Letter to John of Jerusalem

Epistula ad Joannem Hierosolymitanum

Epiphanius of Salamis (c. 310/320–403 AD)

Translated from the Greek by Via Patrum.

About this text

A bishop's urgent plea for unity and truth amid accusations of idolatry in a holy land.

Epiphanius of Salamis (c. 310/320–403) was bishop of Salamis, also called Constantia, in Cyprus. He wrote this letter in Greek. It is one of the few pieces of his correspondence that survive through Jerome, who rendered it into Latin at his request and kept it in his own collection.

He sent it to John, bishop of Jerusalem, to explain and defend his act of tearing a curtain painted with a human image in a church at Anautha and to send a replacement. Behind it lay John's anger because Epiphanius had ordained a priest, Jerome's brother Paulinian, inside John's jurisdiction, while the wider Origenist dispute was at its height and Epiphanius had openly charged John with being an Origenist. The letter reads as a half apology that only made matters worse.

Epiphanius urges John not to be carried away by pride of office, where office means clerical office, but to heed Scripture, prays that God will crush Satan under the feet of Christians and keep the bond of love, peace, right faith and truth unbroken, then tells how on his way to meet John at Bethel he tore the idol-like curtain as an abomination and said it should wrap a poor dead person. The reader also hears the grumblers, quoted in direct speech to say he should have supplied a replacement from his own store before he tore it. Here curtain is the cloth hung in a church, human image means a painted person, honor is the form used to address John, church means building and people, and the warning against grumbling is quoted from 1 Corinthians 10:10 without naming Paul, with a hint of 10:9.

Translated from PG 41 – 43 (Greek)

This work has passed our source check. We made this study translation with AI help. No scholar has yet certified it as faithful and complete. Open Greek on any section to see the source text. It is not a critical edition.

Greeting and warning against pride and grumbling §1

Epiphanius opens his letter to John of Jerusalem with a formal greeting, then immediately warns him not to be carried away by pride of office, citing Scripture against grumbling.

To the most reverend brother and papa John, Epiphanius, bishop, sends greetings in the Lord.

We ought not, beloved, to be carried away by the pride of office, but... For the divine Scripture says: “Do not grumble, as some of them grumbled and were destroyed by the destroyer” ( 1 Corinthians 10:10 , with allusion to 10:9).

Prayer for peace and unbroken bond §2

Epiphanius, having just quoted Scripture against grumbling, now prays that God will crush Satan and preserve the bond of love, peace, faith, and truth among Christians.

But the God of peace, in his love for humankind, will act with us so that Satan is crushed under the feet of us Christians, and every wicked pretext is driven away, so that the bond of Christ's unfeigned love, peace, right faith, and truth is not torn from us.

Tearing the painted curtain at Anautha §3

Epiphanius tells John what happened when he entered a church at Anautha while traveling to meet John at Bethel.

But I heard that some grumbled against us. While we were traveling on to the holy place at Bethel to meet with your honor, we came to the village called Anautha. I saw a lamp burning, and when I asked I learned that there was a church in that place. I went in to pray, and I found a dyed curtain on the door, painted with some human image, idol-like. They said it was perhaps a likeness of Christ or of one of the saints, for I myself, though I saw it, do not remember whose image it was.

Knowing that it is an abomination for such things to be in a church, I tore it and advised wrapping a poor dead person in it. But those who grumbled said, “He ought to have replaced the curtain from his own means before he tore it,” although I had promised to send another in its place. I was slow to send it because pressing need held me.

Sending the replacement curtain and urging John to prevent such hangings §4

Epiphanius is closing his letter to John of Jerusalem, explaining that he has now sent the replacement curtain and asking John to order the local presbyter to receive it and to prevent such images in churches.

I had expected to send one from Cyprus, but now I have sent what I found. Deign, then, to order the presbyter of the parish to receive what has been sent from the reader, and I ask you to command that such things not be hung in the churches. For it is fitting for your honor to care about all things and to examine carefully what is beneficial for the church of God and for the people entrusted to you.

From Via Patrum: https://viapatrum.org/works/epiphanius-epistula-ad-joannem-hierosolymitanum/. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Credit: Via Patrum.
