On James, the Brother of the Lord, and David

In sanctum Iacobum fratrem Domini et Davidem

Hesychius of Jerusalem (fl. c. 412–450 AD)

Translated from the Greek by Via Patrum.

About this text

A short passage from Hesychius comparing Bethlehem with Zion, then praising James, the Lord's brother, for his ruling at the council in Jerusalem.

The surviving text contrasts Bethlehem and Zion and praises James. Hesychius begins by reflecting that if Christ had not humbled himself and become obedient to death, servants would not have been called kinsmen, nor would the clay have been called father of the potter. He then develops a sustained comparison between Bethlehem, where Christ was born, and Zion, where the Church now receives him, showing how the mysteries of the incarnation are fulfilled in the Church.

The homily turns to praise James, the brother of the Lord, as commander-in-chief of the new Jerusalem, leader of the priests, and chief of the apostles, whose brief judgment at the apostolic council settled the question of Gentile inclusion. A reader will meet Peter, mentioned as a public speaker, and Thomas, to whom Zion bared Christ's side when he wished to touch it. The homily quotes or alludes to Philippians 2:8 and Acts 15:19.

Translated from PG 93 (Greek)

This work has passed our source check. We made this study translation with AI help. No scholar has yet certified it as faithful and complete. Open Greek on any section to see the source text. It is not a critical edition.

Bethlehem and Zion compared §1

Hesychius, priest of Jerusalem, opens his homily on James the brother of the Lord and David the ancestor of God by contrasting Bethlehem, where Christ was born, with Zion, where the Church now receives him.

If our Savior had not humbled himself and become obedient to the point of death ( Philippians 2:8 ), servants would never have been called kinsmen, nor would the clay ever have been called the father of the potter.

In Zion I greet Bethlehem as though she were present; in the daughter I see the mother.

In you one torch-bearing star was kindled, but in her many were kindled. That star guided the Magi, but she gave torchlight to Parthians, Medes, Elamites, and people from all the nations with light like lightning.

You draw milk from virgin breasts, but she draws down the Spirit from the Father's bosom.

Bethlehem's hidden mysteries versus Zion's open fulfillment §2

Hesychius continues his comparison between Bethlehem, where Christ's mysteries were hidden, and Zion, where they are now revealed and fulfilled.

You leavened the bread, but Zion displayed a supper. You nourished the calf at the manger, but Zion led it up to the altar. You hid Jesus in swaddling clothes, but she bared his side to Thomas when he wished to touch it. You have a virgin giving birth while the organs of nature remained closed; she has a bridal chamber that, while the doors were closed, receives the bridegroom within and holds him.

How to praise James, the servant and brother of Christ §3

Hesychius, the preacher, is asking how he can worthily praise James, the brother of the Lord, after contrasting Bethlehem and Zion.

How shall I praise the servant and brother of Christ, the commander-in-chief of the new Jerusalem, the leader of the priests, the chief of the apostles, the crown among heads, the one shining beyond among lamps, the one shining beyond among stars? Peter speaks in public, but James gives the law, and a few words contracted the magnitude of the question: “I judge not to trouble those from the nations,” and so on ( Acts 15:19 ).

The Judge Speaks Through James §4

Hesychius is explaining that James's words at the apostolic council are not merely human, but the voice of Christ the judge of all speaking through James as an instrument.

“I judge.” It is not lawful to set aside his judgment, nor to despise his decree. For in me speaks the judge of all, both the dead and the living. The instrument is mine, but the craftsman is above me. I supply the tongue, but the Word, the maker, supplies the word. Pay no attention to the reed, but to the one who writes with it. Let obedience follow the hearing.

From Via Patrum: https://viapatrum.org/works/hesychius-homilia-i-lazarum/. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Credit: Via Patrum.
