. The exception is some discourses on the wrong side of the question, which explain it quite away. And it cannot be doubted that these were occasioned, at least in great measure, by the crude, unscriptural, irrational explanations of others, who did not know what they spoke, nor what they affirmed.

It more nearly concerns the Methodists, so called, to understand, explain, and defend this doctrine clearly, because it is one grand part of the testimony which God has given them to bear to all mankind. It is by his peculiar blessing upon them in searching the Scriptures, confirmed by the experience of his children, that this great evangelical truth has been recovered, which for many years had been very nearly lost and forgotten.

What the witness is §3

But what is the witness of the Spirit? The original word may be rendered either, as it is in several places, the witness, or, less ambiguously, the testimony, or the record. So it is rendered in our translation. 1 John 5:11 . This is the record, the testimony, the sum of what God testifies in all the inspired writings, that God has given to us eternal life, and this life is in his Son.

The testimony now under consideration is given by the Spirit of God to and with our spirit. He is the person testifying. What he testifies to us is that we are the children of God. The immediate result of this testimony is the fruit of the Spirit, namely love, joy, peace, long-suffering, gentleness, goodness. And without these the testimony itself cannot continue. For it is inevitably destroyed, not only by the commission of any outward sin, or the omission of known duty, but by giving way to any inward sin. In a word, it is destroyed by whatever grieves the Holy Spirit of God.

An inward impression §4

I observed many years ago that it is hard to find words in the language of men to explain the deep things of God. Indeed there are none that will adequately express what the Spirit of God works in his children. But perhaps one might say, and I desire any who are taught of God to correct, soften, or strengthen the expression: By the testimony of the Spirit I mean an inward impression of the soul, by which the Spirit of God immediately and directly witnesses to my spirit that I am a child of God. That Jesus Christ has loved me, and given himself for me. That all my sins are blotted out, and I, even I, am reconciled to God.

After 20 years of further consideration, I see no cause to retract any part of this. Neither do I conceive how any of these expressions may be altered so as to make them more intelligible. I can only add that if any of the children of God will point out any other expressions which are clearer, or more agreeable to the word of God, I will readily lay these aside.

Meanwhile, let it be observed, I do not mean by this that the Spirit of God testifies this by any outward voice. No, nor always by an inward voice, although he may do this sometimes. Neither do I suppose that he always applies to the heart, though he often may, one or more texts of Scripture. But he so works upon the soul by his immediate influence, and by a strong though inexplicable operation, that the stormy wind and troubled waves subside, and there is a sweet calm. The heart rests as in the arms of Jesus, and the sinner is clearly satisfied that God is reconciled, that all his iniquities are forgiven, and his sins covered.

What is not in dispute §5

Now, what is the matter of dispute concerning this? Not whether there is a witness or testimony of the Spirit. Not whether the Spirit does testify with our spirit that we are the children of God. No one can deny this without flatly contradicting the Scripture, and charging a lie upon the God of truth. Therefore, that there is a testimony of the Spirit is acknowledged by all parties.

Neither is it questioned whether there is an indirect witness or testimony that we are the children of God. This is nearly, if not exactly, the same as the testimony of a good conscience toward God. And it is the result of reason, or reflection on what we feel in our own souls.

Strictly speaking, it is a conclusion drawn partly from the word of God, and partly from our own experience. The word of God says that everyone who has the fruit of the Spirit is a child of God. Experience, or inward consciousness, tells me that I have the fruit of the Spirit. And hence I rationally conclude, therefore I am a child of God. This is likewise allowed by all, and so is no matter of controversy.

Nor do we assert that there can be any real testimony of the Spirit without the fruit of the Spirit. We assert, on the contrary, that the fruit of the Spirit immediately springs from this testimony. Not always, indeed, in the same degree, even when the testimony is first given. And much less afterward. Neither joy nor peace always stays at one level. No, nor does love. And the testimony itself is not always equally strong and clear.

But the point in question is whether there is any direct testimony of the Spirit at all. Whether there is any other testimony of the Spirit than that which arises from a consciousness of the fruit.

Two witnesses in the text §6

I believe there is, because that is the plain, natural meaning of the text. The Spirit itself bears witness with our spirit, that we are the children of God ( Romans 8:16 ). It is plain that two witnesses are mentioned here, who together testify the same thing, the Spirit of God and our own spirit. The late Bishop of London, in his sermon on this text, seems astonished that anyone can doubt this, which appears upon the very face of the words. Now, the testimony of our own spirit, says the Bishop, is one, which is the consciousness of our own sincerity. Or, to express the same thing a little more clearly, the consciousness of the fruit of the Spirit. When our spirit is conscious of this, of love, joy, peace, long-suffering, gentleness, goodness, it easily infers from these premises that we are the children of God.

It is true that this great man supposes the other witness to be the consciousness of our own good works. This, he affirms, is the testimony of God's Spirit. But this is included in the testimony of our own spirit. Yes, and in sincerity, even according to the common sense of the word.

So the Apostle says, Our rejoicing is this, the testimony of our conscience, that in simplicity and godly sincerity we have had our conversation in the world. There it is plain that sincerity refers to our words and actions, at least as much as to our inward dispositions. So this is not another witness, but the very same one that he mentioned before. The consciousness of our good works is only one branch of the consciousness of our sincerity. Consequently there is only one witness still.

If, therefore, the text speaks of two witnesses, one of these is not the consciousness of our good works, nor of our sincerity. All this is plainly contained in the testimony of our spirit.

The Spirit of adoption §7

What, then, is the other witness? This might easily be learned, if the text itself were not clear enough, from the verse immediately before it. You have received, not the Spirit of bondage, but the Spirit of adoption, by which we cry, Abba, Father. It follows, The Spirit itself bears witness with our spirit, that we are the children of God ( Romans 8:16 ).

This is further explained by the parallel text. Galatians 4:6 . Because you are sons, God has sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your hearts ( Galatians 4:6 ), crying, Abba, Father.

Is not this something immediate and direct, not the result of reflection or argument? Does not this Spirit cry, Abba, Father, in our hearts, the moment it is given? Before any reflection upon our sincerity, yes, before any reasoning whatsoever? And is not this the plain, natural sense of the words, which strikes anyone as soon as he hears them? All these texts, then, in their most obvious meaning, describe a direct testimony of the Spirit.

The witness comes first §8

That the testimony of the Spirit of God must, in the very nature of things, come before the testimony of our own spirit, may appear from this single consideration. We must be holy in heart and life before we can be conscious that we are so. But we must love God before we can be holy at all, this being the root of all holiness.

Now we cannot love God until we know he loves us. We love him, because he first loved us. And we cannot know his love to us until his Spirit witnesses it to our spirit. Until then we cannot believe it. We cannot say, The life which I now live, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me, and gave himself for me.

Then, only then, we feel our interest in his blood, and cry with joy unspeakable, You are my Lord, my God.

Since, therefore, the testimony of his Spirit must come before the love of God and all holiness, it follows that it must come before our consciousness of that love and holiness.

What the children of God have found §9

And here properly comes in, to confirm this scriptural doctrine, the experience of the children of God. The experience not of two or three, not of a few, but of a great multitude which no man can number. It has been confirmed, both in this age and in all ages, by a cloud of living and dying witnesses. It is confirmed by your experience and mine.

The Spirit itself bore witness to my spirit that I was a child of God, gave me an evidence of it, and I immediately cried, Abba, Father. And this I did, and so did you, before I reflected on, or was conscious of, any fruit of the Spirit. It was from this testimony, once received, that love, joy, peace, and the whole fruit of the Spirit flowed. First I heard,

Your sins are forgiven. You are accepted. I listened, and heaven sprang up in my heart.

Those under the wrath of God §10

But this is confirmed not only by the experience of the children of God, thousands of whom can declare that they never knew themselves to be in the favor of God until it was directly witnessed to them by his Spirit. It is confirmed also by all those who are convinced of sin, who feel the wrath of God abiding on them. These cannot be satisfied with anything less than a direct testimony from his Spirit, that he is merciful to their unrighteousness, and remembers their sins and iniquities no more.

Tell any of these, You are to know you are a child by reflecting on what he has worked in you, on your love, joy, and peace. And will he not immediately reply, By all this I know I am a child of the devil.

I have no more love to God than the devil has. My carnal mind is enmity against God. I have no joy in the Holy Ghost. My soul is sorrowful even to death. I have no peace. My heart is a troubled sea. I am all storm and tempest.

And which way can these souls possibly be comforted, but by a divine testimony? Not a testimony that they are good, or sincere, or conformable to the Scripture in heart and life, but that God justifies the ungodly. The one who, until the moment he is justified, is all ungodly, void of all true holiness. The one who does not work, who works nothing that is truly good, until he is conscious that he is accepted, not for any works of righteousness which he has done, but by the mere, free mercy of God. Wholly and solely for what the Son of God has done and suffered for him.

And can it be any otherwise, if a man is justified by faith, without the works of the law? If so, what inward or outward goodness can he be conscious of, before his justification? Is not the having nothing to pay, that is, being conscious that there dwells in us no good thing, neither inward nor outward goodness, essentially, indispensably necessary, before we can be justified freely, through the redemption that is in Jesus Christ? Was ever any man justified since his coming into the world, or can any man ever be justified, until he is brought to that point?

I give up every plea beside. Lord, I am damned. But you have died.

To deny it is to deny justification §11

Everyone, therefore, who denies the existence of such a testimony does in effect deny justification by faith. It follows that either he never experienced this, either he never was justified, or that he has forgotten, as Saint Peter speaks in an old Greek line, the purification from his former sins. He has forgotten the experience he then had himself, the manner in which God worked in his own soul, when his former sins were blotted out.

What the children of the world say §12

And the experience even of the children of the world here confirms that of the children of God. Many of these have a desire to please God. Some of them take much pains to please him. But do they not, one and all, count it the highest absurdity for anyone to talk of knowing his sins are forgiven? Which of them even pretends to any such thing?

And yet many of them are conscious of their own sincerity. Many of them undoubtedly have, in a degree, the testimony of their own spirit, a consciousness of their own uprightness. But this brings them no consciousness that they are forgiven, no knowledge that they are the children of God. Yes, the more sincere they are, the more uneasy they generally are, for want of knowing it. This plainly shows that this cannot be known, in a satisfactory manner, by the bare testimony of our own spirit, without God's directly testifying that we are his children.

The objections §13

But many objections have been made to this. It may be well to consider the chief of them.

Experience is not the foundation §14

It is objected, first, Experience is not sufficient to prove a doctrine which is not founded on Scripture. This is undoubtedly true, and it is an important truth. But it does not affect the present question. For it has been shown that this doctrine is founded on Scripture. Therefore experience is properly alleged to confirm it.

Madmen and French prophets §15

But, it is said, madmen, French prophets, and enthusiasts of every kind have imagined they experienced this witness. They have so. And perhaps not a few of them did, although they did not retain it long. But if they did not, this is no proof at all that others have not experienced it. A madman's imagining himself a king does not prove that there are no real kings.

No, many who pleaded strongly for this have utterly decried the Bible. Perhaps so. But this was no necessary consequence. Thousands plead for it who have the highest esteem for the Bible.

Yes, but many have fatally deceived themselves by this, and got above all conviction.

And yet a scriptural doctrine is no worse, though men abuse it to their own destruction.

When the fruit is not yet seen §16

But, says one, I lay it down as an undoubted truth, the fruit of the Spirit is the witness of the Spirit. Not undoubted. Thousands doubt it. Yes, they flatly deny it. But let that pass.

If this witness is sufficient, there is no need of any other. But it is sufficient, except in one of these cases. The first case is the total absence of the fruit of the Spirit. And this is the case when the direct witness is first given. The second case is the not perceiving it. But to contend for it in this case, it is said, is to contend for being in the favor of God, and not knowing it.

True: not knowing it at that time in any other way than by the testimony which is given for that end. And this we do contend for. We contend that the direct witness may shine clear, even while the indirect one is under a cloud.

Not a proof of an earlier profession §17

It is objected, secondly, The design of the witness contended for is to prove that the profession we make is genuine. But it does not prove this. I answer, the proving of this is not the design of it. It comes before our making any profession at all, except that of being lost, undone, guilty, helpless sinners. It is designed to assure those to whom it is given that they are the children of God, that they are justified freely by his grace, through the redemption that is in Jesus Christ.

And this does not suppose that their preceding thoughts, words, and actions are conformable to the rule of Scripture. It supposes quite the reverse, namely, that they are sinners all over, sinners both in heart and life. Were it otherwise, God would justify the godly, and their own works would be counted to them for righteousness. And I cannot but fear that a supposition of our being justified by works is at the root of all their objections. For whoever cordially believes that God imputes to all who are justified a righteousness without works will find no difficulty in allowing the witness of his Spirit, coming before the fruit of it.

What the evangelists actually say §18

It is objected, thirdly, One evangelist says, Your heavenly Father will give the Holy Spirit to those who ask him. The other evangelist calls the same thing good gifts, and from this claims an abundant demonstration that the Spirit's way of bearing witness is by giving good gifts. But neither saying speaks of bearing witness at all. Until this demonstration is better demonstrated, I let it stand as it is.

Try the spirits by the fruit §19

It is objected, fourthly, The Scripture says, The tree is known by its fruits. Prove all things. Try the spirits. Examine yourselves.

Most true. Therefore let every man who believes he has the witness in himself try whether it is of God. If the fruit follows, it is. Otherwise it is not. For certainly the tree is known by its fruit. By this we prove if it is of God.

But, it is said, the direct witness is never referred to in the book of God. Not as standing alone, not as a single witness, but as connected with the other. As giving a joint testimony, testifying with our spirit that we are children of God. And who is able to prove that it is not thus referred to in this very Scripture: Examine yourselves whether you are in the faith. Prove your own selves. Do you not know yourselves, that Jesus Christ is in you?

It is by no means clear that they did not know this by a direct as well as a remote witness. How is it proved that they did not know it, first by an inward consciousness, and then by love, joy, and peace?

But the testimony arising from the internal and external change is constantly referred to in the Bible. It is so. And we constantly refer to that change, to confirm the testimony of the Spirit.

No, all the marks you have given, by which to distinguish the operations of God's Spirit from delusion, refer to the change worked in us and upon us. This likewise is undoubtedly true.

Two witnesses, joined together §20

It is objected, fifthly, that the direct witness of the Spirit does not secure us from the greatest delusion. And is that a witness fit to be trusted, whose testimony cannot be depended on? That is forced to fly to something else, to prove what it asserts?

I answer. To secure us from all delusion, God gives us two witnesses that we are his children. And this they testify together. Therefore, what God has joined together, let not man put asunder. And while they are joined, we cannot be deluded. Their testimony can be depended on. They are fit to be trusted in the highest degree, and need nothing else to prove what they assert.

No, the direct witness only asserts, but does not prove anything. By two witnesses shall every word be established. And when the Spirit witnesses with our spirit, as God designs it to do, then it fully proves that we are children of God.

A trial that can shake confidence §21

It is objected, sixthly, You admit that the change worked is a sufficient testimony, except in the case of severe trials, such as that of our Savior upon the cross. But none of us can be tried in that manner. But you or I may be tried in such a manner, and so may any other child of God, that it will be impossible for us to keep our confidence in God as his children without the direct witness of his Spirit.

Proud contenders, and meek ones §22

It is objected, lastly, The greatest contenders for it are some of the proudest and most uncharitable of men. Perhaps some of the hottest contenders for it are both proud and uncharitable. But many of the firmest contenders for it are eminently meek and lowly in heart, and indeed in all other respects also,

True followers of their lamb-like Lord.

The preceding objections are the most considerable that I have heard, and I believe they contain the strength of the cause. Yet I take it that whoever calmly and impartially considers those objections and the answers together will easily see that they do not destroy, no, nor weaken, the evidence of that great truth, that the Spirit of God does directly, as well as indirectly, testify that we are children of God.

The sum of all §23

The sum of all is this. The testimony of the Spirit is an inward impression on the souls of believers, by which the Spirit of God directly testifies to their spirit that they are children of God. And it is not questioned whether there is a testimony of the Spirit. But whether there is any direct testimony. Whether there is any other than that which arises from a consciousness of the fruit of the Spirit.

We believe there is, because this is the plain natural meaning of the text, illustrated both by the words that go before it, and by the parallel passage in the letter to the Galatians. Because, in the nature of the thing, the testimony must come before the fruit which springs from it. And because this plain meaning of the word of God is confirmed by the experience of innumerable children of God. Yes, and by the experience of all who are convinced of sin, who can never rest until they have a direct witness. And even by the experience of the children of the world, who, not having the witness in themselves, one and all declare that no one can know his sins are forgiven.

The objections, and the answers §24

And whereas it is objected that experience is not sufficient to prove a doctrine unsupported by Scripture. That madmen and enthusiasts of every kind have imagined such a witness. That the design of that witness is to prove our profession genuine, which design it does not answer.

That the Scripture says, The tree is known by its fruit. Examine yourselves. Prove your own selves. And that, meanwhile, the direct witness is never referred to in all the book of God. That it does not secure us from the greatest delusions. And, lastly, that the change worked in us is a sufficient testimony, except in such trials as Christ alone suffered.

We answer. First, experience is sufficient to confirm a doctrine which is grounded on Scripture. Second, though many fancy they experience what they do not, this is no prejudice to real experience. Third, the design of that witness is to assure us we are children of God, and this design it does answer.

Fourth, the true witness of the Spirit is known by its fruit, love, peace, joy, not indeed coming before it, but following it. Fifth, it cannot be proved that the direct witness, as well as the indirect witness, is not referred to in that very text, Do you not know your own selves, that Jesus Christ is in you? Sixth, the Spirit of God witnessing with our spirit does secure us from all delusion. And, lastly, we are all liable to trials in which the testimony of our own spirit is not sufficient, in which nothing less than the direct testimony of God's Spirit can assure us that we are his children.

Do not separate the witness from the fruit §25

Two inferences may be drawn from the whole. The first: let no one ever presume to rest in any supposed testimony of the Spirit which is separate from the fruit of it. If the Spirit of God does really testify that we are children of God, the immediate consequence will be the fruit of the Spirit, even love, joy, peace, long-suffering, gentleness, goodness, fidelity, meekness, temperance.

And however this fruit may be clouded for a while, during the time of strong temptation, so that it does not appear to the tempted person, while Satan is sifting him as wheat, yet the substantial part of it remains, even under the thickest cloud. It is true, joy in the Holy Ghost may be withdrawn during the hour of trial. Yes, the soul may be exceedingly sorrowful while the hour and power of darkness continue. But even this is generally restored with increase, until we rejoice with joy unspeakable and full of glory.

Do not rest in the fruit alone §26

The second inference is, let no one rest in any supposed fruit of the Spirit without the witness. There may be foretastes of joy, of peace, of love, and those not delusive, but really from God, long before we have the witness in ourselves, before the Spirit of God witnesses with our spirits that we have redemption in the blood of Jesus, even the forgiveness of sins. Yes, there may be a degree of long-suffering, of gentleness, of fidelity, meekness, temperance, not a shadow of them, but a real degree, by the preventing grace of God, the grace that goes before. This may be so before we are accepted in the Beloved, and consequently before we have a testimony of our acceptance. But it is by no means advisable to rest here. It is at the peril of our souls if we do.

If we are wise, we shall be continually crying to God, until his Spirit cries in our heart, Abba, Father. This is the privilege of all the children of God, and without this we can never be assured that we are his children. Without this we cannot retain a steady peace, nor avoid perplexing doubts and fears. But when we have once received this Spirit of adoption, this peace which passes all understanding, and which expels all painful doubt and fear, will keep our hearts and minds in Christ Jesus. And when this has brought forth its genuine fruit, all inward and outward holiness, it is undoubtedly the will of him who calls us, to give us always what he has once given. So there is no need that we should ever again be deprived either of the testimony of God's Spirit, or of the testimony of our own, the consciousness of our walking in all righteousness and true holiness.

Where the printed sermon ends §27

The sermon, as printed, ends with the place and date, Newry, 4 April 1767.

From Via Patrum: https://viapatrum.org/works/john-wesley-the-witness-of-the-spirit-discourse-ii/. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Credit: Via Patrum.
