On the Trinity

De Trinitate

Didymus the Blind (c. 313–c. 398 AD)

Translated from the Greek by Via Patrum.

About this text

Didymus the Blind defends the full divinity of Father, Son, and Spirit against those who rank them.

Didymus the Blind (c. 313–c. 398) was a Christian teacher in Alexandria, Egypt, blind from early childhood. A treatise called On the Trinity has traditionally been ascribed to him, but its authorship is now widely disputed. Many scholars consider it an anonymous work rather than a genuine composition of Didymus.

The text draws on Cyril of Alexandria's anti-Arian theology and cites mid-fifth-century sources on Arians, Macedonians, and Eunomians. This shows it was written after those controversies. It is addressed to Orthodox Christians contending with anti-Trinitarian heretics.

The treatise defends the full divinity and shared essence of the Son and the Holy Spirit against claims that they are creatures or lesser powers. A reader will meet the apostles Paul, Peter, and John, the prophets Isaiah and David, and heretics such as Macedonius, whose words are quoted and argued against. Psalms are cited by Septuagint numbers, which are usually one behind modern English numbering.

We have not yet re-checked this work against its source. We made this study translation with AI help. No scholar has yet certified it as faithful and complete. Open Greek on any section to see the source text. It is not a critical edition.

Paul’s Witness: No Knowledge of God Apart from the Son §1

1So Paul, faithful to the law and made wise by the divine Spirit, guarantees that those who believe in the Son escape the charge of giving glory to created gods.

More than that, he even calls “godless” those who before this knew God the Father alone, apart from the Son, since the Son is not counted among the things that were made. In one place he writes: “Remember that at one time you Gentiles in the flesh, called the uncircumcision by what is called the circumcision, made in the flesh by hand, were at that time without Christ, estranged from the hope of Israel and strangers to the covenants of the promise, having no hope and godless in the world” (Ephesians 2:11-12).

In another: “But then, when you did not know God, you were slaves to beings that by nature are not gods. Now, however, that you have come to know God, or rather to be known by God, how can you turn back again to the weak and beggarly elements, to which you want to be slaves all over again?” (Galatians 4:8-9).

Yet he holds the saving proclamation about Christ and the Holy Spirit, ever new and never sinking into old age, and the Church’s ordinance, to be more excellent than the older law, because it is perfect and has nothing either [...] lawless [...] to trouble it, or [...] finer or greater that ought to be set before it [...] in word or in manner [...]. For on this matter he writes to [...]: “I became”; “as to zeal, a persecutor of the church; as to the righteousness that is in the law, blameless. But whatever gains I had, these I have counted loss for Christ’s sake. Indeed, I count all things to be loss because of the surpassing excellence of the knowledge of Jesus Christ our Lord, for whose sake I have suffered the loss of all things and count them as refuse, that I may gain Christ” (Philippians 3:6-8).

And to the Romans: “For if the one who comes preaches another Jesus, whom we did not preach, or if you receive a different spirit, which you did not receive” (2 Corinthians 11:4).

With what in view, then, and with what thoughts proper to a pure knowledge of God, has he written again? To the Corinthians, in the second letter, that if anyone is reconciled to the Son, he has been reconciled to God, and that the world’s accord with God is in Christ. The passage runs: “That God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself, not counting their trespasses against them, and placing in us the word of reconciliation. So we are ambassadors on behalf of Christ, as though God were appealing through us. We plead on Christ’s behalf: be reconciled to God” (2 Corinthians 5:19-20).

And again, as though he had set everything else aside, he proclaimed with great boasting that even what seems to bring reproach on Christ, because of his loving dispensation for mankind, teems with all honour and strength. He does this, I think, on purpose, so that anyone who does not discern, from the glorious passion, the uncreated, pure and unchangeable Godhead may stand indicted for arrogance.

His words were these: “I decided to know nothing among you except Jesus Christ, and him crucified” (1 Corinthians 2:2). And to the Romans: “The righteousness of God through faith in Jesus Christ for all who believe” (Romans 3:22). Through faith in the Son, he says, each person is justified by God.

And to the Galatians: “Knowing that a person is not justified by works of the law but through faith in Jesus Christ, we too have believed in Jesus Christ, so that we might be justified by faith in Christ and not by works of the law; for by works of the law no flesh will be justified” (Galatians 2:16). And elsewhere too he explains that “neither circumcision counts for anything nor uncircumcision, but a new faith working through love” (Galatians 5:6).

The saying runs deep, and its sense must be unfolded. What he means to teach is that the appearing of Christ found a new faith, the only faith, for all people, and by it left no room either for Judaism or for the religion of the Greeks. This faith may also be understood by the saying: “See, the old things have passed away; all things have become new” (2 Corinthians 5:17). And, to put it briefly [...], the one who knows God ceases from the law, since, he says, circumcision is not perfect. But there shone forth for …

The Free Son; the Fable That the Father Made the Son to Serve §2

2… salvation and teaching to all: the true and free light, the Son. And he sets forth in a hidden way this truth, which some of them did not know because the memory of the polytheism of Egypt still rang in their ears.

So the august Son of God, bearing further witness that his own nature is free from above and does not have creation, so to speak, for a sister (for everything brought into being is the slave of the one who brought it into being, and what has been created is the creature of its creator), says to Peter: “From whom do the kings of the earth take toll or tribute? From their own sons, or from strangers?” And when he answered, “From strangers,” Jesus said to him, “Then the sons are free. But so that we may not give them offence, go to the sea, cast a hook, and take the first fish that comes up; when you open its mouth you will find a stater. Take that and give it to them for me and for you” (Matthew 17:25-27).

So much for these matters. Yet even so they do not stop.

On those who spin the fable that the Father made the Son for service in the work of creation.

Blasphemously they counter-attack and spin their fables, saying that the Father made for himself a Son, most useful for serving him in making the rest of the creatures. They no longer notice what hangs on this guesswork of theirs: envy, reluctance, and other things that belong to matter.

For surely these consequences too must be faced. If creating is good, as indeed it is good, and the sole property and sole prerogative of the divine and ungrudging nature, so that it might have someone by whom it is glorified, why did he not create all things through himself, but, as it were, shrank from the task? And if it is a great thing for created beings to be brought forward [...] by the greater and [...], if indeed, as they hold, the Father is greater than his own Son, the Word, did he begrudge those who glorify him the privilege of being made through himself?

And if making what is brought into being through a mediator is not altogether free at once of arrogance and of weakness, then it shows the glory of the one who brings a thing forth through himself to be greater than that of one who makes it through another. For what does not yet exist obeys the nod of him who always is: it is all but instantly brought to completion, receives its fitting measures, and lacks nothing in any part. [...] not only is the one who [...] arrogant, but already [...] would be shown [...] all that [...] authority and [...].

And if Jesus says to the dead Lazarus, “Come out!” (John 11:43), and to another, “Your sins are forgiven you” (Mark 2:5), and to another, “I command you: come out of him” (Mark 9:25), then for God to do these things through another, on their way of thinking, shows that God the Father, whose thought…

… of created gods, those who believe in the Son: this is what Paul, faithful to the law and made wise by the divine Spirit, guarantees.

More than that, he even calls “godless” those who before this knew God the Father alone, apart from the Son, since the Son is not counted among the things that were made. In one place he writes: “Remember that at one time you Gentiles in the flesh, called the uncircumcision by what is called the circumcision, made in the flesh by hand, were at that time without Christ, estranged from the hope of Israel and strangers to the covenants of the promise, having no hope and godless in the world” (Ephesians 2:11-12).

In another: “But then, when you did not know God, you were slaves to beings that by nature are not gods. Now, however, that you have come to know God, or rather to be known by God, how can you turn back again to the weak and beggarly elements, to which you want to be slaves all over again?” (Galatians 4:8-9).

Yet he holds the saving proclamation about Christ and the Holy Spirit, ever new and never sinking into old age, and the Church’s ordinance, to be more excellent than the older law, because it is perfect and has nothing either [...] lawless [...] to trouble it, or [...] finer or greater that ought to be set before it [...] in word or in manner [...]. For on this matter he writes to [...]: “I became”; “as to zeal, a persecutor of the church; as to the righteousness that is in the law, blameless. But whatever gains I had, these I have counted loss for Christ’s sake. Indeed, I count all things to be loss because of the surpassing excellence of the knowledge of Jesus Christ our Lord, for whose sake I have suffered the loss of all things and count them as refuse, that I may gain Christ” (Philippians 3:6-8).

And to the Romans: “For if the one who comes preaches another Jesus, whom we did not preach, or if you receive a different spirit, which you did not receive” (2 Corinthians 11:4).

With what in view, then, and with what thoughts proper to a pure knowledge of God, has he written again? To the Corinthians, in the second letter, that if anyone is reconciled to the Son, he has been reconciled to God, and that the world’s accord with God is in Christ. The passage runs: “That God was in Christ…

The Father Whose Thoughts Are Deeds Needs No Helper §3

3“… reconciling the world to himself, not counting their trespasses against them, and placing in us the word of reconciliation. So we are ambassadors on behalf of Christ, as though God were appealing through us. We plead on Christ’s behalf: be reconciled to God” (2 Corinthians 5:19-20).

And again, as though he had set everything else aside, he proclaimed with great boasting that even what seems to bring reproach on Christ, because of his loving dispensation for mankind, teems with all honour and strength. He does this, I think, on purpose, so that anyone who does not discern, from the glorious passion, the uncreated, pure and unchangeable Godhead may stand indicted for arrogance.

His words were these: “I decided to know nothing among you except Jesus Christ, and him crucified” (1 Corinthians 2:2). And to the Romans: “The righteousness of God through faith in Jesus Christ for all who believe” (Romans 3:22). Through faith in the Son, he says, each person is justified by God.

And to the Galatians: “Knowing that a person is not justified by works of the law but through faith in Jesus Christ, we too have believed in Jesus Christ, so that we might be justified by faith in Christ and not by works of the law; for by works of the law no flesh will be justified” (Galatians 2:16). And elsewhere too he explains that “neither circumcision counts for anything nor uncircumcision, but a new faith working through love” (Galatians 5:6).

The saying runs deep, and its sense must be unfolded. What he means to teach is that the appearing of Christ found a new faith, the only faith, for all people, and by it left no room either for Judaism or for the religion of the Greeks. This faith may also be understood by the saying: “See, the old things have passed away; all things have become new” (2 Corinthians 5:17). And, to put it briefly [...], the one who knows God ceases from the law, since, he says, circumcision is not perfect.

But there shone forth for salvation and teaching to all the true and free light, the Son. And he sets forth in a hidden way this truth, which some of them did not know because the memory of the polytheism of Egypt still rang in their ears.

So the august Son of God, bearing further witness that his own nature is free from above and does not have creation, so to speak, for a sister (for everything brought into being is the slave of the one who brought it into being, and what has been created is the creature of its creator), says to Peter: “From whom do the kings of the earth take toll or tribute? From their own sons, or from strangers?” And when he answered, “From strangers,” Jesus said to him, “Then the sons are free. But so that we may not give them offence, go to the sea, cast a hook, and take the first fish that comes up; when you open its mouth you will find a stater. Take that and give it to them for me and for you” (Matthew 17:25-27).

So much for these matters. Yet even so they do not stop.

On those who spin the fable that the Father made the Son for service in the work of creation.

Blasphemously they counter-attack and spin their fables, saying that the Father made for himself a Son, most useful for serving him in making the rest of the creatures. They no longer notice what hangs on this guesswork of theirs: envy, reluctance, and other things that belong to matter.

For surely these consequences too must be faced. If creating is good, as indeed it is good, and the sole property and sole prerogative of the divine and ungrudging nature, so that it might have someone by whom it is glorified, why did he not create all things through himself, but, as it were, shrank from the task? And if it is a great thing for created beings to be brought forward [...] by the greater and [...], if indeed, as they hold, the Father is greater than his own Son, the Word, did he begrudge those who glorify him the privilege of being made through himself?

And if making what is brought into being through a mediator is not altogether free at once of arrogance and of weakness, then it shows the glory of the one who brings a thing forth through himself to be greater than that of one who makes it through another. For what does not yet exist obeys the nod of him who always is: it is all but instantly brought to completion, receives its fitting measures, and lacks nothing in any part. [...] not only is the one who [...] arrogant, but already [...] would be shown [...] all that [...] authority and [...].

And if Jesus says to the dead Lazarus, “Come out!” (John 11:43), and to another, “Your sins are forgiven you” (Mark 2:5), and to another, “I command you: come out of him” (Mark 9:25), then for God to do these things through another, on their way of thinking, shows that God the Father, whose thoughts are themselves acts of making, cannot bring the whole work to completion through himself without the help of that one through whom or in whom he makes; and the …

The Incomprehensibility of Divine Generation §4

4… Son as a kind of lifeless instrument. How could anyone not spit hard at such savage slanders, hold up his upturned hands against them and withdraw, afraid of being held answerable before the divine court even for a hearing he did not choose?

On what the heretics say: “When was the Son begotten, and when did the Spirit proceed?” and the rest.

There are, then, so many and such clear proofs, and Scripture urges us “not to be carried away by various and strange teachings” (Hebrews 13:9) and to shun “empty talk” (2 Timothy 2:16). Yet the heterodox, at a loss to establish the tenets of their religion from the Scriptures, and [...] like drunken men, with their argument on each point tossed this way and that, put forward various sophisms, put together with evil craft and long rehearsed. Among them are these: “Are not all things, then,” he says, “from God?”

To them we must answer: Yes, but not by begetting, as the Son is, nor by procession, as the Spirit of God is; nor do they share in such operations, nor have they been counted worthy of so glorious a manner of existence.

Next: “When, then, was the Son begotten, and when did the Spirit proceed?” At the time when the Father was not begotten. For though they are from him, they are not after him. And as it is unlawful to seek [...] in a place, since neither the one who begot nor the one begotten is circumscribed [...], so neither [...] in time. For the Son, being God and the Word of the [...], [...] but of making. So too the Spirit [...].

“And how,” he says, “was he begotten?” It is written of the Son, “From the womb, before the morning star, I begot you” (Psalm 110:3), and of the Holy Spirit, “A Spirit goes forth from me”; David sings, “By the word of the Lord the heavens were made firm, and by the Spirit of his mouth all their powers” (Psalm 33:6); Job says, “A divine Spirit is what made me, and the breath of the Almighty is what teaches me” (Job 33:4); the Lord teaches, “The Spirit of truth, who proceeds from the Father” (John 15:26); and Paul writes that the Spirit is God’s own, as their own spirit is men’s (1 Corinthians 2:11). Yet even so, this so far surpasses every mind that the same Apostle writes to the Corinthians: “But thanks be to God, who always leads us in triumph in Christ and through us has made known the fragrance of the knowledge” (2 Corinthians 2:14). He means that, because it cannot be contained, we have not shared in the whole of the knowledge, but only, as it were, in a kind of semblance or waft of it.

And again: “We see through a mirror and in a riddle” (1 Corinthians 13:12) the things that concern him. And with good reason, for according to the divine saying, “The glory of the Lord hides a word” (Proverbs 25:2), since it lies beyond every created perception by a measure that is unspeakable and boundless. This is not only because it is too heavy to bear, but because what is before the ages and before all creation would have stayed unknown to creation had the Scriptures not made it known.

And again, writing a second time to the same readers, he puts it [...] most beautifully: “But we will not boast beyond measure, but according to the measure of the rule which God has apportioned to us as a measure, to reach even as far as you” (2 Corinthians 10:13). And in the first letter he says: “If anyone thinks he knows something, he does not yet know as he ought to know” (1 Corinthians 8:2).

What is the difference between begetting and procession? As the manner is unknown, so is the difference, if indeed it is permitted even to hear or to speak of this very thing. For to assign causes to what is beyond all cause and thought is rash; but to marvel at the divine, and to hold that the awesome thought of it is a thing to fear, is safe.

“Did God, then,” he says, “beget willingly or unwillingly?” But we must first state their aim and then answer. Their aim is to turn either word into a counter-argument against simple people. For if they seize on “he begot unwillingly” (though no one gives them that answer), they say: “Then God endured what he did not will when he begot the Son, the necessity of nature driving him to it against his will.” And if they are granted “he begot willingly”, they infer: “So the begetting of the Son hangs on the Father’s will, which gave him existence the way a maker does.”

But such an answer is utterly senseless. For both the God and Father who begot and “the radiance of his glory” (Hebrews 1:3), the Son, come before willing and not willing and before every concept; and nothing can be conceived between the Son and the one from whom he is. The same holds of “the image of God” (2 Corinthians 4:4). Again, the Son is an existence that neither begins nor ends, prior to willing or not willing. So he begot in the nature that is beyond counsel and mind.

But this premise of theirs too is full of absurdity. For a passion of desire goes before willing; and before not willing, yet making …

Will and Generation §5

5… the force that comes of necessity. And with it comes the notion that the will, and before the will the act of thought, can be conceived as prior to the hypostasis of the Father, a hypostasis that in every respect and at every point has the radiance subsisting together with it.

Besides this, if they believe that all things came into being from the will of the Father through the Son, then the will does not exist beforehand. For it is unworkable and impossible that the Creator should not yet subsist and that afterwards the decision should be taken to create through him.

But this too is full of folly. For if he himself says, “I am, and I have not been changed” (Malachi 3:6), how could the unchangeable nature undergo change with respect to the hypostases, not standing firm in the sameness of the persons but moving and shifting?

And there is this as well. If it is true, as indeed it is true, that “whatever the Father does, the Son also does likewise” (John 5:19), then the Son too will make another son, so that he may do all things just as the Father does. But if he has not made one and does not make one, then he is not a creature, and no fatherly will goes before him.

Let me say something more. If the Saviour says, “This is the will of him who sent me, that everyone who beholds the Son and believes in him should have eternal life” (John 6:40), then it is not the Son who comes from will, but the one who beholds him. For here too the will is found after the Son.

One could thrust away this argument of theirs too, altogether and more quickly, not only by what has been said already but also by what we shall now bring against them. That is, suppose one puts to them in turn a like question: “Does the Father exist because he willed it, or not?” For the very same things they have rehearsed will meet them in return. To “not because he willed it” the answer will be that his subsisting befell him against his purpose, since a necessity of nature turned him, unwilling, to this. To the second, the answer will be that before the willing he was not. For his existence will be traced back to his will, and the will, as their babbling has it, drives him into subsistence as a craftsman makes a thing.

Likewise with another question, which differs from the one before it only in wording: “Is God immortal and good by willing it, or without willing it?” For the same things will be brought against it.

But one will do better to answer them briefly: nothing comes upon the all-perfect God as an addition, nor does anything fall short in him. And just as no will goes before the Father’s existence, his immortality and his goodness, so none goes before the generation either. All such notions are out of tune with right thinking about God.

It is concerning created things that David sings in Psalm 115, “Our God is in heaven; and on the earth he has made all things whatever he willed” (Psalm 115:3), and “You made all things in wisdom” (Psalm 104:24), that is, in the Son, and not in a will. So too in Psalm 73: “You took hold of my right hand; you guided me by your counsel, and you received me with glory” (Psalm 73:23-24). And in Psalm 30: “For wrath is in his anger, and life in his will” (Psalm 30:5), and in the same psalm: “Lord, by your will grant strength to my beauty” (Psalm 30:7). And in Psalm 18: “He will rescue me, because he willed me” (Psalm 18:19).

For in the same way that the Father, being immortal and good, wills to be these things and, willing, is these things, yet does not have his will as their cause (if I may put it so), nor is he these things without willing them, so the will is not the cause of his begetting either.

With us, however, some things we have from the working of God and others from the will that lies in our own power. For it is not by our own will but by God’s that we come to be composed of soul and body and to be rational. How could we, who did not yet exist, will or not will? But by our own choice we are good or bad, and knowledgeable by applying ourselves or ignorant through sloth.

They have come to this head of their argument by taking up, without an accurate understanding, the words “This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased” (Matthew 3:17). Had they understood them, they would have had from those very words a firm anchor of the right faith. But as it is, they claim that “in whom I am well pleased” shows the Son to be a creature.

The Unchanging Essence and the Names of the Trinity §6

6And indeed the whole sense of these words leans toward his becoming man. For when he said, “I am the Son of God,” and they retorted, “You blaspheme” (John 10:36), the Father ratified it for him: “This alone is my true Son.” That is what “this,” and “beloved,” and his being named “Son” with the article make plain. “In this one,” he says, “I was well pleased that through his becoming man salvation should be won for you.”

And even if someone takes “I was well pleased” of his Godhead, their sophism is made void. For not every expression spoken by God, and least of all about God the Word, yields a meaning by the custom of this world. Then again, if he said “in whom I was well pleased” of the Son who already existed, the good pleasure is not found to be the cause of his existence.

To make plainer what such an expression signifies, let us take as our witness the one who sings in Psalm 149, “For the Lord takes pleasure in his people” (Psalm 149:4). The good pleasure did not come about before the people, but after them. For he took pleasure in them, and sent them peace and grace, at the times when they served him rightly. When they did not, the reverse, as he now prophesies: “When he slew them, then they sought him” (Psalm 78:34). And in Psalm 44: “Their arm did not save them, but your right hand, and your arm, and the light of your face, because you took pleasure in them” (Psalm 44:3). Here he names the Son “the right hand and arm of God” and “the light of his face.” And in Psalm 106: “Remember us, Lord, in the good pleasure of your people” (Psalm 106:4).

On their saying, “If the unbegotten God is wholly generative, he did not beget from his essence,” and, “If his essence was changed into an offspring, the essence of God is not unchangeable.”

This too is theirs, a random and faulty argument, set down in words like these: “If the unbegotten God is wholly generative, the one begotten was not begotten from his essence, since his whole essence has the property of begetting, but not of being begotten.”

But let them hear this: “If the light is wholly generative, it does not beget its radiance from its essence but takes it on from outside, since its whole essence has the property of begetting, but not of being begotten.” But if the light does not take on its radiance from outside, but begets it from its whole essence without any interval, then neither did God acquire the Son from outside. He begot him from his whole hypostasis without any interval, since he is without body. That is why he is truly Father.

Again they press on, everywhere pursuing a course contrary to Scripture: “If the essence of God, by being transformed, is called offspring, then his essence is not unchangeable, since it was the change that brought about the Son’s own distinct being.”

But no one grants them leave to say even this. For the Scripture we have mentioned proves such talk foreign to Christians, and it stands against every heretical and most grievous disorder. For if light, by being transformed, becomes radiance, then light is not unchangeable, since the change brings about the radiance’s own distinct being. But if light has begotten radiance without being changed, remaining light itself and having from itself its radiance, complete and grown together with it, then God too remains God without turning, being Father of his own radiance. He did not take it on from outside, but begot it complete from his essence.

On those who prattle that, on the ground of the name “Father,” the essence of the Son himself is different.

Going round and round the same things on the same subjects, and counterfeiting the beauty of the truth at every point, they say this too, without love for God: things whose names differ must also differ in essence. For he says, “The word ‘Father’ does not signify the word ‘Son,’ nor does the name ‘Son’ show the hypostasis of the Father.”

But let them hear, first, this. If the divine hypostases had not been made known by fitting names, what sign could anyone have used to make known the Father himself, and that he has a Son, without saying the name “Father”? Or how, without naming the names “Son” and “Spirit,” could anyone have addressed the Son himself or the Spirit, and shown that the Son has a Father and that the Spirit is the Spirit of God?

And second, this. In the holy Trinity, apart from the one who truly is Father being called Father, and the one who was begotten by nature being called Only-begotten, and the one who is exactly what it has been called, and belongs to the Father, being named Spirit of God, all the other names stand the same: such as God, Lord, holy, righteous, good, light, life. So, on the contrary, in the blessed Trinity alone, those whose names are the …

The Son Without Beginning, from John’s Prologue §7

7… same, their essence too stands as one, so that it follows that like is marked out by like. For to the true and eternal light, in relation to the true and eternal light, and to the truly [...]

“I am God, and there is no other besides me. There is no righteous one and Saviour except me. Turn to me and you will be saved, you who are from the end of the earth. I am God, and there is no other. By myself I swear: righteousness shall surely go out of my mouth, and my words shall not be turned back, that to me every knee shall bow, and every tongue shall swear by God” (Isaiah 45:21-23), which means, will acknowledge God, or “will confess to God.”

So God the Father is not ahead of the Son, not in being without beginning, not in essence, not in glory. They stand on equal terms, except perhaps in the matter of fatherhood. For that these are the words of the only-begotten Son the inspired Paul made clear when he wrote to the Romans, saying: “For we shall all stand before the judgment seat of Christ, as it is written: As I live, says the Lord, every knee shall bow to me, and every tongue shall confess to God” (Romans 14:10-11).

Likewise John the theologian too said in the Gospel: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things came into being through him, and without him not one thing came into being that has come into being. In him was life, and the life was the light of men. And the light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not grasp it” (John 1:1-5). And in the Revelation: “He who is and who was and who is to come, the Lord our God, the Almighty” (Revelation 1:8).

“He who is” signifies the everlasting being of the divine hypostasis, as we have said elsewhere too. For the expression is without limit, and that is why God gave “He who is” as his own name (Exodus 3:14).

“In the beginning was” (John 1:1) sets in plain view, and makes very clear indeed, how absurd and how much to be shunned is the saying “There was when he was not.” For the word “was” is indefinite. In Latin this indefinite form is made up of two words, the “pluperfect,” which is rendered “more than perfect.” So here it requires that he be understood as beyond time altogether, or without beginning. For if anyone were to say that he was not in the beginning, then the beginning, which has no cause, would once not have been. And again, how can time, which did not yet exist, be the measure of the one who made it?

“Was with God” (John 1:1) sets before us the kinship of nature that the Son has with God the Father, and that from the time the self-originate Father was (if it is lawful to say so) the Son who is from him exists together with him. “Was with God” could also be understood in a strong sense: that like God he was without beginning, unoriginate, uncontainable, good, immortal, King of all. For if this were not so with the wisdom that has welled up, it would not be so with the spring that sent the wisdom welling up either. But it is so with both. For John’s aim, and his word handed down from God, is clear, firm, free of idle subtlety, and looks to the divine alone.

“The Word was God” (John 1:1) establishes that the Word has real being, and that he is God such as that God is whose Word he is; and again, that he has no cause.

“All things came into being through him, and without him not one thing came into being” (John 1:3) shows him, as has been said already, to be not only Creator, but also not created. For if not one created thing received its being without him, it is plain to everyone that he himself did not come into being, but was begotten as God is begotten. Indeed, it is impossible that he who gave existence to the universe, and essence and immortality to rational beings, should have come from non-being into being. For nothing created can give essence, or immortality, or make beings rational. It works only on the substance of gold, or silver, or bronze, or iron, or wood, or stone, already brought out of non-being by God, and from it fashions something without soul or reason, a statue perhaps, or something else. But this very thing, to bring forth an essence that was not, or to show it forth as living and rational, is the peculiar and singular property of the one all-powerful and self-complete divine nature alone. And the Father made all things through him as light makes through its own radiance, and as mind through word.

“In him was life” (John 1:4) teaches us further that he is without beginning, being the life of the one supreme nature, and that when nothing at all existed he was the cause of the things that exist. That is why he himself says, “I am the life” (John 14:6), “I am the light” (John 8:12).

He is lavish with testimonies to the one without beginning, saying “was” so many times, so that by repeating such a word he might either open the deaf ears of heretics, or leave no pretext at all for “There was when he was not” at the coming universal and unswerving judgment.

“And the life was the light of men” (John 1:4) teaches the same things once more. For he says: this …

The Son Is Called the Almighty §8

8… unoriginate life is what holds together the originate nature of human beings.

“And the light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not grasp it” (John 1:5) does not tolerate the opinions of the heretics. For it shows, not obscurely but with great sharpness, that whatever time before time, or briefest instant, or age before the ages anyone may suppose, he shines eternally as the inseparable radiance of God, and the darkness of non-existence never grasped it.

“The Almighty” (Revelation 1:8) needs no interpretation at all. For it shows that he holds the kingdom undivided with God the Father and his Holy Spirit, and that he is “God over all” (Romans 9:5). “Who is to come” (Revelation 1:8) shows the Son, who is going to come a second time and “judge the living and the dead” (2 Timothy 4:1).

So John the Baptist too, establishing that “He who is” was said of the Son, makes it plain when he says to the Master, “Are you” (that is, are you that One who is, whom, when you were God in the womb of the Virgin, I myself, being in the belly of the barren woman, recognized and worshipped by my leaping), “or do we look for another?” (Matthew 11:3).

And John, the friend and apostle of the Lord, writes in his first epistle as well: “That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked upon and our hands have handled, concerning the Word of life (and the life was made manifest, and we have seen it, and bear witness, and declare to you the eternal life, which was with the Father and was made manifest to us), that which we have seen and heard we declare to you also, so that you too may have fellowship with us. And our fellowship is with the Father and with his Son Jesus Christ” (1 John 1:1-3).

Mark once more how often he says “was,” and how those who do not confess that he is Son by nature, without beginning together with God, have no fellowship of salvation with the Father or with the Only-begotten. For it is in this faith, handed down to us by the Master of all in the mystery-teaching of the illumination, that we have the fellowship of which Peter wrote, “that you may become partakers of the divine nature” (2 Peter 1:4). For a creature, a thing subject to time, is not divine nature.

Remember besides that he said “our fellowship” is “with the Father and with his Son,” with equal honour, and not “through his Son.”

And Amos too, in his prophecy, likewise names the Son “Almighty,” saying somewhere like this: “He who builds his ascent into heaven, and lays the foundation of his promise upon the earth; who calls the water of the sea and pours it out upon the face of all the earth: the Lord God Almighty is his name” (Amos 9:6). Of this ascent David too sings: “God went up with a shout, the Lord with the sound of a trumpet” (Psalm 47:5).

Both these sayings are about the Son. For the Father neither came down nor went up, as the Apostle explains when he writes: “Now what does ‘he went up’ mean, if not that he also first came down? He who came down is the very one who also went up far above all the heavens, that he might fill all things” (Ephesians 4:9-10). He means: as one who has risen above all things and surpasses them, together with the Father who begot him, since he is unoriginate. For it is plain that he understood it so, from the fact that the spiritual powers, too, since they are measured creatures, are in heaven, but not above the heavens, and do not fill all things.

And Zephaniah likewise proclaims him “Almighty,” saying: “This shall be theirs in return for their insolence, because they reproached and magnified themselves against the Lord Almighty. The Lord will appear against them, and the Lord will utterly destroy all the gods of the nations of the earth, and they will worship him, each from his own place” (Zephaniah 2:10-11).

And Malachi, following on, says in the person of the Master: “For from the rising of the sun to its setting my name has been glorified among the nations, and in every place incense is offered to my name, and a pure sacrifice; for my name is great among the nations, says the Lord Almighty. But you profane it” (Malachi 1:11-12).

For the mention both of his appearing and of his being glorified among the nations shows that the Son is meant, whose name the Jews profane together with those who worship a creature. And the very sequence of the text requires him to be Almighty, since, as image and only-begotten of the Almighty, he must be understood as image of the Almighty in this too.

And Paul writes to the Hebrews: “who, being the radiance of the glory of the Father” (Hebrews 1:3), that is, without beginning together with him and of one essence with him. For so that things beyond comparison might be shown somehow by a comparison, if even so what is beyond the mind might be taken into the mind in some measure, …

The Eternal Nature of the Son §9

9… I will say, comparing the great, the only truly great, with something small: as soon as there is a sun, at that same moment the whole light shines forth with it from the sun’s nature and from the whole disk, undivided, without interval and in equal measure; it works together with the sun and together with it gives warmth to everything that can receive sensation. And the light that is poured out at once and not later, that goes forth with its source and subsists with it, displays in itself the whole quality of the substance that sent it forth.

But if, as those people would have it, “there was when the radiance was not,” where is the hypostasis of the light that sends that radiance out? It must surely slip away together with the radiance. And indeed Daniel too said in prophecy, “And light was with him” (Daniel 2:22), meaning “the Son was with the Father.”

For this above all shows how great the Godhead is, and how far beyond all guessing: the Father begot, without passion, one who is without beginning together with him and shares his rule, and who is at the same time perfect and his exact likeness. Not to beget and be begotten in this way belongs to a creature and not to the Creator, to what is changeable and not to the unchangeable, to what is under judgment and not to the Judge, to what is given life and not to the giver of life, to what is under sin and not to God.

For if he himself, before any other activity at all had taken place, “made the ages” (Hebrews 1:2), which are made up of times, and set a beginning to all things; and if nothing can be conceived before times and ages except the incomprehensible nature, truly the only one, the first of all and the first at work, which alone is without beginning and eternal and stands lower than no other: how can he not be believed to have been begotten without beginning from the Father’s hypostasis, and not from his activity? Where time sets no bounds, there is no earlier and later. What is not under time is without beginning, and what is without beginning is uncreated. Just as there is no time that did not come into being, so there is no creation without time: creation has time as its measure, for time came into being together with it. And fittingly all things are measured from the Maker as coming second, but he himself is measured by nothing, since he is without beginning and God by nature.

The same holds for the Holy Spirit. For Scripture nowhere says “he proceeded,” but “he proceeds” (John 15:26). And how can life itself be given life, or the true light be enlightened? So the divine light and “eternal life” (1 John 5:20) always was, and that is what the truthful and great God calls himself.

There was certainly never a time when the Father did not have “the radiance of glory and the stamp of the hypostasis and the image of goodness and the power and wisdom and righteousness of God” (Hebrews 1:3; Wisdom of Solomon 7:26; 1 Corinthians 1:24; 1 Corinthians 1:30), which Paul testifies that the same Only-begotten is, and then (what it is not fitting even to say) took on any of these later. But if he had them, then the Only-begotten, who is these things, always was. For neither can the one who is these things ever be conceived outside God, nor God without the one who is these things for him. And the Only-begotten is these things not as a state or an aptitude, but in his very being, as was said before.

And if at the beginning of the world’s making the first trees came into being together with their fruit (and there is nothing strange in the fruit springing up together with the root), how could the Father, who lacks no resource, have been so without resource as not to be fruitful with his own Son from the beginning, and the radiance not to shine forth at once from the glory of his hypostasis?

So then, just as his birth below, the birth of his becoming man, cannot be compared with any other birth (for it was from a virgin, without flux and without injury, which our nature does not have), so too his birth above is incomprehensible, and still more so, and differs from every other birth. We must not disbelieve it; nor is it safe for us to search out or explain the manner, since we cannot say how a virgin gave birth and remained a virgin, and we do not even understand our own birth. Even if we knew ours, we would by no means know God’s as well, for it is incomprehensible even to the heavenly powers.

Therefore the prophet says in amazement about the birth below: “And he is a man, and who …”

The Incomprehensible Birth and the One Godhead §10

10… will know him?” (Jeremiah 17:9), meaning “no one.” And about the birth above: “And who will tell of his generation? For his life is taken up from the earth” (Isaiah 53:8). In the most mystical way he called the begetting “generation,” his existence “life,” and his being lifted beyond all measure above the earth and surpassing every mind, “is taken up from the earth.”

For he stands boundlessly higher than any time that one might conceive after circling long in thought, incomparably greater than every quantity, in his substance beyond conceiving, and on every side wholly out of sight, encompassing himself and having nothing of himself outside. Before an incomprehensibility so great the multitude of angels gives way, and so does the whole people of the heavenly ranks. All this they proclaim aloud: David in the eighteenth Psalm, “He made darkness his hiding place, and round about him was his tent” (Psalm 18:11); the Song of Habakkuk, “His excellence covered the heavens” (Habakkuk 3:3); and Matthew, “No one knows the Son except the Father, nor does anyone know the Father except the Son” (Matthew 11:27).

For what is born from creation is begotten through the union of one with another; it is not inseparably one with its begetter, nor does it come forth perfect at once and without passion. With the Godhead it is the reverse. Since creation is of this kind, the Author of all that comes to be is the opposite, and not like his own works, but as the blessed Trinity alone knows. For he would not be incomprehensible if he were comprehended, nor a mystery if he were known, nor divine if he could be contained, nor the Maker of all if he were from time, nor uncompounded and without parts if he were of the order of bodies.

When we hear it said of the Father, “From age to age you are” (Psalm 90:2), and “His truth reaches to the clouds” (Psalm 57:10), we do not set limits to him, but believe that he is eternal; for the age is not his contemporary. In the same way we ought to think of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, for we are speaking of the one nature that rules over all, to which these all-honoured hypostases belong.

The same is sung of the Son: “You are the same, and your years will not fail” (Psalm 102:27; Hebrews 1:12). And if it is no small thing that it is written of the Father, “He who exists before the ages” (Psalm 55:19), no small thing either is what was spoken in prophecy of his Son, that he is “God before the ages” (Psalm 74:12). It is plain that he is beyond conceiving, as will be shown not much later. And just as the Father “has immortality” (1 Timothy 6:16), or rather is himself immortality, so the Son is “eternal life” (1 John 5:20); and that is the same thing.

And just as the Father is called “one God,” so the Son is called Only-begotten, God, Word, and “one Lord Jesus Christ” (1 Corinthians 8:6). And as James writes of him, “There is one lawgiver and judge, who alone is able to save” (James 4:12), so the Spirit is hymned by Paul, writing to the Corinthians and the Ephesians, as “one” and “the same” (1 Corinthians 12:11; Ephesians 4:4), and as only, so that by this very quasi-number, if one may put it so, these blessed hypostases are shown to bear the oneness, that is, the singleness, of the Father’s Godhead. And if “God and Lord” is true of the Father, it is just as free of falsehood of his Son and of the Spirit.

For, as we have recalled in many places, the older covenant, guarding their equal honour, declared: “The Lord said to my Lord” (Psalm 110:1); and “The Lord rained from the Lord” (Genesis 19:24); and “God made man according to the image of God” (Genesis 1:27); and “Who is God except the Lord, and who is God besides our God?” (Psalm 18:31). And in the new covenant John said what has already been quoted; Thomas said, “My Lord and my God” (John 20:28); and Paul, “Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom” (2 Corinthians 3:17); and again, “as from the Lord, the Spirit” (2 Corinthians 3:18); and “May the Lord grant the household of Onesiphorus to find mercy from the Lord” (2 Timothy 1:16; 2 Timothy 1:18). And Job: “The divine Spirit that made me” (Job 33:4), and “the divine Spirit that is still in my nostrils” (Job 27:3).

It is the same thing for Scripture to say “divine” or “God,” as they teach: Paul, writing to the Romans, “his eternal power and Godhead” (Romans 1:20); the Acts, “We ought not to think that the divine is like gold or silver or stone, an image carved by art and human thought” (Acts 17:29); and Peter in his second letter, “that through these you may become sharers of the divine nature” (2 Peter 1:4).

And just as the Father is incomprehensible, so too, according to Paul, the riches of Christ are beyond tracing. For he says, “To me, the very least of all people, this grace was given, to preach among the nations the untraceable riches of Christ” (Ephesians 3:8). And more: “Of his greatness there is no end” (Psalm 145:3), nor “of understanding any number” (Psalm 147:5), as David says, nor “of peace any bound” (Isaiah 9:7), as Isaiah says …

The Unoriginate Hypostases §11

11“And your incorruptible spirit,” he says, “is in all things” (Wisdom of Solomon 12:1), and “The Spirit of the Lord has filled the world” (Wisdom of Solomon 1:7). For no one would be found so dull and slow of mind as not to see, from these unfeigned and pure testimonies, the boundlessness of the Only-begotten and of the all-holy Spirit.

And I say that what the Apostle wrote about both hypostases is of equal weight and in like words: what he says of the Father, “God, who is over all and through all and in all” (Ephesians 4:6), and “The God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who is blessed for ever, knows that I do not lie” (2 Corinthians 11:31); and what he wrote to the Romans of the Son, “who is God over all, blessed for ever. Amen” (Romans 9:5). Besides this there is also “the fullness of him who fills all in all” (Ephesians 1:23).

Again, what is declared of the Father is alike, “that God may be all in all” (1 Corinthians 15:28), and of his Son, “where there is neither Greek nor Jew, barbarian, Scythian, slave, free, but Christ is all in all” (Colossians 3:11); and elsewhere, “that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, of things in heaven and things on earth, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is one Lord” (Philippians 2:10-11).

As for the Spirit, both by what was said of him just now and because all that the Father is must be understood of him too, as his Spirit, except for being Father. For he images God both in this and in all things, as it declares: “By this we know that he is in us, from his Spirit, which he has given us” (1 John 3:24).

And of equal force with what was sung of God the Father, “You alone are Most High over all the earth” (Psalm 83:18), is what was spoken in prophecy of the Son in the eighty-seventh Psalm, “Mother Zion will say: A man, and a man was born in it, and the Most High himself founded her” (Psalm 87:5), and what was said of the Holy Spirit in the Gospel, “You will receive power from on high when the Holy Spirit has come upon you” (Luke 24:49; Acts 1:8).

And just as the Father is great, among other things, because he knows the Son, so the Son too is great because he knows the Father; and likewise the Holy Spirit, for it says, “So too no one knows the things of God except the Spirit of God” (1 Corinthians 2:11). And no different from what Paul wrote to the Hebrews about the Father, “For it was fitting for him, for whom are all things and through whom are all things” (Hebrews 2:10), is what was spoken in prophecy about the Son, “All things were made through him” (John 1:3), and about the Spirit, “By the word of the Lord the heavens were made firm, and by the breath of his mouth all their powers” (Psalm 33:6).

So these glorious hypostases, honoured equally with God the Father, as having received for their portion his divine nature, which is over all, unmixed and beyond compare: how could they be counted among all things under God, as those who vote them creatures would have it?

For just as it is impossible that the Father should not be Father without beginning and in truth (for he did not get this name in time, nor as an added title), so it is impossible that the Son, the Word, and his Spirit should not be without beginning and by nature from his hypostasis. For at once with his being Father (let me be pardoned for putting it so), without any interval the one was begotten and the other proceeded.

So he has not been deprived of being Father of the Only-begotten and of having his Spirit proceeding from him. And because he is Father, he does not differ from the Son and his Spirit either in time or in substance. For if he had begotten later, he would have been changed or altered, which is foreign to the Godhead; and besides, God would be found at some time not called Father, or not being Father, as not yet having begotten.

And the Apostle, setting before the Hebrews how the generation of the Son of God is without beginning and beyond comprehension, writes of Melchizedek: “Without father, without mother, without genealogy, having neither beginning of days nor end of life, made like the Son of God” (Hebrews 7:3).

He had been made like him (in that he was not given a genealogy, as it was the custom to do in the tribes of Israel for those held in honour among them) because he is a type and a kind of outline of the Lord, who above is without mother and without time, and below is without father and in time.

And yet Melchizedek was a notable priest, so that Abraham was blessed by him and gave him tithes of the spoils, as the same Apostle says: “Consider how great this man is, to whom Abraham gave a tenth of everything” (Hebrews 7:4). And again: “And, so to speak, through Abraham even Levi, who receives tithes, has paid tithes” (Hebrews 7:9), that is, through his forefather Abraham. “For he was still,” he says, “in the loins of his father” (Hebrews 7:10): Levi, the descendant of Abraham, from whom the …

In the Beginning Was the Word: The Son Before the Ages and Maker of All §12

12… tithing for the Lord comes, is meant in a general sense: “when Melchizedek met him” (Hebrews 7:10), that is, met Abraham.

What, then, is the aim of their empty talk, and where does its absurdity lie? Consider: all who wish to speak of a beginning for him confess an end as well; and by declaring that he came into being, they also accept the death that follows from coming into being. And by supposing that he came to be from things that are not, or from a substance unlike the divine one, they declare him at once mortal and a stranger to the Godhead he shares with the Father. Even to say this, let alone to believe it, is full of every kind of godlessness.

But what are their supposedly strong arguments against “In the beginning was the Word” (John 1:1)? “The word ‘was’,” he says, “was written of creation too. For Scripture has, ‘In the beginning God made the heaven and the earth; and the earth was invisible and unformed’ (Genesis 1:1-2), and ‘There was a man from Armathaim Sipha’ (1 Samuel 1:1).”

But “In the beginning was” has nothing in common with “In the beginning he made,” any more than the Creator has with the creature. For “was,” in the case of creation, is said and believed only of time, which flows and comes to an end. Creation “was” after it came to be from things that are not. Scripture first said that God made it, and only then added “was,” so that it would not be thought to have come about of itself. But in the case of God the Word, “was” signifies what is beyond all beginning. For “In the beginning,” it says, “was,” and “was God” (John 1:1); and “In the beginning was” drives out “from things that are not.”

That the Son is before the ages and the Maker of the ages, the witnesses testify thus. Paul, writing to the Hebrews: “In many parts and in many ways God spoke of old to the fathers in the prophets; in these last days he has spoken to us in a Son, whom he appointed heir of all things, through whom he also made the ages” (Hebrews 1:1-2). So he inherits what is his own, both as its Maker and as true Son; and he was appointed heir as having become man. And to the Corinthians, in the first letter: “For no one can lay a foundation other than the one that is laid, which is Jesus Christ” (1 Corinthians 3:11); that is, it is impossible to conceive a beginning of the Son. For “in him and through him” (Colossians 1:16) is every beginning.

And David in the seventy-fourth Psalm, singing of the one without beginning: “But God, our King before the ages, worked salvation in the midst of the earth” (Psalm 74:12). He means Golgotha, calling it the most central place and, as it were, the centre of the land under heaven. There the Son worked salvation for us in his becoming man: by his divine foreknowledge before the age, and in deed when he, the impassible one, suffered for us out of goodness, as he knew and willed, and came, so to speak, even to “the heart of the earth” (Matthew 12:40). So Ezekiel too prophesies: “Jerusalem herself, I have set her in the midst of the nations” (Ezekiel 5:5).

And in the hundred and nineteenth Psalm: “For ever, Lord, your word endures in heaven” (Psalm 119:89). And the Master himself, speaking of himself, surely shutting the door on heretics, said: “Truly, truly, I say to you, before” the ages came to be, “I am” (John 8:58).

As for his being established as the Maker of all things, bodiless and bodily, not an assistant or a go-between, and at the same time without beginning: besides the testimonies already set out, David also sings in the hundred and fifteenth Psalm, “Our God in heaven and on earth has done all things whatever he willed” (Psalm 115:3). He did not say “whatever he was assigned.” Who then would deny that he who works by himself, of his own will, and has all things running together at his bare nod without delay, belongs to the self-governing and all-governing substance of the Monad?

And in the hundred and second Psalm: “In the beginning, Lord, you founded the earth, and the heavens are the works of your hands. They will perish, but you will remain; and all of them will grow old like a garment, and like a cloak you will roll them up, and they will be changed. But you are the same, and your years will not fail” (Psalm 102:25-27), meaning, “You are without beginning and without end.”

Paul too writes the same, to the Ephesians, “in God who created all things” (Ephesians 3:9), and to the Colossians, “For in him all things were created, in the heavens and on the earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or principalities or authorities; all things were created through him and for him, and he is before all things, and in him all things hold together” (Colossians 1:16-17). For above him who images God in his very being and is before all things in Godhead no one is set and no one is older, just as below the one who comes after all no one is set and no one is later.

Put another way: if he is before all things, alone from the Alone and in a manner his alone, he was begotten ineffably before every activity and is the Son of the Father in his very being. For it is necessary …

The Son Called Angel and God: Jacob’s Ladder §13

13… he who is before all things, and who governs every nature in a way beyond nature, should be none of all things, and should not be thought a creature by comparison with the things brought into being by him, which have received as their lot a complete difference from him.

Or to put it another way: if someone, attending to the truth and fully assured by the divine oracles, declares him the maker of everything that is made and the one who bears the whole creation, and names him the image of God and Son, how could he also confess him to be a thing made, or less than God who bears all things, or to have someone born before him, unless he were mad?

That he has been called both God and angel, the prophets foretell. Malachi says this: “The Lord whom you seek will come to his temple, and the angel of the covenant whom you desire. Behold, the Lord is coming; and who will endure the day of his entrance? Or who will stand at his appearing?” (Malachi 3:1-2). The beginning of the saying shows the saving dispensation; what follows shows his second coming, fearful and full of love for mankind.

And Isaiah cries out, in the way people who share a joy are wont to announce it to those who have not yet learned what has happened: “A child has been born to us, a son also has been given, and his name is called Angel of great counsel, Wonderful Counsellor, Mighty God, Potentate, Prince of peace” (Isaiah 9:6).

Jacob too calls this God the Word an angel, when, on his way to Mesopotamia, he fell asleep and saw a dream. For it says: “And behold, a ladder set firm on the earth, whose top reached to heaven; and the angels of God were going up and coming down on it. And the Lord stood firm upon it and said: I am the Lord, the God of your fathers, the God of Abraham and the God of Isaac. Do not fear. The land on which you are sleeping I will give to you and to your seed. And I will be with you and guard you on every way by which you go, and I will bring you back in safety to your father’s house. And your seed will spread out to the south and the west, to the north and the east” (Genesis 28:12-15).

Through the ladder the cross was foretold, by which the faithful go up to the heavenly dwellings; and the God who stood firm on the ladder is himself the one who of his own will was nailed to the cross for us.

And after other things: “Jacob vowed,” it says: “If the Lord God is with me and guards me on the way by which I go, and gives me bread to eat and a garment to put on, and brings me back in safety to my father’s house, then the Lord shall be my God; and this stone, which I have set up as a pillar, shall be to me a house of God; and of all that you give me I will give you a tenth” (Genesis 28:20-22).

Then, when he had prospered with Laban, at the time the flocks conceived (Genesis 31:10) he again saw in a vision the God who had appeared to him earlier, and he told it like this: “The angel of God said to me in my sleep: ‘Jacob, lift up your eyes and see the rams and the he-goats mounting the sheep and the she-goats; for I know all that Laban will do to you. I am the God who appeared to you on the way by which you were coming, where you set up a pillar to me and vowed a vow to me there’” (Genesis 31:11-13).

And in Egypt too the same Jacob asks this angel and “great God” for his blessing on the sons of Joseph, saying: “The God whom my fathers Abraham and Isaac pleased, the God who has fed me from my youth to this day, the angel who rescues me from all my evils” (Genesis 48:15-16).

On those who say that “the Father is incomparable and greater than the Son,” that “image is one thing and God another,” and that “man too was written to be the image and glory of God” (1 Corinthians 11:7); and on the testimony that the Father differs from the Son in nothing.

They assign incomparability and being greater to the Father because he is unbegotten, and unlikeness to the Son because he is begotten; once again they drag what concerns the most ineffable Godhead down to the conditions of our own nature and the …

In No Respect Is the Father Greater than the Son §14

14… intelligible realities, supposing that they are made like the flux of matter. For the things above the heavens all surpass every mind and every thought, while earthly things are lowly, and come to be and pass away in time.

But above all, he was born without beginning, co-existing and co-working with his own true Father, as light with the disc of the sun. And he has the witness of the Scriptures that he is God, Lord, holy, Creator, incorruptible, life, light, and everything that the Father is. And he ought rather to be granted likeness and equality from the many than unlikeness from the one.

And how did Adam and Eve, who were not begotten and had no father, come to be equal in nature to us who are descended from them? Or what comparison at all did they make of what they call ‘unlike’? Or by what measuring did they settle on ‘better and greater’, when Scripture neither divides by nature the holy, beginningless, one and undivided Trinity, nor marks off within it a first and a later? Two things are plain: that what is greater is not necessarily of another substance, and that comparatives, as a rule, are used of things of the same substance, not of things of different substance. Nor could they say anything to the point even by guesswork, since they cannot do so even about ‘incomparable and greater’.

It is not by size or any bulk. For God the Word is without size or breadth, and stands apart from all magnitude, composition and shape, as do the Father and his Holy Spirit; he himself is contained by nothing, but contains all things. For he is also the beginning of all magnitudes, as their maker. Where indeed is there size in the highest and superior hypostases, which are beyond even the incorporeal?

Nor is it in respect of being without beginning. For he co-exists with the Father as “the radiance of his glory” (Hebrews 1:3), and has no God before him. For indeed it says: “In the beginning was the Word” (John 1:1). And God, the Maker, is not measured by time alongside a thing made. For necessity demands of them, a thing perilous even to think, that they posit a time before the God and Father who is without beginning and beyond comprehension, and so make the comparison. People are accustomed to call ‘greater’ those who were born earlier in time, as when Isaac ordains: “The greater shall serve the lesser” (Genesis 25:23).

Nor is it as cause: for he is not his cause. For the only-begotten Son too has been shown to be without beginning; otherwise the Father would be greater than him in the same way as he is greater than us, which be it far from us to say or to hear.

Nor is it in substance and likeness. For he is from him “as the Only-begotten from the Father, full of grace and truth” (John 1:14), and as “the stamp of his hypostasis” (Hebrews 1:3), a stamp in every respect, and as “the image of God” (2 Corinthians 4:4; Colossians 1:15), of which it is said that “he who has seen it has seen the Father” (John 14:9). “For in him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead” (Colossians 2:9). And the words “Let us make man after our image and likeness” (Genesis 1:26) are also drawn in as witness to this.

Nor is it by a heightening of quality, since the divine and ineffable hypostases are not qualities. Quality is found in bodies, but they are incorporeal and intelligible. Indeed, it cannot even be thought of them that there is something more beautiful than the beautiful and better than the more beautiful, in the manner of Paul’s saying on another matter: “And now these three remain: faith, hope, love; but the greater of these is love” (1 Corinthians 13:13). For he assigned ‘greater’ to love because of its intensity toward virtue: having loved, he says, we believe, and having believed we hope to reign with Christ.

For if “one God” (1 Corinthians 8:6) is true, and “that you may become partakers of the divine nature” (2 Peter 1:4), not ‘of natures’, then it has been shown that the good, taken absolutely, is also one: I mean the Godhead.

Nor is it in respect of equality, because it is written that the Son is great and “God over all” (Romans 9:5), “making himself equal to the Father” (John 5:18), and “swearing by himself, since he has no one greater” (Hebrews 6:13).

Nor is it in power. For it is written: “Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God” (1 Corinthians 1:24), and “Whatever the Father does, the Son also does likewise” (John 5:19). Nor is it in glory or any rank. “For if they had known,” it says, “they would not have crucified the Lord of glory” (1 Corinthians 2:8). And it is the Father’s will, according to John, “that all should honour the Son just as they honour the Father” (John 5:23).

In what respect, then, does ‘greater’ and ‘unlike’ still hold? As has been shown, in none. And so the Apostle, checking the impious suppositions of heretics about the only-begotten Son and God, and proclaiming his identity of nature with his Father and, moreover, that he is equally without beginning, wrote, as was said above, “who, being the radiance of the glory of the Father,” and went on: “and the stamp of his hypostasis” (Hebrews 1:3).

And …

The Son, the Natural Image of the Father §15

15… again he wrote to the Colossians and to the Hebrews: “who is the image of the invisible God” (Colossians 1:15). And in the Gospel according to John, the Son, showing that his own substance has been sealed with the Father’s stamp, said: “For on him the Father, God, has set his seal” (John 6:27).

The seal, plainly, subsists together with the archetype and bears the same impress, and in itself shows perfectly and truly the oneness of nature of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit. For the seal, like the stamp, signifies what is like and genuine. Otherwise it would be time to say that the Father too is not ungenerated and incomparable, if he is imaged and stamped by something generated and unlike.

These divine oracles, which need no interpreter, they did not rightly understand. Twisting them, and fighting the words of God with human notions, they assert: “God is one thing and the image of God another, as a man is one thing and the image of a man another.” And in a way they liken the living and active God the Word to a motionless image. But he is the image of the Father in substance and in every respect, most exact and without beginning: not by shape and figure, like a statue moulded or carved, without breath and unable to move itself, nor by appearance and colour, like the image made by art, imitative and voiceless. For these show forth the prototype neither by nature nor indeed in all its other features.

A son of a man is indeed an image of the substance of his own father; but he may differ in age, or appearance, or disposition, or power, or rank, or in a combination of these, or in something else. But God the Word, without variation and with exactness in every respect, images the simple, uncompounded and unvaried Godhead of the Father, by nature and without beginning.

For it is not even permitted to think that he is the image of God in one respect and differs from him in another. Nor indeed can there be an image of the ‘incomparable’; nor can the true, the archetypal, the greater, the self-determining and the incomparable appear through what is unlike, or smaller, or under another’s authority; nor again can the natural form of the Creator be perceived through a creature. For no nature shows another nature in itself.

But the Father too turns out to be without hypostasis, when heretics will not grant that he has the stamp of his hypostasis. Nor does the invisible, uncompounded God, who has no figure, have an image of the imitative kind they present. And the words that follow plainly undo their views, for they run: “He did not count being equal to God a thing to be seized” (Philippians 2:6).

Moses too explains a natural image, in these words: “Adam begot Seth according to his form” (Genesis 5:3). Now Seth was of necessity not of a different substance from Adam; and yet Moses gave the name ‘form’ to this image and likeness of substance.

“But of man too,” he says, “it is written that he is ‘the image and glory of God’” (1 Corinthians 11:7). But nowhere, you people, is man or any other thing made written to be “the radiance of the glory of God and the stamp of his hypostasis” (Hebrews 1:3). It is one thing for man to be the image of God, that is, as the thing crafted is the image of its craftsman, as a stool is of the carpenter (for Solomon says: “By analogy from created things their Maker is beheld”); and it is another thing to be, in sameness of form, identity of substance and equal beginninglessness, the radiance of glory and the stamp of the hypostasis, having its own subsistence and wholly true.

For he says: “He who has seen me has seen the Father” (John 14:9). But he who has seen a man has not seen God, as one who has looked at the stool has not seen the carpenter. Indeed, it is necessary that the image of the only invisible God be alone invisible, and not man, who is visible and made after the image.

So the Son is neither like another, for it is written: “Who will be likened to the Lord among the sons of God?” (Psalm 89:6); nor unlike his own Father: “For I and the Father,” he says, “are one” (John 10:30). Those who apply to him the notion of a created image become like Nebuchadnezzar, who ordained that a manufactured, lifeless image be worshipped (Daniel 3:1-6).

God justly cast Adam out of paradise for his disobedience (Genesis 3:23-24); but the Son brought in the thief (Luke 23:43), and with him Adam and the whole common race, since he is altogether equal in Godhead, goodness and lordship to him who cast Adam out.

Where is it written that “the Father is incomparable” with his own Only-begotten, or that his Son, the Maker and Judge of all, is a “creature” in his divine nature, infinite and exalted above all things? Or at all that once “he was not”? Or where did the Father say expressly, “I created for myself a Son”? Or the Son: …

The Devil, Not the Son or the Spirit, Is the First Creature §16

16… “I was created by the Father”? That is dreadful to hear, let alone to say, and something to flee from. Nowhere at all, then, are these things found in the divine and spiritual Scripture. On the contrary, all the sayings of the Only-begotten about his Godhead are those of one who compares himself with the Father, unites himself to him and declares himself equal in honour.

Nor has he ever been called ‘child’ or ‘little child’ or ‘offspring’ with respect to his generation above, which is infinite and which nothing whatever can describe, so that no one should imagine anything small, or anything that lends colour to their sophistical blasphemies already mentioned. He is called ‘Son’, rather, because he is perfect, because he was begotten without beginning, and because his nature does not vary from the Father’s.

All the things that some think small with respect to the Godhead, including “The Father who sent me is greater than I” (John 14:28), were uttered in the sacred books because of his loving and ineffable becoming man, which took place for our sake and on our behalf. Because of it, too, it is written that he was made lower than the angels, as the Apostle writes: “But we see Jesus, made a little lower than the angels because of the suffering of death” (Hebrews 2:9).

I think, then, and I am not altogether mistaken, that it was of the Father and himself that he spoke, showing the goodness and the oneness of substance of both: “Either make the tree good and its fruit good, or make the tree rotten and its fruit rotten; for by the fruit,” he says, “the tree is known” (Matthew 12:33).

Some, fighting against God, dare to say that the Son, and with him the Holy Spirit, is the first creature, and Macedonius says this of the Spirit alone. May the holy and consubstantial Trinity turn upon them the weight of our having to mention such mad and condemned words. For our part, we shall show from the divine Scriptures we set out that the first creature of God came to be in this way. The first creature, lifted up, was hurled down from the heavens like lightning, as he who created it well, and later justly hurled it down, beheld it in the Gospel (Luke 10:18).

And he speaks thus in Job: “But behold, a beast beside you that eats grass like oxen. Behold, its strength is in its loins, and its power on the navel of its belly. It set up its tail like a cypress, and its sinews are woven together; its ribs are bronze, and its back is cast iron. This is the beginning of the Lord’s handiwork, made to be mocked by the angels” (Job 40:15-19).

So it says that the devil is the first creature, and that he made himself a thing to be mocked by the holy angels because of the unholiness and malice of his choice. The Son, who fashioned even him, would not have been created after him; nor indeed would the Spirit of God.

On the holy Trinity: that because of the sameness of substance the same names are used alike of the hypostases, except fatherhood, sonship and the procession of the Spirit, for this is proper to each hypostasis on its own; that sometimes the Father, sometimes the Son, sometimes the Spirit is placed first; and that both the threeness and the oneness are shown in Scripture.

From all that has been said, then, it is established that their teachings are in every way foreign to the truth. For it is the work of sophistry to invent quibbles, but of wisdom to search the Scriptures with reverence and with the acceptance that befits them.

It remains necessary, then, to pass over their implausible rubbish and wrangling, and, having washed out brackish ears, as the saying goes, with the fresh, intelligible water of the Holy Spirit, to show that the Scriptures, because of the sameness of the Godhead, sometimes name one of the divine hypostases and sometimes the three, and assign the good to each of them alike. So when Moses says, “Hear, Israel: the Lord your God is one Lord” (Deuteronomy 6:4), by saying “one” he showed the one Godhead, and by “Lord”, then “God”, and again “Lord”, he signified the Trinity, from whom every good in the world and above the world has come, and will come, to mankind.

And again: “God said: Let there be a firmament; and God made the firmament; and God saw that it was good” (Genesis 1:6-8). It should be noted that he names three hypostases and calls each one God, and shows the concord and co-working of the one who spoke, the one who made and the one who praised.

And again: “God commands Moses,” it says, “saying: Speak to Aaron and to his sons: Thus you shall bless Israel …” (Numbers 6:22-23)

The Trinity Foreshadowed in the Old Testament §17

17… “May the Lord bless you and keep you; may the Lord make his face shine upon you and have mercy on you; may the Lord lift up his face upon you and give you peace” (Numbers 6:24-26). To show three Persons, he did not say once, “May the Lord bless you and shine upon you and give you peace”; he named “Lord” three times.

So it is too when Haggai and Isaiah prophesy. Haggai brings a voice given by God, spoken in the person of the Father, which runs thus: “Be strong, Zerubbabel, for I am with you; and my good word and my Spirit are in your midst” (Haggai 2:4-5). Isaiah says that the sending came, equal in honour, from hypostases equal in honour and complete in themselves; in one brief saying he points out their whole communion, and he cries: “And now the Lord, the Lord has sent me, and his Spirit” (Isaiah 48:16). It was not idly that he named the Lord twice, “Lord, Lord”, and then “his Spirit”: he meant to show both the hypostases and the one Godhead and will.

And David too: for he also comes to the aid of this article of faith, fills everything with song, and shows in these words where he stood in faith. In Psalm 18: “Who is God but the Lord, and who is God besides our God? It is God who girds me with power” (Psalm 18:31-32). In Psalm 59: “You, O God, are my helper. My God, his mercy will go before me. My God will show me among my enemies” (Psalm 59:9-10). In Psalm 96: “Sing to the Lord a new song; sing to the Lord, all the earth; sing to the Lord, bless his name” (Psalm 96:1-2). By naming “Lord” or “God” three times he pointed to the Trinity.

Hannah too, praying in the Book of Kingdoms, called upon the Trinity when she said, “Adonai, Lord, Eloi Sabaoth” (1 Samuel 1:11). In the Hebrew tongue “Adonai” means “Lord”; then she said “Lord” again in Greek; and a third time, in Hebrew, she said “Eloi Sabaoth”, that is, “O God of hosts”, or “of powers”.

And now Elijah the Tishbite too, in the third book of the history of the Kingdoms, prayed that the son of the widow of Sidon, who was dead, might come back to life; he breathed into him three times and so raised him up (1 Kings 17:21). By this he all but declared that he himself had called upon the life-giving Trinity in his prayer, and he taught us as well to believe and to glorify in no other way. And when he urged the water-carriers, “Do it a second time” and “Do it a third time” (1 Kings 18:34), he was showing that the three all-praised hypostases act everywhere and in all things with equal power and equal honour.

If you wish, I will make the matter in hand known to you once more, from a divine voice as well. In the book of Genesis, at the building of the tower, God the Father disclosed the blessed hypostases when he said to his own Son and to his Holy Spirit: “Come, let us go down and confuse their tongues there, so that each may not understand the voice of his neighbour” (Genesis 11:7).

Moses too, as I think, showing the equality of the Trinity, set forth one vine on three stocks (Genesis 40:10), and nowhere said that one stock ran deeper than another. So no one should suppose that this hypostasis comes before that one; rather, we should all believe that the three are joined together in one Godhead.

That is why the God-inspired Scripture forbade making steps up to the altar (Exodus 20:26), the altar at which the Trinity is glorified: so that people should not, as though on steps, define the divine hypostases as standing in some order of descent.

In short, the Old Testament, bearing a type of the New, speaks in mysteries and with the greatest forethought. In many places it hints rather than declaring everything in one place; and yet it declares, more than it hints, the mystery that was revealed later. It does this so that it may neither strike the uninitiated, those not yet steady or able to receive the vision of God, with a sudden onslaught, nor yet leave them wholly deprived. The first would have shown want of skill, the second want of humanity. And often, too, the things it perhaps expressed to us here in a way hard to grasp …

The Trinity in the New Testament and the Goodness of the Son §18

18… it has supplied the solution through another Scripture. The New Testament, however, no longer speaks as in a shadow and behind a veil, but clearly and in so many words, as these witnesses show.

Paul writes to the Romans, “Since God is one” (Romans 3:30), and to the Galatians and the Corinthians, “God is one” (Galatians 3:20). And again to the Corinthians, in the second letter: “The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ and the love of God and the communion of the Holy Spirit be with you all” (2 Corinthians 13:14). Here, because the Godhead is the same, he mentioned the Son first, then the Father, and then his Holy Spirit. And he spoke of the communion of the Holy Spirit with the Father and the Son: a communion in the one Godhead, glory and kingdom. For what other communion could there be in God?

To the Ephesians he writes: “One Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all” (Ephesians 4:5-6). Then to the same readers: “For this reason I bend my knees to the God and Father, from whom every family in the heavens and on earth is named, that he may grant you, according to the riches of his glory, to be strengthened with power through his Spirit in the inner man, so that Christ may dwell in the hearts through faith” (Ephesians 3:14-17). Here again, in the same way, because the hypostases are equal in honour, he mentioned the Spirit first after the Father, and then the Son.

And again to the Corinthians: “I urge you, brothers, through our Lord Jesus Christ and through the love of the Spirit, to strive together with me in your prayers to God for me” (Romans 15:30).

And to the Hebrews: “For if the word spoken through angels proved firm, and every transgression and disobedience received a just recompense, how shall we escape if we neglect so great a salvation? It began to be spoken through the Lord, and it was confirmed to us by those who heard him, while God bore witness with them by signs and wonders and various mighty works, and by distributions of the Holy Spirit according to his will” (Hebrews 2:2-4). By “the Lord”, then, the Son is made known; by “God”, the Father; and then also the Holy Spirit, free in his own will and almighty.

The Son too showed the one Godhead by saying, “Why do you call me good? No one is good but one, God” (Mark 10:18); and he showed the three hypostases, equal in honour and equal in power, by his teaching on baptism (Matthew 28:19). To the lawyer who questioned him to test him he did not say, “Do not call me good,” but, “Why do you call me good?” So he showed that he himself is good, equally with the Father; that his own goodness shines out from the Father’s goodness; and that he is good, begotten of the Good.

“For if,” he says, “you know me to be good, and are not tying the word to ‘teacher’ as in ‘Well done, good servant’ (Matthew 25:21), and ‘The good man brings out good from the good treasure of his heart’ (Luke 6:45), and ‘Samuel was good with God and with men’ (1 Samuel 2:26), and ‘Saul, son of Kish, of the tribe of Benjamin, was good, taller than all Israel from the shoulders upward’ (1 Samuel 9:1-2), and ‘Good is the living dog, above the lion that is dead’ (Ecclesiastes 9:4), then take nothing away from the primal Good. Acknowledge me as God: not other than the Father in Godhead, but in hypostasis.”

For the Godhead of the two is one; otherwise the first Good would no longer be found to be one. “For you have read somewhere,” he says, “that ‘it is good for you to trust in the Lord rather than to trust in man’ (Psalm 118:8), and ‘to cling to God is good’ (Psalm 73:28); and I have always urged you to follow me as good and to walk behind me.” That is why he did not say, “No one is good but one, the Father,” but, “No one is good but one, God,” just as he says somewhere else, “Why do you call me ‘Lord, Lord,’ and do not do my words?” (Luke 6:46).

For creation, he says, has its goodness by participation. It imitates as far as it can, if one may say so, the innate and perfect goodness of God, and is preserved by it. The very existence of the good in creation is its sharing in God’s goodness, as it clings to him by obedience and by love for him. For it is written, “Those who remove themselves far from you will perish” (Psalm 73:27), and, “God is far from the ungodly” (Proverbs 15:29), and, “Salvation is far from sinners” (Psalm 119:155). Plainly this distance is one of relation and disposition, caused by opposition to the good and slowness toward virtue, and not one of place.

That he too is good, since by nature he is one with the good Father, he himself says in Matthew: “Or is your eye evil because I am good?” (Matthew 20:15); and again: “Mary has chosen the good portion, which shall not be taken away from her” (Luke 10:42). And he said “the good portion” …

How Scripture Names the Three, Together and Apart §19

19… himself. And they join in proclaiming it, by the Spirit: men unseen, yet men who kept very close company with the divine Spirit. Among the others who go along with them are these. The sacred psalmist, in Psalm 118: “Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good” (Psalm 118:1); and in the same psalm: “Let all who fear the Lord now say that he is good” (Psalm 118:4). Jeremiah in his lament: “The Lord is good to those who wait for him, to the soul that seeks him” (Lamentations 3:25). And Isaiah: “The Lord is a good judge to the house of Israel” (Isaiah 63:7).

That the Holy Spirit of God is also good, David, whom I have mentioned, sings in a psalm: “Your good Spirit will lead me in a level land” (Psalm 143:10). Further: if eternal life is good, and the words of the Son are good (for he said, “I am the life” (John 14:6), and again, “The words that I have spoken to you are spirit and are life” (John 6:63)); and if “the sanctification of the Holy Spirit” is good, and his working in illumination (for he is named with them as a fellow worker), and also the distribution of the heavenly gifts; then the Son and the Holy Spirit are certainly good.

We were not taught by hearing alone. We have also seen, as far as that is possible, what is proper to each hypostasis of the august and consubstantial Trinity: the Father saying from heaven, “This is my beloved Son” (Matthew 3:17); his Only-begotten being baptized on earth; and his one and only Holy Spirit coming down in the form of a dove and remaining upon the Only-begotten God and Son himself (John 1:32). A treasure of David in Psalm 85 confirms this too: that he who took flesh from our earthly nature was attested by God the Father as Son. The saying is known to all; it runs: “Truth has sprung up from the earth, and righteousness has looked down from heaven” (Psalm 85:11).

In the same way, because there is no difference of Godhead in the awesome and spotless Trinity, the oracles sometimes show the Father with the Son. So David says, “The Lord said to my Lord, ‘Sit at my right hand’” (Psalm 110:1), and Paul, “Grace to you and peace from God the Father and the Lord Jesus Christ” (Romans 1:7). Sometimes they join the Father with the Holy Spirit, as when Haggai prophesies, “For I am with you, says the Lord Almighty, and my Spirit stands in your midst” (Haggai 2:4-5); and again, “Not by great power nor by strength, but by my Spirit, said the Lord Almighty” (Zechariah 4:6).

We must linger over this text. For since the heterodox sometimes say, when the Spirit is mentioned with the Father, that some power without a hypostasis of its own is meant, the text before us stands guarded against them. Isaiah too: “And now the Lord has sent me, and his Spirit” (Isaiah 48:16). And again: “There the deer met and showed one another their faces. They passed by in number, and not one of them perished; one did not seek the other, because the Lord commanded them, and his Spirit gathered them together” (Isaiah 34:15-16). And Paul to the Corinthians: “Do you not know that you are God’s temple, and the Spirit of God dwells in you?” (1 Corinthians 3:16); and again, “The love of God has been poured out in your hearts through the Holy Spirit” (Romans 5:5); and again, “But to us God has revealed it through his Spirit” (1 Corinthians 2:10).

At other times they name the Son alone, as when Isaiah prophesies, “And now, Lord, you are our Father; and we are clay, all of us the work of your hands” (Isaiah 64:8); and Paul to the Galatians: “For as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ” (Galatians 3:27).

At other times they proclaim the Only-begotten together with the Holy Spirit. So Paul writes to the Corinthians, “But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ and in the Spirit of our God” (1 Corinthians 6:11); and to the Romans, “I speak the truth in Christ, I am not lying, my conscience bearing me witness in the Holy Spirit” (Romans 9:1); and again, “For if the one who comes preaches another Jesus, whom we did not preach, or you receive a different spirit, which you did not receive” (2 Corinthians 11:4).

And at other times Scripture mentions the Holy Spirit alone, as when Isaiah prophesies, “They disobeyed and provoked the Holy Spirit” (Isaiah 63:10), and again, “A Spirit came down from the Lord and guided them” (Isaiah 63:14); and Paul writes to the Corinthians, “But the fleshly man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God” (1 Corinthians 2:14). So too Stephen says in the Acts, “You resist the Holy Spirit” (Acts 7:51); and again, “We are witnesses of these words, and so is the Holy Spirit” (Acts 5:32), just as we commonly say, “Only we are here, and God.”

Scripture Names the Three in Any Order §20

20And in John the Saviour too mentions the divine Spirit alone, saying, “But when he comes, the Spirit of truth, he will guide you into all the truth” (John 16:13). The Acts likewise confirm this: “While Peter was pondering the word, the Holy Spirit said to him, ‘Rise, go down, and go with them without any hesitation, for I have sent them’” (Acts 10:19-20). And again: “Thus says the Holy Spirit: ‘Set apart for me Paul and Barnabas for the work to which I have called them’” (Acts 13:2). And again the Holy Spirit said to Peter, “Rise and go,” to the house of Cornelius.

And once more the apostolic Acts, with a certain elegance, give room to dwell on a statement of this kind. They contain: “Then Paul, filled with the Holy Spirit, said to him” (Acts 13:9-10), and further: “For Peter, filled with the Holy Spirit, said to the people” (Acts 4:8).

In the same way, the equal weight and equal power of the all-honoured hypostases is signified in this too: that the Master, God the Word, by his all-praised saying about baptism, which I mentioned before (Matthew 28:19), kept for himself and for the Holy Spirit their equality of honour with the Father. Because of it the sacred books sometimes mention the Father first and then the Son or the Holy Spirit, and sometimes mention the Son first, since the nature is undivided and there is no difference in the way the three are spoken of as God.

So Job, plainly showing the Trinity, says: “As the Lord lives, who has judged me thus, and the Almighty, who has made my soul bitter: truly, while my breath is still in me, and the divine Spirit that remains to me in my nostrils” (Job 27:2-3). He means the Holy Spirit, who gives him life and still makes him breathe.

So too when Paul writes to the Thessalonians the second time: “Now our Lord Jesus Christ himself, and God and Father, will comfort your hearts” (2 Thessalonians 2:16-17); and to the Galatians: “Paul, an apostle, not from man nor through man, but through Jesus Christ and God the Father” (Galatians 1:1); and to the Corinthians, as was said before: “The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ and the love of God and Father and the communion of the Holy Spirit” (2 Corinthians 13:14). And the Saviour says, “I and the Father will come, and we will make our dwelling with him” (John 14:23).

Sometimes they name the Holy Spirit first, and afterwards the Father or the Son, as when David sings, “Where shall I go from your Spirit, and from your face where shall I flee?” (Psalm 139:7). And Job, showing his grateful mind, says, “It is the divine Spirit that made me, and the breath of the Almighty that teaches me” (Job 33:4). And so Paul writes in the first letter to the Corinthians: “There are varieties of gifts, but the same Spirit; and there are varieties of ministries, but the same Lord; and there are varieties of workings, but the same God who works all things in all” (1 Corinthians 12:4-6).

Sometimes they speak of two hypostases by the same name, as when Zechariah says, “The Lord said to the devil, ‘The Lord will rebuke you, devil’” (Zechariah 3:2). This was also shown above at greater length.

That what is said at one time of the Father is said at another of the Son or of the Holy Spirit, because the Trinity exists in one Godhead.

The revealers of holy things, then, knowing the glorious Trinity in one Godhead, and that what is said of it as God is shared in common, set forth at other times, some of them, about the Son or the Holy Spirit what others have just said about the Father. They do not contradict themselves. They do it so that we too may know this very point, the crucial thing in right faith: that whichever hypostasis we mention, we have by all means taken up the other with it in faith, since it cannot be separated.

The truthful interpreters of God must speak truly; and those who teach the simple and real truth of God, that is, his goodness, must be clean of every opinion that denies the truth. For they say it is not lawful for the impure to touch the pure; and these men were pure, and strangers to all false belief.

We shall find this at once in the vision of God that Isaiah saw. But why should I not first recall that whole passage as it stands? He says, then (Isaiah 6:1-3): “I saw the Lord Sabaoth sitting on a throne high and lifted up, and the house was full of his glory. And seraphim stood around him; six wings to the one and six wings to the other; with two wings they covered their faces, with two their feet, and with two they flew. And they cried one to the other, ‘Holy, holy …

Isaiah’s Vision and Scriptural Witnesses §21

21… holy, Lord Sabaoth; heaven and all the earth are full of his glory” (Isaiah 6:3).

And after other things he says: “He said to me: Say to the people: Hearing you will hear and will not understand, and seeing you will see and will not perceive. For the heart of this people has grown thick, and with their ears they have heard heavily, and they have shut their eyes, lest they should see with their eyes and hear with their ears and understand with their heart and turn, and I would heal them” (Isaiah 6:9-10). And in between, among other things, he adds: “And I saw with my eyes the King, the Lord Sabaoth. And one of the seraphim was sent to me” (Isaiah 6:5-6), and what follows.

Now this Isaiah knows that the Lord Sabaoth and King who was seen is God the Father himself. But Paul, in the book of the Acts of the Apostles, declared that it is the Holy Spirit, speaking out in these words: “The Holy Spirit spoke well to your fathers through Isaiah the prophet, saying: Go to this people and say to it: Hearing you will hear and will not understand” (Acts 28:25-26), and the rest, as set out above.

And John in his Gospel determined that it is the Son of God. For he said: “Though Jesus had done so many signs, they could not believe, because Isaiah said: He has blinded their eyes and hardened their heart, so that they should not see with their eyes and understand with their heart and turn, and I would heal them” (John 12:37-40). And at once he adds: “These things Isaiah said when he saw his glory” (John 12:41), that is, the glory of the Son of God. So much, then, more or less, on these matters.

But hear also other texts of the same force. David, in the ninety-fifth Psalm, sang on the lyre in the person of God the Father in these words: “Your fathers tested me and saw my works for forty years. Therefore I was angered with this generation and said: They always go astray in their heart; and they did not know my ways. So I swore in my anger: They shall not enter into my rest” (Psalm 95:9-11).

Paul, writing to the Hebrews from the same psalm, determines that it comes from the Holy Spirit, in this way: “As the Holy Spirit says,” he writes, “Today, if you hear my voice, do not harden your hearts as in the provocation, on the day of testing, where your fathers tested me and saw my works for forty years” (Hebrews 3:7-9). And Stephen, in the Acts of the Apostles, putting the Jews to shame from the same scripture, said: “Stiff-necked and uncircumcised in heart and ears, you always resist the Holy Spirit; as your fathers did, so do you” (Acts 7:51).

Likewise Moses, for his part, says that it was the Lord who led the Hebrews out of Egypt. In Deuteronomy he says: “For the Lord alone led them, and …” (Deuteronomy 32:12)

One Guide and One Inheritance: Father, Son and Spirit §22

22… there was no foreign god with them” (Deuteronomy 32:12). And Jeremiah likewise: “And you did not say,” he says, “Where is the Lord who brought you up out of the land of Egypt, who guided you in the wilderness?” (Jeremiah 2:6).

But Isaiah says that it was the Holy Spirit who guided them: “For he led them through the deep,” he says, “like a horse through the desert, and they did not grow weary; and like cattle through a plain, the Spirit came down from the Lord and guided them” (Isaiah 63:13-14).

And Paul teaches that Christ became their guide: “For they drank,” he says, “from a spiritual rock that followed them, and the rock was Christ” (1 Corinthians 10:4). In harmony with him Jude too writes in his catholic letter: “For the Lord Jesus, having once saved a people out of Egypt, afterward destroyed those who did not believe in him” (Jude 1:5).

Here, then, the argument of those who call the venerable Son and the divine Spirit a creature is overthrown twice over: first, because the words that signify the one infinite nature have been spoken in prophecy of each hypostasis; and second, because beside them stands the line “there was no foreign god with them,” that is, none of another substance.

In the same way Moses says: “The Levites shall have no portion or lot in the land; the Lord himself is their portion” (Deuteronomy 18:1-2; Numbers 18:20). And Jeremiah: “He who formed all things,” he says, “is himself the inheritance of Jacob; the Lord is his name” (Jeremiah 10:16). And David in the sixteenth Psalm: “The Lord is the portion of my inheritance and of my cup” (Psalm 16:5).

But Paul, writing to the Ephesians, says that the Holy Spirit is the inheritance: “In whom,” he says, “having believed, we were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise, who is the pledge of our inheritance” (Ephesians 1:13-14). Likewise Paul writes to the Corinthians: “Now there are varieties of gifts, but the same Spirit; and there are varieties of ministries, and the same Lord; and there are varieties of workings, but it is the same God who works all things in all” (1 Corinthians 12:4-6).

And to show the identity of the Godhead, he not only names the Spirit first here, then the Son, and only then the Father; but he who has just said that God works all things adds a little later: “But all these things are worked by one and the same Spirit, who distributes to each one individually as he wills” (1 Corinthians 12:11). So he presents the Spirit clearly and in so many words as God, of one substance with the Father and the Son, and at the same time as free and sovereign in his own right.

We may also hear God the Father, who has said in Isaiah: …

Equal Glory, and the Trinity Dwelling in the Faithful §23

23… “And I will not give my glory to another” (Isaiah 42:8); while John says, “that all may honour the Son just as they honour the Father” (John 5:23). For he already knew clearly that the glory is not offered up to the Only-begotten and to the Holy Spirit as to beings of another substance.

Again, Mark says, from Christ’s own lips: “For whoever is ashamed of me and of my words in this adulterous and sinful generation, of him the Son of Man will also be ashamed, when he comes in the glory of his Father with the holy angels” (Mark 8:38). Matthew, setting out the same passage, did not say “in the glory of the Father” but “in the glory of the Son,” writing thus: “But when the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the holy angels with him, when he sits on the throne of his glory” (Matthew 25:31). And in John too he says: “Glorify me with the glory that I had with you before the world was” (John 17:5).

That the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit dwell in the faithful because they are of one substance and equal in power; and a reply to the objection of those who think otherwise.

We shall find the oneness of substance of the Trinity, and that all things are possible to it without any difference, in yet another way, if we see that it alone, being beyond even what is immaterial and invisible, can be shared in according to substance, and can fill the temple it has created. And not only does the thing itself belong to it, but the word fits it as well. For being shared in brings with it being unchangeable, and that in turn being uncreated, which is also being without beginning.

But nothing created, as far as the usage of the Scriptures goes, can be shared in by way of participation, or fill a human being in substance; it can do so only in the way that a good or a bad disposition does. For it is by a figure of speech that we say some people are filled with virtue and knowledge, and are able, with understanding, to bring forth the rewards of virtue and knowledge, like those who have received an unmixed share in the grace of the Holy Spirit.

It is attested, then, that the Father, the Son and the Spirit dwell in us; as when Paul, writing to the Corinthians the second time, says from Jeremiah: “For we are the temple of the living God; as God said: I will dwell in them and walk among them, and I will be their God, and they shall be my people” (2 Corinthians 6:16). And again: “Do you not know that you are God’s temple, and that the Spirit of …” (1 Corinthians 3:16)

God Dwells in the Faithful; Satan Only Deceives §24

24… God dwells in you?” (1 Corinthians 3:16). And: “Do you not know that your bodies are a temple of the Holy Spirit within you, whom you have from God?” (1 Corinthians 6:19). And to the Ephesians: “That he may grant you, according to the riches of his glory, to be strengthened with power through his Spirit in the inner man, so that Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith” (Ephesians 3:16-17).

And it is as when the Master says in John: “The Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it neither sees him nor knows him. But you know him, because he remains with you and will be in you” (John 14:17). And again: “If anyone loves me, he will keep my word; and my Father will love him, and we will come to him and make our dwelling with him” (John 14:23).

This will be still plainer to anyone who considers that God the Word, who can do all things, by his own will both remained unchangeable and was carried in the womb by the Virgin.

But they rise up again to object, with a show of reason: “It is written of Ananias, ‘Why has Satan filled your heart?’ (Acts 5:3), and of Judas, that ‘Satan entered into him’ (Luke 22:3; John 13:27).”

To them we must answer that Satan is not shared in, nor does he board the soul, as it were, and ride in it. He fills the one who does not heed the word, “Do not give your foot to be shaken, and he who guards you will not slumber” (Psalm 121:3), by deceiving him, by working evil counsels and a shifty character into him, and by making him a mere by-work of his own wickedness.

In this way he filled Elymas, his son, with the prompting to a satanic deed. For Paul says to him, a man foul in mind and in deeds, brimming with the devil’s villainy and using sophistry against the saints, so that his father, the author of evil, seemed to dwell in him: “O full of all deceit and all villainy, son of the devil!” (Acts 13:10).

So too he filled the false elders, in the matter of the most modest Susanna, with a licentious mind. The text runs: “And the two elders came, full of their lawless intent” (Susanna 1:28).

And so as not to weary the ear with a great crowd of words, we will pass over much that we could say on this point and put it briefly: if this argument of theirs holds, it is time to stop thinking it a great thing that the divine Serenity dwells in the faithful, and to suppose instead that this has its glory in mere appearance.

The Trinity Speaks in Us, Gives Us Life, Law and Name §25

25That the Trinity speaks in the faithful because its nature and essence admit no variation.

The divine hypostases speak alike in the saints, and this too proclaims that their nature and authority admit no variation. For Zechariah, not the prophet but the father of John, said that the Lord, the God of Israel, had spoken through the prophets (Luke 1:68–70). Paul likewise wrote to the Hebrews: “In many portions and in many ways God spoke of old to the fathers in the prophets; at the end of these days he has spoken to us in a Son” (Hebrews 1:1–2). And to the Corinthians he wrote about the Son: “since you seek proof of the Christ who speaks in me” (2 Corinthians 13:3). And the Savior himself teaches in Matthew: “For it is not you who speak, but the Spirit of your Father is the one who speaks in you” (Matthew 10:20).

That for the same reason, namely that the Trinity is of one essence, it is written that we live to the Father, to the Son and to the Holy Spirit.

The fact that Scripture says we live to the Father, to the Son and to the Holy Spirit also teaches us to see this most plainly. So Paul argues in his letter to the Romans: “Count yourselves dead to sin, but alive to God in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Romans 6:11). And again: “that those who live may no longer live for themselves, but for Christ, who died and was raised for them” (2 Corinthians 5:15). And to the Galatians: “If we live to the Spirit, let us also walk by the Spirit” (Galatians 5:25).

That for this reason it is written that the law from above belongs to the Father, to the Son and to the Holy Spirit.

For the reason we have given, the law from above is also written to be the law of the Father, of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. So the sacred psalmist says in Psalm 37: “The law of his God is in his heart” (Psalm 37:31); and in Psalm 40: “I have willed to do your will, O God, and your law is in the midst of my inmost parts” (Psalm 40:8). So too Paul writes to the Galatians: “Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfil the law of Christ” (Galatians 6:2). And to the Corinthians, in the first letter: “To those without the law I became as one without the law, not being without the law of God but under the law of Christ, that I might win those without the law” (1 Corinthians 9:21). And to the Romans: “For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has set me free from the law of sin and of death” (Romans 8:2). And again, hinting at the new covenant and the old, he says: “But now we have been released from the law, having died to that in which we were held, so that we serve in newness of the Spirit and not in oldness of the letter” (Romans 7:6). And again: “For we know that the law is spiritual” (Romans 7:14).

That for the same cause, the one essence of the Trinity, we are called men of God, or Christians, or spiritual.

This, then, is why we are called either men of God, or Christians, or spiritual. We hear these names from the widow in Zarephath, who says to Elijah the Tishbite: “What is there between me and you, man of God?” (1 Kings 17:18), and again: “Now I know that you are a holy man of God” (1 Kings 17:24). The Shunammite says to her husband about the prophet Elisha: “See, a great man of God is coming to us” (2 Kings 4:9). The histories of the Kings say: “And a man of God came out of Judah and prophesied against the altar in Bethel” (1 Kings 13:1–2). The sacred psalmist, in the heading of Psalm 90, says: “A prayer of Moses, the man of God” (Psalm 90). Paul, writing to Timothy for the second time, says: “that the man of God may be complete, fully equipped for every good work” (2 Timothy 3:17). The Acts say: “It came about that for a whole year they were gathered together in the church, and that the disciples were first called Christians in Antioch” (Acts 11:26). And Paul, discoursing with the Corinthians in a letter, says: “Now about spiritual things, brothers, I do not want you to be ignorant. You know that when you were Gentiles you were carried off to the voiceless idols, however you happened to be led. Therefore …” (1 Corinthians 12:1–3).

What Scripture Calls the Father’s It Also Calls the Son’s and the Spirit’s §26

26… I make known to you that no one can say ‘Jesus is Lord’ except in the Holy Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:3). And again: “The natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him, and he cannot know them, because they are judged spiritually. But the spiritual man judges everyone, while he himself is judged by no one. For who has known the mind of the Lord, so as to instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ” (1 Corinthians 2:14–16). And again: “Brothers, if a man is overtaken in any trespass, you who are spiritual should restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness, looking to yourself, lest you too be tempted. Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfil the law of Christ” (Galatians 6:1–2).

That for the same cause, the one essence of the Trinity, Scripture says at one time that things are the Father’s and at another that the same things are the Son’s or the Holy Spirit’s.

Scripture, making plain that there is one Godhead and one lordship, says at one time that certain things are the Father’s, and at another declares that they belong to the Son or to the Holy Spirit. So it is when the Savior says to the Jews in Matthew: “Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s” (Matthew 22:21). So it is too when the renowned Paul writes to the Philippians: “For all seek their own things, not those of Jesus Christ” (Philippians 2:21); and to the Galatians: “And those who are Christ Jesus’s have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires” (Galatians 5:24); and to the Corinthians: “For the love of Christ holds us fast, since we have judged this: he died for all, that those who live may no longer live for themselves, but for him who died and was raised for them” (2 Corinthians 5:14–15). And again: “The natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him” (1 Corinthians 2:14). And again: “Be zealous for the things of the Spirit” (1 Corinthians 14:1).

The Church, too, understood together with the glory sent up within it and the bloodless worship offered there, he declared to be God’s, writing to the Corinthians the first time in this way: “Give no offence to Jews or to Greeks or to the church of God” (1 Corinthians 10:32); and again: “We have no such custom, nor do the churches of God” (1 Corinthians 11:16). But writing to the Ephesians in turn, he taught that it is Christ’s, saying: “that he might present the church to himself blameless, having no spot or wrinkle or any such thing, but that it might be holy and without blemish” (Ephesians 5:27). If he did not think so, let someone explain what the prophet Haggai means when he says that “great shall be the latter glory of this house, beyond the former” (Haggai 2:9): that is, the glory of the Church of Christ and of the praise given in it, beyond the synagogue of the Jews, in which God the Father alone was confessed as God and glorified.

Following on, then, he says that the gospel too is at one time God the Father’s, writing to the Romans: “Paul, a slave of Jesus Christ, called to be an apostle, set apart for the gospel of God” (Romans 1:1); and again: “For I am not ashamed of the gospel, for it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. For in it the righteousness of God is revealed; and the righteous shall live by faith” (Romans 1:16–17); and to the Corinthians, the second time: “that I preached the gospel of God to you free of charge” (2 Corinthians 11:7). At another time he writes that it is the only-begotten God’s. To the Corinthians, the first time: “But we did not make use of this right; we bear all things, so as not to put any hindrance in the way of the gospel of Christ” (1 Corinthians 9:12); and the second time: “When I came to Troas for the gospel of Christ” (2 Corinthians 2:12); and again: “glorifying God for the submission of your confession to the gospel of Christ” (2 Corinthians 9:13); and to the Romans: “For God is my witness, whom I serve in the gospel of his Son” (Romans 1:9).

He also said that the sacred ministry is performed at one time for God the Father and at another for God his only-begotten Son, writing to the Corinthians the first time: “Let a man regard us in this way, as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God. Moreover it is required of stewards that one be found faithful” (1 Corinthians 4:1–2); and the second time: “in everything commending ourselves as ministers of God” (2 Corinthians 6:4); and again: “Are they ministers of Christ? I speak as one beside himself: I am more” (2 Corinthians 11:23). And [...]

[...] “Who trusted in the Lord and was put to shame? Or who held fast in his fear and was forsaken? Or who called upon him, and he overlooked him?” (Sirach 2:10). For, as even those outside say, whoever obeys God, him he gladly hears. Accordingly, that nothing in himself is acquired or worked in him by another, but that from his own store …

All That the Father Has Is the Son’s §27

27… he brings in all good things. This he shows by giving, with authority, the one divine peace, of which “there is no end” (Isaiah 9:7), and of which Isaiah cried aloud: “O Lord our God, give us peace, for you have given us all things. O Lord, we know no other besides you” (Isaiah 26:12–13). He gives it as his own, because nature and lordship are held in common. For he said: “Peace I leave with you; my peace I give to you” (John 14:27).

That is why Paul too, and not least, said that both uncreated hypostases supply this God-given gift without any difference, writing to the Romans somewhere in these words: “Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ” (Romans 1:7). And this saying too has given us to discern that the matter stands so: “All that the Father has is mine” (John 16:15). For no one who is not ignorant takes these words of the creation; they are taken of the divine rank, if one must speak of rank in the case of God.

“For the Father,” he says, “is God. So am I, for I am his only-begotten, true and beloved Son. The Father is Lord. I too am Lord of all, and heir of a living Father, master of the inheritance. I inherit what is his, partly as its maker and partly as his true-born Son; but I was appointed heir as one who became man. The Father is Creator and King. So am I, for I told you that ‘there was a certain king, and he went to make a wedding feast for his son the king’ (Matthew 22:2). The Father is unchangeable. So am I, for it has been prophesied of me: ‘You are the same, and your years will not fail’ (Psalm 102:27). The Father is impassible. So am I, so that those who share in me also partake of impassibility. The Father is without beginning. So am I. For there was never a time when he did not have the name of Father, and did not have me, the subsisting radiance of his glory, the ‘exact imprint of his hypostasis’ (Hebrews 1:3) and the ‘image of the Godhead.’ Life and light and goodness and power and wisdom and truth, and all that is worthy of God: this the Father is. So am I, as you have already heard. And indeed I too am Savior, ‘making the sun rise on the righteous and on sinners’ (Matthew 5:45), and not bringing ‘evil for evil.’ The Father loves mankind. So do I, since for your sake ‘I emptied myself, taking the form of a slave’ (Philippians 2:7), and bore with you as you struck me, spat on me, mocked me and crucified me.”

So he said that all the Father’s attributes are his, so as to grant God the Father nothing more than this alone: to be Father of a Son who is without beginning together with him and subsists together with him. This saying too persuades us to believe so: “All that is mine is yours, and what is yours is mine, and I have been glorified in them” (John 17:10). For if this was not said because of their natural relation, and if the Son has not been glorified in his essence with all that is the Father’s, if there is not one kingdom and one lordship, then, by heretical reasoning at least, there are things that fall not under the Father’s authority but under the Son’s.

And again: “If I glorify myself, my glory is nothing; it is my Father who glorifies me” (John 8:54). “When I speak to you,” he says, “of my own divine glory, that ‘I and the Father are one’ (John 10:30), you do not believe. But there is the Father who bears witness to me that I am glorified by nature, since I am his beloved and true Son, and your God and Master.” Then he says: “Father, glorify your Son, that your Son also may glorify you” (John 17:1). Here too equal honor and glory are kept for the divine hypostases. For in whatever way we take the Father to glorify his Son, in that same way he himself is glorified by him.

And again he goes on: “And now, Father, glorify me with yourself with the glory that I had with you before the world was” (John 17:5). It is dreadful to hear: he who has glory without beginning with his own Father, for this is what “with the glory that I had before the world was” means, is not glorified by heretics. And what was this glory? The one that Mark too, I think, spoke of: “when the Son comes in the glory of his Father” (Mark 8:38), which is to say: he has the Father’s glory, and in it he will come the second time. And those whose glory is one do not have one Godhead, kingdom and worship here and another there. Hence he charges them beforehand: “Believe in God, and believe in me. In my Father’s house there are many dwelling places” (John 14:1–2). “For since the Godhead,” he says, “admits no difference, you must hold one knowledge of faith concerning the Trinity, so that in this way you may dwell in those thrice-blessed courts, which are fitting and sufficient for all.”

So, granting not only what a teacher grants but also what God grants, he says: “Your sins are forgiven you” (Luke 5:20). Here too you notice his sovereign freedom: that, as it were, …

Equality of Father and Son §28

28… does not plead with one greater, but forgives as sovereign.

Matthew too, adding his own share to what is taught of the only-begotten Son as God, said: “No one knows the Father except the Son, nor does anyone know the Son except the Father” (Matthew 11:27). How then do these men quarrel as though they knew the Father to be incomparable, his Son to be unlike him, and his essence to be unbegottenness? They leave nothing as the special preserve of the knowledge that belongs to God the Father and the only-begotten God, and they do not reckon that nothing of a different nature has a knowledge equal to that of a being whose essence is other than its own.

Paul likewise writes to Timothy in the first letter: “I charge you before God, who gives life to all things, and Christ Jesus, who bore witness to the good confession before Pontius Pilate, to keep the commandment spotless and blameless until the appearing of the Lord Jesus Christ, which in his own times the blessed and only Mighty One will show, the King of those who reign and Lord of those who rule, who alone has immortality and dwells in unapproachable light, whom no one among men has seen or can see; to whom be honor and eternal glory to the ages of ages. Amen” (1 Timothy 6:13–16). The heretics have resolved to give to the Father alone the words “the only Mighty One and King of those who reign” and what follows. But just as Paul spoke of both the ever-remembered hypostases, “I charge you before God and Christ Jesus,” so he sang the praises that follow of both of them, as of one in Godhead. For he was not ignorant, as these men are, of “All that the Father has is mine” (John 16:15), and “that all may honor the Son just as they honor the Father” (John 5:23), and “This is the true God and eternal life” (1 John 5:20), and “This is our God; no other shall be reckoned beside him” (Baruch 3:35), and “This is my beloved Son” (Matthew 3:17).

Rather, the words set out here point more toward the Son. For the text runs: “to keep the commandment until the appearing of the Lord Jesus Christ, which in his own times the blessed and only Mighty One will show” (1 Timothy 6:14–15). And it is plain that the Son will show his own appearing when he comes the second time. Observe, then, that Paul assigns to him the first glory too.

And to the Romans: “For his invisible things, from the creation of the world, are clearly seen, being understood through the things that are made, both his eternal power and divinity” (Romans 1:20). These words too, because Father and Son are equal in honor, do not tilt toward a thing made. For the Creator’s being understood as begotten does not keep his eternity and divinity from being known, that is, his Godhead, which is always and in the same way. And to the Philippians: “Who, being in the form of God, did not count being equal to God a thing to be seized, but emptied himself, taking the form of a slave” (Philippians 2:6–7).

What in this equality is found unequal? “He did not seize it,” Paul says; he did not take to himself his being equal by nature to God the Father. And indeed he who was emptied by no one else, but emptied himself, showed himself to be at once Master in his own right and eternal. For if he came to be in the form of a slave, it is beyond dispute that before this happened he did not dwell among things made, but was in the free nature of the Father. Since he could not be seen, he came down, without change and not in mere appearance, as far as the form of a household slave. He thrust off the slave’s burdens and gave the beginning of a brighter life; and so he who was without beginning came to be known.

As for the other things written to these same Philippians, in which Paul already shows in some way, as far as the unintelligent need it, that the Son is pre-eminent and supreme together with his own Father, I have already spoken of them above, in the seventh chapter. But nothing prevents our establishing this from the ancient Scripture as well, for theology must not be handled in passing. So God says in Isaiah: “Your new moons and sabbaths and your feasts my soul hates. You have become a surfeit to me; I will no longer let your sins go. Even if you make your prayer full, I will not hear you, for your hands are full of blood. Wash yourselves, become clean, take away your sins from your souls” (Isaiah 1:13–16).

You see, then, that his love for mankind runs ahead even of his threat: he is all but reconciled already, and does not know how to keep his anger long, or rather how to be angry at all. He hates their feasts, that is, their worship, because it falls short of the most perfect knowledge of God; and he bids them be baptized, so as to receive the faith according to the Master’s ordinance for baptism. And Paul has assured us elsewhere too, crying aloud in so many words that he does not …

The Son Swore by Himself: The Divinity of the Son §29

29… have anyone greater than himself: the Son. For in Genesis God said to Abraham, “Offer me your son as a sacrifice” (Genesis 22:2). Abraham did this readily, and he was about to bring his hand down upon him, armed with a knife, when an angel of the Lord called to him and said, “Abraham, do not lay your hand on the boy, and do him no harm at all. For now I know that you fear God, and for my sake you have not spared your beloved son” (Genesis 22:12).

Then a ram was found for the sacrifice in place of Isaac, and Abraham completed the sacrifice: in intention through the boy, in the slaughter through the ram. And “the angel of the Lord,” it says, “called him a second time from heaven, saying: ‘By myself I have sworn, says the Lord: because you have done this thing, and for my sake have not spared your beloved son, I will surely bless you, and I will surely multiply your seed as the stars of heaven and as the sand of the sea; and in you all the nations shall be blessed, because you obeyed my voice’” (Genesis 22:15-18).

Yet this was neither the Father nor, for that matter, a ministering angel. For a servant does not swear by himself, or bless, or say, “For my sake you have not spared your beloved son.” Nor does he dare to halt a sacrifice that is being offered to God, nor, again, has he authority to accept it. No: the one who asked for the sacrifice was the only-begotten God, the Word, who granted Abraham his only son. So Paul explains when he writes to the Hebrews in this way: “For when God made his promise to Abraham” (the things he both promised and performed), “since he had no one greater by whom to swear, he swore by himself, saying, ‘I will surely bless you’” (Hebrews 6:13-14). And to the Romans, too, he explains that it is the Son who once more swears by himself: “For we shall all stand before the judgment seat of Christ, as it is written: ‘As I live, says the Lord, to me every knee shall bow, and every tongue shall confess to God’” (Romans 14:10-11).

Then there is his sitting with the Father at his right hand; and, besides, the evangelist’s declaring, with a tongue that spoke the words of God, that the seat fitting for the Son is the Father’s bosom. If these do not signify sameness of substance and equal honour, and that the only-begotten God and Son must be worshipped together with the Father and his Spirit, then (if we must take what is written about God in a human way, as we should not) by their reckoning the one at the right hand is greater and more glorious, the one who has the divine, ineffable bosom for his throne, like the many-eyed throne of the cherubim. God forbid that this be said of the most ineffable and most serene Trinity! For David sings of the Father in Psalm 110: “The Lord said to my Lord, ‘Sit at my right hand’” (Psalm 110:1). Paul instructs the Hebrews: “Who, being the radiance of the Father’s glory and the imprint of his hypostasis, and upholding all things by the word of his power, when he had made purification for sins, sat down at the right hand of the Majesty on high” (Hebrews 1:3). And the evangelist says: “The only-begotten God, who is in the bosom of the Father, has made it known” (John 1:18).

Likewise the theology concerning the Son: that “in him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead”; that he is “great God” and “over all,” the one “with whom no other shall be compared,” “true God” and “eternal life,” “only Master,” “only worker of wonders,” “Most High,” “King,” and “Sovereign”; that “Christ is all in all”; and the rest.

So much on these matters was enough. But the initiates of divine things, zealous for all that belongs to the Trinity, whose providence is over all, do not rest; they pursue still other lofty truths. What they declare of the Father as God, they declare of the Son as well: that “in him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead” (Colossians 2:9); that he is “great God” (Titus 2:13) and “over all” (Romans 9:5), the one “with whom no other shall be compared” (Baruch 3:35), “true God” and “eternal life” (1 John 5:20), “the true light” (John 1:9), “only Master” (Jude 4), “only Most High,” “only worker of wonders,” “great King,” “Lord of all” (Acts 10:36), and …

The Psalms and Isaiah Name the Son God §30

30“Creator,” and “Sovereign,” and “of his peace there is no bound” (Isaiah 9:7), and “Saviour,” and “Christ is all in all” (Colossians 3:11), and “blessed for ever” (Romans 9:5); and that “great is the mystery of godliness” (1 Timothy 3:16), plainly the mystery of the Christians, among whom Christ is hymned as uncreated God; and that by his own Godhead “he acquires the people,” because he is of one substance with the Father.

Such, then, is what the saints we shall now mention say on these matters, the saints to whom God, as Psalm 16 says, “made known the ways of life” (Psalm 16:11). David in Psalm 7 prays: “Arise, O Lord my God, by the command you gave, and an assembly of peoples shall surround you; and for its sake return on high” (Psalm 7:6-7). You see that the prophet knows him as Lord and God, and entreats him when he says “Arise”: arise to your ineffable incarnation, in the way you marked out beforehand when you said, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up” (John 2:19). For by “for its sake” he means the salvation that comes to us from it: “The nations will surround you by faith; and you, return without separation to the place from which you came.”

And in Psalm 47: “The Lord is a great God, and a great King over all the earth” (Psalm 47:2). And in Psalm 50: “From the rising of the sun to its setting, out of Zion is the splendour of his beauty; God will come openly” (Psalm 50:1-3). And in Psalm 68: “Let God arise, and let his enemies be scattered” (Psalm 68:1), and “Make a way for him who rides upon the west; the Lord is his name” (Psalm 68:4). And in Psalm 82: “Arise, O God, judge the earth” (Psalm 82:8).

Observe how each word kindles his glory and is enough to persuade us that he is of the substance of the Father’s unity. Observe, too, that the writer of great things calls God the one who was laid in the tomb not without life, so that he might save, together with the living, those also who had departed from human affairs; and he prophesies that he rises from the grave to judge those who, after a kindness so great and so vast, set their minds on earthly things. Know that by “the west” he means the last times; for it was in them that he came openly into this visible world.

And in Psalm 77: “Your way is in the holy place. Who is a great God like our God? You are the God who alone works wonders” (Psalm 77:13-14). Here too he extols God the Word made flesh, who loved to linger in the Jewish temple, and taught there, and worked wonders.

And in Psalm 118: “Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord; the Lord is a great God, and he has appeared to us” (Psalm 118:26-27). If it is with good reason that the Lord who appeared to us is, in the prophet, “a great God” and “blessed” (that is, glorified), and “great King” and “only worker of wonders,” and this is the Son, then it is without reason that the heretics suspect him of being less than his own Father. For it is not possible for one and the same being, in truth, to hold the first place according to the prophecy and the second according to them.

If we inquire of the same psalmist, we shall learn that he knows the Son, like the Father, to be the God of our forefathers. For in Psalm 47 he has cried out: “God reigns over the nations; God sits upon his holy throne. The rulers of the peoples were gathered with the God of Abraham” (Psalm 47:8-9). They assembled together with God made man, of whom it is sung in Psalm 2: “Why did the nations rage, and the peoples plot vain things? The kings of the earth stood up, and the rulers were gathered together against the Lord and against his Christ” (Psalm 2:1-2).

Isaiah cries out that he, like God the Father, is beyond compare: “From of old we have not heard, nor have our eyes seen, a God besides you” (Isaiah 64:4). For we have seen no other God than the one born of the Virgin Mary in the saving incarnation; nor have we heard any other, except the one to whom God the Father bore witness: “This is my beloved Son” (Matthew 3:17). And again, as was said before: “A child was born to us, a son also was given, whose rule is upon his shoulder; and his name is called Mighty God, Sovereign, Prince of Peace, Father of the age to come” (Isaiah 9:6). And after other words he adds: “And of his peace there is no bound” (Isaiah 9:7).

The Son of God, he means, having become man, was born a child and was given to us, himself bearing upon his shoulder the rule, the very beginning, of this his birth here below. That is, he is himself his own beginning, in that he was born of a virgin without passion and was ineffably made flesh from her, while no union with a man supplied his beginning. And his name is “Mighty God, Sovereign.” He did not say “subject to authority”; he disclosed his nature, his power, his sovereign authority. Knowing this name, David sings: “Let them know that your name …

The Great God and Saviour: Baruch, Titus and Colossians §31

31… is Lord; you alone are Most High over all the earth” (Psalm 83:18). He said “alone” because of the one Godhead. He called him Father of the age to come, though he is the Creator of the past ages as well, because it was from the time of the dispensation that he became widely known to men. So he called him Father of a created nature, not of an uncreated one; for the Father of the uncreated and consubstantial Son is one. And pointing to the immeasurable greatness of his Godhead, he said: “Of his peace there is no bound” (Isaiah 9:7).

Jeremiah too, or Baruch (for the two have one book), speaks of him in solemn words: “This is our God; no other shall be compared with him. He found out every way of knowledge and gave it to Jacob his servant and to Israel whom he loved. Afterwards he was seen on earth and lived among men” (Baruch 3:35-37). If, then, it is not understood in a way worthy of God, that the passage before us was spoken so because both the ineffable hypostases have the same Godhead, it remains to fall into godlessness and say that the God and Father who begot him is not our God and is not to be compared with his Son.

So the argument of those who slander God the Word as lesser and a subordinate has fallen and vanished altogether. For how could another be beyond compare with God, he “with whom no other shall be compared”? And again: “Let the gods who did not make the heaven and the earth perish from the earth. The Lord, who made the heavens by understanding, he is the living and true God” (Jeremiah 10:10-12). This is said because no other Godhead is true except that of the genuine Son of God, through whom and from whom the heavens too were brought forth, together with the whole world.

And Paul, the most eminent of men, keeping the same sequence as the prophets, gives the words that befit him. To Titus he writes: “Awaiting the blessed hope and the appearing of the glory of the great God and Saviour Jesus Christ, who gave himself for us, to redeem us from all lawlessness and to purify for himself a people of his own, zealous for good works” (Titus 2:13-14). By declaring “of the great God and our Saviour Jesus Christ,” he shows that the Son does not stand second in substance, and that he is without beginning in relation to the great God the Father. Indeed, one can see it from what is plain on the surface: if the Son is small, how will the Father be great? If there “was a time when he was not” for God the Word, there was a time when the name of Father did not exist. May we be pardoned for daring to say such things; we say them because of the senselessness of others. “For reverence,” as they say, “is a fine habit for those who practise it.”

By saying “who gave himself for us, to purify for himself a people of his own,” and not “to purify a people for another,” he brings out something further, in keeping with what has been mentioned. For it signifies that he has received as his own the one Godhead, self-determining and good, the cause of all things. To die for one’s own handiwork, if one may put it so, belongs to a creator and not to a creature; and to acquire the people for himself belongs to a beloved Son whose Godhead and kingdom are no different from the Father’s.

Carrying the argument on, this great and true interpreter sets out to show that he is at once a loving and saving God, and at once that it was by prevailing upon himself, and not by yielding to a higher Godhead, that he came to be with us as one of us, without change and without sin. He says: “When indeed the kindness and love for mankind of God our Saviour appeared, not by works which we had done, but according to his great mercy, he saved us through the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:4-5).

To the Colossians he both gives rebuke and lays the foundation of the very first theology concerning him, writing, as was said already in the chapter “On the Consubstantial”: “Why according to the tradition of men, according to the elements of the world, and not according to Christ Jesus? For in him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead bodily” (Colossians 2:8-9), that is, in substance. For he is by nature fullness itself, being in his substance the Father’s Godhead. “For he did not count it robbery to be equal with God” (Philippians 2:6). But we, through his goodness, received grace from the fullness, a grace which by nature, as servants, we did not have. So John says: “And from his fullness we have all received, and grace for grace” (John 1:16); that is, the grace of rebirth in place of the grace we cast away when we set aside the first ordinance, given about the one tree. “For no longer,” …

God Manifest in the Flesh: Paul, Thomas, John and Jude §32

32… he says, “are you under law, but under grace” (Romans 6:14). And again: “For in him all the fullness was pleased to dwell, and through him to reconcile all things to him” (Colossians 1:19-20).

This too follows from what went before. For the Father is by nature in the Son, and the Son in the Father, just as everything akin stands, in a way, inseparable from what is akin to it, even if it is divided in hypostasis. So the saying in the passage under discussion is fine as well, though it is not very deep, yet not easy for everyone to take in at a glance: “through him and to him to reconcile all things.” Thus the word spoken of the Father, “from whom are all things” (1 Corinthians 8:6), fits the Son too, if indeed both what has now been said and the words “in him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead” (Colossians 2:9) hold sound.

Writing to Timothy as well, Paul spoke of him as God in the highest degree, and from both expressions he taught that in his Godhead he is not outside the Father’s nature. For he spoke thus: “Confessedly great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifested in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen by angels, preached among the nations, believed on in the world, taken up in glory” (1 Timothy 3:16). For this Maker and Benefactor of all, who was not yet plainly manifest to all, was found manifest when, for the salvation of all, he willingly became as one of all.

Hence “he was justified in the Spirit”: that is, he was declared, or rather confirmed, to be true God even by those who had not known him in the time before. And this, he says, was not without testing, but by the very movement of our soul, as common usage puts it: “So-and-so was justified as truly the son of such a one,” when he has furnished proof of his descent; and again, “So-and-so was justified in governing well.”

And so that the account may seem more persuasive, he holds that he was seen by angels too, to whom, because of his divine infinity and formlessness, he had been invisible before that time, like “the only invisible God” (1 Timothy 1:17); and that he was hymned by them: “Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace, good will among men” (Luke 2:14). He holds that he was preached and believed on in this whole world, because he who shone forth timelessly from the ineffable light was ineffably born of the ever-virgin in later times, out of love for mankind, and showed forth in himself all that is the Father’s; and that he went up to the One who embraces all things, in the glory in which he always was with God.

Worthy of belief, too, is the very one of whom we speak, when he bears witness to his own Godhead and lordship. In Matthew he says to the devil, “You shall not tempt the Lord your God” (Matthew 4:7); in John he says to the apostles, “You call me the Lord and the Teacher, and you say well, for so I am” (John 13:13). And Thomas, when he touched the marks of the nails, which the Saviour in his love for mankind bore from us for our sake, was not troubled, nor did he lower his supreme estimate of him. For he knew that it belonged only to the sovereign nature, infinite in power and supremely good, and certainly not to a created one, not only to suffer for its own creatures, but also to bestow the salvation we call universal and general, and that for ever. Therefore, taking still greater courage from this, he offers him firm faith in return and cries out: “My Lord and my God” (John 20:28).

In the catholic epistles too, as was said before, they wrote of the Son as God equally with the Father and in the same words. John, the great among theologians, says: “And we know that the Word of God has come and has given us understanding, so that we may know the true God; and we are in the true one, in the Son of God, Jesus Christ. This is the true God and eternal life” (1 John 5:20). Do not seek, he means, a God other in substance than the Son of God. For I have twice told you that “true” belongs to him: he is both “true Son” and “true God,” who has given understanding to those worthy to receive it; so that you may know that he was truly begotten and is truly consubstantial with the God who begot him.

Jude, one of the twelve, defined him as sole Owner, as one who has received for his lot the Father’s Godhead, which is over all and through all and in all. He writes somewhere in this way to those everywhere: “For certain men have crept in, who long ago were marked out for this judgment, ungodly men, turning the grace of our God into licentiousness and denying the only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ” (Jude 4). And Peter too, the chief among the apostles, is shown in the Acts saying: “The word which he sent to the sons of Israel, preaching peace through Jesus Christ: he is of all …

The Son, Sun of Righteousness and Giver of Every Good §33

33… Lord” (Acts 10:36). On what ground, then, or how, or when could he be brought in as unlike the Father, when he has been honoured with so many oracles, so clear, so alike in manner, and in no way different from those spoken of the Father?

That the Son makes every good thing dawn, and is “the sun of righteousness and healing,” “the treasure of wisdom and knowledge,” and “light”; and that those who believe and “are not made to stumble in him” “become sons of light.”

Those, at any rate, who have sung his praises show us his Godhead in various ways, and that he presides in full over his own works. They teach that he is the giver of every good: a light good in form and doing good, a sun seen by the mind. With the unceasing light that comes from himself he makes bright the eyes of souls that do not wander and are ready to receive him. He leads them within the vantage point of contemplation and makes them see what, because of sin, they could not see before by their own nature; or he even makes the whole perfected man full of light, as the sun makes sunlike the bodies it comes upon. They teach, further, that he is also healing, and an inexhaustible and all-sufficient “treasure of wisdom and knowledge.”

And those who are sincerely disposed toward him, as toward his Father, become sons of light, since they are sons of God the Father. So Malachi proclaims: “For you who fear my name the sun of righteousness will rise, and healing in his wings” (Malachi 4:2). And Peter in his second letter: “Until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts” (2 Peter 1:19). He meant, I think, the illumination that is to rise on souls at his second appearing and to make bright all that darkness holds fast. And elsewhere: “And the glory of the Lord has risen upon you” (Isaiah 60:1).

Zechariah prophesied: “If anything is good, it is his; and if anything is beautiful, it will come from him” (Zechariah 9:17). And Paul said of him to the Colossians: “In whom all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge are hidden” (Colossians 2:3); and to the Romans: “For the Scripture says,” he writes, “‘Everyone who believes in him will not be put to shame.’ For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek; for the same Lord of all is rich toward all who call on him. For everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved” (Romans 10:11-13).

But what name of the Son do they call on, who call him, the glorious victor, the Saviour of heaven and earth and sea, neither uncreated God nor Son of one substance with the Father?

John likewise says of him: “While you have the light, believe in the light, so that you may become sons of light” (John 12:36). For after death, he says, there is no repentance, as David too sings: “But in Hades who will confess to you?” (Psalm 6:5). And again, from the Saviour: “Go and tell John what you see and hear: the blind receive their sight, the lame walk, the dead are raised, and the poor have the good news preached to them; and blessed is whoever is not made to stumble in me” (Matthew 11:4-6).

For what will he say about those who are led astray and those who lead them astray? Isaiah foretold it: “My people, those who call you blessed lead you astray and confuse the path of your feet. But now the Lord will take his stand for judgment and will set his people for judgment. The Lord himself will come to judgment with the elders of the people and with their rulers. But you, why did you set my vineyard on fire?” (Isaiah 3:12-14).

The Lord himself will come to judgment with the teachers and rulers, not as one who is himself to be judged by another, but to convict them, as he declares in another place: “Come, and let us go to judgment, says the Lord” (Isaiah 1:18): “what things,” he says, “came to you from me, and what things have been done by you to me and to my servants.”

For he calls the world, or the people, a “vineyard.” The interpreters of the heretics and of the Jews made it liable to the fire of Gehenna by their blasphemous teaching; and the rulers, who did not make its welfare their own concern but abused their authority, wronged it in many and various ways.

The Son as Judge and Saviour, and the Father Who Draws Us to Him §34

34For another saying of the same kind is spoken by the same prophet in the person of the Master: “Who is it that goes to law with me? Let him stand against me. And who is it that goes to law with me? Let him come near to me” (Isaiah 50:8). That is: if anyone has just things to say, as one fortified by his deeds, let him be set against me, since I wish it, and let him come near with his arguments.

Some, however, read it this way: “Who is it that goes to law with me? Let him stand over against”—that is, facing me and somewhere far off—“me,” as one who has no good provisions for the road, and is therefore unworthy to be compared with me and to touch the most pure judgment seat. For no one begrudges the worthy if they obtain good things; these have been prepared for them.

That the Son of God is “judge of the living and the dead,” granting forgiveness of sins, and that “there is salvation in no one else.”

For he himself is “the judge of the living and the dead” (Acts 10:42), that is, of the righteous and of sinners. He grants forgiveness of sins to those who believe in his name, and saves us by his own glory and gift. And “there is salvation in no one else” (Acts 4:12), since he is by nature merciful and Saviour, in nothing inferior to the merciful and saving God and Father. So the other Scriptures declare, and Micah in particular, saying: “Who is a God like you, taking away iniquities and passing over wrongs?” (Micah 7:18).

And Peter in the Acts, thus: “And he commanded us to preach to the people and to testify that he is the one appointed by God as judge of the living and the dead. To him all the prophets bear witness, that everyone who believes in him receives forgiveness of sins through his name” (Acts 10:42-43).

Here, then, we have him acclaimed and appointed by God because of his saving incarnation, in which he came “to seek and to save what was lost” (Luke 19:10). Because of it, too, it is written: “For the Father judges no one, but has given all judgment to the Son” (John 5:22). And he is judge as one set apart from creatures; for a creature does not judge, but is subject to law and judgment.

And again: “This is the stone that was despised by you, the builders, which has become the head of the corner. And there is salvation in no one else” (Acts 4:11-12).

He also sends a second general letter, which among other things says this too about him: “As his divine power has given us all things that pertain to life and godliness, through the knowledge of him who called us by his own glory and excellence, through which he has given us the greatest and precious good tidings, so that through these you may become partakers of the divine nature” (2 Peter 1:3-4). That is why James too said in his general letter: “There is one lawgiver and judge, who is able to save and to destroy” (James 4:12).

But what need is there, after all, of a host of Scriptures for this? The Samaritans too, right-minded men, raise their voices in John, the exact spokesman of God: “For we ourselves,” they say, “have heard, and we know that this is truly the Saviour of the world, the Christ” (John 4:42); he who says gently, as Scripture says: “Take heart, child; your sins are forgiven” (Matthew 9:2).

That because the Trinity is equal in honour, the Father reveals the Son to us and draws us to him, and in turn the Son himself and the Holy Spirit bring us to the Father. Here also, on Peter’s confession, and that there is repentance.

For, so that the equal honour of the blessed Trinity in all things might be shown through everything, the Father reveals his own Son to us, draws us through himself to him, and transfers us into his kingdom (Colossians 1:13). And in turn the Son and the Holy Spirit bring us to God the Father. For God would not have transferred us to one of another substance, or greater, nor to lower powers handed down like sceptres from among his own. So the new covenant has brought the old to completion, through faith in the Son and the divine Spirit.

And they speak thus. God the Father says to the Son in Isaiah: “Behold, proselytes will come to you through me, and will dwell beside you, and will take refuge with you” (Isaiah 54:15 LXX). And the Son in John: “No one can come to me unless the heavenly Father draws him, and I will raise him up on the last day” (John 6:44).

And again, when Peter said, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God” (Matthew 16:16), he replied: “Blessed are you, Peter Bar-Jonah, for flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my Father who is in heaven. And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades will not overpower it. And I will give you the keys of the heavens; and whatever you bind on earth will be bound in the heavens, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in the heavens” (Matthew 16:17-19).

Peter’s Confession and the Unending Kingdom of the Son §35

35Oh, how much faith can do, and the confession that the only-begotten God the Word is the true Son of God and not a creature!

Peter did not waver through flesh and blood when he saw God gladly dwelling on earth; that is what “flesh and blood has not revealed this to you” (Matthew 16:17) means. He recognized the branch of God that shares his nature and his eternity. In him he honoured the self-existent root without beginning that had revealed him. He believed in the oneness of Godhead that the Son has with the Father. He was declared blessed by the only blessed Master.

On this rock the churches have been built, and “the gates of Hades” (Matthew 16:18), that is, the syllogisms of heretics, shall not overcome them. He was entrusted with the keys of the heavens, so that for those who believe he might open the way in the kingdom of God, believing as Peter himself plainly answered just now, and as he heard from Christ together with the other apostles: “baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 28:19); and that for those who do not give glory in this way he might shut the thrice-blessed and most longed-for entrance. For by the very thing for which he was called blessed, he himself was received into this glory, while those who say the opposite were rebuked and cast out.

So, having spoken the truth in confessing him the Son of God, that is, genuine and of one substance, he heard the like in return: Bar-Jonah, which is translated “son of Jonah.” And Peter was certainly not of another substance from the one who begot him.

Besides this he received authority (or rather all received it through him) not to give up on those who fall, but to receive them when they repent. For no one is without sin except the one who entrusted this authority to Peter. That is the meaning of: “Whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in the heavens” (Matthew 18:18). From then on he cast away the inhumanity of Novatian and Sabbatius.

Paul in turn follows what has been set out, writing to the Galatians: “But when God, who set me apart from my mother’s womb, was pleased to reveal his Son in me” (Galatians 1:15-16); and to the Colossians: “Giving thanks to the Father, who has made us fit for a share in the inheritance of the saints in the light. He rescued us from the power of darkness and transferred us into the kingdom of the Son of his love, in whom we have redemption, the forgiveness of sins” (Colossians 1:12-14); and to the Corinthians: “God is faithful, through whom you were called into the fellowship of his Son Jesus Christ our Lord” (1 Corinthians 1:9); and to the Ephesians: “And he came and preached peace to you who were far off and peace to those who were near; for through him we both have access in one Spirit to the Father” (Ephesians 2:17-18).

That the kingdom of the Only-begotten has no end.

And to put to shame the heretics who say that after the general resurrection the Son will hand over the kingdom to the Father, the Scriptures proclaim that the dominion of the Son has no end. They do so thus. Gabriel in Luke, bringing the good news to the God-bearer: “And the Lord God,” he says, “will give him the throne of David his father, and he will reign over the house of Israel for ever, and of his kingdom there will be no end” (Luke 1:32-33). And very truly so. For if he gives the kingdom back, in what kingdom of his, and when, shall we reign with him?

And Paul, writing to the Ephesians: “Every fornicator or unclean or greedy person, that is, an idolater, has no inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and God” (Ephesians 5:5). He certainly means the kingdom after the resurrection. When, then, on their view, does he hand over the kingdom?

And to Timothy in the second letter: “I charge you before God and Christ Jesus, who is to judge the living and the dead, and by his appearing and his kingdom: preach the word” (2 Timothy 4:1-2). It is clear that he means the kingdom which he holds undivided and without successor with the Father and the Holy Spirit, both now and in the age to come.

And to the Hebrews: “Of the angels he says, ‘He makes his angels spirits, and his ministers a flame of fire’; but of the Son, ‘Your throne, O God, is for ever and ever’” (Hebrews 1:7-8). And David in the forty-fifth Psalm: “Your throne, O God, is for ever and ever; a sceptre of uprightness is the sceptre of your kingdom. You have loved righteousness and hated iniquity; therefore, O God, your God has anointed you with the oil of gladness beyond your companions” (Psalm 45:6-7). See once more: his kingdom is boundless and his Godhead without beginning.

The Son’s Unending Kingdom and the Glory Owed to Him §36

36Because of his ineffable incarnation he added “your God” (Psalm 45:7). And in the hundred and forty-fifth Psalm: “Your kingdom is a kingdom of all the ages, and your dominion is in every generation and generation” (Psalm 145:13). And in the tenth Psalm: “The Lord will reign for ever and ever” (Psalm 10:16).

And to Peter the Son, as Lord, gave the keys of the kingdom: not of the present age, for we do not yet possess it, but of the age to come, the one in which the heretics guess that he even hands it over. He gave them so that those who believe his kingdom to be without beginning and without end should be admitted, and, as was said a little earlier, those should be thrust away who do not cry out with Nathanael: “You are the Son of God, you are the King of the Christians” (John 1:49).

And the prophecy of Isaiah that says, “I have seen with my eyes the King, the Lord of hosts” (Isaiah 6:5), Paul referred to the Spirit of God (Acts 28:25), and John, as was said before, to the Only-begotten (John 12:41), because the Godhead is shared and the one kingdom has no successor. For how could it even be that one rules and the other sits idle, as happens among men, when the Father abides in the Son and the Son in the Father (John 14:10), and when the Spirit proceeds from the Father (John 15:26) and abides with the Son in a divine way?

On the glorifying of the Son of God himself.

So look, then, at what the saints testify once more about his glory, those “of whom,” it says, “the world was not worthy” (Hebrews 11:38). They teach us, who on earth have been called sons by grace, to glorify the only-begotten Son, who is from the substance of the Father, with a glory equal to his, and to look to the glory that he had with the Father before the world existed (John 17:5); for the Father does not begrudge the Beloved. The divine is free from envy and from every passion.

David, in the seventy-second Psalm, which by common consent he prophesied about Christ, says: “His name shall be blessed for ever; his name shall endure before the sun, and before the moon for generations of generations. And all the tribes of the earth shall be blessed in him; all the nations shall call him blessed. Blessed be the Lord, the God of Israel, who alone does wonders; and blessed be the name of his glory for ever and for ever and ever. And the whole earth shall be filled with his glory. So be it” (Psalm 72:17-19).

He said “Blessed be the Lord, the God of Israel” in place of “glorified” or “praised.” For God is blessed by his works, that is, glorified; and he himself blesses his own creatures, that is, sanctifies them. And it should be noted that he is also God of Israel, that is, God of the fathers, just as his Father has been proclaimed.

And in the eighty-sixth Psalm, setting forth the almighty and all-powerful nature of the Only-begotten and that he ought to be glorified, he sings: “All the nations you have made shall come and worship before you, Lord, and shall glorify your name; for you are great and do wonders; you alone are God” (Psalm 86:9-10).

And in the nineteenth: “The heavens declare the glory of God” (Psalm 19:1). How? By showing, from the greatness and beauty given them, that the one who made them, God the Word, is unsurpassable and glorified. For “by the word of the Lord the heavens were made firm, and by the Spirit of his mouth all their powers” (Psalm 33:6). So they are not even put to shame by the witness of lifeless things to the glory of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.

And in the twenty-fourth: “Lift up your gates, you rulers, and be lifted up, you everlasting gates, and the King of glory shall come in” (Psalm 24:7). He bids the creation below lift up the gates at his incarnation, and the creation above at his ascension. And in the hundred and seventeenth: “Praise the Lord, all you nations, and let all the peoples praise him” (Psalm 117:1).

And Isaiah: “You shall see a king with glory” (Isaiah 33:17). And Ezekiel: “Blessed be the glory of the Lord from his place” (Ezekiel 3:12), and, “This vision is the likeness of the glory of the Lord” (Ezekiel 1:28).

Then Paul: “Claiming to be wise, they became fools, and exchanged the glory of the incorruptible God for the likeness of an image of corruptible man” (Romans 1:22-23). And again to the Romans: “Therefore he gave them up in the desires of their hearts to impurity, to the dishonouring of their bodies among themselves. They exchanged the glory of God for a lie, and worshipped and served the creature rather than the Creator, who is blessed for ever. Amen” (Romans 1:24-25). And who is the maker of all, whom he says is blessed for …

Witnesses to the Glory of Christ §37

37… the ages, if not the Only-begotten? And who are those who have exchanged his glory? Those who say, “Glory to the Father through the Son in the Holy Spirit,” who glorify him as a creature and not even as eternal King.

Then he says of the same people: “So that they are without excuse; because, although they knew God, they did not glorify him as God or give thanks, but became futile in their reasonings, and their senseless heart was darkened” (Romans 1:20-21). And who is the God who was known and yet not acknowledged by heretics, Jews and Greeks, if not God the Word, who appeared in the flesh?

In his first letter to the Corinthians, too, showing that he is Lord of glory by nature, he writes thus: “For if they had known, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory” (1 Corinthians 2:8). And elsewhere: “That at the name of Jesus Christ every knee should bow, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father” (Philippians 2:10-11), which means: he exists in the Father’s own glory.

And again: “For we see Jesus, who was made lower because of the suffering of death, crowned with glory and honour” (Hebrews 2:9). This is said in inverted order. For what he means is this: Jesus, who seemed to some to have been made lower because of the suffering of death, we see crowned with glory and honour.

But he also calls him glory, since by nature he is the radiance of the Father’s glory (Hebrews 1:3), in the words he writes: “The God of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of glory” (Ephesians 1:17). He said “God” with respect to the ineffable incarnation, and “Father” with respect to the generation that has no beginning.

And again John: “We beheld his glory, glory as of the Only-begotten from the Father, full of grace and truth” (John 1:14). And again in Mark, from the Saviour himself: “When the Son comes in the glory of his Father” (Mark 8:38), showing that his glory is equal in honour to the glory of the Father; and in Matthew: “When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all his angels with him” (Matthew 25:31).

And John, once more establishing that he is in glory and that glory is owed to him by all, said: “Though Jesus had done so many signs, the Jews did not believe in him, so that the word spoken through Isaiah might be fulfilled” (John 12:37-38): “Hearing you will hear, and you will by no means understand” (Isaiah 6:9). And a little further on he adds: “These things he said when he saw his glory, and he spoke of him” (John 12:41).

Peter too, in his first epistle: “Inasmuch as you share in the sufferings of Christ, rejoice, so that at the revelation of his glory you may also rejoice and exult” (1 Peter 4:13); and in the second: “Since his divine power has granted us all things that pertain to life and godliness, through the knowledge of him who called us by his own glory and virtue” (2 Peter 1:3). That is to say: the glory of the Only-begotten, the glory of his nature, of his miracles, of his kingdom and of the doxology itself, is like and equal to the glory of the Father, from whom he has been begotten by nature and without interval; and he has all things in himself as the Only-begotten, so that even when he became flesh he underwent no change or diminution.

So too the three youths, aglow not with the Babylonian flame but with longing for the Creator and Benefactor, and minding not so much the furnace that surrounded them as the Gehenna prepared for those who worship a creature, prompted creation to glorify the one who appeared with them in the furnace, of whom it is written, “And the appearance of the fourth is like the Son of God” (Daniel 3:25): “Bless the Lord, all you works of the Lord; sing his praise and exalt him above all for ever” (Daniel 3:57 LXX).

And when the Lord’s murderers, he says, were vexed with the children and the crowds because they glorified Jesus as God and said, “Hosanna in the highest; blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord” (Matthew 21:9), he reminded them of the Scripture that says, “Out of the mouth of infants and nursing babes you have prepared praise” (Psalm 8:2; Matthew 21:16). So he fitted this saying to himself and showed that glory is not offered to him unfittingly. And angels too, he says, …

The Son Is Worshipped; Faith in God the Father §38

38… were saying at his birth: “Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace” (Luke 2:14).

A summary on worship.

So we have seen him glorified, and we have seen him worshipped too. Both are fitting for God and owed to him, and not to a creature, as the saints cited below write. David, in the ninety-fifth Psalm: “Come, let us worship and fall down before him, and let us weep before the Lord who made us; for he is our God, and we are the people of his pasture and the sheep of his hand” (Psalm 95:6-7). And in the twenty-second: “All the ends of the earth shall remember and turn to the Lord, and all the families of the nations shall worship before him; for the kingdom is the Lord’s, and he rules over the nations” (Psalm 22:27-28). What then will they say, who share out the names separately, “God” to the Father and “Lord” to the Son, when they hear here that the Lord is worshipped, that he rules, and that the kingdom is his?

And again, in the ninth Psalm: “And I will worship you, Lord, my strength.” And in the hundred and thirty-second: “Let us worship at the place where his feet stood” (Psalm 132:7). Paul, writing from the Song of Deuteronomy: “And when he brings the Firstborn into the world, he says: And let all the angels of God worship him” (Hebrews 1:6). And the evangelist: “The magi said,” he writes, “We saw his star in the east and have come to worship him” (Matthew 2:2). And again: “Behold,” he says, “a leper came and worshipped him” (Matthew 8:2). And again in Matthew he says: “The wind ceased. And those in the boat worshipped him, saying, Truly you are the Son of God” (Matthew 14:32-33); not, he means, in the way we are sons, who have been called so by a bountiful gift. And: “A certain ruler worshipped him” (Matthew 9:18). And after his resurrection, on the mountain, he says: “The apostles, when they saw him, worshipped him” (Matthew 28:16-17).

On faith in God the Father.

Scripture, then, says many things about the Son that are, to all appearance, greater than what it says about the Father. It declares him Almighty (Revelation 1:8), Maker of the ages (Hebrews 1:2), Creator of all things (John 1:3), true God (1 John 5:20), one who has no God before him (Isaiah 43:10), above all (John 3:31), the great God, God over all (Titus 2:13; Romans 9:5), to whom no other shall be compared (Baruch 3:35), seated with the Father at his right hand (Hebrews 1:3), and dwelling in his bosom (John 1:18). It says that he is eternal life and the true light (1 John 5:20; John 1:9), Lord of all (Acts 10:36), the only Master (Jude 4) and Sovereign, whose peace has no bound but surpasses all understanding (Philippians 4:7), and whose kingdom has no end (Luke 1:33); that salvation is in no one else (Acts 4:12); and that the Father draws the worthy to the Son (John 6:44). Yet the Father is not on that account thought in any respect inferior (God forbid!), nor is his Spirit.

In the same way, when Scripture speaks of the Father in lofty terms, the Only-begotten or the Holy Spirit ought not to be reckoned lesser or unlike. For none of the things just mentioned belongs to any created power, but to the uncreated alone: to create substance, both irrational and rational, out of what is not; to give life; to forgive sins (Mark 2:10); to call creation his own; to know the Father on equal terms, as he is known by him (John 10:15); to work as the Father works (John 5:19); to be in the Father and to have the Father in himself equally (John 14:10); and to be served by angels (Matthew 4:11). And, what surpasses even these, to be attested as only-begotten Son and God, light from light, eternal life, truth and Saviour; to be present everywhere; to have all things established in him; to give the kingdom of heaven and the divine peace, which is his own, ungrudgingly to all (John 14:27); and to grant believers who call on him a sure hold on everlasting salvation.

For those who call the true Son of God and the holy and life-giving Spirit a creature, and not without beginning, do not believe in these hypostases, even if they say they do; and perhaps they do not believe in the Father either. For they transgress the commandment of the Father, who charges: “Hear, my people, and I will speak to you; Israel, I will testify to you, if you will hear me: there shall be no new god among you, nor shall you worship a foreign god” (Psalm 50:7; Psalm 81:8-9), meaning one that once was not, or one of another substance. They transgress “You shall worship the Lord your God, and him only shall you serve” (Deuteronomy 6:13; Matthew 4:10), and “You shall have no other gods besides me” (Exodus 20:3), and “Cursed is everyone who sets his hope on man” (Jeremiah 17:5), that is, on a thing made.

And they transgress this commandment of the Son as well, who says in Matthew: “No one can serve two lords” (Matthew 6:24), that is, two natures or two lordships; and in Paul, to the Romans …

The Heretics’ Doxology, and How to Read Scripture’s Theology §39

39… writing: “They worshipped and served the creature rather than the Creator” (Romans 1:25). And they transgress this command of Moses the lawgiver: “Whoever sacrifices to foreign gods, and not to the Lord alone, shall be stoned” (Exodus 22:20). Now a new and foreign god is one who is not consubstantial with God the Father and who once did not exist.

And those who say, “Glory to the Father through the Son in the Holy Spirit,” do not glorify the Son or the Spirit of God. For they send up the glory to one, through another, in another; or rather, to neither. And they do injury both to the will of the Father, who says, “My glory I will not give to another” (Isaiah 42:8), meaning to one of another nature, and who wills that the Son be honoured as he is (John 5:23), and to the tradition handed down by the Son. They fare like those who called him Christ with their mouths but struck him with their hands and cried out, “Prophesy to us, Christ: who is it that struck you?” (Matthew 26:68); the same who said, “We believe as Moses and the prophets did,” and yet crucified the very one who had been prophesied.

Since, then, God the Father too goes unheeded together with the only-begotten God, and faith in a creature is useless, able to harm rather than to save, let them consider for themselves whether their faith is free of danger while they deny salvation. For a person must be saved by believing rightly. To be saved is a fine thing, as they say; the rest is another story.

The children of Macedonius, too, do not keep the glory of the Only-begotten, any more than that of the Holy Spirit. They call him of like substance with the Father, and not of the same substance, so that he is understood to be of another substance, a similar one.

So the heretics are left with this choice. Either they must change, in their worship, the name of the Father, since among them he is not truly Father; and that of the only-begotten Son as well; and that of the Spirit of God too, as not being that either (may the holy, venerable and consubstantial Trinity, whom we glorify, pardon us for saying it!). And above all they must change their own name, and no longer be called Christians or spiritual, nor count themselves sons of one kind with their own fathers. Or else they must not estrange the true Son and his Holy Spirit from the Father’s Godhead and glory. For it is the mark of Jews to honour the Father alone, and of Greeks to worship a multitude of demons, great and small, bound by time and of other substances.

How the theology of the Scriptures is to be understood.

I, unworthy as I am, was drawn to take up the cause of the theology of the only-begotten Son and the Holy Spirit, without impairing, even in thought, the ineffable glory of God the Father. For it is well known that, even if he has not been set forth here ahead of both the divine hypostases just named, both hypostases are nevertheless from him by nature and as one in nature with him: that of the Son by way of begetting, that of his Spirit by way of procession. Rather, I was clearing away the ruinous interpretations of the heretics and showing this: that by the very means through which they seem to honour the Father more than Scripture does, they grieve him and outrage his Only-begotten and the Spirit.

More on the same subject.

The orthodox, then, must know this. Even about a small work of God (if one may dare to call any work of God small), those who wish to treat it need words; and works before words; and faith before both of these; and much reverence and the most searching reflection. All this so that, counted worthy through these things to know that even the small thing cannot be captured by the mind, but itself surpasses human efforts of thought without limit (for if it is God’s work, even if it seems small, it is great, as being God’s: “How could anyone take great things with small labours? It is foolish,” they say, “even to want it”), and that much more does the comprehension of the ineffable God himself surpass even the perception of archangels, they may withdraw from perilous inquiries, leaving the knowledge of these things to God alone, and say with the apostle: “I believed, and therefore I spoke” (2 Corinthians 4:13).

And they must understand the theology of the Scriptures in this way. When the Scriptures speak from one person, it is because of the one nature and will; when from both, it is to show the distinct subsistence of the holy and pure Trinity. So when Isaiah says, “I the Lord stretched out the heaven and made firm the earth” (Isaiah 44:24), and again, “I am, and there is no other God besides me” (Isaiah 45:5), it is because of the one Godhead and concord, as was said before. When the Holy Spirit seems not to be mentioned, it is because he is included together with God, whose Spirit he is. When the mystical teaching …

How Scripture Speaks of the Three; the Incomprehensible Trinity §40

40… the Master, in handing it down, says, “Baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 28:19), it is because the hypostases are equal in honour, equal in might and consubstantial, and yet clearly distinct. When what is said in one place of God the Father is recorded elsewhere of the Only-begotten or of the Holy Spirit, it is for the reasons given before. When the Scriptures teach in different ways that both hypostases do the same works, the same activity, it is for the reason stated before.

When, though each hypostasis was able to create and make all things, God the Father was pleased that all things should come into being through the Son, who is God, and be sanctified through the Holy Spirit, it is because of the one will of the Trinity, and to show that every good thing is supplied from it, and so that we may send up to it a common and equal thanksgiving and doxology.

When the Scriptures use the same names for the blessed Trinity, such as “God”, “Lord”, “Holy”, “Righteous”, “Good” and the like (except that “the Father” is alone and always Father, “the true Son and God” is Son and God without beginning, and “the Holy Spirit” is, without beginning, one and the same Spirit of God), it is because of their communion in nature and kingdom and all things; and this holds of the Trinity alone. When they speak in veiled terms, it is because the mystery of the faith is always guarded, revealed to the faithful alone. When they say that God the Father begot, that the Son, the Word, was begotten, and that the Holy Spirit proceeds, it is so that we may understand, as befits God, that they came forth from the hypostasis of the Father without beginning and without passion, not as creatures do, and that they are united.

When he says, “The Father who sent me is greater than I” (John 14:28), and whatever else is thought too small for the Godhead, it is because of his ineffable and voluntary economy for our sake and on your behalf. For in the Godhead neither smallness nor not being everywhere has any place.

When the Son says, “My Father has given me a commandment, what I should say and what I should speak, and I have not spoken from myself” (John 12:49), and of the Holy Spirit, “He will not speak from himself” (John 16:13), and the like, it is because of the concord of the divine hypostases, and because the teachings and gifts of the blessed Trinity are common, not at odds with one another as those of men are.

That the Holy Trinity is incomprehensible.

Those who strive to be a temple, worthy in some measure, of the Holy Spirit who dwells in the faithful (1 Corinthians 6:19), as men who once for all have the inaccessible light (1 Timothy 6:16) shining within them, glorify with equal honour, as the Master decreed in the mystagogy of baptism, the self-existent God and Father; the beloved and only-begotten Son, the Word, who is from him and coexists with him; and the Holy Spirit just named, who alone proceeded from his hypostasis, without beginning and without interval.

They do not disbelieve the consubstantiality of the Trinity, but neither do they inquire into the manner of begetting and of procession, or the difference between them. For this is unknown even to the ministering powers of heaven, ineffable, and fearful to ponder. So too is how the Holy Trinity co-subsists with itself without beginning, ever the same and in the same way; and how, seated on the eternal throne, it can look upon the depths, be heard while it is silent, and hear those who are silent; and know what is to come before it is done; and bring all things into being by a word, and faster than a word, by willing alone; and, before anyone has searched his own heart (only let it be in faith and righteousness), give at once its verdict on the request; and fit for everyone the right moment for kindness; and be slow to anger but ready to do good; and be provoked by our offences, yet remit the punishment out of its own love for mankind.

More than that, it is incomprehensible how it has one will, and speaks and bestows in common, as one; and how it looks not so much to the good health of bodies as to the contrite heart itself. And this too: how it is invisible and not to be grasped even by the eyes of the seraphim, not to be contained by word or place; without parts in its power, beyond touch, without size, untaught, without breadth, without form; all-surveying, all-hearing, and the hope of all; brighter by far than heavenly light, higher than every height beyond what can be said, and more intelligent than every mind by an infinite measure.

For how could the things of the Trinity fail to be incomprehensible to all, when it is itself the author of all things and highest above every intellectual creation, and indeed every intelligible one? Beyond it there is nothing whatever, but all things …

The Spirit’s Work and the One Divine Nature §41

41… rather beneath it, and for its sake, and under its feet as its works? For the Father, in his good pleasure, made the first beginning; the only-begotten Son fashioned; and the Spirit of God sanctified, and by his sanctification perfected, enlightened, strengthened and gave life.

He is whole in all and whole in each; all share in him and receive him whole, because of his goodness. He is not divided, he does not pass from place to place, he does not change. He breathes on all things always and alike, not in part, and keeps his own purity unstained by bodies. He shines divinely on all things and everywhere multiplies sanctification, love, peace, wisdom, joy, security and every good, since he has shone forth, subsisting in his own right, from the Father’s fountain.

Through him and because of him the God and Father draws near to us; with him the Father both is in the heavens and abides with us. Each divine hypostasis could, needing nothing further, have made all things perfectly. But the creation was brought to fullness in common by the Holy Trinity for this reason: to show that they work together, and that nothing varies between them, neither their essence nor the worship, glory and thanksgiving that we owe.

So, to present the creation as set in order by the Trinity, he sings: “By the word of the Lord the heavens were made firm, and by the spirit of his mouth all their powers” (Psalm 33:6). For he called God the Father “Lord”; the only-begotten Son “word”, through whom and by whom they were created; and “spirit” the Holy Spirit of God, who subsists in his own right, by whom they were sanctified and strengthened.

For he is the divine name, the almighty and surpassing dignity, the one named and glorified together with Father and Son; the one who sanctifies, gives life and imparts heavenly light; the one who keeps each thing abiding in its identity; the one who sounded within prophets and apostles and strengthened martyrs to stand against the cruelty of tyrants; the one who renews and sets free as Lord, and makes us sons of God as the Spirit of adoption (Romans 8:15); the one who by his illumination drives off the hosts of demons and puts the adversary to shame; the one who throws open to us the gates of heaven, leads us to the entrance of salvation, and makes us sharers in the angels’ way of life and in their hymns.

He becomes for us the path that carries us to the heavenly God and Father himself. He is the sovereign, surpassing and most serene manifestation; the fruitful, boundless and saving power; the hypostasis beyond all magnitude, beyond compare and worthy of reverence; the undefiled, chosen and all-pure glory; the divine grace that fills up what is lacking and heals what is weak; the unspeakable and everlasting goodness; the fountain of unfailing gifts and the advance of every good mind; the true disclosure of things to come and things unknown.

He is the saving seal and the divine anointing, the pledge of everlasting good things, by whom all creation, visible and invisible, rational and irrational, is strengthened. From him we have the divine rebirth, the forgiveness of lawless deeds and the covering of sins (Psalm 32:1), and kinship with God; from him come a crown for the righteous and the receiving of good things, a dwelling in heaven, life without end, and the everlasting inheritance of the kingdom of God.

Whoever shares in his fellowship through rebirth obtains the good things just named and, as the catholic epistles say, becomes a sharer in the divine nature (2 Peter 1:4). For one who has received the incorruptible and everlasting illumination stays ageless in mind, in youthfulness and gentleness, and is made like him who alone has immortality and dwells in unapproachable light (1 Timothy 6:16).

For the sacred seers of the old and the new covenant know that the Holy Spirit belongs to the one supreme divine nature. Here, for instance, is their witness.

That the Holy Spirit is of God; and on a heretical objection.

First, that he is the Spirit of God and from God, though not after …

The Prophets and Apostles Call the Spirit God’s Own §42

42… him, and that he alone knows the things of God and comes upon all, they say such things as these.

Moses in Genesis, speaking in the person of God: “My spirit shall not remain in these men for ever, because they are flesh” (Genesis 6:3). Haggai likewise, with the divine voice: “I am with you, and my spirit stands in your midst” (Haggai 2:4-5). Zechariah likewise: “But hear my words, and receive my statutes, which I command by my spirit to my servants the prophets” (Zechariah 1:6).

Isaiah, speaking from the Father to the Son: “My spirit, which is upon you, and the words which I have put in your mouth, shall not fail from your mouth or from the mouth of your seed” (Isaiah 59:21). By his seed he means the faithful, whom he also called to adoption as sons. And again, in the person of the Son: “The Spirit of the Lord is upon me” (Isaiah 61:1). That these things were brought to fulfilment in the economy of salvation Matthew stated thus: “So that what was spoken through Isaiah the prophet might be fulfilled, which says: Behold my servant, whom I have chosen, my beloved, in whom my soul is well pleased; I will put my spirit upon him” (Matthew 12:17-18). And again, in the person of the Father: “For a spirit shall go forth from me” (Isaiah 57:16 LXX).

And in Ezekiel the Most High Father calls our spirit “your” spirit, but names the Holy Spirit his own, since it proceeded from him by nature: “And I will give you a new heart and a new spirit; and I will take the heart of stone out of your flesh and give you a heart of flesh; and I will put my spirit within you” (Ezekiel 36:26-27). And in Joel: “I will pour out of my spirit upon all flesh” (Joel 2:28).

And that these things have been accomplished Paul wrote to Titus: “When our saving grace appeared, not by works that we ourselves had done, but according to his great mercy, he gave us new birth through the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit, whom he poured out on us richly through Jesus Christ” (Titus 3:4-6).

And when did he pour him out? When Christ breathed on them and said, “Receive the Holy Spirit” (John 20:22). “Poured out” is well said, too, since the Spirit proceeded from him consubstantially, like water, and is a divine ointment, as we will show at the right time in the places that suit it. And so is “upon all flesh”. For these words fit the essence of the Holy Trinity, which is shared by many together, and not a created rational nature, which cannot be shared. For nowhere was it written, nor would it be plausible to say, “I will pour out of the archangel”; but “of my spirit”, and not even that without qualification, but “upon all flesh”.

And David, too, cries out in supplication: “Do not take your holy spirit from me” (Psalm 51:11); and again: “Your holy spirit will guide me on level ground” (Psalm 143:10). And Matthew, quoting the Son: “It is not you who speak, but the Spirit of my Father who speaks in you” (Matthew 10:20); that is, not you, who are created, but the uncreated Spirit of God.

Paul, too, writes to the Corinthians in his first letter: “What eye has not seen, and ear has not heard, and has not entered the heart of man, what God has prepared for those who love him, God has revealed to us through his Spirit. For the Spirit searches all things, even the depths of God. For who among men knows the things of a man, except the spirit of the man that is in him? So also no one knows the things of God, except the Spirit of God. Now we have not received the spirit of the world, but the Spirit who is from God, so that we may know the things freely given us by God” (1 Corinthians 2:9-12).

He spoke of the good things “prepared” by God, and said that “the Spirit” “revealed” them, as one who gives together with God; and he said “his Spirit” in contrast to our spirit. And taking care once more that the Spirit should not be thought an angel or some other created spirit, he added: “We have not received the spirit of the world”, that is, one that came into being, “but the Spirit who is from God”, that is, by elimination, the one who proceeded from the hypostasis of God. And he showed that the Spirit alone knows the things of God, as Lord, and as being the same in nature with the Father. For “the servant”, as he says in the Gospel, “does not know what his master is doing” (John 15:15).

But he did not go on to say, as he did of man, “that dwells in God”, lest the God who is not composite be thought composite.

To the Ephesians: “Do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, by whom you were sealed for the day of redemption” (Ephesians 4:30). To the Romans: “You are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, if indeed the Spirit of God dwells in you; but if anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, he does not belong to him” (Romans 8:9). To the Galatians: “And because you are sons, God has sent the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, Abba, Father” (Galatians 4:6). To the Philippians: “For I know that …” (Philippians 1:19)

The Spirit of God, Uncreated and Proceeding from the Father §43

43… this will turn out for my salvation through your prayer and the supply of the Spirit of Jesus Christ” (Philippians 1:19).

Observe, then, how merely calling him “Spirit of God”, and adding “my” and “your”, has also signified this plainly: that he is uncreated and God, and that he holds the name not as something brought in from outside, but because by nature he is the very thing he is called.

And that he is written “Spirit of the Son” likewise showed his fellowship of nature with the Son, so that he should not be thought the Son’s creature. For how could the Son have created for his own Father, as though the Father did not have it from himself before, that which both is and is written “Spirit of God”? That is not only blasphemous but foolish as well. “Spirit of Christ” may be understood as “power of Christ”, in the way it is said: “Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God” (1 Corinthians 1:24). For since these blessed hypostases came forth from the nature of one Father, and not by a creative act, they are traced back to the same One.

For so that no one may suspect that he has a beginning or an end, but may truly believe, from the procession that belongs to his nature, that he is the Spirit of God, breathed forth without beginning and not made like one of the other ministering spirits, the Lord teaches in the Gospel according to John and says: “The Spirit of truth, who proceeds from the Father” (John 15:26). He did not say “is created”. For every begetting and every procession is brought about through what is equal and alike; and most of all, beyond every other, is the begetting and procession from the one Father, in the unity of his own Godhead. But among creatures the original goes before in time; with God it is not so: they subsist together and have come forth together.

In harmony with the Lord, John too proclaimed that the Holy Spirit is equal to the Father and does not differ from him. He shows that the Spirit, a partial grace of the Father, embraces, so to speak, the whole of God the Father, who cannot be circumscribed, and is found among the faithful as a partial grace, when he says: “For by this we know that we abide in him and he in us, by his Spirit, whom he has given us” (1 John 4:13). In the same way the Son said: “Whoever has seen me has seen the Father” (John 14:9); and: “I came forth from the Father” (John 16:28).

For nothing at all that falls short in essence, or in time, or in glory, can display the whole truth, or be of the same kind and have equal knowledge; nor could anyone gain a share in true Godhead through a creature. The Holy Spirit is given, not by cutting him into portions, but on the principle of participation, and so that he may not be thought to dwell in us as one different from the Father in nature or in will.

At the same time “the son of thunder” (Mark 3:17) showed that where the Holy Spirit is, God the Father is present, whose Spirit he is. God himself proclaimed this beforehand when he said: “I will dwell in them and walk among them; and I will be their God, and they shall be my people” (2 Corinthians 6:16). So again the opposite makes plain that whoever does not have the Spirit of God as true God does not have the Father either; and where he is not, there is nothing true, nothing safe, nothing firm.

So, conversely, anyone at all who speaks of him, even if he happens to be a heretic, if asked what spirit he is talking about, says, “The Holy Spirit”; and if the question is put to him again, “Which Holy Spirit?”, he must say, to make it as plain as possible, “The Spirit of God”, since the other spirits are not his in essence.

But the heretics, a trouble to themselves and to their hearers, slander with violent arguments the saints who are better than both us and them, who far surpass us, and who uttered oracles about the Holy Spirit; and no one may lay down rules against them. For they say, word for word: “When God says, ‘My servant Isaiah’ (Isaiah 20:3), and ‘Israel my firstborn son’ (Exodus 4:22), does the syllable ‘my’ show that human nature has something in common with the nature of God? Just as he said this, then,” he says, “as the cause of their being, so too he called the life of their souls ‘my spirit’.”

If they had any regard for truth and precision, they would not have stumbled so badly. For first, by the very names “Isaiah” and “Israel” he showed that they were men; and he added the “my” to them as a special honour, as men who belonged to him by their deeds. He called Isaiah “servant”, that is, a member of his household, and Israel “firstborn”, as the first to begin to worship him, and as standing in the rank of a son through God’s favour and care toward him. So the “my”, said of the …

“My Spirit”: Kinship of Nature and the Spirit’s Divine Names §44

44… true Son and the true Spirit, when God says it, shows that they are akin to him in nature; but of all the others it shows that they belong to him by lordship or by faith. So we too are used to saying, of those who share our essence, “my son, my spirit”, but of other things, “my field, my horse”, and also “my God”.

For in the same way, it is not his being called simply and without qualification Son, and Only-begotten, and Word of God, and Christ, that shows that the Word of the divine nature, who subsists in his own right, was begotten from the hypostasis of God; it is his having the syllable “my” or “your” joined to these names. So when God says, “This is my beloved Son” (Matthew 3:17), and again, “My good word” (Psalm 45:1), and, “I have prepared a lamp for my Christ” (Psalm 132:17), we in turn acclaim him: “Your Son, your Only-begotten, your Christ.”

Nor, indeed, does the fact that Scripture writes of us with the same or a like name, “Sons of men, how long will you be heavy of heart?” (Psalm 4:2), drag the Son of God away from the Godhead by the sharing of a name. So with the Holy Spirit: it is not his being called simply “spirit”, but the joining to the name of “my”, as from God, or of “your”, as from creation, or of the word “holy” or “incorruptible” or “everlasting”, that shows that he has proceeded from the Father’s hypostasis. Nor, indeed, does the fact that the ministering spirits and our own spirits are called by the same name, “holy” or “everlasting”, drag him away from being by nature the true Spirit of God.

For even in the riddles that speak of him there is always some declaration of his divine nature and power. But created things received holiness and everlastingness in the measure of their own nature, and do not possess these things by nature of themselves at all.

Otherwise, are these heretics not found accusing themselves, since they readily accept the “my” said of the Son of God, and the “holy” and the “everlasting”, as announcing that he has the same divine nature? Then, besides this, in the proofs set out above it was not the life of our souls that he named “spirit”, but his own Holy Spirit. For when we already had our own spirit, the Spirit of God was given us as well. The Father said, “My spirit shall not remain in these men” (Genesis 6:3), and the Son, “Receive the Holy Spirit” (John 20:22). And it is clear that it was to those who already had our own spirit that these words about the divine Spirit were spoken.

As the Son, then, the Word of God, is begotten as a son, so the Holy Spirit proceeds as spirit, and not by way of creation. And as there is no variation of essence, power or glory between the only-begotten Son and God the Father, but every difference, if it is right to say so, between him and creation, so it is with the one divine Spirit as well.

So it is more just not even to listen to what heretics say than to listen to it, even without accepting it.

That the divine nature of the Holy Spirit is shown by various names.

As we said at the beginning, the oracles bear witness, in the second place, that the Spirit of God has various names fit for God. To the propositions before us these names bring much further, exalted meaning, and a relation that is above all things, bound closely to the Father and the Son, and beyond the most fitting expression. They unfold, some of them, his divine nature, and others his sovereign power. They console our weakness in reaching him worthily, whether in the expression of words or in the contemplation of the mind. And they give us boldness to call him, without danger, consubstantial with God, and to trust in his sanctification.

We do not find any of the other spirits deemed worthy to be called by these names; and that which alone and by nature is all these things is no one among all things, but God.

These are the names. Holy Spirit, as is written everywhere. Spirit of holiness, and sanctifying, as Paul writes to the Romans: “Paul, a servant of Jesus Christ, called to be an apostle, set apart for the gospel of God, which he promised beforehand through his prophets in the holy Scriptures concerning his Son, who was born of the seed of David according to the flesh, who was declared Son of God in power according to the Spirit of holiness” (Romans 1:1-4). And again: “That the offering of the Gentiles may be acceptable, sanctified in the Holy Spirit” (Romans 15:16). And elsewhere: “But we ought always to give thanks to God for you, brothers beloved by the Lord, because God chose you as firstfruits for salvation in sanctification of the Spirit and faith in the truth” (2 Thessalonians 2:13).

Spirit of power and of love and of self-control, as Paul in his second letter to …

The Spirit’s Names: Love, Power, Wisdom, Faith and Grace §45

45… Timothy, wrote: “For God did not give you a spirit of slavery, but a spirit of power and of love and of self-control” (2 Timothy 1:7); and to the Romans: “I appeal to you, brothers, through our Lord Jesus Christ and through the love of the Spirit” (Romans 15:30); and elsewhere: “But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace” (Galatians 5:22).

This is like the saying “God is love” (1 John 4:8), and “He brought us over into the kingdom of the Son of his love” (Colossians 1:13); and “just as Christ loved the church” (Ephesians 5:25); and again, “the Son of God, who loved me” (Galatians 2:20). It is like, too, the saying “From now on you will see the Son of Man seated at the right hand of the power of the Father” (Matthew 26:64), and “I knew that power had gone out from me” (Luke 8:46).

He is the Spirit of wisdom and understanding, the Spirit of counsel and strength, the Spirit of knowledge and godliness, the Spirit of the fear of God (Isaiah 11:2-3), the Spirit of judgment and of burning (Isaiah 4:4), as Isaiah prophesies. So too Wisdom says, “For the spirit of wisdom is a lover of mankind” (Wisdom of Solomon 1:6). And Moses relates in Exodus: “See, God has called by name Bezalel, the son of Uri, the son of Hur, of the tribe of Judah, and has filled him with a divine spirit of wisdom and understanding and knowledge” (Exodus 31:2-3). And in Baruch: “You have forsaken the fountain of wisdom” (Baruch 3:12). And as the Proverbs teach: “God by wisdom founded the earth, and by understanding he prepared the heavens” (Proverbs 3:19). In the same way Isaiah said of God the Father, “He in his wisdom brought evils upon them” (Isaiah 31:2); and of the Only-begotten Paul said, “Christ, the power of God and the wisdom of God” (1 Corinthians 1:24); and another says, “I will bless the Lord, who gave me understanding” (Psalm 16:7).

He is the Spirit of gentleness, as Paul admonishes the Galatians: “Brothers, if anyone is caught in some trespass, you who are spiritual should restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness” (Galatians 6:1).

He is the Spirit of instruction, that is, of wisdom. For Wisdom says: “The spirit of instruction will flee from deceit, and will rise and depart from senseless thoughts” (Wisdom of Solomon 1:5).

He is the Spirit of adoption, as Paul first wrote to the Romans: “For all who are led by the Spirit of God are sons of God. For you received the spirit of adoption, in whom we cry, ‘Abba, Father’; the Spirit himself bears witness with our spirit that we are children of God” (Romans 8:14-16).

He is the Spirit of promise, as the same apostle says when he writes to the Ephesians: “In him you also, when you believed, were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise, who is the pledge of our inheritance” (Ephesians 1:13-14); and to the Galatians: “Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us, for it is written, ‘Cursed is everyone who hangs on a tree’, so that in Christ Jesus the blessing of Abraham might come to the Gentiles, so that we might receive the promise of the Spirit through faith” (Galatians 3:13-14).

He is the Spirit of faith and of revelation, as the same apostle shows the Corinthians in the second letter: “Since we have the same spirit of faith” (2 Corinthians 4:13); and again: “But God has revealed it to us through his Spirit” (1 Corinthians 2:10). This is like what he made plain to the Romans: “God is faithful, by whom you were called into the fellowship of his Son” (1 Corinthians 1:9); and like what Moses said in Deuteronomy: “And you shall know today that the Lord your God, he is God, the faithful God” (Deuteronomy 7:9); and like the psalmist: “The Lord is faithful in all his words, and holy in all his works” (Psalm 144:13 LXX).

He is the governing Spirit, the upright Spirit, as David says in his confession in the fifty-first Psalm: “Establish me with a governing spirit” (Psalm 51:12). So too the psalmist in the thirty-third: “For the word of the Lord is upright, and all his works are done in faithfulness” (Psalm 33:4); and Moses, when he says, “The Lord our God is upright, and there is no unrighteousness in him” (Psalm 92:15).

He is the Spirit of grace, as the apostle writes to the Hebrews: “He who has trampled underfoot the Son of God and outraged the Spirit of grace” (Hebrews 10:29). For the same apostle wrote of the Father, “By the grace of God I am what I am, and his grace toward me” (1 Corinthians 15:10), and of the Son, “The grace of our Lord Jesus …

Truth and Light; Shared Names Do Not Make the Spirit a Creature §46

46… Christ.”

He is the Spirit of truth, as John proclaims the good news from the Saviour: “If you love me, keep my commandments. And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Paraclete, so that the Spirit of truth may be with you for ever” (John 14:15-17). And again in his first letter: “And the Spirit is the one who bears witness, because the Spirit is the truth” (1 John 5:6). This is the same manner of speech as the Son’s saying, “I am the truth” (John 14:6).

He is divine Spirit, and the breath of the Almighty, and a lover of mankind, in the words of Job (Job 33:4) and in the words of Moses recalled a few lines above in this chapter (Exodus 31:3).

The Holy Spirit has also been hailed as light, in whom and by whom we are enlightened. So the apostle writes: “that he may give you a spirit of wisdom and of revelation in the knowledge of him, the eyes of your heart having been enlightened” (Ephesians 1:17-18). And David sings: “For with you is the fountain of life; in your light we shall see light” (Psalm 36:9), that is, in your Son, the radiance of your glory (Hebrews 1:3), your Holy Spirit. And again: “The light of your face has been set as a sign upon us, O Lord” (Psalm 4:6). For what else could the Spirit be, who proceeds from the Father, that is, from the Light? Of the Father John sang in his first letter, “God is light” (1 John 1:5), and in the Gospel, of the Only-begotten: “He was the true light, which enlightens every man coming into the world” (John 1:9), and, “I am the light, I am the life” (John 8:12; John 11:25).

Nor is it any wonder if he, being one and remaining always the same, is glorified under different titles. For since his unspeakable Godhead cannot be grasped by the words of mortals, we sing, as far as we are able, of the workings that reach us, and so we make use of different names as well.

But those who champion the doctrine of Macedonius, belonging to their heresy rather than to the truth, see nothing that agrees with the words of Scripture. With words meant to carry the hearer off, they spin the tale, in so many words, that one need not pay attention to homonyms or synonyms or likenesses of wording.

“For with God,” they say, “the name ‘good’ is woven together with ‘one God’; but in the case of the Holy Spirit, ‘one God’ is not yoked to the name ‘good’.” And again: “Man too,” they say, “is written to be good, as when it says, ‘Do good, O Lord, to the good’ (Psalm 125:4), and, ‘The good man brings good things out of his good treasure’ (Matthew 12:35).”

“In the same way,” they say, “even lifeless things are called good by the same name, as when he prophesies, ‘If you are willing and listen to me, you shall eat the good things of the land’ (Isaiah 1:19). It is said even of things that, of course, have no substance of their own: ‘It is good to give thanks to the Lord’ (Psalm 92:1).”

“Likewise,” they say, “a man too is called holy, and a grub too is called the power of God, where it is written, ‘The caterpillar, my great power’ (Joel 2:25); and the Saviour as well: ‘The powers of the heavens will be shaken’ (Matthew 24:29).”

Now this, I grant, not paying attention to homonyms and likenesses of wording, makes sense for things that differ in kind and in substance; but not for the Holy Spirit and him whose Spirit he is, nor, indeed, for the Son. For Scripture adds a safeguard of its own to the homonyms or synonyms, and sets beside them the syllable “my” or “your”, or the word “holy” or “good”. That is, it says either, as from God, “my Spirit”, or, as from David and from us, “Your good Spirit will lead me” (Psalm 143:10).

We must therefore be persuaded by what is far more profitable, I mean the scriptural testimonies already cited, and know that the Holy Spirit shares homonymy or synonymy and likenesses of wording with God and with his only-begotten Son, who are hymned under the same names, and not with the creatures, on account of the homonymy that is sometimes found in them.

For even if we were to grant that creatures share some name or word with God, they do not share his substance, nor the working of his power and sanctification. For these things do not belong to them by nature at all. Rather, “good” is ranked by comparison with evil, and “holy” by comparison with sin, or rather with passion. For what is not very evil and sinful, or given to passion, is here called good and holy.

For as wickedness and sin, that is, passion and weakness, are not found in the one Holy Spirit, since he is uncreated, so in none of the things that have come into being are the good, the holy and the powerful present in perfection, but only by participation. And where these are nowhere present in perfection, the uncreated is nowhere present.

For where there is darkness, there is no light at all; and “where there is night, there is no day.” Hence it was said even by Hermes, called Trismegistus: “It is impossible for the good to be in what comes into being; it is in the uncreated alone. And just as a share in all things has been given to matter, so too a share in the good.”

The Holy Spirit, then, is like and equal to the Father’s and …

The Spirit Holy by Nature; Angels Are Spirits Made, Not Proceeding §47

47… the Only-begotten’s Godhead. And from a judgment of these things it is shown that he is by nature holiness and goodness and power, since he is one from the one. For by their wrangling, not even the Son, who is most good and merciful by nature, will be good any longer, since he does not have “one God” joined to his name. Nor indeed will the Father, who loves mankind above all and is wholly merciful, and the Son keep the names of the Godhead just mentioned as their own marks; but by these very names they will be brought down, so to speak, as heretics are in the habit of saying, to us who share the names. Be gracious, Holy Trinity!

“But the Son,” they say, “was begotten together with his goodness and has it inborn, and all else that the Father has.” But the Holy Spirit too proceeded together with it and is good by nature, and has all that God the Father has.

If, then, their dispute were about ordinary matters or the affairs of daily life, it might well have been needful for them at times to make up some tales, and, with a cleverness that is Aristotelian, of course, and with skill in arguments, like Eunomius, to twist the matter round and cast a shadow over the truth. But as it is, Paul teaches: “If you do not believe, neither will you understand” (Isaiah 7:9 LXX), and, “The wisdom of men is foolishness with God” (1 Corinthians 3:19). We must not play the sophist with the sayings about the glorious Spirit, which are greater than human reasonings.

For blame does not harm the Holy Spirit, and the reproaches and gibes of the heretics, on whom wrong thinking has come, go no further than the ear. Rather, those who use such words will labour without end, and will do something like those who try to jeer at this light, which has its strength from the inaccessible light (1 Timothy 6:16), and to defile it with their words.

We must believe that the teaching that comes from the saints has more power to instil conviction than teaching from men. So it befits us to rebuke them, so that they may not, out of excessive goodwill toward their own heresy, drag the divine down, as far as lies with them, among the finished works of creation by their sophistries; nor through these beget a love of perdition in the simpler and less experienced, and lead them on to the desire of greater sins.

Against the heretics who say, “God is spirit” (John 4:24), “and how is the Holy Spirit the Spirit of a spirit?” and again, “Are not the angels, then, from God, and holy, and spirits of God?”

But they set aside what is simple and straightforward and complete, and they fill with ignorance the intent of the sacred words, by which God the Father wills that his Spirit be ranked with him, as the only-begotten Word is, and by which he makes sure that the Spirit is set apart from creation and stands above it; for this reason too he is hailed as thrice holy. And then they say, “How is the Holy Spirit the Spirit of a spirit?”

That this is written has been shown. But the how lies beyond our mind and reason, and even beyond the knowledge of the angels. For as God the Word was begotten from him, since he is Father, so from him and with him the Holy Spirit came forth into light. And in this above all his incomprehensibility is shown: that what appears, and is, impossible for creation is possible with him. Otherwise, what difference would there be between the nature that is uncaused and gives life and the nature that was fashioned and is given life? It is not possible that the Spirit should not be consubstantial and equal in honour with him from whom he is. That is why he is also holy by nature.

“Are not the angels, then,” they say, “from God, and holy, and spirits of God?” They are from God in that they came into being at his command, as all things did; holy once they have been sanctified, as men are; and spirits in that, compared with us, they are bodiless. They have not been called spirits of God, or from God, or proceeding from the Father, or divine, or spirits of truth, or spirits of holiness, but ministering angels and heavenly bodies, because they stand infinitely far from the uncreated Spirit of God and far beneath him. So the experienced apostle writes: “earthly bodies and heavenly bodies” (1 Corinthians 15:40).

For as the spirits of the winds are not on their level, so neither are they on the level of the Holy Spirit of God. For they were created; they did not proceed from the hypostasis of God and Father. They do not regenerate us, they do not make us divine, they do not forgive sins, they do not give life, they do not create, they do not sanctify, they do not judge; rather, they are even judged. For “you,” he says, “will judge even angels” (1 Corinthians 6:3).

Nor are the powers of the heavens like this in themselves. They are not uncircumscribed by place, nor immeasurable in extent. For when Gabriel spoke with Daniel (Daniel 9:21-22), or brought the good news to the Mother of God …

The Spirit Fills All Things; Angels Are Bounded and Serve Him §48

48… virgin (Luke 1:26-27), he was not in heaven as well in his substance, as he was in thought, but was at that time on earth only. Nor are the angels beyond the bounds of the ages; for “he who makes,” it says, “his angels spirits, and his ministers a flaming fire” (Psalm 104:4).

They do not do a single one of the things done by the Holy Spirit; rather, they serve him, as the archangel Gabriel showed when he ministered to Mary, the Mother of God, and said, “The Holy Spirit will come upon you” (Luke 1:35). Nor, then, is man their temple, as he is the temple of God and of his Spirit and of the only-begotten Son. They are not counted together with God. And the angelic hypostasis is not some single one; the angels are past numbering.

But the Holy Spirit, radiant beyond all things, came forth timelessly, of one nature and one form with it, from the ineffable, super-essential, pre-essential, universal and formless hypostasis of the Father, and he has been named divine. He is one, not multiplied, good, without envy, inaccessible, not to be circumscribed by any thought, infinite in power, unfailing, existing in a way that is his alone. He is by nature holy and the Spirit of God; he is none of the things that exist, but God, who is both in heaven and with us, the cause for all of every good thing. He is present to the whole universe without matter, without form, without change of shape.

Yet he does not depart from his ineffable seat beside the Father. He spreads out everywhere and pervades all, and dwells in all things without being mingled with them. He enters into the thoughts both of us and of those who are invisible to us, and searches all things exactly, though he knows all things (1 Corinthians 2:10). Without a voice he sounds within; he hears souls crying out within in silence, and takes pity on them all in all things without delay, and strengthens them, and gives unspeakable gladness to every nature everywhere. He holds together the frame of this universe and has all things under himself. He enlightens with divine light, and does good by his boundless working and goodness.

Those of better will he leads toward a more perfect goal. Those that are worse, and live amiss, he does not deprive of his kingly protection, which makes for concord and is undivided; instead he sets them longing for, and pondering, the consubstantial Trinity, which supplies every good thing in the universe. He works together with all who labour at what is good, while being set apart above all. So it was that to one of the apostles staying in India, to another in Spain, and to others in other places to the end of the earth, each apportioned his place by him, he imparted his own unerring and unadulterated wisdom. He did not come to this one now and to another later, nor breathe more on one and less on another, but shone upon all at once and upon each, together and distinctly, always alike, just as the Lord, too, said: “I am with you all the days until the end of the age” (Matthew 28:20).

For surely not — since they themselves transfer to God and Father the theology about the Spirit that stands in John, where he said, “God is Spirit” (John 4:24), saying that it was written so because he is spirit; and further, since it is also written, “The Spirit of our face, Christ the Lord” (Lamentations 4:20 LXX) — will they then number the Father and the Son too, as spirit, with the other ministering spirits? But if this is not so, neither is the Holy Spirit to be thought of with the other spirits. For he is not an archangel. Michael and Gabriel and those like them are archangels; and not even heretics would say that the Holy Spirit of God has been ranked after them.

Where, then, or among what kind of creatures do they think fit to rank him after all? For after God we have been taught from the Scriptures of no other rational nature than that of the many spirits and of bodies such as ours.

Further, they draw a sophistical conclusion from the passages set out above: the Father and the Son are written “true”, but the Spirit “truth”, as if this were out of tune with that. But it is the same, as was shown in the first book, and this does not differ from that.

Against those who say, “Since God the Word is only-begotten, what shall we call the Spirit?” On the Son being attested as only-begotten. The Holy Spirit is one and only; and again, the Son is the Word, the Holy Spirit is the utterance. On comparison; and that there is no example of the incomparable substance.

To this the heretics, who are most intricate and most shifty in speech (whether in mind as well I cannot say, though certainly in this too), strangers to the simpler and truer teaching, turning the same words over again and again, say: “God the Word was called only-begotten because the Holy Spirit is not from the hypostasis of the Father. For if he would not have been called only-begotten, while the …

Why the Son is only-begotten and the Spirit one and only §49

49…Holy Spirit would have been called his brother.”

So they argue, out of tune even with themselves; but the truth answers them. The Son is written “only-begotten” both because he alone was begotten from the hypostasis of the Father, and did not proceed, as the Holy Spirit does; and so that the blasphemies of heretics who call him a creature, and a son in the way we are sons, may be shut out. The Holy Spirit, too, is written to be one and only, both because he alone, in a single way, proceeded from the hypostasis of God the Father and was not begotten, as the Son was; and so that he may not be suspected of being a creature, as the other spirits are.

For the one is not two. The Spirit is not foreign to the Father’s essence, nor is he cut off from union with the One. He does not fall short of the Father, nor is there anyone more one in nature with him, or nearer to God, than the Spirit himself. Nor does he allow himself to be called a number, since he belongs to the essence of the Unity, or to be ranked with the things that were brought into being, for he is one of those who brought all things into being, with the Father and the Son. The one Holy Spirit, then, cannot be unlike the one Father or the one Son, nor like the multitude of spirits.

For while there is one God and Father, and one true Son, all of us who were made after the image have been called gods and sons through his goodness and generosity, though we are not so in truth, as the words run: “I said, You are gods, and all of you sons of the Most High” (Psalm 82:6). Just so, while there is one and only Holy Spirit of truth, many spirits are spoken of that are not by nature spirits of God.

Without stopping to look and consider how they might seem to the theologians to be saying anything consistent, they do not hesitate to bring in other harmful notions as well. And let no one blame me, before he has heard the whole argument, if I call their views harm. For he will find that what they utter runs straight against the mind of the men who spoke of God, men who received from God, as a gift, the power to excel in this very matter. For they say: “If the Holy Spirit is God, he is either Father or Son. But since he is neither of these, he is not God, any more than the other spirits are.”

We must answer them in this way. The Father is God not because he is Father, but because he is of the divine nature. The Son is God not because he is the son of just anyone, but because he is the Son and Word of God and is necessarily of his divine nature. Just so, the Holy Spirit is God not because he is simply a spirit, but because he is the one and only Holy Spirit of God and stands in his divine nature, as was said before. And though we have heard “God is one” (Romans 3:30) and “You shall worship the Lord your God, and him only shall you serve” (Matthew 4:10), we still believe that the only-begotten Word is God equally with the Father, and we worship him and serve him. In the same way we stand toward the Holy Spirit.

For in the rule given about incorruptible baptism, on which the whole order of our life and worship hangs, we were commanded to rank him with the Father and the Son, to worship and glorify him together with them, and to serve him (Matthew 28:19). This is the reasonable worship of which Paul wrote: “that you present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, well-pleasing to God, your reasonable worship” (Romans 12:1).

And though the Apostle declared that God alone is wise (Romans 16:27) and has immortality (1 Timothy 6:16), we believe that the Son likewise has immortality and is wise, since he is indistinguishable from the Father in essence, and is his Word and eternal life, as Scripture writes. So too with the Holy Spirit. He does not have immortality and wisdom by grace or by gift, as the ministering spirits do; he possesses them by nature, for he is the Spirit of wisdom. That is why it is written: “No one knows the things of the only wise One except his Spirit” (1 Corinthians 2:11). For if they should grant that these things are not so, they will either defraud God …

What Scripture says of the Father and the Son it says of the Spirit §50

50…the Word, or they will be seen to act against the Scriptures.

For nothing is ranked with the Trinity in one Godhead: not the spirits because they are called spirits, to say nothing of the profane ones; not human beings because they are called gods, for we are not gods in truth. And if they do not think that the words “to the only wise God” (Romans 16:27) and “who alone has immortality” (1 Timothy 6:16) tell against themselves, they will not be able to use anything at all to argue cleverly against the Holy Spirit. For Paul spoke in this way because the Son is the Word of God and the Holy Spirit is his Spirit, and they belong to him inseparably by nature and are referred back to one Godhead. Even among those outside it is said: “One God, self-fathered, from whom all these things came to be.”

As Paul, then, wrote of the Father to the Romans, the Galatians and Timothy, “God is one” (Romans 3:30; Galatians 3:20; 1 Timothy 2:5), so John said of the Son, “the only-begotten God, who is in the bosom of the Father” (John 1:18); and of the Holy Spirit Paul taught the Corinthians, “to another gifts of healing in the one Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:9). For oneness is proper to the divine nature, which is not multiplied. And as it was written that the Son was begotten, and he says in witness, “I came forth from the Father” (John 16:28), so it was written, and the same Lord said, “the Spirit of truth, who proceeds from the Father” (John 15:26), that is, who proceeded.

And as the Son, being God and Lord, is the Son of God and Lord, so the Holy Spirit, being God and Lord, is the Spirit of God and Lord. And as the Son is written “Word” because he exists together with the Father, in the same way the Holy Spirit is written “utterance of God” (Ephesians 6:17), and “breath of his mouth” (Psalm 33:6), and “breath of the Almighty” (Job 33:4), since, subsisting together with him, he shone forth from him; so that no one may suppose him to be outside the Godhead of the Father or of his Word. For the utterance belongs to the word, and the word to the mind; and so the saying is fulfilled, “the one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all” (Ephesians 4:6).

And as the Son is shown to be indistinguishable from the Father where it is written, “He who has seen me has seen the Father” (John 14:9), so is the Holy Spirit, by the words, “By this we know that God is in us, by his Spirit whom he has given us” (1 John 3:24). It is altogether necessary, then, since the Father is true God, that he too who shows him by his own manifestation should be true God, equal to him.

And as all things came to be through the Son (John 1:3), so by the Spirit all things were sanctified and empowered. For the apostles say: “Master, you who made heaven and earth and the sea and all that is in them, who through the Holy Spirit, by the mouth of David your servant, said” (Acts 4:24–25). And as the Only-begotten is shown to be equal in power with the Father, like him, and sovereign, according to the words, “Whatever the Father does, these things the Son also does likewise” (John 5:19), so too is the Spirit of God, according to the words, “All these things the one and the same Spirit works” (1 Corinthians 12:11).

And as Christ said of himself, “No one has known the Father except the Son” (Matthew 11:27), so the like is said of the Holy Spirit: “No one has known the things of God except the Spirit of God” (1 Corinthians 2:11). And as the Son, because he announces, was called “Messenger of great counsel” (Isaiah 9:5 LXX), so it is with the Holy Spirit too, for Scripture says: “But we received the Spirit of God, that we might know the things freely given to us by God” (1 Corinthians 2:12).

Very like “Christ the firstfruits” (1 Corinthians 15:23) is the text that says, “and having the firstfruits of the Spirit” (Romans 8:23). Matched with “May the Lord sanctify you, that you may be pure and blameless for the day of redemption” is “that the offering of the Gentiles may be acceptable, sanctified in the Holy Spirit” (Romans 15:16). And of equal weight with saying, “He who set me apart from my mother’s womb, through his grace, to reveal his Christ in me” (Galatians 1:15–16), is “God revealed it through his Spirit” (1 Corinthians 2:10).

Of equal force with saying, “Examine yourselves, whether Christ is in you” (2 Corinthians 13:5), is the saying, “We have not received the spirit of the world, but the Spirit of God” (1 Corinthians 2:12). And “Do you not know that you are the temple of God, and the Spirit of God dwells in you?” (1 Corinthians 3:16) is equal to what John wrote, “If we love one another, God abides in us. By this we know that we abide in him and he in us, by his Spirit whom he has given us” (1 John 4:12–13), and to “I and the Father will come and make our dwelling with him” (John 14:23).

And as the Holy Spirit is given through the Father and the Son, according to “I will pour out of my Spirit on all flesh” (Joel 2:28) and according to “Receive the Holy Spirit” (John 20:22), so through the Holy Spirit Christ is given, according to Paul, who writes to the Ephesians, “that he may grant you …

The Spirit speaks, sends and works as the Lord does §51

51…according to the riches of his glory, to be strengthened with power through his Spirit, so that Christ may dwell in the inner man” (Ephesians 3:16–17).

We may take as alike and equal “The word of the Lord came to such and such a prophet,” and “The Lord said,” and “Thus says the Lord Almighty,” with what Peter said in the Acts, “The Scripture had to be fulfilled, which the Holy Spirit spoke beforehand” (Acts 1:16); with what Paul said in Rome to the Jews, “Well did the Holy Spirit speak through Isaiah the prophet” (Acts 28:25); and with “But the Spirit expressly says” (1 Timothy 4:1), and “Thus says the Lord Almighty.”

Of equal honour with “the eternal God” is what Paul proclaimed: “who offered himself through the eternal Spirit” (Hebrews 9:14). Comparable with “No one can receive the Holy Spirit except from the Lord,” and with “Receive the Holy Spirit” (John 20:22), is “No one can say ‘Lord Jesus Christ’ except in the Holy Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:3).

To be “guided by the Holy Spirit into the truth” (John 16:13), that is, to be guided by the Holy Spirit into the true faith, is the same as to be guided by the Master Christ when he decrees, “baptizing them into the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 28:19). Of equal strength with the text that says, “Do we provoke the Lord to jealousy? Are we stronger than he?” (1 Corinthians 10:22), is the writing, “Do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, in whom you were sealed for the day of redemption” (Ephesians 4:30). And worded alike with “You will send forth your Spirit, and they will be created” (Psalm 104:30) is “You will send forth your word, and it will melt them” (Psalm 147:18).

On a par with saying, “The Lord bears witness to my soul that I do not lie,” is the writing, “The Spirit of truth, who proceeds from the Father, he will bear witness about me” (John 15:26), and “The Spirit bears witness to me in every city, saying” (Acts 20:23). And likened to the Master’s saying, “Behold, I send you out as sheep in the midst of wolves” (Matthew 10:16), is “So these, sent out by the Holy Spirit, went down to Seleucia” (Acts 13:4).

The writing “Since you seek proof of the Christ who speaks in me” (2 Corinthians 13:3) is equal to the writing that “they told Paul through the Spirit, Do not go up to Jerusalem” (Acts 21:4). Akin to “The Son is eternal life” is what he himself said: “The water that I will give him will become in him a spring of water leaping up to eternal life” (John 4:14). “Now this he said about the Holy Spirit, whom those who believed in him were to receive” (John 7:39). And akin to “For we have become partakers of Christ” (Hebrews 3:14) is “For it is impossible for those who were once enlightened, who have tasted the heavenly gift and become partakers of the Holy Spirit” (Hebrews 6:4).

What is said in the Acts in these words, “There appeared to the apostles tongues as of fire, divided, and they sat on each one of them, and all were filled with the Holy Spirit” (Acts 2:3–4), and what John said, “He will baptize you in the Holy Spirit and fire” (Matthew 3:11), are very like what was declared by Moses, “God is a consuming fire” (Deuteronomy 4:24), and by Isaiah, “Behold, the Lord will come as fire” (Isaiah 66:15). And the saying “You were circumcised with a circumcision not made with hands, in putting off the body of sins, in the circumcision of Christ” (Colossians 2:11) is in harmony with the written words “circumcision of the heart, in the Spirit” (Romans 2:29).

And if Peter’s words are fitly said about God, “Let each one repent of his wickedness and of the evil way, and be baptized into the name of the Lord Jesus, and he will be saved” (Acts 2:38), then his Spirit is indistinguishable from God. This is plain also from the Master’s words to the disciples, in so many words: “Wait for the promise of the Father, which you have heard, that John baptized with water for repentance, but you will be baptized in the Holy Spirit” (Acts 1:4–5). For this shows nothing other than what his other teaching on the rite of enlightenment shows: that the Holy Spirit works and is able to do the very things that the name of the Father and of his Son does, since he is of the same Godhead.

The preaching of the Son and that of the Holy Spirit are without difference and equally to be revered, as Paul writes to the Romans: “For if he who comes preaches another Jesus, whom we did not preach, or you receive a different spirit, which you did not receive” (2 Corinthians 11:4). The same proof lies in “For I will not dare to speak of anything except what Christ has worked through me to bring the Gentiles to obedience, by word and deed, in the power of signs and wonders, in the power of the Spirit of God” (Romans 15:18–19), as in “The Father who abides in me does the works himself. Believe that I am in the Father and the Father in me” (John 14:10–11). For observe that, as the Father, so too the …

The one Spirit, the utterance of God, is no creature §52

52…his Spirit abides with Christ, being inseparable in the divine nature; and that the divine works are done by the ineffable Trinity with one mind; and that, as the Father, existing in his own hypostasis, is imaged in the Only-begotten because their Godhead, that is, their essence, is without difference, in the same way the Only-begotten is imaged in the one Holy Spirit. And how many other things are set down about the divine Spirit that do not differ from what is written about God the Father and his only-begotten Son! Some of them are contained in various places of this book, through which the course of the argument has passed.

Besides, when they are questioned in turn, will they not say that Eve, and the children born of her, came from Adam? How then were the children written as begotten, while she was called neither his child nor the sister of those who were born? Yet the single and incomparable nature cannot be shown by a comparison drawn from creatures, since it remains unseen by the mind and does not allow itself even to be brought forth to the hearing or in words. For even if some small shadow of a likeness, so to speak, is found in some way, the greater part escapes and leaves the one who draws the comparison somewhere far below. An example can never be identity. It is safe to say only those things which the Scriptures have taught, to the measure of our capacity.

That the Spirit of God the Father is written to be one and only, because he is separated by nature from the other spirits and joined to the Father and his Son in the very account of essence, Paul teaches. He writes to the Corinthians in the first letter: “to another gifts of healing in the one Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:9); and again: “All these things the one and the same Spirit works, dividing to each one individually as he wills” (1 Corinthians 12:11); and again: “We were all made to drink of one Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:13). To the Ephesians he writes: “for through him we both have access in one Spirit to the Father” (Ephesians 2:18); and again: “eager to keep the unity of the Spirit” (Ephesians 4:3), that is, to take great care not to separate him from the supreme Unity and self-complete essence.

That he is also named “utterance,” they bear witness in this way. Paul writes to the Ephesians: “Taking up the whole armour of God, and the breastplate of righteousness, and the shield of faith, and the helmet of salvation, and the sword of the Spirit, which is the utterance of God” (Ephesians 6:13–17). Matthew too mentioned this sword, speaking in the person of Christ: “I did not come to bring peace, but a sword” (Matthew 10:34). He does not mean a blade, but the indescribable wisdom of the Holy Spirit, which reaches beyond peace and cuts through hardened hearts. And Paul writes to the Hebrews: “upholding all things by the utterance of his power” (Hebrews 1:3).

By what utterance? David prophesied: “By the word of the Lord the heavens were made firm, and by the Spirit of his mouth all their powers” (Psalm 33:6). And again Paul: “For it is impossible for those who were once enlightened, who have tasted the heavenly gift and become partakers of the Holy Spirit, and have tasted the good utterance of God” (Hebrews 6:4–5). And Peter: “For all flesh is as grass, and all its glory as the flower of grass. The grass withered and the flower fell, and its beauty perished; but the utterance of God abides for ever” (1 Peter 1:24–25). In the same way the Psalmist sings of the Son in the hundred and nineteenth Psalm: “For ever, O Lord, your word abides in heaven” (Psalm 119:89). For Scripture hands down many things, in a most hidden way, about the highest and most divine hypostases.

That everything proper to the Godhead is attested of the Holy Spirit, as follows.

Next, then, the Scriptures declare about the pure and inexpressible nature of the Holy Spirit such things as they declare about God the Father, who holds sway over all, and about the Son, who is beyond all and Lord of all, because he is not of another essence, nor less in power and glory. And none of these things is found to belong of itself to any created thing. For whatever a creature does have, it has as a gift bestowed by the Trinity in one Godhead. And each thing can always be recognized from what belongs to it: what it is and what it is not, whether it is God by nature or a creature. For example:

That he is not the first creature, as the heretics say, but God.

For the first creature is Satan. Creation has being, though at first it was not; and it was shown in Job which is the first thing made among rational beings, for the book speaks of the devil, who belied his nature by his conduct. But that the Holy Spirit, as “breath of the Almighty” (Job 33:4), is a creature or has any beginning at all is nowhere written. For no thing made could have existed before the Spirit who makes, and such a …

The Spirit Fills the World and Is Incorruptible §53

53… reprobate, ungrateful and profane, having shown itself such by its own will. Scripture, for its part, nowhere says that the divine Spirit has a beginning; it honours him as “Spirit of God”, “from God”, “divine” and “holy”. Nor does it mark off, in the nature of the divine hypostases, a “first of all” and an “afterwards”. What dispute, then, is left about their being in the one unbegotten Godhead and in equal honour?

That he fills the world and holds all things together.

Nothing created fills the world, or holds all things together, and is present in all things. Even the intellectual powers have a limit and a fixed quantity; for these things belong to the Godhead alone. But the greatness of the Holy Spirit cannot be broken up and has no bound; it is always everywhere, through all things and in all things. By his Godhead he fills the world and holds it together, yet by his power he cannot be contained; he measures, but is not measured. “For God does not give the Spirit by measure,” as the Saviour says in John (John 3:34). So too in Wisdom, which runs: “For you love all things that exist, and loathe none of the things you have made; for you would not have fashioned anything if you hated it. How would anything have lasted, had you not willed it, or how would what you had not called have been kept? You spare all things, because all things are yours, Master, lover of souls, and your incorruptible Spirit is in all things” (Wisdom of Solomon 11:24-26; Wisdom of Solomon 12:1). Hence we rightly name God Father of all, though he is not our Father by nature, as he is the Father of his Only-begotten.

And again: “The Spirit of the Lord has filled the world, and that which holds all things together has knowledge of the voice” (Wisdom of Solomon 1:7). That is: he has embraced the invisible and the visible creation, the intelligible and the sensible, and nothing in all the world lacks a share in his eternal oversight; that is what “holding all things together” shows. And he hears every voice, the text means, since he is God, always present in all things everywhere. He brings all the disorder of matter round into its fitting order, and he spares and cares for the things made by him, since he is by nature providence and wisdom, passing through all things, as the Father does. For who is it that has such knowledge? Isaiah says: “a spirit of knowledge and godliness” (Isaiah 11:2). And David sings: “Where shall I go from your face? And from your Spirit where shall I flee?” (Psalm 139:7).

The Master too taught that the Godhead of the Holy Spirit is not bounded by place, but is at once in heaven and on earth, and has always supplied, and still supplies, every sufficiency to creation. So he said in John: “If you love me, keep my commandments. And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Paraclete, so that the Spirit of truth may be with you, whom the world cannot receive; it does not see him or know him. But you know him, because he abides with you and will be in you” (John 14:15-17).

And so that it may be known that such testimonies too declare him to belong to the one boundless nature that is present everywhere, the saints handed down the same things about each of the other two undefiled hypostases. Jeremiah, setting it out as from God the Father: “I fill heaven and earth, says the Lord” (Jeremiah 23:24). David, singing of the Son in the hundred and forty-fifth Psalm: “And of his greatness there is no end” (Psalm 145:3). And Paul, proclaiming the same Son: “He who descended is himself also the one who ascended far above all the heavens, that he might fill all things” (Ephesians 4:10).

That he is incorruptible.

Creation is not incorruptible once and for all. It admits corruption, that is, the turning which we also call change, as the prophecy says: “He who makes all things and transforms them.” The wise men of the outsiders overheard this and say: “dissolving them into themselves, and making them grow again out of themselves.” For the bodiless rational creation has corruption by choice. God gave it an abiding nature and established it for ever and ever (Psalm 148:6); but it changes of its own choice, falls away into a worse lot, and by this very …

Creation Changes; the Spirit Is Unchangeable and Eternal §54

54… thing it is corrupted, so that on this account it loses, as it were, its title to be called eternal. For anything whatever that goes out of itself, that is, is altered, meets death, even if it lasts on in some other way: its own alteration is that death. Whatever you may conceive as having come to be afterwards is the death of what was there before. So, for instance, when wickedness turns into goodness, it is put to death by the goodness in the one from whom it has departed; and conversely, goodness is put to death by wickedness. For there are some beings that will not bear to stand always in their first station, although this was never denied them.

So it is that Peter and Jude state this plainly in their letters. Peter: “For if God did not spare the angels when they sinned, but cast them into Tartarus in chains of gloom and has kept them for the judgment of the great day, and did not spare the ancient world …” (2 Peter 2:4-5). And Jude: “And the angels who did not keep their own original rank, but abandoned their proper dwelling, he has kept under gloom in everlasting bonds for the judgment of the great day” (Jude 6).

The bodily rational creation admits alteration. It is altered in disposition, as when Judas lost his sanctification, and as Paul writes: “But the widow who lives for pleasure is dead while she lives” (1 Timothy 5:6), though she is still living out her life among men. And it is altered in substance, when it first comes to an end and then passes over into immortality. “For this corruptible,” he says, “must put on incorruption, and this mortal must put on immortality” (1 Corinthians 15:53).

The non-rational creation undergoes turning and passes away. So, when the light was turning into darkness and the water into blood, it was prophesied: “This is the change of the right hand of the Most High.” And elsewhere: “Heaven,” he says, “and earth will pass away” (Matthew 24:35). For it was prophesied that there will be new heavens and a new earth (Isaiah 65:17). And this is true: everything that has received a beginning also has an end.

But the Holy Spirit is of the ineffable nature that rules over all things, eternal and incorruptible. He is always the same and in the same respects. He alone knows and does the things of God (1 Corinthians 2:11). He guards all things: the rational beings who are perfect in faith, and the non-rational too, until the term given to the non-rational for their continuance in sameness. So by nature and by will he stands incapable of turning and change; that is, he is incorruptible. What cannot turn, that is, what is incorruptible, is at once without beginning, without end and above the ages; and what is without beginning is the Maker, not a thing made. That is why Wisdom says with full propriety: “Your incorruptible Spirit is in all things” (Wisdom of Solomon 12:1); and Peter: “in the incorruptibility of the gentle and quiet spirit” (1 Peter 3:4).

So too the Father, who is always equal to himself and like himself, admitting neither slackening toward the worse nor heightening toward the better, is spoken of by James as the one “with whom there is no variation or shadow of turning” (James 1:17), and by Paul as “the incorruptible, invisible, only wise God” (1 Timothy 1:17). In the same way the Son too was attested in the hundred and second Psalm: “But you, Lord, remain for ever” (Psalm 102:12); and again: “In the beginning, Lord, you founded the earth, and the heavens are the works of your hands. They will perish, but you remain; they will all grow old like a garment, and like a cloak you will roll them up, and they will be changed; but you are the same always, and your years will not fail” (Psalm 102:25-27; Hebrews 1:10-12).

That he is eternal.

Creation does not possess eternity once for all and in its own right. First, because it does not have it of itself: it obtained it for the time to come, from the moment it came to be, as a gift shared by the God who alone, and above the ages, exists of himself. For being good he creates, and in the end, presiding over his own work, he generously bestows eternity on it. Secondly, for the reasons explained in the chapter before this one.

But the Holy Spirit has eternity by nature, as befitted the creating and good Spirit of God, who works all things eternally, is never himself bounded, and yet can set bounds to the things made by him; and so he was honoured with this title. You may learn this, if you will follow me, in the following way. Paul writes to the Hebrews: “who through the eternal Spirit offered himself without blemish to God” (Hebrews 9:14). He means Christ the Master, who in his holy incarnation offered himself through the Holy Spirit to his own Father in our place. Peter too sounds the same note, as was already mentioned: “But the word of God remains for ever” (1 Peter 1:25). For here he calls the Spirit of God “word of God”. Indeed, because the Godhead of the Father and of the Son is the same, Paul, when he mentions them, uses the same reverent expression: “The God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ,” he says, “knows, he who is blessed for ever” (2 Corinthians 11:31); and again: “Jesus Christ yesterday and …

The Heretics’ Argument on “Eternal” Answered §55

55… today, the same for ever” (Hebrews 13:8). But what those who are hostile to the theology of the Holy Spirit have laid down on this head too cannot, simply cannot, be borne by the ear. For prejudice carries them off to the ends of the earth, and an undiscerning passion does not usually show the marks of careful examination. Still, nothing hinders us, so to speak, from hearing that very piece of plausible pleading; for in this way they would be condemned all the more.

It runs like this. If something has been called “eternal” by a shared name, it cannot for that reason be called God; rather, if anyone is God, he is the maker of eternal things. For it is written: “God is the maker of times and ages”; and again: “In many parts and in many ways God spoke of old in the prophets; in the last of the days he has spoken to us in a Son, whom he appointed heir of all things, through whom he also made the ages” (Hebrews 1:1-2). For if a thing has been called eternal, it is not bound to be named God; otherwise there will be countless gods. For it is written: “And be lifted up, eternal gates” (Psalm 24:7); and again: “Eternal years were remembered” (Psalm 77:5); and once more: “like eternal sheep”; and: “These will rise to eternal punishment” (Matthew 25:46); and elsewhere: “Those in the dust of the earth will rise, some to eternal life, and some to eternal shame” (Daniel 12:2). Are the punishment and the shame gods, then? You see into how much absurdity and impiety this sharing of the name “eternal” falls.

Now in their thoughts and words a brine floats on the surface and is mixed all through; but what follows dissolves it. As we mentioned just now, the other things, even if they did obtain the name “eternal”, not only obtained it from a point in time, but are also subject to corruption, the turning that comes from their own will; and their “eternal” is altogether unlike the divine eternal. In the same way, one who is called holy, whether angel or man, is not holy in like and equal measure with the Spirit, the holy of holies; for the Spirit is holiness and eternity entire.

Let them attend, then, to the grandeur of speech with which “eternal” has been proclaimed of the Holy Spirit, and to the fact that Paul added to it that wonderful thing, beyond the grasp of all: I mean that through the Holy Spirit the one who fashioned the ages offered himself to his own true Father on our behalf. Let them consider, too, that all the powers of the heavens are in the Holy Spirit, surely as in the fellow-creator of the Creator who needs nothing; and that the very oracles we brought forward on this head foretold the end of those eternal gates and sheep which the heretics mentioned, not to the point but for effect.

And let the difference be clear to them between what is eternal without beginning and without change, and what is eternal from a point in time and is changeable. Let it be clear that this difference is not small, nor does it lie only in the substance and in some further beauty: it is a difference in every respect. Let this too be known: the Holy Spirit, when called eternal, is to be judged alongside God the Father, who gave strength to all things, and alongside the Son, not alongside the creatures. So let them give up the worse opinion and choose the better. Instead of what they admire now, let them admire what is worth admiring, and let them fare better in the time to come; no one grudges it. And from the very points on which they hurt themselves by their boastful fault-finding, let them now carry off the profit of repentance.

For if this word was used of God the Father and of the Son as showing something worthy of God, it would be taken equally and in the same way of the Spirit of God. That is one point. Another is this: none of the “eternal” things they mentioned has been called divine, or Holy Spirit proceeding from God, or even a single being rather than a multitude. None is ranked with the Father and the Son in the divine initiation and the divine gift; nor, not to say more, has any been thought worthy of any other honour that belongs to the Godhead.

There are other points besides. God the Father was pleased that all things should be created through his Son, the Word. And what slur, as they dream, is it on his all-holy Spirit that he did not create, unless indeed, by their account, he is not ineffably a co-worker with the Creator, as the Father is? That every working and gift, creative, good and perfect, belongs to his only-begotten Son the Word and to the one Holy Spirit and is common to them, while all of it is referred back to the One from whom and with whom these blessed hypostases shone forth in a way past telling: this anyone would learn very easily who quietly examined the oracles full of wisdom, both those cited in various places of this book and those in the book before it. And Paul too, greater than human measure, set this out, affirming it plainly to the Corinthians: “But you were washed, but you were justified, but …

The Spirit Re-creates, Admits No Change, and Is Holy by Nature §56

56… you were sanctified in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ and in the Spirit of our God” (1 Corinthians 6:11). Observe, then, observe: if the name of the Son is a divine name, as indeed it is, then beyond all doubt so is the name of the Holy Spirit; for he made plain one name belonging to both. Observe too that the Holy Spirit, as he ineffably shared in creating at the beginning, now also creates anew; for “to be washed” signified “to be created anew”. And to Titus he writes: “having begotten us again through the washing of rebirth and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5). The sacred psalmist, no less, would have us know that those who already exist by birth are now being created spiritually in the divine font. For he says: “A people that is being created will praise the Lord” (Psalm 102:18).

So, then, the hypostases that have the same honour and the same working have received the same nature as their portion. They differ from one another in nothing, in Godhead or in power, and they alone can be naturally joined with the One, ranked with him, and everywhere conceived together with him. He it is who has both from himself, without beginning, on equal and like terms, united with him and bound to him in a way past speaking, though he himself is not the hypostases of the two.

Further, besides what has been said: every plea of these heretics follows the same pattern, and uses the same words, as the stale sophistry of theirs that is now in motion; we shall learn this by experience before long from the chapters themselves. For if some word, say “eternal” or “good”, which carries a divine meaning about the Trinity in unity and belongs to it wholly and perfectly, happens to have been said somewhere of a creature, with the qualification proper to a creature, they say nothing about God the Father and his Son (what indeed could they say?); but at once, most senselessly, they bring the Holy Spirit down to the creation, instead of raising him, as is most fitting, to God and the Only-begotten, whom the theologians have most aptly praised in like and equal terms with the Holy Spirit.

Now the arguments we have put forward in the chapter we are pursuing cannot, even on their own, be got past, and they suffice for the whole contest with the heretics. So either let them show (a thing very grievous even to say) that a beginning or an end of the Holy Spirit has been declared anywhere in the oracles; or that he had any road at all toward corruption, as angelic and human choice has; or else, as the saying goes, let “an ox stand on their tongue”. So much for them. I shall now pass on to the subject I set out from.

That, being unchangeable, he admits neither virtue nor vice.

The rational creation admits both virtue and vice. Among the bodiless, as we said before, we find the approved angels within virtue and those cast out within vice; and so too among beings in bodies, such as we ourselves are. But the divine Spirit is above virtue and glory, or rather is himself the spring from which the highest virtue flows, and he admits none of these, as neither does the Father nor the Son. If he does not admit them, neither is his will other than theirs; and if that is so (for he does all that the Father wills), neither is his substance other. From this, then, two things are gathered: that he is not a creature, but stands toward God the Father and his Son without any difference; and that through him we know that God, from whom he proceeded by nature, is in us too, as it is written (1 John 3:24).

That he is holy by nature, and sanctifies and justifies.

Creation is sanctified and justified by God, who is holy by nature; for it is able to receive sanctification and justification, not to bestow them. But the Holy Spirit stands apart from creation and is joined by nature to him from whom he has proceeded, the one about whom we were taught in the mysteries that “every good giving and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, with whom there is no variation or shadow of turning” (James 1:17). He cares and provides for all, even for the guilty. So he sanctifies, justifies and makes wise, and furnishes every form of heavenly virtue; but he himself is in no way found to have any capacity to be sanctified, justified or made wise by another, just as neither has the self-existent Father nor his Son, who shares his nature. For this reason too he is rightly praised as holy in himself and as “Spirit of holiness” (Romans 1:4), that is, holy by nature and of himself; as “divine Spirit”, that is, God by nature; and as “breath of the Almighty” (Job 33:4), that is, consubstantial with the Almighty, breathed forth from his hypostasis. Even one such name, then, taken alone, shows him to be consubstantial with God the Father, and sanctifying, and beyond the reach even of reason. Accordingly Paul, mighty both to speak and to set out the patterns of the faith, …

Only the Godhead is holy by nature and makes holy §57

57…set it out. In one stroke he put forward the very heading we are now pursuing, and with it the Holy Spirit’s fellowship with God the Father in the great gifts and in the rebirth of baptism. He showed too that the name “God” is one and belongs equally to the Trinity, and that God the Father, God the Son and God the Spirit, when called upon, always work with equal power. Writing to the Corinthians, he declares: “But you were washed, but you were justified, but you were sanctified in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ and in the Spirit of our God” (1 Corinthians 6:11).

That is why those who share in him, that is, those counted worthy to be sanctified, justified and made wise by him, are called “partakers of the Holy Spirit” (Hebrews 6:4), as the same apostle teaches the Hebrews. And to the Ephesians he writes: “In him you also, when you believed, were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise” (Ephesians 1:13). It is plain that those who are sealed, that is, sanctified, share in him; they are not shared in. Indeed, if the Holy Spirit or the Son were a creature, what need would there be for a creature to sanctify and to fill up what is lacking, when God the Father had already sanctified enough? We who are created know that this anointing belongs to the uncreated one. So we do not supply sanctification from our own store, but we say, “May God sanctify you.”

I will go on to another proof, agreed by all and strong, after which not even those who have trained themselves in shamelessness will be able to keep it up. The Master of the universe, after giving his command about God the Father and himself without any qualifier, “baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son” (Matthew 28:19), did not simply go on, “and of the Spirit,” but added, “the Holy.” So he did not merely avoid naming him in a lower way; he named him in a higher one. For the Spirit is by nature what the self-complete hypostases are, which the one name signified, the name under which the Spirit himself was named with them. And in the same way the Holy Spirit is established as what the Father and his Son are in Godhead, and he was named together with them. That much, as the saying goes, is plain even to a blind man.

But this belongs to a fuller theology. Still, so that it may be readily believed that it is proper to the Godhead alone to be called holy and righteous, and to be so by nature, and further to sanctify and justify its own creatures, Scripture sings of the Father in the same terms. So the Son himself says in John, “Holy Father, keep them in your name” (John 17:11), and again, “Sanctify them in your truth; your word is truth” (John 17:17), and once more, “Righteous Father” (John 17:25). So too the prophets: Ezekiel, “And let them know that I am the Lord who sanctifies them” (Ezekiel 20:12); David in the eleventh Psalm, “The Lord is righteous, and he has loved righteousness; his eyes have seen uprightness” (Psalm 11:7); and another, “And all who are sanctified are under your hands, and they are under you” (Deuteronomy 33:3). So too Paul, writing to the Thessalonians, “May the God of peace himself sanctify you completely” (1 Thessalonians 5:23); to the Romans, “It is God who justifies; who is the one who condemns?” (Romans 8:33-34); and to the Hebrews, “that the virgin may be holy in body and spirit” (1 Corinthians 7:34). He speaks as one for whom it is possible either that she, by turning of her own will, is not holy, or that she is made holy by virtue. By “spirit” he here means the settled state of the soul, and by “body” its practical activity, as Isaiah prophesies: “And those who go astray in spirit will come to understanding” (Isaiah 29:24), that is, those who go astray in deed or in settled state.

And of the Son, as when he is praised, “One is holy, one is Lord, Jesus Christ”; and as the Acts say, “They killed those who announced beforehand the coming of the Righteous One” (Acts 7:52); and as Peter said, “Christ died for sinners, the righteous for the unrighteous” (1 Peter 3:18). From such oracles, then, they ought, if they wished to act justly, to be led on to praising the Spirit as God. This they do not do. Instead they assert that the angels were not sanctified and yet are holy…

The Spirit is shared in by substance and is the Good itself §58

58…not noticing that either the angels too were sanctified, as men were, which is true, since they are created; or else they stand lower than the men who have been sanctified by God and share in him.

That he is shared in by substance, which is proper to God alone.

No creature can be shared in by the rational soul in its very substance, so as to make its dwelling in the soul; to be shared in this way is proper to God alone. But the Holy Spirit is shared in by substance, as the Father and the Son are, as was said in the first book. Here too, once the Father dwells in the worthy, why would the Son and the Holy Spirit have to burst in and run in with him, if not because of the unity of the divine nature and the fullness that comes to us? Surely no one would ever choose to say that a crowd of gods, as it were, dwells in us. It is one God, since the three hypostases are one in a unity of Godhead.

That he is good, and himself gives birth to the goodness, truth, wisdom and love found in creation; and that every good giving and every perfect gift is understood to be in him.

Creation has the good because the Trinity in one Godhead, which is the Good itself, has given it a share. To have some good by participation, according to one’s own measure, ranks second to being by nature the first and unmeasured Good itself. The good found in creation is not woven together with the one creating and first-working Good, nor ranked with it. All things desire that Good; it desires nothing. This holds even though the Gospel says, “Well done, good servant” (Matthew 25:21), and, “The good man brings forth good out of the good treasure of the heart” (Luke 6:45). For it is not speaking, so to say, of the inmost good, good in the proper sense, but of the good that is joined to creation and fitting for it.

That Good abounds, and lavishes goodness on its own works, so that by it each thing that exists may be preserved and remain in the rank it was allotted. It is the one Good, the cause of all good things for all. Through it the good here below is done. It preserves everything to which it is present, just as evil, which springs from our own choice, destroys. Even those outside the Church have seen this, and say: “The wicked have this greatest good in themselves: while they try to harm others, they are the first to reap the fruit of their own wickedness.”

But the Holy Spirit, as was said before, is the very Good that lacks nothing, the good that is whole, always and toward all, and not second to the one and first Good. On this point too he has received testimonies equal to those given the Father and the Son, as was shown in the first book. So Ezra, who spoke boldly to the divine goodness because he knew that, even if one stumbles, no harm can come from that goodness, prophesied: “And you gave your good Spirit to instruct them” (Nehemiah 9:20).

Matthew and Luke also show that the Spirit is in substance the divine goodness itself, and that “every good giving and every perfect gift” (James 1:17) is understood to be in him. The one wrote, “How much more will the Father from heaven give good things to those who ask him?” (Matthew 7:11), and the other, “How much more will the Father from heaven give the Holy Spirit to those who ask him?” (Luke 11:13). For it is proper to a changeable substance, that is, a created one, to be made good or sanctified or made wise by another, and not to be these things itself without change.

God too, in Isaiah, shows that no one will ever receive his spiritual blessings who has not first been found full of the wisdom and understanding of the Holy Spirit, when he says, “I will put my Spirit upon your seed and my blessings upon your children” (Isaiah 44:3). In keeping with this Paul wrote: “For this reason,” he says, “we also, from the day we heard, have not stopped praying for you and asking that you may be filled with the knowledge of his will in all spiritual wisdom and understanding, walking worthily of the Lord” (Colossians 1:9-10). It is clear that by “spiritual” he means “of the divine Spirit.” He means that the endless kingdom above is understood together with the Spirit of God, and is not foreign to him, because of his close bond with the Father and the Son. And again, in the same epistle, he confirms it when he writes, “For the kingdom of God is not food and drink, but righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit” (Romans 14:17).

Nor did this escape Peter. Defending himself to those who found fault with his meeting with Cornelius, he said: “If then God gave them the same gift, granting the Holy Spirit, as he did to us at the beginning, who was I, that I could hinder God?” (Acts 11:17). And again: “And God, who knows the heart, bore witness to them by giving them the Holy Spirit, just as he did to us…” (Acts 15:8).

The Spirit loves mankind and is free by nature §59

59“…and he made no distinction between us and them, cleansing their hearts by faith” (Acts 15:9). That is, the outpouring of the Holy Spirit, or, as one might put it, his unrestrained and unstinting coming upon us, is the cause of prophecy and renewal, of heavenly goods, and of seeing the beauty of divine truth. For, as the apostle holds, “the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace” (Galatians 5:22). That is why he writes again, “For the love of God has been poured out in our hearts by the Holy Spirit” (Romans 5:5).

So, though the goodness of the Trinity in unity is one, many forms of goodness are born for us. In the same way, truth and righteousness and wisdom above are one. I mean the truth of which Scripture says, “You are mighty, Lord, and your truth is round about you” (Psalm 89:8), and that truth is the only-begotten God; and the wisdom of which it says, “to the only wise God” (Romans 16:27). Yet many truths and righteousnesses and wisdoms are multiplied for us from above, as it is written: “The Lord seeks out truths” (Psalm 30:24 LXX), and, “The Lord is righteous and has loved righteous deeds” (Psalm 11:7), and, “A multitude of the wise is the salvation of the world” (Wisdom of Solomon 6:24), and, “Walk with the wise and you will be wise” (Proverbs 13:20). It is clear, then, that the Spirit of God is, in his very existence, a good Spirit, a Spirit of wisdom and truth, the Spirit of the invisible and uncompounded God and Father.

That he loves mankind.

Creation is nowhere written to be a lover of mankind, for that belongs properly to the consubstantial Trinity alone. The Father loves mankind: “He is not angry with us to the end, nor wrathful for ever; he does not deal with us according to our sins, nor repay us according to our iniquities,” as the hundred and third Psalm says (Psalm 103:9-10). And as Solomon says, “But you spare all things, because all things are yours, O Master, lover of souls” (Wisdom of Solomon 11:26), as has been said. For these reasons too he is called our Master and our Father, since his care is blended with his power. No title is more proper to God than Father, lover of mankind, good and holy.

The Son loves mankind. For our sake, who are the works of his holy hands, hands to be understood spiritually, “he emptied himself, taking the form of a servant” (Philippians 2:7). So the apostle writes to Titus: “But when the kindness and the love for mankind of God our Saviour appeared” (Titus 3:4). Whoever gives him all that befits the only-begotten God goes away having received more than he hoped for.

The Holy Spirit of God loves mankind, as Wisdom says: “For the spirit of wisdom loves mankind, and will not acquit the righteous” (Wisdom of Solomon 1:6). He did not overlook human nature as it perished. He came of his own accord, guiding us, teaching all truth, renewing us, and bestowing the divine gifts. From the beginning he took such care of the creature made after the image that he bears this title too, as a token of his surpassing goodness. Heaven, earth and sea are great elements. Great too is the rational creation of angels and of every power above the world. But the Trinity did not choose to be named from any of these. From its goodness toward man it has the name “lover of mankind.”

That he is free by nature and not a slave; and that, as God and Lord, he sets free and makes sons.

Creation is the slave of the Master who crafted it. It does not possess freedom of itself, and it cannot give freedom either to itself or to others. For the prophecy says, “All things are your slaves” (Psalm 119:91). But the Holy Spirit is not only never written as a slave; he is also written as Master and free by nature. Wherever he is, and to those he visits, he gives the freedom he has. Only things made are brought under the yoke of slavery. What is not a slave is not a thing made, and what is not a thing made is God by nature.

The apostle is a faithful witness of this. He writes to the Corinthians in the second epistle, “Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom” (2 Corinthians 3:17); to Timothy, “For God did not give us a spirit of slavery, but a spirit of power and of love and of self-control” (2 Timothy 1:7); to the Romans, “For you did not receive a spirit of slavery to fall back into fear, but a spirit of adoption, in whom we cry, ‘Abba, Father’” (Romans 8:15); and to the Galatians, “God sent the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, ‘Abba, Father.’ So you are no longer a slave, but a son” (Galatians 4:6-7). Just as we were set free by the Son when we heard, “You are no longer a slave, but free,” and, “in the freedom with which the Son set you free” (Galatians 5:1), so too, because the substance and the lordship are the same, we are set free by the Spirit, through the saying already quoted: “Where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom” (2 Corinthians 3:17).

That he commands and does not serve.

Creation, whether spiritual or perceived by the senses, serves; it does not command of itself. As is said of the angels, “mighty in strength, doing the word…” (Psalm 103:20).

The Spirit commands, empowers, does not lie, is truth, and knows the things of God §60

60“…of his” (Psalm 103:20). But the Holy Spirit of God gives commands to prophets and apostles on his own authority, as God and Master, as may be shown in the chapters below.

That he empowers.

Creation is empowered by the all-strong and all-powerful might of God, but it does not empower. It received only the power that suffices for itself, and it has no strength to share it with its fellow slaves. But the Spirit of God empowers by his fruitful, nourishing and unfailing might, since he is Creator and not creature. For the Saviour says in the Acts, “But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you” (Acts 1:8), for without his coming we have no power or hope toward God.

Two further things should be noticed here. First, the Saviour shows that the Holy Spirit came with authority. Second, the Spirit did not come as his own messenger; he was announced beforehand by the great God and Saviour himself. So again he says, “But you, stay in the city until you are clothed with power from on high” (Luke 24:49). And this was the power of the Holy Spirit.

Paul writes to the Romans words that no one can easily admire or explain as they deserve, least of all in passing: “I have, then, confidence in Christ Jesus toward God. For I will not dare to speak of anything except what Christ has worked through me, in word and deed, to bring the Gentiles to obedience, in the power of signs and wonders, in the power of the Holy Spirit” (Romans 15:17-19).

That he does not lie, which is proper to God alone.

Creation does not always speak the truth. Of its own will, as one side of its changeableness, it sometimes lies too. Among the bodiless powers the devil does; among those in the flesh, as Scripture says, “Every man is a liar” (Psalm 116:11), and, “You will destroy all who speak falsehood” (Psalm 5:6). Even those outside the Church wrote, “Father God will be no helper to liars.” And so among the saints: Paul says of the apostles, “But when I saw that they were not walking straight according to the truth of the gospel, I said to Cephas before them all” (Galatians 2:14) what he said. Truly, never to lie belongs to the divine nature alone. That is why he wrote to the Hebrews, “so that,” he says, “through two unchangeable things, in which it is impossible for God to lie, we who have fled for refuge may have strong encouragement to hold fast to the hope set before us” (Hebrews 6:18).

But the Holy Spirit’s communion with the Father and the Son is a communion in nature, so it extends to all things, and so also to never lying. For he is the Spirit of truth of God, as was said before. He speaks by the one will of the Father and the Son and himself, and does not speak from himself, as the Son bore witness of him: “He will not speak on his own” (John 16:13).

That he is truth, because he is in full accord with the one Godhead.

Nothing in creation has been called “truth,” because the divine truth is one, just as holiness and goodness are one; and from that one source, we confess, these gifts have come to each of us. But the Holy Spirit has been called “truth,” as the Father and the Son are, since he belongs to the same one Godhead and has nothing in him split into many parts or out of accord. The Son bears witness about the Father and himself when he says, “Father, your word is truth” (John 17:17), and again, “I am the life and the truth” (John 14:6); and about the Holy Spirit, as was said before.

That no one knows the things of God except the Holy Spirit (1 Corinthians 2:11); and that, because the Spirit is equal to the Father, God in turn knows the things of the Holy Spirit.

Creation does not know the things of God. They surpass it, and no creature dares to set out after such knowledge, however highly it is esteemed. To know the things of God is altogether impossible for one who is not of God’s nature and does not have the same knowledge as God. So the Saviour taught, saying in John, “The slave does not know what his lord is doing” (John 15:15); and Peter wrote, “There are things which he now announces to you through those who preached the gospel to you by the Holy Spirit sent from heaven, things into which angels long to look” (1 Peter 1:12).

But that the Holy Spirit knows, as God of one substance with the Father, the apostle wrote to the Corinthians, as was said before. And again, setting forth the Spirit’s majesty and his equality with the Father, he writes a saying of equal weight: “And he who searches the hearts knows what is the mind of the Spirit” (Romans 8:27). Saying something great about the Father, he said that the Father knows the mind of the Spirit. In the same way, setting forth the Holy Spirit’s communion with him in nature and will, and his equality in dignity and power, he wrote that the Spirit alone knows the things of the Father and searches his depths (1 Corinthians 2:10-11) and his unknown thoughts, which one must also…

Only the Son and the Spirit see the Father; the Spirit is hymned, not hymning §61

61…when the time is right, make known to those who are worthy.

As for Peter having written, as was said before, that the Spirit was sent from heaven (1 Peter 1:12), let it be understood in the way that “the Son was sent” is understood. For as that one was sent as the Word, so this one too was sent as the utterance and Spirit of God. And such expressions are set down because we know that what is said by Christ or by the Holy Spirit is said also by the Father, because of the one will. For the Spirit is not ignorant, nor is he sent as a slave; nor does he speak or act or come of himself, as a rival to God.

That no one sees God the Father except the Son alone and the Holy Spirit; and against those who say, “Is it not written, then, that the angels see the face of the Father?”

Creation does not see God the Father as he is, for to a nature other than his this is beyond its capacity and beyond its strength to bear. To creation applies the word: “No one shall see my face and live” (Exodus 33:20).

But the Scriptures say that sometimes the Son alone, and sometimes the Holy Spirit alone, sees or knows God the Father, since the Trinity is in a unity of Godhead. So the Saviour says in John: “Not that anyone has seen the Father, except him who is from God; he has seen the Father” (John 6:46). Now the Son is from God by nature by way of begetting, and the Holy Spirit by way of procession. And again: “For no one knows the Father except the Son, and anyone to whom the Son chooses to reveal him” (Matthew 11:27). So too when Paul, as was said before, writes to the Corinthians specifically about the Holy Spirit (1 Corinthians 2:11), and when Isaiah prophesies: “A spirit of wisdom and understanding, a spirit of knowledge and godliness” (Isaiah 11:2).

“Is it not written, then,” they say, “in Matthew, from the Saviour: ‘See that you do not despise one of these little ones; for I tell you that their angels in heaven always see the face of my Father who is in heaven’ (Matthew 18:10)?” Yes; but they see, not how great God is or what he is, but as much as they themselves can take in. The Only-begotten and the Holy Spirit, because the Godhead is the same, see God, who is without magnitude and without form, as he is.

That the Holy Spirit makes creation worthy of adoption, while he himself proceeds from the hypostasis of God.

When rational creation becomes worthy of renewal and adoption, it is made worthy of these by the all-powerful grace of the Holy Spirit, since he is not a creature but God, such as he is who created it in the first place.

That he does not sing hymns as the rest of creation does, since he is himself among those to whom hymns are sung.

All creation, visible and invisible, is bidden by name to sing hymns to God and exalt him for ever by the three youths, Ananias, Azarias and Misael, who were cast into the furnace in Babylon (Daniel 3:57-88 LXX). Further, the Cherubim and the divine throne, by which the Seraphim are meant here, glorify him, since they too are part of creation. For the same youths said: “Blessed are you who sit upon the Cherubim” (Daniel 3:55 LXX); and again, instead of naming the Seraphim: “And blessed are you on the throne of your kingdom, praised above all and exalted above all for ever” (Daniel 3:54 LXX). Likewise David, moved by the Holy Spirit, bids creation praise the Lord in the hundred and third and the hundred and forty-eighth Psalms (Psalm 103:20-22; Psalm 148:1-12).

But the Holy Spirit, like the Son, was not named along with them, since he too is not a thing made but the Maker; nor is he among those who sing hymns, but among those to whom hymns are sung, even by the Seraphim themselves. With great fear they stand around the divine judgment seat, covering themselves with their wings, and answering one another in turn with mouths that are never silent and a voice that never ceases, they cry “Holy” three times, for the three hypostases, and “Lord” once, for the one lordship (Isaiah 6:2-3). This, above all, shows the Godhead of the all-praised Spirit.

But the Macedonians, on their guard and as if afraid that they might ever be seen saying what befits him, or might let slip without noticing what does not befit him, without any right give themselves leave to attack even the …

The Spirit is named with the Father and the Son, never with the angels §62

62…chapter, wielding their unbridled arguments like weapons of every kind and claiming, to snatch assent: “It is written,” they say, “‘Praise the Lord, for a psalm is good; let praise be sweet to God’ (Psalm 147:1), and ‘It is good to give thanks to the Lord and to sing to your name, O Most High’ (Psalm 92:1). But nowhere, if you please, do we find, ‘Praise the Holy Spirit.’”

They must be answered like this. If you take the words you have brought forward as spoken of the Father, you throw out the Son; if as spoken of the Son, the reverse. For the Holy Spirit too both is Lord and is written as Lord, and it is not clear here of which hypostasis “Lord” is written. Consider, then, whether you have not used these texts against yourselves.

That the Holy Spirit does not sing hymns, since he is not a creature, but is hymned together with God because he is the Spirit of God, is easier to learn both from his being ranked with God and from the fact that the three youths and the sacred psalmist bid all creation by name to sing hymns, but not the Spirit of God, though the saints are accustomed to name things one by one. For if, as the heretics say, he is of a nature midway between God and the angels, and more honoured than all and higher than all, then, since he is above all a single being, they ought either to have bidden him by himself to sing hymns, or at least to have named him first and included the rest with him as a class; not, as they presumptuously guess, the very reverse.

That he is named together with the Father and the Son. And on an objection of the heretics.

Creation is not counted together with God. For what does a thing that exists in lessening have in common with him who is highest of all and beyond all excess, or a thing that came to be with him who made it? But the all-honoured Spirit, as God, is named together either with the Father and the Son, as when the Master gives the rule of baptism (Matthew 28:19), and as when the Apostle writes to the Corinthians the second time, “The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, and the love of God, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all” (2 Corinthians 13:14); or with one of their hypostases; or he is mentioned even on his own, as was said in the first book.

Starting from the teaching of the outcast and rejected Valentinus, who turned Manichee and, besides his other absurd fables, said in his madness that the divine Spirit was of an age with the angels, the Macedonians say: “Paul wrote to Timothy, ‘I charge you before God and the Lord Jesus Christ and the elect angels’ (1 Timothy 5:21); but he passed over the Holy Spirit in silence, having, so they claim, ranked him with the angels.” But this notion comes out of the abundance of their own heart (Matthew 12:34).

For even if at times no particular mention is made of the Holy Spirit, he is included with God the Father, since he is his Spirit by nature. That is exactly why there are times when either God the Father himself was not mentioned in words, but only in the believing mind, while the Son and the Holy Spirit were mentioned, or the reverse. Valentinus, indeed, who ought not even to be mentioned, called the sanctifying Spirit “Paraclete,” as the Master Christ too was called “Paraclete” from being called to our side; but the ministers who are sanctified he named “angels.”

Besides this, nowhere in Scripture do we find angels mentioned together with God in the work of creation, or in the rites of initiation, or in the giving of glory. But Paul wrote of the Holy Spirit’s fellowship with the Godhead to the Corinthians in his second letter: “The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, and the love of God the Father, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit” (2 Corinthians 13:14); and elsewhere: “If there is any fellowship of the Spirit” (Philippians 2:1).

The sacred psalmist, at any rate, proclaims how the uncreated Word and the divine Spirit differ from the ministering spirits, and that they are not of the same rank as these. Rather, by these self-complete hypostases, and through them, and for their sake, as also for the sake of God the Father, and in them, the angels were created and all things are perfected and held together. He cries out in these words: “By the word of the Lord the heavens were made firm, and by the breath of his mouth all their powers” (Psalm 33:6). For by “word” we must understand him through whom all things were made; by “breath of the mouth of the Lord,” the Holy Spirit; and by “powers of the heavens,” both their very frames and also angels, principalities, authorities and powers. And again: “Who makes his angels spirits, and his ministers a flaming fire” (Psalm 104:4).

The Apostle too contends with them, crying out: “We were made to drink of one Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:13). For as it is impossible for the radiance to be parted from the light, and wisdom from the wise, that is, the Son from the Father, so too the Holy Spirit cannot be parted from him whose Spirit he is, just as with us that which …

The Spirit shares God's names, is one, and is the water of life §63

63…we breathe. So, without noticing it, by the very arguments in which they so untimely refuse to agree with us, they are going back into the unshaken house of the beginning, from which they leapt away. They make trouble for the Apostle, who on their account, in the words of his now before us, solemnly testified before the uncreated nature and the created, much as the one who said, “I have sinned against God and against men,” and “I call heaven and earth to witness this day” (Deuteronomy 4:26; Deuteronomy 30:19), and “Hear, O heaven, and give ear, O earth” (Isaiah 1:2).

That he shares with God, who is Spirit, and with his only-begotten Son, in the names as in the substance.

Creation has names that are not shared with the names spoken of God, just as it has a nature that is not shared. But the Holy Spirit shares in the names of God because he shares in the nature too; except that the Father alone is called “Father,” because he alone begot a hypostasis, and the Son is called “Son,” and not father of an uncreated nature, because he was truly begotten but did not beget. So Scripture names the Spirit himself as well “Lord,” as ruling over all and sharing the one kingdom with the Father and the Son; “Holy,” as holy by nature himself and as making creation holy; “Incorruptible,” “Good,” “Love,” “Wisdom,” “Understanding,” as it has also called God; “Power,” because he gives power; “Righteous,” because he makes righteous, being himself without sin; “Paraclete,” as it calls the Son too; “Fire,” because he appeared to the apostles in tongues of fire (Acts 2:3). In the same way Moses says of the Father, “Our God is a consuming fire” (Deuteronomy 4:24), and John says of the Son, “He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire” (Matthew 3:11); and there are many more such names.

That he is one and not many, as creatures are.

Creation has nothing that exists in a single hypostasis, that is, in one person. For angels and archangels are many; so are the Seraphim; the Cherubim are not some single thing; principalities and authorities are spoken of, powers and dominions and thrones; the heavens are named in the plural, and so are men and the rest of the things that were made. Even sun and moon share with the multitude of the stars both in nature and in being of fire, as the first book set out more fully. But the oracles have proclaimed to us that the Holy Spirit, as not to be counted among creation, is one and the same.

That because he is consubstantial and without beginning, he is written to be the water of life, which has proceeded from the Father’s fountain.

Creation is not written to be the water of life, for it did not have everlasting life from itself, as God has, who lives without beginning. But the Holy Spirit is praised as being this by the sacred heralds who will be mentioned in what is written below, as proceeding by nature from the immortal and naturally living fountain of the Father, not as being created. For just as we said in the first book that light does not create its own radiance but begets it, so here we say that the fountain does not create the water that comes from it, but has it proceeding from itself and consubstantial with itself. For no one is the creator of his own son or spirit; otherwise he would no longer be father, nor one who has a spirit.

Jeremiah, speaking in the person of God: “Heaven was astonished at this, and the earth shuddered at this; for my people have done two evil things. They have forsaken me, the fountain of living water, and dug for themselves broken cisterns, which will not be able to hold water” (Jeremiah 2:12-13). The prophet sets out the mystery in a hidden way. For he called God “fountain,” and the Holy Spirit “living water”: the Spirit who in the font washes away all our sins, who cannot be torn away from the nature of the spiritual fountain, as neither can the stream that flows from springs.

Isaiah likewise: “I will give water in thirst to those who walk in a waterless land; I will put my Spirit upon your seed and my blessings upon your children; and they shall spring up in the midst of water like grass, and like a willow beside running water” (Isaiah 44:3-4). This too, through hidden words, has a spiritual sense. For to those, he says, who are ignorant of baptism, and for that reason “walk in a waterless land,” “I will put my Spirit,” who is able to make the font bring them to flower again like plants that love water, and “like the tree planted by the channels of the waters, which will give its fruit in its season, and its leaf will not fall” (Psalm 1:3).

And the sacred psalmist, out of necessity making the truth of the matter somewhat hidden in his words, sings in the thirty-sixth Psalm, “For with you is the fountain of life” (Psalm 36:9), and in the hundred and forty-seventh, “He will send out his word and melt them; he will blow with his Spirit, and waters will flow” (Psalm 147:18), “making glad the great city of God” (Psalm 46:4). And this city is the whole inhabited world. For, if I may put it so, what each city is to men, this, to the Almighty, is the …

Living water, and the anointing with the Spirit §64

64…inhabited world.

Baruch, weeping over the people who were in the land of the Chaldeans, who did not have the Holy Spirit, cries out: “What is it with you, Israel, that you are in the land of your enemies? You have grown old in a foreign land, you have been defiled with the dead, you have been counted with those in Hades. You have forsaken the fountain of wisdom. If you had walked in the way of God, you would have dwelt in peace for ever” (Baruch 3:10-13). By “fountain” he means God, and by “wisdom” the Holy Spirit.

John, giving the Son’s words to the Samaritan woman: “If you knew the gift of God, and who it is that is saying to you, ‘Give me a drink,’ you would have asked him, and he would have given you living water” (John 4:10). By this he means the immortal streams of the font of the Holy Spirit. For that all these things are said of the Spirit of God, the evangelist just mentioned explained in so many words. When the Saviour had said, “If anyone thirsts, let him come to me and drink. Whoever believes in me, as the Scripture has said, out of his belly will flow rivers of living water” (John 7:37-38), he at once added, “Now this he said about the Spirit, whom those who believed in him were to receive” (John 7:39).

That the Saviour was anointed with the Holy Spirit; and if the Spirit were a creature, would not the uncreated one have been anointed with his own handiwork? And that we too have his anointing.

Creation is anointed in baptism with created oil that has been made holy. The Saviour, as God, was anointed with the all-holy Spirit, who is uncreated with him, above us who are his fellows. For if the Spirit were a creature, would not the uncreated one have been anointed with his own handiwork? The witnesses are those set down below. Isaiah, speaking for the Saviour: “The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he has anointed me” (Isaiah 61:1). And David: “Therefore God, your God, has anointed you with the oil of gladness above your fellows” (Psalm 45:7). What is this “therefore”? Because, being God not made with hands, he was anointed by God, uncreated and without beginning. And he said “your God” because of his birth from a virgin.

Peter in the Acts: “You know the word that went out through all Judea and Samaria, beginning from Galilee after the baptism which John preached: Jesus of Nazareth, how God anointed him with the Holy Spirit and with power” (Acts 10:37-38). The Acts again: “They were gathered together in truth in this city against your holy servant Jesus, whom you anointed” (Acts 4:27).

The Song too speaks of this, in these words: “Your name is ointment poured out; therefore the maidens have loved you” (Song of Songs 1:3). It says that Christ bears the name of “ointment,” the name of the Paraclete, since both hypostases share the name, and in themselves give off the fragrance of the nature of God the Father. By “maidens” it means the churches in which he is glorified. Of them David too spoke in the sixty-eighth Psalm: “Rulers went in front, close behind those singing psalms, in the midst of maidens playing timbrels” (Psalm 68:25). He put it so because their faith is proclaimed far and wide, and because they ring out into all the earth with their readings and their singing of psalms.

And in the Song the Bridegroom himself, fair in his beauty, speaks chastely to each of them: “Behold, you are fair, my companion; behold, you are fair” (Song of Songs 1:15; Song of Songs 4:1). And again he sings, as it were, a wedding song: “Come from Lebanon, bride, come from Lebanon; you shall come and pass on from the beginning of faith” (Song of Songs 4:8 LXX).

That we too receive an anointing in our renewal, John writes in his first letter: “And you have an anointing from the Holy One, and you know all things” (1 John 2:20). As the Saviour was anointed in his saving dispensation, he says, so “you too have an anointing from the Holy” Spirit.

And that this saving gift has been furnished to us by the blessed Trinity in common, they teach as follows. Isaiah: “And the Lord of hosts will make for all the nations on this mountain: they shall drink wine, they shall be anointed with ointment on this mountain. Hand on all these things to the nations” (Isaiah 25:6-7 LXX). For by “mountain” he foretold the Church of God, because of the loftiness of the faith; by “wine,” the Lord’s saving blood; by “ointment,” the oil with which, once made holy, we are anointed by the priest. John, in the same first letter, about Christ: “And as for you, the anointing which you received from him abides in you, and you have no need that anyone should teach you; but as his anointing teaches you about all things” (1 John 2:27). And Paul in the second letter to the Corinthians: “Now he who establishes us with you in Christ, and has anointed us, is God, who has also sealed us and given the pledge of the Spirit in our hearts” (2 Corinthians 1:21-22).

On the divine workings and gifts of the Holy Spirit.

So then, the oracles, having shown with great generosity the divine and supreme nature of the Holy Spirit, which is above life and above mind, also, as its equal, the …

The Spirit gives life, and the one Godhead raised Christ §65

65…most caring divine working they display, in this way.

That he gives life.

He gives life, since he is the Spirit of the God who brings all things to life. So says Paul, the trumpet of the faith, writing to the Romans: “For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has set me free from the law of sin and of death” (Romans 8:2); and again: “He who raised Jesus Christ from the dead will give life also to your mortal bodies through his Spirit who dwells in you” (Romans 8:11). And to the Corinthians: “Not that we are sufficient of ourselves to reckon anything as coming from ourselves; our sufficiency is from God, who has also made us sufficient as ministers of a new covenant, not of the letter but of the Spirit. For the letter kills, but the Spirit gives life” (2 Corinthians 3:5-6). By “the letter” he meant the law of Moses, which lays down “eye for eye and tooth for tooth” (Exodus 21:24) and punishes the one who lives without understanding. By the one who “gives life” he meant the Holy Spirit of God, who has put us no longer under law but under grace (Romans 6:14), and has charged us not to repay “evil for evil” (Romans 12:17), but rather to return good for evil. “If your enemy is hungry,” he says, “feed him” (Romans 12:20). And again, to the same church: “The first Adam became a living soul; the last Adam a life-giving spirit” (1 Corinthians 15:45). And to the Galatians: “He who sows to the Spirit will from the Spirit reap eternal life” (Galatians 6:8). So too John, speaking for the Saviour: “It is the Spirit that gives life” (John 6:63).

Ezekiel shows this very thing, and shows that the Spirit, being God’s own Spirit, will bring about the resurrection together with God, when he prophesies: “Thus says the Lord to these dry bones: Behold, I am bringing into you a spirit of life. I will put sinews upon you, bring up flesh upon you and stretch skin over you; I will put my Spirit upon you, and you shall live, and you shall know that I am the Lord” (Ezekiel 37:5-6).

Life in its very being, the power that gives life, has neither beginning nor end nor change. And what is not subject to these things is God by nature and in truth, since it possesses of itself the very prerogatives of God the Father. For nothing created can be the cause of life or show life in itself; and all things deprived of the divine Spirit are dead. “For in him we live and move and are,” as the Acts of the Apostles said (Acts 17:28). Indeed, if all things that come into being are also perishable, and things that perish suffer the loss of life, how could they bestow on others what they themselves come to lack? We are given life, then, by the Holy Spirit, just as by him who said, “I am the resurrection and the life” (John 11:25).

That because the Godhead is the same and the working equal, it is written that Christ, who willingly suffered in the flesh for us, was raised at one time by the Father, at another by himself, at another by the Holy Spirit. And against a heretical statement of faith.

Because the Godhead is the same and its working one, the Scriptures say that Jesus Christ, in the form of the servant, was raised at one time by the Father, at another by himself, at another by the Holy Spirit. So the Acts: “This man God raised on the third day” (Acts 10:40). John, speaking for the Saviour: “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up” (John 2:19). “But he was speaking of the temple of his body” (John 2:21). And again: “I lay down my life, that I may take it again. No one takes it from me, but I lay it down. I have authority to lay it down, and I have authority to take it again” (John 10:17-18). Peter in his first letter: “Christ died once for sins on our behalf, the righteous for the unrighteous, that he might bring us to God, put to death in the flesh but made alive in the Spirit” (1 Peter 3:18).

That he creates and raises from the dead. With this, that to sanctify is to create, and is more needful than creating. And against a heretical statement of faith.

That he creates man, the great creature, raises him from the dead, gives him life and turns him back toward heaven; and that the earth, which had been swept down to ruin together with the lawless deeds of men, he renewed …

The Spirit creates with the Father and the Son: “Let us make man” §66

66…again and warmed it back to life: the Holy Spirit did, without toil and as if of his own accord, being fellow-creator and equal in working with God, the master craftsman who gave the earth its being in the beginning. So we are permitted to know from what these have declared. Job: “A divine Spirit made me, and the breath of the Almighty teaches me” (Job 33:4). David, in the hundred and fourth Psalm: “You will send forth your Spirit, and they shall be created, and you will renew the face of the earth” (Psalm 104:30). The apostle confirms this, writing to the Corinthians the second time: “So if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; the old things have passed away; behold, all things have become new” (2 Corinthians 5:17). And in the thirty-third Psalm: “By the word of the Lord the heavens were made firm, and by the Spirit of his mouth all their powers” (Psalm 33:6).

Do not run past what can be heard straight from these words. See rather that the Spirit of God, as creator and good God, abiding for ever, supplies the creation with a lasting friendship, has bound it fast with bonds that cannot be loosed, and has set it firm. Unshaken, he also upholds all things by his own power. See too that it is unlawful to call a creature him who creates and gives strength to the creatures of God. For the psalmist, presenting him in a hidden way as God’s fellow-worker and of one essence with God, since he is his Spirit and his finger, as was shown in the first book, prophesies in the eighth Psalm: “For I shall see the heavens, the works of your fingers” (Psalm 8:3).

Moses too, in Genesis, speaking for God the Father to the Son and to his Holy Spirit, says: “Let us make man according to our image and likeness, and let them rule over the things on the earth” (Genesis 1:26). For God did not take angels or other spirits as fellow-workers or advisers, “since the servant does not know what his master is doing” (John 15:15). Nor is he ever found to have taken a creature along with him for the work of creation, as David sings in the thirty-third Psalm: “He who fashioned their hearts by himself alone” (Psalm 33:15); and in the hundred and thirty-ninth: “My bone was not hidden from you, which you made in secret” (Psalm 139:15). And as Paul writes to the Romans: “For who has known the mind of the Lord? Or who has been his counsellor?” (Romans 11:34); that is, no one in creation. For the word “who,” being broad, makes this plain.

By not saying “Make” but “Let us make,” he showed that the Son and the Holy Spirit are not underlings, but of one power and one will; and by adding “according to our image and likeness,” that the Trinity has one essence. He showed too that this was not said to angels, who have “the image and likeness” in a measure infinitely and incomparably less, if it is safe for one who is only a man to say this of the Trinity, which has no form, no shape, and is beyond speech. Therefore the same writer of the world’s making added: “And God made man; according to the image of God he made him; male and female he made them, and he blessed them” (Genesis 1:27-28); and again: “God saw that it was good.” In these words, once more, the perfection, harmony, ordering beauty and all-embracing bounty of the self-complete Trinity, author of all that comes to be, are signified in a hidden way. For Moses, or rather God who sounded these words in his ears, did not think them fit for theatres and the crowd, but only for as many as would not sin against them. For “God made” (that is, the Son) “man according to the image of God” (that is, of the Father), “he made him; and God saw” (that is, the Spirit) “that it was good, and he blessed them,” that is, he sanctified them.

“According to the image,” as it seems to me, should be understood in this way: that from the divine breathing we have the immortal spirit, and a mind ever in motion and steering toward what it ought, and wise speech, pleasing to the one who gave it, which with faith can become the cause of the begetting of children, of life, of the raising of the dead and of the moving of mountains; and besides these, that we have also received a share in his goodness.

Then Paul too, as was said a little before: “He will give life also to our mortal bodies through his Spirit who dwells in us” (Romans 8:11). And to the Hebrews, proclaiming that the ages came into being and the creation was made firm by the Holy Spirit, and calling the Spirit the word of God, as has already been mentioned, he writes: “By faith we understand that the ages were framed by the word of God, so that what is seen did not come into being from things that appear” (Hebrews 11:3); and again: “For he upholds all things by the word of his power” (Hebrews 1:3). And the psalmist: “You made all things in wisdom” (Psalm 104:24), that is, in your Spirit and in your Son. How, then, is the divine Spirit not without beginning, and creator, and God in the proper sense? He is inseparable from him who breathed him forth and from the creator Son; he built the ages, and with them were brought forth heaven, what is in it, and everything else that is created; he bears and governs all things by his own power; he, at the very moment of the …

To sanctify is to create: the Spirit renews, and overshadowed the incarnation §67

67…coming into being of heaven, earth and sea, was borne upon the water and made it bring forth and nourish life (Genesis 1:2)? For just as Job’s saying about the Son, “who alone stretched out the heaven” (Job 9:8), does not shut out from the work of creation the Father, from whom are all things (1 Corinthians 8:6) and in whom all things hold together (Colossians 1:17), for how else could these words still be true? So neither is it holy to thrust the Spirit of God, the Spirit of wisdom and power and holiness, out of being fellow-creator with God.

And what greater proof of this could be found than that the Spirit of God, day by day, in baptism renews and sanctifies, and calls us back to the better and first pattern of life? This is shown too by its being named in the same breath as creating: so the apostle, speaking of those who are expected to be made whole by the new birth and to enjoy the achievement greatest of all, cries out: “that you may become according to the image of him who created you” (Colossians 3:10); and David too prophesies in the hundred and second Psalm: “A people being created shall praise the Lord” (Psalm 102:18). If the Spirit had no fellowship of essence, of lordship and of working with the Father and with the Son, “through whom all things came to be” (John 1:3), he would not renew and sanctify.

That is why Christ, after the resurrection, re-creating and sanctifying with the all-holy Spirit the man who had been ruined by disobedience, breathed into the faces of the disciples and said: “Receive the Holy Spirit” (John 20:22). So he fulfilled the prophecy of Nahum, which, out of an irrepressible longing for the boundless beauty of the event, tells what was still to come as if it were already being done: “He who breathes into your face has gone up from the earth, and he rescues you from affliction” (Nahum 2:1).

That to sanctify, which the divine Spirit by nature does, is also to create, David testifies when he sings: “Create in me a clean heart, O God” (Psalm 51:10); that is, sanctify me, so that I may be renewed, ruined as I am by sin. For how else could another heart have been created for him? And he joins to this: “And renew a right spirit in my inmost parts” (Psalm 51:10). This stands for: grant me your venerable Spirit, who surpasses all things, so that, he says, made pure and shown so by his sanctification, I may become his worthy temple. For only through the oversight of him and of your Son do you yourself, Master, set your seal upon us; and we receive a remedy for all evils, and come to stand in sure hopes of every eternal good. It is plain to us, then, that David asks for this Spirit to be renewed in him; otherwise how could the spirit he already had be renewed as though it were only now coming upon him?

Scripture, moreover, knowing that to sanctify is greater and more needful than to create, said of pitiable Judas, who lost his sanctification: “It would have been good for that man if he had not been born” (Matthew 26:24); because, it says, he did the most ruinous thing of all: he sold his Master, who had done him no wrong, and bartered life for pieces of silver.

And indeed, concerning the form of the servant in the ineffable dispensation, of which John says, “And the Word became flesh” (John 1:14), and Paul, “He emptied himself, taking the form of a servant” (Philippians 2:7): Solomon said, “Wisdom has built herself a house” (Proverbs 9:1), and Matthew, because the divine nature and working are the same, set it out thus: “Now the birth of Jesus Christ was in this way. When his mother Mary had been betrothed to Joseph, before they came together, she was found to be with child from the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 1:18). The archangel too said: “For what has been begotten in her is from the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 1:20); and again: “The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you; therefore the holy one to be born will be called Son of the Most High” (Luke 1:35).

We must remember, then, that because of the idle talk of the heretics the evangelist set the ‘coming into being’ of the incarnation first, and then the ‘birth’. For they disparage our proofs from Scripture and ask, in mock inquiry: “Is Christ, then, the son of the Spirit?” They hear with faith neither these words nor what he said to the apostles: “You do not know of what spirit the Son of Man is” (Luke 9:55).

If, then, because the Father is true God, his working is for that reason divine in every way and altogether, then, since the working of the Holy Spirit is seen to be equal and like to his, for that reason the Spirit too is true God. And it would be fitting to say the same of the Son. Otherwise, if the Father’s working were better than the Son’s or the Spirit’s, why would the Spirit or the Son work upon us at all, bringing the inferior power, if indeed they are unlike him, as the heretics say? But if the fulfilment brought by the Son and the Spirit is useful and saving, then unlike in no respect will be the …

The Spirit who created also renews: against the argument from craftsmen §68

68…Son or the Spirit. For neither would the Most High, who is rich in mercy (Ephesians 2:4), have borrowed from one inferior and poorer, nor would we have been worked upon in two ways, and unequally. And indeed, what sense does it make that a man should be the maker and craftsman of good things, say, or of bad, while the Spirit is not? A man does this or that by God’s permission; and out of a substance that God has supplied beforehand he fashions whatever lifeless thing he may wish, but not the substance itself, as we have already said. The Spirit, however, makes with sovereign authority, and brings substance into being out of things that are not, as fellow-worker and “breath of the Almighty” (Job 33:4).

This is why God in Ezekiel, showing that our spirit is renewed while the Holy Spirit renews, and that this is not simply a spirit but properly his own, declares: “And I will give you a new heart, and a new spirit I will give you; I will take away the heart of stone out of your flesh and give you a heart of flesh; and my Spirit I will put in you” (Ezekiel 36:26-27).

But these men, making light even of these divine words and finding themselves at a complete loss for just arguments, have at last resorted to the arts of outsiders, and try to shift onto this thing and that what has been said so clearly. For they say, in these very words: “The dead, those who are put to death, are raised only by him who created them. A painter would not repair a master builder’s work when it decays, nor would a hunter repair a shipwright’s, nor a runner a house-builder’s; no, a master builder repairs a master builder’s work, and a shipwright a shipwright’s. But the Holy Spirit,” he says, “neither raised the dead nor created. For human nature,” he says, “was created once, in Adam; no other has been created besides it, nor has it been created many times. Even Eve was created together with Adam by the common principle of nature, and was given her own form afterwards.”

But we who are orthodox, since creating and raising the dead are above all the mark of divine power, confess that the Holy Spirit, who has done these things, is God. For “by the word of the Lord the heavens were made firm, and by the Spirit of his mouth all their powers” (Psalm 33:6). And since from the beginning, when all things were being created, he was present with God and was inseparable from him in Godhead and in working, for that reason he is also present with him and named with him when they are being renewed. For, as these very men have said, to renew belonged to no other essence, that is, nature, than that of the one who created. So it is of those who exist and live as though they did not exist, but are now being created spiritually and in a more divine way, that David and Paul preach, as was said before and as we shall find in many places. Indeed, all my time would fail me if I chose to mention every passage everywhere.

If, then, it had not seemed one thing to the Scriptures and another to these men, then first, they would at some point have taken to heart the divine writings recalled in this book and in the one before it. For what would they say, when they heard them, that the one who uttered these oracles teaches? Second, they would have reasoned that, just as the Father is co-maker by his good pleasure when the Son creates, so too is his Spirit. And they would not have dragged the things of the blessed Trinity, which mingles with nothing and which made us too, craftsmen of words and of the shaping of materials, into comparison with things unlike it: things that need one another’s help and the help of time, and do not carry out their purpose readily and blamelessly in every respect. So they say what they ought never to have said. For what could we say (and how great are we?) to God the Father, who had but once to will it, and all things came to be through the Son, the Word?

Certainly, of him who is of the seed of David according to the flesh (Romans 1:3), of Abraham, and of the root of Jesse (Isaiah 11:10), it has been proclaimed, as was said just now: “For what has been begotten in her is from the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 1:20); so that from this too it may be agreed that the sanctifying Spirit was fellow-worker with the Creator who works good. That is why it is written again: “Jesus was led in the Spirit into the wilderness” (Luke 4:1); for the guiding Spirit was with him, as God with God, and as one who holds all things together and is present everywhere, with him on whom all things are founded, who is in all things and fills all things. Otherwise, by their reasoning and their way of arguing, neither would the Father be creator or raiser of the dead. For all things came to be through the Son (John 1:3), without toil; for toil is a passion, and passion is a road to corruption.

We say these things without denying that the Master took flesh, without sin, from the nature of Adam, that is, from the Virgin, in other words from our own nature. Rather, we even confirm it by saying that from …

The Spirit saves, frees from death and forgives sins §69

69…of the Holy Spirit he was born. For, as has been said, at the beginning too the Spirit of God, who is before the ages and before the world, was present with the maker of our nature, not as with one who needed help, but in sameness and equality of Godhead and of will, like light not cut off from light.

So, Macedonian, either agree with the saints, who do not call the divine Spirit a creature but say that he has proceeded from God, as his Spirit by nature; or else, since it is your habit to claim that he is lesser than God by nature but greater than the angels, having been allotted some middle nature and rank, show us that the saints have declared this as an oracle. For their words are rightly honoured by God above yours and above those of Arius. You are not free, as the law of rhetorical art and of sophistry allows, to grow bold and let fly arguments of your own against the divine Spirit. You could not have caught sight of his divine nature in even the smallest measure, not even if you had eyes of the mind as many and of such a kind as Scripture gave to the cherubim. For who can lay hold of the invisible Godhead that nothing can contain? Or else condemn your own impiety, give way to us, and withdraw from the contest for first place.

That he sanctifies and justifies.

But let us come back again to the subject we began with: that he sanctifies and justifies, as we said before.

That he supplies salvation.

He supplies salvation even to those who have gone astray, and this belongs to the almighty essence alone. For without God it is impossible for a created thing to do anything, “not even so much as to open the bright circles of the eyelids.” For the Apostle spoke to the Philippians in these words: “For I know that this will turn out for my salvation through your prayer and the supply of the Spirit of Jesus Christ” (Philippians 1:19). So it is sung of the Father in Hosea: “Besides me you shall know no other, and there is none who saves except me” (Hosea 13:4); and of the Son in the Acts: “And there is salvation in no one else. For there is no other name under heaven given among men by which one must be saved” (Acts 4:12).

That he frees from death and forgives sins.

He frees from death and forgives sins, since from the root of the Father’s essence he bears immortality and mercy as his fruit. But a creature cannot either be sinless or do one of these things by its own power. For none of the spirits, as was shown earlier, is sinless; nor perhaps, to put it in the strongest terms, is the creation that is not rational. For even heaven itself and the sun are not blameless beside the purity of God.

For even if apostles at times appear to have done some such thing, they did not prevail by their own power, but by the power of him who said, “In my name you will do greater things than these” (John 14:12), and by the power of the Spirit of the Father who spoke in them (Matthew 10:20), as Paul teaches the Romans: “For the law of the Spirit in Christ Jesus has set me free from the law of sin and of death” (Romans 8:2). And in John the Master, giving back to us the Holy Spirit whom we had lost through the ancient disobedience, breathed into the faces of the disciples and said: “Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained” (John 20:22–23). Here the sovereign freedom of the ever-remembered Spirit is so great that he both forgives sins by himself, and in his name and by his power the apostles and all who believe in him grant forgiveness of sins.

That it belongs to God alone to show mercy to sinners, glorious sayings of God make plain. “I,” he says, “am he who blots out your sins” (Isaiah 43:25); and, “If your sins are like crimson, I will make them white as snow; and if they are like scarlet, I will make them white as wool” (Isaiah 1:18). And the Saviour too, as the Son of God, said to the paralytic, “Child, your sins are forgiven you” (Mark 2:5); and, “Behold the Lamb of God, who takes away the sins of the world” (John 1:29).

That he works together with the Father and the Son; and that Christ did signs and wonders and cast out demons in the power of the Spirit, because of the …

The Spirit works with the Father and the Son, and speaks as God §70

70…inseparability of the Godhead.

He works together with God the Father, who lacks nothing and gives all things, and with his Son, and with them he supplies all things to all, never putting it off until tomorrow. For he is the Spirit of the Father, sharing his knowledge and one with him in mind; his being and his reigning with the Father cannot be taken from him, and he has received as his share the Godhead of the Father, from whom he came forth, subsisting together with him.

And Christ, who holds all authority and all power, did the signs and the wonders and cast out demons with the power of his own most holy Spirit, as the sacred teachers have explained. Micah says: “Thus says the Lord concerning the prophets who lead my people astray” (Micah 3:5); and a little later he adds: “For there will be no one who hears them, unless I fill them with strength in the Spirit of the Lord, and of judgment and of might” (Micah 3:7–8). So he said that the Lord works strength in the Spirit of the Lord, to show both the Trinity and the bond of its nature. And he hints at the judgment, in which there is no longer any repentance, and no one who hears. “For in Hades,” he says, “who will confess you?” (Psalm 6:5). And “I will fill them with strength” stands for “I will make a great requital with the divine Spirit.”

Paul, the most approved of the apostles, writes to the Ephesians: “For this reason I bow my knees to God the Father, from whom every family in heaven and on earth is named, that he may grant you, according to the riches of his glory, to be strengthened with power through his Spirit in the inner man, so that Christ may dwell in you” (Ephesians 3:14–17); and to the Romans: “I have, then, confidence in Christ Jesus toward God. For I do not dare to speak of anything that Christ has not worked through me, by word and deed, for the obedience of the Gentiles, in the power of signs and wonders, in the power of the Holy Spirit” (Romans 15:17–19). Hypostases alike in nature are worthy of like honour. So this saying too comes close to the words “Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God” (1 Corinthians 1:24). Matthew reports from the Saviour: “But if I cast out the demons by the Spirit of God, then the kingdom of God has come upon you” (Matthew 12:28).

And how he works together with them in enlightenment: it is impossible, then, to be one in accord and in working when the essence is not one. And that is why the Master says at one time, “The Father who dwells in me does the works himself” (John 14:10), and at another, as was just said, “I cast out the demons by the Spirit of God” (Matthew 12:28). And that is why Paul too said “in the power of the Holy Spirit” (Romans 15:19), confessing that it was by the divine working of the Trinity that they raised the dead: he himself Eutychus (Acts 20:9–12), and Peter Tabitha (Acts 9:40).

That as God the Father does, so the Holy Spirit too gives revelation, and so is shown to be God and Master.

As God the Father does, so the Holy Spirit too gives revelation, and so is shown to be God and Master, as Luke declares: “There was a man in Jerusalem whose name was Simeon; and this man was righteous and devout, waiting for the consolation of Israel; and the Holy Spirit was upon him. And it had been revealed to him by the Holy Spirit that he would not see death before he had seen the Lord’s Christ. And he was led by the Spirit into the temple. And when the parents brought in the child Jesus, to do for him according to the custom of the law, he took him up in his arms, and blessed God and said: ‘Now, Master, you let your servant depart in peace, according to your word; for my eyes have seen your salvation’” (Luke 2:25–30).

So the Holy Spirit gave the revelation. Simeon took Christ into his arms as the revelation had said. He blessed the one who had revealed it, that is, he glorified the Holy Spirit, having seen the salvation that brought the oracle to its fulfilment. And the very one who had revealed it to him he called God and Master. God the Father also gave revelation, when he declared himself to Job: “Do you think I have answered you for any other reason than that you might be shown to be righteous?” (Job 40:8 LXX).

But those who have trained themselves to fight against the true Spirit of God gather from every part of the subject things that belong to other matters and contribute nothing to theology, so as to cast a shadow over the truth. They do not take up precisely what befits the divine mystery and fits the subject, and against this chapter too they bring forward words of Scripture that have no bearing on it. Up and down they repeat, as if it were a great and evident point, that cold and deceitful saying: “From such testimonies,” he says, “the Holy Spirit is brought down to the nature of an angel, since the angels too are seen to give revelation.” And so, out of absurd arguments of their own, they drag the right meanings of Scripture into upheaval. “For it is written,” he says, “in the Acts of the Apostles: ‘Cornelius, a centurion, …

The angel learns what the Spirit reveals §71

71…a righteous man who fears God, well spoken of by the whole nation of the Jews, received a revelation from a holy angel to send for you to come to his house and to hear words from you’” (Acts 10:22). As for you, if you had kept silent and stitched shut your slandering mouths, you would have done yourselves far more good.

But we refer this chapter too to the more perfect aim; we give good cheer to those who will read it, and we instil a greater zeal for the orthodox faith. So we say that, just as a creature has no communion of nature with the uncreated nature, so neither has it communion in giving revelation. For the angel announces whatever he is moved by the Holy Spirit to say without knowing it himself, and that is why his name is “angel,” that is, messenger. But the Holy Spirit, since he knows all the things of God, as Paul affirms (1 Corinthians 2:10–11), gives revelation in the manner of God, as the Father does: whatever he sees with the sleepless eyes of the Godhead that he wills, and that the Father and the Son will. He does not do it as a servant, as the angel of the guard does. “For the servant does not know what his master is doing” (John 15:15); nor indeed can one of another essence possess the same knowledge as one who is of a different essence. For to each nature belong the knowledge and the memory proper to it; and even what a created nature has come to know sometimes flies away with time.

That is why here too these unfair men have deliberately left out the beginning of the passage in the heat of their argument. For it runs: “While Peter was pondering the matter, the Holy Spirit said to him: ‘Behold, three men are looking for you. Rise, then, and go with them without any doubting, for I have sent them.’ And Peter went down to the men and said: ‘Behold, I am the one you are looking for. What is the reason you have come?’ And they said: ‘Cornelius, a centurion, a righteous man’” (Acts 10:19–22), and the rest, as set out above. So, before fair judges, here too the angel is plainly seen to have learned the oracle from the Holy Spirit. For to foretell without error is the distinctive mark of the Godhead; and this is for the good of those who hear, so that, being made secure, they may be saved.

Then do you not see that by bringing in such ideas you somehow begrudge the creation, and find fault, as it were, with him who out of his generosity adorned his own works with the words spoken of himself? For his grace surely goes with such a gift. And by this he in no way dishonoured himself; rather he showed himself worthy of praise, and, as is his custom, made his works shine.

As for us: even though the Holy Spirit’s giving of revelation lends a certain divine majesty to the whole subject, and is enough as testimony when taken by itself, we have still brought forward not that alone, but a whole host of other lofty and indisputable proofs. If you attend to them without hostility, you will surely be more speechless than the fish.

Paul too, then, refutes your plausible trickery most clearly, writing to the Ephesians: “To me, who am less than the least of all the saints, this grace was given: to preach among the Gentiles the unsearchable riches of Christ, and to bring to light for all what is the plan of the mystery hidden from the ages in God, who created all things, so that the manifold wisdom of God might now be made known through the church to the principalities and the powers in the heavenly places” (Ephesians 3:8–10). Consider, then, how far the nature of the angels is removed from knowing anything of the future by itself, and from giving revelation: it learns the great things even through the church of God in this world, which is ourselves. And what he wrote to the Colossians can also help somewhat to persuade on this point. He writes: “This mystery, which was hidden before the ages and from the generations, but has now been revealed to his saints” (Colossians 1:26). For before this, he means, it was known to God alone.

Besides these, there is what Peter declared, as was said before, about the things that brought benefit to all men (I mean the things of the unspeakable plan of salvation), in these words: “Into which,” he says, “angels long to look” (1 Peter 1:12). But if they had some innate knowledge, they would not long even to peer into it. Since they do not have it, they fall, in a way, as men do, into an overwhelming desire for things whose knowledge is not within their reach. For it is natural in other matters too that what is easy to find is overlooked, while what is rarer is prized. And yet this too is not by any choice of their own; rather, by the common law of their nature some of them, though I do not say all, are subject to it. “For if,” he says, “God did not spare angels when they sinned” (2 Peter 2:4), what innate knowledge of the …

The Spirit reveals as King, the angels as servants; an address to the archangels §72

72…things to come, or what sovereign right to give revelation, can they have, as God has? These angels do not know things of themselves, nor do they give revelation by any authority of their own; the fact proves itself even without any argument. If, then, because the one word alone is said of both in common, you have sounded the call to blame and accusation, you have acted rashly and without thought, and not even to the point. For even if some others should happen to say of God the Father that he gives revelation and that he is good, it would not be fitting for us to say the opposite.

Let me tell you something else as well: “Consider whether, by the angel who gave revelation to the centurion, Scripture did not mean the Saviour, the Holy of Holies. For in using this name Scripture appears to speak of him in a hidden way, with great and divine emphasis, because as Son and Word he announced the Father’s will in the plan of salvation. For it did not name him, as it usually does: Michael, Gabriel, or so-and-so.”

What, then, in all our arguments could anyone reasonably charge? And what fault could he find with the faith of the orthodox, which gives no ground anywhere for being called to account? And how is it not right to believe that the Holy Spirit gives revelation royally, that is, as God does, while the angels do so as ministers, that is, as servants? As it is hard, then, as the saying goes, to hold the tiller for one who has no skill in steering, so it is hard also to teach for one to whom the grace of the divine Spirit is not present, the grace that works the salvation of men together with the Father and the Son; for one who does not know the certainty that is found even in the riddles of the sacred oracles, nor the answer given from the understanding of faithful men; and for one whose speech never comes out without a contentious, contradicting and shifting intent.

But I know clearly, O glorious angels of God, who dwell in the heavenly light, that you, being blameless and perfect, were not offended at what I have said about the angels who are like you in nature, though not in the praiseworthiness of their will. Blame has followed them from the beginning, and they seem to you, above all, to be unpersuasive in their struggle against the truth. For my discourse is on behalf of the divine Spirit, who enlightens all things and lavishes on creatures divine gifts that rival those of the Father and his Only-begotten; who sanctified you too, and is glorified by you together with the Father and the Son in the thrice-holy hymn. Better still, you nodded your assent with me when I acclaimed this Spirit of the hypostasis of God as one and only, and as God.

And you would perhaps wish (and in this part my book keeps festival for me), out of the abundance of your goodwill toward the venerable and consubstantial Trinity, that the words spoken from the meaning of the Scriptures by many, and now by me, were your own, that silence might never be laid upon them, and that all men would spend the leisure their affairs leave them on such a subject.

Therefore, for this reason, by the most high judgment, you, holy Michael, were appointed to command the bodiless hosts, and were honoured with a girdle, as it were, of the mind, and you are a kind of fragrance of the all-holy and compassionate Trinity that is Lord of all. And you, holy Gabriel, were chosen to serve the mystery of the plan of salvation that cannot be told, as one who keeps a secret and is faithful. One has been honoured with one God-given gift and another with another, without even asking for it: a gift such as others do not have, and such as we do not have. But we too have a gift such as you do not have.

For God the Word did not become an angel for the sake of the angels who sinned, but a man for the sake of men in sin: without change, without confusion, without sin, beyond telling, as he knows and as he willed, from the Virgin, and in accordance with her flesh and that of all of us; remaining what he was and is and will be, one and the same. “For one,” he says, “is holy, one is Lord, Jesus Christ, to the glory of God the Father” (Philippians 2:11). And just as he went up from earth into the heavens, so he will come a second time (Acts 1:11), with glorious angelic battalions, myriads upon myriads, serving him; and he will also judge, and act in accordance with his love for mankind.

That is why, after the churches, houses of prayer to God bearing your name, O well-pleasing pair of archangels, have been founded not only in the cities, but also privately in lanes, in houses and in fields, adorned with gold and silver, or even ivory. And people go even to places far from the land that bore them, places that have these houses of prayer set up as, so to speak, halls where prayers are granted. They do not shrink from crossing even a wide sea, if need be, and a road of many days on end …

The archangels’ shrines, and the writer’s loyalty to his intercessors §73

73…and at times a hard road at that, to see it through, as people who expect to find in you a greater goodwill toward their petition, and from God a share in the good things of those who strive eagerly for what is good. For in his holy churches, in the houses of prayer and the shrines of the martyrs, as in other heavens, he has set out his unfailing good things. And from the gifts that he himself, “the King of those who reign and Lord of those who rule” (1 Timothy 6:15), has given and gives every day to each, from these he receives the bloodless sacrifice offered with piety and holiness, and he has every honour that men can give.

And I think that in the case against the heretics and in the things of theology even the brute beasts, nay rather the very stones, eagerly join their voices with ours. For what does love for God not do? Or to what does the heart’s true love give way?

For you know (but let all be said with God) that, with you and with the saints who came from our own nature interceding for me, I have so conducted myself that no one, even to this day, has yet chosen to bring against me any suit, so to speak, not even one for slander, on behalf of you, our intercessors, who receive from all people honours that match your measure. No one has summoned me by name to trial and judgment on this charge, though there are people to be found who accuse others of things that never happened. No one has even tried to convict me of having heard words spoken against God the Word and the Holy Spirit and then, perhaps from respect for the speaker or fear of him, of having nodded assent and praised what was not good; or of having ever been wholly negligent and treated with unbecoming slackness the duty of resisting as far as my strength allowed. On the contrary, many say that in such matters I always came forward vigorous and gentle, whether to answer for myself or to call others to account.

For I rightly count it the greatest gain, and an eternal one, for myself, for those who come from me and for those who are with us, to choose every toil, if need be, and every danger for the sake of him who made us and saves us, and who is able to judge, and to show loving-kindness on account of it: Father and Son and Holy Spirit.

Knowing, then, as chosen worshippers of the all-holy Trinity and intercessors for the human race, that after the Trinity itself, the cause of all and the giver of life, I have left nothing lacking in the reverence toward you that is owed to those who plead my cause with the Trinity, who supplies thoughts and wise words, both to itself…

A prayer to the archangels and the Trinity; the Spirit will judge with Christ §74

74…pleasing, and doing good to us; and then to you as well. And “then” only so far as it is fitting, when things are set in their order, to make due mention of the created nature after the uncreated. Pray especially for me, for those who come from me and those who are with me, and for all (for you have not been permitted to grant us more than this): that my resolve in this may be kept unmoved; that the prayer may be accepted, which you, most good, self-complete and undivided Trinity, bring to fulfilment without end; and that we may be counted worthy, with all our children, all our household, all our kin and all our friends (and our friends are the orthodox), together with you and all the saints, to sing the thrice-holy praise of the Trinity in the heavens to the endless ages of ages, and by its grace to obtain its kingdom, promised and believed by us, which has no end and is not divided. Amen, amen, amen.

That with Christ he will judge all things.

But it is time to turn back again to the subject we began: that the Holy Spirit, being God and Creator, will judge all things with Christ. For whose task is it to judge, if not his who shares with their Maker in godhead and kingship? So Isaiah prophesies: “A rod shall come out of the root of Jesse, and a flower shall rise up from the root. And the Spirit of God shall rest upon him, a spirit of wisdom and understanding, a spirit of counsel and strength, a spirit of knowledge and godliness; and a spirit of the fear of God shall fill him. He will not judge by appearance, nor convict by what people say; but he will give judgment to the lowly, and convict the proud, and rescue the lowly of the earth; and he will strike the earth with the word of his mouth, and with the Spirit, through his lips, he will destroy the ungodly” (Isaiah 11:1-4).

He calls “a rod and a flower from the root of Jesse” the one who sprang from that root in the incarnation and with his own fragrance gave strength to the whole world under the sun. Upon him we saw in the Gospels the Holy Spirit resting (John 1:32); but as judge together with the Holy Spirit, at the…

The Spirit as judge everywhere; Paul blinds Elymas by the Spirit’s power §75

75…second coming he is awaited, to be seen. For this is what is meant both by “with the Spirit, through his lips, he will destroy the ungodly” (Isaiah 11:4) and by the words spoken elsewhere by the same prophet: “by a spirit of judgment and by a spirit of burning” (Isaiah 4:4). And David says in the hundred and thirty-ninth Psalm: “Where shall I go from your Spirit? And where shall I flee from your face?” (Psalm 139:7). The words “where shall I go” and “where shall I flee” carry a broad meaning: they signify that the Holy Spirit is present everywhere and is judge. For truly, as the apostle says, “it is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God” (Hebrews 10:31), who says in the fiftieth Psalm, “I will convict you, and set your sins before your face” (Psalm 50:21). The prophecy of Micah quoted a little earlier also bears on this heading (Micah 3:8). And what stronger proof of this could anyone name than that the Saviour himself, in John, says of the Holy Spirit: “When he comes, he will convict the world concerning sin and concerning righteousness and concerning judgment” (John 16:8)?

That Paul, by the power of the Spirit, blinded Elymas the sorcerer.

It was by the surpassing power of the Holy Spirit that Paul, in Cyprus, blinded with a word Elymas the sorcerer, who was making war on the saints and doing violence to the truth. For Scripture, to show that the power was the Spirit’s, says in so many words: “Then Paul, filled with the Holy Spirit, said to him: ‘Look, the hand of the Lord is upon you, and you will be blind, not seeing the sun’” (Acts 13:9-11). And truly, had he not had the Spirit’s power that works all things, he could not by a word have quenched the sight of a man who kept himself safe by sorceries and trusted in demons.

That by the power of the all-holy Spirit the heavens were opened and seen by holy Stephen.

It was by the power and grace of the Holy Spirit that the heavens were unfolded and seen by the man with the double crowns…

Stephen sees heaven opened; the Spirit foreknows what is to come §76

76…of apostleship and martyrdom, which he had bound upon his head. For Scripture says: “Stephen, filled with the Holy Spirit, saw the heavens opened” (Acts 7:55-56). So the line spoken by one of the ancients came true: “And from heaven the boundless upper air broke open.”

That he has foreknowledge.

He foreknows, as the Father and the Son do; and to know the things to come exactly belongs to the divine nature alone. For creation brings out everything that comes from itself only as conjecture, and foresees without error and without fail only what the Holy Spirit teaches it. For with his divine rays he not only shines on the powers in heaven but also makes bright the eyes of our souls; he often shows the things to come, in various ways, and in his own goodness and love for mankind he lets creation at times declare the things that serve the good of human nature. These our material nature sometimes credits not to the one who supplied them through creation as a go-between, but to creation itself.

The testimonies to the Spirit’s foreknowledge from the Acts of the Apostles are these. From Peter, speaking to the Jews: “Brothers, the Scripture had to be fulfilled which the Holy Spirit spoke beforehand through the mouth of David about Judas, who became guide to those who arrested Jesus” (Acts 1:16). He was right, then, to say “had to”; for only of God is it true that no word of his goes unfulfilled. And from Paul: “The Holy Spirit testifies to me in every city, saying that bonds and afflictions await me” (Acts 20:23). And through the prophet Agabus too the Spirit, being good, foretold a famine that would come upon the world under heaven because of men’s offences (Acts 11:28), just as in the case of Nineveh (Jonah 3:4-10), so that people might take warning and escape the evil by repentance; and the famine did come, long afterwards, under Claudius. And in the Gospel Christ says of the Spirit: “And he will declare to you the things that are coming” (John 16:13), that is, the things to come.

From Via Patrum: https://viapatrum.org/works/didymus-de-trinitate/. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Credit: Via Patrum.