Treatise against Those Who Make Images

Tractatus contra eos qui imagines faciunt

Epiphanius of Salamis (c. 310/320–403 AD)

Translated from the Greek by Via Patrum.

About this text

Epiphanius argues against painting images of Christ, the Mother of God, the saints, and the angels, saying they dishonor those they mean to honor.

Epiphanius of Salamis (c. 310/320–403) was bishop of Salamis, the chief city of Cyprus, from 367 until his death. This treatise is attributed to him and belongs to a small group of writings against images that circulated under his name, though modern scholars debate whether all of them are genuine. It is addressed to Christians who make and honor painted images of Christ, the Mother of God, martyrs, angels, and prophets.

The work opposes the practice of making painted images for memorial and honor, which the author regards as a return to idolatry. He argues that making images of the saints dishonors rather than honors them, since Scripture promises they will be transformed into glory like Christ and the angels, not depicted in dead, voiceless matter.

The fathers at the Council of Laodicea are quoted pronouncing an anathema on those who abandon the church to invoke angels. The author calls Christ incomprehensible and uncircumscribable, meaning he cannot be grasped by the mind or contained in a visual form. The word images renders painted likenesses, worship renders the act of bowing before them, and idolatrous custom renders the practice the author opposes. Old Testament quotations follow the Greek Septuagint book names and Psalm numbering.

This work has passed our source check. We made this study translation with AI help. No scholar has yet certified it as faithful and complete. Open Greek on any section to see the source text. It is not a critical edition.

The opening charge against image-making §1

Epiphanius opens his treatise by stating his target: those who make painted images of Christ, the Mother of God, martyrs, angels, and prophets, and he begins to answer their claim that the images are for memorial and honor.

1A discourse of Saint Epiphanius against those who make a practice of producing images according to an idolatrous custom, in likeness of Christ and of the Mother of God and of the martyrs, and further of angels and prophets.

They whitewashed the wall and impressed images on it with varied colors.

Because, they say, we make images of the saints as a memorial and for their honor.

Falsely named.

But how did bones and sinews fitted together become visible to him in the painting of the archangel? It would take his own wit to say.

Those who think they honor the apostles in this way should learn that instead of honoring them, they dishonor them all the more.

For Paul, insulting the falsely named priest, declared him to be a whitewashed wall.

The saints' future glory makes images of them dishonoring §2

Epiphanius is arguing against making images of the saints, and here he cites John and Paul on the saints' future glory, then turns to the angels' refusal of worship.

2John says, "We know that when he appears, we shall be like him" (1 John 3:2), and Paul proclaimed that the saints are "conformed to the Son of God" (Romans 8:29). So how can you wish to see the saints, who are destined to shine in glory, in inglorious, dead, and voiceless matter, when the Lord says of them, "They will be like the angels of God" (Matthew 22:30)? And how can you paint angels, who are spirits and always alive, painting them in dead things and worship them, when the prophet says, "He who makes his angels spirits and his ministers a flaming fire" (Psalm 103:4 LXX, 104:4 Hebrew)? I say that they themselves do not wish to be worshipped. "See that you do not do it; I am a fellow servant with you and your brothers who hold the testimony of Jesus. Worship God," he says (Revelation 19:10). But the apostles did not wish to be worshipped either.

Apostles and Laodicea refuse worship §3

Epiphanius is arguing that neither the apostles nor the angels wish to be worshipped, and he now cites the apostle's words to Cornelius and the Council of Laodicea's anathema against invoking angels.

3When the apostles were sent out to preach the gospel, they did not want to be worshipped themselves, but only Christ who sent them. The one who received authority from him to bind and loose on earth and in heaven said to Cornelius, "I am a human being of like nature with you," and he taught that he himself was not to be worshipped, but only Christ the Savior.

As for the angels, the fathers who gathered at Laodicea—for they certainly assembled because of just such a matter—say: "If anyone abandons the church of God and invokes angels, let him be anathema, because he has abandoned our Lord Jesus Christ and has fallen into idolatry."

No one can depict the incomprehensible Christ §4

Epiphanius is closing his treatise by attacking the opponents' claim that the incarnate Christ can be depicted, arguing that the command to make such images comes from the evil one, not from God.

4How can anyone claim to paint the incomprehensible, the inexpressible, the inconceivable, the one who cannot be encompassed or depicted—the one Moses could not even gaze upon? Some say, "Since he became a perfect human being from Mary the ever-virgin, that is why we make him as a human being." And did he become incarnate for this reason—so that you could paint with your hands the incomprehensible one through whom all things were made? Then is he not like the Father, and does he not give life to the dead? Where did he command you, when he came to earth, to make something like him and to worship it and gaze upon it? This command is from the evil one, so that you would despise God. For God abolishes these things in all the Old and New Testaments, saying precisely: "You shall worship the Lord your God, and him alone shall you serve" (Deuteronomy 6:13).

From Via Patrum: https://viapatrum.org/works/epiphanius-tractatus-contra-eos-qui-imagines-faciunt/. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Credit: Via Patrum.